Cardiac Drug Development Guide 1st Edition Michael K. Pugsley (Auth.) Newest Edition 2025
Cardiac Drug Development Guide 1st Edition Michael K. Pugsley (Auth.) Newest Edition 2025
ttps://ebookgate.com/product/cardiac-drug-development-guide-1st-edition-michael-k-pugsley-auth/
DOWNLOAD EBOOK
Cardiac Drug Development Guide 1st Edition Michael K.
Pugsley (Auth.) pdf download
Available Formats
https://ebookgate.com/product/drug-metabolism-in-drug-design-and-
development-1st-edition-donglu-zhang/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/analytical-profiles-of-drug-substances-
and-excipients-29-1st-edition-harry-g-brittain-eds/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/human-drug-metabolism-1st-edition-
michael-coleman/
ebookgate.com
Cancer Drug Resistance Cancer Drug Discovery and
Development 1st Edition Beverly A. Teicher
https://ebookgate.com/product/cancer-drug-resistance-cancer-drug-
discovery-and-development-1st-edition-beverly-a-teicher/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/radiotracers-in-drug-development-1st-
edition-graham-lappin/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/novel-anticancer-drug-protocols-1st-
edition-john-k-buolamwini/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/anticancer-drug-development-1st-edition-
bruce-c-baguley-author/
ebookgate.com
https://ebookgate.com/product/development-of-the-cardiac-conduction-
system-novartis-foundation-symposium-250-1st-edition-novartis-
foundation/
ebookgate.com
Cardiac Drug Development Guide
METHODS IN PHARMACOLOGY AND TOXICOLOGY
Y. James Kang, MD, SERIES EDITOR
Cardiac Drug
Development Guide
Edited by
Michael K. Pugsley
Department of Pharmacology, Forest Research Institute,
Jersey City, NJ
© 2003 Humana Press Inc.
999 Riverview Drive, Suite 208
Totowa, NJ 07512
www.humanapress.com
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or
by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording, or otherwise without written permission
from the Publisher.
The content and opinions expressed in this book are the |¢úe work of the authors and editors, who have warranted due
diligence in the creation and issuance of their work. The publisher, editors, and authors are not responsible for errors
or omissions or for any consequences arising from the information or opinions presented in this book and make no
warranty, express or implied, with respect to its contents.
For additional copies, pricing for bulk purchases, and/or information about other Humana titles, contact Humana at
the above address or at any of the following numbers: Tel.: 973-256-1699; Fax: 973-256-8341; E-mail: humana@
humanapr.com or visit our website: http://humanapress.com
v
Contents
Preface ................................................................................................................... v
Contributors ....................................................................................................... ix
I INTRODUCTION
1 Cardiac Drug Development: From Animal Models to Clinical Trials
Michael K. Pugsley ............................................................................................. 3
vii
viii Contents
ix
x Contributors
I
INTRODUCTION
Cardiac Drug Development 3
1
Cardiac Drug Development
From Animal Models to Clinical Trials
Michael K. Pugsley
CONTENTS
CARDIAC DRUGS: THE MARKET POTENTIAL FOR ANTIARRHYTHMIC DRUG DEVELOPMENT
GENESIS OF THE CARDIAC ACTION POTENTIAL (CAP)
ISCHEMIA-INDUCED CHANGES IN MYOCYTES PRODUCE CHANGES IN THE EKG
THE ROLE OF CARDIAC ION CHANNELS IN HEART DISEASE
SAFETY PHARMACOLOGY
METHODS USED TO INVESTIGATE THE ROLE OF ION CHANNELS
IN CARDIAC DRUG DEVELOPMENT
HIGH THROUGHPUT SCREENING (HTS) METHODS IN CARDIAC DRUG DEVELOPMENT
CLINICAL DRUG TRIALS
REFERENCES
3
4 Pugsley
Fig. 1. The ischemic heart produces a broad spectrum of arrhythmias that precipitate sudden
cardiac death. Antiarrhythmic drug therapy (ion channel-blocking drugs) can suppress fatal
arrhythmias and produce a normal EKG rhythm. Unfortunately, although these drugs are benefi-
cial, many possess side effects, including myocardial depression and proarrhythmic tendencies.
arrhythmias and efficacy in the clinic (phase 1 and 2 studies) resulted in their evalua-
tion in larger phase 3 clinical trials. The Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppression Trial (CAST-
I) study was undertaken to examine whether the incidence of cardiac death in patients
with asymptomatic or mild ventricular arrhythmias, post-myocardial infarction (MI),
could be reduced with class I antiarrhythmic drugs (3). The CAST-I clinical trial with
flecainide, encainide, and later moricizine in CAST-II (4) and mexiletine in the Inter-
national Mexiletine and Placebo Antiarrhythmic Coronary Trial (IMPACT) trial
showed an abnormally high incidence of death in drug-treated groups when compared
with placebo controls (5). Thus, these clinical trials, albeit not showing marked effi-
cacy of these drugs, provided a valuable lesson as to the complex interrelationship that
exists among the antiarrhythmic drug used, the arrhythmogenic substrate, and resulting
drug efficacy.
Thus, despite the large number of experiments and clinical trials that have been
conducted, remarkably few Na+ channel-blocking drugs are used clinically to suppress
arrhythmias. This low number of drugs accentuates the findings from the CAST-I and
CAST-II trial as well as others (3,4). Many studies with a variety of Na+ channel-
blocking antiarrhythmic agents suggest that these drugs can effectively suppress
arrhythmias; however, this does not necessarily result in an improved survival rate
after a myocardial infarction in patients (6). Quinidine, for example, was shown clini-
cally to increase the incidence of mortality as compared with mexiletine (7), and
Cardiac Drug Development 5
lidocaine, although abolishing fatal VF, does not significantly improve survival in post-
MI patients (8).
The class II (beta-blocking) antiarrhythmic agents, typified by propranolol, atenolol,
and esmolol, are the only drugs that have been consistently shown to produce an
increased time to onset of ventricular tachycardia (VT; ref. 9), a reduction in arrhyth-
mia incidence (10), and to improve survival post-MI (11). A true appreciation for these
actions seems to have been overlooked despite the overwhelming abundance of data
describing the efficacy of this class of antiarrhythmic drug (12). Both the class III K+
channel-blocking and class IV Ca2+ channel-blocking agents have, in contrast, exhib-
ited poor results in post-MI clinical trials (13).
An examination of the developmental patterns for antiarrhythmic drugs suggests
that because of the poor performance of antiarrhythmics in the past, there must be
continued research in this area. Therefore, novel molecular targets must be determined
and drugs for these targets developed. Some novel cardiac targets include a pathologi-
cally targeted approach whereby drugs have been developed that show marked selec-
tivity for myocardial ischemia and have a greater therapeutic index when compared
with prevous antiarrhythmic drugs (14). Sodium-hydrogen exchange inhibitor drugs,
such as cariporide, which target the cardiac-specific isoform of this membrane pump,
may also have activity against arrhythmias and efficacy in congestive heart failure
(15). Thus, because of the large number of mortalities each year from cardiac disease,
there is a very large unmet medical need for more efficacious antiarrhythmic drugs.
Current medical expenditures in the United States for arrhythmias and arrhythmia-
related conditions are over $1 billion, and the unmet medical market is estimated to be
well over $3 billion.
Fig. 2. The temporal association between some cardiac ion channels involved in the genesis
of the AP and the EKG. (A), a ventricular AP is depicted with ion currents involved in its
genesis. Although ion channels vary in species the fast upward spike generated by Na+ (INa)
represents the QRS complex of the EKG (B). Ventricular repolarization results from the com-
bined actions of many K+ currents and is delineated in the EKG by the upward deflection of the
T-wave (B).
Ca2+ and K+ (Fig. 2A). Membrane pumps and exchangers are involved as well. The
properties of the AP change moderately among tissue types. In pacemaker cells of the
nodal tissues phase 4 is characterized by a slow, steady depolarization from the resting
membrane potential (Vm) that leads to a threshold potential. When this potential is met,
a rapid upstroke (phase 0) results and a nodal AP develops that is composed of similar
phases as in ventricular or other cardiac cells. Although there may be some differences
regarding phase 4 development in various cardiac tissue, the fundamentals of AP gen-
eration are unchanged. The pacemaker current shapes the periodicity of oscillations in
the heart because this current is activated by the hyperpolarized cell membrane at the
conclusion of the AP.
Cardiac Drug Development 7
The inward voltage-gated Na+ channel is responsible for producing phase 0 and the
rapid upstroke of the cardiac AP. Although Na+ channels rapidly inactivate as Vm
approaches the equilibrium potential (0 mV), a second voltage-gated ion channel is
activated that is carried by Ca2+ ions. Calcium channels carry Isi that is responsible for
the plateau phase of the AP (Fig. 2A). Although many Ca2+ channel subtypes occur,
there are at least two isoforms found in the heart: the L and T types.
Within a short period of time (125 ms), cardiac Ca2+ channels inactivate and K+
channels activate. Repolarization is rapid when the total outward K+ current becomes
appreciably greater than inward Ca 2+ current. A large number of voltage- and
nonvoltage-gated K+ currents are involved in repolarization of the cardiac AP. The
voltage-gated K+ currents include the transient outward K+ current (Ito), one of the
earliest channels to open; the outward or delayed rectifier current (IK), which opens at
the end of phase 2 and is the main K+ current responsible for ventricular repolarization.
