AAA_Diamond_Rating_Guidelines_2012

Dear Hospitality Professional,
On behalf of AAA, I am pleased to introduce to you the latest edition of the Lodging Approval Requirements &
Diamond Rating Guidelines. This year marks the 76th anniversary of AAA professional inspectors. Continuing our long-
held tradition, AAA’s expert inspectors use these published guidelines to conduct unannounced evaluations, assigning
Approved establishments a rating of One to Five AAA Diamonds.
Since its inception in 1902 as a federation of independent motor clubs, AAA has been dedicated to providing safer roads
and more pleasurable travel experiences for member motorists. Now, with more than 53 million members, AAA offers
roadside assistance, insurance and financial services, safety education, and member advocacy — and is an undisputed
leader in travel information and services.
In 1937, the first AAA field representatives were hired to inspect lodgings and restaurants; and in 1963, AAA began
assigning lodging ratings from ‘good’ to ‘outstanding’. In 1977, AAA introduced the Diamond Rating System, using a
diamond to mark the association’s 75th anniversary, and began rolling out Diamond Ratings for restaurants in 1985.
The first AAA Lodging Diamond Rating Guidelines booklet was introduced for industry review in 1987, with subsequent
updated versions published since then to reflect evolving industry trends and guest expectations.
This new edition of the Lodging Approval Requirements & Diamond Rating Guidelines was designed with three
objectives in mind:
• To provide AAA inspectors comprehensive guidance for conducting their evaluations.
• To ensure AAA members receive accurate and consistent travel planning and decision-making information.
• To provide hotels and restaurants a thorough understanding of the Diamond Rating System to help them
achieve a successful evaluation and rating.
To that end, we partner with the hospitality industry to gather input, discuss the meaning of our ratings, and openly
share how Diamond Ratings are applied at the property level. Unique to AAA, we ask our members what elements of
their hotel or dining experience are most important and then weight the rating factors to reflect member expectations.
We strongly urge property representatives to take full advantage of the information provided by AAA inspectors during
an on-site evaluation, since our experts are exposed to a wide range of properties throughout the United States,
Canada, Mexico and the Caribbean. Annually, AAA evaluates more than 33,000 lodgings, 30,000 restaurants and
thousands of attractions. AAA Approved listings can be accessed in the AAA TourBook guides, downloadable
eTourBook guides at AAA.com/ebooks, and online at AAA.com/Travel. Smartphone users can access Diamond Rated
establishments using the free AAA TripTik Mobile app or AAA Mobile app at AAA.com/mobile.
Visit AAA clubs online at AAA.com. Access AAA news releases, high-resolution images, broadcast-quality video, fact
sheets and podcasts on the AAA NewsRoom at NewsRoom.AAA.com.
We appreciate your continued commitment to serving the travel needs of AAA members and your participation in AAA
programs.
Sincerely,
Michael Petrone, CEC
Director/AAA Tourism Information Development

AAA 1938 Northeastern Hotel Directory

CCOONNTTEENNTTSS
SSeeccttiioonn 11:: TThhee AAAAAA DDiiaammoonndd RRaattiinngg SSyysstteemm ........................................................................................................................................................ 66
Approval Requirements and Diamond Rating Guidelines … what’s the difference?......................................................................................6
How do I apply for a AAA inspection?......................................................................................................................................................................6
What to Expect During the AAA On-Site Inspection............................................................................................................................................7
AAA Approval Requirements......................................................................................................................................................................................8
SSeeccttiioonn 22:: TThhee AAAAAA DDiiaammoonndd RRaattiinngg GGuuiiddeelliinneess..............................................................................................................................1111
The AAA Diamond Rating Guidelines.................................................................................................................................................................... 11
What the Diamonds Mean........................................................................................................................................................................................ 11
Glossary ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 12
Exterior.....................................................................................................................................................................................13
Public Areas – Main Lobby / Registration Area ................................................................................................15
Public Areas – Other Common Area(s)....................................................................................................................18
Guestroom...............................................................................................................................................................................21
Bathroom.................................................................................................................................................................................26
SSeeccttiioonn 33:: AAddddiittiioonnaall IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn....................................................................................................................................................................................3030
The AAA Four and Five Diamond Ratings............................................................................................................................................................. 30
Four and Five Diamond Service Expectations....................................................................................................................................................... 30
AAA Hospitality Standards........................................................................................................................................................................................ 31
The Listing .................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 35
Lodging Classifications................................................................................................................................................................................................ 35
Accessibility.................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 36
Member Comment Procedures............................................................................................................................................................................... 36
The AAA Appeals Process........................................................................................................................................................................................ 36
Green Programs.......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 37
Contact Information................................................................................................................................................................................................... 37

Section 1: The AAA Diamond Rating System
AApppprroovvaall RReeqquuiirreemmeennttss aanndd DDiiaammoonndd
RRaattiinngg GGuuiiddeelliinneess …… wwhhaatt’’ss tthhee ddiiffffeerreennccee??
AAA’s Diamond Rating System comprises two distinct
components. The Approval Requirements are
uncompromising, mandatory standards, while Diamond Rating
Guidelines are somewhat flexible – with the overall rating
based on prevalence of attributes and inspector opinion
based on thousands of property inspections.
The evaluation process is made up of three parts:
1. Apply for an inspection via AAA.biz/Approved
2. Become AAA Approved – To receive AAA
Approval, establishments must meet
uncompromising, mandatory standards identified as
Approval Requirements
3. Receive a AAA Diamond Rating – After an
establishment is Approved by AAA, the inspector
recommends a rating using the Diamond Rating
Guidelines and subjective elements based on
professional experience and training.
Properties must meet all AAA Approval Requirements
to be considered for AAA Approval. Approval Requirements
are common-sense qualifications that AAA members tell us
are critical to them and, similarly, most professional
operators routinely seek to achieve.
Properties must meet most AAA Diamond Rating
Guidelines to be assigned a particular rating level
The Diamond Rating Guidelines reflect attributes typically —
but not universally — observed throughout a lodging industry
segment. Therefore, the lack of some components listed for a
designated rating level does not necessarily preclude the
achievement of that rating. During evaluations, inspectors
assess the strengths and weaknesses of the property and
assign the most appropriate rating that will provide the best
match in meeting AAA member expectations.
Not all guidelines apply to all property types
For example, meeting rooms are not expected at a bed and
breakfast, but are essential at a convention-oriented hotel.
Expectations regarding the availability and type of swimming
pool are dictated by climatic influences and/or the property
classification. AAA inspectors apply only those Diamond
Rating Guidelines appropriate for the property classification.
HHooww ddoo II aappppllyy ffoorr aa AAAAAA iinnssppeeccttiioonn??
AAA CONSIDERS ALL VALID APPLICATIONS FOR
INSPECTION. By applying for – and/or consenting to – an
inspection, you agree to allow AAA to publish your property
information and the respective Diamond Rating in our digital
and printed travel information. Currently listed
establishments need not reapply, as our inspector will
routinely conduct an assessment of previously Approved
properties.
To expedite the application process, we suggest the following
approach:
♦ Verify your property's eligibility for approval by
reviewing the AAA Approval Requirements
Properties must meet all Approval Requirements to
be considered a valid applicant for inspection.
♦ Complete and submit the Lodging Application for
Evaluation (pdf). Include recent and accurate pictures
of the exterior, public areas, standard double guest
unit, bathroom and guest unit door locks.
Important notes:
♦ If our records indicate past disqualifying issues, you
may be asked to provide written documentation of
the corrective action taken since then.
♦ AAA does not guarantee an immediate evaluation of
all properties that apply, and we reserve the right to
apply priority consideration to those demonstrating
the highest degree of AAA member value according
to the following criteria:
GOOD LOCATION
NEWLY BUILT/RENOVATED
HIGH DEGREE OF CLEANLINESS AND
COMFORT
APPROPRIATELY MAINTAINED
CONDITIONS
PRICE (willingness to provide a discount or
best rate available)
-6-

