SlideShare a Scribd company logo
C LO U D STAC K

 Clayton Weise cweise@iswest.net
IRC: iswcin #cloudstack on freenode
LICENSING


 This presentation and it’s contents unless otherwise
  noted are released under a Creative Commons
  Attributions, Share-Alike 3.0 unported license.
H I STO RY

   Original company formed - 2008 (VMOps)
   Project open sourced as CloudStack – May 2010
   Acquired by Citrix – July 2011
   Dropped open core – August 2011
   Release of Acton (3.0) – Real soon now
W H AT I S C LO U D STAC K ?

Open Source Infrastructure as a Service platform that
supports multiple hypervisors, complex network, firewall,
load balancer and VPN configurations, high availability, in a
multi-tenant environment.
W H AT D O ES I T R EA L LY D O ?

 Provide separation for the varied tenants
 Allocate compute resources in a deterministic manner
 Expose to the end user the ability to provision various
  computing services in a controlled manner (VLAN
  allocation, firewall rules, load balancer deployment, VM
  creation, etc)
 Manage High Availability
 Massively Scalable
 Permit the placement of resource limits to be applied
 Measuring usage over time
M U LT I P L E H Y P E RV I S O R S U P P O RT

   KVM
   XenServer
   Xen Cloud Platform
   VMware (via vCenter)
   Oracle VM
   Bare Metal
M U LT I - T E N A N T S E PA R AT I O N

 Largely built around abstraction from an end-user POV
    No interaction with hypervisor directly
    No knowledge of underlying storage
 Networking separation
    Every account has at least one dedicated/isolated VLAN
     (Tagged Networking)
    Layer 3 isolation aka Security Groups for untagged
     networking
 Option to use dedicated hardware
N E T WO R K I N G

 CloudStack has a number of network models
 They are generally broken down by:
    Method of isolation (VLAN, Security Groups)
    Physical hardware or virtual
 CloudStack largely manages network infrastructure
N E T WO R K I N G

 Services managed by CloudStack
      DHCP
      VLAN allocation
      Firewall
      NAT/Port forwarding
      Routing
      VPN
      Load Balancing
N E T WO R K I N G

 CloudStack can also manage physical network hardware
  (or the virtualized alternatives)
    F5-Big IP
    NetScaler
    Juniper SRX

 Additionally you can ‘mix and match’ some network
  elements as service offerings.
S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S

 Traditional isolation has been via VLAN
 VLANs isolate well, but have some problems scaling
    Standard has a hard limit of 4096 VLANs
    Hardware that can actually keep up with 4096 VLANs is
     VERY expensive.
    Regardless people tend to not like having arbitrary limits
     on what they can do.
 Amazon and others use layer 3 isolation (Security
  Groups)
S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S

 Assumption of a quasi-trusted Layer 2 network
 Typically will only have hypervisors directly connected to
  that network.
 Filtering/isolation occurs at the bridge device (from a
  Linux perspective – think ebtables)
 Deny by default
S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S
S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S
H I G H AVA I L A B I L I T Y

 RFMTTR – but apparently HA looks better in marketing
  slicks and is used that way across the virtualization
  industry.
 CloudStack is not a magical solution for HA – but might
  be a useful tool in the process to increase availability.
 CloudStack will watch for HA-enabled VMs to ensure that
  they are up, and that the hypervisor it’s on is up – and
  will restart on another hypervisor if it goes down.
 Redundant router
A L LO C AT I O N A LG O R I T H M S

 How do you place VMs?, allocate storage, etc.
 CloudStack ships with a number of options:
      First Fit
      Fill first
      Disperse
      Create your own
 Tags
 OS Preference
U SAG E

 Not billing per se – but does give you something to bill
  against.
 Usage stats show VM count, CPU usage, disk allocation
  and usage, network usage; all over time.
 Lots of integration and howto’s - from Excel
  spreadsheets to Ubersmith, Amysta, and Cloud Portal.
H I G H L E V E L A RC H I T EC T U R A L OV E RV I E W




            © Copyright David Baird and licensed for reuse under this CC-BY
S ECO N DA RY STO R AG E

