The Learning Brain Lessons For Education 1st Edition Sarah-Jayne Blakemore PDF Download
The Learning Brain Lessons For Education 1st Edition Sarah-Jayne Blakemore PDF Download
https://ebookfinal.com/download/the-learning-brain-lessons-for-
education-1st-edition-sarah-jayne-blakemore/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/follow-me-creating-a-personal-brand-
with-twitter-1st-edition-sarah-jayne-gratton/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/brain-powered-lessons-to-engage-all-
learners-1st-edition-lavonna-roth-2/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/brain-powered-lessons-to-engage-all-
learners-1st-edition-lavonna-roth/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/sarah-laughed-modern-lessons-from-the-
wisdom-and-stories-of-biblical-women-1st-edition-vanessa-ochs/
Drupal for Education and E Learning Second Edition James
G. Robertson
https://ebookfinal.com/download/drupal-for-education-and-e-learning-
second-edition-james-g-robertson/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/teaching-and-learning-lessons-from-
psychology-1st-edition-richard-fox/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/the-psychology-of-education-the-
evidence-base-for-teaching-and-learning-2nd-edition-martyn-long/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/brain-stimulation-in-psychiatric-
treatment-review-of-psychiatry-1st-edition-sarah-h-lisanby/
https://ebookfinal.com/download/wiring-the-brain-for-reading-brain-
based-strategies-for-teaching-literacy-1st-edition-sprenger/
The Learning Brain Lessons for Education 1st Edition
Sarah-Jayne Blakemore Digital Instant Download
Author(s): Sarah-Jayne Blakemore, Uta Frith
ISBN(s): 9781405124010, 1405106220
Edition: 1
File Details: PDF, 3.57 MB
Year: 2005
Language: english
LEAPR 3/23/05 11:19 PM Page i
BLACKWELL PUBLISHING
350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148-5020, USA
9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK
550 Swanston Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053, Australia
The right of Sarah-Jayne Blakemore and Uta Frith to be identified as the Authors of
this Work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs, and
Patents Act 1988.
1 2005
A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library.
The publisher’s policy is to use permanent paper from mills that operate a sustainable
forestry policy, and which has been manufactured from pulp processed using acid-free
and elementary chlorine-free practices. Furthermore, the publisher ensures that the
text paper and cover board used have met acceptable environmental accreditation
standards.
contents
Acknowledgements vi
1 Introduction 1
2 The Developing Brain 18
3 Words and Numbers in Early Childhood 37
4 The Mathematical Brain 53
5 The Literate Brain 67
6 Learning to Read and its Difficulties 81
7 Disorders of Social-emotional Development 94
8 The Adolescent Brain 111
9 Lifelong Learning 123
10 Learning and Remembering 139
11 Different Ways of Learning 151
12 Harnessing the Learning Powers of the Brain 167
Appendix 188
Further Reading 196
Glossary 198
Illustration Sources and Cedits 207
Index 211
LEAPR 3/23/05 11:19 PM Page vi
acknowledgements
We could not have written this book without the help of many friends and col-
leagues who provided us with information, talked to us about their work, and
provided us with graphs and other visual aids. For this we are deeply grateful.
We would also like to thank our colleagues at the Institute of Cognitive Neuro-
science and Wellcome Department of Imaging Neuroscience for checking facts
and reading sections of the manuscript, in particular, Jon Simons, Sam Gilbert,
Lauren Stewart, Suparna Choudhury, and Antonia Hamilton. We are very grate-
ful to the following people for reading and reviewing drafts of our book: Paul
Howard-Jones, Andrée Blakemore, Chris Frith, Colin Blakemore, and James
Kilner. We have benefited immensely from the comments on earlier versions of
the book by Christopher Ball, Christopher Brookes, Janet Hatcher, Maggie
Snowling, and Sam Hood. Erin Hope Thompson helped a great deal with the
index. We are also grateful to the Wellcome Trust, the MRC, and the Royal
Society for funding our research.
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 1
Chapter 1
introduction
Evolution and education, like nature and nurture, have often been put into oppo-
sition. Here, our aim is to bring them together. The brain has evolved to educate
and to be educated, often instinctively and effortlessly. The brain is the machine
that allows all forms of learning to take place—from baby squirrels learning how
to crack nuts, birds learning to fly, children learning to ride a bike and memo-
rizing times tables, to adults learning a new language or mastering how to
program a video recorder. Of course, the brain is also our natural mechanism
that places limits on learning. It determines what can be learned, how much, and
how fast.