♦ There may be an application fee required to process
your request. We will provide written notice once
we have reviewed your application and, if selected
for evaluation, an invoice for your application fee.
Payment is nonrefundable and has no bearing on the
outcome of the inspection. Do not send a
payment with the initial application.
♦ On receipt of the application fee, AAA will schedule
your property for an unannounced inspection as
quickly as practicable.
♦ Basic listings in AAA travel products are provided
without charge to Approved properties.
WWhhaatt ttoo EExxppeecctt DDuurriinngg tthhee AAAAAA OOnn--SSiittee IInnssppeeccttiioonn
A THREE-PART, ON-SITE PROCESS:
1. Introduction, Interview
On arrival (unannounced), the AAA inspector will speak with a
property representative for a brief, but extremely important, interview
to:
♦ Collect factual information for potential use in AAA publications.
♦ Answer your questions and be advised of any plans for
improvement.
2. Property tour and assessment of Approval Requirements,
Diamond Rating Guidelines, and subjective review
Following the interview, the inspector will request a tour of all public
areas and a cross section of guestrooms to assess current property
conditions. The inspector will point out strengths and weaknesses as
appropriate if a property representative is in attendance. This valuable
dialogue is unique to the AAA inspection, and we highly recommend
that a property representative accompany the inspector. Ideally, this
would include the general manager and head of housekeeping.
TTHHEE IINNSSPPEECCTTIIOONN IINNCCLLUUDDEESS AA RREEVVIIEEWW OOFF SSEEVVEERRAALL KKEEYY
AARREEAASS::
CLEANLINESS AND CONDITION
Properties will receive a mark of ‘Pass’ or ‘Fail’/sub-rating
for the overall condition of the property in terms of
cleanliness, comfort, and maintenance. A passing mark is
required for AAA Approval.
MANAGEMENT AND STYLE OF OPERATION
Properties will receive a mark of Pass or Fail for the
manner of staff interaction based on the overall level of
hospitality, professionalism, and deportment. A passing
mark is required for AAA Approval.
EXTERIOR AND PUBLIC AREAS
GUESTROOMS
BATHROOMS
Each of these three areas is assessed against the
Approval Requirements with a mark of Pass or Fail.
If each area passes, Diamond Rating Guidelines are
applied and points are assigned for available attributes in
varying weights based on the importance to the guest
experience. The points are tallied to determine a sub-
rating for each area.
GUEST SERVICES/HOSPITALITY (For those that qualify)
Properties that match the physical guidelines for a Five
Diamond Rating are scheduled for a series of anonymous
visits by AAA inspectors to assess the guest
services/hospitality level. The overnight hospitality
assessment includes a review of critical guest interaction
points. Properties must achieve a Five Diamond Rating in
guest services/hospitality to be considered for a Five
Diamond Rating overall.
3. Assessment Summary
If a property is Approved, the inspector will recommend
a Diamond Rating or FYI designation as appropriate
based on conditions that exist at the time of the
evaluation. Each property will receive an e-mail
containing a summary of AAA’s findings and the Diamond
Rating status. The frequency of subsequent AAA
evaluations varies slightly, depending on the classification
and assigned rating.
-7-

1964-65 AAA TourBook
Our reporters are not permitted to do any selling of any kind, nor to accept complimentary
accommodations, as we wish their reports to be absolutely unbiased and uninfluenced. They
will not pry nor be meddlesome. They seek only authentic information in order that we may
render dependable and satisfactory service to our members.
~ excerpt from “Introducing AAA Field Reporters”, 1946
AAAAAA AApppprroovvaall RReeqquuiirreemmeennttss
AAA APPROVAL REQUIREMENTS REFLECT THE
MINIMUM ACCEPTABLE CONDITIONS AS ESTABLISHED
THROUGH MEMBER SURVEYS AND CONTINUOUS
FEEDBACK.
To be AAA Approved and Diamond Rated, an establishment
must meet the following requirements:
Cleanliness and Condition
1. All facilities associated with a property are clean and
well-maintained throughout.
2. At a minimum, each guest unit is thoroughly cleaned,
with complete bed and bath linens changed between
guest stays.
3. Basic housekeeping services and supplies are available on
request.
4. All indoor areas are properly ventilated to ensure guest
comfort.
Management and Style of Operation
Establishments will:
5. Provide AAA members value in all aspects of operation.
6. Cater primarily to transient rather than residential
guests, with four or more units available for AAA
members.
7. Be in compliance with all local, state, and federal codes.
Property management will:
8. Assist AAA in the resolution of member complaints.
9. Accommodate unannounced AAA property evaluations
within 20 minutes of notice.
10. Conduct business in a professional and ethical manner –
providing attentive, conscientious service to guests.
11. Place AAA members in AAA inspected and
approved guest units only. Overflow
buildings or guest units associated with the
property but not approved by AAA are not
acceptable accommodations.
12. Be readily accessible at all times to address
guest needs.
13. Provide guests easy access to 24-hour
incoming and outgoing phone service,
ensuring prompt message delivery.
14. Readily provide property information, as requested, for
the purpose of maintaining the most accurate travel
information in AAA’s print, online and mobile travel
planning products.
Property management will not:
15. Use AAA trademarks—including but not limited to, the
AAA logo and Diamond Rating—without AAA’s prior
written consent, including, but not limited to, the Lodging
Official Appointment Agreement.
Exterior and Public Areas
Establishments will have:
16. Accurate, legible signage in appropriate areas (e.g., entry,
corridors, walkways, stairways, landings, parking areas).
17. Good illumination in all public areas (e.g., entry,
corridors, walkways, stairways, landings, parking areas).
18. Procedures in place to ensure all facilities associated with
a property and provided for guest use (e.g., restaurant,
health club, gift shop, recreation facilities) meet all
appropriate AAA Approval Requirements.
Guestrooms
Each guest unit will have:
19. A comfortable bed with a mattress pad, two sheets, two
pillows with pillowcases, and an appropriate bed
covering.
20. A nightstand or equivalent by each bed, a chair, a writing
surface, a waste container, clothes-storage space, and
clothes-hanging facilities with hangers for two guests.
21. Adequate shades, drapes, or blinds to cover all windows
or other transparent areas, to provide the guest with
privacy.
Requirements-8-

22. An adequate level of soundproofing to muffle outside
noises and normal sounds in adjacent units and public
areas.
23. An active light switch at the main entry.
24. Good overall illumination to include direct lighting at a
writing surface, sitting area, and each bed.
25. Door(s) equipped with both a primary lock and a
secondary deadbolt lock.
26. Deadbolt lock(s) on each door to connecting guest units
or maintenance corridors.
27. A viewport or window (convenient to the door) for each
entry door.
28. A functional lock for each window that overlooks a
common walkway or is in a ground-floor unit.
29. An operational, single station smoke detector. When
battery-operated detectors are used, there must be an
adequate maintenance program to routinely test and
replace batteries.
Primary lock is a keyed mechanism that allows the door to be locked
from the outside. Passkeys are strictly controlled and available only to
recognized guests and essential associates for routine room access (e.g.,
management, housekeeping/maintenance staff, security).
Secondary lock is a mortised, deadbolt-locking mechanism with a one-
inch throw extending from the edge of the door into the door frame.
This extra device affords guests a certain level of privacy. Unlike the
primary lock passkeys, master keys for secondary locks are available
only to essential associates and only for emergency purposes (e.g.,
management or security).
Secondary Lock Variances
In certain instances, the requirement for secondary locks may be
modified to meet a variety of exceptions. The most common are
noted below. AAA claims the right of final arbitrator in all decisions
related to locks.
Sliding Glass Doors – Each sliding door must be equipped with an
effective locking device. A secondary security lock is required on all
ground-floor doors and those accessible from common walkways
and adjoining balconies.
French Doors – In addition to the deadbolt lock requirements,
surface-mounted slide bolts must be provided at the top and
bottom to secure the stationary/auxiliary door. These bolts must
extend into the upper doorframe and the lower doorframe or
floor and must be strong and sturdy mechanisms.
Guest Bathrooms
Each guest unit will have:
30. A private bathroom.
31. A toilet, sink with well-lit mirror, convenient electrical
outlet, adequate shelf space, and a tub/shower with a
non-slip surface.
32. Good overall illumination to include direct lighting at the
mirror(s).
33. A bath towel, hand towel, face cloth, and cup/glass for
each guest.
34. Toilet tissue, a cloth bath mat, and two bars of soap or
equivalent.
35. Non-porous surfaces (e.g., floors, walls, baseboards) in all
toilet areas.
Requirements-9-

Section 2: The AAA Diamond Rating Guidelines
Guidelines
TThhee AAAAAA DDiiaammoonndd RRaattiinngg GGuuiiddeelliinneess
AAA DIAMOND RATINGS REPRESENT A COMBINATION OF THE OVERALL QUALITY, RANGE OF FACILITIES,
AND LEVEL OF HOSPITALITY OFFERED BY A PROPERTY. The widely recognized and trusted AAA Diamonds help
members choose lodgings that will meet their needs and expectations.
AAA's Diamond Rating Guidelines indicate what is typically found at each rating level—from economy to the most luxurious
properties. The Diamond Rating is determined based on a compilation of all property characteristics, with a focus on overall guest
impression rather than on individual elements. While properties at the same rating level may have variations in the attributes
offered, an overall predominance of characteristics from a particular rating level drives the rating. Additional factors that may impact
a property rating are comfort, overall appeal, condition and cleanliness.
The inspector’s Diamond Rating recommendation is based on both the Diamond Rating Guidelines and professional judgment —
an essential component of the rating assessment. Our inspectors are North America’s travel experts, immersed in the hospitality
industry on a daily basis as they conduct more than 33,000 lodging evaluations per year.
WWhhaatt tthhee DDiiaammoonnddss MMeeaann
One Diamond
Budget-oriented, offering basic comfort and hospitality.
Two Diamond
Affordable, with modestly enhanced facilities, décor and amenities.
Three Diamond
Distinguished, multi-faceted with enhanced physical attributes, amenities and guest comforts.
Four Diamond
Refined, stylish with upscale physical attributes, extensive amenities and a high degree of hospitality, service, and
attention to detail.
Five Diamond
Ultimate luxury, sophistication and comfort with extraordinary physical attributes, meticulous personalized service,
extensive amenities and impeccable standard of excellence.
-11-