 Used for storing templates and snapshots
 Historically NFS – just added the option of object storage
    Technically Swift, but Caringo, GlusterFS and others should
     work.
 Managed by Secondary Storage VM – manages moving
  templates and snapshots from/to primary storage, aging
  snapshots out, etc.
P R I M A RY STO R AG E

 In the UI we support NFS, iSCSI, and CLVM.
 We can also make use of local storage
    No HA, no live migration, etc.
 Shared mountpoint
    Anything that all the hypervisors can mount and write to.
R ES O U RC E D I V I S I O N

 We have some somewhat arbitrary divisions of resources
  within CloudStack
    Zones
       • Pods
           – Clusters
ZO N E

 In general practice this is used to designate a specific
  geographic location.
 Shares secondary storage resource across the entire zone
 Single network model for the entire zone
POD

 In general practice – this is used to refer a rack of
  machines or a row of racks.
 Shares guest network
C LU ST E R

 This is typically a max of 8-15 machines per cluster and
  homogenity is enforced:
    Same hypervisor (and same version of the hypervisor)
    Same CPUs
    Same networking (i.e. /dev/eth0 is connected to the same
     network across all machines)
 Primary storage is cluster specific
P L E T H O R A O F N E T WO R KS

 Management Network: Where the hypervisors and
  management server communicate
 Private Network: Default network for system VMs.
  (virtual router, secondary storage VM, Console proxy VM)
 Public Network: The public (often internet-facing
  network)
 Guest Network: The network that VMs are provisioned
  on.
 Link-local network: The RFC 3927 network used for
  communication between hypervisor and system VMs.
M A N AG E M E N T S E RV E R

 UI/API pieces are stateless (state is stored in a MySQL
  database.
 All UI functionality is an API call
API

 RESTful API interface
      Unauthenticated API interace on 8096 (for localhost)
      Authenticated API interface natively on port 8080
      Responses in XML or JSON
      http://demo4.cloudstack.org/client/api?apikey=ZRFLiXIkm
       AHqgRmZzdiXMfaROyK35P_dXxS517WSa9Tmy1Hg&comm
       and=deployVirtualMachine&serviceofferingid=1&template
       id=291&zoneid=1&signature=eXW%2fxfqx%2fhu%2frMreF
       ksVsp3cT4M%3d
UI

 Go play with the UI
Q U EST I O N S

 ASK!
CO N TAC T

   http://cloudstack.org
   Docs: https://cwiki.apache.org/CLOUDSTACK
   IRC: #cloudstack on Freenode
   Twitter/identi.ca: @cloudstack
   Mailing Lists
     https://lists.sourceforge.net/mailman/listinfo/cloudstack-users
     https://lists.sourceforge.net/mailman/listinfo/cloudstack-devel
 Forums

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

PPTX
Demystifying Networking: Data Center Networking Trends 2017
Cumulus Networks
 
PDF
Comparison between VMware and Open Stack Cloud
Saeed Siddik
 
PDF
CloudSmartz Layer 2 Direct Connect [Factsheet] | Smarter Transformation
CloudSmartz
 
DOC
Storage Area Network interview Questions
Sandeep Sharma IIMK Smart City,IoT,Bigdata,Cloud,BI,DW
 
PDF
Unified Underlay and Overlay SDNs for OpenStack Clouds
PLUMgrid
 
PPT
Drive into calico architecture
Anirban Sen Chowdhary
 
PPTX
Linux network namespaces
Mike Wilson
 
PPT
Introduction to san ( storage area networks )
sagaroceanic11
 
PPTX
Storage area network
Syed Ubaid Ali Jafri
 
ODP
Hpc to OpenStack: Our journey
Arif Ali
 
PDF
At the Crossroads of HPC and Cloud Computing with Openstack
Ryan Aydelott
 
PPS
Linux12 clustering onlinux
Jainul Musani
 
PPTX
Meetup 23 - 02 - OVN - The future of networking in OpenStack
Vietnam Open Infrastructure User Group
 
