Welcome to Write the Story! Each month, Writers Unite! will offer a writing prompt for writers to create and share a story with everyone. WU! wants to help our members and followers generate more traffic to their platforms. Please check out the authors’ blogs, websites, and Facebook pages and show them support. We would love to hear your thoughts about the stories and appreciate your support!


Mystery Under the Lake
Marian Wood
The Café by the lake
Looking out over the quiet Lake I sipped at my coffee and tried to listen to the man across from me. Hearing words here and there I was distracted by the white house and the red thing, is that a shop or a phone box. Snow on the trees reflected in the water as I learnt about a hidden tunnel and a plan.
Why use a café to discuss such matters? I had followed him from the churchyard after observing him walking amongst the gravestones. I had become curious as he stopped at each one making notes. Something wasn’t right, he was a stranger to our village, what interest did he have in our deceased folk?
This is when it got interesting. The odd words, “tunnel, treasure and brave.” I certainly should not have been listening but there he was on his phone and I couldn’t help it. Was he a bad person or was he a Christmas philanthropist? He then hung up and started to look around the room. Who or what was he now looking for? As he noticed me watching him, I quickly turned to watch the water. Feeling an uneasy sick feeling, am I in trouble now?
Annie
‘Hi, just wondering, have you lived here long? Can I buy you another drink?”
Stammering I answered, “About ten years and no, my coffee is fine.”
As I willed him to go away, he pulled out the chair and sat down. Struck by his handsome smile I reminded myself that I’ve been caught here before. I’ve so far got to meet a genuine nice man, so far they are all rogues and cheats.
“Did you ever meet a little lady called Annie Hart?” She lived in the house just over there and she would help on Sundays at the church.
I remembered Annie, she died about six months ago. I nodded.
“Did you know her well? and any of her family?”
“I didn’t, it was more just hello and nod. I was always unsure of her family”.
“Ok, and do you often trust your uneasiness? He smiled.
“I do, but I’m not always right”. Where was this headed? Handsome stranger approaches girl in café and asks questions about a dead old lady.
“Was Annie well liked?”
“I think so but there was always something about her, might have been her sons but she was not someone that you upset. You just smiled, nodded and kept going.”
“You are wise, would it surprise you to learn that I’m also one of her sons”.
“It would, but I’ve never seen you before”. My stomach was churning, what was happening here?
The family
“Have you ever heard about the lake passageway?”
No never, as far as I know there is just a footpath that goes around it if that’s what you mean?”
“What’s your name? I’m Philip.”
He held out his hand, shaking it I answered,
“I’m Carla”. Should I be careful? Can Philip be trusted? His brothers you certainly can’t.
“I’m aware that you followed me from the cemetery which means you are either nosey or curious in a mystery like I am.”
“Or I am a girl who likes a handsome man in a suit but confused why he is taking notes in a graveyard”.
Why was he trusting me with this. Pulling out his notebook I was now shocked with what I was reading.
The deaths of Annie and Ted then other names that I didn’t recognise.
“My dad was her first husband, William George.”
“Was he not murdered? His killers never found”.
“Yes, and who would be your suspects for his murder.”
“Her sons, but surely not?”
“Did you know that those boys were not actually hers. She was with Ted maybe just twenty years the boys she saw them as sons, but they were not her blood. Do you also know what happened to their mum.”
“I’m guessing murdered”.
“She vanished, never found. I’m suspecting that she knew she was in danger”.
The plan
“Okay so Philip, what is happening here. So far, I have pieced together treasure and a tunnel under the lake. A lady who maybe lived a life that was a lie. Why did you not visit sooner.”
“About four years ago I attended a funeral a good few miles from here, Ted informed me that she was dead and I believed him. Don’t know who we buried that day, but the internet is a wonderful thing. Her more recent death came up on my internet newsfeed and I’m now finally here to do something for her, years too late! Ted died maybe a year back and those boys are still here. Carla they are dangerous!”
“How can your suspicions be proven?”
He pulled out a letter and a map of the lake. An underground pathway ran all the way from the café to the church.
“Mum has left something that we need to find. She must have been scared for years, I stayed away as was warned away by Ted. We need to get into the cellar of this café. The police will not listen to my suspicions, that’s who I was talking to. They just mocked my theories as a daft treasure hunt. The treasure here is not gold, it’s getting Mick, Fred and Bob locked away for murder”.
