LinkedIn respects your privacy

LinkedIn and 3rd parties use essential and non-essential cookies to provide, secure, analyze and improve our Services, and to show you relevant ads (including professional and job ads) on and off LinkedIn. Learn more in our Cookie Policy.

Select Accept to consent or Reject to decline non-essential cookies for this use. You can update your choices at any time in your settings.

Agree & Join LinkedIn

By clicking Continue to join or sign in, you agree to LinkedIn’s User Agreement, Privacy Policy, and Cookie Policy.

Skip to main content
LinkedIn
  • Top Content
  • People
  • Learning
  • Jobs
  • Games
Join now Sign in
  1. All
  2. HR Management
  3. Staff Development

You're facing employee performance issues. How do you handle defensive reactions effectively?

When addressing employee performance issues, expect some pushback. To navigate this challenge:

  • Listen actively: Show empathy and understand their perspective before responding.

  • Maintain objectivity: Stick to facts and specific examples to keep the conversation focused.

  • Provide support: Offer resources or training to help them improve and feel supported.

How do you approach defensiveness in performance conversations?

Staff Development Staff Development

Staff Development

+ Follow
  1. All
  2. HR Management
  3. Staff Development

You're facing employee performance issues. How do you handle defensive reactions effectively?

When addressing employee performance issues, expect some pushback. To navigate this challenge:

  • Listen actively: Show empathy and understand their perspective before responding.

  • Maintain objectivity: Stick to facts and specific examples to keep the conversation focused.

  • Provide support: Offer resources or training to help them improve and feel supported.

How do you approach defensiveness in performance conversations?

Add your perspective
Help others by sharing more (125 characters min.)
15 answers
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Sergiy Kuznetsov

    HR Manager & Recruiter | مدير الموارد البشرية مسؤول التوظيف

    • Report contribution

    How to Handle Defensive Reactions to Employee Performance Issues 🧘♂️Stay Calm: Maintain composure to keep the conversation productive. 👂Listen Actively: Understand their perspective before responding. 📊Be Specific: Focus on concrete examples, not generalizations. 💬Ask Questions: Encourage collaboration with open-ended questions. 🤝Offer Support: Provide solutions and resources for improvement. Approach performance discussions with empathy to reduce defensiveness and drive positive outcomes.

    Like
    11
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Muhammad Faisal Naseer-CHRP(PIPD)

    Experienced HR Professional | Assistant Manager Human Resources| Ex-Style Textile | HRMS & SAP | Payroll & Benefits | Policy Making | HR Operations | Recruitment & Onboarding | Performance & Talent Management |

    • Report contribution

    Handling defensive reactions during performance discussions requires a calm, empathetic, and structured approach. Start by setting a non-confrontational tone, emphasizing that the conversation is about growth, not blame. Use specific examples of performance gaps and focus on observable behaviors rather than personal traits to reduce defensiveness. Actively listen to the employee’s perspective without interruption, validating their feelings where appropriate. Redirect the discussion toward finding solutions by asking open-ended questions like, “What support would help you improve in this area?” This collaborative approach builds trust, reduces defensiveness, and fosters a sense of shared responsibility for improvement.

    Like
    6
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Shireen Khan

    Associate Director – HR & Delivery Team || HR Leadership & Team Management || Talent Acquisition & Recruitment Strategy || Vendor & Partner Relations || Client Relationship & Stakeholder Engagement

    • Report contribution

    Approach defensive employees with empathy, acknowledging their concerns and emotions. Reassure them that the discussion aims to support their growth rather than blame, fostering trust and collaboration. Shift the conversation from problems to solutions by involving the employee in creating an improvement plan. This empowers them to take ownership and reduces their defensiveness.

    Like
    5
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Aishwarya M

    Co-Founder & COO | DMS Designs | 1927 Pixels | Let’s Make your Brand the Next Big Thing!

    • Report contribution

    I allow the employee to share their perspective without interruption and focus on finding collaborative approach to solutions rather than assigning fault, while showcasing empathy and understanding, even in cases that I disagree with them.

