E-Books Workflows
The Ongoing Challenges of Managing
Materials and Improving Discoverability
Molly Beisler
Head, Discovery Services
University of Nevada, Reno
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Summary
• What has been happening in the academic e-book
environment over the past 10 years
• Workflow and organizational change in
UNR’s Technical Services
• New (and ongoing) challenges
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Technical Services ca. 2005
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Technical
Services
Acquisitions Serials Cataloging
Workflow
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Acquisitions
• Ordering
• Activation
Cataloging
• Catalog titles
• Add URLs in
856 field in
MARC
record
Technical Services ca. 2008
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Technical
Services
Acquisitions
E-Resources
& Serials
Metadata &
Cataloging
Workflow
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Acquisitions
• Ordering
ERS
• License
management
• Activation
• Receipt of files
for batch
loading
MCD
• Batch loading
of titles into
catalog
• Maintenance of
records
• Merging
duplicates
• Fixing
problem URLs
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Photo by Bob Semk, CC BY-NC-ND
Challenges
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
• Interdepartmental communication
• Need for evaluation prior to acquisition
• How to handle licenses for monographs?
• How to handle changes to
packages/platforms?
• How to track owned vs. leased titles?
• How to handle DDA?
• What impact will discovery service have?
Major changes needed
• Librarian coordinating access & discovery
• Shift ILS from single to separate record
approach
• New ILS coding/tracking for DDA e-books
• Expanded use of ERM: for e-book packages,
more detail in license records
• Automated workflow (using SharePoint)
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Technical Services ca. 2012
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Knowledge Access
Management
Services (KAMS)
E-Resources &
Acquisitions
Services
Knowledge Access
& Discovery
Librarian
Metadata &
Cataloging
Design &
Discovery
Team
SharePoint workflow: 3 paths
1. Database
subscription or
standing order
• E-resources staff
(ERS): full process,
from ordering
through activation
and testing access
2. One-time
purchase, no annual
fees
• Acquisition staff up
through activation
• Ordered through
YBP, with licenses
on file
• ERS: activation and
testing access
3. One-time
purchase, with
annual fees
• Acquisitions staff
up through
activation
• ERS: recurring fees
& license, then
activation and
testing access
MCD staff load MARC records and maintain links
ERS monitors changes to subscriptions and notifies MCD
Data Gathered in SharePoint
Worksheet
• Name of requestor
• Date
• E-book/package title
• E-book type
• Order type (one-time,
subscription, etc.)
• Annual access fee?
• Price
• Publisher name
• Vendor contact information
• Review by …
• Approved by …
• Order status
• Order instructions
• Order record number
• License data: required or not,
new, addendum, etc.; date
signed; record created in ILS
• Access start date
• Title list
• Trial information
• MARC record details: availability
and quality review
• Comments
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Technical Services 2014
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Knowledge Access
Management
Services (KAMS)
E-Resources &
Acquisitions
Services
Metadata &
Cataloging
Discovery Services
Workflow: New things to accommodate
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
• Worksheet in SharePoint grows from 36 to 52
fields
– When is it too much …?
• How to handle and communicate fluctuation
in e-book holdings?
• Managing E-books in discovery service:
Choosing where and how users will find books
Impact of Discovery Service on E-book Use
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Online Views Downloads
Fall 2014 (only accessible
through Databases A-Z list)
448 31
Spring 2015 (records in
Summon but not in
catalog)
8286 536
Over 1800% increase Over 1700% increase
The Future
• Workflow solutions from vendors, with next-
generation ILS systems?
• Will products from different vendors continue to work
effectively together?
• Will discovery services become the solution, with no
more ebook records in catalogs?
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Advice
• Automate what you can (but double-check
what’s happening)
• Use your ERM to its full potential (or get an
ERM if your library doesn’t have one)
• Be flexible!
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno
Questions?
Contact: Molly Beisler abeisler@unr.edu
Resources:
Beisler, Amalia, and Lisa Kurt. "E-Book Workflow from Inquiry to Access: Facing
the Challenges to Implementing e-Book Access at the University of Nevada,
Reno." Collaborative Librarianship 4.3 (2012): 96.
Beisler, Amalia, and Katherine Dirk. "Changing from Single to Separate Records:
A Case Study from the University of Nevada, Reno." Serials Review 41.1 (2015):
8-14
UNR E-book LibGuide: http://guides.library.unr.edu/e-books
MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER
University of Nevada, Reno

E-book Workflows: The Ongoing Challenges of Managing Materials and Improving Discoverability

