HAMILTON COUNTY JUDGE CASE
HAMILTON COUNTY JUDGE CASE
GROUP MEMBERS
NAME SAP ID
ANUBHAV KHURANA 80303190023
AYUSH SINHA 80303190051
GAGAN MAKKAR 80303190053
ABHISHEK SHRIVASTAVA 80303190116
ANUBHAV ANAND 80303190117
PROBABILTY 2
PROBABILTY OF CASES APPEALED AND REVERSED
PROBABILITY OF CASES BEING PROBABILITY OF CASES
COURTS TOTAL CASES DISPOSED APPEALED CASES REVERSED CASES APPEALED BEING REVERSED
COMMON
PLEA COURT 43945 1762 199 0.04009557 0.00452839
DOMESTIC
RELATIONS
COURT 30499 106 17 0.00347552 0.0005574
MUNICIPAL
COURT 108464 500 104 0.00460982 0.00095884
PROBABILTY 3
PROBABILITY OF A CASE BEING APPEALED FOR EACH JUDGE
Probability of
cases being
Judges Total cases disposed Appealed cases appealed
Fred Cartolano 3037 137 0.04511031
Thomas Crush 3372 119 0.03529063
Patrick Dinkelacker 1258 44 0.03497615
Timothy Hogan 1954 60 0.03070624
Robert Kraft 3138 127 0.04047164
William Mathews 2264 91 0.04019435
William Morrissey 3032 121 0.03990765
Norbert Nadel 2959 131 0.04427171
Arthur Ney, Jr. 3219 125 0.03883194
Richard Niehaus 3353 137 0.04085893
Thomas Nurre 3000 121 0.04033333
John O'Connor 2969 129 0.04344897
Robert Ruehlman 3205 145 0.04524181
J.Howard Sundermann 955 60 0.06282723
Ann Marie Tracey 3141 127 0.04043298
Ralph Winkler 3089 88 0.02848818
Penelope Cunningham 2729 7 0.002565042
Patrick Dinkelacker 6001 19 0.003166139
Deborah Gaines 8799 48 0.005455165
Ronald Panioto 12970 32 0.002467232
Mike Allen 6149 43 0.006993
Nadine Allen 7812 34 0.0043523
Timothy Black 7954 41 0.0051546
David Davis 7736 43 0.0055584
Leslie Isaiah Gaines 5282 35 0.0066263
Karla Grandy 5253 6 0.0011422
Deidra Hair 2522 5 0.0019826
Dennis Helmick 7900 29 0.0036709
Timothy Hogan 2308 13 0.0056326
James Patrick Kenney 2798 6 0.0021444
Joseph Luebbers 4698 25 0.0053214
William Mallory 8277 38 0.004591
Melba Marsh 8219 34 0.0041368
Beth Mattingly 2971 13 0.0043756
Albert Mestemaker 4975 28 0.0056281
Mark Painter 2239 7 0.0031264
PROBABILTY 4
Jack Rosen 7790 41 0.0052632
Mark Schweikert 5403 33 0.0061077
David Stockdale 5371 22 0.0040961
John A.West 2797 4 0.0014301
PROBABILTY OF A CASE BEING REVERSED FOR EACH JUDGE
Probability of
cases being
Judges Total cases disposed Reversed cases reversed
Fred Cartolano 3037 12 0.003951268
Thomas Crush 3372 10 0.002965599
Patrick Dinkelacker 1258 8 0.0063593
Timothy Hogan 1954 7 0.003582395
Robert Kraft 3138 7 0.00223072
William Mathews 2264 18 0.00795053
William Morrissey 3032 22 0.007255937
Norbert Nadel 2959 20 0.00675904
Arthur Ney, Jr. 3219 14 0.004349177
Richard Niehaus 3353 16 0.004771846
Thomas Nurre 3000 6 0.002
John O'Connor 2969 12 0.004041765
Robert Ruehlman 3205 18 0.005616225
J.Howard Sundermann 955 10 0.010471204