PPTX
Overlay networks ppt
Akshay Hegde
 
PDF
Openstack deployment-with ubuntu
Francisco Gonçalves
 
PPTX
OpenStack Quantum Intro (OS Meetup 3-26-12)
Dan Wendlandt
 
PDF
Open Hardware for All - Webinar March 25, 2015
Cumulus Networks
 
PPTX
Opening the Path to Technical Excellence
NETWAYS
 
PDF
Open stack networking_101_update_2014-os-meetups
yfauser
 
PDF
OpenContrail SDN for Kubernetes
Michelle Holley
 
Demystifying Networking: Data Center Networking Trends 2017
Cumulus Networks
 
Comparison between VMware and Open Stack Cloud
Saeed Siddik
 
CloudSmartz Layer 2 Direct Connect [Factsheet] | Smarter Transformation
CloudSmartz
 
Storage Area Network interview Questions
Sandeep Sharma IIMK Smart City,IoT,Bigdata,Cloud,BI,DW
 
Unified Underlay and Overlay SDNs for OpenStack Clouds
PLUMgrid
 
Drive into calico architecture
Anirban Sen Chowdhary
 
Linux network namespaces
Mike Wilson
 
Introduction to san ( storage area networks )
sagaroceanic11
 
Storage area network
Syed Ubaid Ali Jafri
 
Hpc to OpenStack: Our journey
Arif Ali
 
At the Crossroads of HPC and Cloud Computing with Openstack
Ryan Aydelott
 
Linux12 clustering onlinux
Jainul Musani
 
Meetup 23 - 02 - OVN - The future of networking in OpenStack
Vietnam Open Infrastructure User Group
 
Overlay networks ppt
Akshay Hegde
 
Openstack deployment-with ubuntu
Francisco Gonçalves
 
OpenStack Quantum Intro (OS Meetup 3-26-12)
Dan Wendlandt
 
Open Hardware for All - Webinar March 25, 2015
Cumulus Networks
 
Opening the Path to Technical Excellence
NETWAYS
 
Open stack networking_101_update_2014-os-meetups
yfauser
 
OpenContrail SDN for Kubernetes
Michelle Holley
 

Viewers also liked (8)

PDF
How to build a sustainable online store in nigeria
FortPlus Solutions
 
DOCX
Comm430week 3
kmirvis86
 
PDF
Fkhd presentation aug 2013
Hibiscus Marketing
 
PDF
Concurso (1)
Alfredo Carlos
 
PPT
Esructura techumbre
Hector Valenzuela
 
PPTX
Team1 conflict resolution and reconciliation
jckeefe
 
PDF
CloudStack In Production
Clayton Weise
 
PPSX
Ajedrez
MARUPIE
 
How to build a sustainable online store in nigeria
FortPlus Solutions
 
Comm430week 3
kmirvis86
 
Fkhd presentation aug 2013
Hibiscus Marketing
 
Concurso (1)
Alfredo Carlos
 
Esructura techumbre
Hector Valenzuela
 
Team1 conflict resolution and reconciliation
jckeefe
 
CloudStack In Production
Clayton Weise
 
Ajedrez
MARUPIE
 
Ad

Similar to CloudStack Build A Cloud Day (SCaLE 2013) (20)

PPTX
vBACD - Deploying Infrastructure-as-a-Service with CloudStack - 2/28
CloudStack - Open Source Cloud Computing Project
 
PDF
CloudStack - LinuxFest NorthWest
ke4qqq
 
PPTX
Getting Started with Apache CloudStack
Joe Brockmeier
 
PDF
Cloud stack for_beginners
Radhika Puthiyetath
 
PDF
Hacking apache cloud stack
Nitin Mehta
 
PDF
Cloudstack for beginners
Joseph Amirani
 
PDF
Txlf2012
Joe Brockmeier
 
PPTX
Deploying Apache CloudStack from API to UI
Joe Brockmeier
 
PPTX
CloudStack Overview
sedukull
 
PPTX
Apache CloudStack: API to UI (STLLUG)
Joe Brockmeier
 
PPTX
Apache CloudStack from API to UI
CloudStack - Open Source Cloud Computing Project
 
PDF
CloudStack Networking Deepdive CCCEU13
Chiradeep Vittal
 
ODP
Build a Cloud Day - CloudStack
ke4qqq
 
ODP
Build a Cloud Day - CloudStack
ke4qqq
 
PPTX
Apache CloudStack Hyderabad meetup-April 2014
Srikanteswararao Talluri
 
PPTX
Cloud stack overview
howie YU
 
PPTX
Automating CloudStack and hypervisor installation and configuration
Dag Sonstebo
 