When you see the following terms used, please refer back to this page for more information.
On the following Diamond Rating Guidelines pages, there are words/terms referenced that describe the essence
of an attribute and/or instructions on how to “build” upon identified elements across rating segments.
• Basic – Of, relating to, or forming the base or essence; simplest form; minimal amounts.
• Decorative – Obvious ornamental embellishment with attractive results.
• e.g. – For example. Items following are only examples of what is typical and should not be interpreted as a
required appointment.
• Leading Edge – Most advanced in their profession; luxuriant, luxury materials, highly fashionable/grand design
and functionality working in sync to provide sumptuous level of comfort.
• Modest/Modestly Enhanced – More than basic; slight enhancement; limited in size or scope.
• Plus – When you see this term used (such as 2D, plus), it means that the rating includes the bolded elements
of the previous columns in addition to elements of the current column.
• Residential – Of, relating to or connected with residential style; invokes a personal presence of home.
• Upscale – Obviously high grade; upmarket, luxurious feel; cohesive designs; not just the latest trend.
KEY NOTES:
• Additional Factors - All areas may be subject to point additions/subtractions related to: overall impression,
comfort, design and layout, condition and cleanliness. Also, AAA members express significant dissatisfaction with
additional non-use fees (e.g., “resort fees”, safes, microwaves, refrigerators, etc.). Free and effective Internet
bandwidth within the guestroom is also expected.
• Exceptions – Not all of the Diamond Rating Guidelines will apply to all property types. AAA inspectors will
only use the sections of the Diamond Rating Guidelines that are appropriate for the property classification in
assessing the overall Diamond Rating. If an attribute exists at the property, it will be rated accordingly.
-12-

EXTERIOR
See Glossary Section – page 12
General Curb
Appeal
(Applies as a
common theme
throughout the
Exterior)
♦ Minimal quantity,
variety and/or
coordination of basic
materials
♦ Basic design and
effect
♦ Increased quantity,
variety and/or
coordination of
materials
♦ Modest design and
effect
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials
♦ Well-coordinated
and attractive
residential design
♦ Significantly
enhanced effect
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale materials
♦ Substantial, cohesive
and impressive
design
♦ Upscale effect
4D, plus:
♦ Luxuriant materials
♦ Leading-edge design
and effect
Building
Structure &
Design
Basic materials,
design and/or
function
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or function
e.g., roof mansard,
gable, cupola, window
shutters/ sashes,
siding, columns,
railings, etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Significant decorative
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or function in
the most prominent
structural areas, i.e.,
façade
♦ Obvious residential
effect
e.g., enhanced roofs,
window treatments/
moldings,
stone/veneer accents
or balconies, etc.
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale
enhancements
♦ Substantial, cohesive
and impressive
design throughout
the property
footprint
4D, plus:
♦ Grand architectural
features
and effect
Landscaping ♦ Minimal quantity,
variety of plants
and/or landscape
materials
♦ Basic surroundings
and visual interest
♦ Modest
enhancements to
quantity, variety of
plants and/or
landscape materials
♦ Some surroundings
reflect a coordinated
design of moderate
visual interest
♦ Significant,
decorative
enhancements to
quantity, variety of
plants and/or
landscape materials
♦ Overall residential
design
♦ Creates an obvious
visual interest in
most areas
3D, plus:
♦ The entire grounds
are professionally
planned and
manicured with an
extensive use of
appropriate, mature
plants and landscape
materials
♦ Cohesive, upscale
design that
withstands seasonal
weather conditions
♦ At least one accent
feature
e.g., statuary, water
feature, serenity
garden, etc.
4D, plus:
♦ Luxuriant landscape
materials
and effect
♦ Multiple accent
features are
meticulously
integrated by design
Guidelines-13-

EXTERIOR
(Continued)
Main Entrance ♦ Basic materials,
design and/or
function
♦ Covered entry door
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or function
♦ If covered entry has
drive through
capability, capacity is
limited to one-car
width
2D, plus:
enhancements to
materials, design and
function (façade
and/or driving
surface)
e.g., brick, stone or
stamped concrete
♦ Capacity is
appropriate for the
size of the hotel
(minimum two-car
width or depth)
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale materials,
design
♦ Capacity is greater
than two-car width
and depth
4D, plus:
♦ Luxuriant materials
and effect
♦ Expanded drive or
courtyard
Other Exterior Attributes: (Points allocated as appropriate)
♦ Location
♦ Parking
-14-

Public Areas
Main Lobby / Registration Area
General Décor
Style
(Applies to Main
Lobby/ Registration
Area)
♦ Predominantly basic
materials, design
♦ Minimal function
and/or coordination
♦ Adequate level of
comfort
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
♦ Increased function
and/or coordination
♦ Enhanced level of
comfort
2D, plus:
♦ Residential style
♦ Significant
enhancements to
materials, design
♦ Well-coordinated,
with increased
functionality
♦ Obvious degree of
comfort
3D, plus:
design and/or
function
♦ Exceptional degree
of comfort
4D, plus:
♦ Luxurious materials
and effect
Floor
Coverings
Basic materials, design
e.g., linoleum/vinyl,
plain ceramic tile,
painted concrete, low
density pile carpet
(with limited/no
padding— floor feels
hard), etc.
Modestly enhanced
materials
e.g., floating wood
laminates, patterned
linoleum/vinyl, medium
density pile carpet of
simple design/ pattern
(with padding that
provides average
comfort underfoot),
etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative materials
and design with
patterns, textures or
inlays
e.g., wood laminates,
carpet, ceramic/stone/
glass tile, polished/
stamped concrete,
terra cotta, etc.
♦ Hard surfaced floors
have decorative area
rugs in seating areas
and other locations
as appropriate
3D, plus:
Highest grade
materials
e.g., wood, marble,
granite/ other upscale
stone floors, high
density pile carpet
(with padding that
provides exceptional
comfort underfoot),
etc.
4D, plus:
♦ Custom inlays or
textured
enhancements
and effect
♦ Area rugs are
luxurious
Free Floor
Space
Obviously restricted
by size and/or
placement of
appointments
Modest restrictions
due to size and/or
placement of
appointments
No restrictions, as
placement of
appointments is well-
proportioned to area
size and traffic flow
3D, plus:
Area size and
placement of
appointments provide
an obvious degree of
spaciousness allowing
increased ease of
movement for guests
4D, plus:
Area size and
placement of
an abundance of space
that contributes to the
ultimate level of
comfort and relaxation
Guidelines-15-

Public Areas
Main Lobby / Registration Area (Continued)
Furniture
Quality &
Design
♦ Basic materials,
design
and/or coordination
♦ Provides an
adequate level of
comfort
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or coordination
♦ Provides an
enhanced level of
comfort
enhancements to
materials, design
♦ Well-coordinated
with increased
functionality
♦ Provides an obvious
degree of comfort
3D, plus:
e.g., granite/stone,
solid wood, polished
metals, high-gloss
lacquers, veneer
finishes with solid
wood accents, high-
grade laminate insets,
etc.
♦ Distinctive design
and/or function
e.g., antiques, leather,
plush padding, designer
fabric, sculptured
shape, crisp line, etc.
of comfort
4D, plus:
♦ Custom
workmanship
and effect
Guest Service
Area(s)
Basic, small counter
registration
Enhanced front desk
e.g., size or design
2D, plus:
♦ Front desk is part
of a spacious
common area
♦ Multiple guest
service capability
3D, plus:
Multiple guest service
areas
e.g., front desk, bell
stand, concierge, video
kiosk, etc.
4D, plus:
Staffed concierge area
(minimum 16 hrs./day)
Illumination ♦ Basic fixtures
♦ Good level of overall
illumination
1D, plus:
Modestly enhanced
design, materials,
positioning and/or
function
2D, plus:
♦ Well-positioned
♦ Decorative and well-
coordinated design,
materials and/or
function
illumination at each
key task area
3D, plus:
♦ Fixtures reflect
upscale design
♦ Excellent level of
overall illumination
enhances the
intended use of the
space
4D, plus:
♦ Custom fixtures of
outstanding quality
♦ Leading-edge
illumination effect
Seating Layout ♦ Minimal or no
seating capacity
♦ Limited seating
capacity
♦ Furniture
arrangement
accommodates one
small group
e.g., a sofa and two
armchairs
2D, plus:
♦ Expanded seating
capacity
♦ Furniture
arrangements
accommodate two
small groups with
obvious separation
of space from front
desk area
3D, plus:
♦ Multiple
conversational
groupings
♦ One semi-private
area (away from
traffic flow)
4D, plus:
Multiple semi-private
areas
-16-

