Choosing Faculty Mentors
&
Finding “Mentoring Communities”
for Academic Success
Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
MATC Scholars Program
March 26, 2021 - April 9, 2021
University of Nebraska-Lincoln
OUTLINE
• Introduction
• Learning Objectives
• Learning Outcomes
• Session Presentation
• Conclusion
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
• What is mentoring?
• Benefits of mentoring
• Identifying and selecting a mentor
• Expectations of mentors and mentees
• Understanding the social environment
• Understand the components of a mentor
community strategy
LEARNING OUTCOMES
• Understand how to select a mentor
• Gained an appreciation for faculty mentors
and advisors
• Learn about mentor expectations
• Know his/her responsibilities as a mentee
• Develop a mentor community strategy
The word mentor has a unique history. The word is
in fact the proper name of a person, Mentor.
The story of Mentor is found in Greek mythology’s
epic poem Odyssey. The Odyssey is a poem about
Odysseus, king of Ithaca, who led the Greek soldiers
during the Trojan War.
The story goes that Odysseus roamed the countryside
for 10 years after the war before reaching home.
However, before Odysseus went off to war he hired
Mentor and entrusted him with the education of his
son, Telemachus. Mentor became Telemachus's
teacher, counselor, and guide.
THE WORD MENTOR
MENTORING
Mentoring is an enabling, one-on-one relationship
that foster individual growth and development. It is
an integrated approach that brings together the
functions of coaching, advocacy, nurturing,
sponsoring, and tutoring.
What does “Faculty Mentor” mean to you?
MENTORING
Create a list of terms or phrases that define a
faculty mentor.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Mentors have the ability to assist graduate
students of color with adjustment to both the
academic and nonacademic aspects of graduate
education. There are several models of mentoring
programs at many universities throughout the
country.
The relationship involves an experienced individual
(mentor) who influences the behavior, habits,
performance and progress of a less experienced
person (protégé).
MENTORING
• What is an advisor?
• This person is typically assigned to you by the
department or graduate program.
• Advisors duties and responsibilities includes:
• Helps students select courses
• Direct Thesis or Dissertation
ADVISOR versus MENTOR
• Is an advisor also a mentor?
• Relationships with mentors tend to be deeper
and more personal. Many students maintain
contact with their mentors after graduate school
and mentors often are a source of information
and support as new graduates enter the world of
work.
ADVISOR versus MENTOR
Individuals in effective mentoring relationships
• Experience fewer adjustment problems;
• Advance at a faster pace;
• Are more productive; and
• Are more responsible for the choices they
make.
BENEFITS OF MENTORING
• Research literature shows that greater
success results from strong mentoring
relationships.
• Council of Graduate Schools survey of
doctoral recipients report that the
availability and quality of mentoring and
advising played a major role in their
ability to complete the degree. (2009)
MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA
10-Year STEM Doctoral Completions Rates
Study shows 54% of URM doctoral students who entered their STEM
programs at the participating institutions between May 1992 and April 2002
earned their doctorates within ten years.
MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA
Source: Council of Graduate Schools, 2009
• One of the most important influences to a
student’s pursuit of graduate education—if not
the most important—is having a faculty mentor
during a student’s undergraduate education.
This is especially relevant for students of color
who remain underrepresented in graduate
education (Kim, 2011; U.S. Department of
Education, 2014).
MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA
• Background
• Building the Relationship/Negotiating
Agreement
• Department Chair
• Minority Faculty Member
• Research Area
• Planning for Mentoring
• Developing Protégé /Maintaining Momentum
• Ending the Formal Relationship
IDENTIFYING A MENTOR
Characteristics of a Good Mentor
The 3P’s of Effective Mentoring
by
Howard G. Adams and Associates, Inc.
Effective mentoring provides protégés an EDGE:
• PROCESS – strategies (“how-to) for problem solving.
• PERMISSION – the okay to function; grants permission.
• PROTECTION – shields from outside attacks.
IDENTIFYING A MENTOR
Mentor’s Role
• Provide information and/or resources
• Give Advice
• Detail Expectations
• Share experiences and knowledge
• Develop an academic plan and goals
EXPECTATIONS OF MENTORS AND MENTEES
Protégé’s Role
• Must be proactive
• Express interest
• Demonstrate appreciation of mentor’s time and
support
• Committed to learning
• Receptive to being directed and learn from
experiences
EXPECTATIONS OF MENTORS AND MENTEES
Mentor of the Year 2019
University of Nevada-Reno Faculty Member
Wins National Faculty Mentor of the Year Award
By
Institute on Teaching and Mentoring
Dr. Kelly Cross
“Mentoring is a brain to pick, an ear to listen, and a push
in the right Direction.” ~John Crosby
Good mentorship consist of assessing, coaching,
demonstrating, teaching, interacting, and counseling. This
could lead to a protégé having a better understanding of the
following:
•Academic protocol
•Organizational norms
•Office politics
•Skills and competencies required
•Attributes and qualities to be successful
•Avenues for advancement
UNDERSTANDING THE SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT
Peer Mentoring
• What does this mean to you?
