Reliability of PWM Inverters in Nigeria
Reliability of PWM Inverters in Nigeria
M.B. Adamu1, I.G, Saidu2, M.B. Abubakar3, N.S. Jega4, M.I. Ilyasu5, A.Tukur
(MIEEE, MIET, MITP)6, M.A. Yusuf7
1,6
(Physics department, faculty of science, Usman Danfodiyo University, Sokoto – Nigeria)
2,3,5
(physics unit, Sokoto state polytechnic, sokoto- Nigeria)
4
(School of nursing and midwifery, Birnin Kebbi, kebbi state-Nigeria)
7
(Electrical engineering department, Sokoto state polytechnic, Sokoto-Nigeria)
ABSTRACT: A power inverter, or inverter, is an electrical power converter that changes direct current (DC)
to alternating current (AC) the converted AC can be at any required voltage and frequency with the use of
appropriate transformers, switching, and control circuits. The paper presents mathematical modeling for
assessing reliability of PWM power inverter in Nigeria. The part stress method was used to predict the
reliability of the system. Data on the failure of PWM Inverter in Sokoto were used as a case study, with special
consideration given to factors like environmental impact, quality of power supply, service personnel, human
factors (over and under usage). A comparative assessment was made on the reliability and reliability indices of
the power inverter when operated within Sokoto environment and when operated within the environment for
which it was designed (china). The result shows that lower reliability level is associated with the use of PWM
power inverter in Sokoto state of Nigeria, as compared with the country for which it was designed.
I. INTRODUCTION
250-5000 watts PWM DC/AC 220V power inverter is as electrical device which is designed to coverts
direct current DC to alternating current AC with the use of a transformer, switching and control circuits
[13][14]. The reliability of this system, which has an original environment for which it was designed for,
becomes necessary to determine the degree to which it could be relied upon in the applied environment –Sokoto
state Nigeria [1][2][6][7].
1.1 Reliability
Reliability in engineering can generally be defined as the characteristic of an item expressed as the
probability that it will perform a required function understated conditions for a stated period of time [4].
Reliability predictions are an important tool for making design trade-off decisions and estimating future system
reliability [8][11]. This requires the understanding of probability and statistical concepts and has, therefore, been
found to be a very important tool in forecasting the patter of failure for systems and hence the reliability
assessment of the system at hand [10].
1.2 Part stress method
This is one of two methods used in assessing the reliability of electronic equipment. In the part stress
method, the effects of the various stresses on the actual hardware are put into consideration, with the
environmental factor and the quality of the utility. The parts count method (the other method) of assessing the
reliability of system is based on the number of different parts, quality level and application environment. The
aim in both cases is to determine the failure for a given system operating in a specific environment [9].
However, the part stress method is better method for mathematical assessing the reliability of the existing
system, based on the possibility of considering various stress peculiar to the equipment in a specific area of
application [4] and as such cold be relied upon to asses the reliability of the PWM power inverter.
1.3 The PWM power inverter system
Pulse-width modulation (PWM) is a commonly used technique for controlling power to inertial
electrical devices made practical by modern power switches. Power inverter is an electrical device that converts
direct current DC to attempting current AC with the use of a transformer, switching and control circuits. These
are two general types of power inverter: true sine wave or modified-sine wave (square wave). True sine wave
www.ijesi.org 51 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
inverter produce power that is either identical or sometimes slightly better to power from the public utility
power grid system [13].
Modified sine wave and square wave inverters are the most common types of power inverters on the
market. Modified sine wave produces a power wave that is sufficient for most devices. The power wave is not
exactly the same as electricity from the power grid. It has a wave form that appears as a choppy square off wave
when viewed through an oscilloscope [14].
The schematic circuit design is for a 250 watt output to increase the power of the circuit you have to
add more of the Q7 and Q8 transistor in parallel, each pair you add will increase your power by 250 watts.
If you increase the power transistors you have to enlarge the T2 transformer to match the new needs. The circuit
transformer is rated 25 amps to handle 220V.
Driver stage
220v/12v +Vcc
0.5 amp
1 2
2 IN 7808 OUT
2.2K
GND
+ R1 1K + Power stage
T1 – 3
4 3.9k (1/2 watt) 4700uF 1K
1 D
3 +
47uF 20uF +
100K
1uF
+
+
10uF 4.7K
104 10K Q7 2N6277 Filter
BC327
1 16
4.7K
100 Q5 2N3055
1N4007
2 15
Q3 TIP122
104 Q1
3 14 BC337 1K
2.2uF/ 400V
D1
100K
0.1 / 600V
4 13
SG3524
10uF D1
Q2
6 11 BC337
100K 1K 100
Q4
7 10 TIP122
C1
8 9 Q6
R2 2N3055
100K 104 Q8
2N6277
www.ijesi.org 52 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
- A cooling fan will be needed to reduce heat off the heat sinks and transformer, when you power up the
circuit the fan will start this will give you a simple way to know that 220V is present and everything is ok.
