Ronnie Bago
Ronnie Bago
Teaching Effectiveness
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
The Educator's performance is very important in the teaching and learning process. In a sense, it is arguably the most influential
school-related factor determining a student's accomplishment in schools and in the curriculum per se. According to Deunk et. al.
(2018), computer technology can be a helpful tool in facilitating instructional techniques especially in delivering the required
competencies to the learners. In addition, Regier (2020) believed that mastery experiences had the greatest impact on
administrators' self-efficacy for teaching tactics, followed by verbal persuasions, physiological condition, and vicarious experiences.
Furthermore, individuals who reported higher self-efficacy for teaching methods regarded themselves as more confident in their ability
Through such, it is evident that there are multiple approaches for educational leaders to provide the proper method for effective
manner facilitating learning, which will be the primary source of their efficient and effective learning. Various educational practices and
Science Educator's Performance will be determined through the use of the analysis, as well as the amount to which these Educators
Theoretical Frameworks
The study used Kolb's Theory of Learning Styles. Kolb's constructivist learning theory is one of the most well-known
and commonly applied learning styles theories. In 1984, psychologist David Kolb presented his hypothesis of learning styles for the
first time. According to the said theory, Kolb (1984) believed that our unique learning styles develop as a result of our genetics, life
experiences, and the demands of our current environment. Kolb's theoretical foundation for experiential education has been updated
to reflect the present organizational and educational situation. It will be a valuable resource for anybody seeking to encourage more
effective learning in higher education, training, program management, life - long learning contexts, and beyond. Because of the
Learning Style that has been conveyed, this can serve as a foundation for educators to successfully execute skills and educational
methodologies.
Also, the paper used Mischel’s Cognitive-Affective Model as a part of its Theoretical Framework. According to Mischel
(1968), an individual's conduct is impacted by two factors: the precise qualities of a given circumstance and how he interprets the
situation. In contrast to classic social cognitive theories, Mischel suggested that a person only behaves similarly when the outcomes
are extremely likely to be the same. It is also stated that the research revealed that an individual's conduct is essentially dependent on
situational cues—the necessities of a certain situation—rather than just the outcome of his or her features. Mischel's ideas inspired him
to create the cognitive-affective personality paradigm. Finally, Mischel argued that behavior does not occur and that our qualities are
essentially cognitive strategies or things we do for ourselves in order to achieve the type of benefit we desire. In line with these,
Alternative Learning approaches may be developed and applied for the Learners, and the Educator's mentoring and coaching will
increase as a result.
Conceptual Framework
The concepts of the study focus on the educational practices and its correlation to the performance of public secondary science
teacher. From this, the researcher is to focus on identifying the Input, Process and Output of the study. It is clear that that concepts of
study are presented using the IPO research paradigm. The input of the study involves the extent of the educational leadership. Also
the performance of the Science teachers are placed as input of the study. For the process, the study has involved data gathering
procedures in the form of survey questionnaire. For the output of the study, it involves evaluation of the relationship between school
administrative practices and the performance of Science Teachers. It is also included in the output the generation of an intervention
model that addresses the things that are needed to be addressed in this study. Below is a figure or diagram tat completely identifying
Figure 1
The study aims to know the correlation between the educational leadership practices and the performance of the science
teachers for the past three years. Specifically, the study answers the following questions:
1. To what extent do the school administrators practice educational leadership in their respective schools as assessed by the
3. What is the performance of Elementary and Secondary Science teachers for the past three years?
4. Is there a significant relationship between the educational practices and performance of Science teachers?
5. What are the problems encountered by the school administrators as educational leaders?
Hypothesis
The researcher assumed in the study that the Educational Practices being implemented and the Performance of Elementary and
Secondary Science Teachers have a significant relationship to each other. It is assumed in this hypothesis that the Educational
This research is conducted in selected elementary and secondary schools in the Division of Biñan City in the year 2021. The
researcher's goal is to obtain potential strategies that can be implemented to those for whom this study is important, as well as to
support and effectively manage the existing problem. The study investigates how the elementary and secondary Science Educators'
educational practices and methodologies affect their teaching quality effectiveness. Lastly, to evaluate the relationship between
Educational Practices and Educators' Teaching Performance, the Researcher used (attach Research instrument) accordingly.
This section demonstrates the importance of the research to individuals, organizations, and humankind as a whole. The
Department of Education - The Department of Education will gain insight into how these Science Teachers conduct excellent
instructional strategies as a result of the research. If the findings show that educators appear to be inefficient when it comes to
teaching, the Department of Education will undoubtedly be able to determine what programs to implement and how to implement
them in order to provide the Educators with ideas on how to improve their teaching methods in order to improve their performance.
School Administrators - School Administrators may analyze the effectiveness of elementary and secondary science teachers' ability
or competence in leading, organizing, planning, and evaluating as a result of the research. The study will also provide information on
ways to improve curriculum, teaching, faculty and staff development, and physical facility development, which will help School
Elementary and Secondary Science Teachers - Science Teachers can now have the different strategic plans that can be applied
to boost teaching performance efficiency with the usage of this research because it is the main emphasis of the research. The findings
of this study can be used to help these educators improve and be more effective in delivering the Learners' performance.
Future Researchers - As a result of the research, future researchers will be able to determine which aspects of the problem remain
unsolved and how they are still influences current educators and instructional practices. Following researchers will be able to prove
and solidify their understanding of the problem, as well as broaden the scope of the study's impact, as a result of this.
Definition of Terms
Unknown terms that are key or important terms in the study are clearly clarified in this section.
Cognitive
: of, relating to, or involving conscious mental activities (such as thinking, understanding, learning, and remembering)
Educational Practices
: the instructional tasks and strategies that promote learning at each level and how to sequence and individualize those learning
activities (knowledge of how to cultivate both content knowledge and learning competencies as part of everyday instructional
practices)
Genetics
Homogeneous
: of the same or a similar kind or nature; of uniform structure or composition throughout a culturally homogeneous neighborhood
Influential
Instructional
: intended or used for teaching; educational; giving detailed information about how something should be done or operated.
Insufficient
Physiological
: relating to the branch of biology that deals with the normal functions of living organisms and their parts.
Precise
Psychologist
Secondary
: coming after, less important than, or resulting from someone or something else that is primary.
Self-efficacy
: refers to an individual's belief in their capacity to execute behaviors necessary to produce specific performance attainments. Self-
Foreign Literature
Cheng et. al. (2018) said, academic effectiveness and local implementation are major determinants in survival following cardiac
arrest, according to the formula for survival in resuscitation. Contemporary educational options, such as standardized online and face-
to-face courses, are inadequate. This correlates to subpar clinical care and poor cardiac arrest survival rates. And as per the American
Society of Resuscitation Educators (ASERT) and the American College of Emergency Medical Practitioners, recovery education must be
enhanced to guarantee that persons experiencing cardiac arrest receive quality resuscitative care (ACMP). The use of recognized
educational strategies that improve knowledge retention should be incorporated into the design and delivery of resuscitation
education.