Knowledge of how the brain learns could, and will, have a great impact on
education. Understanding the brain mechanisms that underlie learning and
memory, and the effects of genetics, the environment, emotion, and age on learn-
ing could transform educational strategies and enable us to design programs that
optimize learning for people of all ages and of all needs. Only by understanding
how the brain acquires and lays down information and skills will we be able to
reach the limits of its capacity to learn.
Neuroscientific research has already shed a great deal of light on how the brain
learns. Recent advances in technology have provided an amazing tool for neu-
roscientists to discover more about how the brain functions. Techniques such as
brain imaging, which measures activity in the brain as people perform a certain
task, have significantly pushed forward our knowledge of the human brain and
mind. Brain scientists can now offer some understanding of how the brain learns
new information and deals with it throughout life.
In the past few years, interactions between educators and brain scientists have
begun to take place. One of the authors spent three months in the spring of 2000
working at the Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology (POST), on
secondment from her PhD in Neuroscience at University College London. The
remit of POST is to provide the British Houses of Commons and Lords with
timely briefing material on topical scientific issues.
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 2
2 Introduction
At the time, the Early Years Education subcommittee was holding an inquiry
into the appropriate care and education of children between birth and six years.
The subcommittee had been bombarded with letters, reports, and manifestos
from early years charities, schools, psychologists, and educators, many of whom
cited research on brain development as grounds for changing early years educa-
tion in the UK. Some of the arguments put forward contradicted each other. On
the one hand, some argued that formal education should not start until six or
seven years old because the brain is not ready to learn until this age. On the other
hand, others argued that it was clear from research on brain development that
children should be “hothoused”—taught as much as possible as early as possible.
What were the Members of Parliament on the subcommittee to make of the con-
flicting evidence?
Both authors were engaged in these kinds of debates when, in June 2000, we
compiled a report for the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC) to indi-
cate whether insights from neuroscience could inform the research agenda in
education. The first thing we did was to organize a multidisciplinary workshop
on brain research and education at the beginning of September 2000. Given the
very short notice and the fact that the workshop was being held on a Saturday
at the end of the summer, we predicted that it would be a very small meeting.
Advertising the meeting locally, and only to people we thought might have a spe-
cific interest in the subject, we nevertheless received over 140 emails from people
interested in participating—scientists and educators in equal proportions. It was
an exciting and fascinating day. The only criticism of the workshop was that one
day was not enough. In our discussions with teachers and education researchers,
it became clear, to our surprise, that there is almost no literature on the links
between brain science and education.
Yet scientists now know a considerable amount about learning—how
brain cells develop before and after birth; how babies learn to see, hear, talk,
and walk; how infants acquire a sense of morality and social understanding; and
how the adult brain is able to continue learning and growing. What amazed us
was, despite this growing body of knowledge and its relevance to education
policy, how few links exist between brain research and education policy and
practice.
One of the major contributions neuroscience is capable of making is illumi-
nating the nature of learning itself. Despite major advances in our understand-
ing of the brain and learning, neuroscientific research has not yet found
significant application in the theory or practice of education.
Why is this? It might, in part, be due to difficulties of translating knowledge
of how learning takes place in the brain into information of value to people con-
cerned with education. We know one brain scientist who, after giving a
talk about the brain to a group of educators, was told that “there is no point in
showing teachers pictures of brain images—they just aren’t interested in that.”
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 3
Introduction 3
We do not believe this to be true of all teachers, but we have to admit that
there is currently very little material about the relevance of brain research to edu-
cation that is readily accessible to the nonspecialist. In writing this book our aim
was to reduce the gap that unfortunately separates brain science and education
science.
There are many obstacles to interdisciplinary understanding, not least the con-
fusion caused by claims and counterclaims in brain research. One finding about
the brain can be contradicted just months later by another scientist’s research.
But disagreements, findings and counterfindings, are part and parcel of normal
scientific progress and integral to the evolution of our understanding about the
brain.
