4D Radiotherapy Paul Keall Virginia Commonwealth University
Outline Medical rationale Basic science and technology State-of-the-art Future needs, directions and opportunities Advice …
Medical rationale What is the purpose of your research?
What do we know? Where the ‘visible’ tumor is To within 1 cm (on day of imaging study) Where the microscopic tumor extends to To within 1 cm Where the patient’s skeleton is wrt the radiation beam To within 1 cm What the shape of the tumor is To within 1 cm Where the tumor is wrt the skeleton To within 2 cm
What can we do about it? Reduce the uncertainties Improved/functional imaging Ongoing commitment to education Daily 2D/3D imaging Monte Carlo dose calculation/optimization Intrafraction motion Develop methods to account for residual uncertainties Incorporate uncertainties into planning process Probabilistic planning Online planning
Why 4D? Chemo-response GI motion Inter-observer  differences Tumor growth Tumor shrinkage Tumor spread Reoxygenation Repair Repopulation Redistribution Vascular growth Weight loss Cardiac motion Hormone response Diet Bladder filling Rectal filling Intra-observer differences Skeletal motion Respiratory motion Weight gain Respiratory motion
Respiratory motion affects: All tumor sites in the thorax and abdomen Lung cancer alone: 173 770 new cases in 2004 (ACS) 160 440 deaths (28% of cancer deaths) 15% five-year survival Evidence of tumor dose response 50%/30 month LPFS at 85 Gy (Martel  et al ) Strong evidence of lung dose response (many 100+ patient studies)
Problems of respiratory motion in radiotherapy
The tumor moves with time
Distorted images, incorrect anatomical positions, volumes or shapes   Conventional   With gated imaging Keall  et al  Aust Phys  Eng Sci Med 2002 Tumor
Treatment Planning: Large margins are added to the clinical target volume Increases normal tissue dose and limits target dose PTV CTV Conventional  With gating CTV PTV
IMRT Delivery: Interplay between anatomy and MLC leaf motion leads to motion artifacts Dose Position Planned dose Delivered   dose
Basic science and technology What is the underlying scientific/technological basis of your research?
“ The explicit inclusion of the temporal changes in anatomy during the imaging, planning and delivery of radiotherapy”  What is 4D radiotherapy? 4D Radiotherapy Panel ASTRO 2003
The 4D radiotherapy process 4D Radiotherapy 4D CT Imaging 4D Treatment Planning 4D Treatment Delivery Acquisition of a sequence of CT image sets over consecutive phases of a breathing cycle The explicit inclusion of the temporal changes in anatomy during the imaging, planning and delivery of radiotherapy Designing treatment plans on CT image sets obtained for each phase of the breathing cycle   Continuous delivery of the 4D treatment plans throughout the breathing cycle
4D Radiotherapy I: 4D CT Imaging
4D CT imaging
4D CT images Vedam  et al  PMB  2003 48:45-62 8 respiratory phases Peak inhale Early inhale Mid inhale End inhale Peak exhale Early exhale Mid exhale Late exhale
 
