Enhancing Motivation to Change in
the Substance-Using Adolescent:
…What the Non-Specialist Needs to Know
By Elizabeth Kotkin, MA, LMFT
Clinical Standards Coordinator
What Do You Do to
Relax?
What If Someone Said NO
• Took away all the ways
you relax.
• Told you that you have
to do something else.
• Told you that you have
to stop doing what you
like to do to relax, but
everyone you know can
continue.
• Just think about some of the family dynamics
that ‘our’ kids go ‘home’ to.
o Do their parents use? Where they born
addicted?
o Are they safe?
o Have they witnessed the un-imaginable?
o Are there any mental health or learning
disabilities?
o How early did they start using?
So Why Do Adolescents Use
Drugs?
• To try new things
• To be oppositional
• To be accepted
• To get away from
negative emotions or
feelings
• To try to be in
control
The Cycle Of Addiction
Tension
Inability
to
control
affective
state
Behavior
Drug &
Alcohol
Use
Return of
Negative
Feelings
Negative
Emotions
Move to coping
mechanism to
reduce tensionTemporary
Relief
Definitions
According to Gold and Miller (1994), recent research indicates that drugs
are addictive because they “reinforce drug-taking behavior…addiction
arises because prolonged use of the drug alters the basic neurochemistry of
the brain, leading to physiological and psychological changes…(which) in
turn result in continued and accelerating use of the drug.”
The American Psychiatric Association’s DSM-IV (APA, 1994) now
reflects this updated research-based definition of addictive disorder,
with core concepts including:
(1) Compulsion
(2) Loss of control
(3) Continued use despite negative consequences
What Do Adolescents Really
Want?
To be accepted
Motivational Interviewing
“Motivation can be understood not as something one has but rather
as something one does. It involves recognizing a problem, searching
for a way to change and then beginning and sticking with that
change strategy” Miller (1995)
o Motivational Interviewing is a way to minimize resistance,
resolve ambivalence and induce change.
o Readiness levels are accepted starting points for treatment rather
than reasons for elimination from treatment services.
Motivation: The Old Way
o Motivation is key to change and it is constantly in flux
o Motivation is influenced by social interaction, namely
the counselor’s style
o At all stages of change, ambivalence is seen as normal
and not pathological
o Confrontation is a goal, not a therapeutic technique
CONCEPTUALIZING MOTIVATIONAL
INTERVIEWING
Client Resistance
Involves feelings-actions-behaviors of an interpersonal nature
where there is a lack of collaboration
Stages Of Change
• Precontemplation stage
• Contemplation stage
• Preparation stage
• Action stage
• Maintenance
• Relapse
“There is a myth…that more is always better. More education,
more intense treatment, more confrontation will necessarily
produce more change. Nowhere is this less true than with
precontemplators. More intensity will often produce fewer results
with this group. So it is particularly important to use careful
motivational strategies, rather than mount high-intensity
programs…We cannot make precontemplators change, but we
can help motivate them to move to contemplation.” DiClemente,
(1991)
Stage 1: Precontemplation
• The client does not consider change. Seeks treatment due to
outside pressures such as family, job, etc., or due to legal
and/or medical concerns
Motivational Interviewing Tasks
Building Readiness
• A) Raise doubt about client’s belief that AOD use is
harmless
• B) Increase the client’s perception of risks and problems
with current behaviors
Clinical Interventions
• A) Establish rapport and trust and explore what brought
client into treatment
• B) Summarize: link the information together, especially
focusing on the client’s ambivalence. Educate about
possible links to AOD use
“Contemplation is often a very paradoxical stage of change…
Ambivalence is the archenemy of commitment and a prime
reason for chronic contemplation. Helping the client to work
through the ambivalence, to anticipate barriers, to decrease the
desirability of the problem behavior and to gain some increased
sense of self-efficacy to cope with this specific problem are all
stage-appropriate strategies.” DiClemente, (1991)
Stage 2: Contemplation
o The client is highly ambivalent about change. The client both
considers change and rejects it. The client will seesaw
between reasons for concern and justifications for continued
AOD use
Ambivalence
• A state of mind in which a person has coexisting but conflicting
feelings, thoughts, and actions about something
• The “I do but I don’t” dilemma
Motivational Interviewing Tasks:
Increasing Commitment
• A) Tip the decisional balance and strengthen self-efficacy
• B) Evoke from the client reasons to change and risks of not
changing
Clinical Interventions
• A) Show interest in how AOD use affects all areas of the
client’s life
• B) Reframe resentment: validate the client’s observations, but
offer a new interpretation of the data
Stage 3: Preparation
• The client is committed to and planning to make a change in the
near future but is still considering what to do
• Goal: Help client to get ready to make a change
• Elements of Change:…Ready….Willing….Able
Strategies For Preparation Stage
• Clarify goals & strategies
• Menu of options
• Offer advice
• Negotiate change plan
• Identify barriers
• Get social support
• Treatment expectations
• Publicize change plans
Stage 4: Action
• Client has decided to make a change
• Client has verbalized or demonstrated a firm commitment to change
• Efforts to modify behavior and/or environment are being taken
• Client demonstrates motivation and effort to achieve real change
• Client is involved in, and committed to, the change process
• Client is willing to follow suggested strategies and activities to change
Maintenance and Relapse
You Can Make A Difference

Motivational Interviewing with Adolescents

  • 1.