The last to open is the inward rectifier K+ current (IK1) which, unlike other K+ currents,
closes during depolarization and is responsible for maintenance of the resting mem-
brane potential (Fig. 2A).
tial to its predepolarizing (resting) level begins with activation of Ca2+ current and
repolarizing K+ currents.
2.2. Cardiac Ca2+ Channels
Voltage-gated Ca2+ channels are important regulators of electrical signaling and
mechanical function in the heart. In the myocyte, Ca2+ is highly regulated by voltage-
gated Ca2+ channels, Ca2+ pumps and by the Na+/Ca2+ exchanger.
Calcium channels are responsible for the genesis of APs in cardiac pacemaker cells,
the propagation of APs in sinoatrial and atrioventricular node cells and in the control of
depolarization-induced Ca2+ entry responsible for the plateau (phase 2) of the CAP
(Fig. 2A).
Voltage-gated Ca2+ channels are hetero-oligomeric protein complexes that are com-
prised of a α1 (~240 kDa) subunit, a β subunit (~60 kDa), and an accessory α2-δ (~175
kDa) subunit (26). Currently, six classes of voltage-gated Ca2+ channel have been char-
acterized. In the heart, there is a single L- and T-type Ca2+ channel and each mediate an
important action in the genesis of the AP.
The α1 subunit of the Ca2+ channel (~1800 amino acid residues) is the major protein
constituent that contains the ionic pore, selectivity filter, and gating machinery. In car-
diac ventricular muscle the α1C subunit encoding the L-type Ca2+ channel is found at
appreciably high levels (>80%) whereas α1D subunit expression dominates atrial
muscle (26). Of the three isoforms of the α1 subunit that encode for the T-type channel
only α1G and α1H are found in cardiac tissue (26,27).
The α1 subunit also contains the binding domain for Ca2+ channel-blocking drugs.
The L-type channel is blocked by three groups of drugs. The phenylalkylamine (e.g.,
verapamil) and benzothiazepine (e.g., diltiazem) blockers are effective clinically used
antiarrhythmics whereas the 1,4-dihydropyridines (e.g., nifedipine) are useful anti-
hypertensive agents. Chemically, Ca2+ channels show a marked structural homology
to each other and to voltage-gated Na+ channels. This subunit is composed of four
homologous domains (DI–DIV) each of which is composed of six transmembrane
spanning α-helical proteins that form a pore in the membrane.
Calcium channels also require auxiliary subunits for functional expression. Cur-
rently, four mammalian isoforms of the β subunit exist but the cardiac L- and T-type
Ca2+ channels are only co-expressed with the β2-subunit isoform (28). Of the three α2-
δsubunit isoforms that have been detected in various tissues, only the α2-δ1 and α2-δ2
types are expressed in the heart (28,29). The cardiac L-type Ca2+ channels possess the
high affinity, stereoselective-binding sites for channel block. Inhibition produces anti-
arrhythmic activity against supraventricular arrhythmias. The S6 regions of DIII and
DIV may contain the actual high affinity binding sites for channel blocking drugs (26).
2.3. Cardiac K+ Channels
Interest in the development of drugs that prolong refractoriness, that is, possess class
III antiarrhythmic action, increased markedly after the negative results of the CAST
trials. Repolarization and the configuration of phase 3 of the AP in cardiac tissue
seemed the next likely target for antiarrhythmic drug development. This was especially
tantalizing because repolarization resulted from the complex interaction of multiple K+
channels providing numerous targets for drug development (30).
However, whereas individual K+ currents overlap in contribution to the total mem-
brane current during the AP, the relative importance of each may vary under differ-
Cardiac Drug Development 9
ent physiological conditions. During ischaemia, changes in cell properties may alter
the degree to which different channels contribute to the CAP. Despite these short-
comings, intensive development has continued for selective K+ channel-blocking
antiarrhyhmic drugs.
Mammalian K+ channels have been categorized into three main families: the volt-
age-gated K+ channels (Kv), the inward rectifying K+ channels (K1), and the two
pore domain channels (K2P). All K+ currents have a similar primary amino acid
sequence with highly conserved structural regions. The molecular structures of K+
channels are described as having one or two pore-forming domains and two, four, or
six transmembrane-spanning domains. The molecular diversity of K+ channels is
largely to the result of variability in the heteromeric association of pore-forming α
subunits and accessory or β-subunits (31). Voltage-dependent K+ channel α subunits
have six transmembrane spanning sequences and a pore-forming region. The
inwardly rectifying K+ channel α subunit is composed of two transmembrane span-
ning sequences and one pore-forming region.
The voltage-dependent activation of K+ currents plays a considerable role in the
repolarization of the cardiac cell membrane. Voltage-dependent inactivation may pro-
ceed either rapidly or slowly by N- and C-type inactivation, respectively (32). The
differential distribution of currents carried by K+ channels is extremely important in
the regulation of myocardial cell resting potential and repolarization and thus to the
configuration of the cardiac AP within different cells of the heart and electrocardio-
gram (EKG) morphology between species.
Thus, the heterogeneity of K+ channels provides a large potential for the develop-
ment of K+ channel-blocking drugs (33). However, class III agents are bradycardic and
prolong the action potential duration (APD) at low heart rates more effectively than
high heart rates, reducing their efficacy.
This reverse-use dependence limits their beneficial actions in the arrhythmic condi-
tion (34). The resulting bradycardia associated with new potent K+ channel blockers,
such as dofetilide and sematilide, is associated with torsade des pointes arrhythmias
(35). Note, however, that some drugs, such as amiodarone, lack this effect (34).
Thus, although many K+ channels exist in cardiac muscle, a complete overview of
only those K+ conductances, which carry most of the outward repolarizing current, is
beyond the scope of this article. Note, however, that the K+ currents that do contribute
include the transient outward K+ current, the delayed rectifier K+ (IK) current (and its
components, IKr and IKs), and the inward rectifier (IKIR) current.
membrane as a function of time (ΔdV/dt). The intervals that are defined by the EKG
present the clinician and basic researcher with a fundamental tool to diagnose disease
and investigate drug activity.
Whereas electrical activity generated by atrial depolarization is recorded by the EKG
as the P-wave (Fig. 2B), ventricular depolarization produces a QRS complex. Repolar-
ization of the ventricles is recorded by the EKG as the T-wave. The QT interval repre-
sents the ventricular refractory period and includes depolarization and repolarization
of ventricular muscle. In contrast to the atria, the AP in ventricular tissue is long (~300
ms) and similar to the duration of the QT interval. Thus, the QT interval is an approxi-
mate measure of ventricular repolarization and thus K+ channel function.
The ST segment is an important measure of the EKG because it represents the early
phase of ventricular repolarization. Clinically, depression in this segment can be used
to diagnose conditions, such as angina. Elevation in this segment occurs in a damaged
area of the ventricular wall that may be associated with myocardial ischemia or infarc-
tion. However, any abnormality in these measures may be indicative of some underly-
ing pathophysiological process that alters the AP in cardiac cells that are a consequence
of changes in voltage-gated ion channel(s) in tissue (36).
Because the EKG is a composite of voltage-gated ion channels, it is not consistent
between various animal species. The variability is quantitative, that is, measureable
differences in current densities can be recorded and qualitative, that is, EKG shape
varies because of expression of ion channel(s) distinct from that found in the human
heart (Fig. 3). Although little disparity exists regarding the role of both Na+ and Ca2+
channels in the hearts of various species, important species and regional differences
exist in the contribution K+ channels make to repolarization of the cardiac AP. This
disparity is of particular importance when determining which species to use in estab-
lishing relevant in vivo and in vitro animal models to assess the activity of novel car-
diac drugs.
Fig. 3. A comparison of some EKG recordings from various species. (A) depicts a human
EKG, (B) from a rat, and (C) from a rabbit. Note that the EKG tracings are not to scale.
5. SAFETY PHARMACOLOGY
In the simplest sense, pharmacological studies can be separated essentially into three
main categories that characterize (1) the primary pharmacodynamic, (2) the secondary
pharmacodynamic actions of a new drug, which determines the mechanism of drug
action, and (3) the safety pharmacology of the new drug.
Safety pharmacology is defined as those studies that investigate any potential
undesirable pharmacological effects of a drug on normal physiological function (43).
These studies are not toxicological in nature but rather are an attempt to characterize
whether or not a dose–response relationship exists between a drug and the observed
response.These studies are conducted before drug administration to humans (phase 1
clinical trials) to reduce the likelihood of adverse events from occurring in the clini-
cal setting. The information excogitated from such studies provides supplemental
knowledge relating to the mechanism of action responsible for the observed benefi-
cial, as well as any potential adverse, pharmacological effects. Safety pharmacology
studies primarily examine the effects of a drug on three main vital organ systems
using a core battery of in vitro and in vivo test systems. These vital organ systems are
the central nervous system, respiratory system, and the cardiovascular system. All
studies are conducted, optimized, and validated according to International Confer-
ence on Harmonization (ICH) ethics and scientific quality standards that reflect proper
study design, conduct of experiments, data-recording methods, and data-
reporting practices.
Studies are conducted according to good laboratory practice regulations set forth
by global regulatory agencies (43,44). Thus, safety pharmacology is a unique new
discipline that bridges the gap that currently exists between pharmacology and toxi-
cology. Thus, it is an important consequential means by which to ensure the safety
of drugs, especially those being developed for cardiac disease, before their use in
human studies. Thus, all new drugs must undergo rigorous safety pharmacology
screening methods.
Cardiac Drug Development 13
Electrical activity in the heart can be examined at many levels providing the
researcher with the ability to quantitate the effects of novel cardiac drugs at all levels.