4D Radiotherapy II: 4D Planning
4D Planning Flow Chart Acquire 4D CT Define anatomy Create/adjust treatment plan Evaluate dose distribution 1 4 3 2 Proceed to treatment 6 … Plan acceptable? No Yes Deformable  registration … Automated planning … Deformable  registration 5
4D PTVs
BEVs 3D BEV 4D BEV
3D (solid) vs 4D (dashed) DVHs
4D Radiotherapy III: 4D Delivery
4D radiotherapy delivery
MLC leaf motion  3D    4D Keall  et al  PMB  2001 46:1-10
MLC leaf motion  3D IMRT   4D IMRT
Tracking motion perpendicular and parallel to the MLC
Finite response time- need motion prediction
Respiratory motion causes problems during the imaging, planning and treatment stages of radiotherapy Several methods have been proposed to address respiratory motion 4D radiotherapy has some advantages over existing methods There are still many unanswered questions … 4D radiotherapy summary
State-of-the-art How does your research fit into the overall scheme of medical research?
Respiratory motion solutions Breath-hold techniques (ABC/DIBH) Uncomfortable for patients, limited applicability (MSKCC:  7/13 patients) Increases treatment time (MSKCC:  17 to 33 minutes for conventional RT) Respiratory gating Residual motion within  gating window Increases treatment time Baseline shift 4D Radiotherapy Hardware/Software  complexity
Future needs, directions and opportunities What is currently limiting your research or what change in direction do you anticipate in the future?
Limitations Ethics/IRB Length of grant review cycles Industry support We need them unless resource and time unlimited Why isn’t my project the highest priority? Distractions
Directions Incorporate recent scientific and technical developments  Greater scope More general More scientifically rigorous Integrate with concurrent internal and external programs
Opportunities Many problems to solve Many different ways to solve problems
NCI Roadmap A focus on the following initiatives will move the work of NCI through the process of discovery, development, and delivery toward the goal of eliminating suffering and death from cancer by 2015 …
Advice
1999 $4500 VCU faculty grant-in-aid 2001 $20 000 ACS Inst. Research Grant 2002 $1.5 million NCI grant 2003 $400 000 industrial grant 2003 Co-I $1 million NCI grant 2004 Consultant $1 million NCI grant 2004 Co-I STTR … How did you get started?
Why get a grant? Promotion Tenure Independence Invitations Staff Resources Travel Intangibles
What advice can you give? Write early Write often Work hard Work smart Think broadly Good luck
And get a great team! Ted Chung  Rohini George Sarang Joshi Vijay Kini Radhe Mohan Jeffrey Siebers Sastry Vedam Krishni  Wijesooriya Jeffrey Williamson ACS NIH MDACC MGH Philips Medical Systems Standard Imaging UNC Varian Medical Systems
Another great team!

More Related Content

PPTX
4D Scan and Respiratory Gating
PPTX
Best 3D printing presentation
PPTX
TIME DOSE & FRACTIONATION
PPTX
Esophageal cancer
PDF
Motion Management in Radiation Therapy
PDF
Dosimetry
PPTX
Glioblastoma vibhay
PPT
Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy
4D Scan and Respiratory Gating
Best 3D printing presentation
TIME DOSE & FRACTIONATION
Esophageal cancer
Motion Management in Radiation Therapy
Dosimetry
Glioblastoma vibhay
Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy

What's hot (20)

PPT
Beam Directed Radiotherapy - methods and principles
ODP
Helical Tomotherapy
PDF
Target volume definition
PPTX
PPTX
BASICS RADIOBIOLOGY FOR RADIOTHERAPY
PDF
Commissioning of Truebeam LINAC
PDF
planning systems in radiotherapy
PPTX
GAMMA KNIFE , X-KNIFE AND CYBERKNIFE
PPT
Treatment Planning Ii Patient Data, Corrections, And Set Up
PPTX
Electron beam therapy
PDF
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
PPTX
Total skin electron irradiation
PDF
Fast neutron beam therapy
PPT
RADIXACT X9 TOMOTHERAPY SYSTEM OVERVIEW
PPTX
MOTION MANAGEMENT IN RADIOTHERAPY
PPTX
Total body irradiation
PDF
Image guided adaptive radiotherapy
PPTX
Treatment verification and set up errors
Beam Directed Radiotherapy - methods and principles
Helical Tomotherapy
Target volume definition
BASICS RADIOBIOLOGY FOR RADIOTHERAPY
Commissioning of Truebeam LINAC
planning systems in radiotherapy
GAMMA KNIFE , X-KNIFE AND CYBERKNIFE
Treatment Planning Ii Patient Data, Corrections, And Set Up
Electron beam therapy
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
Total skin electron irradiation
Fast neutron beam therapy
RADIXACT X9 TOMOTHERAPY SYSTEM OVERVIEW
MOTION MANAGEMENT IN RADIOTHERAPY
Total body irradiation
Image guided adaptive radiotherapy
Treatment verification and set up errors
Ad

Similar to 4D Radiotherapy (20)