Misconceptions about neuroscience—what neuroscientists are interested in,
and how far neuroscience can extend in terms of its application to education—
are only too easy to foster. Take, for instance, the popular idea about how few
brain cells (is it 5 percent? 10 percent?) we actually use. There is no evidence for
this whatsoever! Let’s consider the percentage of the brain used just to tap one
finger. As you can see in the brain image shown in Figure 1.1, a large proportion
of the brain is activated when a finger is tapped. Tap your finger at the same time
as reading this, and as well as maintaining your balance, breathing, and body
temperature, almost all of your brain will be active. But don’t worry—the brain
has a fantastic capacity to reorganize itself, and although you use all of your brain
at some point, you can always learn more.
But what about Mrs. W., who has massive brain damage and apparently lives
a perfectly normal life? Does such a case demonstrate that the brain plays an
insignificant role in controlling behavior—that we can effectively do with-out it?
The contradictions in this example are less real than apparent. This brain-
damaged person reveals remarkable but counterintuitive facts about the brain.
First, the case demonstrates the resilience of the brain: just a tiny proportion
of cells left intact in an otherwise damaged region of the brain can be sufficient
to perform a task. These cells can start the process of repair. Neuroscience is
studying how this is possible.
Secondly, the case demonstrates not only the possibility for compensation but
also its limits. Mrs. W. may well not have undergone extensive psychological
assessments. So, superficially, she may seem to behave normally, but this might
be because she has learned strategies to compensate for any difficulties caused
by her condition. Indeed, she might well show abnormalities when tested on
appropriately sensitive tasks. Before her brain damage she was right-handed.
Now she would be unable even to pick up a pen with her right hand. She has
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 4
4 Introduction
Figure 1.1 We use a lot of the brain a lot of the time. This figure shows that a large propor-
tion of the brain is activated during the simple act of tapping one finger. Activations are shown
in black.
learned to compensate almost perfectly with her left hand, using only her left
hand to pour tea, pick up objects, write, and so on. This is just one example of
the need for rigorous science when drawing conclusions about how much we
depend on a properly working brain.
The expansion in genetics research over the past few decades has revealed how
important genes are in creating the individual. It is likely that genes play a sig-
nificant role in learning and learning disabilities, and this is the kind of question
beginning to be investigated by research groups worldwide. Thinking about the
educational implications of genetics research will be a hugely important task for
the future. The jump from gene to behavior is much greater than the jump from
brain to behavior. We believe this jump can be made more easily once we have
understood the links between brain and behavior.
Introduction 5
Figure 1.2 Research into the genetics of learning is beginning. Can we imagine a day when
it will be possible to select genes for teaching and learning?
areas of the brain can develop only when the environment contains a variety of
sensory stimuli—visual stimuli, textures, and sounds. We will discuss this in more
detail in the next chapter. It is plausible that the same is true for all areas of the
brain, not just the sensory areas, and for all mental functions. From well before
birth, the brain is shaped by environmental influences, not just by genetic pro-
grams. Take an acorn seed, which cannot grow without the right conditions of
light, water, and nourishment, even though it contains all the necessary genetic
material to become a mighty oak. It is meaningless to debate which is more
important, nature or nurture, since both are needed to produce a living plant.
Similarly, both nature and nurture are needed for normal development of the
brain.
Here is another example that shows how nature and nurture go together.
Many people like to lie in the sun to achieve a desirable tan. Melanin is respon-
sible for this, and the more you have, the deeper your tan. To modern eyes, at
least in the West, this looks healthy and beautiful. Imagine a Northern European
woman with very pale skin, an African woman with very dark skin, and a
Mediterranean woman with what is often called olive skin. No matter how much
the Northern woman lies in the sun, her skin will only burn and will not turn
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 6
6 Introduction
dark. No matter how much the African woman avoids the sun, her skin will not
turn pale. But in the case of the olive-skinned woman, we can see pronounced
differences in skin color that are directly correlated with the amount of exposure
to the sun. In this case, environmental effects (sun exposure) are the most strik-
ing observation; in the case of the other women, genetic effects (melanin pro-
duction) are the most striking. When one type of effect is highlighted in some
examples, say nature, this does not mean that the other effect, nurture, is thereby
diminished.