    Like
    3
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Garrett Kennedy CPsychol AFBPsS HCPC Reg

    Person-Centred Leadership | Psychological Expertise | Strategic Consultancy

    • Report contribution

    In managing defensive reactions to performance conversations, psychological safety built must precede any discussion. I supported a staff member through challenging circumstances affecting their work - our established relationship made conversations easier. We cleared non-essential commitments, created recovery space, and streamlined workload. Reframing the conversation as collaborative problem-solving helped, because my desire to help was genuine. Leaders: Focus on the person first, not metrics. Invest much more time than you think necessary in developing facilitative relationship skills, starting with counselling skills training. Invest in reflective supervision from a good therapist and get comfortable with not knowing all the answers.

    Like
    2
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Swarna Sharma

    Senior HR Generalist @ SourceBae | 39K+ strong community here Passionate about people, culture & building teams that actually work. Helping founders hire right & create workplaces that feel right.

    • Report contribution

    Addressing employee performance issues requires empathy and clarity. Start by focusing on specific behaviors, not personal traits, to keep the conversation objective. Listen actively to their perspective, showing that you value their input. Offer constructive feedback with actionable solutions, and collaborate on a plan for improvement to build trust and accountability.

    Like
    2
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    uzma Khan

    Human Resources Executive @ StackRoof Technologies | Master's in Commerce

    • Report contribution

    Handling defensive reactions needs a calm, understanding, and positive approach. Start by talking in private and giving clear, specific feedback without blaming. Listen carefully to their side, acknowledge their feelings, and focus on finding solutions together. Set clear steps for improvement and follow up regularly to show support and build trust.

    Like
    2
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Rahul Chatterjee

    Head Learning and Development @ BSS Microfinance Limited | Best Selling Author

    • Report contribution

    To make the most of a limited training budget, prioritize essential skills that support key organizational objectives. Opt for affordable options like virtual training sessions, e-learning platforms, or collaborative learning among team members. Utilize internal expertise by organizing workshops or mentorship programs. Choose training materials that can benefit various roles or departments. Explore free or budget-friendly tools and industry resources. Track progress by setting specific goals and assessing outcomes to ensure the training effectively boosts performance and delivers value for the investment.

    Like
    2
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Nagarjun SB

    Assistant Manager Recruitment @ GoComet | SAAS | GTM Recruiter |

    • Report contribution

    Defensiveness can derail a performance discussion, but preparation and mindset make all the difference. I focus on: Setting a positive tone.Framing feedback constructively. Encouraging mutual understanding. The goal is to foster trust and alignment, ensuring both the employee and the organization thrive.

    Like
    1
  • Contributor profile photo
    Contributor profile photo
    Ajeet Kaur

    Manager 经理- Supply Chain - 供应链 || XCMG Group II Mandarin Expert || Procurement with 9 years of experience

    • Report contribution

    Reassure them that the discussion aims to support their growth rather than blame. Encouraging mutual understanding. Allow the employee to share their perspective without interruption and focus on finding collaborative approach to solutions rather than assigning fault

    Like
    1
View more answers
Staff Development Staff Development

Staff Development

+ Follow

Rate this article

We created this article with the help of AI. What do you think of it?
It’s great It’s not so great

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.

Tell us more

Report this article

More articles on Staff Development

No more previous content
  • Team members clash over learning priorities. How do you resolve these conflicts?

    19 contributions

  • A new hire is resistant to feedback during onboarding. How will you ensure their professional growth?

  • Your team is scattered across the globe. How do you keep them engaged and motivated with virtual training?

  • You're managing a team with diverse age groups. How can you foster effective collaboration?

  • Ensuring equal participation in virtual meetings is crucial. How can you engage all team members effectively?

No more next content
See all

More relevant reading

  • Employee Engagement
    How can you keep top employees?
  • Recruiting
    How can you evaluate temporary employee performance on a tight deadline?
  • Critical Thinking
    What strategies can you use to create a strong analytical framework for evaluating employee performance?
  • Organizational Culture
    How do you involve your employees in defining and shaping your shared values?

Explore Other Skills

  • Training and Development (HR)
  • Human Resources (HR)
  • Training
  • Career Counseling
  • HR Consulting
  • Career Development
  • HR Operations
  • Resume Writing
  • Recruiting
  • Global Talent Acquisition

Are you sure you want to delete your contribution?

Are you sure you want to delete your reply?

  • LinkedIn © 2025
  • About
  • Accessibility
  • User Agreement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Copyright Policy
  • Brand Policy
  • Guest Controls
  • Community Guidelines
Like
15 Contributions