Old DTDs/Schema in deployment descriptors of Tags/Pages/Servlet/Assembly Platform TCK tests

[gurunrao]

Effected Jakarta EE Platform TCK version 9.1/10.0.

Platform specification 9.1/10 states "support for versions of DTDs and schemas prior to Jakarta EE 8 is optional".
Platform specification detailed reference on support of previous schema can be found at: https://jakarta.ee/specifications/platform/10/jakarta-platform-spec-10.0#a3447

Following tests have old schema[ http://java.sun.com/dtd/web-app_2_3.dtd ] reference in the web.xml descriptor.

Tags tests:
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#negativeScriptFreeTlvNoDeclTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveBundleLocalizationScopeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveCatchVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveCWOTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveDateParamQueryTimestampTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveDefaultEncodingTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveFDValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveFNScopeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveFormatLocalizationContextI18NTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveForTokensTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveIfScopeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveImportAbsUrlTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveItemsObjArrayTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveJSTLURITest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveMessageKeyTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveOutEscXmlTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveParamNameValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveParamValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveParseVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positivePDValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positivePermittedTlvTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positivePNValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveQueryScopeAttributeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveRedirectTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveRemoveScopeVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveResultGetRowsCountTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetBundleScopeVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetDataSourceScopeAttributeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetLocaleValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetScopeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetSelectVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveSetTimezoneValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveTimezoneValueTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveTransformVarTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveTxQueryCommitTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveUpdateBodyContentTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveUrlScopeTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveXParamNameTest
  
Pages tests:
com/sun/ts/tests/jsp/spec/configuration/elevaluation/URLClient.java#elEvaluation23WebApplicationTest

Following servlet test have old schema [ http://java.sun.com/j2ee/dtds/web-app_2_2.dtd ] reference in the web.xml descriptor.

com/sun/ts/tests/servlet/compat/LeadingSlash/WithLeadingSlash/URLClient.java#WithLeadingSlashTest
com/sun/ts/tests/servlet/compat/LeadingSlash/WithoutLeadingSlash/URLClient.java#WithoutLeadingSlashTest

Following assembly test have old schema [ http://java.sun.com/j2ee/dtds/web-app_2_2.dtd ] reference in the web.xml descriptor.

  com/sun/ts/tests/assembly/compat/standalone/war/compat12_13/Client.java#testStandaloneWar
  com/sun/ts/tests/assembly/compat/standalone/war/compat12_14/Client.java#testStandaloneWar
  com/sun/ts/tests/assembly/compat/standalone/war/compat12_50/Client.java#testStandaloneWar
  com/sun/ts/tests/assembly/compat/standalone/war/compat13_14/Client.java#testStandaloneWar

Above mentioned tests violate Platform specification optional support for versions of DTDs/schemas prior to Jakarta EE 8 and make support of older DTDs/schema mandatory for the vendors of Jakarta EE 9.1/10.
The Tests are failing with deployment failures of test war/ear in Application servers which do not support old DTDs/schema.

[scottmarlow]

It sounds like this is a Platform TCK challenge for the mentioned tests so the Platform Spec team should approve or deny the challenge.

Note that there is some overlap with the jakartaee/tags#255 challenge:

com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveFormatLocalizationContextI18NTest
com/sun/ts/tests/jstl/compat/onedotzero/JSTLClient.java#positiveTimezoneValueTest

CC @pnicolucci @markt-asf

[scottmarlow]

Email sent to Platform to vote on this challenge as well as BCC sent to JSTL, JSP, Servlet mailing lists https://www.eclipse.org/lists/jakartaee-platform-dev/msg04461.html

[ivargrimstad]

+1

[gurunrao]

@scottmarlow - added 4 more tests from assembly module of platform TCK.

[pnicolucci]

@scottmarlow from a Jakarta Tags perspective are you asking to update the schema version in the deployment descriptors for the application?

[scottmarlow]

@scottmarlow from a Jakarta Tags perspective are you asking to update the schema version in the deployment descriptors for the application?

@pnicolucci
If this TCK challenge is accepted, we would either exclude the mentioned tests or update the schema version to something like:

http://java.sun.com/dtd/web-app_2_3.dtd + http://java.sun.com/j2ee/dtds/web-app_2_2.dtd to https://jakarta.ee/xml/ns/jakartaee/web-app_5_0.xsd

http://www.sun.com/software/sunone/appserver/dtds/sun-application-client_1_4-0.dtd + http://www.sun.com/software/sunone/appserver/dtds/sun-application-client_5_0-0.dtd to https://jakarta.ee/xml/ns/jakartaee/application-client_10.xsd

@gurunrao do you agree?

Email sent to Platform to vote on this challenge as well as BCC sent to JSTL, JSP, Servlet mailing lists https://www.eclipse.org/lists/jakartaee-platform-dev/msg04461.html

FYI, the email wasn't sent to JSTL, JSP, Servlet mailing list as but it did go to the Platform mailing list.

[gurunrao]

@scottmarlow from a Jakarta Tags perspective are you asking to update the schema version in the deployment descriptors for the application?

@pnicolucci If this TCK challenge is accepted, we would either exclude the mentioned tests or update the schema version to something like:

http://java.sun.com/dtd/web-app_2_3.dtd + http://java.sun.com/j2ee/dtds/web-app_2_2.dtd to https://jakarta.ee/xml/ns/jakartaee/web-app_5_0.xsd

http://www.sun.com/software/sunone/appserver/dtds/sun-application-client_1_4-0.dtd + http://www.sun.com/software/sunone/appserver/dtds/sun-application-client_5_0-0.dtd to https://jakarta.ee/xml/ns/jakartaee/application-client_10.xsd

@gurunrao do you agree?

Email sent to Platform to vote on this challenge as well as BCC sent to JSTL, JSP, Servlet mailing lists https://www.eclipse.org/lists/jakartaee-platform-dev/msg04461.html

FYI, the email wasn't sent to JSTL, JSP, Servlet mailing list as but it did go to the Platform mailing list.

we should update schema to Jakarta EE 8+ schema, as per Platform Specification document. Document reference can be found at https://jakarta.ee/specifications/platform/10/jakarta-platform-spec-10.0#a3447

[scottmarlow]

we should update schema to Jakarta EE 8+ schema, as per Platform Specification document. Document reference can be found at https://jakarta.ee/specifications/platform/10/jakarta-platform-spec-10.0#a3447

If we update to EE 9+ schemas, that would be helpful for the Tags TCK testing with Jakarta EE 11.

[scottmarlow]

As mentioned in the Platform TCK call, I think this challenge is likely to be approved.

We mentioned in the call that this challenge is for the EE 9.1 + 10.0 Platform TCK but the related component specs (Tags/Pages/Servlet) could opt into having component TCKs released as well to address this challenge.

CC @pnicolucci @markt-asf