How Guilt and Shame May Influence Intimate Partner Violence and Moral Injury

What is it about?

This study explores how an individual's tendency to feel guilt and shame relate to aggressive behavior toward intimate partners, such as physical violence, psychological abuse, and sexual coercion. Shame involves severe self-condemnation ("I am a bad person"), while guilt focuses on specific actions ("I did something bad"). The researchers wanted to understand if and how these feelings influence (a) one's perpetration of aggression and (b) their experience of moral injury—a type of suffering that happens when people feel that themselves or others have violated their moral standards. The study involved 321 adults from the United States who had been in romantic relationships within the past year. Participants answered surveys measuring their experiences of IPA, their tendency to feel (a) guilt and (b) shame in different scenarios, moral injury, and PTSD symptoms. The researchers found that people who tend to feel shame are more likely to act aggressively toward their partners. On the other hand, those who are more prone to feeling guilt are less likely to engage in such behaviors. Meanwhile, individuals who engaged in aggression against their intimate partners were more likely to experience increased moral injury. Importantly, individuals who tended to feel shame experienced elevated moral injury, while individuals who tended to feel guilt experienced less shame-related moral injury. Overall, this research shows that how people are dispositionally prone to feel about their actions—whether shame or guilt—may influence why some behave aggressively in relationships. Understanding and addressing these emotions may help prevent partner violence and improve mental health outcomes.

Featured Image

Photo by Adrian Swancar on Unsplash

Photo by Adrian Swancar on Unsplash

Why is it important?

This study is important because intimate partner aggression is common and has serious consequences for everyone involved. Understanding what drives some people to act aggressively helps target prevention efforts. The research suggests that feeling shame may predict an individual's likelihood to engage in aggressive behavior, whereas experiencing guilt might prevent people from engaging in such actions. By examining the role of moral injury—a distinct type of trauma related to one's experience of moral violations—the study offers new insights into how emotional responses like shame and guilt affect behavior and mental health. Recognizing that moral injury and feelings of shame can contribute to or result from abusive behavior highlights the need for specialized treatments. Programs that help individuals manage shame and foster guilt (which involves feeling responsible and remorseful) could reduce violence and support mental health recovery. Key Takeaways • Tendency to feel shame was related to more aggressive behaviors, whereas tendency to feel guilt was related to less aggressive behaviors. • Moral injury, a type of trauma resulting from one's experience of moral violations, was related to perpetration of intimate partner aggression, and may play a role in the cycle of partner abuse. • Interventions should focus on fostering guilt and managing shame to prevent partner violence.

Perspectives