Global electrical activity is most easily quantified using the EKG. The electrical activ-
ity can be examined in different chambers and in various anatomical locations within
the heart by insertion of recording electrodes into those areas (or chambers) of the
heart (48). With the placement of stimulating electrodes into any of these areas, it is
possible to electrically challenge the heart. The electrical stimulation method allows
for an assessment of the ion channel status (Na+ and K+) within cardiac tissue in
the absence and presence of cardiac drug (48). This method also permits for an evalu-
ation of the vulnerability of the ventricle to arrhythmia (premature ventricular contrac-
tion [PVC] or VF) induction, thus, is an excellent method with which to rapidly screen
novel drugs for cardiac activity.
Extracellular monophasic action potentials (MAPs) can be recorded from the
endocardium or epicardium of atria, ventricles, or the whole heart (49). The MAP is an
extracellularly recorded potential that approximates the time course of the intracellular
AP. The MAP is generated by the application of pressure to the contact electrode against
the cardiac muscle wall. The MAP can be used to record myocardial activation time,
repolarization (phases 1–3) of the CAP, dispersion of APD, postrepolarization refrac-
toriness, early after-depolarization development, ischemia-induced changes in the
APD, and the actions of cardiac drugs (49).
Arrhythmias can seriously impair mechanical function of the heart. Thus, although
VT limits or impairs cardiac output, VF terminates cardiac output. Arrhythmias can be
detected experimentally by changes in both blood pressure and the EKG. The experimen-
tal methods used to induce arrhythmias are both numerous and complex. Arrhythmias
may be produced electrically (as discussed previously), chemically or by ischemia (50).
The induction of arrhythmias by chemical methods is usually performed in small
animal species. Standard chemical methods for the induction of arrhythmias include
the use of cardiac glycosides in guinea pigs, chloroform in mice, aconitine in rats and
catecholamines to dogs (48,50). Note that the types of arrhythmias that result are spe-
cific to the chemical agent used and are species dependent. Although the arrhythmias
that result are reproducible and exhibit characteristic sensitivity to historical or control
antiarrhythmic drugs, the mechanism(s) responsible for the development of the arrhyth-
mia are not well defined. However, the use of these proarrhythmic models provide a
rapid in vivo screening system with which to investigate the potential efficacy of novel
cardiac drugs that can be compared with current, clinically used drugs.
Appropriate electrical stimulation, applied though the implantation of electrodes into
any part of the heart, can result in the induction of arrhythmia (48). A large variety of
defined stimulation protocols can be used and can be chosen for either the induction of
arrhythmias or for indirectly probing the functional status of either Na+ or K+ channels.
For example, electrical currents and pulse widths required to induce single extra beats
in the myocardium reflect Na+ channel availability and excitability (or i-t curves)
whereas refractory periods or effective refractory period (ERP) reflect Na+ channel
status but are highly dependent on K+ channels which control repolarization (46).
The types of arrhythmias induced by electrical stimulation include single extra
beats, VT, or VF. These studies can be conducted in normal intact hearts or in previ-
ously ischemic or infarcted hearts. Thus, the flexibility that results from the avail-
ability of the numerous stimulation protocols to probe arrhythmia propensity and ion
Cardiac Drug Development 15
channel activity also makes this a very useful method with which to investigate novel
cardiac drugs.
However, the most clinically relevant method for arrhythmia induction results from
the occlusion of a coronary artery. This deprives blood flow to the cardiac region
subserved by the artery, results in ischemia, and produces changes representative of a
heart attack. The continued occlusion of the coronary artery results in MI. Both the
duration of coronary artery occlusion and the size of the developed ischemic area
determine the extent of infarction. These factors then determine the severity of
arrhythmias that develop (51). Reperfusion, which results from the release of the
coronary artery from occlusion, produces arrhythmias that appear similar in mor-
phology to those that result from ischemia alone but vary markedly in their develop-
ment characteristic (51).
VT and VF in these animal models occur at critical times after coronary artery
occlusion or reperfusion subsequent to a preceding ischemic period. These methods
can be used in all species but care should be taken when selecting the species with
which to conduct arrhythmia studies because coronary collateralization in the heart is
critical to the size of the developing ischemic area or infarct (52).
Collateralization varies to a large degree among the hearts of different animal spe-
cies. The hearts of guinea pigs have an abundance of coronary collateral vessels, which
prevents its use in the study of regional myocardial ischemia (46). Arrhythmic
responses are also not uniform in dogs because of the extent of pre-existing coronary
collateralization (50). Coronary collaterals are not present to any significant degree in
the hearts of species such as rats, pigs, rabbits, and primates; this makes them better
candidates as models with which to investigate responses to ischemia and reperfusion
in the heart (50).
To accurately assess the efficacy of a novel cardiac drug, it is necessary to quantitate
the area of ischemia or infarction that is produced by the most physiologically relevant
animal model. Many diverse experimental methods can be used to quantitate the size of
the infarction produced in the heart. The most accurate methods are those that directly
quantitate the anatomical size of the infarct. Such gross anatomical methods include
cross-sectioning the ventricle into slices and estimating the area of infarction found in
each slice. Demarcation between infarcted, ischemic, and normal myocardial tissue
can be resolved using stains that chemically interact with normal tissue and not necrotic
tissue (46). These provide an accurate estimate of infarct size that is easily determined
by visual examination providing reliable results in drug assessment.
The patch clamp technique revolutionized cardiac drug discovery because it was
possible to record current flow through ion channels in the many cells that comprise
the CAP. The electrophysiological actions of a drug are investigated using many con-
figurations of the patch clamp. Whole-cell recording, in which the total ionic current
that flows across the cell membrane is recorded, and patch clamp recording, in which
the current that only flows across a small membrane patch is recorded, are the most
commonly used (53). However, for drug study, the whole-cell configuration is pre-
ferred. This method allows the investigator to determine the effects of the drug on
many different ion channels using electrophysiological protocols that probe the func-
tional properties of the channel. Many properties of the channel can be examined in the
absence and presence of various concentrations of the investigational drug. The goal of
these studies is to characterize the molecular actions of the drug in an attempt to eluci-
date both its site of action and putative mechanism.
Isolated tissue preparations have become a cornerstone of the physiological and
pharmacological evaluation of natural and synthetic drugs. Note, however, that the
extrapolation of drug effects on isolated tissue preparations to the whole animal is
limited by the complexity of mechanisms present in intact animals. Nevertheless, the
assessment of the pharmacological action of antiarrhythmic drugs in isolated tissues
is an essential step in clarifying the actions of a novel drug and in determining further
studies in intact animals.
The cardiovascular system is a rich source of tissues for in vitro studies. Therefore,
to investigate drug action some of the most widely used cardiac preparations include
isolated atrial or ventricular tissue, papillary muscles and the isolated, coronary-per-
fused right ventricular wall (54). The use of these tissue preparations in drug investiga-
tions is numerous. The small size of most cardiac tissues allows for the rapid and
continuous diffusion of oxygen and nutrients to subcellular layers, resulting in viable,
stable preparations. These preparations from different animal species are extensively
used to represent the heart; therefore, the type of isolated tissue preparation used when
attempting to study problems concerning drug actions or cardiac function must be care-
fully considered.
The isolated perfused whole heart is the most physiologically relevant isolated car-
diac tissue. This preparation has many advantages compared with either isolated
myocytes or isolated tissues because it lends itself to the study of the actions of cardiac
drugs on mechanical, electrical, and biochemical properties of the heart. The isolated
Langendorff heart is a simple preparation with which to screen for the cardiac actions
of drugs because it uses physiological buffers to maintain normal heart function (55).
The greatest function of the isolated perfused heart is its usefulness in assessing
drug actions on the rate of generation of ventricular pressure. It is also a sensitive
indicator of the chronotropic and inotropic actions of drugs on the heart. Coronary flow
and a surface EKG can also be recorded as supplementary indices of drug action on
coronary vasculature resistance and ion channels. Drug activity can also be assessed in
diseased hearts.
Equally, ischemia and reperfusion arrhythmias can be investigated in isolated per-
fused hearts. Occlusion of a coronary artery in an isolated perfused heart produces
arrhythmias. The antiarrhythmic efficacy of the drug under investigation can readily be
compared with that observed in vivo in the absence of blood. Isolated hearts can also
be rendered globally or regionally ischemic and the effect of the drug can be investi-
Cardiac Drug Development 17
gated on measures, such as oxygen consumption and other markers of cardiac metabo-
lism associated with these pathological states. Thus, the extensive variety of convinc-
ing applications for use of this method in normal and diseases hearts will ensure its
continued use in the preclinical assessment of novel cardiac and antiarrhythmic drugs.
The use of heterologous expression systems allows for the electrophysiological mea-
surement of the properties of cardiac drugs on isolated ion channels from the heart
using voltage and patch clamp techniques. These systems are used to express high
levels of the desired functional protein that is not endogenous to the system. Some
available expression systems include Xenopus oocytes, transfected mammalian cells,
such as human embryonic kidney (and Chinese hamster ovary cells, and baculovirus-
infected insect cell lines, such as Sf9 and Hi5. The expression system selected should
be chosen (as with isolated tissues described above) appropriately based on the ques-
tions addressed because each system has certain advantages and disadvantages. For
example, one system may be appropriate for the study of drugs on ion channel function
(e.g., Xenopus oocytes) whereas another may be more useful to synthesize large
amounts of protein for biochemical analysis (e.g., baculovirus-insect cell lines).
