Properties of Recycled Aggregates and Their Effects - On - Concrete (#1329203) - 3271924
Properties of Recycled Aggregates and Their Effects - On - Concrete (#1329203) - 3271924
*Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, İstanbul University Cerrahpaşa, 34315, İstanbul
** Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, İstanbul Nişantaşı University, 34398, İstanbul
([email protected], [email protected])
‡
Hosein Zoriyeh Aligholi, Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, İstanbul University Cerrahpaşa, 34315
Avcılar İstanbul, Tel: +90 553 922 28 41
Abstract- The increase in the cost of extracting natural aggregates, the destruction of nature through the consumption of
natural resources, and the increase in construction waste have led to an increase in studies being conducted today on the use of
"recycled concrete aggregates" for concrete production. Concrete with recycled aggregates is an alternative to the use of
natural aggregates in concrete. In this study, a database of 27 items was created to study the parameters that affect concrete
produced using recycled concrete aggregates in different proportions. Firstly, physical properties of recycled concrete
aggregates such as abrasion value, density, water absorption capacity were investigated in the database. In the second stage, the
factors affecting the slump, unit volume weight and strength of concretes produced with RCA were evaluated. As a result, it
was found that the increase in the density of the recycled aggregate resulted in a decrease in abrasion values, while the unit
volume weight and strength of the concrete increased. It was also found that the recycled aggregates had no effect on the slump
of the concrete, and that the unit volume weight and strength of the concrete decreased as the amount of aggregate used
increased.
Keywords Concrete Waste, Recycled Concrete Aggregates, Compressive Strength
1. Introduction with large quantities of homogeneous waste to be reused on
site (e.g., reconstruction of roads and highways, large
Concrete is the most widely used construction material industrial facilities). Processing in mobile recycling plants is
worldwide, consisting of 60–80% by volume of natural limited to single stage crushing, magnetic separation and
aggregates. The increasing demand for concrete structures sieving [2].
and the development of infrastructure are putting a strain on
Concrete with recycled aggregate is an alternative to
the limited available non-renewable resources, so it is crucial
using natural aggregate in concrete. Recycled aggregate is an
to reduce environmental impact and conserve non-renewable
aggregate obtained by recycling clean concrete waste and
resources by developing sustainable sources such as recycled
must contain a very low percentage of other construction
aggregates in the construction industry. Replacing natural
waste. For example, the British Standard defines recycled
aggregates with recycled aggregates in concrete products not
concrete aggregate as recycled aggregate with a maximum
only offers a sustainable solution to these problems but can
brick/fine material content of 5%, a maximum lightweight
also reduce construction costs [1].
material/asphalt content of 0.5%, and a maximum other
Recycled aggregates are produced in recycling plants in contaminant content of 1%. Replacement of natural
the same way as natural aggregates. The process usually aggregates with recycled concrete aggregates can be
involves two stages: Crushing (primarily with jaw crushers complete (100%) or partial [3]. However, due to the high-
and secondarily with impact crushers), removal of impurities, water demand of fine materials smaller than 150 μm, the use
and sieving. After the first crushing stage, large pieces of of fine recycled concrete aggregates below 2 mm is rare. The
steel are separated by electromagnets. Impurities such as dirt, high water absorption and high cohesion of the fine recycled
gypsum, plaster and other construction waste must be concrete aggregates also make the quality control of the
carefully removed by water cleaning or air screening. concrete very difficult. Therefore, some standards and
Recycled aggregates can also be processed in mobile specifications prohibit the use of fine recycled concrete
recycling plants. These are typically used on demolition sites aggregates for structural purposes [4].
