"Bestseller" badges backfired and hurt revenue by over 1.5% We thought social proof would boost sales. Wrong. The test: Added "Sehr beliebt" (bestseller) badges to popular products sitewide - homepage, product pages, search results, everywhere. What happened: - Revenue per user dropped 1.53% - Conversion rate down 1.50% Why? The site already had other badges. Adding more just made everything look cluttered and spammy. Turns out some people actively avoid bestsellers. They want unique stuff, not what everyone else is buying. Badge overload makes nothing feel special anymore. Reality check: Social proof can backfire. Making everything look "popular" sometimes makes it look less desirable. Less is often more when it comes to trust signals. Bottom line: Don't assume what works elsewhere will work for your customers. Test everything, even the "obvious" wins. Got more insights like this in my E-com Product Master Base - - covers what actually drives product page conversions. Comment "PRODUCT" if you want it. Follow me (Melina Hess) for more CRO tips and breakdowns!
Too much social proof can work against you. When everything is labeled special, nothing feels special anymore.
surprising how “bestseller” can actually repel the exact buyers you want
Too many badges and nothing feels special anymore
Product
PRODUCT
Too many badges and nothing stands out scarcity beats popularity for certain buyers every time.
Product
Badge overload = trust erosion. Great reminder to test everything Melina
Loving these shared insights Melina Hess I've often found the 'no brainers' are the ones that surprise you the most (not getting the results clients may have thought) all part of the process :)
B2B Digital Marketer | Business Development | Tech growth marketing at @42DM
2moThis is a great lesson in testing assumptions. Social proof can be powerful, but overloading it can make the site feel less genuine and actually hurt conversions.