PPTX
Taking the open cloud to 11
Joe Brockmeier
 
PDF
Network Functions Virtualization and CloudStack
Chiradeep Vittal
 
PDF
RedHat OpenStack Platform Overview
indevlab
 
vBACD - Deploying Infrastructure-as-a-Service with CloudStack - 2/28
CloudStack - Open Source Cloud Computing Project
 
CloudStack - LinuxFest NorthWest
ke4qqq
 
Getting Started with Apache CloudStack
Joe Brockmeier
 
Cloud stack for_beginners
Radhika Puthiyetath
 
Hacking apache cloud stack
Nitin Mehta
 
Cloudstack for beginners
Joseph Amirani
 
Txlf2012
Joe Brockmeier
 
Deploying Apache CloudStack from API to UI
Joe Brockmeier
 
CloudStack Overview
sedukull
 
Apache CloudStack: API to UI (STLLUG)
Joe Brockmeier
 
Apache CloudStack from API to UI
CloudStack - Open Source Cloud Computing Project
 
CloudStack Networking Deepdive CCCEU13
Chiradeep Vittal
 
Build a Cloud Day - CloudStack
ke4qqq
 
Build a Cloud Day - CloudStack
ke4qqq
 
Apache CloudStack Hyderabad meetup-April 2014
Srikanteswararao Talluri
 
Cloud stack overview
howie YU
 
Automating CloudStack and hypervisor installation and configuration
Dag Sonstebo
 
Taking the open cloud to 11
Joe Brockmeier
 
Network Functions Virtualization and CloudStack
Chiradeep Vittal
 
RedHat OpenStack Platform Overview
indevlab
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Q2 FY26 Tableau User Group Leader Quarterly Call
lward7
 
PDF
Blockchain Transactions Explained For Everyone
CIFDAQ
 
PPTX
AUTOMATION AND ROBOTICS IN PHARMA INDUSTRY.pptx
sameeraaabegumm
 
PDF
[Newgen] NewgenONE Marvin Brochure 1.pdf
darshakparmar
 
PDF
Building Real-Time Digital Twins with IBM Maximo & ArcGIS Indoors
Safe Software
 
PDF
What Makes Contify’s News API Stand Out: Key Features at a Glance
Contify
 
PPTX
Building Search Using OpenSearch: Limitations and Workarounds
Sease
 
PDF
"Beyond English: Navigating the Challenges of Building a Ukrainian-language R...
Fwdays
 
PDF
CIFDAQ Market Wrap for the week of 4th July 2025
CIFDAQ
 
PDF
IoT-Powered Industrial Transformation – Smart Manufacturing to Connected Heal...
Rejig Digital
 
PDF
CIFDAQ Market Insights for July 7th 2025
CIFDAQ
 
PDF
Empower Inclusion Through Accessible Java Applications
Ana-Maria Mihalceanu
 
PPTX
Webinar: Introduction to LF Energy EVerest
DanBrown980551
 
PDF
Achieving Consistent and Reliable AI Code Generation - Medusa AI
medusaaico
 
PDF
"AI Transformation: Directions and Challenges", Pavlo Shaternik
Fwdays
 
PPTX
WooCommerce Workshop: Bring Your Laptop
Laura Hartwig
 
PDF
HCIP-Data Center Facility Deployment V2.0 Training Material (Without Remarks ...
mcastillo49
 
PDF
Smart Trailers 2025 Update with History and Overview
Paul Menig
 
PDF
Newgen Beyond Frankenstein_Build vs Buy_Digital_version.pdf
darshakparmar
 
PPTX
COMPARISON OF RASTER ANALYSIS TOOLS OF QGIS AND ARCGIS
Sharanya Sarkar
 
Q2 FY26 Tableau User Group Leader Quarterly Call
lward7
 
Blockchain Transactions Explained For Everyone
CIFDAQ
 
AUTOMATION AND ROBOTICS IN PHARMA INDUSTRY.pptx
sameeraaabegumm
 
[Newgen] NewgenONE Marvin Brochure 1.pdf
darshakparmar
 
Building Real-Time Digital Twins with IBM Maximo & ArcGIS Indoors
Safe Software
 
What Makes Contify’s News API Stand Out: Key Features at a Glance
Contify
 
Building Search Using OpenSearch: Limitations and Workarounds
Sease
 
"Beyond English: Navigating the Challenges of Building a Ukrainian-language R...
Fwdays
 
