BRAD PITT SPOILER CONTAINED HEREIN:
When this or that male character winds up dying in a rugged survival flick, it’s usually because society regards him as lacking in social value or gravitas and is therefore disposable or diminishable.
Lee Tamahori‘s The Edge (’97) is about three guys who’ve crash-landed in a remote Alaskan lake — aloof billionaire Charles (Anthony Hopkins), smart-ass photographer Bob (Alec Baldwin) who’s been secretly schtupping Charles’ wife Mickey (Elle MacPherson), and Bob’s black assistant Steve (Harold Perrineau). The film was largely (though not entirely) about the trio trying to avoid being eaten by a Kodiak bear.
It was obvious to audiences back then that Perrineau would be eaten first. Because those were the Hollywood rules in the late ’90s. White movie stars would prevail while an occasional dude of color might buy the farm.
It was equally obvious that Robert Redford wouldn’t die in J.D. Chandor‘s All Is Lost (’13). Because he was the great Redford at age 77…no way could he have drowned!
In 1965 audiences knew going in that James Stewart and at least a few of the crash-landed guys in The Flight of the Phoenix would survive. It was written in stone that the intrepid Stewart could not and would not die in the desert. Hollywood law insisted.
And yet at the end of Joe Carnahan‘s The Gray (’11) Liam “paycheck” Neeson appeared to end up dead of fang-toothed wolf bites. Why did this happen to the Taken guy? No simple answer but his death was certainly unexpected.
In Chris Kentis‘ Open Water (’03), a married couple, played by Daniel Travis and Blanchard Ryan, wound up being devoured by sharks. Why? Because Travis and Ryan weren’t established name actors, and it was presumed that however shocking the finale, audiences would accept their demise.
And yet in The Mountain Between Us (2017), another romantically linked couple, played by Idris Elba and Kate Winslet, survive horrific blizzard conditions and come together at the end. Why? The rules of 2017 were that you couldn’t kill a charismatic black actor or a name-brand actress. Signed, sealed, delivered.
One of the most glorious outdoor survival sagas is Kevin McDonald‘s Touching The Void (’03). It was such a profound high when the real-life Simon Yates emerged exhausted but alive at the end. A true story and incredibly life-affirming.
If Brad Pitt had starred in a man-against-the-elements drama in the late ’90s, he would have absolutely survived at the end. Same deal if he had starred in the same kind of film in the aughts or early teens.
But after the drunken-Brad-vs.-Angelina Jolie-and-the-kids airplane incident of 2016, Pitt was seen as a somewhat flawed and perhaps even a diminished fellow. And so, in David Ayer‘s Heart of the Beast, two or three large wolves attack his character, a grizzled ex-special forces guy with a tennis-ball haircut, and…well, Pitt and Liam Neeson are suddenly the victims of a shared fate. Because on some submerged level, fairly or unfairly, society had decided that Pitt needed to symbolically atone.
This is why I forgot to review Heart of the Beast after seeing it last weekend. I just couldn’t get behind a film that champions the idea of a German Shepherd surviving but his owner, provider and best friend going down for the count. It feels inconsequential.