The cellar
I now knew I could help. Reaching for his hand, I pulled him up. Following behind me we now approached the kitchen, I knocked on the door and opened it.
“Pam, please can me and Philip have a look in your cellar?”
“Why love what’s in the cellar?”
“That’s what we need to find out, I just need to check something with Philip”.
She handed me the keys smiling,
“I don’t know what you are up to but there’s rats down there. I haven’t been down those steps in years”.
“Okay come on Philip. Sorry I used to work here, Pam the cook is a good friend.”.
Opening the door we now studied the map. Using his phone as a torch Philip led the way.
Standing in an empty room that’s stank of damp we now looked for a door or gap. Moving some hessian bags and then shelves, Philip led out a whoop.
“Do you have just one key or two?”
“There has always been a mystery key with the cellar key but as Pam said people don’t come down here.”
The passageway
Opening the exposed door with a loud shove and then a creek, we walked through. I’m sure this had been dismissed as a cupboard, certainly not a tunnel. under the lake. I let Philip take my hand; this was an unexpected adventure.
Possibly about halfway under the lake the tunnel opened into a room. Boxes were piled up on the sides and forgotten beer cans littered the floor. According to the map there is something buried under the boxes. I was surprised as he pulled a garden trowel out of his jacket, we need to dig about here.
Pulling boxes out of the way he now started digging, hearing the scrape of metal he breathed heavily. This was it treasure found. As he grabbed it we heard a noise and then Bob appeared in the room holding a gun. I stood sweat pouring of me now, I’m too young to die. As the shouting started and the threats got louder I closed my eyes. Philip stood shielding me as I started to cry. I certainly am not brave. Now as if my prayers were all answered at once, the sound of many footsteps were coming from the church. Then a loud gun shot, no this couldn’t be happening.
Help
Philip grabbed me as the team of Policemen appeared,
“Mr George, I presume, sorry we mocked you. Pam phoned us concerned for Carla, she thought she might be in danger, we came straight away to meet you the other way from the church. Didn’t expect to need to shoot Bob here, but he is known to be dangerous. We just couldn’t prove it”.
Philip now sat with the metal box. Inside his birth certificate reading Philip George, and a photo of him and his mum. Photos of his dad and then letters. Letters written in fear of a man threatening to come between them. Philip took what was his and passed the tin to the policeman,
“I think this is your evidence, mum buried it under the lake as knew it could get her killed. I’m hoping it was natural causes that got her and not Teds sons”.
“That we don’t know, but reading through this it’s evident that your suspicions for your dad are true. Was there any reason for them to latch onto your family as they did?”
Inheritance
“My dad after he died left a large inheritance to my mum, Ted and his boys have been abusing that for years”.
Finding an envelope addressed to Philip in the tin, the policeman passed it.
“You might be wanting that.”
He opened it, “okay I think I need a solicitor, my mother is a very clever lady”.
Turned out that William had left a much larger sum of money. They had planned ahead and Philip was now inheriting thousands.
So, all in a day’s work, one murderer shot, two more to catch and a new handsome stranger helped.
A year later
Philip is no longer a stranger, we are having our own much safer adventure together, The person who I suspected as a bad man is actually a very good kind man, full of stories and plenty of laughter. We are happy and life is good.
The ;police with help from Annie’s letters had now found Sandra, Teds first wife, not dead just running. The boys now imprisoned she no longer needed to hide. Grateful to Philip and Annie, her and Annie had been writing for years. Both scared of angering Ted and the boys they had been supporting each other. I was relieved to find that she was alive not murdered, and was living a happy life on another continent with her husband Fred and his two daughters. Watching the four of them now I hugged Philip. He was a good man, Sandra truly now had her freedom and Annie was in a much happier place away from Teds evil sons.
So, what about our future? no wedding ring yet but right now we couldn’t be much happier. The day I followed my handsome stranger to the café by the lake, I didn’t expect an adventure and love, but this is exactly what I got.
Please visit Marian on her blog https://justmuddlingthroughlife.co.uk/2025/12/20/mystery-under-the-lake
Images are free use—Image by Wolfgang-1958 from Pixabay.