As per Close et. al (2018), with the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act in 2002, federally mandatory testing became a
reality. Large-scale assessments became one of the cornerstones of accountability-based systems and policies for not only districts,
schools, and students, but also teachers, as a result of this step. Despite this, Congress passed “Every Student Succeeds Act” in 2015
in response to acknowledged flaws in such methods, particularly at the student and teacher levels (ESSA). The new law offered states
more discretion over their state evaluation and accountability systems while reducing federal oversight.
As reported by Darling-Hammond et. al. (2017) to acquire competencies such as deep knowledge of difficult topics, sophisticated
teaching methods are required. To assist instructors in learning and refining pedagogies, effective professional development (PD) is
required. In order to foster improvements in teacher practices and student learning, professional development programs tend to be
ineffectual. Also, Teachers’ professional learning is gaining popularity as a means of supporting students' development of increasingly
sophisticated skills in preparation for future education and career in the twenty-first century.
According to the study of Day (2017), Teachers' Worlds and Work is a comprehensive, research-based examination of major
variables that influence teachers' work and lives individually and in combination. The book offers innovative, in-depth, and holistic
perspectives on their influence, as well as recommendations for improving and maintaining instructors' abilities and enthusiasm to
teach. Identifying what factors influence the quality of a teacher's work over the course of their career is critical to fostering and
However, According to Fauth et. al. (2019), in a pre-post approach, learners' conceptual grasp and interest were assessed during
different instructional units. Learners' interest was positively associated with teacher competency (pedagogical content understanding,
self-efficacy, and instructional excitement). These associations were mediated by three aspects of teaching quality (cognitive
As per Gore et. al. (2017) concluded that the Quality Teaching Framework (QT) is not just technique in the sense of practicing
single teaching abilities, but also in the context of complete lessons. In this way, rather than weakening the academic and spiritual
parts of teaching, the method increases them. The findings add to the global evidence foundation for bettering teaching. Although we
believe the QT framework and its implementation in Quality Teaching Rounds are part of the most current practice-based change in
teacher education (Zeichner, 2012), we feel they do different sorts of work. QT encompasses concerns for social justice, integrating
classroom learning to broader social challenges, and the handling of knowledge, among other things.
Based on what Hanunshek and Rivkin (2010) study, the precise approach for attributing disparities in classroom accomplishment
to teachers has sparked a lot of debate and inquiry. The authors begin by quickly describing the overall analytical framework that
underpins much of the work in this field, and then go on to present the breadth of findings from recent efforts to assess teacher
efficacy variance. An education production function is generally used to begin an analysis of teacher value added.
According to Regmi and Jones (2020), the following characteristics have been highlighted as having an impact on e-learning:
cooperation and discussion between help learners develop; taking into account learners' incentive and expectations; using consumer
software; and placing learners at the center of pedagogy. There is a lot of room for better understanding the difficulties surrounding e-
learning enablers and facilitators, as well as building policies and programs to determine when, how, and where they fit best, thereby
requires an educational system that provides a venue for the development of scientific knowledge and skills. Evidently, the rapid
development of this field of knowledge through scientific inventions and discoveries posts a challenge to educational institutions to
contribute their part in this growing demand of scientific inquiry. In the Philippines, the study of science is mandatory in all levels of
education and the state is mandated to give priority to science and technology education, training and services. Students need to
develop scientific literacy in order to participate fully as citizens, community members, and in the globalized economy. Scientific
literacy dictates that students should have the reading ability to evaluate the print-based information presented to them.
Lastly, Usanov (2020) believed that one of the most hotly debated topics in contemporary Uzbek society is the state of education
and its prospects. Language training is also looked into from other angles. The essay examines eight ways to improve teaching and
looks at the educational process in general. It makes suggestions for how teachers might improve their teaching - learning process.
The article illustrates the role of student involvement and preference in furthering the instruction, in line with teachers' classroom
management skills. The problem of addressing students' academic needs is discussed in the article as a critical aspect in improving
education quality.
Local Literature
According to the study by Torres et al. (2020) a faculty member plays a critical role in a university's success and good reputation,
both among students and among professors. Being employed as a faculty member in a university necessitates proficiency. It is a
method of promoting students' learning by ensuring not only the quality of teachers in their particular field of study, but also that
students interact with experts. Personal traits, professional qualities, social qualities, and instructional skills are the four components of
an effective educator. All of these attributes will be examined for key future decisions, according to the researchers.
As mentioned in the study by Fiscal (2019) Higher education institutions (HEIs) are critical in the generation, transmission,
dissemination, and application of knowledge to students, faculty, and industry. As a knowledge-based institution, HEIs should always
act and function in accordance with the knowledge agenda. The public has challenged HEIs to innovate and distribute information by
changing their function from teaching, research, and service. Universities all across the world have implemented KM processes,
systems strategies, approaches, practices, methodologies, and models to address the challenge. The goal of KM adoption in higher
education institutions is to adapt to globalization and integration. Research, training, knowledge usage for better decision making, and
knowledge exploitation to increase the degree of knowledge distribution are all specific goals of KM implementation.
Based on the study by Alipio (2020) Science helps the learners to improve the knowledge about different forms of scientific
explanation and phenomenological science facts can be proven by the use of experimental evidence. Educational practices resulting
best plan to have a proper learning system that learners need to widen learning and have interest in Science. Higher education
completion is a significant milestone in a person's life. The transition from senior high school to college, on the other hand, can be
difficult, and students' ideas about their fate during this time can be a source of stress. Another change is college professors' adoption
of a new approach known as Outcome-Based Education (OBE). The Commission on Higher Education (CHED) mandated the
implementation of this scheme in Philippine universities and colleges in 2012 through CHED Memorandum Order No. 46, in order to
As reported by Cruz (2020) academic overload refers to students' feelings of being overwhelmed by their academic
obligations while obtaining a degree at a university. Students who are overworked academically may believe this. There is insufficient
time to manage all academic tasks properly and sufficiently, such as tests, exams, research projects, essays, and oral presentations.
The amount of effort students put into academic work is influenced by their judgments of the demands of the academic tasks and
their assessments of their abilities to complete the tasks, and insufficient effort can lead to academic failure. In reality, it has been
proven that issues controlling academic burden have a detrimental impact on academic adjustment to university and academic
success. To effectively seek help, students must first identify the problem that requires assistance, recognize that learners require
assistance with that problem, and feel that seeking help would be beneficial. Several students may seek psychological or counseling
services during their time at university academic support to aid individuals with interpersonal, social, academic, or career-related
issues.
