A perspective  on  Institutional Quality Assurance
QUALITY ??
National Conference on Innovations in Higher Education Quality Quality Enhancement Quality Sustenance Quality Promotion Quality Culture Quality Awareness Quality Assurance How are they different ?
QUA LITY  ASSURANCE Quality Culture
The Quality Assurance Program Advance Sustain Attain
Higher Education - Today More people entering higher education than ever before Developed countries – working  to expand  higher education resources Developing countries – enhancing existing infrastructures to cope with demand The globalisation of education Growth in networks of higher and further education institutions across regions and countries Move towards mobile learning and remote learning Online learning increasingly at the heart of education Increasing competition Universities competing for staff, students (particularly from abroad), research funding, and partnerships Institutions investing heavily in ICT to support and maintain competitive position Increased  Access, Equity and  Accountability External Quality Assessment & Accreditation
Institutional quality assurance  - REQUIREMENTS Entire Institution! All Programmes! What? What are the  standards  ? Policy and procedures  for quality assurance F ormal mechanisms  for the approval, periodic review and monitoring of the programmes and awards. Assessment of students Public information Information systems Learning resources and student support Quality assurance of  teaching staff
QUALITY ASSURANCE  AT THE  LEVEL OF AN INSTITUTION Q = 9 M factors Man (Academic staff, Students) Materials Machines-Equipment Management Methods Measurement Motivation Money Markets
Monitoring and measurement Self assessment  Analysis of data Continuous improvement Human Resource Management Management review Need for Internalizing and Institutionalizing Quality Assurance –    measurement, analysis & improvement
The National Policy on Education NPE-86 recognises that a human being is a positive asset and a precious national resource which needs to be cherished, nurtured and developed with tenderness and care, coupled with dynamism. All Educational Institutions with the primary responsibility of human resource development must cater to  Holistic Education leading to Student centric development: Personal skills  (Self-awareness and Self-esteem) Interpersonal Skills  (Teamwork )  and Societal Skills  (Knowledge about Indian constitution  and civic responsibilities) Therefore, Educational Services of an Institution should be directed towards Learner-develpment
  "Tell me and I forget.  Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn."   Ben Franklin Therefore, all activities should be learner-centric
Evaluating Institution Effectiveness - Challenging Programs Institution Students Central focus  of  learning Courses Social Experiences (Adventitious  happenings) Previous Academic Experiences Intentions, Goals, Commitments Psychology  of  individuals Pre entry  attributes I N T E G R A T I O N Empirical support Strong  Weak Competencies and Life Skills  acquired Societal demands Aspirations, Goals, Commitments 21 st  Century global  competition Departure attributes and decisions M A R K E T D E M A N D S
NEED  FOR A HIGH QUALITY LEARNING EXPERIENCE In the 21 st  century context Self learning Skills for moving with times Communication skills Significant and lasting learning Augmentation of Intelligence Quotient IQ) Emotional Quotient(EQ) Spiritual Quotient(SQ) Practical skills  Foundational knowledge Student engagement  Human dimensions Value education
The following aspects are to be emphasized: 1.   Commitment 2.  Team work and Team building 3.  Planning the Quality Assurance activities 4.  Arriving at an Institutional quality Model 5.  The discipline of Continuous Improvement 6.  Willingness to adopt changes 7.  March towards Excellence through strategic    planning 8.  Meet global challenges
1.  Commitment Wanting to do well, to feel a sense of belonging to a group or a team of people working towards the same goals, and being determined to achieve those goals or targets should be the natural aspirations  of staff in any organisation
2.  Importance of Team work  and  Team Building “ It’s a fact that people working as a team can achieve better results than individuals working alone.”
Use the Team Building Tool http://www.teambuildinginc.com
Key Roles of Teams
PLAN CHECK DO ACT 3.  Planning the Quality Assurance activities: The PDCA Cycle has utmost relevance to education institutions Plan a change to the process. Predict the effect this change will have and plan how the effects will be measured Implement the change on a small scale and measure the effects Adopt the change as a permanent modification to the process, or abandon it. Study the results to learn what effect the change had, if any.