Ann Marie Tracey 3141 13 0.004138809
Ralph Winkler 3089 6 0.001942376
Penelope Cunningham 2729 1 0.000366435
Patrick Dinkelacker 6001 4 0.000666556
Deborah Gaines 8799 9 0.001022844
Ronald Panioto 12970 3 0.000231303
Mike Allen 6149 4 0.00065051
Nadine Allen 7812 6 0.00076805
Timothy Black 7954 6 0.00075434
David Davis 7736 5 0.00064633
Leslie Isaiah Gaines 5282 13 0.00246119
Karla Grandy 5253 0 0
Deidra Hair 2522 0 0
Dennis Helmick 7900 5 0.00063291
PROBABILTY 5
Timothy Hogan 2308 2 0.00086655
James Patrick Kenney 2798 1 0.0003574
Joseph Luebbers 4698 8 0.00170285
William Mallory 8277 9 0.00108735
Melba Marsh 8219 7 0.00085169
Beth Mattingly 2971 1 0.00033659
Albert Mestemaker 4975 9 0.00180905
Mark Painter 2239 3 0.00133988
Jack Rosen 7790 13 0.00166881
Mark Schweikert 5403 6 0.00111049
David Stockdale 5371 4 0.00074474
John A.West 2797 2 0.00071505
PROBABILITY OF REVERSAL GIVEN AN APPEAL FOR EACH JUDGE
PROBABILTY 6
RANK OF JUDGES IN EACH COURT
PROBABILTY 7
DOMESTIC RELATIONS COURT
Judges Probability Rank(appealed) Probability Rank(reversed) Probability Rank Total
of cases of cases of reversal rank
being being given an
appealed reversed appeal
Penelope 0.00256504 2 0.00036643 2 0.14285714 2 6
Cuningham 2 5 3
Patrick 0.00316613 3 0.00066655 3 0.21052631 4 10
Dinkelacker 9 6 6
Deborah 0.00545516 4 0.00102284 4 0.1875 3 11
Gaines 5 4
Ronald 0.00246723 1 0.00023130 1 0.09375 1 3
Panioto 2 3
Judges Probabilit Rank(appealed Probability Rank(reversed Probability Ran Total
y of cases ) of cases ) of reversal k Ran
being being given an k
appealed reversed appeal
Mike Allen 0.006993 20 0.0006505 7 0.0930232 4 31
1 6
Nadine 0.0043523 9 0.0007680 11 0.1764705 10 30
Allen 5 9
Timothy 0.0051546 12 0.0007543 10 0.1463414 6 28
Black 4 6
David Davis 0.0055584 0.0006463 6 0.1162790 5 26
15 3 7
Leslie Isaiah 0.0066263 19 0.0024611 20 0.3714285 18 57
Gaines 9 7
Karla 0.0011422 1 0 1 0 1 3
Grandy
Deidra Hair 0.0019826 3 0 1 0 1 5
Dennis 0.0036709 6 0.0006329 5 0.1724137 9 20
Helmick 1 9
Timothy 0.0056326 17 0.0008665 13 0.1538461 7 37
Hogan 5 5
James 0.0021444 4 0.0003574 4 0.1666666 8 16
PROBABILTY 8
Patrick 7
Kenney
Joseph 0.0053214 14 0.0017028 18 0.32 16 48
Luebbers 5
William 0.004591 11 0.0010873 14 0.2368421 14 39
Mallory 5 1
Melba 0.0041368 8 0.0008516 12 0.2058823 13 33
Marsh 9 5
Beth 0.0043756 10 0.0003365 3 0.0769230 3 16
Mattingly 9 8
Albert 0.0056281 16 0.0018090 19 0.3214285 17 52
Mestemake 5 7
r
Mark 0.0031264 5 0.0013398 16 0.4285714 19 40
Painter 8 3
Jack Rosen 0.0052632 13 0.0016688 17 0.3170731 15 45
1 7
Mark 0.061077 18 0.0011104 15 0.1818181 11 44
Schweikert 9 8
David 0.0040961 7 0.0007447 9 0.1818181 11 27
Stockdale 4 8
John A West 0.0014301 2 0.0007150 8 0.5 20 30
5
PROBABILTY 9
