| “The Day the Earth Stood Still” (2008) — movie review | |
| Today’s review is for the 2008 science fiction remake: “The Day the Earth Stood Still“, starring Keanu Reeves as Klaatu (the alien), Jennifer Connelly as Dr. Helen Benson (an exobiologist who tries to save Klaatu and the world), Jaden Smith as Jacob Benson (Helen’s stepson by marriage), Kathy Bates as Secretary of Defense Regina Jackson and John Cleese as Professor Barnhardt (the “smartest” man in the world). | |
| Background: If the 1951 original was a Cold War sermon presented as a silver saucered UFO, the 2008 version is a post-9 / 11 eco-parable dressed in nanotech and CGI. This remake exchanges the threat of nuclear weapons in space for environmental collapse on Earth. It recasts Klaatu not as a galactic diplomat, but as a cosmic “Silver Surfer” herald / exterminator who develops a conscience. Humans are no longer just violent — we are the destroyers of Earth’s sustainability. Klaatu arrives not to warn, but to execute. | |
| Basic Plot: A mysterious large orb lands in Central Park in New York City, along with a host of others spread around the globe. Klaatu, a humanoid emissary of an alien coalition, emerges and is promptly shot by some unidentified panicked soldier. He’s detained, healed, and interrogated. He escapes with the help of Dr. Helen Benson, a scientist who believes humanity deserves another (and another) chance. As global panic spreads, Klaatu witnesses human behavior firsthand, especially through Helen and her stepson Jacob. The question looms: will he spare us / save us based on watching family interaction, or allow planetary cleansing based on watching TV news? | |
| So… is this movie any good? The acting? The filming / FX? Any problems? Did I like it? Short answers: VERY so-so; Reeves is robotically bland, Connelly unaccountably emotional; the FX are impressive enough visuals; loads – mainly the story doesn’t really make much (any) sense; and, it’s more “just” okay than “Wow! I liked that!“. | |
| Acting: Keanu Reeves plays Klaatu with icy detachment — no diplomat and not a messiah from the stars. He seems to suddenly develop a conscience as a moral algorithm. His monotone delivery suits the alien role, but it is also an emotional flatline. Jennifer Connelly anchors the film with conviction, but while she is compassionate, rational, and deeply human, there was nothing “there” for me. Jaden Smith as Jacob is… important in the plot, but his character’s transformation (like Connelly’s) just didn’t make sense to me. Kathy Bates is a bureaucratic model as the Defense Secretary (with another uneven conversion), who is more a narrative device to explain why humanity cannot trust aliens to be “good and peaceful” towards us – hint: because we wouldn’t be towards them. Finally, there is John Cleese who makes a brief, earnest appearance as a Bach-loving physicist making a plea for humanity. He’s okay in the role, but he’s a poor Einstein substitute and the blackboard scene (which is lifted from the original movie) loses it’s context in this remake. | |
| Filming / FX: The film has the advantage of 50+ years of development in production design / FX. The alien spheres are interesting visually — silent, glowing, and ominous. GORT, the iconic robot, is re-imagined as a nano-tech swarm capable of global destruction. In this film, “GORT” is an acronym for “Genetically Organized Robotic Technology“, which is assigned to the object by the military – even though there is no evidence of genetics or robotics. Both are just assumed (I guess). The nanite destruction sequences — Shea Stadium, trucks dissolving into dust — are visually appealing even if they don’t make any sense logically. | |
| Problems: The main problem with this film is you have to WANT to believe the story for it to make any sense. In reality, it’s a loosely connected remake of a “classic” Sci-Fi movie which loses the thread by trying to update the reason for the alien visit to a modern day motive. Reeves / Klaatu’s conversion from executioner to redeemer is too abrupt. Smith’s / Jacob’s role seems like it’s pivotal but badly written. And, Bates / Jackson starts out as a believable Defense Secretary, but she ends up completely unable to communicate with “someone” (we assume is the President) and they inexplicably try to bomb a “cloud” of nanites. [Spoiler Alert: the spheres are dispersed around the planet because they are mini-Arks (as in Noah’s “Ark”) meant to collect various animal species for preservation. And, yes, the practicality of this is just as laughable as is the Noah story.] | |