Mission statement goals &  aims expected  outcomes process study  programmes research projects community services output graduates scientific production services 4.   Arriving at an Institutional Quality Model input management policy staff students funding facilities Realised mission Achieved goals Achieved outcomes Satisfaction stakeholders
5.   The Discipline of Continuous Improvement Teaching, Learning, Community Building Deploy Integrate  Approach  Learn
Quality improvement (TAKING MEASURES FOR CORRECTION AT EACH CYCLE) TEMPORAL QUALITY ASSURANCE  AT THE  LEVEL OF AN INSTITUTION Every next cycle  must be of better quality
6.  Be willing to adopt changes  Survival of any Institution  …… depends on  recognizing the writings on the wall ! It has to change with the times It has to learn from others who are doing better It has to brace up for the challenge:  -from  competition, -impact of internet, -sophistication of technologies,  -constant  response   to  stakeholder preferences -global demands .
What makes an  institution Strong?   Quality and versatility  The  continued   relevance, quality  and attractiveness of its  courses The ability to renew itself without losing its  base  of excellence Committed and capable men and women who build and sustain it, regarding it as their own  Do the staff belong to the college or does the college belong to them?
Every institution must Plan for Change knowledge sharing activities –  match  teachers talents with student training. Study demands of the Generation X and stakeholder needs. Make a 10 year blue print for the campus/institution  Specify short-term goals for each year – review progress Net working/twinning  for  -sharing resources & manpower -exchange programme tie ups with other institutions in  the neighbourhood (a thought on cluster institutions)
Quality Assurance calls for: Quality system deployment Advanced quality planning Comprehensive quality manuals Use of quality cost Involvement of non - production operation Failure Mode and Effect Analysis Statistical process control
Quality enhancement is a multi-pronged transformation process  Gap analysis and awareness creation Faculty attitudinal change Institutional resources and  innovation Policy  reviews Administrative commitment Improved learning Changes In the Curricula Outcome: Effective education & employable graduates Multi-Stakeholder participation (all levels) Internalization and Institutionalization of Quality
Changing Ahead of the Curve “ Many institutions wait too long to attempt transformations, doing so only when the signs of trouble have become obvious.  But in today’s  unforgiving environment, that’s probably too late.  High performers by contrast, change  before they must, knowing that the best way to  transform is from a position of strength.”
Institutional Processes  to Improve Process  Evaluation 7. March Towards Excellence through Strategic Planning: Adopt the Performance Excellence Model Adopt Performance Improvement, Benchmarking & Innovation Process Implementation Improvement Plan (PIIP) Student Learning Student Services Employee Services Support Services Strategic Planning Shared Learnings
Vision into Action  is Strategic Planning  Vision Mission Culture Values Why are we in business? ? How do we do business? ? Where are we now? ? Where do we want to be? ? Strategies Environment Assessment Gap Analysis
Strategic Planning Process  contd … Goals Tactics Coordination Budgets How can we get there? ? How will we know we’ve arrived? ? Stakeholder satisfaction Reports Milestones
The difficult bit is ALWAYS  yet to be achieved IN THE CLIMB UP  THE EXCELLENCE MOUNTAIN
8. Higher Education: Global Challenges Collaboration tools  Provide students with personalised learning experiences Help develop new learning/teaching platforms with stronger accountability and performance tracking Meet students demands for new learning tools and solutions to take advantage of Internet capabilities   Recruit, retain, results Integrate and access a variety of student data securely (health, academic, business, legal)  Utilise better solutions to manage administrative (HR, Finance) and supply chain demands Improve management processes Operations Cross institutional/business information-sharing and tracking  Build research communities that are geographically dispersed Realise value of research  Drive collaboration for innovation Institutions seeking opportunities to build global  value chains Expand “for profit” opportunities to support financial needs. Web based systems to process student data  Integrate data and applications across functions Implement management tools to cut IT costs  Virtual classroom environment to provide e-learning environment for “anywhere” access to classes Create web based instructional tools and easier access to digital resources Deliver cost- effective IT infrastructure, access, multi-media learning environments Use of high powered computing & custom applications in research  centres Technology enablers Challenges Description Teaching Research