Public Areas
Main Lobby / Registration Area (Continued)
Wall Coverings ♦ Basic materials,
design
e.g., cinder block/
brick, prefab modular
laminate paneling,
wallpaper, etc.
♦ Rubber or vinyl
baseboards
♦ Modest
enhancements
e.g., drywall with basic
paint finish or plain
vinyl coverings, etc.
♦ Carpeted
baseboards
♦ Decorative
enhancements
e.g., expert-smooth
painted drywall
with/without textured
finish (knockdown,
orange peel, comb, slap
brush, etc.), plaster/
Venetian plaster, vinyl
coverings/wood planks/
veneers/stone, accent
wall(s), etc.
♦ Wood/ ceramic tile
baseboards
3D, plus:
♦ One upscale design
enhancement
e.g., furniture-finish
wood planking, soft
wall coverings,
crown/cove molding,
wainscot,
architectural feature,
etc.
♦ Oversized (>4”)
wood/stone
baseboards
4D, plus:
♦ Multiple design
enhancements
♦ Leading-edge effect
Wall Hangings
/ Decorative
Enhancements
♦ Poster(s) or
common artwork
with unframed/thin,
un-enhanced wood,
metal, or plastic
frame(s)
♦ Common
knickknacks
1D, plus:
♦ Enhanced frame(s)
♦ -Or- other modest
appointments
Well-coordinated,
decorative
appointments
3D, plus:
Varied assortment that
provides a distinctive
or thematic upscale
appeal
4D, plus:
Variety of styles and
accent pieces
e.g., limited edition
prints, canvas art,
tapestries, or
lithographs with
enhanced matting and
preservation frames,
assorted artisan
pieces, sculptures, etc.
Other Main Lobby / Registration Area Attributes: (Points allocated as appropriate)
♦ Ceilings
Guidelines-17-

Public Areas
Other Common Area(s)
General Décor
Style
(Applies as a common
theme throughout the
Common Areas)
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
2D, plus:
♦ Significant
enhancements to
materials, design
with increased
functionality
comfort
3D, plus:
design and/or
function
of comfort
4D, plus:
and effect
Business Center Personal computer,
with Internet access,
available in lobby for
guests’ use
♦ Dedicated, out-of-
the-way area
♦ Multi-guest capability
to include at least
three business-
related items
e.g., PC, printer,
copier, supplies, etc.
3D, plus:
♦ Spacious, well-
appointed area
♦ Latest business
technology
integrated for
efficient use
♦ Comprehensive
office supplies
4D, plus:
♦ Luxurious
surroundings
♦ -Or-personalized
services are
provided
Elevator Elevator is available for
guests' use in all multi-
story buildings
2D, plus:
♦ Elevator includes
decorative
appointments
♦ Landing includes
multiple residential
furnishings
e.g., chair/sofa, table,
lamps/wall sconce,
phone, artwork,
mirror, flowers/plants,
etc.
3D, plus:
♦ Multiple elevators
♦ Upscale
appointments
♦ Landings are
recessed
♦ Additional service
elevator is available
for staff’s use
4D, plus:
♦ Elevator cabs have
additional features
e.g., dual call button
panels, television, card
key access, voice
indicators, etc.
Exercise
Facility
♦ Designated room
onsite
♦ Three pieces of
cardio/strength
equipment
♦ Mirrored walls
♦ Television
♦ Water cooler
♦ Towels
♦ Clock
♦ Sanitizer
2D, plus:
♦ Five or more pieces
of professional grade
equipment
♦ Additional personal
training options
e.g., free weights,
benches, floor mats,
physio balls, toning
bars/rollers, etc.
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale facility
♦ Full array of fitness
equipment
appropriate with
room count
♦ Provides an obvious
degree of
spaciousness
♦ All equipment is
state-of-the-art
♦ Specialized, high-
impact flooring
♦ Ambient lighting/
aromatherapy scents
4D, plus:
♦ Leading-edge facility
♦ Luxurious health
club environment
♦ Guided training
programs
♦ Dressing area
includes: lockers,
showers, and
restrooms
♦ In-room exercise
programs available
-18-

Public Areas
Other Common Area(s) (Continued)
Food &
Beverage
Outlets
Restaurant
(if applicable)
One quick-service
outlet onsite
i.e., comparable to a
One Diamond
restaurant
♦ One full-service
restaurant
Two Diamond
restaurant
♦ Lounge or bar area
♦ Upscale, full-service
restaurant
Three Diamond
restaurant
♦ Separate lounge or
bar area
♦ Room service
available for
breakfast, lunch, and
dinner
4D, plus:
♦ Multiple outlets
i.e., at least one is
comparable to a Four
Diamond restaurant
♦ Room service
available 24/7
OR OR OR OR OR OR
Breakfast Area
(Expanded Continental
– At minimum, two
items in each of the
following categories:
juice, coffee, fresh
fruits, breads, pastries,
cereals)
Standard continental
breakfast
i.e., minimum: juice,
pastry, and hot
beverage
♦ Expanded
continental breakfast
is served in a
dedicated area with
modest restrictions
due to size and/or
placement of
appointments
♦ Limited seating is
available
♦ Television
2D, plus:
♦ Includes hot item(s)
e.g., waffles/ pancakes,
eggs, breakfast meats
♦ Appointments are
well-proportioned
to area size, with
appropriate seating
for the size of the
establishment
3D, plus:
♦ Clearly refined
menu
♦ Full service
♦ Upscale
surroundings
4D, plus:
♦ Highly personalized
experience
♦ Luxurious
surroundings
Meeting Rooms ♦ Small (size of 1-2
guestrooms)
♦ Solely-purposed for
meetings
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
appointments
♦ Comprehensive
facility
♦ Expanded meeting
space
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale
appointments
♦ Latest audiovisual
technology
♦ Ample variety of
meeting rooms
e.g., ballroom,
boardroom, theatre,
and/or meeting rooms
of various sizes
4D, plus:
♦ Luxuriously
appointed, first-class
facilities
Plants
Throughout
Property
Artificial/live plants 1D, plus:
♦ Healthy/ attractive
♦ Limited locations
2D, plus:
Obviously used as
decorative accents in
key areas of the
property
3D, plus:
Use enhances an
upscale theme
throughout the
property
♦ Garden-fresh
condition
♦ Outstanding variety
of uncommon
/seasonal live plants
and flowers
♦ Uniquely arranged to
provide a leading-
edge effect
throughout the
property
-19-

Public Areas
Other Common Area(s) (Continued)
Restrooms One unisex ♦ Decorative
appointments
♦ Multiple unisex or
separate gender
restrooms in a
convenient location
(If property has
expanded meeting
facilities, then
additional restrooms
are available in
proportion)
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale
appointments
♦ Multiple locations
4D, plus:
First-class with
luxurious
appointments
Signage
Throughout
Property
design
♦ Limited locations
1D, plus:
Modestly enhanced
materials, design
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
enhancements
♦ Ample locations
3D, plus:
Intuitive, upscale
materials, design and
location
4D, plus:
♦ Custom materials,
design
♦ Creatively placed for
a leading-edge effect
Sundries &
Shops
♦ Modest selection of
amenities available
at the front desk
♦ -Or- in vending
machine
e.g., toothbrush/ paste,
razors, mouthwash,
shower caps, combs,
etc.
♦ Dedicated sundry
area
♦ -Or- conventional
gift shop offering a
moderate variety of
merchandise
e.g., health and beauty
needs, food, beverage,
and reading materials,
etc.
♦ Upscale gift shop
providing a wide
variety of
merchandise
♦ -Or- property is
conveniently
connected to
shopping area
4D, plus:
Variety of first-class
shops
Swimming Pool ♦ Pool area reflects
the use of modest
materials and design
♦ Limited amount of
furniture
♦ Simple or mixed
styles
♦ Pool area is well
appointed with
decorative features
and design
♦ Good variety of
comfortable pool
furniture
♦ Weather
appropriate pool
i.e., usable at least nine
months annually
3D, plus:
♦ Pool area reflects
the use of upscale
materials and design
♦ Includes a water
therapy feature
e.g., hot tub, whirlpool
spa, steam room, sauna,
etc.
♦ Food and beverage
service is available
poolside
4D, plus:
♦ Leading-edge
appointments
e.g., in-pool seating,
sculptures, water
feature, exotic plants
and gardens, stone/tile
surfaces with designer
inlays, etc.
♦ Additional poolside
amenities
e.g., cabanas, Bali beds,
umbrellas, lotions
♦ Attendants on duty
Other Common Area Attributes: (Points allocated as appropriate)
♦ Additional Recreation Facilities/Programs
♦ Non-use Fee(s)
♦ Spa
-20-

