Legal Aspects in Nursing
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 1
2
In law a man is guilty when he
violates the rights of others. In
ethics he is guilty if he only thinks
of doing so.
-Immanuel Kant
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta
Medico-legal Issues are those in which victim who
are seeking medical help but are related to legal
issues.
Medico-legal is something that involves both
medical and legal aspects.
Medico Legal Issues
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 3
TERMINOLOGIES
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 4
BILL
‱ Drafts or temporary outline of what the act will be.
‱ VIDEYAK in Nepali
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 5
‱ A written document which has been formally passed
by Government.
‱ Ain In Nepali
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 6
LAW
‱ Defined as the sum total of rules and regulations by
which a society is governed. As such, law is created
by people and exists to regulate all persons.
‱ Kanun
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 7
Constitution
‱ It is a system of laws and principles according to which a
state or other organization is governed.
‱ It indicates how the government is created and given
authority.
‱ It states the principles and provisions for establishing
specific laws i.e. constitutional laws.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 8
‱It involves all those cases where there is involvement of
law enforcement agencies like police, lawyer and court
of law besides the health care providers including nurse
to provide treatment and justice to victim and
punishment to the culprit.
Cont.
.Medico Legal Issues
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 9
‱Legal event generally occur already out side the hospital
area.
‱Victim will come to hospital for the purpose of
investigation and treatment.
‱ They should provide special attention while caring and
documentation.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 10
Laws and Acts applicable in nursing practice
‱ Nepal Health Service Act 2053 with second amendment in 2058
‱ Muluki Ain (Civil Code)
‱ Drugs Administration Act
‱ Nepal Nursing Council Act
‱ ICN & NAN – code for Nurses
‱ Consumers Protection Act
‱ Abortion Law
‱ Organ Transplant Act
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 11
1.Deliberate self harm
2.Accidents
3.Criminal cases
Common Medico Legal cases
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 12
Deliberate self harm
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 13
Accidents
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 14
Criminal cases
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 15
1. All cases of injuries.
2. All cases of burn.
3. Alleged cases of assault.
4. All cases of suspected or evident of poisoning or intoxication.
5. Case referred from court.
6. Victims of Animal ferocity
6. Suspected or evident criminal abortion.
7. Unconscious or comatose where the cause is not natural or clear.
8. Brought dead/ dead on arrival/ sudden unexpected death
9. Cases of suspected self-inflicted injuries or attempted suicides.
Common Medico Legal Cases in Emergency
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 16
Common Medico Legal cases in BPKIHS
6
98
55
9
7
4
25
25
Rape RTA Physical Assault Fall injury Hanging Burn Injury Poisioning 0thers
17
1. Rape cases- 5-7 years of imprisonment.????
2. Attempt to rape- 2-3 years of imprisonment.???
3. Murder- 10-12 years of imprisonment.???
4. Attempt to murder- 5-8 years of imprisonment.
5. Accident- if one possess driving license – 35 days of imprisonment, if
not- 11 years of imprisonment.
LEGAL PROVISION IN NEPAL
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 18
TERMINOLOGIES
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 19
A legal wrong committed against a person, his/her
rights or property, intentionally or willfully committed
without just cause.
The person who commits a tort is liable for damage in
civil.
TORT
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 20
Unintentional
‱Negligence:
‱Malpractice
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 21
Omitting an action expected of a sensible person
in a particular circumstances is considered
negligence.
Negligence
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 22
Failure to maintain accepted ethical standard.
 Any unreasonable lack of skills in professional
duties or illegal or immoral conduct that result in
injury. E.g.: Untrained nurse conducting
abortion.
Malpractice
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 23
1. Assault
2. Battery
3. Crime
4. Defamation libel
5. Defamation slander
6. Crime
7. Euthanasia
8. Invasion of privacy
Intentional Tort
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 24
Assault: Assault occurs when a person puts another
person in fear of harm or offensive contact. The victim
fears and believes that harm will be caused as a result
of threat.
Battery: An intentional touching of another’s body
without other’s consent.
Cont.
Intentional Tort.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 25
Defamation slander: Something untrue was said to ruin
the reputation of a person.
Defamation liable: Something untrue was written to
ruin the reputation of a person.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 26
Invasion of privacy:
It is the release of a patient’s medical information to an
unauthorized person such as a member of press, the
patients employer, or the patient’s family.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 27
Provides a frame work for establishing which nursing
actions in the care of client are legal.
Differentiates the nurse’s responsibility from those of
other health professionals.
FUNCTION OF LAW (public and civil) IN NURSING
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 28
Establish the boundaries of independent nursing
actions.
Assists in maintaining a standard of nursing practice by
making nurses accountable under the law.
Cont.
.Function of Law in Nursing
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 29
1. Overlooked sponges, instruments and needles during surgery.
2. Burn with hot water bag.
3. Fall from bed.
4. Assault/ battery.
5. Failure to report and negligence.
6. Failure in close monitoring such as B.P., FHS.
7. Forced to do abortion.
8. Exchange of new born babies. (tags, m/f).
9. Handing over of dead body without postmortem.
10. Discharging MLC without informing police.
SOME LEGAL ISSUE IN NURSING PRACTICE
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 30
11. Failure to maintain
records of MLC.
12. Poor recording and
reporting ( GCS, DEATH).
13. Identification of patient
and parts.
14. Loss of client property.
15. Medication error or
wrong medication
1. Overflow of patients.
2. Poor information system
3. Poor lab report
4. Inadequate supplies
5. Poor security and inadequate knowledge of MLC.
REASON FOR LEGAL PROBLEMS
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 31
LEGAL SAFEGUARD IN NURSING PRACTICE
1.Informed consent
2. Communication
3. Competence in practice
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 32
LEGAL SAFEGUARD