ICT Challenges Mobility  (students, faculty members)    wireless capabilities, always-on connectivity, information sharing Data management     Database capabilities, hosting, reporting, sharing e-learning/distance learning      Infrastructure for remote and/or live lectures, conferences and seminars Community and collaboration     Collaborative infrastructure, networking (portals, extranet…), anywhere/anytime access, identity management
Seek Solutions to Meet the Digital Challenge Learning Delivery  & Management Teacher/Student Technology Experience Managed  Operating  Environment Integrated  Administration Learning Potential Programmes Community IT Academy Learner Psyche Learning Gateway Learning Suite Learning Network Manager Integrated  Administration
Enable Connected Learning Need:  A Learning Gateway  for a single, consistent framework that supports thriving communities of educators, policy makers, administrators, governments and students In too many cases stakeholders in higher education operate in loosely connected networks preventing true collaboration
Accreditation by any  Quality Assurance Agency   must not be the beginning but an end to the  internal quality enhancement processes and efforts of any institution   so that the spiralling effects of internalizing Quality Assurance paves way for perceivable enhancement in all constituents of the institution and leads to  Excellence  Otherwise……
This is how an HEI (and individual components of an HEI) would get  entangled if change is not adopted at an appropriate time  to MOVE FORWARD!!!  Then it would be a point of no return !!!  SO LET  US  ALL  ACT NOW
  Right Qualification frame work Right infrastructure Right Faculty Right Learning resources Right Delivery mechanism Right encouragement for research and Consultancy  Right programs for institution-specific  staff development  &  Right mechanisms of Internal Quality  Assurance  Therefore, Let us pledge to promote the eight “Rights” in an educational institution:
Let us  all  see  Learning  in  a  Whole  New  Light?
A perspective on institutional quality assurance

A perspective on institutional quality assurance

  • 1.
    A perspective on Institutional Quality Assurance
  • 2.
  • 3.
    National Conference onInnovations in Higher Education Quality Quality Enhancement Quality Sustenance Quality Promotion Quality Culture Quality Awareness Quality Assurance How are they different ?
  • 4.
    QUA LITY ASSURANCE Quality Culture
  • 5.
    The Quality AssuranceProgram Advance Sustain Attain
  • 6.
    Higher Education -Today More people entering higher education than ever before Developed countries – working to expand higher education resources Developing countries – enhancing existing infrastructures to cope with demand The globalisation of education Growth in networks of higher and further education institutions across regions and countries Move towards mobile learning and remote learning Online learning increasingly at the heart of education Increasing competition Universities competing for staff, students (particularly from abroad), research funding, and partnerships Institutions investing heavily in ICT to support and maintain competitive position Increased Access, Equity and Accountability External Quality Assessment & Accreditation
  • 7.
    Institutional quality assurance - REQUIREMENTS Entire Institution! All Programmes! What? What are the standards ? Policy and procedures for quality assurance F ormal mechanisms for the approval, periodic review and monitoring of the programmes and awards. Assessment of students Public information Information systems Learning resources and student support Quality assurance of teaching staff
  • 8.
    QUALITY ASSURANCE AT THE LEVEL OF AN INSTITUTION Q = 9 M factors Man (Academic staff, Students) Materials Machines-Equipment Management Methods Measurement Motivation Money Markets
  • 9.
    Monitoring and measurementSelf assessment Analysis of data Continuous improvement Human Resource Management Management review Need for Internalizing and Institutionalizing Quality Assurance – measurement, analysis & improvement
  • 10.
    The National Policyon Education NPE-86 recognises that a human being is a positive asset and a precious national resource which needs to be cherished, nurtured and developed with tenderness and care, coupled with dynamism. All Educational Institutions with the primary responsibility of human resource development must cater to Holistic Education leading to Student centric development: Personal skills (Self-awareness and Self-esteem) Interpersonal Skills (Teamwork ) and Societal Skills (Knowledge about Indian constitution and civic responsibilities) Therefore, Educational Services of an Institution should be directed towards Learner-develpment
  • 11.