PPT
4 dcrt, FourDimensionalConventionalRadiationTreatment
PPTX
MOTION MANAGEMANT IN LUNG SBRT BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
PPTX
Implementing Change Using Multi-Disciplinary Teams (MDTs)
PPT
4 D Adaptive Radiotherapy & Tomotherapy
PPTX
Innovations conference 2014 dr john kipritidis can we use ventilation imagi...
PDF
Getting started at the national level from demonstration to spread
PPTX
MLS13 QI Workshop
PPTX
Motion management in Radiation Oncology - 2020
PPTX
ERAS and regional anesthesia at PGA 2015
PPTX
Implementation science tailored to precision prevention
PPTX
Technology Assessment, Outcomes Research and Economic Analyses
PPTX
Technology Assessment/Outcome & Cost-Effectiveness Analysis 2016
PPTX
NCRI poster SuPPORT 4 All 2015
PPTX
Evolving Role of Radiation Therapists & Concernment of Risk Management in Mod...
PPTX
Big sky perioperative medicine 2020
PPT
Ser talk dr.n. khandelwal
PDF
Advances in automatic tuberculosis detection in chest x ray images
PPTX
Dr. Davy Cheng
PDF
Primer in quality improvement in radiology department
PPTX
4-Dr.Kaleem_Rajput.pptx
4 dcrt, FourDimensionalConventionalRadiationTreatment
MOTION MANAGEMANT IN LUNG SBRT BY DR KANHU CHARAN PATRO
Implementing Change Using Multi-Disciplinary Teams (MDTs)
4 D Adaptive Radiotherapy & Tomotherapy
Innovations conference 2014 dr john kipritidis can we use ventilation imagi...
Getting started at the national level from demonstration to spread
MLS13 QI Workshop
Motion management in Radiation Oncology - 2020
ERAS and regional anesthesia at PGA 2015
Implementation science tailored to precision prevention
Technology Assessment, Outcomes Research and Economic Analyses
Technology Assessment/Outcome & Cost-Effectiveness Analysis 2016
NCRI poster SuPPORT 4 All 2015
Evolving Role of Radiation Therapists & Concernment of Risk Management in Mod...
Big sky perioperative medicine 2020
Ser talk dr.n. khandelwal
Advances in automatic tuberculosis detection in chest x ray images
Dr. Davy Cheng
Primer in quality improvement in radiology department
4-Dr.Kaleem_Rajput.pptx
Ad

More from fondas vakalis (20)

PPTX
Esophageal squamous Cancer-therapy-Vakalis
PPTX
radiotherapy-pancreatic cancer
PPTX
radiotherapy of bone metastases,Vakalis
PPT
sbrt for inoperable lung cancer
PPT
Spinal cord compression bhf aos study day mar 2014 final
PPTX
Vakalis breast radiotherapy
PPTX
Vakalis - RT for prostate cancer
PPT
Her2 positive metastatic breast ca
PPT
nonsquamous NSCLC
PPT
Advanced breast cancer
PPT
Second line therapy for nsclc
PPTX
Vegf in colorectal ca
PPTX
HER2 negative metastatic breast ca
PPTX
817731 slides
PPT
Radiobiology behind dose fractionation
PDF
2012-michael joiner-hypofractionation
PPTX
RECTAL CA - VAKALIS . X
PPTX
Vakalis - gastric ca radiotherapy
PPTX
Vakalis.X H&N CANCER
PPTX
Vakalis pancreas
Esophageal squamous Cancer-therapy-Vakalis
radiotherapy-pancreatic cancer
radiotherapy of bone metastases,Vakalis
sbrt for inoperable lung cancer
Spinal cord compression bhf aos study day mar 2014 final
Vakalis breast radiotherapy
Vakalis - RT for prostate cancer
Her2 positive metastatic breast ca
nonsquamous NSCLC
Advanced breast cancer
Second line therapy for nsclc
Vegf in colorectal ca
HER2 negative metastatic breast ca
817731 slides
Radiobiology behind dose fractionation
2012-michael joiner-hypofractionation
RECTAL CA - VAKALIS . X
Vakalis - gastric ca radiotherapy
Vakalis.X H&N CANCER
Vakalis pancreas