| Final Recommendation: Moderate (at best) — worth the time watching for sci-fi fans curious about remakes of “classics” and less worth it for trumped up moral dilemmas about world ecology. It’s a film which (I think) tries to frame and ask big questions, but in the end fails the framing and answers none. Sit for a viewing with the hope of a decent remake and get up with the feeling: “Well, at least the special effects were decent enough…” | |
| Other thoughts: I’m a fan of most of Reeves’ work. I’ve liked him since the “Speed” days… This was not some of his best work. I AM thoroughly convinced about the dangers to humanity from “Climate Change”. I believe this type of representation of the danger is (was) not helpful as it only served to trivialize the immediate and long term issues and problems in the mind of the public. Seventeen years on from this film and we (a significant number of anti-intellectuals AND corporatists in the United States) are still acting / sounding as if there is no danger. Maybe, Earth (and humanity) will need a savior from outer space… Okay, I’ll now get off of my soap-box. | |
| . | |
| Click here (1 August) to see the posts of prior years. I started this blog in late 2009. Daily posting began in late January 2011. Not all of the days in the early years (2009-2010) will have posts. | |
Posts Tagged ‘Cold War’
A Colder Savior
Posted in General Comments, Movie Review, Movies, Reviews, tagged “The Day the Earth Stood Still” (2008) — movie review, Central Park, Cold War, Dr. Helen Benson, General Comments, Gort, Jacob Benson, Jaden Smith, Jennifer Connelly, John Cleese, Kathy Bates, Keanu Reeves, Klaatu, Mankind, Moderate Movie Recommendation, Movie Reviews, New York City, Professor Barnhardt, Reviews, Secretary of Defense Regina Jackson, Silver Surfer on August 1, 2025| 3 Comments »
What If…?
Posted in Leadership, Movie Review, Movies, Politics, Reviews, tagged American Politics, Andrew Duggan, Ava Gardner, Burt Lancaster, Col. Martin 'Jiggs' Casey, Col. Oliver North, Col. William 'Mud' Henderson, Cold War, Coup Attempts, Dave, Democracy, Edmond O'Brien, Eleanor Holbrook, Fredric March, Gen. James Mattoon Scott, General Michael Flynn, Highly Recommended To Must See Movie, John Houseman, Joint Chiefs Of Staff, Kirk Douglas, Leadership, Martin Balsam, Military Coup, Movie Reviews, Movies, Oscars, Paul Girard, President Jordan Lyman, Reagan Administration, Sen. Frederick Prentice, Sen. Raymond Clark, Seven Days In May (1964) -- movie review, The American President, The West Wing, The White House, Trump Administration, U.S., U.S. Capitol Riot, U.S.S.R., Vice Admiral Farley C. Barnswell, Whit Bissell, White House Down on August 4, 2023| Leave a Comment »
| “Seven Days In May” (1964) — movie review | |
| Today’s review is for the black & white political drama “Seven Days In May” starring: Burt Lancaster as Gen. James Mattoon Scott (the “bad-guy” military officer); Kirk Douglas as Col. Martin ‘Jiggs’ Casey (the “good-guy” military Officer); Fredric March as President Jordan Lyman (unpopular because he is trying to get a peaceful disarmament treaty with the USSR); Ava Gardner as Eleanor Holbrook (the former mistress of Gen. Scott); Edmond O’Brien as Sen. Raymond Clark (a longtime personal friend of the President); Martin Balsam as Paul Girard (White House Chief of Staff); Andrew Duggan as Col. William ‘Mud’ Henderson (a loyal officer who comes to the aid of Sen. Clark); Whit Bissell as Sen. Frederick Prentice (a “bad-guy” Senator who supports the military coup). | |
| Basic plot: When the President seeks to negotiate a nuclear disarmament treaty with the USSR, the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the Pentagon develop a plan to stage a coup to overthrow the government. The coup plot is discovered by an aide (Col. Casey) who then convinces the President the plot is real and about to happen. The White House then scrambles to prevent the coup. Through a fortunate finding of evidence, the coup is narrowly prevented and the nation’s democracy is maintained. | |
| Is this movie any good? The actors? The drama / plot? Is it worth your time viewing? Yes; Good to Very Good; Very Good; Absolutely! | |
| Any good: This is a surprisingly good movie! At almost sixty-years old, it presages our times as well as or better than “The West Wing“, “The American President“, “Dave” and “White House Down“. The former two demonstrating the eloquence of a “good” President and the later two political and / or military corruption as a narrative for the destruction of American democracy. It is worth noting this movie came out at a time when the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. were still very engaged in the “Cold War” and the American public was still practicing nuclear attack drills. At the start of the movie, there is a riot between protesting groups in front of the White House. While watching it, all I could think of was 6 January 2021 and the attack on the U.S. Capitol by the Trump supporters. | |
