💥 We Are Not “Just Task-Doers”

💥 We Are Not “Just Task-Doers”

Why We Need a Standalone Framework to Prove Nursing as Strategic, Knowledge-Producing Science


🚨 We’ve Been Saying It Too Long

For decades, we’ve told the world:

👉 “Nursing is more than giving injections and dressing wounds.”

  • We’ve said it in classrooms.
  • We’ve said it in conferences.
  • We’ve said it in policy rooms.

But here’s the hard truth: words alone have not shifted perception.

Nursing hasn’t been misunderstood by accident. The image of nurses as task-doers — syringes and wound dressers — was deliberately engineered. Taskification was designed to keep us subordinate to medicine’s monopoly, to erase our science, and to collapse our role into compliance.

This is not just a perception problem. It is systemic sabotage. And unless we build our own framework, we remain caged.


🌱 Why We’ve Been Stuck

We didn’t end up here by chance. The roots of our invisibility run deep.

  • We borrowed too much. Instead of standing on our own constants, we leaned on medicine, sociology, psychology. We became interpreters of others’ sciences, never guardians of our own.
  • We romanticized caring. Caring was framed as sentiment — beautiful, but scientifically fragile. A candlelight easily blown out by medicine’s storm of pathology.
  • We let practice collapse into tasks. In classrooms, we spoke theories. In hospitals, we delivered tasks. The “theory–practice gap” widened until neither side could respect the other.

This isn’t just history. It is a wound that bleeds into our present: the identity crisis of the largest workforce in healthcare.


🌀 My Journey of Questioning

I could not ignore this wound. I carried it with me through my personal and professional journey, and it fueled relentless questioning.

The seeds of the Bio-Holistic Nursology Theory (BHNT) were planted in those restless moments when I confronted the classics: Nightingale, Orem, Roy, Rogers, Watson, Newman, Benner.

Each was brilliant. But each was partial. Adaptation, self-care, caring, consciousness, environment — all fragments of truth, yet no unshakable foundation.

And so my questions kept circling back:

  • What is the truest substance of nursing identity?
  • Why must “caring” be central — and why not something deeper?
  • What is the bio-logic of nursing — the rational order, the explanatory power?
  • Is nursing truly knowledge-producing, or has it accepted dependency?
  • Why should patients request nursing services specifically? What is our propositional value?
  • How does a nurse save life, create healing, foster prevention, and enable flourishing?
  • What constants of reality can we claim so that we stop being defined by borrowed sciences?

This questioning was not despair. It was the birth of a vision: a framework to elevate nursing into a sovereign explanatory and interventions-producing science.

And I will say it openly: I cannot do this alone. I call on nurse leaders, theorists, universities, and every passionate nurse to help bring this theory to life. Because without it, the nursing profession will continue to suffer in the shadows and will never see the light of day.


🌿 The Framework We Need

That vision became the Bio-Holistic Nursology Framework (BHN).

Unlike past theories, it does not borrow its spine. It anchors itself in six constants of reality:

  1. Wholeness → Humans are irreducible beings, not fractured parts. A nurse doesn’t just monitor blood pressure, they integrate stress, diet, sleep, and family conflict as one whole picture.
  2. Sufferings → We live inside many sufferings; disease is only one. Hypertension is not just arterial strain — it is also economic hardship, loneliness, existential stress.
  3. Continuum → Health is not binary; it’s a trajectory from survival to flourishing. A nurse doesn’t settle for “discharged alive.” They push recovery into prevention and flourishing.
  4. Modulation → Health is bent by rhythms, environments, relationships, behaviors. A nurse times interventions to rhythms — dimming lights for sleep, aligning meals with circadian cycles.
  5. Care-as-Act → Care is intentional, knowledge-driven intervention, not sentiment. Teaching foot care in diabetes is not kindness; it is an act that prevents amputation.
  6. Bio-Entailment → Internal states are entailed by external surroundings. Poor water quality is not just an environmental issue; it inscribes itself as kidney failure in the body.

These are not values or philosophies. They are ontological constants — enduring truths that don’t shift with culture, trend, or borrowed sciences.


🌱 A New Definition of Competency

If our constants change, then our competency must change too.

The old model — “knowledge, skill, attitude” — reduces us to good task performers. It traps us in compliance.