      "Tell meand I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn." Ben Franklin Therefore, all activities should be learner-centric
  • 12.
    Evaluating Institution Effectiveness- Challenging Programs Institution Students Central focus of learning Courses Social Experiences (Adventitious happenings) Previous Academic Experiences Intentions, Goals, Commitments Psychology of individuals Pre entry attributes I N T E G R A T I O N Empirical support Strong Weak Competencies and Life Skills acquired Societal demands Aspirations, Goals, Commitments 21 st Century global competition Departure attributes and decisions M A R K E T D E M A N D S
  • 13.
    NEED FORA HIGH QUALITY LEARNING EXPERIENCE In the 21 st century context Self learning Skills for moving with times Communication skills Significant and lasting learning Augmentation of Intelligence Quotient IQ) Emotional Quotient(EQ) Spiritual Quotient(SQ) Practical skills Foundational knowledge Student engagement Human dimensions Value education
  • 14.
    The following aspectsare to be emphasized: 1. Commitment 2. Team work and Team building 3. Planning the Quality Assurance activities 4. Arriving at an Institutional quality Model 5. The discipline of Continuous Improvement 6. Willingness to adopt changes 7. March towards Excellence through strategic planning 8. Meet global challenges
  • 15.
    1. CommitmentWanting to do well, to feel a sense of belonging to a group or a team of people working towards the same goals, and being determined to achieve those goals or targets should be the natural aspirations of staff in any organisation
  • 16.
    2. Importanceof Team work and Team Building “ It’s a fact that people working as a team can achieve better results than individuals working alone.”
  • 17.
    Use the TeamBuilding Tool http://www.teambuildinginc.com
  • 18.
  • 19.
    PLAN CHECK DOACT 3. Planning the Quality Assurance activities: The PDCA Cycle has utmost relevance to education institutions Plan a change to the process. Predict the effect this change will have and plan how the effects will be measured Implement the change on a small scale and measure the effects Adopt the change as a permanent modification to the process, or abandon it. Study the results to learn what effect the change had, if any.
  • 20.
    Mission statement goals& aims expected outcomes process study programmes research projects community services output graduates scientific production services 4. Arriving at an Institutional Quality Model input management policy staff students funding facilities Realised mission Achieved goals Achieved outcomes Satisfaction stakeholders
  • 21.
    5. The Discipline of Continuous Improvement Teaching, Learning, Community Building Deploy Integrate Approach Learn
  • 22.
    Quality improvement (TAKINGMEASURES FOR CORRECTION AT EACH CYCLE) TEMPORAL QUALITY ASSURANCE AT THE LEVEL OF AN INSTITUTION Every next cycle must be of better quality
  • 23.
    6. Bewilling to adopt changes Survival of any Institution …… depends on recognizing the writings on the wall ! It has to change with the times It has to learn from others who are doing better It has to brace up for the challenge: -from competition, -impact of internet, -sophistication of technologies, -constant response to stakeholder preferences -global demands .
  • 24.
    What makes an institution Strong? Quality and versatility The continued relevance, quality and attractiveness of its courses The ability to renew itself without losing its base of excellence Committed and capable men and women who build and sustain it, regarding it as their own Do the staff belong to the college or does the college belong to them?
  • 25.
    Every institution mustPlan for Change knowledge sharing activities – match teachers talents with student training. Study demands of the Generation X and stakeholder needs. Make a 10 year blue print for the campus/institution Specify short-term goals for each year – review progress Net working/twinning for -sharing resources & manpower -exchange programme tie ups with other institutions in the neighbourhood (a thought on cluster institutions)
  • 26.
    Quality Assurance callsfor: Quality system deployment Advanced quality planning Comprehensive quality manuals Use of quality cost Involvement of non - production operation Failure Mode and Effect Analysis Statistical process control
  • 27.
    Quality enhancement isa multi-pronged transformation process Gap analysis and awareness creation Faculty attitudinal change Institutional resources and innovation Policy reviews Administrative commitment Improved learning Changes In the Curricula Outcome: Effective education & employable graduates Multi-Stakeholder participation (all levels) Internalization and Institutionalization of Quality
  • 28.
