Today in wine group we decided to do a comparison of three grapes; Gamay, Grenache, and Pinot Noir. We chose those three because they have a lot in common and can easily be mistaken one for the other. Tasting them side by side would provide, we thought clear differences. We tasted them blind, made our notes and then determined as best we could which wine was which.
According to the French Wine Scholar Study Manual, all three grapes have red fruit aromas (cranberry, raspberry, strawberry, cherry). Two of the three have floral notes (Gamay and Pinot Noir). Two of the three have spice aromas, (Grenache and Pinot Noir). The Gamy may have notes of hard candy. Grenache may have notes of licorice. And the Pinot Noir may have notes of earth, mushroom, sandalwood, smoke and tea. If the aromas don’t identify the grapes for us, then the structure surely will. Gamay should present a moderate alcohol, high acid and low tannin. Grenache would present hight alcohol, moderate acid and moderate tannin. And Pinot Noir should present moderate alcohol, moderate plus acid and moderate tannin. There are enough differences that discerning which is which should be pretty easy.
Before going to wine group, I played a few games of pool with my husband. My grandfather taught me to play pool as soon as I was tall enough to see over the pool table, about six years old. He taught me angles, bottom English, banking, cutting. He knew and loved the game. Even now, I still have to think through the angle. His words come back to me often, ‘Hit the ball and the rail at the same time. It’ll follow the rail down to the pocket.’ But once in a while, I don’t have to think at all. It’s a shot I’ve done enough times that I can just feel when the cue is at the right angle. I know I’ll make the shot without thinking about it. It’s like playing piano. When I hit a certain level of fluidity, muscle memory takes over.
Sometimes I put my nose in the glass and know the wine without thinking through the details, or analyzing the structure. The identity of the wine speaks to me loud and clear. That didn’t happen today for any of us. Maybe we were over analyzing, but these three wines are more similar than they are different. It was a great exercise. And as I tell myself with pool, the more mistakes I make the more I learn. But the real take away for me is, I really need to drink more Gamay, Grenache and Pinot Noir.
La Rubiconde, 2023; Pink rim, opaque, stem, mushroom, cola, ripe red cherry, strawberry, earth, tea, violets, roasted walnut shell, tart on the palate, medium plus acid, medium tannin, medium alcohol Grenache
Jean Paul Brun, Moulin a Vent, 2023; Pink rim, translucent, tart strawberry, cranberry, rosemary, margoram, violet, chalk, mineral, oyster shells, orange zest, black tea, moderate plus acid, moderate plus tannin, moderate alcohol. Gamay
Domaine A.F. Gros, Haut Cotes de Nuits, 2022; Ruby translucent, candied strawberry, cranberry, black cherry, rhubarb, tart on the palate, red roses, perfumed, black tea, cinnamon, clove, Moderate acid, moderate tannin, moderate plus alcohol. Pinot Noir