• Are there any benefits?
COMPONENT OF A MENTOR COMMUNITY STRATEGY
• Peer-mentoring program for new graduate students can
supplement the mentoring provided by faculty
• Builds community within the graduate program.
• Peer mentors selected from more advanced graduate
students should be trained at providing support to new
students in their graduate program.
• Peer mentors are often able to decipher the unwritten
rules of the institution or the dominant culture and can
be more effective than faculty in sharing survival skills.
COMPONENT OF A MENTOR COMMUNITY STRATEGY
Peer Mentoring
Mentoring
Skills in this area are easier to develop as a graduate
student than you think. Like teaching, mentoring
requires skills that emphasize support, respect,
constructive feedback, character and integrity. Mentors
help mentees clarify goals (career, learning,
educational) and carry out a plan to achieve those
goals. Mentors guide and direct, share insights and
knowledge, and show interest and enthusiasm in the
development of their mentees.
UNL Mentoring Handbook-
It is written for mentors and mentees.
A skillful mentor…
• Supports others.
• Encourages excellence.
• Is enthusiastic.
• Demonstrates respect and professionalism in all interactions.
• Employs effective listening skills.
• Builds constructive relationships characterized by mutual respect and
cooperation.
• Shows sensitivity to the needs of others.
• Is interested in sharing expertise.
• Uses good judgment.
• Resolves difficult or complicated problems.
• Thinks creatively.
• Holds both him/herself and the mentee accountable.
• Has an ongoing commitment to learning and development.
UNL Mentoring Handbook-
Support
• Encourage students to discuss their ideas; even those ideas students
might fear are naïve or "crazy."
• Work with students to set specific goals and measures of
accomplishment. For example, help students set reasonable writing
deadlines that ensure successful completion of a journal article or
research paper.
• Teach students to break large tasks into smaller ones to avoid being
overwhelmed by the nature of school/research work.
• Give students enough space to be creative. Do not rush in too quickly
with interpretations of data or solutions to problems. By doing this, you
prepare your trainees to work through projects independently, and you
benefit from their insights and creativity.
• Let students know it is okay to make mistakes. Remind them how much
we learn from our failures.
UNL Mentoring Handbook-
Respect
• Acknowledge the skills and experience students bring with them to the
classroom or the laboratory.
• Give students your full attention when talking with them. Minimize
interruptions during your meetings with them so they can experience
more personalized time.
• Develop a system for remembering previous conversations with a
student and review those notes prior to scheduled meetings.
• Tell students what you learn from them. This may help them realize
they are potential colleagues.
UNL Mentoring Handbook-
Constructive Feedback
• Provide students with forthright assessments of their work. Don’t
assume students know what you think about their work.
• Provide feedback on a student’s work in a timely manner; a delayed
response to their work can hinder their progress.
• If students fall behind in their work, don't automatically assume this
reflects a lack of commitment. Talk with them to learn what's going on.
Perhaps they're exhausted, are unclear about what they're supposed to
do next, or maybe dislike the project they're working on. Maybe they
feel overwhelmed, socially isolated, or are experiencing family
problems.
UNL Mentoring Handbook-
Character and Integrity
• Recognize that those new to research are still forming their
professional beliefs and habits. They'll be watching you, trying to
learn your way of doing things.
• Set high standards for yourself and your protégés. Offer a
supportive, yet disciplined, learning environment.
CONCLUSION
Source: http://www.grad.washington.edu/mentoring/
CONCLUSION
Mentoring Guides for Students
Source: http://www.grad.washington.edu/mentoring/
How to Get the Mentoring You Want: A Guide
for Graduate Students at a Diverse University
Source: http://www.rackham.umich.edu/downloads/publications/mentoring.pdf
CONCLUSION
• http://www.minoritypostdoc.org/
• Science Mentoring: Does Race Matter?
• Council of Graduate Schools
– http://www.cgsnet.org/
• Lesson Four – Mentoring Systems
• http://www.grad.washington.edu/mentoring/
• Includes Mentoring Resources
• Howard G. Adams and Associates
– https://howardgadamsasso.com/
REFERENCES
Slide design © 2009, Mid-America Transportation Center. All rights reserved.
Dr. Edgar R. Blevins
Professor
Southern University A & M College
Mechanical Engineering Department
359 Pinchback Engineering Hall
Baton Rouge, LA 70813
Edgar_Blevins@subr.edu
CREDITS

2021 Scholars Program: Dr. Edgar R. Blevins

  • 1.
