Precious Metals Advisory
                                                                                                                                            Vol. XXV, No. 12                  6 December 2012


 Precious Metals Prices May Lack Direction in 2013                                                                                                 Next Scheduled Issue: 10 January 2012
                                                                                                          Market Data                              (Data as of 6 December; changes from 8 November)
There is a tremendous amount of uncertainty in the mar-
ket regarding the economy and the future for precious                                                     Nymex/Comex Nearby Active Prices                                %∆                         $∆
metals prices. As a result precious metals investors may                                                 Gold                                 1,701.80        ↓              -1.4%                 -24.20
wait on the sidelines in December. Many price-moving                                                     Silver                                  33.11        ↑               2.7%                   0.87
factors appear already priced into the market, such as de-                                               Platinum                             1,600.70        ↑               3.8%                  58.20
mand expectations for the PGMs and silver, a continua-                                                   Palladium                              697.05        ↑              13.5%                  82.70
tion of the recession in Western Europe, China’s reduced                                                 Rhodium*                             1,100.00        ↓              -4.3%                 -50.00
economic growth trajectory, and sovereign debt handling                                                   *Rhodium price is BASF daily settlement price.

in Europe. The approaching U.S. fiscal cliff may have                                                     Nymex/Comex Inventories                     oz                     ∆                       oz
contributed to precious metals price increases in Novem-                                                 Gold
ber and may continue to influence prices through the end                                                   Eligible                         8,800,826         ↑            119,225          8,681,601
of the year.                                                                                               Registered                       2,602,693         ↑             15,114          2,587,579
                                                                                                           T otal                          11,403,519         ↑            134,339         11,269,180
                                                                                                         Silver
Precious metals prices typically move higher in the first
                                                                                                           Eligible                      105,456,690          ↓         -1,141,470        106,598,160
few months of the year due to seasonal factors. Overall,                                                   Registered                     39,836,930          ↑          3,428,100         36,408,830
however, prices are expected to average modestly lower                                                     T otal                        145,293,620          ↑          2,286,630        143,006,990
in 2013 relative to 2012 levels. Investment demand vol-                                                  Platinum - T otal                   207,850          ↑              9,350            198,500
umes for gold and silver are expected to come off further                                                Palladium - T otal                  531,100          ↓             -2,000            533,100
next year, which will be the primary driver behind lower                                                  Open Interest1                              oz                     ∆                       oz
gold and silver prices. Investors are expected to continue                                               Gold
to welcome opportunities to buy at price dips. That ten-                                                   February                        27,853,400         ↑        21,074,800            6,778,600
                                                                                                           T otal                          42,851,800         ↓        -2,187,500           45,039,300
dency to view dips in prices as buying opportunities                                                     Silver
could dissipate as the year progresses if sell-offs are not                                                March                         426,995,000          ↑      318,450,000           108,545,000
followed by significant rallies, as investors would begin                                                  T otal                        704,615,000          ↑       15,535,000           689,080,000
                                                                                                         Platinum
to re-evaluate their longer term bullish sentiments in light                                               January                          2,724,400         ↓            -79,200            2,803,600
of weaker prices. The platinum group metals may trade                                                      April                              344,950         ↑            154,100              190,850
                                                                                                                                            3,091,700                                         3,005,250
modestly higher on an annual average basis, with weak                                                      T otal                                             ↑             86,450
                                                                                                         Palladium
fabrication demand limiting the upside and constrained                                                     March                            2,362,200         ↑          2,074,900              287,300
supply keeping prices well supported.                                                                      T otal                           2,377,100         ↑            200,700            2,176,400