| The actors: I felt the actors in this movie were almost all good to great. It would be hard for me to pick out any one of them for their superior performance. If I had any objections, it would be John Houseman’s portrayal of Vice Admiral Farley C. Barnswell. Between Houseman’s accent and the unrecognizable (to me) uniform he was wearing, I just went: “Huh???” He (sounded) and the uniform (looked) – too British! And it wasn’t that Houseman couldn’t / didn’t carry off with the role (acting wise). I just didn’t buy him. (Can an actor “look” believable – in role, but not be believable?) Other than that, all of the actors were (IMHO) well-known to famous actors who played their roles brilliantly. | |
| Drama / plot: These were (60 years ago) great actors in well cast roles. There is buildup, conflict and resolution. Is it a perfect movie? No. But, the film was nominated for two Oscars including O’Brien for Best Supporting Actor. | |
| Worth your time: This movie is well worth your time! If nothing else, just to see the Lancaster vs Douglas face-off near the very end of the film! Gardner was also outstanding as the hurt mistress struggling to find herself. I never realized what a good actress she was until I re-watched this movie. Now I’ll have to be on the lookout for her in other films. LoL | |
| Final recommendation: Highly recommended to MUST see cinema. As much as this movie is a fictional drama, coups remain a realistic “threat” to our democracy. This on-going threat from within is obvious from the felonious activities of real-life senior officers like Col. Oliver North (during the Reagan Administration) and General Michael Flynn (before, during and since the Trump Administration). The threat is also obvious by the “dark money” constantly pouring in to our elections with the hopes of buying seats at the table when social / political options are being weighed and decisions are being made. Even in “fiction” America only barely survives based on the resolute actions taken by a few agents-for-good; individuals who happen to be at the right place at the fortuitous moment in history. | |
| . | |
| Click here (4 August) to see the posts of prior years. I started this blog in late 2009. Daily posting began in late January 2011. Not all of the days in the early years (2009-2010) will have posts. | |
-
Join 2,104 other subscribers
Ripple’s In Time…
Translate
Look For Stuff…
Ripple Crests
-
Recent Ripples In The Continuum
Blogroll
Charities
Environment
Faith Family and Friends
Military Service
Places
Politics
Science and Learning
Tributaries and Eddies
Older Ripples In The Continuum
Ripplets (Tags)
#DumbDonald #IncompetentDonald #LyingDonald 2023 Warriors Regular Season American Politics Anonymous Attitude Basketball Books Carl Sagan Courage Diet Disclaimer Dr. Leo F. Buscaglia Economics Education Eleanor Roosevelt Environment Faith Family Family and Friends Favorite Lines Fear Freedom General Comments God Golden State Warriors Happiness Health Highly Recommended Movie History Hope Humor Images Included Video Knowledge Leadership Learning Life Love Mark Twain Movie Reviews Movies Music My Journal National Basketball Association NBA On Life Other Blogs Philosophy Pictures Poems Poetry Politics Quotes Ralph Waldo Emerson Reading Recommended Reading Reviews Running Science Sports Steph Curry Strong Movie Recommendation Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas Time Time Magazine Truth Vevo Warren Buffett Wired Magazine Wisdom Work Writing YouTubeRipple Riders
Ripple Stats
- 328,693 hits
Howdy, Uh, How’re You Guys Doin’?
Posted in General Comments, Movie Review, Movies, Reviews, tagged Best Visual Effects Oscar, Bud Brigman, Cold War, Deep Core, Ed Harris, General Comments, Highly Recommended Movie, Hollywood, James Cameron, Kimberly Scott, Leo Burmester, Lindsey Brigman, Lt. Coffey, Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio, Michael Biehn, Movie Reviews, Navy SEAL Team, Non-Terrestrial Intelligence, NTI, Pseudopod, Reviews, Super-Oxygenated Fluids, The Abyss – Special Edition” (1989) — movie review, The Day the Earth Stood Still, Tidal Wave, Todd Graff on March 16, 2026| Leave a Comment »
Rate this:
Share this:
Read Full Post »