In line with Ancheta Ancheta (2020) management of learning materials is simple for both teachers and students at
academic institutions with their own LMS. Quizzes, classwork, and other performance assignments, such as quarterly exams, can all be
made available online. For simple communication, user administrators can create email accounts for students using Microsoft Office
365. Schools with minimal funding and resources, on the other hand, make full use of the system. A strategy that is modular. If there
isn't a platform for uploading learning materials, parents can request items from the school by following the required procedures. In
practice, this enables professors to work from home while students learn at their own speed at home. However, there is a big problem
with online evaluations. To counter the impact of Covid-19 in the Philippines, the Department of Education (DepEd) reiterates its
commitment to providing quality education that is relevant to basic education services, based on its tagline "Sulong Edukalidad"
framework. The redesigned MELCs are also part of the DepEd's reaction to establish a resilient education system, particularly during
According to the study by Hero (2019) in the Philippines, the execution of the K to 12 Education program demands the use of
technology in the classroom. Technology integration in the classroom enables and assists Social Studies teachers to bridge the gap
between traditional teaching techniques and technology-based teaching and learning tools and facilities, thereby addressing the
shortcomings of traditional teaching methods. As a result, an increasing number of educators are exposing themselves to the
technological infusion that can help them improve their teaching performance in Social Studies. Furthermore, integrating technology
into the classroom is critical for increasing teacher productivity and performance. Currently, the country is implementing the K to 12
Education program, which highlights technology integration in teaching as one of its key features in improving teacher performance
and productivity, particularly among Social Studies teachers in public high schools, as well as how technology can be used in the
learning process.
As reported in the study Sumardani (2021) teachers must keep in mind that each country has its own method. Every country has
its own approach to science education. For the Philippines, the official curriculum instruction is to teach all courses in English. Another
difficulty is that English is the official language of instruction in science classes. However, it is widely acknowledged that most teachers
and students employ a combination of English and Filipino dialects in classroom instruction and discussion. Teachers' minds are always
drawn back to the issue of language. Teachers inquire as to how they might teach science to children who are unable to comprehend
the language. To overcome linguistic barriers, the obvious solution is to use actual goods and experiences. In any language, direct
experience is also the best approach to develop word meanings. To add to the difficulties, appropriate instructional resources are
scarce.
In line with Walag et al. (2020) self-efficacy beliefs are a teacher's assessment of his or her ability to facilitate the
accomplishment of desired learning objectives and to engage pupils in learning and performance. Self-efficacy beliefs are crucial in
deciding teaching behaviors, which include selecting appropriate instructional activities, planning lessons, and preparing for difficult
situations. Teachers who have a high level of self-efficacy are more likely to use inquiry-based teaching methods and create learner-
centered environments for their learners. The many science concepts and applications are now taught in a spiraling progression
manner, in which the scope and order of contents are built in such a way that concepts and skills are repeated at each grade level to
facilitate mastery from one level to the next. Science teachers must teach all of science's specialties in each grade level, with
Meanwhile the study by Roberto & Madrigal (2018) teachers' ability to teach is determined by their teaching standards.
Participation in various in-service trainings and programs improved their knowledge, abilities, and attitudes. However, work habits and
experience in the profession have the greatest impact on teaching performance. Teachers' standards competency influences or
associates with their teaching performance. Teachers can keep track of their own progress in meeting teaching standards, which will
help them achieve the requisite competency and improve their teaching performance. Personal growth and development, such as
obtaining additional education and pursuing a master's degree or other professional courses, is a major problem that the school must
her class. The latter requires a theoretical and practical understanding of educational psychology, teaching methods, new
communication strategies, social psychology, and communicating outcomes to others, among other things students who take into
account the entire teacher-cognition process. The new Philippine Professional Code is being adopted and implemented. Standards for
Teachers recognizes the value of professional standards in the ongoing professional development and advancement of teachers, based
on the principle of lifelong learning, which refers to the systematic acquisition, upgrade, and promotion of knowledge, skills, and
Foriegn Studies
The study of Bal-Taştan et. al. (2018) found out that for scientific education and academic achievement of students in science,
the impact of instructor attributes on self-efficacy level is critical. The effects of teacher efficacy and enthusiasm on learners'
educational excellence in scientific education in secondary and high schools in Iran and Russia were explored in this study.
Fischer et. al. (2018) stated that components of instructional implementation features are connected with student performance in
a meaningful but modest way. As a result, this study reaffirms the need for high-quality career development for instructors and
advises that research into effective teaching approaches be advanced. A quantitative analysis backs up some of Desimone's (2009)
teacher professional improvement theoretical model. Multilevel structural equation models based on national data sets containing data
from 133 336 students and 7434 instructors show that career development engagement and contextual school- as well as instructor
As reported by Fawns et. al. (2020), a growing number of metrics convert items, traits, and practices into data, which can
subsequently be manipulated. While evaluation should aid in making informed decisions, it should also include relationships and
situations. It should make a concerted effort to support teacher development and pedagogically sound educational practice. Empirical
study on how evaluation might leverage data-driven methodologies to support nuanced judgments, not just about teaching, but about
According to Hartinah (2020) stated the licensed teacher's performance was directly influenced by the principal's leadership and
the work environment. Aspiration to affiliate, on the other hand, had no effect on teachers' performance. The data was evaluated
using the most up-to-date technique, Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), which is based on Partial Least Square. Autonomous head
management and workplace environment elements can explain individual teacher's productivity.
As stated by Malik (2018) study, the converging impact of globalization, ICT and knowledge explosion has led to phenomenal
changes in modern society. To cope with these run-away changes we need to prepare the workforce with skills to handle a range of
electronic technologies. A different approach to the delivery of education is required. The study contends that nothing other than a
major shift in the way education is offered to tomorrow's and tomorrow's 'digital natives,' especially in low - income nations, is
required. It is critical for a country to give calibrated education to produce internationally competitive citizens, according to the
argument that education is the engine room and the strength of a nation is founded on its quality education.
While Mosbiran et. al. (2020) stated that the headmaster's leadership is critical in defining the school's success path. Absolutist,
democrat, and politique leadership approaches are all used to describe school leadership. In Malaysia, a meta-analysis was undertaken
to look into past studies on special needs students' leadership. Qualified teachers in middle and high schools were also known to be
In line with Suryawati and Osman (2017), the study aims to determine the impact of contextual instruction on learners' scientific
attitudes and Natural Science performance among junior high school students in Pekanbaru, Indonesia. A total of 215 Form VII pupils
from three public schools were involved in this quasi-experiment, which was divided into three groups depending on cognitive abilities.
Overall, the findings demonstrated that considerable differences exist from across the board. In terms of student achievement, the
experimental groups outperformed the control groups. There is, unfortunately, no such thing. In terms of science approach, there is a
substantial difference. These discoveries have a big impact. Implications for improving high - level thinking skills in a variety of pupils'
Moreover, Swain et. al. (2019) said that the impact of selective bonus payments (SRB) on close to the bottom, high-poverty
schools is estimated in this study. According to the findings, schools who offered SRBs experienced higher test score gains in later
years. The bonus program's theoretical approach is straightforward: SRBs result in more highly effective teachers. According to the
findings, schools who provided SRBs experienced higher test score gains in later years, particularly on state language exams.