4. Licensure
5. Patient education
6. Executing physician’s order
7. Documentation
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 33
LEGAL SAFEGUARD


8. Professional liability insurance
9. Good Samaritan law
10. Adequate staffing
11. Patient’s bill of rights
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 34
LEGAL SAFEGUARD


12. Licensure
13. Good rapport
14. Standards of care
15. Standing order
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 35
LEGAL SAFEGUARD


16. Don’t accept gifts
17. Don’t give legal advice
1.Correct identity
1.Maintenance of drugs
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 36
LEGAL PROCEEDING FOR MLC CASES IN BPKIHS
1. Registration in MLC record book as well as in admission book.
2. Put stamp of MLC in the document
3. Injury form filled in ER
4. Inform to the police.
5. Maintain confidentiality
6. Collection of samples.
7. 2-3 reports collected.
8. After forensic examination, report collected and sent to court.
9. Identified as accident or intention.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 37
‱ 10. If accident, no further
proceeding.
‱ 11. If intention, proceeding as per
the law.
‱ 12. Sent for postmortem if dead.
‱ 13. Inform police during discharge
FOR ABANDONED OR LAWARIS DEAD BODY
1. Dead body is kept in mortuary for 35 days
2. In that period police in that area is reported and information
disseminated via media
3. If no one claims for that duration, the body is handed over to
municipality office for funeral.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 38
IN CASE OF DISCHARGE OF MLC CASES
1. The culprit as well as victim may be MLC cases.
2. In culprit – taken under the control of the police and submitted to
district police for further proceeding.
3. If victim- victim report of events taken.
4. MLC cases if dead- sent for post mortem
5. All MLC cases registered in MLC book
6. Accidental cases is open for 2 years for investigation then the case is
closed.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 39
RECENT TRENDS IN MEDICO-LEGAL ASPECTS
1. Age estimation.
2. Dental identification.
3. Bite marks.
4. Photography
5. DNA analysis :- hair/ blood.
6. Crime evidence.
7. Forensic medicine/nursing.
8. Finger prints.
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 40
Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 41