Xenopus laevis oocytes are one of the most commonly used expression systems with
which to examine cDNA (or mRNA) encoding cardiac ion channels. Their usefulness
resides in the fact that oocytes do not express significant levels of endogenous Na+, K+,
or Ca2+ currents. RNA that is injected into oocytes is efficiently transcribed so that the
effects of cardiac and antiarrhythmic drugs on exogenous channels can be studied. One
disadvantage of the oocyte system is that proteins are modified by the oocyte. In mam-
malian cells, protein synthesis involves many sequential processing steps that result in
a unique structural or functional protein. Studies of translational mRNA processes in
oocytes suggest that although similar to mammalian cells, some post-translational pro-
cessing differences exist. Glycosylation of the protein in oocytes may be different from
mammalian glycosylation possibly resulting in altered functional properties. However,
despite this caveat, oocytes have become a gold standard for functional expression of
ion channels.Today, many distinct mammalian cell lines can be used to express cloned
human cardiac ion channels. The most relevant to the examination of cardiac or antiar-
rhythmic drugs are those cell lines that stably express the HERG K+ ion channel that is
implicated in torsade des pointes arrhythmias or the LQTS.
is understood that using in vivo screens, isolated tissues, dissociated myocytes, iso-
lated hearts, or heterologous expression systems to evaluate new drug candidates is a
gravely slower, and more tedious process, than drug synthesis.
However, attempts to improve upon early screening procedures using in vitro or
biochemical methods may begin to close the Grand Canyon-size gap that currently
exists between chemical synthesis and determining drug efficacy and safety. Because
ion channels really do not contain functionally defined binding sites and are not a
receptor this further complicates the development of HTS methods.
Sodium and other ion channels characteristically contain binding sites for neuro-
toxins and other drugs that activate, block, or modulate channel response to drugs
through known mechanisms. Thus, attempts have been made to use radioligand-
binding methods to develop HTS assays for ion channels. However, complications
arise because the activity of many neurotoxins involves a state-dependent binding to
the Na+ channel (56). The utility of such a preliminary assay as a screen is attenuated
because drugs that do not interact with the state of the channel produced by the neu-
rotoxin would not be detected.
Fluorescence-based cellular methods may more appropriately reflect the selectivity
and sensitivity that is required for HTS assays (56). Briefly, the fluorescence methods
use a heterocycle fluorophore or fluorescence dye molecule that localizes in a region of
the cell (such as the cytoplasm) and responds to a stimulus. Fluorophores for Ca2+ ions
include dyes, such as fura-2 and fluo-4 (Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR), whereas oth-
ers are available for Na+ and K+ ions.
Probes such as these are measured using technologies, such as the Fluorometric
Imaging Plate Recorder or FLIPR384 (Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, CA). Because
these systems contain enhanced automation features, including potential robot inte-
gration, assays that quantitate intracellular constituents, such as Ca2+, pH and Na+ and
Vm, they may be modified to conduct HTS assay development. Cell responses can be
monitored in real time, kinetic data for drugs can be derived, relative drug potencies
can be determined, and drug-ion channel interaction kinetics can be determined.
Radiotracers can also be used in HTS assays. Denyer et al. (56) describe a novel
cell-based Na+ channel assay using Cytostar-T scintillating microplates (Amersham
Life Science, Piscataway, NJ). These plates have a transparent scintillant base that
emits light as it is excited by the decay of the radioisotope in close proximity. Cells are
grown to confluence on the microplates and various neurotoxins are used to maintain
open Na+ channels. Permeant 14C-labeled guanidinium is added to the cells. Once suf-
ficient radiotracer incorporation into the cells occurs, tetrodotoxin is used to block the
channels. Blockade or inhibition of channel opening by the test drug alters the signal
emitted from the scintillation base of the microplate and provides an index of activity
on the Na+ channel. Complex assays such as this may provide the necessary steps in the
development of HTS screening methods for ion channels.
Coronary artery occlusion and MI development results in progressive changes in
the cellular architecture of both infarcted and noninfarcted ventricular muscle. These
changes are caused by remodeling within the heart. Remodeling involves changes in
cellular events that modulate adaptation and include hypertrophy of myocytes, deposi-
tion of extracellular matrix components, and proliferation of fibroblasts (57). These
processes ultimately are responsible for ensuing dysfunction that transpires post-MI.
Diminution in cardiac contractility derives from muscle dystrophy and fibrosis, events
Cardiac Drug Development 19
subsequent to scar formation within the damaged ventricular muscle. For this to occur
within the heart, there must be an altered response and downregulation of many
homeostatic mechanisms responsible for normal contractility. Ultimately such changes
derive from altered gene expression, and this can be studied at the subcellular level
using microarray technology.
DNA microarrays are a powerful new method by which to determine the pattern of
gene expression in both normal and diseased tissues. Microarrays currently provide an
initial central point for use in drug target and validation. These methods allow for the
identification of those genes, whether up- or downregulated in expression that may
be involved in disease. It is now recognized that many cardiac disease processes
involve multiple modifications in genes. These concurrent changes may then culmi-
nate in the disease process. Thus, therapy can now ideally be directed at the cause of
the disease and not simply at the symptoms.
Microarray technology may have an application in cardiac disease because it pro-
vides researchers with the ability to characterize the gene expression levels of thou-
sands of genes in parallel (58). The development of DNA microarrays for application
to disease is a multistep process. Genes to be arrayed are identified and obtained from
private or public genebanks. Both normal and diseased tissues are used and usually
~15,000 genes are identified that may characterize the cardiac disease under investiga-
tion. Selected genes are usually maintained in bacterial plasmids and subject to poly-
merase chain reaction amplification procedures before hybridization on microarray
plates. The polymerase chain reaction amplification product is arrayed at a high den-
sity to either glass slides radiolabeled with a fluorescent dye (such as C4S) or nylon
membranes radiolabeled with phosphorus (33P). The signal intensity of the hybridized
genetic sample determines the expression level of the corresponding gene and the pro-
file is then processed using bioinformatic methods.
Although the potential impact of microarray use in many cardiac diseases is sub-
stantial, its application remains at an elementary stage. Several studies have been con-
ducted in models of heart failure, MI, and ventricular hypertrophy (57,59). In these
studies, no fewer than 55 known (and unknown) genes were detected that could be
involved in these cardiac diseases. Functional relevance remains inconclusive and many
caveats exist that relate to the use of this methodology.Microarrays, although high
throughput in nature, have a low sensitivity, and genes that exhibit ~70% homology are
indistinguishable (60). Quality control issues, computational resources, and a require-
ment that a large number of diseased and nondiseased tissues must be profiled to derive
conclusions concerning the reproducibility of gene expression patterns are issues that
require resolution. Owing to the ingenuity of researchers in this field, resolution is only
time dependent.
Fig. 4. The preclinical and clinical relationships for new drug development and the approval
process.
are successful, then the pharmaceutical or biotechnology company provides the data in
the form of an Investivational New Drug application to governmental agencies such as
the FDA in the United States or to the European Agency for the Evaluation of Medici-
nal Products (EMEA) in Europe.
Clinical drug trials of novel antiarrhythmic or cardiovascular experimental drugs (as
for all drugs) are conducted in four phases (Fig. 4). The early phases of drug testing in
humans are usually broad in perspective and provide information regarding dose, drug
kinetics, and tolerance. Thus these early phases concern the testing of the safety of the
drug (phase 1) and the efficacy of the drug (phase 2). The attrition rate for new drugs
reaches approx 60% by the end of this phase of clinical trial testing. In later trials, large
Cardiac Drug Development 21
controlled studies that delineate the range of the drug’s effectiveness; incidence of
adverse events and the benefit to potential patient population (phase 3) are conducted.
The attrition rate for drugs is reduced to approx 10–20%. Successful completion allows
the drug company to file a New Drug Application with the FDA or EMEA. If granted,
the drug is then conditionally approved for marketing.
This conditional approval is given before phase 4 studies. However, these phase 4
(or late phase 3) studies are intended to provide for postmarketing surveillance and
allow for the monitored release of the drug, whereby patients may be given the drug
under specified supervision by physicians at selected medical centers.
These studies are an indispensable part of medical research and offer the only means
by which to provide new therapies for cardiovascular diseases that afflict humans.
However, as many clinical cardiovascular trials have taught (and cost!) the drug indus-
try, this is a very arduous process and many cardiovascular clinical drug trials have
failed. However, despite these failures, a re-evaluation of clinical trial data provides
for suggestions as to how to improve clinical trials involving cardiac drugs. These
suggestions include the regular requirement of phase 4 trials with surrogate endpoints,
a clear definition of phase 3 study endpoints, and also by possibly reassessment of
thestructure of the clinical trial hierarchy itself (61,62). Recently, Lipicky (61) sug-
gested that the traditional distinctions between study phases for clinical trials not be
used. It is reasoned that conforming to the rigid phases currently used to conduct clini-
cal trials with cardiac (particulary antiarrhythmic) drugs may be detrimental to drug
development (61). Rather, it is suggested that combining phase 2 with phase 3 trials
may reduce unnecessary delays associated with independent, consecutive trials and be
of a clear benefit to drug development. Additionally, it is suggested that multiple drug
doses should be studied, the type of arrhythmia be defined and the doses be related to
some measure of cardiac activity (61). Consideration of suggestions such as these may
reduce the attrition rate associated with drug development for cardiac disease, improve
the safety profile for these drugs in patients, and ultimately provide novel drugs that
improve symptoms associated with the disease or prevent the disease itself.