Just as Torlak and Kuzey (2019), only managing by exception (MBE) and idealized influence (II), inspirational motivation (IM),
intellectual stimulation (IS), and individualized consideration (IC) were found to have a substantial beneficial relationship with EJS and
EJP. MBE had a considerable beneficial influence on both EJS and EJP, whereas contingent rewards had no significant effect on EJS
and a modest positive significant effect on EJP. In addition, II, IM, IS, and IC showed a considerable favorable impact on EJS and EJP.
As per Walag et al. (2020), The level of self-efficacy was reported in terms of personal science teaching efficacy and science
teaching expectancy outcome. The science teachers scored satisfactory in both personal science teaching efficacy and science teaching
expectancy outcome. This was believed to be due to their limited actual teaching experience. In terms of subject-specific self-efficacy,
teachers reported being more confident in teaching chemistry, followed by earth and space science, biology, and physics. Primary
teachers were found to be more confident in teaching chemistry, whereas high school teachers were most confident in biology. Both
groups noted to be less confident in teaching physics, which could be due to the nature of this subject. It is with these reasons that it
is recommended that in the design of professional development programs for teachers, much attention should be given to the topics
that teachers are least confident in teaching. In addition, in the design of teacher-education curricula, experience in the actual
teaching of different science subjects must be integrated to address their self-efficacy beliefs early on hopefully.
Local Studies
Alea et. al. (2020) stated that gender, length of teaching experience, and geographical area of teachers, on the other hand,
have a substantial impact on their readiness for distant learning instruction. The findings reveal that the teachers were well aware of
the COVID-19 Pandemic's presence and effects. There is no association between the demographic profiles of teachers and their
awareness of COVID-19. The study looked into teachers' knowledge of the COVID-19 pandemic and their perceptions of their schools'
preparedness. There is no association between both the demographic profiles of teachers and their awareness of the outbreak.
As reported by Molano (2020) in 2013, the K to 12 Reform (R.A. 10533) altered the landscape of teacher quality standards
in the Philippines. A similar supportive focus on teacher quality – high-quality teachers – is required as part of the reform process who
are appropriately trained and prepared to fulfill the tasks and functions of a K–12 teacher, and it is via this PPST that they will be able
to contribute to the Department of Education's vision of producing: "Filipinos who are prepared to teach." who fervently love their
country and whose principles and abilities enable them to reach their full potential and effectively contribute to the nation's
development. The talents have been designated as 21st century skills by educators, researchers, and employers, and they must be
taught at all levels of school. This approach has been incorporated into the Philippine Department of Education's K–12 Education
reform agenda. The goal of the Basic Education curriculum is to generate well-rounded persons with 21st-century capabilities. Life and
career skills, learning and innovation skills, communication skills, and media and technology skills are the four categories.
Based on the study by Fuente (2019), Science education is extremely important for the country's economic prosperity. It
promotes national prosperity, advances technology, and enhances health and industry. In this context, the qualitative research looked
into the participants' feelings about their decision to specialize in Science. The fundamental quality, teaching skill, industry awareness,
and research capacity of the teachers are evaluated in order to identify gaps and provide adequate interventions. There are, however,
external elements that influence these aspects, such as a pleasant academic environment in controlling the relationship between
In line with Basco (2020) Science education focuses on improving students' scientific literacy, which will prepare them to be
rational and active citizens capable of making decisions and judgements about the application of scientific knowledge that may have
health, environmental, or societal consequences. Filipino students consistently demonstrate poor science performance, despite the
good effects of these infographics as educational tools. As a result, this research was carried out in order to shed light on the subject.
In the Philippines, there is a gap in the efficiency of infographics in enhancing science academic performance. To assist teachers in
reflecting on and evaluating their own practices as they strive for personal and professional growth; to define teacher quality in the
Philippines; to describe the expectations of teachers' increasing levels of knowledge, practice, and professional engagement; to allow
for teachers' growing understanding, applied with increasing sophistication across a broader and more complex range of
As mentioned by Dela Cruz (2022) the government's requirements and attempts for maintaining its science education
program in light of the changes brought on by the twenty-first century In the Philippines, the science curriculum was implemented to
generate scientifically literate persons who can make responsible decisions and utilize scientific knowledge to find answers to
community problems. The Philippines, on the other hand, came in last among participating countries in the latest results of the
Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) 2018, in which Science was one of the topics examined. The results of the
Philippines' inaugural participation in PISA have prepared the path for the Department of Education to propose more measures to
address the country's poor academic performance and improve education quality. Furthermore, the rapid change brought on by
Industry 4.0 poses a challenge to science educators, as the country must ensure that it can adapt to developing technologies such as
artificial intelligence. As well as robotics Through the responsive and tailor-fit programs and projects, the Department of Science and
Technology and the Science Education Institute have accomplished a number of goals.
According to the study by Cortes et al (2021) in the Philippines, there have been a variety of efforts to promote AR. One of
the attempts to encourage the culture of doing AR in the country is for the country's Commission on Higher Education (CHED) to
incorporate AR as a subject course across all specialties, as mentioned in several teacher education curricular programs. The AR
course is aimed to equip pre-service elementary teachers in their practicum with an opportunity to undertake AR to improve student
learning and teaching techniques. The AR course requires pre-service secondary science teachers to conduct AR in the content or
pedagogy of Biology, Chemistry, Physics, or Earth Science (Commission on Higher Education, 2017b). The objectives of AR courses
differ depending on the curricular program in which pre-service teachers are enrolled.
In the light of Vera et al (2018) to get a detailed grasp of how each context defines it, as well as the accompanying
procedures of implementation and evaluation, government-mandated curricula and standards were juxtaposed with the aims of
science education, as articulated within national policies on science education. This study employs anthropological methodologies as
well as curricular theory in order to determine what each educational system values and how it operates to represent those values.
The relevance and role of a context's educational system's milieus and culture, as well as the values and beliefs contained within both,
cannot be understated among curriculum theorists and practitioners. It is for this reason that a simple uproot-and-plant model of
global educational policies not only fails, but is also a mistaken and potentially dangerous approach to developing cross-cultural
curricula. To avoid localizing the "globalized," Western approach, an investigation of current curricula within both partners' local
As per Tupas (2019) textbooks, instructors' guides, and technology-based materials are among the science curriculum
materials provided by the ministry or department, and are produced by teachers to help students improve their performance. To
generate successful learners, effective science teachers use a variety of teaching strategies and methods. Filipino teachers become
adaptable, employing a variety of tools and procedures to make scientific instruction enjoyable and engaging. Because education is
always changing, professional development is one approach to stay up to date on current information and practices. Teachers'
professional development is essential in order to provide solid science information and enable them to gain new knowledge.
As mentioned in the study by Cordon & Polong (2020) in the growth of education, student science literacy is critical.