  • 1.
    E-Books Workflows The OngoingChallenges of Managing Materials and Improving Discoverability Molly Beisler Head, Discovery Services University of Nevada, Reno MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 2.
    Summary • What hasbeen happening in the academic e-book environment over the past 10 years • Workflow and organizational change in UNR’s Technical Services • New (and ongoing) challenges MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 3.
    Technical Services ca.2005 MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno Technical Services Acquisitions Serials Cataloging
  • 4.
    Workflow MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER Universityof Nevada, Reno Acquisitions • Ordering • Activation Cataloging • Catalog titles • Add URLs in 856 field in MARC record
  • 5.
    Technical Services ca.2008 MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno Technical Services Acquisitions E-Resources & Serials Metadata & Cataloging
  • 6.
    Workflow MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER Universityof Nevada, Reno Acquisitions • Ordering ERS • License management • Activation • Receipt of files for batch loading MCD • Batch loading of titles into catalog • Maintenance of records • Merging duplicates • Fixing problem URLs
  • 7.
    MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER Universityof Nevada, Reno Photo by Bob Semk, CC BY-NC-ND
  • 8.
    Challenges MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER Universityof Nevada, Reno • Interdepartmental communication • Need for evaluation prior to acquisition • How to handle licenses for monographs? • How to handle changes to packages/platforms? • How to track owned vs. leased titles? • How to handle DDA? • What impact will discovery service have?
  • 9.
    Major changes needed •Librarian coordinating access & discovery • Shift ILS from single to separate record approach • New ILS coding/tracking for DDA e-books • Expanded use of ERM: for e-book packages, more detail in license records • Automated workflow (using SharePoint) MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 10.
    Technical Services ca.2012 MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno Knowledge Access Management Services (KAMS) E-Resources & Acquisitions Services Knowledge Access & Discovery Librarian Metadata & Cataloging Design & Discovery Team
  • 11.
    SharePoint workflow: 3paths 1. Database subscription or standing order • E-resources staff (ERS): full process, from ordering through activation and testing access 2. One-time purchase, no annual fees • Acquisition staff up through activation • Ordered through YBP, with licenses on file • ERS: activation and testing access 3. One-time purchase, with annual fees • Acquisitions staff up through activation • ERS: recurring fees & license, then activation and testing access MCD staff load MARC records and maintain links ERS monitors changes to subscriptions and notifies MCD
  • 12.
    Data Gathered inSharePoint Worksheet • Name of requestor • Date • E-book/package title • E-book type • Order type (one-time, subscription, etc.) • Annual access fee? • Price • Publisher name • Vendor contact information • Review by … • Approved by … • Order status • Order instructions • Order record number • License data: required or not, new, addendum, etc.; date signed; record created in ILS • Access start date • Title list • Trial information • MARC record details: availability and quality review • Comments MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 13.
    Technical Services 2014 MATHEWSON-IGTKNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno Knowledge Access Management Services (KAMS) E-Resources & Acquisitions Services Metadata & Cataloging Discovery Services
  • 14.
    Workflow: New thingsto accommodate MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno • Worksheet in SharePoint grows from 36 to 52 fields – When is it too much …? • How to handle and communicate fluctuation in e-book holdings? • Managing E-books in discovery service: Choosing where and how users will find books
  • 15.
    Impact of DiscoveryService on E-book Use MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno Online Views Downloads Fall 2014 (only accessible through Databases A-Z list) 448 31 Spring 2015 (records in Summon but not in catalog) 8286 536 Over 1800% increase Over 1700% increase
  • 16.
    The Future • Workflowsolutions from vendors, with next- generation ILS systems? • Will products from different vendors continue to work effectively together? • Will discovery services become the solution, with no more ebook records in catalogs? MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 17.
    Advice • Automate whatyou can (but double-check what’s happening) • Use your ERM to its full potential (or get an ERM if your library doesn’t have one) • Be flexible! MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno
  • 18.
    Questions? Contact: Molly Beisler[email protected] Resources: Beisler, Amalia, and Lisa Kurt. "E-Book Workflow from Inquiry to Access: Facing the Challenges to Implementing e-Book Access at the University of Nevada, Reno." Collaborative Librarianship 4.3 (2012): 96. Beisler, Amalia, and Katherine Dirk. "Changing from Single to Separate Records: A Case Study from the University of Nevada, Reno." Serials Review 41.1 (2015): 8-14 UNR E-book LibGuide: http://guides.library.unr.edu/e-books MATHEWSON-IGT KNOWLEDGE CENTER University of Nevada, Reno

Editor's Notes

  • #5 -Traditional division of labor, monographs vs serials -Serials unit only worked with serials But then… -Quantity increased -Handling of licenses became more of an issue -Maintenance needs grew
  • #6 Adding language to better reflect what people are doing: E-Resources… and Metadata…
  • #7 -One staff person in MCD spent a lot of time merging duplicate records and processing deletions -Issues faced: Multi-vol. sets with different records for each volume, handled differently on different platforms Duplicates couldn’t be caught with ILS duplicate checking because of inconsistency with titles and ISBNs
  • #8 Serials world was becoming more manageable with ERM systems, eISSNs, and processing of updates from vendors Process didn’t translate readily to e-books -imperfect (and poorly adhered to) standards (for cataloging—provider neutral vs. provider-specific, single vs. separate records—for standard numbers, etc.) -variety of purchasing models (perpetual access, subscriptions) -variety of access models (different numbers of concurrent users, online only, downloadable)
  • #9 Blurring of department roles, overlap in responsibilities (e.g., Who loads batches of DDA e-books?)
  • #10 ILS: Coding for DDA e-books ERM: Coding for concurrent users and perpetual access
  • #12 Activation includes: WAM table, link resolver activation
  • #14 Adding complete new Discovery Services Dept, with 1 librarian + 2 staff
  • #15 Worksheet: -Consortium purchasing info -More process tracking -Discovery Services fields Fluctuation: -Staff training and more staff training -Adding text to public display for “on demand” titles Discovery: -Handling of duplicates a problem: poor matching when we own print and ebook copies -Need to check vendor lists of entitlements against knowledgebase – don’t assume knowledgebase is correct
  • #17 Workflow solutions: -Intota -OCLC Worldshare Management Services -Alma -CORAL or other open source ERMS? Is the metadata really good enough for this to work? Vendor products:
  • #18 Workflow solutions: -Intota -OCLC Worldshare Management Services -Alma -CORAL or other open source ERMS? Is the metadata really good enough for this to work? Vendor products: