| Today’s review is for the movie “Arrival” (2016), which is a drama / thriller / SciFi film (mostly drama and SciFi) starring Amy Adams as Dr. Louise Banks (Linguist), Jeremy Renner as Dr. Ian Donnelly (Physicist), Forest Whitaker as Colonel G. T. Weber, Michael Stuhlbarg as Agent Halpern, Mark O’Brien as Captain Marks, Tzi Ma as General Shang (Head of Chinese military). | |
| Background: I watched this film a couple of years ago, but neglected to review it. I didn’t really remember it well enough to review, so I had to re-watch it. (Darn!) I enjoyed it again. | |
| Plot: Earth is visited by twelve LARGE space ships which hover at various stops around the planet. Each of the nations where a ship has landed tries to communicate with their ship. At first all the nations share communication. Then they stop. Dr. Banks, who is teaching at a university, is approached by the U.S. military (Col. Weber and Captain Marks) to try to contact the ship which has “landed” in Montana. When Dr. Banks arrives, she is met by Dr. Donnelly and National Security / CIA Agent Halpern. Blah, blah, blah… Dr. Banks has continuous “dreams / memories” about her daughter who has died as a young teen from some aggressive illness. The two Doctors make contact and begin communicating with the aliens. Certain parts of the government believe it is a mistake to communicate / trust the aliens and attempt to blow up the alien ship. The attempt fails but one of the aliens (nick-named “Abbott”) is mortally injured. The other nations are about to attack the ships in their area when Dr. Banks figures out what the aliens want. She believes the aliens have come to give us a “tool” (their language) so we (as a species) will survive to help them in 3,000 years. She convinces the Chinese General to not attack and the world is saved. The two Doctors “make” a baby… Not quite a “happily ever after” since we know what happens to the child. | |
| The thrust of the movie is that we (humans) are limited in that our experiences limit our thoughts and our limited thoughts limit our language. The aliens experience “time” differently and think of it differently, so they express “time” in their language differently. Once we (humans) are able to “speak” their language, we will “see / experience” time differently. So, Dr. Banks was able to “see” the future of her life with her daughter. | |
| Is this movie any good? How’s the acting? Will you learn anything about linguistics from a SciFi movie? Is the film entertaining? Yes, good to very good, yes, and yes (but I’d say more “intellectual” than entertaining. | |
| Any good: The movie was well received by critics (lots of award nominations) and made money (cost $50M, made $300M). The story has holes in it but the obvious ones didn’t slap you in the face and call you “stupid”. This is an “intellectual” SciFi film, not an action or horror film. | |
| Acting: I thought the acting was pretty good to very good. Obviously, Adams carried the bulk of the story and she did a very good job. I’ve seen her in multiple films now, and she’s a reliably good-to-very good actress. I also liked Tzi Ma, Whitaker and Renner in their roles – all very believable. I didn’t find Stuhlbarg believable in his role. I’m not sure why. I just didn’t. IMHO the standout (non-star role) was O’Brien as the fearful Captain Marks. You could say his acting was overdone or that it was “spot-on”. I felt it was on the mark. He’s a relatively low level, young officer in WAY over his head and terrified. I don’t know him (O’Brien) from any other roles and it’s been almost 10yrs since this casting… | |
| Learn anything: No. I don’t know anything about linguistics and this was mostly gobbledygook to me. Does language really work the way depicted? It doesn’t seem like it (to me), but I’m willing to give the film the benefit of the doubt. | |
| Entertaining: Surprisingly yes! I thought it was slow in lots of places and quite confusing the way it seemed to alternate between Dr. Banks memories (dreams) and reality, but it all got wrapped up as part of the story. So, it was resolved and the slowdowns (delayed time / timing) seemed intentional and part of the film’s presentation. | |
| Final recommendation: Strong to High! I ran a gamut of feelings about the pace / flow of the movie, but in the end, felt it was interesting, thoughtful and it worked. | |
| Note: The post title is from a “Star Trek (The Next Generation)” episode where two characters are placed in danger in order to learn to communicate with each other. One (Picard) survives and learns to communicate with the alien race. In this film Dr. Banks survives and learns the heptapods’ language. | |
| . | |
| Click here (18 June) to see the posts of prior years. I started this blog in late 2009. Daily posting began in late January 2011. Not all of the days in the early years (2009-2010) will have posts. | |
Posts Tagged ‘National Security Agency’
Darmok And Jalad At Tanagra
Posted in General Comments, Movie Review, Movies, Reviews, tagged Agent Halpern, Amy Adams, Arrival -- movie review, Captain Marks, Central Intelligence Agency, Colonel G. T. Weber, Dr. Ian Donnelly, Dr. Louise Banks, Forest Whitaker, General Comments, General Shang, Jeremy Renner, Linguistics, Mark O'Brien, Michael Stuhlbarg, Montana, National Security Agency, Star Trek: The Next Generation, Strong To Highly Recommended Movie, Tzi Ma on June 18, 2025| Leave a Comment »
-
Join 2,104 other subscribers
Ripple’s In Time…
Translate
Look For Stuff…
Ripple Crests
-
Recent Ripples In The Continuum
Blogroll
Charities
Environment
Faith Family and Friends
Military Service
Places
Politics
Science and Learning
Tributaries and Eddies
Older Ripples In The Continuum
Ripplets (Tags)
#DumbDonald #IncompetentDonald #LyingDonald 2023 Warriors Regular Season American Politics Anonymous Attitude Basketball Books Carl Sagan Courage Diet Disclaimer Dr. Leo F. Buscaglia Economics Education Eleanor Roosevelt Environment Faith Family Family and Friends Favorite Lines Fear Freedom General Comments God Golden State Warriors Happiness Health Highly Recommended Movie History Hope Humor Images Included Video Knowledge Leadership Learning Life Love Mark Twain Movie Reviews Movies Music My Journal National Basketball Association NBA On Life Other Blogs Philosophy Pictures Poems Poetry Politics Quotes Ralph Waldo Emerson Reading Recommended Reading Reviews Running Science Sports Steph Curry Strong Movie Recommendation Supreme Court Justice William O. Douglas Time Time Magazine Truth Vevo Warren Buffett Wired Magazine Wisdom Work Writing YouTubeRipple Riders
Ripple Stats
- 328,646 hits
Most Americans Don’t Want Freedom… They Want Security
Posted in General Comments, Movie Review, Movies, Politics, Reviews, tagged AI, American Politics, Artificial Intelligence, Best Documentary Feature Oscar, Central Intelligence Agency, CIA, Citizenfour, Corbin O’Brian, COVID, Edward Snowden, Ewen MacAskill, General Comments, Geneva, Glenn Greenwald, Hank Forrester, Hawaii, Hong Kong, Japan, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Laura Poitras, Lindsay Mills, Luke Harding, Melissa Leo, Moral Crisis, Movie Reviews, National Security Agency, Nicolas Cage, NSA, Oliver Stone, Reviews, Rhys Ifans, Russia, Shailene Woodley, Snowden (2016) — movie review, Strong to MUST See Movie Recommendation, The Snowden Files, Timothy Olyphant, Tom Wilkinson, U.S. Army, Zachary Quinto on April 8, 2026| Leave a Comment »
Rate this:
Share this:
Read Full Post »