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
With the rapid economic development and urbanization 2. Material and Metod
of society, the construction industry worldwide has entered a
golden age, and as a result, the generation of construction In this study, the physical properties of Recycled
and demolition waste has increased tremendously [5]. This Concrete Aggregates (RCA) were first evaluated. For this
increase has forced practitioners to look for alternatives that purpose, the density, abrasion, and water absorption values
can minimize waste transportation and disposal costs. On the of RCAs were analyzed using data obtained from 27 articles.
other hand, the scarcity of natural resources for fill material Later in the study, the fresh slump values of concretes
needed for geotechnical structures such as railroad and produced with RCA and the effects of RCA percentage and
highway embankments, conventional soil retaining walls, binder dosage on the strength values were analyzed. The
and reinforced soil retaining walls has become a serious strength values are for 28-day specimens. A summary of the
environmental problem in many places. Therefore, especially data set used is given in Table 1.
in densely populated areas, the reuse of concrete demolition
3. Findings and Discussion
as a construction material is considered important both
economically and environmentally [6]. The reuse rates of 3.1. Physical Properties of RCAs
concrete demolition reach 5% in China, 17% in the United
Kingdom, 4.5% in Brazil, 90% in Japan, 75% in the 3.1.1. Density
Netherlands, and 80% in many European countries [7, 8]. The density values of coarse and fine aggregates obtained
Since 2012, at least 10 million tons of construction waste from the articles in the database are presented in Fig.s 2 and
have been generated annually as a result of the urban 3, respectively. For coarse aggregates, these values are
transformation program. In Turkey, the average annual between 2.2 and 2.5 g/cm3, with an average value of 2.41
amount of construction and demolition waste collected only g/cm3. For fine aggregates, these values are between 2.13 and
by IBB has been 57.4 million tons since 2010 (see Fig. 1). 2.69 g/cm3, with an average value of 2.48 g/cm3. In general,
These wastes have been dumped in landfills, causing many the density for both aggregates is above 2.4 g/cm3.
landfills to be 100% full, damaging the environment and Depending on the density, natural aggregates are divided into
opening new landfills, so recycling them is the most logical three as seen in Table 2. Accordingly, recycled materials can
and practical way to eliminate this problem [9]. be called "aggregates".
49
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
50
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
3.1.3. Abrasion
51
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
52
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
weight of concrete. The increase in the water absorption 3.2.3. Compressive Strength
capacity of fine and coarse RCAs led to a decrease in the unit The factors affecting the 28-day compressive
volume weight. The proportional increase in the use of RCA strength values of the RCA-produced concretes in the
in the concrete mix resulted in a decrease in the unit volume database are illustrated in Fig. 13 and Fig. 14.
weight of the concrete. The unit volume weight of concrete
When the strength values are between 20 and 40
increased with the increase in cement dosage in concretes MPa, the increase in the abrasion value does not affect the
produced with RCA. The increase in slump values of fresh strength value, but the increase in the abrasion value in the
concrete led to a decrease in the unit volume weight. lower and upper parts of these values caused an increase in
the strength values. The increase in the unit volume weights
of fine and coarse RCAs caused an increase in compressive
strength values. The increase in the water absorption capacity
of fine and coarse RCAs led to a decrease in compressive
strength values. As the percentage of RCA increased,
strength values decreased. Although there is an increase in
compressive strength values in general as the amount of
cement used in concretes produced with RCA increases, this
increase is not significant in the range of compressive
strength values between 20 and 40 MPa. As the unit volume
weight of the concrete produced with RCA increased, the
compressive strength values increased due to the decrease in
the voids in the concrete. The decrease in slump values
caused a decrease in strength values.
53
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
54
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of ENGINEERING SCIENCE AND APPLICATION
H. Z. Aligholi and A. K. Yıldırım, Vol.7, No.3, September 2023
[18] G.Durmuş, Ö.Cana and O.Şimşek, "Geri Dönüşüm [28] K.K.Sagoe-Crentsil, T.Brown, and A.H.Taylor,
Agregalardan Üretilen Farkli Siniflardaki Betonun "Performance of concrete made with commercially
Mühendislik Özelliklerinin Belirlenmesi", 5. produced coarse recycled concrete aggregate", Cement
Uluslararası İleri Teknolojiler Sempozyumu, Karabük, and concrete research, vol. 31, no. 5, pp. 707-712, 2001.
2009. [29] S.Kamarudin, "Self-Compacting Concrete with
[19] H.Dilbas, Ö.Çakır, and M.Şimşek, "Kentsel Dönüşüm incorporation of Recycled Concrete Aggregates",
Sonucu Oluşan Molozların Geri Dönüşümle Betonda International Journal of Integrated Engineering, vol. 11,
Kullanımı–Silis Dumanı Katkılı Geri Kazanılmış no. 9, pp. 164-173, 2019.