The new model must reflect our sovereignty:

👉 Nursing competency is our integrated capacity to explain, interpret, and act upon the entailed relations between human beings and their surroundings — producing outcomes of healing, recovery, prevention, health, and flourishing.

Contrast this with the old:

  • Old competency: “Do you know what to do? Can you do it correctly? Will you do it with the right attitude?”
  • New competency: “Can you explain suffering? Diagnose disruptions beyond pathology? Intervene with deliberate acts that change physiology and context? Move people toward flourishing? Advocate against systemic barriers?”

This competency does not measure how well we follow orders. It measures how boldly we generate outcomes.


✨ Our Call to Each Other

It’s not enough for us to keep saying “nursing is more than injections.” We need to show, in every classroom, ward, and policy table, a framework that makes this undeniable.

The Bio-Holistic Nursology Framework is not mine alone. It belongs to all of us.

Without a sovereign framework, we will remain the world’s largest invisible workforce — trapped in tasks, erased in textbooks, silenced in leadership. With it, we step into sovereignty — as a profession that explains, intervenes, and produces outcomes no other discipline can.

I am calling every nurse leader, every theorist, every university, and every passionate nurse: join me. The time is urgent. Together, let’s bring this framework to life.

💡 Wisdom to Carry Forward

“The syringe and the bandage are not who we are. They are tools. Who we are is a sovereign science: a profession that explains suffering, produces interventions, and generates outcomes of life, healing, prevention, recovery, and flourishing. That is nursing. That is us.”
Kellie Crothers

Registered Nurse | Emergency & Home Healthcare and Hospice Expert | Case Management | Healthcare Innovator | HealthOS Creator | AI in Healthcare | Future-Ready Nurse Leader

4w

Nurses should be able to be independent, be able to charge insurance companies for services. There is no direct fee for service reimbursement for RNs. Coordination of Care, medication reconciliation, prevention, education, etc. This would be a front line service that could save millions by preventing diseases. Nursing services are typically “bundled” under facility fees or billed under a physician’s or NP’s National Provider Identifier (NPI) instead of the nurse’s own. This means an RN’s work is often hidden in hospital room charges or considered an expense to a physician’s practice, rather than a billable service in its own right. Despite the barriers, a few pioneering efforts at the state and pilot level have begun expanding RN autonomy: Oregon’s Landmark Law (2025): Oregon became the first state to explicitly authorize RNs to bill an insurer directly for certain services

Like
Reply
Robert J. Abel

Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner

1mo

Your post is provocative and, frankly, necessary. But I’d push back on one central point: nursing is not void of its own framework. We do have a sovereign science. Nightingale, Roy, Orem, Neuman, Peplau, Watson, Leininger — these aren’t just “sentiment,” they are organized logics that explain human response, adaptation, recovery, and health beyond biology. The issue isn’t absence; it’s visibility and unity. Our frameworks remain fragmented, under-taught, and under-leveraged in practice environments dominated by medicine and economics. The “taskification” of nursing is real, but that’s a systems distortion, not evidence that nursing has no science. Nurses generate outcomes every day — prevention of complications, faster recoveries, better symptom management, family adaptation — but because we haven’t insisted on measuring and branding those outcomes as nursing, they get absorbed into “teamwork” or “medicine.” So I agree with your call: we must stop pretending task execution is nursing. But I’d add this: we also must stop pretending our science is missing. It exists. The future of the profession isn’t about creating it from scratch — it’s about reclaiming, naming, and applying it with the same rigor medicine applies to its own.

Bernice G. Gulek, PhD, APRN, ACNP

Global Neurosurgery | Systems Thinking | Strategic Change | Advanced Practice | Clinical Research Scientist | aSAH | TBI | HRQOL | Patient Reported Outcomes(PROs) | Response Shift

1mo

There is a need for big “mindshift”, which will take a long time, until each one of us keep ourselves accountable and take the responsibility. It’s happening and it’s very slow. Thank you for your advocacy and tirelessly pushing it forward.

Nursing is at a crossroads like I have never experienced before in over 40 years and we must take the path with the most resistance. We must become sovereign!! Ali Fakher, BSN, RN, I, one hundred percent agree with what you have said. In fact I agree with everything you have ever written in LinkedIn. Nursing needs dynamic leaders like you but you standout!! Please consider publishing!

To view or add a comment, sign in

Others also viewed

Explore content categories