Science literacy, according to the OECD, is the ability of students to engage with issues connected to science and scientific concepts as
reflective citizens. People who are science literate will engage in reasoned debate about science and technology, which will necessitate
the ability to explain phenomena, evaluate, plan Science research, interpret data, and evidence Science. Science literacy is both a
measure of student progress and a measure of a teacher's success in the classroom. It needs to be looked at from a variety of angles
to see what might be causing it, such as the new curriculum (K-12), teacher and student readiness or unpreparedness in this exam, or
other factors. Assessment findings must be utilized to view student performance in the context of the K-12 Program so that relevant
and responsive policies, programs, and reforms can be implemented to further improve the quality of teaching and learning at the
school and national levels. According to the PISA 2018 findings, there is a disparity between senior and junior high schools, rural and
urban locations, and private and public schools. This problem, if discussed in detail, will result in a vast and complex problem, but it is
created by inequity in school facilities, which, if it persists, will result in a slowing in the quality of student learning processes.
However, According to Bug-os et al. (2020), the Philippines had a major revamp in its basic education curriculum, particularly
the implementation of the new K to 12 curricula. Within the five years from its full implementation, several challenges were identified
by curriculum experts, research scholars, and even the in-service teachers. This problem is evident in the revisions made in the science
curriculum. The curricular change has presented a mismatch problem between in-service science teachers and the current science
curriculum. Hence, this study aimed at examining the topics that the science teachers’ least confident in teaching in the elementary
and high school science curriculum. In this manner, the gap between an in-service science teacher and the current science curriculum
will be revealed. This study utilized a descriptive research design with adapted questionnaires from the literature. The PSTE and STEO
have satisfactory levels for elementary and high school teachers. Elementary teachers were most confident in teaching chemistry,
while high school teachers were most confident in teaching biology. Teaching physics is the least confident area in science for both
groups. The results were believed to be due to the limited years of actual science teaching experience. The findings of this study can
be used to design and develop evidence-based courses to address the gap between science teacher's efficacy and the current science
The studies of Cheng et. al. (2018), Close et. al (2018), Darling-Hammond et. al. (2017), Day (2017), Fauth et. al. (2019), Gore
et. al. (2017), Hanunshek and Rivkin (2010), Regmi and Jones (2020), Imam et al. (2014) and Usanov (2020) focused on the various
pieces of information that support educational practices and teaching quality, which can have serious consequences for both students
and teachers.
Meanwhile the studies of Torres et al. (2020), Fiscal (2019), Alipio (2020), Cruz (2020), Ancheta (2020), Hero (2019),
Sumardani (2021), Walag et al. (2020), Roberto & Madrigal (2018), and Gepila (2020) focused on the significance of educational
practices that influence teaching quality and teachers' ability to perform better in the classroom.
While the studies conducted by Bal-Taştan et. al. (2018), Fischer et. al. (2018), Fawns et. al. (2020), Hartinah (2020), Malik
(2018), Mosbiran et. al. (2020), Suryawati and Osman (2017), Swain et. al. (2019), Torlak and Kuzey (2019), Walag et al. (2020)
focused on describing the significance of teachers knowing the necessary practices and the consequences of quality teaching
effectiveness.
On the other hand, Alea et. al. (2020), Molano (2020), Fuente (2019), Basco (2020), Dela Cruz (2022), Cortes et al (2021), Vera
et al (2018), Tupas (2019), Cordon & Polong (2020) and Bug-os et al. (2020) focused on how teachers' education practices must
.
CHAPTER 3
Research Methodology
Research Design
The study is generally a descriptive-correlational study. In this kind of research design, the main objective of the study is
to describe correlation between two indicated variables. For the current study, the research is about correlation of the educational
Moreover, this kind of research utilizes quantitative data. These quantitative data are gathered using research instruments
in the form of mostly survey questionnaire. Using the quantitative data, researcher is to make inferences and analysis based on the
Research Locale
The study is to be proceeded and done in schools found in the first district of Biñan City in the Province of Laguna. Most of
the respondents were consisting of teachers that are handling Science subjects. Also included in the respondents were the school
From the many numbers of schools in the division of Biñan City, Laguna Province, the researcher has utilized a total of 202
respondents. As can be distinguished, there are 190 teachers that are involved in this study. There are 12 respondents that are school
heads. A purposive sampling strategy has been used for this study. A purposive sampling gives the researcher the ability to determine
Research Instrument
The study has utilized the use of survey questionnaire for data gathering. The survey questionnaire is self-made and self-
administered by the researcher itself. It is aligned to the guided questions that are presented in the earlier parts of this research. The
survey questionnaire is divided into four (4) distinct sections. The first section identifies the profile of the respondents from their age,
gender, and highest educational attainment. The second section identifies the performance of the teachers as evaluated on their
IPCRF for the past three years from year 2018 to year 2021. On the third section, the educational leadership practices is evaluated and
assessed based on the respondents’ perception. The final section of the study is designated as an assessment on the problems
encountered by the school administrators as educational leaders. The last two sections of the survey questionnaire have utilized 5-
point Likert scale in order to assess the following statements provided in each section. Below is a table that completely shows the
Table 1
Verbal Interpretation
Score Range
The data gathering commenced as the researcher has given the approval to proceed to conduct the survey. Once approved, the
1. The data gathering starts by providing a letter of request to the division of city schools on the first district of Biñan City.
The letter of request informs the latter for all the actions to be taken for the sake of the research.
2. After processing the approval of the division office, the researcher then submits a letter of request on the target schools.
Attached to the files are the approval letter from the division office and a top letter explaining the brief description of the research.
3. Respondents must be then identified. Each respondent is to be provided with details that informs them and seeks for their
4. Research instrument is then distributed on the target participants. The researcher assures that all needed details are to be
filled up accordingly.
5. Data is then gathered and tabulated. Each tabulated data is presented to the statistician for data analysis and inferences.
Statistical Treatment of Data
The following tools are used in order to analyze the tabulated data from the survey questionnaire. The tools are as follows:
1. Frequency and Percentage Distribution Table - this tool is used to present the frequency and the percentage of each item
2. Mean Formula - this tool is used to identify and evaluate average responses on each item in the survey questionnaire.
3. ANOVA (Analysis of Variance) Test - this tool is used by the researcher in evaluating significant differences.
4. Pearson Product Moment Correlation - this tool is used by the researcher to evaluate the correlation of two variables of the
study.
CHAPTER 4
Sub-Problem No. 1 - To what extent do the school administrators practice educational leadership in their respective
Table 2
Indicators WM VI RANK
4.17 C 4
Overall WM 4.15 C
Table 2 presents the planning, organizing, directing and evaluating. From the results it is explained that they are competent in terms
of planning, organizing, directing and evaluating (Overall WM = 4.15). From the results, it is clear that it is claimed that they are very
competent in facilitating organization and control (WM = 4.22). From the results, it is also indicated that they are competent in
dictating activities (WM = 4.00). It is clearly explained their full excellence in planning, organizing, directing and evaluation.