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
ACUTE PANCREATITIS combined.pptx.pptx in kids
PPTX
Gout, Systemic Lupus Erythematous, RA, AS.pptx
PPTX
This book is about some common childhood
PDF
periodontaldiseasesandtreatments-200626195738.pdf
PPTX
Bacteriology and purification of water supply
PPTX
INFLAMMATORY BOWEL DISEASE(U,CERATIVE COLITIS AND CHROHN'S DISEASE)
PPTX
Computed Tomography: Hardware and Instrumentation
PDF
Biochemistry And Nutrition For Bsc (Nursing).pdf
PPTX
Acute Abdomen and its management updates.pptx
DOCX
ORGAN SYSTEM DISORDERS Zoology Class Ass
PPTX
SAPIENT3.0 Medi-trivia Quiz (PRELIMS) | F.A.Q. 2025
PPTX
Geriatrics_(0).pptxxvvbbbbbbbnnnnnnnnnnk
PPTX
ANTI BIOTICS. SULPHONAMIDES,QUINOLONES.pptx
PPSX
Man & Medicine power point presentation for the first year MBBS students
PPTX
critical care nursing 12.pptxhhhhhhhhjhh
PPTX
Phamacology Presentation (Anti cance drugs).pptx
PPTX
Connective tissue disorder C1 lecture (1).pptx
PDF
Cranial nerve palsies (I-XII) - AMBOSS.pdf
PPTX
ENT-DISORDERS ( ent for nursing ). (1).p
PPT
First Aid Training for construction and other
ACUTE PANCREATITIS combined.pptx.pptx in kids
Gout, Systemic Lupus Erythematous, RA, AS.pptx
This book is about some common childhood
periodontaldiseasesandtreatments-200626195738.pdf
Bacteriology and purification of water supply
INFLAMMATORY BOWEL DISEASE(U,CERATIVE COLITIS AND CHROHN'S DISEASE)
Computed Tomography: Hardware and Instrumentation
Biochemistry And Nutrition For Bsc (Nursing).pdf
Acute Abdomen and its management updates.pptx
ORGAN SYSTEM DISORDERS Zoology Class Ass
SAPIENT3.0 Medi-trivia Quiz (PRELIMS) | F.A.Q. 2025
Geriatrics_(0).pptxxvvbbbbbbbnnnnnnnnnnk
ANTI BIOTICS. SULPHONAMIDES,QUINOLONES.pptx
Man & Medicine power point presentation for the first year MBBS students
critical care nursing 12.pptxhhhhhhhhjhh
Phamacology Presentation (Anti cance drugs).pptx
Connective tissue disorder C1 lecture (1).pptx
Cranial nerve palsies (I-XII) - AMBOSS.pdf
ENT-DISORDERS ( ent for nursing ). (1).p
First Aid Training for construction and other

