Kifune 2004
Kifune 2004
iin i3 i4
S1 D1 S3 D3
v1 vab
Lload Rload Cr io
i1
Ed A B
io
S2 D2 S4 D4 mode 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
v2 Csn
Fig. 2 Operational waveforms of PSM converter
i4
i2
Fig. 1 Proposed PSM high-frequency inverter given between the gate pulses of the diagonal switches, as
shown in Fig. 2. The phase difference was set to 701 because
the switching losses are maximum when the instantaneous
2.2 Switching power losses analysis value of the current at switching becomes maximum when
To achieve high-efficiency operation of a high-frequency the pulse phase difference f ¼ 50–901. In this condition, the
inverter, the turn-off operation of S1 and S2 and the turn- instantaneous value of current at turn-off operation was 50
on operation of S3 and S4 need to be improved to achieve A and the inverter output power was 6.5 kW.
soft switching. It is well known that ZVS operation due As shown in Fig. 3, the turn-off loss per device is larger
to voltage soft commutation can be realised by adding a (62.4 W) than the total of the turn-on loss and the recovery
lossless snubber capacitor Csn in parallel with an active loss (28.0 W). This indicates that the tail current of the
power switch operating at current lagging mode [7, 8]. IGBT increases the turn-off loss. In addition, the current
Similarly, ZCS operation due to current soft commutation value at turn-off operation is larger than the current at turn-
can be achieved by connecting a lossless inductor snubber on operation in the PSM controlled inverter.
Lsn in series with an active power switch operating in the Because the total switching loss in S1 and S2 is 124.8 W
current leading mode. when the inverter output is 6.5 kW, it is expected that
However, adding these components for soft switching efficiency can be improved by 1.93% or less by reducing the
to the inverter increases the cost, although it reduces the turn-off losses of S1 and S2. However, the switching losses
switching losses and improves the conversion efficiency. In including the diode recovery loss in S3 and S4 is only 56.1
addition, these power components cause conduction loss, W, and efficiency improves by only 0.86% even if these
dielectric power loss and core loss. Therefore, it is necessary power losses become zero. Therefore it is reasonable to
to assess the effectiveness of soft switching. Figure 3 neglect these power losses from a practical standpoint. In
indicates the measurement values of the switching power consequence, a high-frequency inverter can realise cost
losses in the proposed PSM high-frequency inverter without effectiveness and high efficiency by improving the turn-off
Csn. Experimental conditions are: fo ¼ 23.4 kHz, Ed ¼ 270 V, of S1 and S2 to ZVS with lossless snubber capacitor Csn.
Csn ¼ 0 mF, Lload ¼ 46.5 mH, Cr ¼ 1 mF and Rload ¼ 4.5 O. A
fourth generation trench gate IGBT (CM100DU-12F) was 2.3 Lossless snubber capacitor
used as the active power switch, and it was driven under the According to Kirchhoff’s voltage law, the switch voltages v1
following conditions: the gate pulse voltage was +15 V/ and v2 across S1 and S2 are given by:
4 V and the gate resistance was 27 O. The experiment was
implemented at f ¼ 701, where f is the phase difference Ed ¼ v1 þ v2 ð1Þ
0
turn-off loss cooling
a
fin
70
C: collector terminal
fan
i4 E: emitter terminal
50
10 200 V/div
3.1 Switching operation modes
50 A/div Figure 5 illustrates the equivalent circuits of the proposed
0 inverter for each operation mode. It is assumed that all the
turn-on loss
b circuit components and power devices are ideal.
