Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
Creepy ‘Would You Rather’ Scenarios That’ll Test How Fearless You Really Are
We’re back with another thought-provoking ‘Would You Rather’ poll! In Part 1, we challenged your fears. In this Halloween-inspired ‘Would You Rather: Spooky Edition,’ we’ll test exactly how brave, curious, and chill-tolerant you really are.
So grab a blanket, dim the lights, and see which spooky scenarios you’d rather live through.
Remember, there are no wrong answers - just ones that reveal how well you’d survive a night or day in the strange and supernatural.
Check out all of our awesome Polls for even more challenges!
🚀 💡 Want more or looking for something else? Head over to the Bored Panda Quizzes and explore our full collection of quizzes and trivia designed to test your knowledge, reveal hidden insights, and spark your curiosity.💡 🚀
This post may include affiliate links.
#1
Would you rather have your reflection blink when you don’t or your shadow move a moment after you do?
Rick Murray 5 days ago
When you have flu real bad, the shadow thing is real - and it's as if your body is moving by itself and the you part of you is following just a moment behind. Perception is weird and easily messed with.
RELATED:
#2
Would you rather get a voicemail from your mom, but her voice sounds slightly off - almost robotic - or receive a birthday card from a relative who passed years ago?
#3
Would you rather receive a daily phone call at the same time, but no one speaks, or a daily letter in your handwriting that you never wrote?
#4
Would you rather wake up to find your furniture rearranged or see muddy footprints leading to your bed?
#5
Would you rather notice that your favorite café always has the same people, in the same seats, wearing the same clothes every day, or that the barista greets you with the order you were just thinking about?
Dread Pirate Roberts 5 days ago
The barista one sounds awesome, actually lol he/she would keep me coming back
#6
Would you rather hear your pet call your name in a calm voice once, or see them staring at the same corner of the room every night?
#7
Would you rather have a friend swear they saw you somewhere you weren’t, or a coworker insist they had lunch with you yesterday when you’re sure they didn’t?
#8
Would you rather find out your neighbor has been watching you through their blinds every night or discover your coworker somehow knows what you dream about?
#9
Would you rather hear a child’s giggle echo through your house, even though there aren’t any children there, or see a chair slowly move on its own?
#10
Would you rather wake up to find every mirror in your home covered or every clock stopped at the same exact time?
#11
Would you rather live in a town where no one ever sleeps or one where everyone disappears at sundown?
Rika 5 days ago
I once took the wrong bus and ended up in a town where all stores were closed and there was no one in the streets although there was still daylight. I finally met a guy and asked him if it was a holiday or something, he said no, it's past 6PM, everyone in the city has gone home and it's like that every day. It weirded me out a little bit.
#12
Would you rather spot an old photo of yourself as a stranger’s screensaver, or discover your full name carved into a tree in a place you’ve never been?
#13
Would you rather be lost in an endless hallway or stuck in a single room that keeps subtly changing each time you blink?
#14
Would you rather stay in a cabin that’s silent except for whispers outside or one that hums with faint lullabies through the night?
#15
Would you rather hear knocking on your window at 3 a.m. or see your door slowly creak open by itself?
#16
Would you rather have your phone start playing eerie music on its own or receive messages from an unknown number saying “I see you”?
Rick Murray 5 days ago
Eerie music? That's just my playlist. [currently listening to Lacrimosa "Apeiron"]
#17
Would you rather walk through a maze that changes every few minutes or be in a house where every door leads somewhere new each time?
Rick Murray 5 days ago
Ah, but does the door lead to new places in the house, or new places in the world? You haven't specified the scope of "somewhere new".
#18
Would you rather be paid to walk through an abandoned carnival at midnight or explore an old, empty hospital with flickering lights and a horrible past?
#19
Would you rather your ex keep appearing in your dreams every night, or a complete stranger keep greeting you by name in public?
#20
Would you rather attend a dinner where everyone speaks in perfect unison or one where no one ever blinks?
Michael Largey 4 days ago
If I was told in advance that everyone was going to speak in unison, I'd be afraid I was walking into a Trump rally.
#21
Would you rather your new neighbor greet you by your full name every morning, or your friend insist they’ve never met you before?
#22
Would you rather have your coworker casually mention something personal they couldn’t possibly know, or your boss greet you by a nickname you’ve never told anyone?
#23
Would you rather keep a journal that writes back or keep a mirror that shows what’s happening in another room?
Add New Image
You May Like “Which Show Is Connected To ‘Breaking Bad’?”: Score At Least 25/27 To Prove You Know Your TV Shows “Do You Remember The Ending?”: Test Your Movie Memory With 27 Iconic Final Scenes “Ready For A Geography Workout?”: Type In 21 European Countries On This Borders Test These 27 Misheard Lyrics Are Driving People Mad: Try Completing The Songs Perfectly
Armandas Lukoševičius
Armandas Lukoševičius
Gerda K.
Armandas Lukoševičius
Related on Bored Panda