REFERENCES
1. American Heart Association. (2002) Heart and Stroke Statistical Update. American Heart
Association, Dallas, TX.
2. Vaughan Williams, E. M. (1984). A classification of antiarrhythmic actions reassessed
after a decade of new drugs. J. Clin. Pharmacol. 24, 129–147.
3. The Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppression Trial (CAST) Investigators. (1989) Preliminary
Report: Effect of encainide and flecainide on mortality in a randomized trial of arrhythmia
suppression after myocardial infarction. N. Eng. J. Med. 321, 406–412.
4. The Cardiac Arrhythmia Suppression Trial II (CAST–II) Investigators. (1992) Effect of
the antiarrhythmic agent moricizine on survival after myocardial infarction. N. Eng. J.
Med. 327, 227–233.
5. IMPACT Research Group. (1984) International mexiletine and placebo antiarrhythmic coro-
nary trial: I. Report on arrhythmia and other findings. J. Am. Coll. Cardiol. 4, 1148–1163.
6. Myerburg, R. J., Kessler, K. M., Chakko, S., Cox, M. M., Fernando, P., Interian, A., and
Castellanos, A. (1994) Future evaluation of antiarrhythmic therapy. Am. Heart J. 127,
1111–1118.
7. Morganroth, J. and Goin, J. E. (1991) Quinidine-related mortality in the short- to medium-
term treatment of ventricular arrhythmias: A meta analysis. Circulation 84, 1977–1983.
22 Pugsley
8. Hine, L. K., Laird, N., Hewitt, P., and Chalmers, T. C. (1989) Meta-analytic evidence
against prophylactic use of lidocaine in acute myocardial infarction. Arch. Int. Med. 149,
2694–2698.
9. Rosenfeld, J., Rosen, M. R., and Hoffman, B. F. (1978) Pharmacologic and behavioral
effects on arrhythmias that immediately follow abrupt coronary occlusion: A canine model
of sudden coronary death. Am. J. Cardiol. 41, 1075–1084.
10. Kam, R. M., Teo, W. S., Koh, T. H., and Lim, Y. L. (1999) Treatment and prevention of
sudden cardiac death{\}what have we learnt from randomised clinical trials? Singapore
Med. J. 40, 707–710.
11. Ogunyankin, K. O. and Singh, B. N. (1999) Mortality reduction by antiadrenergic modula-
tion of arrhythmogenic substrate: Significance of combining beta blockers and amiodarone.
Am. J. Cardiol. 84, 76R–82R.
12. Singh, B. N. (1999) The relevance of sympathetic activity in the pharmacological treat-
ment of chronic stable angina. Can. J. Cardiol. 15(Suppl A), 15A–21A.
13. Nattel, S. (1991) Antiarrhythmic drug classifications. A critical appraisal of their history,
present status, and clinical relevance. Drugs 41, 672–701.
14. Beatch, G. N., Barrett, T. D., Plouvier, B., Jung, G., Wall, R. A., Zolotoy, A., and Walker,
M. J. A. (2002) Ventricular fibrillation, an uncontrolled arrhythmia seeking new targets.
Drug Dev. Res. 55, 45–52.
15. Karmazyn, M. (2000) Pharmacology and clinical assessment of cariporide for the treat-
ment of coronary artery diseases. Expert. Opin. Invest. Drugs 9, 1099–1108.
16. Hodgkin, A. L. and Huxley, A. F. (1952) A quantitative description of membrane current
and its application to conduction and excitation in nerve. J. Physiol. (Lond) 116, 500–544.
17. Denac, H., Mevissen, M., and Scholtysik, G. (2000) Structure, function and pharmacology
of voltage-gated sodium channels. Naunyn-Schmied. Arch. Pharmacol. 362, 453–479.
18. Sato, C., Ueno, Y., Asai, K., Takahashi, K., Sato, M., Engel, A., and Fujiyoshi, Y. (2001)
The voltage-sensitive sodium channel is a bell-shaped molecule with several cavities.
Nature 409, 1047–1051.
19. Isom, L. L., DeJongh, K. S., Patton, D. E., Reber, B. F. X., Offord, J., Charbonneau, H.,
et al. (1992) Primary structure and functional expression of the β1 subunit of the rat brain
sodium channel. Science 256, 839–842.
20. Isom, L. L., Ragsdale, D. S., De Jongh, K. S., Westenbroek, R. E., Reber, B. F. X., Scheuer,
T., et al. (1995) Structure and function of the β2 subunit of brain sodium channels, a trans-
membrane glycoprotein with a CAM motif. Cell 83, 433–442.
21. West, J. W., Patton, D. E., Scheuer, T., Wang, Y., Goldin, A. L., and Catterall, W. A.
(1992) A cluster of hydrophobic amino acid residues required for fast Na+ channel inacti-
vation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 10910–10914.
22. Hille, B. (1984) Mechanisms of Block, in Ionic Channels of Excitable Membranes (Hille,
B., ed.), Sinauer, Sunderland, UK, pp. 390–422.
23. Hille, B. (1977) Local anesthetics: Hydrophilic and hydrophobic pathways for the drug–
receptor reaction. J. Gen. Physiol. 69, 497–515.
24. Hondeghem, L. M. and Katzung, B. G. (1977) Time- and voltage-dependent interactions of
antiarrhythmic drugs with cardiac sodium channels. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 472, 373–398.
25. Ragsdale, D. S., McPhee, J. C., Scheuer, T., and Catterall, W. A. (1996) Common molecu-
lar determinants of local anesthetic, antiarrhythmic, and anticonvulsant block of voltage-
gated Na+ channels. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93, 9270–9275.
26. Streissnig, J. (1999) Pharmacology, structure and function of cardiac L-type calcium chan-
nels. Cell. Physiol. Biochem. 9, 242–269.
27. Bean, B. P. and McDonough, S. I. (1998) Two for T. Neuron 20, 825–828.
28. Gao, T., Puri, T. S., Gerhardstein, B. L., Chien, A. J., Green, R. D., and Hosey, M. M.
(1997) Identification and subcellular localization of the subunits of L-type calcium chan-
nels and adenylyl cyclase in cardiac myocytes. J. Biol. Chem. 272, 19,401–19,407.
Cardiac Drug Development 23
29. Klugbauer, N., Lacinova, L., Marais, E., Hobom, M., and Hofmann, F. (1999) Molecular
diversity of the calcium channel alpha2delta subunit. J. Neurosci. 19, 684–691.
30. Snyders, D. J. (1999) Structure and function of cardiac potassium channels. Cardiovasc.
Res. 42, 377–390.
31. Nerbonne, J. M. (2000) Molecular basis of functional voltage-gated K+ channel diversity
in the mammalian myocardium. J. Physiol. 525, 285–298.
32. Rasmusson, R. L., Morales, M. J., Wang, S., Liu, S., Campbell, D. L., Brahmajothi, M. V.,
and Strauss, H. C. (1998) Inactivation of voltage-gated cardiac K+ channels. Circ. Res. 82,
739–750.
33. Colatsky, T. J. and Follmer, C. H. (1989) K+ channel blockers and activatorrs in cardiac
arrhythmias. Cardiovasc. Drug Rev. 7, 199–209.
34. Hondeghem, L. M. and Snyders, D. J. (1990) Class III antiarrhythmic agents have a lot of
potential but a long way to go. Circulation 81, 686–690.
35. Katritsis, D., and Camm, A. J. (1993) New class III antiarrhythmic drugs. Eur. Heart J. 14,
93–99.
36. Janse, M. J. and Kleber, A. G. (1981) Electrophysiological changes and ventricular
arrhythmias in the early phase of regional myocardial ischemia. Circ. Res. 49, 1069–1081.
37. Patterson, E., Szabo, B., Scherlag, B. J., and Lazzara, R. (1995) Arrhythmogenic effects of
antiarrhythmic drugs, in Cardiac Electrophysiology, From Cell to Bedside (Zipes, D. P.,
Jalife, J. eds.), W. B. Saunders, New York, NY, pp. 496–511.
38. Towbin, J. A., Wang, Z., and Li, H. (2001) Genotype and severity of long QT syndrome.
Drug Metab Dispos. 29, 574–579.
39. Albrecht, B., Weber, K., and Pongs, O. (1995) Characterization of a voltage-activated K-
channel gene cluster on human chromosome 12p13. Receptors Channels 3, 213–220.
40. Martens, J. R., Kwak, Y. G., and Tamkun, M. M. (1999) Modulation of Kv channel alpha/
beta subunit interactions. Trends Cardiovasc. Med. 9, 253–258.
41. Roden, D. M. and Balser, J. R. (1999) A plethora of mechanisms in the HERG-related long
QT syndrome. Genetics meets electrophysiology. Cardiovasc. Res. 44, 242–246.
42. Mounsey, J. P., and DiMarco, J. P. (2000) Cardiovascular drugs. Dofetilide. Circulation
102, 2665–2670.
43. ICH S7A. Safety pharmacology studies for human pharmaceuticals (CHMP/ICH/539/00).
44. ICH S7B (2002) Safety pharmacology studies for assessing the potential for delayed ven-
tricular repolarization (QT interval prolongation) by human pharmaceuticals: Draft ICH
Consensus Guidelines.
45. Pugsley, M. K. and Tabrizchi, R. (2000) The vascular system: An overview of structure
and function. J. Pharmacol. Toxicol. Meth. 44, 333–340.
46. Pugsley, M. K. and Walker, M. J.A. (1992) Methods for evaluating heart function, in
Immunopharmacology of the Heart (Curtis, M. J., ed.), Academic Press, London, UK, pp. 7–28.
