Abstract

Introspection is often conceptualized as a “purely inner” activity, whereby the introspector temporarily breaks their coupling with the external world to focus on their “inner world”. We offer a substantially different picture of introspection. Inspired by radically embodied cognitive science, we argue that introspective processes delivering substantial self-knowledge consist of embodied, world-involving activities wherein the introspector remains coupled with the world in specific, controlled ways. Our argument unfolds as follows: after a brief introduction (Sect. 1), we provide a minimal account of introspection (Sect. 2 ) followed by a brief introduction to radically embodied views of the mind (Sect. 3 ). Then, in Sect. 4, we present in detail a case of radical embodied introspection (Sect. 4.1 ); we argue that that case is indeed a case of introspection (Sect. 4.2 ), and finally we defend our claim from some foreseeable objections (Sect. 4.3 ). In Sect. 5 we offer other examples, showing that radically embodied introspection is a widespread and varied phenomenon. Lastly, Sect. 6 concludes the paper sketching some morals to be drawn from our examples. The appendix briefly situates our view in the broader epistemological landscape.