James Jones | Kevin Barrett's Blog

Posts Tagged ‘James Jones’

A Man Should Be What He Can Do

Posted in General Comments, Movie Review, Movies, Reviews, tagged Alma “Lorene” Burke, Best Director (Zinnemann), Best Picture Oscar, Best Supporting Actor (Sinatra), Best Supporting Actress (Reed), Burt Lancaster, Captain Dana Holmes, Deborah Kerr, Donna Reed, Ernest Borgnine, First Sergeant, First Sergeant Milton Warden, Frank Sinatra, Fred Zinnemann, From Here to Eternity (1953) — movie review, General Comments, Hawaii, Highly Recommended Movie, Hollywood, James Jones, Karen Holmes, Montgomery Clift, Movie Reviews, NCO, Non-Commissioned Officer, Pearl Harbor, Philip Ober, Private Angelo Maggio, Private Robert E. Lee Prewitt, Reviews, Staff Sergeant James R. “Fatso” Judson, World War II on April 4, 2026| Leave a Comment »

“From Here to Eternity” (1953) — movie review
Today’s review is for the World War II romantic – military – drama “From Here to Eternity”, directed by Fred Zinnemann and starring Burt Lancaster as First Sergeant Milton Warden, a career NCO (company First Sergeant) trying to keep his unit running while juggling a dangerous affair with the wife of his company commander; Montgomery Clift as Private Robert E. Lee Prewitt, a stubborn, principled bugler / ex-boxer who refuses to box despite pressure from above; Deborah Kerr as Karen Holmes, the company commander’s wife, trapped in a loveless marriage and drawn to Warden; Donna Reed as Alma “Lorene” Burke, a “club hostess” who becomes Prewitt’s emotional anchor; Frank Sinatra as Private Angelo Maggio, Prewitt’s loyal friend whose run-ins with the stockade system drive much of the film’s tension; Philip Ober as Captain Dana Holmes, the ambitious, morally compromised company commander who abuses his authority to get what he wants; and Ernest Borgnine as Staff Sergeant James R. “Fatso” Judson, the brutal stockade sergeant whose cruelty toward Maggio becomes one of the film’s key conflicts. The film mixes military life, personal choices, and the looming / eventual attack on Pearl Harbor into a story about people trying to hold onto personal dignity in a system and time which doesn’t make it easy.

Background: This is my first viewing of this film as an adult. I’ve known about it for years (and I believe I saw it as a child when it didn’t mean anything to me) mostly for the beach-kiss scene with Lancaster and Kerr and the bar fight scene between Sinatra and Borgnine — but I just never sat down to watch it in its entirety in the last 50-60 years. LoL. This film is one of the “highly recommended” films of two of my high school friends whom I have lunch with a couple of times a year. Released in 1953 and based on James Jones’ novel, the movie was a major critical and commercial success. It received thirteen Academy Award nominations and won eight, including Best Picture, Best Director (Zinnemann), Best Supporting Actor (Sinatra), and Best Supporting Actress (Reed). It’s historically significant as one of the defining Hollywood dramas of the 1950s, remembered for its performances, its frank (for the time) treatment of adult relationships, and its depiction of Army life just before the attack on Pearl Harbor. The film helped revive Sinatra’s career and cemented Lancaster, Kerr, and Clift as major dramatic actors.

Plot: The story takes place in Hawaii in the months leading up to December 7, 1941 and the Japanese attack on the American military bases. Private Prewitt transfers into an infantry company and immediately runs into trouble when Captain Holmes pressures him to join the regimental boxing team. Prewitt refuses (out of principle, but mostly guilt over a past injury he caused a friend) and the company leadership retaliates with a steady stream of “treatment” designed to coerce him. Prewitt’s only real support comes from Maggio, a fellow private whose run-ins with the sadistic stockade sergeant (Ernest Borgnine) escalate into tragedy. Meanwhile, Sergeant Warden begins an affair with Karen Holmes, the captain’s wife, and the two wrestle with whether they can build a life together despite the risks. Prewitt finds his own connection with Lorene, a club hostess who dreams of a different future. As tensions rise, both personal and military, the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor crashes into the story, forcing each character to face the consequences of their choices. The film builds toward a mix of personal loss, wartime chaos, and the realization that some battles are internal long before the guns begin to fire.