Mode 1: S1 and S4 are in the on state, and the power is
70
supplied to the load from the voltage source Ed.
v4 Mode 2: Turning off S1, Csn starts to discharge, and v2 is
power loss per one device, W
60
i4 changed from Ed to zero gradually. At the same time, v1
50 rises from zero to Ed gradually; S1 accordingly achieves
40 ZVS turn-off.
30
20
iin
10 200 V/div i1 i1 i3
50 A/div S1 D3
v3 S1
0 Lload R i0 Lload R i0
recovery loss Ed load Cr load Cr
c
S4
Fig. 3 Comparison of switching losses v2 vC v2 vC v4
sn sn
a Turn-off loss i4
b Turn-on loss mode 1 mode 8
c Recovery loss
IGBT type: CM100DU-12F i3
i1
D1 S3
v1 v3 i0
Lload Rloadi0 C Lload R
r load Cr
Csn S4
where Ed is a inverter input voltage, which is supplied by a v2 vC v2 vC v4
sn sn
i4
circuit including a rectifier, a chemical capacitor and a film
capacitor. It is therefore a continuous value. When S1 and mode 2 mode 7
iin
S2 operate in the current lagging mode, with Csn connected
i3
to S1 and S2, these can achieve ZVS operation because v1 S3
and v2 maintain the continuity. From (1) it can be seen that, v1 v3 v1 i
Lload R i0 Lload Rload 0 C
load Cr Ed
if either v1 or v2 becomes a continuous value, the other is r
2 (d +d)/2
0
Vi2
Po ¼ ð6Þ
Rload
Vi is given by the Fourier transformation of vab:
rffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
8Ed2 yp þ yd
Vi ¼ cos2 ð7Þ
p2 2
where yp (rad) is the gate pulse phase difference, and yd (rad)
is the dead time. yp and yd are expressed, using f (deg), fo
(Hz) and Td (s) as follows: b
200 ns/div
pf
yp ¼ ; yd ¼ 2pfo Td ð8Þ Fig. 8 Effect of Csn in turn-off operation
180 a Without Csn
Substituting Vi in (6) with the right-hand side of (7), we b With Csn ( ¼ 0.1 mF)
obtain:
8Ed2 yp þ yd The measured turn-off time of IGBT is 200 ns without
Po ¼ 2
cos2 ð9Þ Csn, as shown in Fig. 8a. The experimental conditions are
p Rload 2
the same as for Fig. 3. Because the switching loss is roughly
As already mentioned, soft switching operation of the proportional to dv/dt, the turn-off loss can be reduced to 1/4
inverter is limited by the dead time. Hence, (7) and (9) hold if dv/dt become 1/4. Hence, to make dv/dt equal to 1/4, to
under the following condition: obtain 800 ns voltage commutation time, Csn must provide
yd yp p yd ð10Þ the voltage soft commutation time (tcom) of 600 ns
( ¼ 800200 ns). As mentioned above and as shown in
Fig. 8a, the instantaneous current value (Ioff) at turn-off
operation is about 50 A, and the inverter input voltage Ed is
4 Experimental results and discussion 270 V. Therefore, the value Csn is given by:
4.1 Design of capacitors Ed
This inverter operates at the resonant frequency of the series Csn ¼Ioff
tcom ð12Þ
load resonant circuit; the series resonant capacitance Cr is
given by: Csn ffi0:11 mF
12
200 V/div
10 25 A/div
5 µs/div
inverter output power Po , kW
0
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
phase difference , deg
5 Conclusions
AC/DC conversion efficiency , %
95
with Csn
In this paper, a new cost-effective high-efficiency high-
90 frequency inverter with a PSM control scheme has been
proposed for induction heating applications, and experi-
mental evaluation of its switching operation has been
85 without Csn reported. This high-frequency inverter operates at the
resonant frequency of the series load resonant circuit, and
80 both soft switching operation and power regulation can be
realised by the PSM scheme in which the phase difference is
given by the gate pulses of the diagonal switches. The active
75
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
power switches in the left-hand bride leg operate in the
phase angle , deg current lagging mode, which achieves ZVZCS turn-on. The
active power switches in the right-hand bridge leg operate in
Fig. 10 Power conversion efficiency the current leading mode, which achieves ZVZCS turn-off.