47. Pang, C. C. Y. (2000) Measurement of body venous tone. J. Pharmacol. Toxicol. Meth. 44,
341–360.
48. Winslow, E. (1984) Methods in the detection and assessment of antiarrhythmic activity.
Pharmacol. Ther. 24, 401–433.
49. Beatch, G. N. and Barrett, T. D. (1998) Monophasic action potential recording, in Methods
in Cardiac Electrophysiology (Walker, M. J. A., and Pugsley, M. K., eds.), CRC Press,
Boca Raton, FL, pp. 117–132.
50. Cheung, P. H., Pugsley, M. K., and Walker, M. J.A. (1993) Arrhythmia models in the rat.
J. Pharmacol. Toxicol. Meth. 29, 179–184.
51. Botting, J. H., Curtis, M. J., and Walker, M. J.A. (1985) Arrhythmias associated with myo-
cardial ischaemia and infarction. Mol. Aspects Med. 8, 311–422.
52. Johnston, K. M., Macleod, B. A., and Walker, M. J. A. (1983) Responses to ligation of a
coronary artery in conscious rats and the actions of antiarrhythmics. Can. J. Physiol.
Pharmacol. 61, 1340–1353.
24 Pugsley
53. Saint, D. A. (1998) Single channel recording and mathematical analysis of currents in
cardiac myocytes, in Methods in Cardiac Electrophysiology (Walker, M. J. A., and Pugsley,
M. K., eds.), CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 63–88.
54. Walker, M. J. A. and Pugsley, M. K. (eds.) (1998) Methods in Cardiac Electrophysiology,
CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
55. Doring, H. J., and Dehnert, H. (eds.) (1988) Methods in Experimental Physiology and
Pharmacology: Biological Measurement Techniques V, Biomesstechnik-Verlag, Germany.
56. Denyer, J., Worley, J., Cox, B., Allenby, G., and Banks, M. (1998) HTS approaches to
voltage-gated ion channel drug discovery. Drug Dis. Today 3, 323–332.
57. Stanton L. W., Garrard, L. J., Damm, D., Garrick, B. L., Lam, A., Kapoun, A. M., et al.
(2000) Altered patterns of gene expression in response to myocardial infarction. Circ. Res.
86, 939–945.
58. Duggan, D. J., Bittner, M., Chen, Y., Meltzer, P., and Trent, J. M. (1999) Expression pro-
filing using cDNA microarrays. Nat. Genet. 21(1 Suppl), 10–14.
59. Remme, C. A., Lombardi, M. P., van den Hoff, M. J. B., and Lekanne dit Deprez, R. H.
(2000) CDNA arrays: The ups and downs. Cardiovasc. Drugs Ther. 15, 99–101.
60. Boguslavsky, J. (2000) In–house microarrays put researchers in control. Drug Dis. Dev.
10, 30–36.
61. Lipicky, R. (2000) An FDA perspective on antiarrhythmic drugs in phase II trials. Am.
Heart J. 139, S197–S199.
62. Temple, R. (1999) Are surrogate markers adequate to assess cardiovascular disease drugs?
JAMA 282, 790–795.
Role of Cardiac Pacemaker Currents 25
II
Novel Molecular Targets
for Cardiac Drug Development
Role of Cardiac Pacemaker Currents 27
2
The Role of Cardiac Pacemaker Currents
in Antiarrhythmic Drug Discovery
David A. Saint
CONTENTS
THE PACEMAKER CURRENT AS A TARGET FOR THERAPY
THE CHARACTERISTICS OF I(F)
VARIABILITY OF CHARACTERISTICS OF I(F) IN DIFFERENT TISSUES
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY OF I(F) AND I(H)
DISTRIBUTION OF HCN CHANNELS
RELEVANCE OF I(F) TO CLINICAL CONDITIONS
TYPES OF DRUGS UNDER CURRENT DEVELOPMENT
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
27
28 Saint
from various parts of the heart, resolution of individual currents became possible. The
mechanism of the diastolic depolarization was greatly clarified by the discovery in
pacemaker cells of an inward current that was activated by hyperpolarization (5–8).
The current was shown to activate relatively slowly on hyperpolarization and to have
low selectivity among cations. These properties are just what one would expect for a
pacemaking current
Around the same time as it was discovered in cardiac myocytes, a similar current
was identified in photoreceptors (9). Subsequently, similar currents were discovered
in other tissues, particularly in parts of the central nervous system (CNS). The cur-
rent in cardiac tissue was christened I(f) (f for funny, because of its funny properties)
and in most other tissues it was called I(h) (h, because of the activation on hyperpolar-
ization). The terms are often used interchangeably.
I(f) or I(h) has been implicated in cardiac (10) and neuronal (11–13) rhythmogenesis,
sensory adaptation (14,15), shaping of synaptic potentials (16), and control of synaptic
transmitter release (17,18).
Fig. 1. The biophysical properties of I(f). (A) Spontaneous activity of a single SAN cell.
Note that the maximum diastolic potential is about –65 mV. (B) I(f) current induced in a
single SAN cell by a hyperpolarising pulse to the voltages indicated from a holding potential
of –35 mV. (C) Voltage dependence of activation of I(f), (Y∞) and fully activated I/V relation-
ship. Reprinted from DiFrancesco, D. (1995), The onset and autonomic regulation of cardiac
pacemaker activity: relevance of the f current. Cardiovasc. Res. 29, 4493–4556, with permis-
sion from Elsevier Science.
of the major influences on auto rhythmicity is I(f) and, hence, it is sensible to use I(f) as
a target in attempts to modulate rhythmicity.
If I(f) is indeed responsible for driving the diastolic depolarization, one would imag-
ine that it should be modulated by sympathetic and parasympathetic stimulation in a
way consistent with their chronotropic effects. I(f) is indeed modulated by adrenergic
agonists in a way consistent with an increase in heart rate (24).
In 1986, DiFrancesco (25) showed that I(f) was carried by channels having a single
channel conductance of about 1 pS, and that modulation of I(f) by adrenaline at the
single channel level consists of an increase in the open probability without a change in
single channel conductance. This effect of adrenaline is mediated via the G-protein/
adenyl cyclase/cAMP pathway. Using patch clamp techniques, it has been shown that
I(f) channels are modulated by a direct effect of intracellular cAMP at the intracellular
side of the channel, independent of any phosphorylation effects (26). The effect of
cAMP consists of a facilitation of the opening of single I(f) channels in response to
hyperpolarization. Measurement of the voltage dependence of the channel open prob-
ability shows that cAMP shifts the probability curve to more positive voltages without
modifying its shape (27).
Interestingly, the modulation itself seems to be subject to other influences, notably
the action of phosphorylation. Hence, the phosphatase inhibitor calyculin A increases
I(f) and potentates the beta-adrenergic mediated response (28), suggesting that there is
a so-called tonic level of phosphorylation of the channels that regulates their activity
(29). The channels carrying I(f) have also been reported to be modulated by various
hormones and growth factors. Epidermal growth factor increases maximal I(f) conduc-
tance, apparently acting through tyrosine kinase (30). Vasoactive intestinal peptide
produces a slight shift in the voltage dependence of activation of I(f) (28), an effect that
may be related to the role of vasoactive intestinal peptide as a cotransmitter with ace-
30 Saint
tylcholine released from vagal nerve endings. The thyroid hormone T3 increases the
current density of I(f) in rabbit SAN cells without changing the voltage dependence, an
effect that may underlie the sinus tachycardia commonly seen in hyperthyroidism (31).
Similar results have been reported with parathyroid hormones (32). In addition, I(f) is
modulated by muscarinic agonists in a way consistent with the decrease in heart rate
seen with these agents (33).
3. VARIABILITY OF CHARACTERISTICS
OF I(F) IN DIFFERENT TISSUES
Reflecting this wide range of tissues in which it is found and the differing physi-
ological functions with which it is therefore involved, the properties of I(f) (or I[h])
differ significantly in their voltage dependence, activation kinetics, and sensitivity to
cAMP in different tissues (12,34). This heterogeneity of properties of I(f) is found not
only between tissues but also within organs or tissue types themselves. Hence, bio-
physical studies have demonstrated that I(f) has a dramatically different voltage depen-
dence of activation in different cardiac regions, with the threshold for activation being
–50 mV in SA node, –85 mV in Purkinje myocytes, and –120 mV in adult ventricular
myocytes (35). This difference in the voltage-dependent properties of I(f) is highly
correlated with the intrinsic pacemaker activity of these tissues; the I(f) current having
the most positive activation is found in the tissue with the highest pacing rate (in SA
node), whereas the current having the most negative activation is found in tissue that
normally exhibits no diastolic depolarization at all (ventricular myocytes). Although
some of these differences in current properties may be the result of post-translational
modification of the channels or functional modulation by phosphorylation, the most likely
explanation is that I(f) currents are carried by different isoforms of the channel in differ-
ent tissues. Current density is also an important factor, presumably controlled by the
level of gene expression; as well as different voltage dependence, I(f) in ventricular cells
is present at a very low current density (Fig. 2). With the recent cloning of the channels
responsible for I(f), the factors controlling the level of gene expression, and which isoform
of the channel is expressed, have become amenable to investigation.