- Two circuit breakers are recommended instead of fusses, one on the DC side and one on the AC side,
depending on your design example; for a 24VDC (1500 watts design) put a 6 Amps breaker on the DC side and
a 6 Amp on the AC side. For every 1 Amp of 220AC you will be raining like 8 to 10 Amps from the 12V
battery, make your calculations.
- The two heat sinks should be big enough to cool the transistors, they are separate and should not touch
each other.
- Be caution when building this circuit it involves high voltage which is lethal.
1.4 Nigeria
There are three infrastructural indices of development. These are adequate, reliable and always
available energy supply, communication and transportation system. Any society that has got these thee indices is
generally characterized as developed society. Such societies includes USA, UK, Russia, Canada, France, Italy,
Germany and Japan – popularly called G8. Countries which have not attained the three perfect indices above are
generally termed developing countries. Example of such are Nigeria, Malaysia and so on.
Nigeria is mainly considered or at best, assemblers or product designed by developing nations. They inhabit
lands with tropical climates in Africa, Asia and Latin America [5]. The electrical power and hence, have
fluctuating voltages. Some of the region are periodically subjected to every dry dust (harmattan) which is
capable of introducing a high electric field strength of above 4000V/m and sometimes metallic objects moving
in this environment accumulate an average of 1000v/m charge [5].
t
t 1
i t0
MTTF
N
t1 t 0 t 2 t 0 t n t 0
i.e. MTTF
N
where t0 = starting (reference time)
(t1 – t0) = period to 1st failure
(t2 – t0) = period to 2nd failure
(tn– t0) = period to nth failure
N = total number of failure components.
Consider the case in which a fixed number N0 of identical components are tested.
Let Ns = number surving up to time t.
Nf = number failed up to time t.
N0 = Ns + Nf = total number in operation at t=0
Reliability at any time t becomes
Ns
R t (1)
N0
The failure rate (t) is normally defined by the mathematical relation
www.ijesi.org 53 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
lim 1 N f
t
t 0 N s t
1 dN f
(2)
Ns dt
where Ns = number of serving items after a life test
Nf = number of failure item during the time interval, t.
Consider the case in which a fixed number N0 of identical components are tested,
Let Ns = number surving up to time t
Nf = number failed up to time t
N0 = Ns + Nf = total number in operation at t=0
Reliability at anytime t becomes
Ns
R t
N0
and failure rate (for constant failure rate)
1 dN f
from Equation (2)
Nf dt
1 dN f
N0 Ns dt
1
or dt N 0 N s dN f
introducing the limits
t Nf 1
0
dt
0 N0 Ns
dN f
www.ijesi.org 54 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
m Rt dt
0
1
e t
0
1
e e0
1
m (7)
If failure are due to chance and if the failure rate is constant, then
1
for repairable items
MTBF
1
for non-repairable items
MTTF
2.2 Equipment Availability
Mathematically, the utilization factor can be express as [4]:
top
(8)
tm tid top
As seen in equation (8), if the idle time is equal to zero, (i.e. t id = 0) and the maintenance time become as small
as possible, then utilization factor will approach its maximum value and can now be called availability of a unit
or system. Mathematically, this can be expressed as
top
(9)
tm (min) top
Where top = the mean time before failure and tm(min) = the mean time to failure
MTBF
A (10)
MTBF MTTF
2.3 Mean time to failure (MTTF)
The mean time to failure is a term which applies to non-repairable items (such as resistors, capacitors,
electric bulbs and so on, which are disposed off as soon as they fail [12]. MTTF is the average time an item may
be expected to function before failure. This MTTF can be obtained by stressing a large number of components
under known conditions for a period of time and noting the number of failures [4][5]
2.4 Equipment Failure Profile
Over the years, complex equipment and components have been found to follow a familiar pattern of
failure, which has been well documented. Failure rates have been calculated for equal time intervals from
installation to replacement. When the failures rates is plotted against a time scale spanning the equipment life
time, the resulting graph, popularly known as “bathtub is obtained as shown in figure 2.1 [2][4].
It exhibits three district periods or zones, the infant mortality period, the constant failure rates period and the
wear out period.
www.ijesi.org 55 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
This period manifests towards the tail end of the equipment component life. During this period, failure
is due to old age, various components are worn-out, metals become embrittled, and insulation dries out and so
on. Failure rates can only be reduced by preventive replacement of these components.
Generally in some systems, one or two of the phase (usually the ecouly failure and wear our failures) could be
more reduced or effectively absent. Therefore, estimates for parameters that affect equipment failure profile of
the constituent components, especially the length of the constant failure rate period and associated failure rates
are essential ingredients for predicting the reliability.
mortality
TIME IN SERVICE
Fig.2. 1. Equipment failure profile – Bathtub-curve
For the scope of this work, the above equation (11) for the part stress method was reduced to the expression of:
i = nBTK (12)
Where
i = The failure of the ith part
n = number of particular component
B = Base failure rate obtained from the derated data for each generic part against normalized stress and
temperature factor.