    Choosing Faculty Mentors & Finding“Mentoring Communities” for Academic Success Dr. Edgar R. Blevins MATC Scholars Program March 26, 2021 - April 9, 2021 University of Nebraska-Lincoln
  • 2.
    OUTLINE • Introduction • LearningObjectives • Learning Outcomes • Session Presentation • Conclusion
  • 3.
    LEARNING OBJECTIVES • Whatis mentoring? • Benefits of mentoring • Identifying and selecting a mentor • Expectations of mentors and mentees • Understanding the social environment • Understand the components of a mentor community strategy
  • 4.
    LEARNING OUTCOMES • Understandhow to select a mentor • Gained an appreciation for faculty mentors and advisors • Learn about mentor expectations • Know his/her responsibilities as a mentee • Develop a mentor community strategy
  • 5.
    The word mentorhas a unique history. The word is in fact the proper name of a person, Mentor. The story of Mentor is found in Greek mythology’s epic poem Odyssey. The Odyssey is a poem about Odysseus, king of Ithaca, who led the Greek soldiers during the Trojan War. The story goes that Odysseus roamed the countryside for 10 years after the war before reaching home. However, before Odysseus went off to war he hired Mentor and entrusted him with the education of his son, Telemachus. Mentor became Telemachus's teacher, counselor, and guide. THE WORD MENTOR
  • 6.
    MENTORING Mentoring is anenabling, one-on-one relationship that foster individual growth and development. It is an integrated approach that brings together the functions of coaching, advocacy, nurturing, sponsoring, and tutoring.
  • 7.
    What does “FacultyMentor” mean to you? MENTORING Create a list of terms or phrases that define a faculty mentor. 1. 2. 3. 4.
  • 8.
    Mentors have theability to assist graduate students of color with adjustment to both the academic and nonacademic aspects of graduate education. There are several models of mentoring programs at many universities throughout the country. The relationship involves an experienced individual (mentor) who influences the behavior, habits, performance and progress of a less experienced person (protégé). MENTORING
  • 9.
    • What isan advisor? • This person is typically assigned to you by the department or graduate program. • Advisors duties and responsibilities includes: • Helps students select courses • Direct Thesis or Dissertation ADVISOR versus MENTOR
  • 10.
    • Is anadvisor also a mentor? • Relationships with mentors tend to be deeper and more personal. Many students maintain contact with their mentors after graduate school and mentors often are a source of information and support as new graduates enter the world of work. ADVISOR versus MENTOR
  • 11.
    Individuals in effectivementoring relationships • Experience fewer adjustment problems; • Advance at a faster pace; • Are more productive; and • Are more responsible for the choices they make. BENEFITS OF MENTORING
  • 12.
    • Research literatureshows that greater success results from strong mentoring relationships. • Council of Graduate Schools survey of doctoral recipients report that the availability and quality of mentoring and advising played a major role in their ability to complete the degree. (2009) MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA
  • 13.
    10-Year STEM DoctoralCompletions Rates Study shows 54% of URM doctoral students who entered their STEM programs at the participating institutions between May 1992 and April 2002 earned their doctorates within ten years. MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA Source: Council of Graduate Schools, 2009
  • 14.
    • One ofthe most important influences to a student’s pursuit of graduate education—if not the most important—is having a faculty mentor during a student’s undergraduate education. This is especially relevant for students of color who remain underrepresented in graduate education (Kim, 2011; U.S. Department of Education, 2014). MENTORING AND ACADEMIC/CAREER SUCCESS DATA
  • 15.
    • Background • Buildingthe Relationship/Negotiating Agreement • Department Chair • Minority Faculty Member • Research Area • Planning for Mentoring • Developing Protégé /Maintaining Momentum • Ending the Formal Relationship IDENTIFYING A MENTOR
  • 16.
    Characteristics of aGood Mentor The 3P’s of Effective Mentoring by Howard G. Adams and Associates, Inc. Effective mentoring provides protégés an EDGE: • PROCESS – strategies (“how-to) for problem solving. • PERMISSION – the okay to function; grants permission. • PROTECTION – shields from outside attacks. IDENTIFYING A MENTOR
  • 17.
    Mentor’s Role • Provideinformation and/or resources • Give Advice • Detail Expectations • Share experiences and knowledge • Develop an academic plan and goals EXPECTATIONS OF MENTORS AND MENTEES
  • 18.
    Protégé’s Role • Mustbe proactive • Express interest • Demonstrate appreciation of mentor’s time and support • Committed to learning • Receptive to being directed and learn from experiences EXPECTATIONS OF MENTORS AND MENTEES
  • 19.