    Changing Ahead ofthe Curve “ Many institutions wait too long to attempt transformations, doing so only when the signs of trouble have become obvious. But in today’s unforgiving environment, that’s probably too late. High performers by contrast, change before they must, knowing that the best way to transform is from a position of strength.”
  • 29.
    Institutional Processes to Improve Process Evaluation 7. March Towards Excellence through Strategic Planning: Adopt the Performance Excellence Model Adopt Performance Improvement, Benchmarking & Innovation Process Implementation Improvement Plan (PIIP) Student Learning Student Services Employee Services Support Services Strategic Planning Shared Learnings
  • 30.
    Vision into Action is Strategic Planning Vision Mission Culture Values Why are we in business? ? How do we do business? ? Where are we now? ? Where do we want to be? ? Strategies Environment Assessment Gap Analysis
  • 31.
    Strategic Planning Process contd … Goals Tactics Coordination Budgets How can we get there? ? How will we know we’ve arrived? ? Stakeholder satisfaction Reports Milestones
  • 32.
    The difficult bitis ALWAYS yet to be achieved IN THE CLIMB UP THE EXCELLENCE MOUNTAIN
  • 33.
    8. Higher Education:Global Challenges Collaboration tools Provide students with personalised learning experiences Help develop new learning/teaching platforms with stronger accountability and performance tracking Meet students demands for new learning tools and solutions to take advantage of Internet capabilities Recruit, retain, results Integrate and access a variety of student data securely (health, academic, business, legal) Utilise better solutions to manage administrative (HR, Finance) and supply chain demands Improve management processes Operations Cross institutional/business information-sharing and tracking Build research communities that are geographically dispersed Realise value of research Drive collaboration for innovation Institutions seeking opportunities to build global value chains Expand “for profit” opportunities to support financial needs. Web based systems to process student data Integrate data and applications across functions Implement management tools to cut IT costs Virtual classroom environment to provide e-learning environment for “anywhere” access to classes Create web based instructional tools and easier access to digital resources Deliver cost- effective IT infrastructure, access, multi-media learning environments Use of high powered computing & custom applications in research centres Technology enablers Challenges Description Teaching Research
  • 34.
    ICT Challenges Mobility (students, faculty members)  wireless capabilities, always-on connectivity, information sharing Data management  Database capabilities, hosting, reporting, sharing e-learning/distance learning  Infrastructure for remote and/or live lectures, conferences and seminars Community and collaboration  Collaborative infrastructure, networking (portals, extranet…), anywhere/anytime access, identity management
  • 35.
    Seek Solutions toMeet the Digital Challenge Learning Delivery & Management Teacher/Student Technology Experience Managed Operating Environment Integrated Administration Learning Potential Programmes Community IT Academy Learner Psyche Learning Gateway Learning Suite Learning Network Manager Integrated Administration
  • 36.
    Enable Connected LearningNeed: A Learning Gateway for a single, consistent framework that supports thriving communities of educators, policy makers, administrators, governments and students In too many cases stakeholders in higher education operate in loosely connected networks preventing true collaboration
  • 37.
    Accreditation by any Quality Assurance Agency must not be the beginning but an end to the internal quality enhancement processes and efforts of any institution so that the spiralling effects of internalizing Quality Assurance paves way for perceivable enhancement in all constituents of the institution and leads to Excellence Otherwise……
  • 38.
    This is howan HEI (and individual components of an HEI) would get entangled if change is not adopted at an appropriate time to MOVE FORWARD!!! Then it would be a point of no return !!! SO LET US ALL ACT NOW
  • 39.
      Right Qualificationframe work Right infrastructure Right Faculty Right Learning resources Right Delivery mechanism Right encouragement for research and Consultancy Right programs for institution-specific staff development & Right mechanisms of Internal Quality Assurance Therefore, Let us pledge to promote the eight “Rights” in an educational institution:
  • 40.
    Let us all see Learning in a Whole New Light?