It may be possible to ignore the brain when talking about normal child devel-
opment, but the brain cannot be ignored when discussing developmental disor-
ders. Throughout this book when we talk about developmental disorders, we
mean disorders that are caused by some subtle genetic programming fault that
has an effect on brain development. Examples are autism, attention
deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and dyslexia. These disorders may have
subtle origins in the brain but can have far-reaching consequences for cognitive
development. They can come in mild to severe form and they usually persist for
life. They are very different from temporary difficulties of, say, attention or lan-
guage, which can occur from time to time during development for all sorts of
reasons.
Diagnosing a developmental disorder and distinguishing it from a temporary
difficulty is sometimes difficult. It depends not just on a few incidental observa-
tions, but can be arrived at only after systematic assessment of a child’s develop-
mental history. Because there are as yet no biological markers for most
developmental disorders, the diagnosis depends on reports and analysis of behav-
ior. This is not a trivial matter and the assessment tools used are constantly being
improved.
What happens once a diagnosis is obtained? A chance conversation with a
youth worker revealed the following anxiety. One of the young people he super-
vised had been diagnosed with dyslexia. He felt that this had given the student a
passport to be lazy and not to bother with written work. As he saw it, the young
man in question could now use the excuse of having a neurological disorder
whenever somebody demanded an effort of learning.
In another conversation with a 30-year-old woman, she told us about her great
relief when she was at last diagnosed with dyslexia, only after her son, who was
experiencing the same difficulties that she had experienced as a child, had been
seen by a specialist. She got in touch with other people who had similar prob-
lems and who had feared until then that they were just too stupid to learn. She
now reports that both she and her son have made vast improvements in reading
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 7
Introduction 7
since their diagnoses. They each obtained remedial teaching that they would not
have received without the diagnosis.
Between the double dangers of using a diagnosis as an excuse for opting out
of learning and, conversely, of having low self-esteem due to lack of explanation
for a learning problem, there are many other shades of experience. The value of
diagnosis depends on the attitude of individuals and their willingness and moti-
vation to overcome their difficulties. These issues surrounding developmental
disorders will be discussed in Chapters 4–7.
A common vocabulary
If brain research is ever to inform education, then what is needed most urgently
is a common vocabulary between brain scientists and educators. We have
included a short Glossary of terms at the end of this book. In this book, we use
the word learning to encompass all kinds of learning. When we refer to neuro-
science, we include all kinds of study of the brain. That is, we include the study
of molecules and cells in the brain although we concentrate mainly on cognitive
and neuropsychology studies. By cognition we mean anything that refers to the
“mental domain,” which includes thinking, memory, attention, learning, mental
attitudes, and, importantly, emotions. When we refer to cognition or mind, we do
not mean to separate them from the brain. We believe that the brain and mind
have to be explained together.
It might be hazardous to suggest that educational research itself does not or could
not provide the best approach to many educational issues from its own resources
and sound scientific thinking. As well as asking how neuroscience can inform
education, it might often be useful to think about how brain science challenges
commonsense views about teaching and learning.
One topic that comes to mind, and which will be discussed later in this book, is
learning without awareness.
Did you know that the brain can acquire information even when you are not
paying attention to it and don’t notice it? This tendency of the brain to do things
“behind one’s back” is pervasive and is likely to have repercussions on theories
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 8
8 Introduction
Figure 1.3 Scientists are notorious for using jargon, which can only be understood by other
scientists in the particular field. This is a real obstacle when different disciplines attempt to
interact and understand each other. In this book, we try not to use too much scientific jargon.
Where it is impossible to avoid using a specialist term, we define it in the Glossary.
of teaching. We will discuss this ability of the brain to process information implic-
itly in Chapter 10.
Until relatively recently, it was widely believed that the adult brain is incapable
of change. There used to be a strong assumption amongst brain scientists that
after the first few years of life the brain is equipped with all the cells it will ever
have, and that adulthood represents a downward spiral of loss of brain cells and
deterioration in learning, memory, and performance generally. But research is
beginning to show that this view of the brain is too pessimistic: the adult brain
is flexible, it can grow new cells and make new connections, at least in some
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 9
Introduction 9
10 Introduction
Figure 1.4 Teachers are a bit like gardeners when it comes to learning. Just like gardeners,
teachers can sow seeds in a learner’s mind, and can nourish and sustain good ideas and
important facts, and weed out misunderstandings and mistakes. Here, the front of the brain
is on the left.