Guestroom
General Décor
Style
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
2D, plus:
♦ Significant
enhancements to
materials, design
with increased
functionality
comfort
3D, plus:
design and/or
function
of comfort
4D, plus:
and effect
Bed ♦ Basic materials,
design (headboard,
bed base and
mattress)
♦ -Or- no headboard
Modestly enhanced
materials, design
(headboard, bed base,
mattress)
e.g., quilted, soft top,
etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
headboard
♦ Mattress includes
comfort
enhancement
e.g., pillow top, foam
padding, adjustable
comfort level, etc.
3D plus:
♦ Over-sized or
custom made
headboard, bed base,
mattress
4D, plus:
Bedding ♦ Basic bed covering
materials, design
♦ Bed linens are of
common blends,
thread counts
(sheer, coarse to
touch)
♦ Pillows are of a
standard grade (thin
Polyester batting)
♦ Modestly enhanced
bed covering
materials, design
(quilted)
♦ Bed linens are
smooth to touch
♦ Pillows are of an
enhanced grade
(thick Cluster Fiber)
2D, plus:
Three accent features
e.g., triple sheeting,
overstuffed duvet,
skirting, bed
throw/scarf, multiple
pillows, accent pillows/
shams
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale bed
covering materials,
design
♦ Bed linens are very
soft to the touch and
tightly woven
♦ Pillows are of an
upscale grade
e.g., down, natural
memory fibers, hypo-
allergenic, etc.
4D, plus:
♦ Embroidered pillow
cases/shams
♦ Luxuriously soft,
silk-like feel
Floor
Coverings
plain ceramic tile,
painted concrete, low
density pile carpet
(with limited/no
padding— floor feels
hard), etc.
Modestly enhanced
materials, design
e.g., floating wood
laminates, patterned
linoleum/vinyl, medium
density pile carpet of
simple design/ pattern
(with padding that
provides average
comfort underfoot),
etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative materials
and design with
inlays
e.g., wood laminates,
carpet, ceramic/
stone/glass tile,
polished/stamped
concrete, terra cotta,
etc.
have decorative area
rugs in seating areas
and other locations
as appropriate
3D, plus:
Highest grade
materials
e.g., wood, marble,
granite/ other upscale
stone floors, high
density pile carpet
(with padding that
provides exceptional
comfort underfoot),
etc.
4D, plus:
textured
enhancements
and effect
♦ Area rugs are
luxurious
-21-

Guestroom
(Continued)
Free Floor
Space
by size and/or
placement of
appointments
Modest restrictions
due to size and/or
placement of
appointments
No restrictions, as
placement of
proportioned to room
size and traffic flow
3D, plus:
Room size and
placement of
spaciousness allowing
increased ease of
movement for multiple
guests
4D, plus:
Room size and
placement of
ultimate level of
comfort, privacy and
relaxation
Furniture
Quality &
Design
design
and/or coordination
comfort
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
enhancements to
materials, design
with increased
functionality
comfort
3D, plus:
e.g., granite/stone,
solid wood, polished
metals, high-gloss
lacquers, veneer
finishes with solid
wood accents, high-
grade laminate insets,
etc.
♦ Distinctive design
and/or function
e.g., antiques, leather,
plush padding, designer
fabric, sculptured
shape, crisp line, etc.
of comfort
4D, plus:
♦ Custom
workmanship
and effect
Guest
Information
♦ Guest-service
directory
♦ Local Business flyers
e.g., food, attractions,
transportation, etc.
♦ Notepad and pen
2D, plus:
Enhanced materials,
design
3D, plus:
design
♦ -Or- digital format
♦ Additional reading
materials
4D, plus:
♦ Assortment of
complimentary daily
newspapers (room
delivery upon
request)
Illumination ♦ ≥ Three lighting
fixtures reflect basic
materials, design
and/or functionality
illumination
1D plus:
Lighting fixtures reflect
modest enhancements
to materials, design
functionality and/or
placement
2D, plus:
♦ ≥ Four lighting
fixtures reflect
decorative materials,
design
♦ Well-positioned
from multiple
sources
illumination at each
key task area
3D, plus:
design
♦ Superior
functionality
provides for
ambiance options
e.g., dimmers, point
lighting, multiple
switches, remote
control and/or natural
light sources
4D, plus:
♦ Custom fixtures of
outstanding quality
♦ Leading-edge
illumination effect
-22-

Guestroom
(Continued)
Mirror Less than full-length ♦ Full-length mirror
♦ Unframed/beveled
♦ -Or- simple
metal/wood frame
2D, plus:
Decorative frame/
design enhancement
3D, plus:
Upscale materials,
design
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
Seating Layout One chair Seating for two guests 2D, plus:
♦ Desk chair with
arms
♦ One fully
upholstered chair
positioned for
television viewing
3D, plus:
♦ Seating for three
guests
e.g., loveseat, sofa or
two chairs (in addition
to desk chair)
♦ One additional
furniture piece
4D, plus:
♦ Furniture layout
clearly designed for
small grouping
♦ Two additional
furniture pieces
Storage Hang
Space for
Clothing
♦ Open wall-mounted
clothes rack
♦ Basic wire, plastic
/non-detachable
hangers
♦ Recessed area
♦ Detachable wood or
heavy metal/plastic
hangers
♦ Fully-enclosed area
♦ Closet depth is ≥22
inches and can
enclose full- length
apparel
♦ Matching, open-
hook, wood/
sculptured plastic
hangers (heavy gauge
w/metal hook)
♦ Some with skirt or
pant hanging
attachments
♦ Ample supply (for
two guests)
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale quality
enclosure
♦ Two-door width
♦ One or more
additional features
e.g., illumination,
drawers, dresser top,
shoe rack, walk-in
capability, two or
more shelves etc.
4D, plus:
♦ Closet is
illuminated
♦ Comprehensive
selection of
hangers for ≥
three guests
♦ At least two satin
hangers
♦ Two or more
additional features
Storage Space;
Supplementary
♦ Open area (shelving
/credenza)
♦ -Or- limited drawer
space
1D, plus:
♦ Multiple enclosed
drawers
♦ Accommodates the
unpacked contents
of two large
suitcases
♦ Collapsible metal
luggage rack
2D, plus:
♦ Closet provides
sufficient space for
one piece of luggage
♦ Collapsible wood
luggage rack
♦ -Or- decorative
bench available
3D, plus:
♦ Sufficient space for
two pieces of
luggage
♦ Upgraded wooden
racks/ designer-style
benches
♦ Accommodates the
unpacked contents
of three large
suitcases
4D, plus:
Sufficient space to
store all guest luggage
out of sight
Guidelines-23-

Guestroom
(Continued)
Television Type
& Placement
♦ Standard CRT TV
♦ Remote control
1D, plus:
♦ ≤ 32 inch flat panel
♦ Channel directory
♦ One additional
feature
e.g., all-in-one
multimedia hub, high-
definition channels,
free/ pay movie
channels, digital
art/property
information, mood
effects, etc.
2D, plus:
♦ ≥ 32 inch flat panel
♦ Multiple viewing
angles
♦ Two additional
features
3D, plus:
♦ Cables and cords are
hidden from view
♦ Three additional
features
4D, plus:
Custom enhancement
e.g., framing, remote
enclosure, mirrored
screen, etc.
Ventilation ♦ Window style air-
conditioning units
♦ Heat and/or air
conditioning
available on a
seasonal basis as
needed
♦ Heat and air
conditioning
available on demand
♦ Conveniently
located through-
wall HVAC units
♦ Easily accessible
controls
2D, plus:
♦ Modern and quiet
♦ Digital thermostat
control on wall
3D, plus:
Central system
4D, plus:
Quiet and
inconspicuous form
and function
design
e.g., cinder block/
laminate paneling,
wallpaper, etc.
♦ Modest
enhancements
♦ Rubber or vinyl
baseboards
♦ Decorative
enhancements
e.g., expert-smooth
painted drywall
finish (knockdown,
wall(s), etc.
♦ Wood/ ceramic
tile/carpet
baseboards
3D, plus:
enhancement
wood planking, soft
wall coverings,
wainscot, crown/cove
molding, architectural
feature, etc.
wood/stone
baseboards
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
Wall
Hangings/
Decorative
Enhancements
♦ Poster(s) or
common artwork
with unframed/thin,
un-enhanced wood,
metal, or plastic
frame(s)
♦ Common
knickknacks
1D, plus:
♦ Enhanced frame(s)
♦ -Or- other modest
appointments
Well-coordinated,
decorative
appointments
3D, plus:
Varied assortment that
provides a distinctive
or thematic upscale
appeal
4D, plus:
accent pieces
e.g., limited edition
prints, canvas art,
tapestries, or
lithographs with
enhanced matting and
preservation frames,
assorted artisan
pieces, sculptures, etc.
-24-

Guestroom
(Continued)
Window
Coverings
Basic window covering
provides for guest
privacy
1D, plus:
Modestly enhanced
materials, design or
function
e.g., blackout effect,
blinds, full-length
drapes, shutters,
sheers, fabric side
panels, rods w/finials,
valance, glass
treatment, cornice,
etc.
2D, plus:
Decorative
enhancements reflect
residential design
3D, plus:
The overall treatments
are upscale and
provide a significant
visual interest
4D, plus:
♦ Custom design,
luxurious fabrics
Work Space/
Writing
Surface
(A writing surface is
judged on the basis of
available space)
♦ Minimal area
e.g., duplex, triplex, or
small task table
♦ Sufficient space for a
laptop computer and
one 8x10 inch item
♦ Medium-sized desk
or task table
laptop computer and
two 8x10 inch items
♦ Large desk or task
table
laptop computer and
three 8x10 inch
items
♦ Electrical outlet at
desktop (for guest
use)
3D, plus:
laptop computer and
four 8x10 inch items
♦ Multiple electrical
outlets at desktop
4D, plus:
♦ Space is driven by
unique style/design
♦ Uncluttered, with
efficient
functionality
Other Guestroom Attributes: (Points allocated as appropriate)
♦ Ceilings ♦ Refrigerator / Honor bar
♦ Coffee Maker ♦ Robes
♦ Internet ♦ Safe
♦ Iron & Board ♦ Slippers
♦ Microwave ♦ Technology
♦ Non-use Fee(s) ♦ Umbrella
♦ Pillows & Blankets; Extra Availability
-25-

