Swept Away
Book by John Logan
Music & Lyrics by The Avett Brothers
Directed by Jeremy Johnson
Music Directed by Paul S. Katz
Choreographed by Ilyse Robbins
May 14, 2026: Calderwood Pavilion, Boston, Massachusetts

Cast
Wyatt Anton – Ensemble
Christopher Chew – Captain
Max Conner – Little Brother
Peter DiMaggio – Mate
Carson Hollingsworth – Ensemble
Elliot Lazar – Ensemble
Bishop Levesque – Big Brother
Kevin Patrick Martin – Ensemble
Nicholas Papayoanou – Ensemble
Anthony Pires, Jr. – Ensemble
Ezra Quinlan – Aerialist/Ensemble
Scored to music by North Carolina folk-rock band The Avett Brothers, Swept Away is a story of a shipwreck, survival, guilt, and redemption. The story is framed by an older Mate dying of consumption and haunted by the members of the crew he served with on the ill-fated journey. Task with telling their story, Mate recalls setting out in 1888 on an aged whaling ship at the end of the whaling era. Joining the crew are the enthusiastic farm boy Little Brother who wants to see the world before settling down but is pursued by the more practical Big Brother. Before Big Brother can convince Little Brother to come home with him, the ship sets sail and he’s forced to join the crew as well.The first half of the show has a festive feel with the camaraderie of the crew as well as personality conflicts with the pious Big Brother. After the shipwreck, the crew is reduced to Mate, the brothers, and the Captain on a life boat forced to make difficult choices to survive.
I really like the Avett Brothers music (which surprisingly wasn’t written specifically for the show) and the singing and choreography is wonderful. Ezra Quinlan also adds some artistry to climbing the rigging in their aerial performances. I can find no evidence of an aerialist in the Broadway production, so I believe this is an innovation of Speakeasy Stage, and it really works. The plot and characterization are thin, but I feel that the show still delivers on an emotional level. For a story dealing with tragic death, cannibalism, and the darkness of human nature, it has a surprisingly hopeful conclusion.
In the fun game of “Hey, I know that guy!” here are the actors I’ve seen in other productions: Wyatt Anton (Fun Home), Christopher Chew (A Sherlock Carol), Peter DiMaggio (Lizard Boy), and Kevin Patrick Martin (Titanic – does he specialize in doomed ship musicals?).
Speakeasy Stage continues performing Swept Away at Calderwood Pavilion through May 23rd