Individual brains, like individual bodies, are different from each other, but there
is almost nothing that you cannot improve or change. When we look at the world
around us there are many examples of how culture has enhanced nature, or
improved on nature. A few examples that come to mind are glasses that improve
eyesight, nutrition for growth, and orthodontists for crooked teeth. The brain is
just the same. While orthodontists can improve your teeth, teachers can improve
your brain.
Education may be considered a kind of “landscaping” of the brain and edu-
cators are, in a sense, like gardeners. Of course, gardeners cannot grow roses
without the right soil and roots in the first place, but a good gardener can do
wonders with what is already there. Just as with gardening, there are many dif-
ferent ideas of what constitutes the most admirable, and there are distinct cul-
tural differences and fashions over time. Nevertheless, individual gardens involve
making the best of what is there and it is possible to make astonishing new and
influential designs. As we shall see throughout this book, this analogy can illus-
trate what we mean by shaping the brain through teaching and learning.
The brain is one of the most complex systems in the universe, and although we
are starting to learn a great deal about it, we are still a long way from under-
standing exactly how it all works. This remains a puzzle that thousands of
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 11
Introduction 11
Figure 1.5 The brain viewed from its surface. The brain is divided into four lobes: the tem-
poral, frontal, parietal, and occipital lobes. The brain’s outermost surface is known as the
cortex.
scientists all round the world are trying to figure out. But we do know some
facts about the brain (see Figure 1.5).
The adult brain weighs about 3 pounds (1.4 kg) and contains about 100 billion
brain cells (or neurons—see Figure 1.6). This is a gigantic number of cells.
Neurons have both short and long fibers that contact the bodies of other neurons,
and there are about one million billion connections between cells in the brain.
100 billion cells is such a large number, it is hard to imagine. One million is 1,000
times 1,000, the population of a very large town, for example. One billion is 1,000
times one million. The number of connections in the human brain is much bigger
than the whole earth’s population, which is about 6 billion.
In discussing relevant functions such as “experiencing fear,” “learning words,”
“doing sums,” or “imagining movement,” we are never talking about individual
nerve cells. Instead, it is regions of brain tissue containing millions of neurons
that are responsible for cognitive functions like these.
So how do neurons do these things? Like all other cells in the body, neurons
act like tiny batteries. There is a difference in voltage (nearly one-tenth of a volt)
between the inside and the outside of the cell, with the inside being more
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 12
12 Introduction
Figure 1.6 A neuron comprises a cell body, an axon, and dendrites. The axon of most neurons
is covered in a sheath of myelin, which speeds up transmission of impulses down the axon.
The synaptic terminals on the dendrites are the contact points with other neurons.
Here we give only a very brief taste of the kinds of techniques used to study the
brain. If you want to know about these in more detail, you could have a look at
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 13
Introduction 13
Figure 1.7 There are several different types of neurons in the brain, including pyramidal
neurons and Purkinje cells. Pyramidal neurons, which appear pyramid-shaped under a micro-
scope, are found in the cortex. Purkinje cells, named after the Czech scientist who first dis-
covered them, are only found in the cerebellum.
the Appendix at the back of this book, in which we explore in detail the differ-
ent techniques that are currently used in brain research.
There are now several tools that can be used to study the brain. Electrophysi-
ology studies involve recording from single neurons in the brains of animals while
the animal is performing a certain task. This technique gives a direct measure of
neuronal activity. Recording neuronal activity in humans is difficult, and studies
recording from neurons of the human brain (for example, during open skull
surgery) are extremely rare. But such studies are astounding in the wealth of
detail they reveal about memories and actions that can be accessed by a mere
“touch” of a particular tiny part of the brain’s surface.
LEA01 3/23/05 10:56 PM Page 14
14 Introduction
Figure 1.8 Action potentials are the language of the brain. When a neuron is activated it fires
an impulse—an action potential. This briefly reverses the voltage across the cell membrane,
which in turn causes the release of chemicals (neurotransmitters) from the axon terminal of
one neuron. These chemicals cross the synaptic gap and are received by receptor sites on
another neuron’s dendrites.
Our website is not just a platform for buying books, but a bridge
connecting readers to the timeless values of culture and wisdom. With
an elegant, user-friendly interface and an intelligent search system,
we are committed to providing a quick and convenient shopping
experience. Additionally, our special promotions and home delivery
services ensure that you save time and fully enjoy the joy of reading.
ebookfinal.com