So, is this movie any good? How’s the acting? The filming / FX? Any problems? And, did I enjoy the film? Short answers: Yes (duh); excellent; clean, grounded filming; a few; yes.

Any good? Duh… Eight Oscars out of thirteen nominations! Yes. “From Here to Eternity” is a strong, character-driven drama that holds up much better than I expected for a film from the early 1950s. The story is straightforward, but the emotional beats land cleanly, and the film doesn’t shy away from the darker corners of military life: hazing, infidelity, ambition, and the pressure to conform. The pacing is steady, and the film balances its multiple story lines without losing track of the characters. The Pearl Harbor attack isn’t the focus so much as the backdrop that forces everything to a head. It’s a well-made film that earned its long-standing reputation.

Acting: Montgomery Clift gives the standout performance. His Prewitt is stubborn, proud, and quietly hurting, and Clift plays him with a kind of internal tension that makes every decision feel personal. Prewitt has one of my favorite lines (which I’ve used as a quote): “Nobody lies about being lonely.” Burt Lancaster brings authority and presence to Warden, and his scenes with Deborah Kerr have more heat / chemistry than I expected from a 1953 film. Kerr is excellent — sharp, wounded, and believable as someone trying to claw her way out of a bad marriage. Donna Reed surprised me; she brings warmth and sadness to Lorene, and her Oscar win makes sense. Frank Sinatra is terrific as Maggio — funny, loyal, and heartbreaking when things turn. The supporting cast (including Borgnine as the brutal stockade sergeant) fills out the world convincingly.

Filming / FX: The film is shot cleanly and simply, with a focus on faces, barracks life, and the physical environment of the base. The black-and-white cinematography works well, giving the story a grounded, almost documentary feel at times. The beach scene is iconic for a reason — not just for the kiss, but for how the pounding / rushing waves and framing underline the characters’ emotional / physical relationship. The Pearl Harbor attack sequence is brief but effective, using practical effects and tight staging rather than spectacle. Overall, the attack filming supports the story without calling too much attention to itself.

Problems: A few. I’ve never read the novel the film is based on, so I have no way to know how close the film tracks with it. Captain Holmes is drawn a bit broadly as the “bad officer,” and some of the Army politics feel compressed. The romance between Warden and Karen, while well-acted, moves quickly, and the film doesn’t always give their choices enough space to develop. The pacing dips slightly in the middle, and a few scenes feel melodramatic by modern standards. None of these minor issues affect the overall impact of the film. If I had any “REAL” objections to the film it would be Lancaster / Warden holding a machine-gun and firing it from the hip while holding the barrel with towel to prevent burning his hand. This makes for good cinema, but it’s pretty much absolute nonsense. LoL.

Did I enjoy the film? Yes. It’s a strong, well-acted drama with memorable characters and a clear sense of time and place. The relationships feel lived-in, the military setting feels authentic enough, and the emotional beats land. The film balances romance, camaraderie, and tragedy without tipping too far into sentimentality. Watching it now, I can see why it made such an impact in 1953 and why it still gets referenced today (especially the “beach” scene). It’s not a film I’d re-watch constantly, but I’m glad I finally saw it (as an adult, when it meant something to me) and I will almost certainly watch it again.

Final Recommendation: Highly recommended. “From Here to Eternity” is a historically significant, multi-Oscar winning drama with excellent performances and a grounded sense of military life on the eve of Pearl Harbor. Its eight Academy Awards — including Best Picture, Best Director, and two acting wins — reflect the quality of the work, and the film remains an important piece of 1950s Hollywood. If you’re interested in classic cinema, wartime dramas, or character-driven stories with emotional weight, this one is a must see. It’s a film which earned and retains its place in movie history.

.
Click here (4 April) to see the posts of prior years. I started this blog in late 2009. Daily posting began in late January 2011. Not all of the days in the early years (2009-2010) will have posts.