Table 3
4.28 VC 4
2 carries out and directs orders received by him from the administration 4.29 VC 3
4.23 VC 7
another
8 supervises the work performed by his/her staff (teachers and non-teaching) 4.31 VC 1
Overall WM 4.27 VC
Table 3 presents the competence in terms of strategic resource networking. It presents that most of the personnel are very competent
when it comes to resource networking (Overall WM = 4.27). It is even indicated that they are very competent in supervising the work
performed by his/her staff (WM = 4.31). It is also presented that they are very competent in approving each task he had completed
before he is permitted to undertake another and formulating and adopting long range plans and politics (WM = 4.23).
Table 4
Indicators WM VI RANK
4.27 VC 1
action.
3 Makes decision or takes action without approval from the higher up. 3.45 C 7
4 Exercises complete authority on routine matters but refer the majority of
4.17 C 3
scope and establishing the lines of organizational authority for the attainment 4.15 C 4
of these goals.
6 Makes all decisions necessary for the implementation of long-range plans. 4.15 C 4
7 Makes and carries out all decisions which fall within the realm of established
3.77 C 6
Overall WM 4.03 C
Table 4 shows the curriculum and teaching enhancement and linkages. It is explained that they are competent in terms of curriculum
and teaching enhancement and linkages (Overall WM = 4.03). It is even explained that most of the personnel are very competent in
terms of referring questions to the co-administrators and teachers before taking any action (WM = 4.27). It is also explained that they
were competent in making decisions that are taken action without approval (WM = 3.45).
Table 5
Indicators WM VI RANK
4.17 C
Table 5 shows the competency of faculty and staff development. It is denoted that they are competent in terms of faculty and staff
development (Overall WM = 4.19). It is even presented that they are ve9ry competent in terms of giving clear, concise and consistent
orders and directions and give reasons why the orders are given time (WM =4.21). It is even indicated that they are competent in
Table 6
Indicators WM VI RANK
4.29 VC 1
objectives
4.23 VC 5
5 allows teachers to express freely what they feel about evaluation 4.21 VC 7
4.27 VC 2
4.19 C 11
4.24 VC 3
by:
9 ensuring that the workload is within the physical and mental competence of 4.20 VC 9
the teacher or non-teaching personnel
Overall WM 4.22 VC
Table 6 shows the competence on physical facilities development. It is indicated that the personnel were identified very competent in
physical facilities development (Overall WM = 4.22). It is even explained that the teachers are very competent in terms of knowing
the use of various evaluation methods consistent with learning objectives (WM = 4.29). It is even explained that indicators have
provided that they are competent in discussing evaluation results with teachers and examines students’ performance data to extract
Table 7
Indicators WM VI RANK
4.35 VC 2
evaluation.
4.36 VC 1
school.
4.30 VC 5
instructional practices
population
5 shows confidence in his/her skills to lead staff to understand and respect the 4.31 VC 3
diversity of student population
6 shows confidence that he/she can lead staff to appreciate the kinds of
knowledge and skills students and their families can add to the learning 4.30 VC 5
process
4.29 VC 7
difficulties
4.28 VC 8
and strategies
4.23 VC 10
Overall WM 4.30 VC
Table 7 presents the ensuring orderly and conducive environment in teaching. It is presented that many are very competent when it
comes to matter (Overall WM = 4.30). It is then explained that the teachers are very competent in terms of showing confidence in
his/her understanding of the total instruction program in school (WM = 4.36). It is also presented that they are very competent in
terms of establishing links with the non-government agencies for provisions for additional teaching materials, books and references
(WM = 4.23).
Sub-Problem No. 2 - Is there a significant difference in the assessment of the two groups of respondents on the
above-mentioned variables?
Table 8
Educational
Leadership Practices
Table 8 presents the results of the Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) Test Results. From the results, an f-value of 4.11 is calculated. With
this given value of f, a p-value of 0.01. This indicates that the educational leadership practices is significantly different. It even rejects
the hypothesis.
Sub-Problem No. 3 - What is the performance of Secondary Science teachers for the past three years?
Table 9
Table 9 presents the performance of the science teachers for the past three years. Clearly presented that in each succeeding year, the
teacher continuously develop and improve in their performance. From a 5.74 performance rating start, a total of 6.29 performance
rating has been verified. This simply explains that the teachers are performing excellently. They are able to know whether they need
Sub-Problem No. 4 - Is there a significant relationship between the educational practices and performance of Science
teachers?
Table 10
Educational
Weak Negative
Leadership
-0.41 <0.00001 Significant Reject Ho
Correlation
Practices
Performance Rating
of the Teachers
Table 10 presents the results of the Pearson Product Moment Correlation Test. From the results, it is explained that an f-value of -0.41
has indicated weak negative correlation. It is even evaluated to have significant value with <0.00001. This rejects the hypothesis.
Educational leadership practice and the performance of the teachers are found everywhere in the map.
Sub-Problem No. 5 - What are the problems encountered by the school administrators as educational leaders?
Table 11
Indicators WM VI RANK
1.98 SE 9
2.30 SE 5
2.09 SE 6
8 Low salaries and lack of incentives, and benefits of the staff 2.34 SE 2
2.04 SE 8
agencies
Table 11 presents the problems encountered by school administrators as educational leaders. It is presented that they slightly
encounter the indicated problems (Overall WM = 2.12). It is even indicated that they slightly encounter inadequate physical facilities
and equipment (WM = 2.43). It is also indicated that they slightly encounter low salaries and lack of incentives and benefits of the
staff and also Inadequate staff (non-teaching) to do administrative jobs (WM = 2.34).
The Educator's exhibition is vital. It could be said, it is apparently the most compelling school-related factor deciding an understudy's
achievement. As indicated by Deunk et. al. (2018), PC innovation can be a useful device in working with informative strategies, which
has not been canvassed in past audits. Besides, our discoveries exhibit that homogeneous capacity gathering alone is lacking to
guarantee educating approaches. It underscores the meaning of fusing separation techniques into a more extensive scholastic setting.
Moreover, Regier (2020) accepted that dominance encounters greatestly affected executives' self-adequacy for showing strategies,
trailed by verbal influences, physiological condition, and vicarious encounters. Moreover, people who announced higher self-viability for
showing strategies viewed themselves as more certain about their capacity to utilize fitting educational capacities.
Through such, it is obvious that there are numerous methodologies for instructive pioneers to give the appropriate strategy to
successful way working with realizing, which will be the essential wellspring of their productive and powerful learning. Different
instructive practices and Science Educator's Performance not set in stone using the examination, as well as the sum to which these
Table 12
Intervention Plan
KEY
PERSON
EXPECTED
RESPONSIBILIT ACTIVITIES SOURCE OF
OBJECTIVES TIMELINES
INVOLVED
OUTPUT
Y AREA BUDGET
Physical Facilities Provide adequate Teaming up with As the need arises School Admins School Fund Laboratory
the district offices
and well-equipped
facility
learning
Training personnel
positions
teachers number
and faculties
Salary and
and benefit of the salary increase As the need arises School Fund
appealing.