    Mentor of theYear 2019 University of Nevada-Reno Faculty Member Wins National Faculty Mentor of the Year Award By Institute on Teaching and Mentoring Dr. Kelly Cross “Mentoring is a brain to pick, an ear to listen, and a push in the right Direction.” ~John Crosby
  • 20.
    Good mentorship consistof assessing, coaching, demonstrating, teaching, interacting, and counseling. This could lead to a protégé having a better understanding of the following: •Academic protocol •Organizational norms •Office politics •Skills and competencies required •Attributes and qualities to be successful •Avenues for advancement UNDERSTANDING THE SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT
  • 21.
    Peer Mentoring • Whatdoes this mean to you? • Are there any benefits? COMPONENT OF A MENTOR COMMUNITY STRATEGY
  • 22.
    • Peer-mentoring programfor new graduate students can supplement the mentoring provided by faculty • Builds community within the graduate program. • Peer mentors selected from more advanced graduate students should be trained at providing support to new students in their graduate program. • Peer mentors are often able to decipher the unwritten rules of the institution or the dominant culture and can be more effective than faculty in sharing survival skills. COMPONENT OF A MENTOR COMMUNITY STRATEGY Peer Mentoring
  • 23.
    Mentoring Skills in thisarea are easier to develop as a graduate student than you think. Like teaching, mentoring requires skills that emphasize support, respect, constructive feedback, character and integrity. Mentors help mentees clarify goals (career, learning, educational) and carry out a plan to achieve those goals. Mentors guide and direct, share insights and knowledge, and show interest and enthusiasm in the development of their mentees.
  • 24.
    UNL Mentoring Handbook- Itis written for mentors and mentees. A skillful mentor… • Supports others. • Encourages excellence. • Is enthusiastic. • Demonstrates respect and professionalism in all interactions. • Employs effective listening skills. • Builds constructive relationships characterized by mutual respect and cooperation. • Shows sensitivity to the needs of others. • Is interested in sharing expertise. • Uses good judgment. • Resolves difficult or complicated problems. • Thinks creatively. • Holds both him/herself and the mentee accountable. • Has an ongoing commitment to learning and development.
  • 25.
    UNL Mentoring Handbook- Support •Encourage students to discuss their ideas; even those ideas students might fear are naïve or "crazy." • Work with students to set specific goals and measures of accomplishment. For example, help students set reasonable writing deadlines that ensure successful completion of a journal article or research paper. • Teach students to break large tasks into smaller ones to avoid being overwhelmed by the nature of school/research work. • Give students enough space to be creative. Do not rush in too quickly with interpretations of data or solutions to problems. By doing this, you prepare your trainees to work through projects independently, and you benefit from their insights and creativity. • Let students know it is okay to make mistakes. Remind them how much we learn from our failures.
  • 26.
    UNL Mentoring Handbook- Respect •Acknowledge the skills and experience students bring with them to the classroom or the laboratory. • Give students your full attention when talking with them. Minimize interruptions during your meetings with them so they can experience more personalized time. • Develop a system for remembering previous conversations with a student and review those notes prior to scheduled meetings. • Tell students what you learn from them. This may help them realize they are potential colleagues.
  • 27.
    UNL Mentoring Handbook- ConstructiveFeedback • Provide students with forthright assessments of their work. Don’t assume students know what you think about their work. • Provide feedback on a student’s work in a timely manner; a delayed response to their work can hinder their progress. • If students fall behind in their work, don't automatically assume this reflects a lack of commitment. Talk with them to learn what's going on. Perhaps they're exhausted, are unclear about what they're supposed to do next, or maybe dislike the project they're working on. Maybe they feel overwhelmed, socially isolated, or are experiencing family problems.
  • 28.
    UNL Mentoring Handbook- Characterand Integrity • Recognize that those new to research are still forming their professional beliefs and habits. They'll be watching you, trying to learn your way of doing things. • Set high standards for yourself and your protégés. Offer a supportive, yet disciplined, learning environment.
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
    Mentoring Guides forStudents Source: http://www.grad.washington.edu/mentoring/
  • 32.
    How to Getthe Mentoring You Want: A Guide for Graduate Students at a Diverse University Source: http://www.rackham.umich.edu/downloads/publications/mentoring.pdf
  • 33.
  • 34.
    • http://www.minoritypostdoc.org/ • ScienceMentoring: Does Race Matter? • Council of Graduate Schools – http://www.cgsnet.org/ • Lesson Four – Mentoring Systems • http://www.grad.washington.edu/mentoring/ • Includes Mentoring Resources • Howard G. Adams and Associates – https://howardgadamsasso.com/ REFERENCES
  • 35.
    Slide design ©2009, Mid-America Transportation Center. All rights reserved. Dr. Edgar R. Blevins Professor Southern University A & M College Mechanical Engineering Department 359 Pinchback Engineering Hall Baton Rouge, LA 70813 [email protected] CREDITS