T = Room temperature of the environment
K = Voltage stress ratio
𝑀𝑒𝑎𝑠𝑢𝑟𝑑 𝑣𝑜𝑙𝑡𝑎𝑔𝑒
Voltage stress (K) =
𝑅𝑎𝑡𝑒 𝑣𝑜𝑙𝑡𝑎𝑔𝑒
The failure rate of the regions under consideration, Sokoto-Nigeria and China are summed up to calculate the
inherent system reliability. These failures are constant and as best described by the exponential distribution law
for useful operation region.
www.ijesi.org 56 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
www.ijesi.org 57 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
Where
BN = Base failure rate of the inverter in Sokoto-Nigeria
BD = Base failure rate of the inverter in designed environment (China)
Toc(D) = Average room temperature of the designed environment (China)
Toc(N) = Average room temperature of Sokoto-Nigeria
K = Voltage stress ratio
effD = Effective base failure rate for designed environment (China)
effN = Effective base failure rate for the applied environment (Sokoto-Nigeria)
Reliability can be assessed from the failure rates obtained from table 3 for China and the applied environment
(Sokoto-Nigeria).
Table 3: Reliability result
Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5
China 0.779284 0.607283 0.473246 0.368793 0.2873943
Nigeria 0.337190 0.1136968 0.0383374 0.012927 0.0043588
90
80
70
60
50
China
40
30 Nigeria
Reliability
20
10
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
www.ijesi.org 58 | P a g e
Mathematical Modeling For Reliability Assessment Of 250-5000 Watts Pulse
frequency, high relative humidity, among others. The ratio of the failure rate of Sokoto-Nigeria to China is
approximately 4:1.
Comparatively, the rate of failure of the power inverter in the designed country is much less than the Nigerian
case. From the failure rate of the system obtained for the two environments, we obtain the mean time to failure
(MTTF) of the system as follows
MTTF = 1
effD
The mean time the system is expected to function before failure (MTTF) in Sokoto-Nigeria is 0.9 years as
against 4.0 years for the designed country. The rate is about four times higher than the Sokoto-Nigerian case.
REFERENCES
[1]. Adamu, M.B. (2012). “Mathematical Modeling for Reliability Assessment of uninterruptible power supply in Sokoto-Nigeria.
M.Sc. Thesis Usmanu Danfidiyo University Sokoto, Physics department.
[2]. Akinsanmi, O. “Assessing the Reliability of UPS system for Medical Operations in Zaria, Kaduna State”. The Information
Managers. Vol. 5, 2005. PP 1 – 11, Department of Library and Information Science, Ahmadu Bello University Zaria.
[3]. Arsenault, J.E. (1980) “Reliability and Maintainability of Electronics Systems” Pitman Ltd., United Kingdom. PP 162 – 187.
[4]. Oroge, C.A. (1991) Fundamental of Reliability and Testing Methods; Sooji Press Ltd., Kaduna, Nigeria.
[5]. Taylor P.F.U. (1989) Reliability Assessment and Design of Micro Computers for admistrative purposes in developingcountries
PhD. Thesis, ABU, Zaria
[6]. Oluwatope, O.A, (2006) “Failure events trends analysis of computer systems in Nigeria” NSE technical transaction Vol. 41, No.2
April- June, 2006
[7]. Mohammed, A.B, Musa, M., Ismaila, G.S (2012). “Failure events analysis of Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) in Nigeria”
International Journal of Engineering Invention. ISSN (Online): 2319-6734, ISSN (Print): 2319-6726, Volume I Issue I
//December. 2012// PP.13-17
[8]. Boston, B.M, (2004) “Reliability Prediction: Part count, part stress and Dormant”. Reliability training course Vol. 41, PP.2-12
[9]. EPSMA, (2005) “Guidelines to understanding Reliability Prediction”. Retrieved August8, 2012 from http://www.epsma.org
[10]. Gupta. R.C; Gupta, R.L and Gupta, R.D (1997), “Modeling failure time by Lehman alternatives”, Communication in statistics-
Theory and Methods, vol.27, PP.887-904
[11]. Quanterion, (2004), “Reliability prediction” Vol.3, No.5 September, 2004. Retrieved October, 2011 from
http://quanterion.com/knowledge/reliability toolkit.shtm
[12]. Susan, S. (2010), “MTBF, MTTR and FIT Explanation” Statistical Soc. Series B Vol.20, PP.243-302
[13]. Dr Adel, G (2010), “Advanced power electronics PWM Inverter” Retrieved on 17/02/2013 from http://www.adel.gastli.net
[14]. Berrezzek, F and Omeiri, A. (2009) “ Astudy of new techniques of controlled PWM Inverter” European Journals of Science
Research ISSN 1450-216X Vol.32 No.1 (2009), PP.77-89. http://www.eurojournals.com/ejsr.htm
[15]. MIL-HDBK-217, (1995), “Reliability prediction of Electronic equipment”. Developed by Rome Laboratories, and the United
States, Department of Defense
www.ijesi.org 59 | P a g e