UPDATE 20061030: Matt a referred me to a ‘Washington Post’ article entitled “The Walls Tumbled By Time” written by Joel Garreau. It is a very interesting read about historic walls and their eventuality. Thank you, Matt a for sharing the link.
I want to be very clear in my position regarding the illegal immigration problem we face today.
First and foremost, the illegal aliens have broken our laws regarding immigration and failed to recognize our national sovereignty. For that reason I believe amnesty flies in the face of justice and should not be accepted as an outcome to this crisis.
Second, there is a foundational misperception among many Mexicans that parts of this nation still belong to Mexico. This we can do nothing about, but perhaps enough political pressure could force Mexico to educate their population as to the current border.
Third, I do not believe a fence is a worthwhile investment. It is estimated that the 700 mile fence will cost about $6 billion dollars, or about $.857 million per mile. A fence along the entire 2,000 mile border would cost approximately $17 billion. And that does not address our northern border. I believe the money would be better spent actively and legitimately enforcing our current laws.
Fourth, by removing the enticement (employment, social service programs, medical treatment access, and automatic citizenship for offspring) to illegally come into the US, I believe we could reverse the trend and force the vast majority of illegal aliens to return to Mexico. We should require positive proof of citizenship or legal alien status for employment, etc. We already have laws prohibiting the employment of illegals aliens and some states prohibit renting or selling apartments or homes to illegal aliens. We should include social programs and health care access to a list of services requiring proof of citizenship or legal alien status. I also think it is time to review automatic citizenship for offspring born in the USA. I favor applying for citizenship for offspring born to legal aliens and no citizenship granted to offspring born to illegal aliens.
Fifth, the unintended consequences far outweigh the idea that illegal aliens only work the jobs that no one else wants to do. There are skilled illegals that are causing wages to fall because they are willing to work for less pay. The financial burden added to education systems, healthcare emergency rooms, and welfare programs and now social security is not being adequately borne by the illegal aliens. There is a cost passed on to you and me. I find this totally unacceptable.
Finally, our borders could be better control with remote surveillance devices and systems (unmanned aerial vehicles, aerostats, sensors, etc.) provided they are back up with quick reaction forces empowered to enforce our laws. A ‘no apprehension’ policy does not serve border security one bit.
There is no doubt that something needs to be done, I just don’t believe the money would be wisely spent on fencing.
UPDATE 20061029: In the comment stream for this post, Steve, Seth and Gayle have related personal experiences that I beleive help to enlighten, at least partially, why Mexicans (in particular) believe they have a ‘right’ to be in the US without regard to our laws. Please be sure to read their comments if you haven’t already.
So reads the title of this article written by Eduardo Castillo for the Associated Press which I found via Drudge Report.
MEXICO CITY – Mexico’s president sharply criticized President Bush’s signing Thursday of a bill to build 700 miles of additional fencing on its southern border, calling the move an “embarrassment.”
Bush signed the bill, approved by the Senate last month, despite pleas from the Mexican government for a veto.
President Vicente Fox told reporters in the Caribbean resort city of Cancun that the fence would not stop millions of Mexicans from heading north in search of jobs.
“It is an embarrassment for the United States,” Fox said. “It is proof, that the United States does not see immigration as a subject that corresponds to both countries.”
…
An estimated 11 million Mexicans live in the United States, about half of them illegally.
This one is almost too easy, especially for a conservative like me; but every now and then it’s nice to have a sitting duck to shoot or low hanging fruit to pick.
The need to erect a fence should be considered an embarrassment; but to Mexico and Vicente Fox, not the United States and President Bush. If Fox were able to control his side of the border and the citizens of Mexico were willing to recognize the sovereignty of the United States, there would be no need for fencing. It should be an embarrassment to Fox that so many of his citizens would flee their native country in search of a better life. His comment, “the fence would not stop millions of Mexicans from heading north in search of jobs,” is an indictment upon himself and his government.
Fox stated, “It is proof, that the United States does not see immigration as a subject that corresponds to both countries.” Isn’t it strange that Fox’s Mexico would not accept for immigration people such as illegally enters the United States? Mexico is extremely selective about who is allowed to immigrate and then the nationalism regarding land ownership and voting is quite discriminatory against immigrants.
I think it is pretty crass of Fox to feign outrage at our reaction to his exporting 11 million of his citizens to the United States so his administration won’t have to answer for the sorry state of employment in Mexico.
The American people have spoken, Congress finally listened, and the President signed the bill into law. Now we need funding to build the fence; and that is our next grass roots movement.