Bathroom
General Décor
Style
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements to
materials, design
and/or coordination
comfort
2D, plus:
♦ Significant
enhancements to
materials, design
with increased
functionality
comfort
3D, plus:
design and/or
function
of comfort
4D, plus:
and effect
Cabinetry Skirting partially
conceals plumbing
Skirting completely
conceals plumbing
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale, furniture-
finished skirting
♦ Enclosed cabinetry
♦ Multiple shelving,
and/or drawers
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
Counter/ Shelf
Space; Available
e.g., glass shelving,
metal, or sheet
laminate
1D, plus:
♦ Modestly-enhanced
materials, design
e.g., poured acrylic,
cultured marble/
granite, etc.
♦ ≥ 3 sq. ft.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
e.g., granite, ceramic
tile, etc.
♦ ≥6 sq. ft.
3D, plus:
design
e.g., marble or other
solid stone
♦ ≥ 8 sq. ft.
4D, plus:
♦ Multiple counters
and/or shelves
Floor
Coverings
painted concrete, etc.
Modestly enhanced
materials, design
e.g., ceramic tile,
patterned
linoleum/vinyl, etc.
Decorative materials
and design with
inlays
e.g., ceramic/
stone/glass tile,
polished/stamped
concrete, terra cotta,
etc.
3D, plus:
♦ Highest grade
materials
e.g., marble, granite/
other upscale stone
floors, etc.
have area rug(s) as
appropriate
4D, plus:
textured
enhancements
and effect
♦ Area rugs are
luxurious
Free Floor
Space
by size and/or
placement of
appointments
Modest restrictions
due to size and/or
placement of
appointments;
(If vanity area is
separate from the
toilet area, it is
positioned in plain
view of the
guestroom)
No restrictions, as
placement of
proportioned to room
size and traffic flow; (If
vanity area is separate
from the toilet area, it
is positioned in
restricted view from
the rest of the
guestroom)
3D, plus:
Room size and
placement of
spaciousness, allowing
increased ease of
movement
4D, plus:
Room size and
placement of
ultimate level of
comfort and relaxation
for multiple guests

Bathroom
(Continued)
Illumination ♦ Basic lighting fixtures
illumination
1D plus:
Modestly enhanced
lighting fixtures
e.g., box/egg crate
style, Hollywood
bulbs, enhanced
glass/plastic cover, etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative lighting
fixtures
♦ Multiple bulbs and
covers
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale design and
materials
♦ Multiple locations
♦ Illuminated shower
at each location
4D, plus:
♦ Custom function(s)
provides for
ambiance options
e.g., dimmers, point
lighting, multiple
switches, and/or
natural light sources
♦ Leading-edge
illumination effect
Mirror
Basic materials, design ♦ Modest design/size
enhancement
♦ ≥12 sq. ft.
2D, plus:
Decoratively framed/
designed
e.g., floating
3D, plus:
design
♦ ≥ 15 sq. ft.
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
e.g., television,
defogger, built-in
lighting, etc.
Personal Care
(If eco-friendly options
exist, dispensers must
coordinate with
General Décor Style
as described
previously)
Two small (< ¾ oz.)
bars of soap (or
equivalent)
1D, plus:
♦ Two medium (≥ ¾
oz.) bars of soap
♦ One packet or
bottled item
♦ Modest presentation
2D, plus:
♦ Multi-piece personal
care package
includes:
o One large (≥ 1¼
oz.) bar of soap
o One medium (≥
¾ oz.) bar of
soap;
o Two (≥ ¾ oz.)
bottled items
♦ Decorative
presentation
3D, plus:
♦ Enhanced by
fragrance, natural
supplement,
packaging, etc.,
includes:
o Two large (≥ 1¼
oz.) bars of soap
(or equivalent)
o Three (≥ 1 oz.)
bottled items
o Two additional
items
♦ Upscale presentation
4D, plus:
♦ Luxuriant selection
of fashionable bath
products
♦ Ample sized (≥ 1½
oz.) bars of soap
and bottled items
(≥1¼ oz.)
Shower Base
(If separate from tub
or shower only)
e.g., fiberglass, metal,
etc.
♦ Modestly enhanced
materials
e.g., acrylic, ceramic
tile, etc.
♦ -Or- design
e.g., irregular shape,
rectangular, rounded
corner or neo angle,
etc.
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
e.g., ceramic tile,
cultured marble/
granite
♦ >9 sq. ft.
design
e.g., marble, granite,
stone/porcelain tiles
♦ >12 sq. ft.
4D, plus:
♦ Custom treatment
♦ Separate shower and
tub
Shower
Curtain/Door
e.g., plastic or vinyl
curtain
♦ Modest materials,
design enhancement
♦ Lightweight curtain
e.g., vinyl/ polyester
♦ -Or- acrylic door
with aluminum frame
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
♦ Double curtain
♦ -Or- lightweight
glass door with
aluminum frame
♦ -Or- door less
design
3D, plus:
design
e.g., linen texture,
nylon, hemp,
cotton/cotton-poly
blend
♦ -Or- heavyweight
glass door
with/without metal
frame
4D, plus:
♦ Fixed door
enclosure (etched,
frosted, embossed,
tinted, etc.)
-26--27-

Bathroom
(Continued)
Shower
Fixtures
♦ Basic metal or plastic
♦ Single function
♦ Fixed showerhead
1D, plus:
♦ Plastic fixture
♦ Multiple settings
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
♦ Metal finish
♦ Single/multiple
settings
3D, plus:
Upscale materials,
design
4D, plus:
Custom water
features, e.g., body
jets, handheld
sprayers, multiple
showerheads, panel
systems, steam
shower, etc.
Sink ♦ Basic materials,
design
♦ Wall-mounted (no
base)
1D, plus:
♦ Wall-mounted,
vanity style
♦ Modest
enhancement to
materials, design
♦ Self-rimming
porcelain/porcelain
on steel
♦ -Or- seamless
poured acrylic or
cultured
marble/granite
2D, plus:
♦ Decorative
materials, design
e.g., under-mounted,
pedestal, vessel, etc.
3D, plus:
and/or functionality
e.g., glass, stainless
steel, colored vitreous
china, brass, nickel,
copper, marble,
real/synthetic stone,
etc.
4D, plus:
Multiple sinks
Toilet ♦ Basic design
♦ Two-piece, round
(with/without lid)
Two-piece, elongated
(with lid)
2D, plus:
Decorative design
enhancement
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale design
♦ -Or- increased
functionality
♦ Recessed area
4D, plus:
Enclosed toilet-only
area
Towels ♦ Basic, lightweight
♦ Rough to touch
♦ Low absorbency
♦ Displayed on caddies
1D, plus:
♦ Modest
enhancements in
design
♦ Displayed on bars
and/or shelves
2D, plus:
♦ Medium weight
♦ Soft to touch
♦ Medium absorbency
3D, plus:
♦ Heavyweight
♦ Plush to touch
♦ Firm, self-supporting
feel
♦ Premium cotton
with high
absorbency
4D, plus:
♦ Generous sized
towels or bath
sheets
♦ Luxurious
appearance, with
intricate and detailed
enhancements to
design
Tub
(If available)
♦ Basic materials
e.g., fiberglass, acrylic,
porcelain on steel, etc.
♦ Straight sided
rectangular design
♦ < 5 ft. length
♦ -Or- one-piece
fiberglass tub and
shower surround
combination
1D, plus:
Standard size (5 ft.
length x 2.5 ft. width)
2D, plus:
Decoratively enhanced
materials, design
design
e.g., oversized (>5ft.
length x 2.5 ft. width)
oval, round/free form
♦ And/or enhanced
functionality
e.g., water jets,
handheld sprayer, etc.
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
e.g., two-person
capability, European
soaking style,
contoured back, built-
in lumbar back
support, etc.
-28-

Bathroom
Guidelines
(Continued)
Tub / Shower
Surround
e.g., fiberglass, metal,
etc.
Modest enhancement
to materials, design
e.g., acrylic, ceramic
tile, etc.
♦ Decorative
materials, design
♦ Ceramic tile/solid
surface
e.g., cultured
marble/granite,
common mosaics, etc.
♦ Tub and shower
height soap dishes
3D,plus:
design
♦ Solid surface
e.g., marble, granite,
stone or glass/
porcelain tiles
4D, plus:
♦ Custom treatment
♦ Integrated
seating/shelving
design
e.g., cinder block/
laminate paneling,
wallpaper, etc.
♦ Modest
enhancements
♦ Rubber or vinyl
baseboards
♦ Decorative
enhancements
e.g., expert-smooth
painted drywall
finish (knockdown,
wall(s), etc.
♦ Wood/ ceramic tile
baseboards
3D, plus:
enhancement
wood planking,
wainscot, crown/cove
molding, architectural
feature, etc.
wood/stone tile
baseboards
4D, plus:
Leading-edge effect
Wall Hangings
/ Decorative
Enhancements
One modest
appointment
♦ One-piece of
decorative artwork
♦ -Or- other
decorative
appointment
3D, plus:
♦ Upscale artwork
♦ -Or- other
appointments that
provide a distinctive
or thematic upscale
appeal
4D, plus:
accent pieces
e.g., framed art,
assorted artisan
pieces/ sculptures,
floral displays or plants
Other Bathroom Attributes: (Points allocated as appropriate)
♦ Ceilings ♦ Scale
♦ Hair Dryer ♦ Telephone
♦ Makeup Mirror ♦ Television
♦ Nightlight ♦ Vanity Seating
-29-