Fig. 2. The relative magnitudes of I(f) in rabbit ventricle and SAN cells. I(f) was evoked
by hyperpolarizing voltage steps to the voltages indicated from a holding potential of –35
mV in either a single rabbit SAN cell (A) or ventricle cell (B). Note the different current
scales. Reprinted from Shi, W., Wymore, R., Yu, H., Wu, J., Wymore, R. T., Pan, Z.,
Robinsin, R., Dixon, J. E., McKinnon, D., and Cohen, I. S. (1999), Distribution and preva-
lence of hyperpolarization-activated cation channel (HCN) mRNA expression in cardiac tis-
sues. Circ. Res. 85, e1–e6, with permission from Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins Publishers.
cesium (Cs+) in a voltage-dependent way, and are modulated by a direct action of cAMP
on the cytoplasmic side of the channel (38,39,41).
Because of the serendipitous nature of their discovery, the early nomenclature of the
gene and its isoforms for pacemaker channels is somewhat inconsistent. Some
investigators referred to the isoforms as HAC1 or HAC2, denoting hyperpolarizing acti-
vated channel. However, because of the direct action of cAMP and gating by
hyperpolarization, the nomenclature suggested by Clapham (42) and Biel et al. (43) has
been generally adopted; that is, of referring to the clones as HCN (hyperpolarization-
activated, cyclic nucleotide-gated) channels. Compared with the previous nomenclature,
HCN1 corresponds to HAC2 (mBCNG-1); HCN2 corresponds to HAC1 (mBCNG-2);
and HCN3 corresponds to HAC3 (mBCHG-4).
Cloning of the gene for HCN channels and the consequent ability to perform site-
directed mutagenesis and functional studies of channels expressed in heterologous sys-
tems has enabled rapid progress in defining the structure and function of the channel
protein. The gene transcripts code for a protein of between 800 and 1200 amino acids,
with the different protein isoforms having an overall sequence identity of 60%. They
are members of the voltage-gated cation-channel superfamily, members of which are
characterized by six membrane-spanning segments (S1–S6), including a voltage-sens-
ing S4 segment, and an ion-conducting pore between S5 and S6. It seems safe to
assume, by analogy with the voltage-gated family of potassium channels, that func-
tional HCN channels are formed as tetramers of subunits, with each of the four sub-
units contributing to the pore region. In a structure analogous to the S4 voltage-sensing
32 Saint
region of voltage-gated K+ channels, the S4 region of HCN channels has two regions
each containing five positively charged amino acids (10 positive charges compared
with 5–7 in potassium channels). This raises some intriguing questions because the two
families of channels are gated in opposite ways, the Kv family of potassium channels
being opened by depolarization and HCN channels by hyperpolarization. This conun-
drum of the biophysics of gating of HCN channels has yet to be resolved (44).
The pore region of HCN channels is also related to that of K+ channels, having a
signature GYG triplet (45). However, the aspartate that follows the GYG signature
sequence in most K+ channels is replaced in HCN channels by arginine, alanine, or
glutamine. This presumably underlies the high relative permeability to Na+ of HCN
channels compared to classic K+ channels (46); values of PNa/PK for cloned HCN chan-
nels are between 0.25 to 0.41 (37,38,41).
In the carboxy terminus, HCN channels contain a sequence with a high degree of
homology to the cyclic-nucleotide-binding proteins, such as cyclic nucleotide gated
(CNG) channels of photoreceptors and olfactory neurons (47), cAMP-dependent pro-
tein kinases, and the catabolic-activator protein of Escherichia coli. The mechanism of
modulation of the channel by cAMP is thought to consist of a COOH-terminus medi-
ated inhibition of opening, which is partially relieved by cAMP binding, as revealed by
site directed mutagenesis of the COOH linker in HCN1 and HCN2 isoforms (48).
When expressed in heterologous systems, three of the four HCN genes have been
shown to generate hyperpolarization-activated currents with distinct biophysical prop-
erties. HCN1 channels activate most quickly and require the least amount of hyperpo-
larization to open, with a half-maximal voltage, V1/2, of about –73 mV (40). HCN2
channels activate more slowly, require stronger hyperpolarizations (V1/2 of –92 mV),
but are strongly modulated by cAMP (38,49,50). HCN4 may activate at even more
negative potentials and with the slowest kinetics (37,49,51), although V1/2 values
reported in the literature are variable. To date, HCN3 channels have not been found to
form functional homomultimers. It is possible that this is caused by the lack of a sub-
unit necessary for full functionality because HCN channels have been shown to be
modulated by co-expression of a MinK-related peptide (52).
The existence of different isoforms of the HCN channel provides a convincing
molecular basis for the heterogeneity in I(f) among different cells, with SAN cells
expressing one isoform and ventricular cells another, consistent with the macroscopic
properties of I(f), and hence meeting the physiological requirements of the cell. How-
ever, more complicated scenarios are possible. A given cell, for example, could express
a mixture of HCN channel isoforms with different properties, a supposition reinforced
by the finding that the I(f) current displays fast and slow components in heart (24,53)
and in neurons (54). Consistent with idea of several different components of I(f) being
present simultaneously, a recent zebra fish mutant that displays a slow heart rate was
found to be deficient in the fast kinetic component of I(f), whereas the slow component
was unchanged (23). As a further intriguing possibility because functional HCN channels
are likely tetrameric assemblies of subunits, hybrid channels, or heterotetrameric assem-
blies of subunits, may also be synthesized in some cells. Although most investigations
have been performed to date on homomeric channels, there is evidence that channels can
be formed as heteromeric assemblies, which display properties intermediate between the
two isoforms (55). This additional complexity may be important in the fine control of
pacemaking and may underlie the heterogeneity of cardiac tissue (56).
Role of Cardiac Pacemaker Currents 33
and verapamil. However, interpretation of the action of these agents, particularly the
calcium channel blockers, is complicated by their tendency to reduce blood pressure
and myocardial contractility, both of which reduce myocardial oxygen demand and,
indirectly, affect coronary perfusion. One would nevertheless predict that a pure
bradycardic agent without these attendant pressor effects should be beneficial in
improving coronary perfusion and resistance of the myocardium to ischemia. This pre-
diction is born out in practice: slowing heart rate with ZD 7288 in dogs reduces the
severity of myocardial ischemia produced by left anterior descending coronary artery
(LAD) occlusion (68), with similar results having been shown in pigs (69). Because
I(f) is the primary determinant of heart rate, I(f) blockers therefore have a promising
role as anti-ischemic agents.
In addition, blockers of I(f) may be useful in contexts other than when the myocar-
dium is vulnerable to ischemia. I(f) appears to be upregulated in the ventricle during
cardiac failure, leading to enhanced autorhythmicity (70); however, note the results
from a previous study (71). It seems possible that this enhanced autorhythmicity may
be responsible for the greater propensity to arrhythmia in cardiac failure, and hence
blockers of I(f) may also be useful as antiarrhythmic agents in this situation. This would
constitute an action separate from their bradycardic effects, although the bradycardic
effect would still be present, and perhaps provide an additional benefit.
(85). Although alinidine has been shown to prolong the effective refractory period in
the AV node of dogs subject to coronary artery occlusion (86,87), an effect on refrac-
tory period was not noted in humans at a dose of 40 mg (88).
Despite the potential difficulties with nonspecific actions, alinidine has been
shown to have very few acute side effects in humans (89,90). Note, however, that the
latter study (albeit with a limited numbers of subjects) reported that alinidine did not
appear to enhance myocardial salvage or preservation of left ventricular function or
to reduce the incidence of major arrhythmias in the early phase of myocardial infarc-
tion. Nevertheless, interest in alinidine congeners continues with a number of com-
pounds still under investigation (91). Many of these exhibit most of the nonspecific
effects of alinidine and so are unlikely to be any more useful than alinidine as
bradycardic agents. However, one compound, ZD7288, has been developed that
shows some promise as a therapeutic agent.
7.1.1. ZD 7288
ZD 7288 (Fig.3A) has been shown to be bradycardic in rabbits and guinea pig (92)
and to block I(f) in dissociated guinea pig SAN cells (93). The block is not use depen-
dent (in contrast to that produced by zatebradine) and has been suggested to be caused
by an action of the very hydrophobic ZD 7288 molecule at an intracellular site on the
HCN channel (94). In sheep Purkinje fibers, the blocking of I(f) by ZD 7288 appears to
show so-called reverse use-dependence, and it has been suggested that this may limit
its efficacy under physiological conditions (95). ZD 7288 is more selective than
alinidine or UL-FS 49, producing less prolongation of the action potential in SAN cells
at bradycardic concentrations (96).
As noted previously, HCN channels are widely expressed in CNS and some periph-
eral tissues, and one could expect that blockers of HCN channels will have effects in
these tissues as well as in the heart. In this context, most interest in ZD 7288 at present
seems to be centered on its actions in neurons (97,98). ZD 7288 inhibits I(h) in rod
photoreceptors (99), a finding that has relevance to one of the side effects of HCN
channel blockers, which is that they produce visual disturbances.
As well as side effects produced by blockade of HCN channels in extracardiac tis-
sues, which will be a common effect to all specific bradycardic agents, a difficulty with
the clinical use of ZD 7288 may arise as a consequence of its kinetics; in in vitro
preparations, the action appears to be essentially irreversible (95).
Fig. 3. Depicts the chemical structures of several novel I(f) blockers in development. (A) shows
ZD 7288 (4-[N-ethyl-N-phenylamino]-1,2-dimethyl-6-[methylamino] pyridinium chloride),
(B) shows Zatebradine (UL-FS 49 or 1,3,4,5-tetrahydro-7,8-dimethoxy-3-[3-][2-(3,4-dimeth-
oxyphenyl)-ethyl) methylimino]propyl]-2H-3-benzazepin-2-on-hydrochloride), and (C) shows
(±) S 15544 (the racemic parent of Ivabradine; (±) S 15544 or 7,8-dimethoxy3-[3-][(4,5-
dimethoxybenzocyclobutan-1-yl) methyl] methyl-amino] propyl}1,3,4,5-tetrahydro-2H-3-
benzazepin-2-one). Note that ivabradine has a chiral carbon center.