School Admins
parents and counselling for As the need arises School Fund and understand
and Teachers
is identified.
Sub-Problem No. 7 - How acceptable is the proposed intervention model as assessed by the respondents?
Table 13
Indicators WM VI Rank
1. The proposed strategic model could be a program and adopted by the institution. 4.01 A 4
2. The over-all action of the proposed strategic model can be made clear to all concerned. 4.11 A 1
5. The proposed strategic model is flexible enough to adapt to different conditions for
4.07 A 2
which it is intended.
Table 13 presents the acceptability of the proposed intervention model. Based on the perceptions and assessment of the school
administrators, the proposed intervention model is acceptable (Overall WM = 4.02). It is even explained that the intervention model is
clear to all concerned (WM = 4.11). It is even indicated to be workable and can be operated (WM = 3.89).
CHAPTER 5
Summary of Findings
The Educator's presentation is vital. One might say, it is ostensibly the most persuasive school-related factor deciding an
understudy's achievement. As indicated by Deunk et. al. (2018), PC innovation can be a useful device in working with informative
procedures, which has not been canvassed in past audits. Moreover, our discoveries exhibit that homogeneous capacity gathering
alone is lacking to guarantee instructing approaches. It underscores the meaning of fusing separation strategies into a more extensive
scholarly setting. Likewise, Regier (2020) accepted that dominance encounters greatest affected directors' self-viability for showing
strategies, trailed by verbal influences, physiological condition, and vicarious encounters. Besides, people who detailed higher self-
viability for showing strategies viewed themselves as more positive about their capacity to utilize proper educational capacities.
Through such, it is clear that there are various methodologies for instructive pioneers to give the appropriate technique to
successful way working with realizing, which will be the essential wellspring of their proficient and powerful learning. Different
instructive practices and Science Educator's Performance still up in the air using the examination, as well as the sum to which these
1. From the outcomes it is clarified that they are equipped as far as arranging, putting together, coordinating and assessing
(Overall WM = 4.15). From the outcomes, obviously it is guaranteed that they are extremely skilled in working with association and
control (WM = 4.22). From the outcomes, it is additionally demonstrated that they are skilled in directing exercises (WM = 4.00). It is
obviously clarified their full greatness in arranging, putting together, coordinating and assessment. It presents that the vast majority of
the work force are exceptionally skillful with regards to asset organizing (Overall WM = 4.27). It is even shown that they are extremely
skillful in directing the work performed by his/her staff (WM = 4.31). It is additionally introduced that they are extremely skilled in
endorsing each assignment he had finished before he is allowed to embrace another and figuring out and taking on lengthy reach
plans and governmental issues (WM = 4.23). It is clarified that they are able as far as educational plan and showing improvement and
linkages (Overall WM = 4.03). It is even clarified that the vast majority of the staff are exceptionally skillful as far as alluding inquiries
to the co-heads and educators prior to making any move (WM = 4.27). It is likewise clarified that they were capable in settling on
choices that are made a move without endorsement (WM = 3.45). It is indicated that they are equipped as far as facult and staff
advancement (Overall WM = 4.19). It is even introduced that they are ve9ry capable as far as giving clear, compact and predictable
orders and headings and provide justifications for why the orders are given time (WM =4.21). It is even demonstrated that they are
equipped in providing orders in a way that is satisfactory to subordinates (WM = 4.15). It is shown that the faculty were distinguished
exceptionally skilled in actual offices improvement (Overall WM = 4.22). It is even clarified that the instructors are exceptionally skilled
as far as knowing the utilization of different assessment techniques reliable with learning targets (WM = 4.29). It is even clarified that
markers have given that they are skilled in talking about assessment results with instructors and inspects understudies' exhibition
information to remove the data vital for grounds improvement arranging (WM = 4.19). It is introduced that many are extremely able
when it adapts to issue (Overall WM = 4.30). It is then clarified that the educators are extremely able as far as showing trust in
his/how she might interpret the absolute guidance program in school (WM = 4.36). It is likewise introduced that they are exceptionally
capable as far as laying out joins with the non-government offices for arrangements for extra showing materials, books and references
(WM = 4.23).
2. From the outcomes, a f-worth of 4.11 is determined. With this given worth of f, a p-worth of 0.01. This demonstrates that
the instructive initiative practices is essentially unique. It even oddballs the theory.
3. Obviously introduced that in each succeeding year, the educator consistently creates and work on in their presentation.
From a 5.74 presentation rating start, a sum of 6.29 execution rating has been checked. This essentially clarifies that the instructors
are performing astoundingly. They can know whether or not they need to assume responsibility in driving the training.
4. From the outcomes, it is clarified that a f-worth of - 0.41 has shown frail negative connection. It is even assessed to have
huge worth with <0.00001. This dismisses the speculation. Instructive authority practice and the exhibition of the educators are
5. It is introduced that they somewhat experience the demonstrated issues (Overall WM = 2.12). It is even demonstrated
that they somewhat experience insufficient actual offices and hardware (WM = 2.43). It is likewise shown that they somewhat
experience low compensations and absence of motivating forces and advantages of the staff and furthermore Inadequate staff (non-
4.02). It is even clarified that the intercession model is obvious to all concerned (WM = 4.11). It is even demonstrated to be useful
Conclusions
1. From the outcomes, obviously it is guaranteed that they are extremely skilled in working with association and control. From
the outcomes, it is additionally demonstrated that they are skilled in directing exercises. It is obviously clarified their full greatness in
arranging, putting together, coordinating and assessment. It presents that the vast majority of the work force are exceptionally skillful
with regards to asset organizing. It is even shown that they are extremely skillful in directing the work performed by his/her staff. It is
additionally introduced that they are extremely skilled in endorsing each assignment he had finished before he is allowed to embrace
another and figuring out and taking on lengthy reach plans and governmental issues. It is clarified that they are able as far as
educational plan and showing improvement and linkages . It is even clarified that the vast majority of the staff are exceptionally skillful
as far as alluding inquiries to the co-heads and educators prior to making any move. It is likewise clarified that they were capable in
settling on choices that are made a move without endorsement . It is indicated that they are equipped as far as facult and staff
advancement . It is even introduced that they are ve9ry capable as far as giving clear, compact and predictable orders and headings
and provide justifications for why the orders are given time.
2. There is a significant difference between the different educational leadership practices. It only implies the relativity of the
variables.
3. The teachers are performing effectively. They have an excellent performance rating based on the assessment and
evaluation.