Section 3: Additional Information
TThhee AAAAAA FFoouurr aanndd FFiivvee DDiiaammoonndd RRaattiinnggss
These prestigious ratings are achieved by a small percentage of all Approved properties — typically the most luxurious and
pampering properties throughout North America. Less than one half of 1 percent of AAA Approved lodgings receive the Five
Diamond Rating, while less than 5 percent receive the Four Diamond Rating. Establishments at these rating levels must consistently
reflect upscale and extraordinary characteristics in their physical attributes and guest services.
FFoouurr aanndd FFiivvee DDiiaammoonndd SSeerrvviiccee EExxppeeccttaattiioonnss
AAA Four Diamond Properties
Properties identified by AAA as potential candidates for the
Four Diamond Rating must employ competent, full-time
personnel who provide guests with a comprehensive level of
hospitality. Key guest service interaction points are:
♦ PHONE OPERATIONS
♦ ARRIVAL AND DEPARTURE
♦ CHECK IN/OUT
♦ LUGGAGE ASSISTANCE
♦ ROOM DELIVERY
♦ HOUSEKEEPING
♦ GENERAL/CONCIERGE SERVICES
AAA Five Diamond Properties
Properties identified by AAA as potential candidates for the
Five Diamond Rating undergo multiple unannounced
evaluations by a AAA inspector and a final decision by a panel
of experts. Properties that receive the Five Diamond Rating
are subject to rigorous on-site assessments of all guest
service areas. Each section is assigned a point value based on
the overall levels of competency, refinement, and hospitality.
-30-

AAA Hospitality Standards
1...Reservation Services
♦ Operator answers telephone within three rings
♦ Operator extends an appropriate greeting
♦ Reservationist thanks caller for contacting the
property
♦ Reservationist provides an appropriate introduction
to guest
♦ Reservationist addresses caller by name as
appropriate for the manner of the guest
♦ Reservationist anticipates caller's needs or offers a
personalized recommendation
♦ Reservationist provides rate structure and room
availability
♦ Reservationist provides an overview of facilities and
services
♦ Reservationist exhibits competent/accurate
knowledge of all associated facilities and hours of
operation
♦ Reservationist reviews reservation request
♦ Reservationist exhibits a sincere desire to comply
with all guest requests
♦ Reservationist is efficient and sensitive to the manner
of the guest
♦ Reservationist extends an appropriate closing
♦ Property provides follow-up reservation confirmation
in advance of arrival
♦ The guest feels well served
2...Arrival Services
♦ Cars in queue are acknowledged and appropriately
handled on arrival
♦ Attendant promptly opens the car door
♦ Attendant extends an appropriate welcome
♦ Attendant provides an appropriate introduction
♦ Attendant confirms guest's name
♦ Attendant uses guest's name as appropriate for the
manner of the guest
♦ Attendant explains parking procedures
♦ Valet parking is offered
♦ Attendant promptly offers to unload luggage
♦ Attendant explains luggage handling procedures
♦ Attendant provides unsolicited direction to
registration area
♦ Attendant anticipates guest's needs or offers a
♦ Attendant is efficient and sensitive to the manner of
the guest
♦ Attendant exhibits a sincere desire and compliance to
all guest requests
♦ Attendant or lobby greeter escorts guest to the
appropriate area
♦ Attendant extends an appropriate closing
3...Check In Services
♦ Attendant extends an appropriate welcome
♦ Attendant provides an appropriate introduction
♦ Attendant addresses guest by name during initial
greeting
manner of the guest
♦ Preregistered guests are not solicited for additional
information
♦ Attendant confirms rate and type of room
♦ Attendant discreetly provides room number
♦ Attendant provides all registration materials to the
guest in a manner that is convenient for the guest
all guest requests
the guest
♦ Escort of guest and belongings to room is seamless
-31-

4...Bell Services (Check In)
♦ Attendant extends an appropriate greeting
manner of the guest
♦ Attendant takes the initiative in providing information
about all facilities
all guest requests
♦ Attendant places luggage on luggage stand or in
appropriate area
♦ Attendant explains features and functions of room
♦ Attendant offers to fill ice bucket
the guest
5…Evening Housekeeping Services
♦ Attendant folds back or removes bedding as
appropriate
♦ Attendant straightens bathroom
♦ Attendant refolds toilet tissue point
♦ Attendant cleans soiled surfaces
♦ Attendant replaces or straightens (if reuse elected by
guest) used towels
♦ Attendant replenishes used amenities
♦ Attendant empties wastebasket
♦ Attendant adjusts drapes as appropriate for manner
of the guest
♦ Attendant adjusts room lighting
♦ Attendant delivers gift amenity such as goodnight
wish or chocolates
♦ Attendant refreshes ice
♦ Attendant replaces used glasses
♦ Attendant displays evening services available to the
guest, such as: laundry, room service or shoeshine
information
♦ Attendant leaves personalized message for guest
♦ There is additional evidence of personalized services
6…Wake-Up Call Services
♦ Service number is answered within three rings
♦ Operator uses guest's name as appropriate for the
manner of the guest
♦ Operator anticipates guest's needs or offers a
♦ Operator is efficient and sensitive to the manner of
the guest
♦ Operator extends an appropriate closing
♦ Live call is received within five minutes of requested
time
♦ Message includes an appropriate greeting
♦ Message includes the use of guest's name as
appropriate for the manner of the guest
♦ Message includes time of call
the guest
7A...Room Service (Order Services)
♦ Service is available 24/7
manner of the guest
♦ Operator exhibits a sincere desire and compliance to
all guest requests
♦ Operator repeats order to guest for confirmation
the guest
♦ Operator provides time estimate for delivery (within
30 minutes)
-32-

7B...Room Service (Delivery Services)
♦ Delivered within five minutes of operator's
commitment (guest is notified in advance if more than
five minutes early)
♦ Attendant uses guest name as appropriate for the
manner of the guest
all guest requests
♦ Attendant confirms tray/table
placement
♦ Attendant is appropriately
conversant during set-up and
delivery
♦ Attendant reviews guest order
♦ Attendant ask guest's permission
to prepare table, pour beverage
and remove food cover(s); acts
accordingly
♦ Food presentation and quality of
ingredients reflect an upscale
experience
♦ All appropriate dishware and
linens are of an upscale quality
♦ All food is served at the proper
temperature
♦ All food is prepared as ordered
♦ Attendant provides written or
spoken instructions for table/tray
removal
♦ Attendant is efficient and
sensitive to the manner of the guest
♦ Trays/tables are removed within 15 minutes, on
request
8...Bell Services (Check Out)
manner of the guest
♦ Operator exhibits a sincere desire and compliance to
all guest requests
♦ Operator offers to retrieve car or arrange other
transportation
♦ Operator is efficient yet and sensitive to the manner
of the guest
♦ Attendant arrives within five minutes of request
♦ Attendant uses guest's name as appropriate to the
manner of the guest
all guest requests
♦ Attendant is appropriately conversant with guest
while providing assistance
the guest
9...Check Out Services
♦ Attendant recognizes waiting guests
appropriately
♦ Attendant extends an appropriate
greeting
♦ Attendant uses guest's name as
appropriate for the manner of the
guest
♦ Attendant inquires about guest stay
or converses as otherwise
appropriate with guest
♦ Attendant exhibits a sincere desire
and compliance to all guest requests
♦ Attendant places a copy of bill for
review into the guest's hand
♦ Attendant confirms payment method
♦ Attendant presents guest folio
options as appropriate
♦ Attendant expresses a sincere thank
you for staying at the property
♦ Attendant sincerely encourages guest to return
the guest
-33-

10...Departure Services
♦ Given adequate notice, the guest's vehicle is waiting
or alternate transportation is readily available
manner of the guest
♦ Attendant is appropriately conversant with guest
♦ Attendant reviews all of guest's belongings and their
placement in vehicle
♦ Attendant opens and closes door for guest(s)
the guest
all guest requests
11...Concierge Services
♦ Concierge is on duty or a "special services" number is
available for guest use 24/7
manner of the guest
♦ Associate exhibits a sincere desire and compliance to
all guest requests
♦ Attendant demonstrates an extensive knowledge of
all area attractions and services
♦ Attendant fulfills guest's special request(s)
the guest
12...Miscellaneous Staff Services
♦ All associates exhibit a professional vocabulary devoid
of slang
♦ Guests are graciously provided directions or offered
assistance via escort on request
♦ All associates consistently maintain eye contact with
guests
♦ There is evidence that all associates are empowered
by management to resolve guest issues immediately
♦ All staff associates fulfill guest's special requests
♦ All phone calls are answered within three rings
♦ All associates are appropriately attired; name tags are
clearly visible
♦ All associates demonstrate appropriate behavior
♦ All associates demonstrate appropriate hygiene
♦ Short-notice pressing is available
♦ Shoeshine service is available
♦ At least one food and beverage outlet is comparable
to a Four or Five Diamond Rating
-34-