    Enhancing Motivation toChange in the Substance-Using Adolescent: …What the Non-Specialist Needs to Know By Elizabeth Kotkin, MA, LMFT Clinical Standards Coordinator
  • 2.
    What Do YouDo to Relax?
  • 7.
    What If SomeoneSaid NO • Took away all the ways you relax. • Told you that you have to do something else. • Told you that you have to stop doing what you like to do to relax, but everyone you know can continue.
  • 8.
    • Just thinkabout some of the family dynamics that ‘our’ kids go ‘home’ to. o Do their parents use? Where they born addicted? o Are they safe? o Have they witnessed the un-imaginable? o Are there any mental health or learning disabilities? o How early did they start using?
  • 9.
    So Why DoAdolescents Use Drugs? • To try new things • To be oppositional • To be accepted • To get away from negative emotions or feelings • To try to be in control
  • 10.
    The Cycle OfAddiction Tension Inability to control affective state Behavior Drug & Alcohol Use Return of Negative Feelings Negative Emotions Move to coping mechanism to reduce tensionTemporary Relief
  • 11.
    Definitions According to Goldand Miller (1994), recent research indicates that drugs are addictive because they “reinforce drug-taking behavior…addiction arises because prolonged use of the drug alters the basic neurochemistry of the brain, leading to physiological and psychological changes…(which) in turn result in continued and accelerating use of the drug.” The American Psychiatric Association’s DSM-IV (APA, 1994) now reflects this updated research-based definition of addictive disorder, with core concepts including: (1) Compulsion (2) Loss of control (3) Continued use despite negative consequences
  • 12.
    What Do AdolescentsReally Want? To be accepted
  • 13.
    Motivational Interviewing “Motivation canbe understood not as something one has but rather as something one does. It involves recognizing a problem, searching for a way to change and then beginning and sticking with that change strategy” Miller (1995) o Motivational Interviewing is a way to minimize resistance, resolve ambivalence and induce change. o Readiness levels are accepted starting points for treatment rather than reasons for elimination from treatment services.
  • 14.
  • 15.
    o Motivation iskey to change and it is constantly in flux o Motivation is influenced by social interaction, namely the counselor’s style o At all stages of change, ambivalence is seen as normal and not pathological o Confrontation is a goal, not a therapeutic technique CONCEPTUALIZING MOTIVATIONAL INTERVIEWING
  • 16.
    Client Resistance Involves feelings-actions-behaviorsof an interpersonal nature where there is a lack of collaboration
  • 17.
    Stages Of Change •Precontemplation stage • Contemplation stage • Preparation stage • Action stage • Maintenance • Relapse
  • 18.
    “There is amyth…that more is always better. More education, more intense treatment, more confrontation will necessarily produce more change. Nowhere is this less true than with precontemplators. More intensity will often produce fewer results with this group. So it is particularly important to use careful motivational strategies, rather than mount high-intensity programs…We cannot make precontemplators change, but we can help motivate them to move to contemplation.” DiClemente, (1991)
  • 19.
    Stage 1: Precontemplation •The client does not consider change. Seeks treatment due to outside pressures such as family, job, etc., or due to legal and/or medical concerns
  • 20.
    Motivational Interviewing Tasks BuildingReadiness • A) Raise doubt about client’s belief that AOD use is harmless • B) Increase the client’s perception of risks and problems with current behaviors
  • 21.
    Clinical Interventions • A)Establish rapport and trust and explore what brought client into treatment • B) Summarize: link the information together, especially focusing on the client’s ambivalence. Educate about possible links to AOD use
  • 22.
    “Contemplation is oftena very paradoxical stage of change… Ambivalence is the archenemy of commitment and a prime reason for chronic contemplation. Helping the client to work through the ambivalence, to anticipate barriers, to decrease the desirability of the problem behavior and to gain some increased sense of self-efficacy to cope with this specific problem are all stage-appropriate strategies.” DiClemente, (1991)
  • 23.
    Stage 2: Contemplation oThe client is highly ambivalent about change. The client both considers change and rejects it. The client will seesaw between reasons for concern and justifications for continued AOD use
  • 24.
    Ambivalence • A stateof mind in which a person has coexisting but conflicting feelings, thoughts, and actions about something • The “I do but I don’t” dilemma
  • 25.
    Motivational Interviewing Tasks: IncreasingCommitment • A) Tip the decisional balance and strengthen self-efficacy • B) Evoke from the client reasons to change and risks of not changing
  • 26.
    Clinical Interventions • A)Show interest in how AOD use affects all areas of the client’s life • B) Reframe resentment: validate the client’s observations, but offer a new interpretation of the data
  • 27.
    Stage 3: Preparation •The client is committed to and planning to make a change in the near future but is still considering what to do • Goal: Help client to get ready to make a change • Elements of Change:…Ready….Willing….Able
  • 28.
    Strategies For PreparationStage • Clarify goals & strategies • Menu of options • Offer advice • Negotiate change plan • Identify barriers • Get social support • Treatment expectations • Publicize change plans
  • 29.
    Stage 4: Action •Client has decided to make a change • Client has verbalized or demonstrated a firm commitment to change • Efforts to modify behavior and/or environment are being taken • Client demonstrates motivation and effort to achieve real change • Client is involved in, and committed to, the change process • Client is willing to follow suggested strategies and activities to change
  • 30.
  • 31.
    You Can MakeA Difference