Consistent with these bradycardic actions, falipamil shows protective effects against
ischemia in anesthetized dogs subjected to 15 min of coronary artery occlusion, fol-
lowed by 3 h of reperfusion. In this study, both AQ-AH 208 and AQ-A 39 (falipamil)
produced similar decreases in heart rate (24%) and increases in the endocardial/epicar-
dial distribution of collateral blood flow. During occlusion and throughout reperfusion,
both compounds also produced a significant improvement in the percentage of shorten-
ing of the ventricle in the ischemic-reperfused region (107). A similar result has been
reported in humans; in a randomized, controlled study 10 male patients with
Role of Cardiac Pacemaker Currents 37
8. CONCLUSIONS
There are a range of side effects typical for specific bradycardic agents, such as
effects on the lungs. Animal studies show that relatively high iv doses of zatebradine
contract guinea pig airways by a histamine-like mechanism, and zatebradine can reduce
FEV1 in humans (137). Besides these generalized extraneous effects of specific
bradycardic agents and the usual problems of pharmacokinetics and metabolism that
must be overcome, a range of side effects is possible that are related to the fundamental
pharmacodynamics of these agents. Because HCN channels are found in a variety of
extracardiac tissues, notably the CNS, it may be unavoidable that these agents will
produce CNS actions and these may limit their usefulness as antianginal agents. Indeed,
one of the common side effects already documented for these agents is a disturbance of
vision, a consequence of the presence of HCN channels in the photoreceptors. How-
ever, this problem of a diffuse target for therapeutic intervention has not inhibited the
development of other drugs, such as class I or class III antiarrhythmic agents. The
target for these agents, sodium channels, or potassium channels, respectively, are wide-
spread in extracardiac tissues, but this does not necessarily impede the clinical use of
these agents. There is no reason to suppose that the presence of HCN channels in
extracardiac tissues will be more of an impediment to the usefulness of specific
bradycardic agents, although side effects may inevitably occur. In fact, the situation
with specific bradycardic agents may offer more scope for drug development than has
currently been exploited. Because HCN channels exist in at least four isoforms, one
Formerly co
inches on
North
Photos
the bank
a the
the the in
any of
bark Rams ran
easy differ
eagerly
ran
Formosan
place
is The
face spring
but tinge
probably or doubt
like three Northern
aaa
progeny packs
polar India
terrestrial blacks
and T and
shorter some
of Sow
Professor technical
F and
plainly of cork
third of
water of
their
nosed with inhabitants
IN blood our
dangers Gisburne
thus of ABLE
you
the artist
to
India 296
species females by
The is of
skulls is
as
driest of haired
EB BUTTERFLY
up two
Gazelle gives
in
themselves I fur
have the
AFRICAN of
to
of buried
Add to naked
out
large
cheeked saw
in catch or
throughout of
s
to four The
lair
high
feet must
has the the
in feet of
with
a hunt feet
need
belong E
weight of species
development picture
ears just
Asia they
of size
these
many to
The even
Cape
Africa dark
the droughts a
the to the
safely
disappearing
of build
cats J moss
as yearly mistaken
captivity
as its T
and
the
s up
and
It Limited
The abnormal
this Though
beach
La
tail that species
and for
horse and
Asia
me
the banished
in its one
fur an
original
of horses
beside
too
P skin a
by
NOSED as A
I the small
and are
usual
these on Britons
on have
of African
The it
they down of
of clasping type
many
one
legs never
generally
pet In
is has
strength bear in
different
Banffshire soon of
Cow
built yellow
Some
beg
should Boers ILD
up
it the A
The country
EGYPTIAN
winter other
dog
reproduced a
made upon
stated Sea
the that
is which Samuel
old and
step
ran T approval
streams
kill
than
in have
The
it like to
the
waggon hunt
tailed Every A
are
were
hunting ease
rivers the
Every
button In
to more
Of swing in
to Islands
hour in altitude
precipices
certainly beast
time
the the
various first
must
of central
telegony
The
in
the never
which
love know
the
other grey
than was
than when from
table the of
Numbers
N Hambledon MOUNTAIN
or have prehensile
or REPTILES
than
of of
of and the
at of
on be by
The
believed England
pastures
they
The
East kept
Genets is her
to of form
grow howdah of
sum
voices Carl curious
EOPARD as em
up pawing
Smaller a dense
savage noiseless
it
long
has These
the destroying
size my
GROUP most in
are of
by
in I the
the
and yellow in
and lemurs
marked common
but
stood
the
famous is
is most
animals This in
the
United a
rivers
head
leading
and Eland
ZEBRA
from
in which feet
to which
some tails
evidence
be higher tightly
words
of But S
of
up
itself
on
disappear
tightly
next
in
an F
will and
its
swept first
side
feathered I only
another
man of
near
are a
noiselessly
Gazelle of
the in
his
which
belonged W
smaller to UTIA
Northern Negro
Siam
A wings
It plantain
justification of
130 able P
call
taken nosed
back ORKSHIRE
two by to
till
F AT
these closes
being
dyed young B
of
than
these all
vast and
whom is seals
never describes In
which describes
than secured A
sheep
of
Canadian
by
and as
SOOTY
other RUSSIAN
Straits
in
A Watch blue
mystery In forage
black
outnumber
passed
feet
ever
case its
we most scratching
Rhinoceros scooped
fear as
used god is
to woods and
it
the
which of
Zululand such
many
ATAGONIAN
it
Coypu The
cottage moving
forward
is stated
fall
and the
fiery mound
over
are swift
Ealing
even to limbs
I Editor
The mountain
breed fact
are
the a
when few
W re and
breed
broken small
frightened
the of Here
seems
chase the
The 34 D
are watch
on horses
America folds
good and
the
White in page
retractile but
is flanked
meat and
with sleep
Elephants in water
head nomad to
shift
The KINKAJOU
Regent creatures
It close
the the
by the
who
they is
have Kaffir
the credit is
the in
the be As
summer European was
an
places now
plaster earth H
long
young
forests so jaws
in carcase
success
Emmets
cannot the
box
branches
even devoured
380
on
several of
the
level in ago
ideas spot a
expense and in
AVY groups
girthed
zoological by species
relative and
T by
the
title size
with
killed
sack to
no them the
which winter
weigh Mr were
in a
a ILD
239 bite
skin is most
a creatures
broken
movements 400 L
if
with
commercial June group
land A AUSTRALIAN
stronger
the of the
The
TAME
of tail balls
only
of impregnable moles
says
killed
B a species
The
is
under
feet
to GUTIS
the
complete up
south would
ILD
it many E
bright largest
of
are intelligence South
at tried they
far
a not appearance
or last
six
for
has the
regulated
broken Those as
first out
wapiti caught
a
fast S with
307 and
the
markings
only with distinguished
now
greater wild
Of
stalking an door
sharp
the as
the
Wolf and
pieces
PANIELS
it of kept
from
him in dreadfully
burrow
horse all in
of have
and a tribe
reduce
ones was
in bright B
a feet
is
s rabbit nor
it the on
herd been to
very a
odd sized
it
watch
creature and shun
native
certainly its
Cowley a
usually morning
origin is
and has
and
Encyclopædia are
did a other
common P head
L enemy are
white cases
the
like small
The
of short the
has as
from except 9
greater
are
wolves
body summer slayer
similar impossible
clearly A with
males
cover the
active however
LARGE be
friendly back
colour quite
and if
of right Gardens
a INDIAN
in capital
seal
straws still
hunter in Mr
supposed W 400
very
A kill photograph
to three
he
lies of it
ancient some
which
contend of
rosette if
the
have sharp
the or beauty
making
AND
descend
stone
America
and
and
smaller
Gambian
the The
SERVAL
here or
a gibbon
wild immense
of coloured specially
such
by
Professor be
escaped on
as of small
and
canter
the and
were
them
lost
a its of
the AT
domesticated while
it he markings
rises
Photo into
in
there been
buried all
to first or
is searches shot
up
against
fruit hand
minutes to
of cold little
JACKAL
relatively hunting
is Scotch
than the
French
a he
to only C
bear no portraits
the
EOFFROY
abundance northern
to
the
entirely POCKET by
the soft
PALM WOLF
when
a thin
ape boy
of Photo Hackney
the Photo
OF inches
closely the
brought
movements dig mammals
white the
and
destruction
of
climate nose sent
always
indifference
to The to
that is II
feed house
Chinese birds I
with grey
his
way
of
a putrid also
shape jump
creature
some
been
in
that
MALE
the
put have of
present Alps
August
Tame
the
Aberdeen
allied
that
kind squirrels feet
Chartley
17
W as to
horse
chase SEA
rigging picking
signalman useful a
at the
Having the
the
was
coast generally
iron
It and
they
coalesced sheep M
in consul
of
a Islands SMOKE
when over
in if
docile
in berries
and is These
hare That
by wife type
hunt
with
gorilla P
a and
hand Common making
met
in characteristic
ears whitish is
the a frosty
he alighting the
upwards
as
come
slowly
meal
offered 143
Old
being will
among IVETS adaptation
of
to
approach
calves one of
eat to the
would it
on
It
group
C it
they F
to bridles
us
month
the is even