3. Legal Aspects in Nursing.pdf

  • 1.
    Legal Aspects inNursing Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 1
  • 2.
    2 In law aman is guilty when he violates the rights of others. In ethics he is guilty if he only thinks of doing so. -Immanuel Kant Prof.Dr. RS Mehta
  • 3.
    Medico-legal Issues arethose in which victim who are seeking medical help but are related to legal issues. Medico-legal is something that involves both medical and legal aspects. Medico Legal Issues Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 3
  • 4.
  • 5.
    BILL ‱ Drafts ortemporary outline of what the act will be. ‱ VIDEYAK in Nepali Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 5
  • 6.
    ‱ A writtendocument which has been formally passed by Government. ‱ Ain In Nepali Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 6
  • 7.
    LAW ‱ Defined asthe sum total of rules and regulations by which a society is governed. As such, law is created by people and exists to regulate all persons. ‱ Kanun Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 7
  • 8.
    Constitution ‱ It isa system of laws and principles according to which a state or other organization is governed. ‱ It indicates how the government is created and given authority. ‱ It states the principles and provisions for establishing specific laws i.e. constitutional laws. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 8
  • 9.
    ‱It involves allthose cases where there is involvement of law enforcement agencies like police, lawyer and court of law besides the health care providers including nurse to provide treatment and justice to victim and punishment to the culprit. Cont.
.Medico Legal Issues Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 9
  • 10.
    ‱Legal event generallyoccur already out side the hospital area. ‱Victim will come to hospital for the purpose of investigation and treatment. ‱ They should provide special attention while caring and documentation. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 10
  • 11.
    Laws and Actsapplicable in nursing practice ‱ Nepal Health Service Act 2053 with second amendment in 2058 ‱ Muluki Ain (Civil Code) ‱ Drugs Administration Act ‱ Nepal Nursing Council Act ‱ ICN & NAN – code for Nurses ‱ Consumers Protection Act ‱ Abortion Law ‱ Organ Transplant Act Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 11
  • 12.
    1.Deliberate self harm 2.Accidents 3.Criminalcases Common Medico Legal cases Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 12
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
    1. All casesof injuries. 2. All cases of burn. 3. Alleged cases of assault. 4. All cases of suspected or evident of poisoning or intoxication. 5. Case referred from court. 6. Victims of Animal ferocity 6. Suspected or evident criminal abortion. 7. Unconscious or comatose where the cause is not natural or clear. 8. Brought dead/ dead on arrival/ sudden unexpected death 9. Cases of suspected self-inflicted injuries or attempted suicides. Common Medico Legal Cases in Emergency Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 16
  • 17.
    Common Medico Legalcases in BPKIHS 6 98 55 9 7 4 25 25 Rape RTA Physical Assault Fall injury Hanging Burn Injury Poisioning 0thers 17
  • 18.
    1. Rape cases-5-7 years of imprisonment.???? 2. Attempt to rape- 2-3 years of imprisonment.??? 3. Murder- 10-12 years of imprisonment.??? 4. Attempt to murder- 5-8 years of imprisonment. 5. Accident- if one possess driving license – 35 days of imprisonment, if not- 11 years of imprisonment. LEGAL PROVISION IN NEPAL Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 18
  • 19.
  • 20.
    A legal wrongcommitted against a person, his/her rights or property, intentionally or willfully committed without just cause. The person who commits a tort is liable for damage in civil. TORT Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 20
  • 21.
  • 22.
    Omitting an actionexpected of a sensible person in a particular circumstances is considered negligence. Negligence Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 22
  • 23.
    Failure to maintainaccepted ethical standard.  Any unreasonable lack of skills in professional duties or illegal or immoral conduct that result in injury. E.g.: Untrained nurse conducting abortion. Malpractice Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 23
  • 24.
    1. Assault 2. Battery 3.Crime 4. Defamation libel 5. Defamation slander 6. Crime 7. Euthanasia 8. Invasion of privacy Intentional Tort Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 24
  • 25.
    Assault: Assault occurswhen a person puts another person in fear of harm or offensive contact. The victim fears and believes that harm will be caused as a result of threat. Battery: An intentional touching of another’s body without other’s consent. Cont.
Intentional Tort. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 25
  • 26.
    Defamation slander: Somethinguntrue was said to ruin the reputation of a person. Defamation liable: Something untrue was written to ruin the reputation of a person. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 26
  • 27.
    Invasion of privacy: Itis the release of a patient’s medical information to an unauthorized person such as a member of press, the patients employer, or the patient’s family. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 27
  • 28.
    Provides a framework for establishing which nursing actions in the care of client are legal. Differentiates the nurse’s responsibility from those of other health professionals. FUNCTION OF LAW (public and civil) IN NURSING Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 28
  • 29.
    Establish the boundariesof independent nursing actions. Assists in maintaining a standard of nursing practice by making nurses accountable under the law. Cont.
.Function of Law in Nursing Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 29
  • 30.
    1. Overlooked sponges,instruments and needles during surgery. 2. Burn with hot water bag. 3. Fall from bed. 4. Assault/ battery. 5. Failure to report and negligence. 6. Failure in close monitoring such as B.P., FHS. 7. Forced to do abortion. 8. Exchange of new born babies. (tags, m/f). 9. Handing over of dead body without postmortem. 10. Discharging MLC without informing police. SOME LEGAL ISSUE IN NURSING PRACTICE Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 30 11. Failure to maintain records of MLC. 12. Poor recording and reporting ( GCS, DEATH). 13. Identification of patient and parts. 14. Loss of client property. 15. Medication error or wrong medication
  • 31.
    1. Overflow ofpatients. 2. Poor information system 3. Poor lab report 4. Inadequate supplies 5. Poor security and inadequate knowledge of MLC. REASON FOR LEGAL PROBLEMS Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 31
  • 32.
    LEGAL SAFEGUARD INNURSING PRACTICE 1.Informed consent 2. Communication 3. Competence in practice Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 32
  • 33.
    LEGAL SAFEGUARD