TThhee LLiissttiinngg
ONCE A PROPERTY IS APPROVED, AAA PUBLISHING
DETERMINES THE CONTENT AND FORMAT OF
LISTINGS IN OUR PRODUCTS. The basic property
information, which contains no advertising or promotional
verbiage, is published in AAA
products at no cost to the
establishment.
Listing copy describing the lodging
is based in part on objective
information provided by the
establishment. This listing
information is updated annually,
and establishments are contacted
accordingly. Failure to provide
listing information in a timely
manner may result in the deletion
of your establishment from our products.
Listings also include narrative description composed by
AAA’s professionally trained inspectors. Inspectors employ a
degree of skilled subjectivity to convey the feel of an
experience to AAA members.
AAA Approved and Diamond Rated lodgings are eligible to
participate in AAA’s Official Appointment licensing program
that entitles the establishment to use the renowned AAA
(CAA in Canada) emblem and Diamond Rating in advertising
and promotions. This program also entitles the establishment
to an enhanced listing in AAA publications. AAA Approved
and Diamond Rated lodgings are also eligible to purchase
display advertising in AAA publications
FYI Designation
This designation identifies properties that have not been
Diamond Rated by a AAA inspector, but are notable and
offer potential member value. These properties are unrated
due to one of the following reasons:
The property is too new to rate.
The property is under construction.
The property is undergoing extensive
renovations.
The property has not been evaluated.
The property does not meet all Approval
Requirements.
LLooddggiinngg CCllaassssiiffiiccaattiioonnss
ALL DIAMOND RATED LODGINGS ARE CLASSIFIED
USING KEY DESCRIPTIVE ELEMENTS.
STYLE OF OPERATION:
Bed and Breakfast: Typically owner-operated with a high
degree of personal touches. Guests are encouraged to
interact during evening and breakfast hours. A continental or
full, hot breakfast is included in the room rate.
Cabin: Often located in wooded, rural, or waterfront
locations. Freestanding units are typically rustic and of basic
design. As a rule, essential cleaning supplies, kitchen utensils,
and complete bed and bath linens are supplied.
Condominium: Apartment-style accommodations of varying
design or décor, units often contain one or more bedrooms,
a living room, full kitchen, and an eating area. As a rule,
essential cleaning supplies, kitchen utensils, and complete bed
and bath linens are supplied.
Cottage: Often located in wooded, rural, or waterfront
locations. Freestanding units are typically home style in
design and décor. As a rule, essential cleaning supplies,
kitchen utensils, and complete bed and bath linens are
supplied.
Country Inn: Although similar in definition to a bed and
breakfast, country inns are usually larger in scale with
spacious public areas and offer a dining facility that serves
breakfast and dinner.
Hotel: Typically, a multistory property with interior room
entrances offering a variety of guest unit styles. The
magnitude of the public areas is determined by the overall
theme, location and service level, but may include a variety of
facilities such as a restaurant, shops, fitness center, spa,
business center, and/or meeting rooms.
House: Freestanding units of varying home-style design.
Typically larger scale, often containing two or more
bedrooms, a living room, full kitchen, dining room, and
multiple bathrooms. As a rule, essential cleaning supplies,
kitchen utensils, and complete bed and bath linens are
supplied.
Motel: A one- or two-story roadside property with exterior
room entrances and drive up parking. Public areas and
facilities are often limited in size and/or availability.
Ranch: Typically a working ranch with an obvious rustic,
Western theme featuring equestrian-related activities and a
variety of guest unit styles.
-35-

SUBCLASSIFICATIONS (IF APPLICABLE): Historic: Over 75 years old with one of the following
documented historical features:
Maintained the integrity of the historical natureBoutique: Often thematic, typically informal yet highly
personalized; may have a luxurious or quirky style which is
fashionable or unique.
Listed on the National Register of Historic Places
National Historic Landmark or located in a National
Register Historic District
Casino: Extensive gambling facilities are available, such as:
blackjack, craps, keno, and slot machines. Resort: Extensive recreational facilities and programs may
include golf, tennis, skiing, fishing, water sports, spa
treatments or professionally-guided activities.Classic: Renowned and landmark properties, older than 50
years, well known for their unique style and ambiance.
Retro: Overall theme reflects a contemporary design
reinterpreting styles from a past era.Contemporary: Overall theme reflects characteristics of the
present mainstream trends.
Vacation Rental: Typically houses, condos, cottages or
cabins; these properties are a “home away from home” self-
catering accommodation.
Extended Stay: Offers a predominance of long-term
accommodations with a designated full-service kitchen area
within each unit.
Vintage: Overall theme reflects upon and maintains the
authentic traits and experience of a past era.
AAcccceessssiibbiilliittyy All requests may be addressed to:
Accessible Features Icon
AAA Tourism Information Development
1000 AAA Drive, M/S 51
Denotes a property that has some accessible features. It may
be fully accessible, semi-accessible, or meet some of the
needs of hearing-impaired individuals.
Heathrow, FL 32746-5063
Accessibility is not a requirement for listing and will not affect
your Diamond Rating. However, we strongly encourage you
to make every effort to meet the needs of all your guests –
including the mature traveler and those with disabilities.
MMeemmbbeerr CCoommmmeenntt PPrroocceedduurreess
AAA MEMBER RELATIONS CLOSELY MONITORS THE
NUMBER AND TYPE OF COMMENTS SUBMITTED
ABOUT APPROVED PROPERTIES. All comments are
carefully reviewed for validity and included as part of the
property record. If complaints are received, AAA will notify
the establishment to provide an opportunity to respond and
resolve the matter within a reasonable period of time. If a
member complaint is determined to be of an extreme nature,
AAA may act to disapprove a property immediately.
If a property is disapproved for member complaints, a written
request for a re-evaluation may be submitted, accompanied
by an explanation of the actions taken to limit future
complaints. Note: Properties may not reapply until one year
has passed from the date of disapproval.
TThhee AAAAAA AAppppeeaallss PPrroocceessss
THE APPEALS PROCESS IS A RESOURCE FOR ALL
INSPECTED PROPERTIES.
What can I appeal?
You may appeal your property’s Approval status or Diamond
Rating. Each situation is handled on an individual basis.
How do I file an appeal?
First, contact AAA Travel Information-Customer Service,
Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:15 p.m. (Eastern Time)
at 407-444-8370. In many cases, our analysts will be able to
address your question(s) immediately.
If there is a continuing need for additional information or
discussion, we will direct your call to the AAA Regional
Manager for your area.
If an issue remains unresolved after the above steps, an
establishment may choose to present relevant information to
the AAA Appeals Committee for objective review. All
appeals must be submitted by property management in
writing and may include pictures, documents or other
pertinent materials to support the appeal. In order to
expedite this process, appeals should outline the specific
concerns in a succinct manner. Each appeal is thoroughly
-36-

researched and given thoughtful consideration and a
substantive reply by the committee. The committee’s decision
on your appeal is considered as AAA’s final response. You
will be notified as to the status of your appeal within 45 days
of receipt of your written statement.
All appeals should be sent to:
AAA Appeals Committee
GGrreeeenn PPrrooggrraammss
AAA SUPPORTS ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT AND
SUSTAINABILITY THROUGHOUT THE LODGING
INDUSTRY TO THE EXTENT THAT TRULY EFFECTIVE
PROGRAMS MAINTAIN QUALITY STANDARDS OF
GUEST COMFORT. We strongly encourage continued use of
programs that offer guests choices without consequences for
noncompliance and reduce waste without reducing guest
comfort.
The AAA Eco Program identifies AAA
Approved lodgings that are eco-certified by
designated, well-established government and
private programs.
AAA is not involved in the evaluation of a property's
environmental practices. The eco status determined by
reputable certification programs is reported by AAA as a
service to members who consider sustainability when
selecting lodgings. The green Eco icon provides generic notice
only of properties certified by one or more of the recognized
programs listed here: AAA.biz/Approved. Properties seeking
to become eco-certified should contact the program(s)
operating in their region. Eco-certification programs seeking
to provide qualifying "Green" hotels for potential inclusion in
AAA publications should complete the Eco Verification Form.
CCoonnttaacctt IInnffoorrmmaattiioonn
Questions?
Please contact AAA at: AAA.biz/CustomerService
Evaluation Applications, Rating and Listing
Information
(407) 444-8370
TourBook Advertising and Official Appointments
(407) 444-8280
Or:
AAA Tourism Information Development
Properties in Southern California
should contact the following AAA
club:
Automobile Club of Southern California
P.O. Box 25001
Santa Ana, CA 92799-5001
Evaluations, Ratings, and Official Appointments
(714) 885-2247
TourBook Advertising
(714) 885-2375
-37-

Then and Now…
Your Direct Connection to over 53 Million Members

AAA_Diamond_Rating_Guidelines_2012

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

AAA_Diamond_Rating_Guidelines_2012