Agregalı Betonlar", 9.Ulusal Beton Kongresi, Turkey, [30] M.C.Limbachiya, T.Leelawat, and R. K.Dhir, "Use of
2015. recycled concrete aggregate in high-strength concrete",
[20] C.Demirel, A. G. K.Toklu, O.Şimşek, , P.M.Y.Okulu, Materials and structures, vol. 33, pp. 574-580, 2000.
Y.D.B.Kirklareli, "Geri Dönüşüm Agregasinin Beton [31] M.C.Rao, S.K.Bhattacharyya, and S.V.Barai,
Üretiminde Kullanilabilirliği ve Sürdürülebilirlik "Behaviour of recycled aggregate concrete under drop
Açisindan Değerlenirilmesi", 2nd International weight impact load", Construction and Building
Sustainable Buildings Symposium, Ankara - Turkiye, Materials, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 69-80, 2010.
2015.
[32] B.González-Fonteboa, and F.Martínez-Abella,
[21] T. Y., “Geri Kazanilmiş Agregali Betonlarin Cdf "Concretes with aggregates from demolition waste and
Yöntemi İle Donma-Çözülme (Yüzeysel Kabuk Atma) silica fume. Materials and mechanical properties",
Dirençlerinin Belirlenmesi”, Erzurum: Atatürk Building and Environment, vol. 43, p. 429–437, 2008.
Üniversitesi Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü İnşaat Mühendisliği
[33] J.Li, H.Xiao, and Y.Zhou, "Influence of coating
Ana Bilim Dalı Yapı Bilim Dalı, 2014.
recycled aggregate surface with pozzolanic powder on
[22] G.Gaurav, and B.Singh, "Analytical investigation in properties of recycled aggregate concrete",
bond of deformed steel bars in recycled aggregate Construction and Building Materials, vol. 23, no. 3, p.
concrete", Journal of Sustainable Cement-Based 1287–1291, 2009.
Materials, 2020.
[34] W.Tangchirapat, R.Buranasing, x C.Jaturapitakkul, and
[23] Y.Sargam, B.Melugiri Shankaramurthy, and K.Wang, P.Chindaprasirt, "Influence of rice husk–bark ash on
"Characterization of RCAs and their concrete using mechanical properties of concrete containing high
simple test methods", Journal of Sustainable Cement- amount of recycled aggregates", Construction and
Based Materials, 2019. Building Materials, vol. 22, p. 1812–1819, 2008.
[24] M.T.U.Chowdhury, Y.Liu, J.Zhang, M.Ronaldo, [35] B.Gonzalez-Fonteboa, and F.Martinez-Abella, "Shear
W.Zhaoxu, and G.Yaodong, "Comparative Assessment strength of recycled concrete beams", Construction and
of Aggregates on Mechanical Properties of Concrete", Building Materials, vol. 21, no. 4, p. 887–893, 2007.
Journal of Ceramics and Concrete Sciences, vol. 5, no.
[36] K.Eguchi, Teranishi, "Application of recycled coarse
1, 2019.
aggregate by mixture to concrete construction",
[25] J. J.Assaad, P.Matar, and A.Gergess, "Effect of quality Construction and Building Materials, vol. 21, p. 1542–
of recycled aggregates on bond strength between 1551, 2007.
concrete and embedded steel reinforcement", Journal of
Sustainable Cement-Based Materials, 2019.
[37] TS 706 EN 12620, "Beton Agregalari" Türk Standartları
[26] K.Poongodi, P.Murthi, R.Gobinath, A.Srinivas, and Enistitüsü, Ankara, 2003.
G.Sangeetha, "Mechanical Properties of Pavement
Quality Concrete Using Recycled Aggregate",
[38] BS EN 1097, "Tests for mechanical and physical
International Journal of Innovative Technology and
properties of aggregates Determination of particle
Exploring Engineering (IJITEE), vol. 9, no. 1, 2019.
density and water absorption", Britain, 2022.
55