4. There is a significant correlation between the practices of educational leadership and the performance rating. They relative
5. There are problems that are experienced by the involved persons. They tend to slightly experience these problems and are
Recommendation
1. There is a need to improve educational leadership practices. In this way, learning can be more conducive as usual.
3. Further research must be done in order to help improve the intervention model.
References:
Alea, L. A. et. al. (2020). Teachers’ Covid-19 awareness, distance learning education experiences and perceptions towards institutional
%E2%80%99+Covid-19+Awareness%2C+Distance++Learning+Education+Experiences+and+Perceptions+
+towards+Institutional+Readiness+and+Challenges&btnG=#d=gs_qabs&u=%23p%3DIAYCWxByOWIJ
Bal-Taştan, S. et. al. (2018). The impacts of teacher’s efficacy and motivation on student’s academic achievement in science education
motivation-on-students-academic-achievement-in-science-5435
Cheng, A. et. al. (2018). Resuscitation education science: educational strategies to improve outcomes from cardiac arrest: a scientific
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/full/10.1161/CIR.0000000000000583
2795155#:~:text=Kolb's%20learning%20styles%20are%20one,demands%20of%20our%20current%20environment
Close, K. et. al. (2018) the Every Student Succeeds Act: Some Steps in the Right Direction. Retrieved from: https://eric.ed.gov/?
id=ED591993
Darling-Hammond, L. et. al. (2017). Effective Teacher Professional Development. Retrieved from: https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED606743
Day, C. (2017). Teachers’ worlds and work: Understanding complexity, building quality. Retrieved from:
https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/mono/10.4324/9781315170091/teachers-worlds-work-christopher-day
Deunk, M. et. al. (2018). Effective differentiation Practices:A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies on the cognitive effects of
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1747938X18301039
Fauth, B. et. al. (2019). The effects of teacher competence on student outcomes in elementary science education: The mediating role
Fischer, C. et. al. (2018). Investigating relationships between school context, teacher professional development, teaching practices,
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0742051X17314130
Gore, J. et. al. (2017). Effects of professional development on the quality of teaching: Results from a randomised controlled trial of
Hanunshek, E. and Rivkin, S. (2010). Generalizations about Using Value-Added Measures of Teacher Quality. Retrieved from:
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/aer.100.2.267
Hartinah, S. (2020). Retracted: Teacher’s performance management: The role of principal’s leadership, work environment and
the-role-of-principals-leadership-work-environment-and-motivation-in-tegal-city-indonesia.html
Imam, O. et al. (2014) READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND PERFORMANCE IN SCIENCE AMONG HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS IN
Malik, R. S. (2018). Educational challenges in 21st century and sustainable development. Retrieved from:
https://ejournal.upi.edu/index.php/JSDER/article/view/12266
Mosbiran, N. F. et. al. (2020). Meta Analysis for Special Education Leadership In Malaysia. Retrieved from:
https://www.archives.palarch.nl/index.php/jae/article/view/5251
Regier, B. (2020). Examining Relationships Among Concert Band Directors’ Efficacious Sources, Self-Efficacy for Teaching Strategies,
Regmi, K. and Jones, L. (2020). A systematic review of the factors–enablers and barriers–affecting e-learning in health sciences
https://www.sparknotes.com/psychology/psych101/personality/section3/
Suryawati, E. and Osman, K. (2017). Contextual learning: Innovative approach towards the development of students’ scientific attitude
the-development-of-students-scientific-attitude-and-5242
Swain, W. et. al. (2019). Selective retention bonuses for highly effective teachers in high poverty schools: Evidence from Tennessee.
Torlak, N. and Kuzey, C. (2019). Leadership, job satisfaction and performance links in private education institutes of Pakistan.
Usanov, F. (2020). The eight ways to advance pedagogy to the next level. Retrieved from:
References;
Alipio, M. (2020). Predicting academic performance of college freshmen in the philippines using psychological variables and
Ancheta, R., & Ancheta, H. (2020). The new normal in education: A challenge to the private basic education institutions in the
https://iiari.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/The-New-Normal-in-Education-1.pdf
Basco, R. O. (2020). Effectiveness of science infographics in improving academic performance among sixth grade pupils of one
Cordon, J. M., & Polong, J. D. B. (2020). Behind the Science literacy of Filipino students at PISA 2018: A Case study in the Philippines’
Cortes, S. T., Pineda, H. A., & Geverola, I. J. R. (2021). Examining competence in action research of basic education teachers in Cebu
https://journal.unisza.edu.my/jonus/index.php/jonus/article/view/664
De La Cruz, R. J. D. (2022). Science Education in the Philippines. In Science Education in Countries Along the Belt & Road (pp. 331-
Fuente, J. A. D. (2019). Driving Forces of Students’ Choice in specializing science: a science education context in the Philippines
Fiscal, R. R. (2019). Knowledge management of state universities in the Philippines. Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research,
7(1), 33-41.https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Rainer-Fiscal-2/publication/
330751962_Knowledge_Management_of_State_Universities_in_the_Philippines/links/5c52698e92851c22a39d3406/Knowledge-
Management-of-State-Universities-in-the-Philippines.pdf
Gepila Jr, E. (2020). Assessing teachers using Philippine standards for teachers. Universal Journal of Educational Research, 8(3), 739-
746. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/fda4/b00352666c2f5fb4a1b466d43c2c668b27fb.pdf
Hero, J. L. (2019). The Impact of Technology Integration in Teaching Performance. Online Submission, 48(1), 101-114.
https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED606392
Roberto, J., & Madrigal, D. (2018). Teacher quality in the light of the Philippine Professional Standards for Teachers. Philippine Social
Molano, T. C. (2020). The skills of pre-service teachers of region II, Philippines in the 21st century. International Journal of Scientific
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Teresita-Molano/publication/344840730_The_Skills_of_Pre-
service_Teachers_of_Region_II_Philippines_in_the_21st_Century/links/5f92d6f9458515b7cf96d81e/The-Skills-of-Pre-service-Teachers-
of-Region-II-Philippines-in-the-21st-Century.pdf
Sumardani, D. (2021). Philippines: Strength and Weakness of Science Curricula. SEJ (Science Education Journal), 5(2), 99-106.
https://sej.umsida.ac.id/index.php/sej/article/view/1507
Tupas, F. P., & Matsuura, T. (2019). Moving forward in stem education, challenges and innovations in senior high school in the
Philippines: The case of Northern Iloilo polytechnic state college. Jurnal Pendidikan IPA Indonesia, 8(3), 407-416.
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/a157/905bac855d02047439d31eb6caefc84fb4dd.pdf
Vera Cruz, A. C., Madden, P. E., & Asante, C. K. (2018). Toward cross-cultural curriculum development: An analysis of science
education in the Philippines, Ghana, and the United States. In Intercultural studies of curriculum (pp. 37-57). Palgrave Macmillan,
Cham. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-319-60897-6_3
Walag, A. M. P., Fajardo, M. T. M., Guimary, F. M., & Bacarrisas, P. G. (2020). Science teachers’ self-efficacy in teaching different K to
12 science subjects: The case of Cagayan De Oro City, Philippines. Science International, 32(5), 587-592.
https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8873/db02b4c4e7a1d615cb2f482ebc1240727a9e.pdf