CIFDAQ Market Wrap for the week of 4th July 2025
CIFDAQ
 
IoT-Powered Industrial Transformation – Smart Manufacturing to Connected Heal...
Rejig Digital
 
CIFDAQ Market Insights for July 7th 2025
CIFDAQ
 
Empower Inclusion Through Accessible Java Applications
Ana-Maria Mihalceanu
 
Webinar: Introduction to LF Energy EVerest
DanBrown980551
 
Achieving Consistent and Reliable AI Code Generation - Medusa AI
medusaaico
 
"AI Transformation: Directions and Challenges", Pavlo Shaternik
Fwdays
 
WooCommerce Workshop: Bring Your Laptop
Laura Hartwig
 
HCIP-Data Center Facility Deployment V2.0 Training Material (Without Remarks ...
mcastillo49
 
Smart Trailers 2025 Update with History and Overview
Paul Menig
 
Newgen Beyond Frankenstein_Build vs Buy_Digital_version.pdf
darshakparmar
 
COMPARISON OF RASTER ANALYSIS TOOLS OF QGIS AND ARCGIS
Sharanya Sarkar
 

CloudStack Build A Cloud Day (SCaLE 2013)

  • 1. C LO U D STAC K Clayton Weise [email protected] IRC: iswcin #cloudstack on freenode
  • 2. LICENSING  This presentation and it’s contents unless otherwise noted are released under a Creative Commons Attributions, Share-Alike 3.0 unported license.
  • 3. H I STO RY  Original company formed - 2008 (VMOps)  Project open sourced as CloudStack – May 2010  Acquired by Citrix – July 2011  Dropped open core – August 2011  Release of Acton (3.0) – Real soon now
  • 4. W H AT I S C LO U D STAC K ? Open Source Infrastructure as a Service platform that supports multiple hypervisors, complex network, firewall, load balancer and VPN configurations, high availability, in a multi-tenant environment.
  • 5. W H AT D O ES I T R EA L LY D O ?  Provide separation for the varied tenants  Allocate compute resources in a deterministic manner  Expose to the end user the ability to provision various computing services in a controlled manner (VLAN allocation, firewall rules, load balancer deployment, VM creation, etc)  Manage High Availability  Massively Scalable  Permit the placement of resource limits to be applied  Measuring usage over time
  • 6. M U LT I P L E H Y P E RV I S O R S U P P O RT  KVM  XenServer  Xen Cloud Platform  VMware (via vCenter)  Oracle VM  Bare Metal
  • 7. M U LT I - T E N A N T S E PA R AT I O N  Largely built around abstraction from an end-user POV  No interaction with hypervisor directly  No knowledge of underlying storage  Networking separation  Every account has at least one dedicated/isolated VLAN (Tagged Networking)  Layer 3 isolation aka Security Groups for untagged networking  Option to use dedicated hardware
  • 8. N E T WO R K I N G  CloudStack has a number of network models  They are generally broken down by:  Method of isolation (VLAN, Security Groups)  Physical hardware or virtual  CloudStack largely manages network infrastructure
  • 9. N E T WO R K I N G  Services managed by CloudStack  DHCP  VLAN allocation  Firewall  NAT/Port forwarding  Routing  VPN  Load Balancing
  • 10. N E T WO R K I N G  CloudStack can also manage physical network hardware (or the virtualized alternatives)  F5-Big IP  NetScaler  Juniper SRX  Additionally you can ‘mix and match’ some network elements as service offerings.
  • 11. S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S  Traditional isolation has been via VLAN  VLANs isolate well, but have some problems scaling  Standard has a hard limit of 4096 VLANs  Hardware that can actually keep up with 4096 VLANs is VERY expensive.  Regardless people tend to not like having arbitrary limits on what they can do.  Amazon and others use layer 3 isolation (Security Groups)
  • 12. S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S  Assumption of a quasi-trusted Layer 2 network  Typically will only have hypervisors directly connected to that network.  Filtering/isolation occurs at the bridge device (from a Linux perspective – think ebtables)  Deny by default