4D Radiotherapy

  • 1. 4D Radiotherapy Paul Keall Virginia Commonwealth University
  • 2. Outline Medical rationale Basic science and technology State-of-the-art Future needs, directions and opportunities Advice …
  • 3. Medical rationale What is the purpose of your research?
  • 4. What do we know? Where the ‘visible’ tumor is To within 1 cm (on day of imaging study) Where the microscopic tumor extends to To within 1 cm Where the patient’s skeleton is wrt the radiation beam To within 1 cm What the shape of the tumor is To within 1 cm Where the tumor is wrt the skeleton To within 2 cm
  • 5. What can we do about it? Reduce the uncertainties Improved/functional imaging Ongoing commitment to education Daily 2D/3D imaging Monte Carlo dose calculation/optimization Intrafraction motion Develop methods to account for residual uncertainties Incorporate uncertainties into planning process Probabilistic planning Online planning
  • 6. Why 4D? Chemo-response GI motion Inter-observer differences Tumor growth Tumor shrinkage Tumor spread Reoxygenation Repair Repopulation Redistribution Vascular growth Weight loss Cardiac motion Hormone response Diet Bladder filling Rectal filling Intra-observer differences Skeletal motion Respiratory motion Weight gain Respiratory motion
  • 7. Respiratory motion affects: All tumor sites in the thorax and abdomen Lung cancer alone: 173 770 new cases in 2004 (ACS) 160 440 deaths (28% of cancer deaths) 15% five-year survival Evidence of tumor dose response 50%/30 month LPFS at 85 Gy (Martel et al ) Strong evidence of lung dose response (many 100+ patient studies)
  • 8. Problems of respiratory motion in radiotherapy
  • 9. The tumor moves with time
  • 10. Distorted images, incorrect anatomical positions, volumes or shapes Conventional With gated imaging Keall et al Aust Phys Eng Sci Med 2002 Tumor
  • 11. Treatment Planning: Large margins are added to the clinical target volume Increases normal tissue dose and limits target dose PTV CTV Conventional With gating CTV PTV
  • 12. IMRT Delivery: Interplay between anatomy and MLC leaf motion leads to motion artifacts Dose Position Planned dose Delivered dose
  • 13. Basic science and technology What is the underlying scientific/technological basis of your research?
  • 14. “ The explicit inclusion of the temporal changes in anatomy during the imaging, planning and delivery of radiotherapy” What is 4D radiotherapy? 4D Radiotherapy Panel ASTRO 2003
  • 15. The 4D radiotherapy process 4D Radiotherapy 4D CT Imaging 4D Treatment Planning 4D Treatment Delivery Acquisition of a sequence of CT image sets over consecutive phases of a breathing cycle The explicit inclusion of the temporal changes in anatomy during the imaging, planning and delivery of radiotherapy Designing treatment plans on CT image sets obtained for each phase of the breathing cycle Continuous delivery of the 4D treatment plans throughout the breathing cycle
  • 16. 4D Radiotherapy I: 4D CT Imaging
  • 18. 4D CT images Vedam et al PMB 2003 48:45-62 8 respiratory phases Peak inhale Early inhale Mid inhale End inhale Peak exhale Early exhale Mid exhale Late exhale
  • 19.  
  • 20. 4D Radiotherapy II: 4D Planning
  • 21. 4D Planning Flow Chart Acquire 4D CT Define anatomy Create/adjust treatment plan Evaluate dose distribution 1 4 3 2 Proceed to treatment 6 … Plan acceptable? No Yes Deformable registration … Automated planning … Deformable registration 5
  • 23. BEVs 3D BEV 4D BEV
  • 24. 3D (solid) vs 4D (dashed) DVHs
  • 25. 4D Radiotherapy III: 4D Delivery
  • 27. MLC leaf motion 3D 4D Keall et al PMB 2001 46:1-10
  • 28. MLC leaf motion 3D IMRT 4D IMRT
  • 29. Tracking motion perpendicular and parallel to the MLC
  • 30. Finite response time- need motion prediction
  • 31. Respiratory motion causes problems during the imaging, planning and treatment stages of radiotherapy Several methods have been proposed to address respiratory motion 4D radiotherapy has some advantages over existing methods There are still many unanswered questions … 4D radiotherapy summary
  • 32. State-of-the-art How does your research fit into the overall scheme of medical research?
  • 33. Respiratory motion solutions Breath-hold techniques (ABC/DIBH) Uncomfortable for patients, limited applicability (MSKCC: 7/13 patients) Increases treatment time (MSKCC: 17 to 33 minutes for conventional RT) Respiratory gating Residual motion within gating window Increases treatment time Baseline shift 4D Radiotherapy Hardware/Software complexity
  • 34. Future needs, directions and opportunities What is currently limiting your research or what change in direction do you anticipate in the future?
  • 35. Limitations Ethics/IRB Length of grant review cycles Industry support We need them unless resource and time unlimited Why isn’t my project the highest priority? Distractions
  • 36. Directions Incorporate recent scientific and technical developments Greater scope More general More scientifically rigorous Integrate with concurrent internal and external programs
  • 37. Opportunities Many problems to solve Many different ways to solve problems
  • 38. NCI Roadmap A focus on the following initiatives will move the work of NCI through the process of discovery, development, and delivery toward the goal of eliminating suffering and death from cancer by 2015 …
  • 40. 1999 $4500 VCU faculty grant-in-aid 2001 $20 000 ACS Inst. Research Grant 2002 $1.5 million NCI grant 2003 $400 000 industrial grant 2003 Co-I $1 million NCI grant 2004 Consultant $1 million NCI grant 2004 Co-I STTR … How did you get started?
  • 41. Why get a grant? Promotion Tenure Independence Invitations Staff Resources Travel Intangibles
  • 42. What advice can you give? Write early Write often Work hard Work smart Think broadly Good luck
  • 43. And get a great team! Ted Chung Rohini George Sarang Joshi Vijay Kini Radhe Mohan Jeffrey Siebers Sastry Vedam Krishni Wijesooriya Jeffrey Williamson ACS NIH MDACC MGH Philips Medical Systems Standard Imaging UNC Varian Medical Systems