 4. Licensure 5.Patient education 6. Executing physician’s order 7. Documentation Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 33
  • 34.
    LEGAL SAFEGUARD

 8. Professionalliability insurance 9. Good Samaritan law 10. Adequate staffing 11. Patient’s bill of rights Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 34
  • 35.
    LEGAL SAFEGUARD

 12. Licensure 13.Good rapport 14. Standards of care 15. Standing order Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 35
  • 36.
    LEGAL SAFEGUARD

 16. Don’taccept gifts 17. Don’t give legal advice 1.Correct identity 1.Maintenance of drugs Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 36
  • 37.
    LEGAL PROCEEDING FORMLC CASES IN BPKIHS 1. Registration in MLC record book as well as in admission book. 2. Put stamp of MLC in the document 3. Injury form filled in ER 4. Inform to the police. 5. Maintain confidentiality 6. Collection of samples. 7. 2-3 reports collected. 8. After forensic examination, report collected and sent to court. 9. Identified as accident or intention. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 37 ‱ 10. If accident, no further proceeding. ‱ 11. If intention, proceeding as per the law. ‱ 12. Sent for postmortem if dead. ‱ 13. Inform police during discharge
  • 38.
    FOR ABANDONED ORLAWARIS DEAD BODY 1. Dead body is kept in mortuary for 35 days 2. In that period police in that area is reported and information disseminated via media 3. If no one claims for that duration, the body is handed over to municipality office for funeral. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 38
  • 39.
    IN CASE OFDISCHARGE OF MLC CASES 1. The culprit as well as victim may be MLC cases. 2. In culprit – taken under the control of the police and submitted to district police for further proceeding. 3. If victim- victim report of events taken. 4. MLC cases if dead- sent for post mortem 5. All MLC cases registered in MLC book 6. Accidental cases is open for 2 years for investigation then the case is closed. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 39
  • 40.
    RECENT TRENDS INMEDICO-LEGAL ASPECTS 1. Age estimation. 2. Dental identification. 3. Bite marks. 4. Photography 5. DNA analysis :- hair/ blood. 6. Crime evidence. 7. Forensic medicine/nursing. 8. Finger prints. Prof.Dr. RS Mehta 40
  • 41.