  • 13. S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S
  • 14. S EC U R I T Y G RO U P S
  • 15. H I G H AVA I L A B I L I T Y  RFMTTR – but apparently HA looks better in marketing slicks and is used that way across the virtualization industry.  CloudStack is not a magical solution for HA – but might be a useful tool in the process to increase availability.  CloudStack will watch for HA-enabled VMs to ensure that they are up, and that the hypervisor it’s on is up – and will restart on another hypervisor if it goes down.  Redundant router
  • 16. A L LO C AT I O N A LG O R I T H M S  How do you place VMs?, allocate storage, etc.  CloudStack ships with a number of options:  First Fit  Fill first  Disperse  Create your own  Tags  OS Preference
  • 17. U SAG E  Not billing per se – but does give you something to bill against.  Usage stats show VM count, CPU usage, disk allocation and usage, network usage; all over time.  Lots of integration and howto’s - from Excel spreadsheets to Ubersmith, Amysta, and Cloud Portal.
  • 18. H I G H L E V E L A RC H I T EC T U R A L OV E RV I E W © Copyright David Baird and licensed for reuse under this CC-BY
  • 19. S ECO N DA RY STO R AG E  Used for storing templates and snapshots  Historically NFS – just added the option of object storage  Technically Swift, but Caringo, GlusterFS and others should work.  Managed by Secondary Storage VM – manages moving templates and snapshots from/to primary storage, aging snapshots out, etc.
  • 20. P R I M A RY STO R AG E  In the UI we support NFS, iSCSI, and CLVM.  We can also make use of local storage  No HA, no live migration, etc.  Shared mountpoint  Anything that all the hypervisors can mount and write to.
  • 21. R ES O U RC E D I V I S I O N  We have some somewhat arbitrary divisions of resources within CloudStack  Zones • Pods – Clusters
  • 22. ZO N E  In general practice this is used to designate a specific geographic location.  Shares secondary storage resource across the entire zone  Single network model for the entire zone
  • 23. POD  In general practice – this is used to refer a rack of machines or a row of racks.  Shares guest network
  • 24. C LU ST E R  This is typically a max of 8-15 machines per cluster and homogenity is enforced:  Same hypervisor (and same version of the hypervisor)  Same CPUs  Same networking (i.e. /dev/eth0 is connected to the same network across all machines)  Primary storage is cluster specific
  • 25. P L E T H O R A O F N E T WO R KS  Management Network: Where the hypervisors and management server communicate  Private Network: Default network for system VMs. (virtual router, secondary storage VM, Console proxy VM)  Public Network: The public (often internet-facing network)  Guest Network: The network that VMs are provisioned on.  Link-local network: The RFC 3927 network used for communication between hypervisor and system VMs.
  • 26. M A N AG E M E N T S E RV E R  UI/API pieces are stateless (state is stored in a MySQL database.  All UI functionality is an API call
  • 27. API  RESTful API interface  Unauthenticated API interace on 8096 (for localhost)  Authenticated API interface natively on port 8080  Responses in XML or JSON  http://demo4.cloudstack.org/client/api?apikey=ZRFLiXIkm AHqgRmZzdiXMfaROyK35P_dXxS517WSa9Tmy1Hg&comm and=deployVirtualMachine&serviceofferingid=1&template id=291&zoneid=1&signature=eXW%2fxfqx%2fhu%2frMreF ksVsp3cT4M%3d
  • 28. UI  Go play with the UI
  • 29. Q U EST I O N S  ASK!
  • 30. CO N TAC T  http://cloudstack.org  Docs: https://cwiki.apache.org/CLOUDSTACK  IRC: #cloudstack on Freenode  Twitter/identi.ca: @cloudstack  Mailing Lists  https://lists.sourceforge.net/mailman/listinfo/cloudstack-users  https://lists.sourceforge.net/mailman/listinfo/cloudstack-devel  Forums