Melina Hess’ Post

View profile for Melina Hess

CRO | AB Testing | Experimentation @Drip Agency

"Bestseller" badges backfired and hurt revenue by over 1.5% We thought social proof would boost sales. Wrong. The test: Added "Sehr beliebt" (bestseller) badges to popular products sitewide - homepage, product pages, search results, everywhere. What happened: - Revenue per user dropped 1.53% - Conversion rate down 1.50% Why? The site already had other badges. Adding more just made everything look cluttered and spammy. Turns out some people actively avoid bestsellers. They want unique stuff, not what everyone else is buying. Badge overload makes nothing feel special anymore. Reality check: Social proof can backfire. Making everything look "popular" sometimes makes it look less desirable. Less is often more when it comes to trust signals. Bottom line: Don't assume what works elsewhere will work for your customers. Test everything, even the "obvious" wins. Got more insights like this in my E-com Product Master Base - - covers what actually drives product page conversions. Comment "PRODUCT" if you want it. Follow me (Melina Hess) for more CRO tips and breakdowns!

  • graphical user interface, application
Valeriia Stepanets

B2B Digital Marketer | Business Development | Tech growth marketing at @42DM

2mo

This is a great lesson in testing assumptions. Social proof can be powerful, but overloading it can make the site feel less genuine and actually hurt conversions.

Like
Reply
Stefano M. Sinicropi, MD

President & CEO Midwest Spine & Brain Institute | Board Certified Orthopedic Spine Surgeon | Founder HyperCharge Clinics | Regenerative Medicine | Photobiomodulation | Prevention | Podcast Host | Keynote Speaker

2mo

Too much social proof can work against you. When everything is labeled special, nothing feels special anymore.

Like
Reply
Will Leatherman

Founder @ Catalyst // B2B Creator Economy // Bootstrapped to $1.5M+ in Sales • Sharing Content & Sales Systems That Make Money (Over 150+ execs)

2mo

surprising how “bestseller” can actually repel the exact buyers you want

Like
Reply
Joya Dass

I’m a recovering TV anchor helping 1 time pressed woman in her 50’s give a TEDxTalk in 2026 | Currently interviewing candidates for my 2026 Mastermind. Apply joyadass.bio

2mo

Too many badges and nothing feels special anymore

Like
Reply
Jessica Cox

Marketing Lead | Lean Product Development | Consumer

2mo

Product

Like
Reply
Ganesh Jadhav

Content Strategist | Marketing Expertise | Brand Management | Digital Marketing | Social Media Guru | PR & Communication Pro

2mo

PRODUCT

Like
Reply
Brian Dordevic

Add $60,247 per month for your law practice with AI-driven local SEO (without blowing up your Advertising budget). | Hubspot, Google & SEMRush Partner | View my portfolio for inspiration and revenue-generating ideas.

2mo

Too many badges and nothing stands out scarcity beats popularity for certain buyers every time.

Like
Reply
Tyler Sowinski

Head of Conversion Optimization and Customer Experience @ Internet Brands | Experimentation Program Management | Customer Experience | Consumer Research | Online Marketing

2mo

Product

Like
Reply
Shane Barker

Founder @TraceFuse.ai | The Amazon Review Expert | E-commerce Strategist | Influencer Marketing Specialist | Keynote Speaker

2mo

Badge overload = trust erosion. Great reminder to test everything Melina

Like
Reply
Phil Norcross

CRO Consultant helping ecommerce brands turn traffic into sales. I use user research, A/B testing & data to optimise conversions, only publishing changes that increase revenue. Ready to boost your sales?

2mo

Loving these shared insights Melina Hess I've often found the 'no brainers' are the ones that surprise you the most (not getting the results clients may have thought) all part of the process :)

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore content categories