24 IEE Proc.-Electr. Power Appl., Vol. 151, No. 1, January 2004
Experimental comparisons of the switching losses in the 2 Guo, B., Nakamizo, T., Nagai, S., and Nakaoka, M.: ‘Innovative
IGBT module revealed that the turn-off loss is larger than induction-heated high-temperature steamer using voltage-fed high-
frequency resonant inverter’. Proc. Int. Conf. on Power Electronics
the turn-on loss and recovery loss in the PSM inverter. This (ICPE), 1998, pp. 586–591
indicates that only turn-off operation should be changed to 3 Kurose, Y., Muraoka, S., Chandhaket, S., Okuno, A., and Nakaoka,
soft switching from a cost-effective standpoint. Further- M.: ‘An improved zero voltage soft switching PWM high-frequency
inverter with active inductor snubber for induction heated roller’.
more, the switch voltages across S1 and S2 suggest that only Proc. IEE-Japan Power Conversion Conference (PCC), Osaka, Japan,
one Csn is necessary for ZVS turn-off. The circuit topology 2002, Vol. 2, pp. 446–451
4 Hatanaka, Y., Kubota, S., and Sekiya, Y.: ‘Novel zero current
of present inverter was obtained through these experimental switching high frequency inverter applied for an emission control in
and theoretical considerations. diesel engine’. Proc. 7th European Conference on Power Electronics
Theoretical evaluation of the soft switching operation and Applications (EPE), Trondheim, Norway, 1997, Vol. 4,
pp. 315–320
indicates that it is limited only by the dead time duration, 5 Hiraki, E., Nakaoka, M., Horiuchi, T., and Sugawara, Y.: ‘Practical
and that this inverter can maintain soft switching operation power loss simulation analysis for soft switching and hard switching
in a wide PSM power regulation range. An experimental PWM inverters’. Proc. IEE-Japan Power Conversion Conference
(PCC), Osaka, Japan, 2002, Vol. 2, pp. 553–558
evaluation performed under the conditions in which 6 Llorente, S., Monterde, F., Burdio, J.M., and Acero, J.:
fo ¼ 23.7 kHz and Ed ¼ 270 V revealed that the proposed ‘A comparative study of resonant inverter topologies used in
induction cookers’. Proc. 17th Annual IEEE Applied Power
inverter accomplishes soft switching operation over a wide Electronics Conference (APEC), Dallas, USA, 2002, Vol. 2,
power regulation range from 10.39 to 0.28 kW. The actual pp. 1168–1174
power conversion efficiency reached 96.7% in the maximum 7 Forest, F., Laboure, E., Costa, F., and Gaspard, J.Y.: ‘Principle of a
multi-load/single converter system for low power induction heating’,
output power condition. From these considerations, it may IEEE Trans. Power Electron., 2000, 15, (2), pp. 223–230
be concluded that the proposed inverter is suitable and 8 Fujita, H., and Akagi, H.: ‘Pulse-density-modulated power control
sufficiently cost-effective as a high-frequency power supply of a 4 kW, 450 kHz voltage-source inverter for induction
melting applications’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 1996, 32, (2),
for IH applications. pp. 279–286
9 Kifune, H., Hatanaka, Y., and Nakaoka, M.: ‘Novel constant
frequency time ratio controlled series load resonant high frequency
6 References soft switching inverter’. Proc. 33th Annual IEEE Power Electronics
Specialists Conference (PESC), Cairns, Australia, 2002, Vol. 4,
1 Terai, H., Sadakata, H., Omori, H., Yamashita, H., and Nakaoka, pp. 1892–1897
M.: ‘High frequency soft switching inverter for fluid-heating appliance 10 Okuno, A., Kawano, H., Sun, J., Kurokawa, M., Kojina, A., and
using induction eddy current-based involuted type heat exchanger’. Nakaoka, M.: ‘Feasible development of soft-switched SIT inverter
Proce. IEEE 33rd Annual Power Electronics Specialists Conference with load-adaptive frequency-tracking control scheme for induction
(PESC), Cairns, Australia, 2002, Vol. 4, pp. 1874–1878 heating’, IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., 1998, 34, (4), pp. 713–718