The primary concern at present in the precious metals                                                     1
                                                                                                              Data as of 5 December; changes from 7 November.
markets is when to expect demand growth to strengthen.
In 2010 and 2011, assessing demand was fairly easy –                                                      Indicators                                                          %∆                     $∆
these were recovery years so demand was rising rapidly
                                                                                                         DJIA                                 13,074.0        ↑               2.1%                    263
for cars and electronics containing PGMs and silver and                                                  FT World Stock Index                    383.6        ↑               3.0%                  11.07
for gold jewelry in the booming Chinese and Indian mar-                                                  FT Gold Mines Index                   2,777.8        ↓             -11.2%               -351.79
kets. In 2012, demand expectations for all the precious                                                  CRB Index                               297.9        ↑               2.1%                   6.07
metals came off. India’s economy slowed and its govern-                                                  T -Bills                               0.09%         ↑               5.6%                 0.01%
ment raised import taxes on gold in order to reduce its                                                  ICE Dollar Index                        80.24        ↓              -0.7%                  -0.55
current account deficit, which weighed on gold jewelry                                                   $ / Euro                                 1.30        ↑               1.8%                $0.023
sales. Europe’s auto market contracted, weighing on ex-
pectations for PGM demand growth. China’s economic                                                        Report Contents
                                                                                                          Prices in 2013…...…......……….....p.1 Palladium..….………......……...p.27
growth slowed, adding further pressure to demand expec-
                                                                                                          Price Targets...………....…………p.3 Rhodium.…….….......……….…p.32
tations. The demand picture in 2012 is expected to spill
                                                                                                          Macroeconomic Indicators………p.5 Precious Metals Price Table......p.33
into 2013, will no material changes to prospects for
                                                                                                          Gold……...……….……...….…….p.8 Equities and Metrics Table..p.34-35
growth.
                                                                                                          Silver………………...…………..p.16
                                                                                                          Platinum………………………...p.22

Copyright CPM Group 2012. Not for reproduction or retransmission without written consent of CPM Group. Precious Metals Advisory is published monthly by CPM Group and is distributed via e-mail.
The views expressed within are solely those of CPM Group. Such information has not been verified, nor does CPM make any representation as to its accuracy or completeness. Any statements non-factual
in nature constitute only current opinions, which are subject to change. While every effort has been made to ensure that the accuracy of the material contained in the reports is correct, CPM Group cannot
be held liable for errors or omissions. CPM Group is not soliciting any action based on it. Information contained here should not be relied on as specific investment or market timing advice. At times the
principals and associates of CPM Group may have long or short positions in some of the markets mentioned here.
Precious Metals Advisory                 6 December 2012           Page 2

Precious Metals Prices May Lack Direction in 2013 (cont.)
The lack of demand upside in 2013, especially through
the first three quarters, is expected to weigh on precious
metals prices. If the European and U.S. economies begin
to pick up later in the year, industrial demand for pre-
cious metals could help to improve price appreciation
prospects.




Commodities Research and Consulting,
Asset Management, and Investment Banking

CPM Group, founded in 1986, is an authoritative commodities research and consulting company. It is independent of all
producers, processors, financial institutions, and other companies having commercial positions in commodities. CPM
Group has extensive experience in commodities research, trading, and finance, equipping the company to provide finan-
cial advice and consulting grounded in hands-on experience.

email: research@cpmgroup.com
Telephone 212-785-8320
www.cpmgroup.com
Precious Metals Advisory                                      6 December 2012                Page 3


Price Targets                                                                      Key                                   Top of Range         1-Month
Nearby active Comex/Nymex prices. Rhodium prices                                                                                              Projection
                                                                                                                          Forecast Average
are daily BASF prices. All prices are US$/ounce.                                            Average
                                                                                                                                             2nd & 3rd Month
                                                                                                                         Bottom of Range     Projections

GOLD                                                                                                  Near Term Outlook — Gold prices could poten-
                                                                                                      tially move in a wide range between $1,620 and
1,850
                                                                                                      $1,780 during December. If prices settle below
                                                                    1,780
1,800
                                                                                    1,800             $1,680, prices could decline toward $1,650 or
                                                                                                      even $1,620. A decline in prices or consolidation
1,750                                                                                                 at present low levels could induce bargain buying
                                                                     1,710          1,715
                                                                                                      by various market participants including investors,
1,700
                                                        1,721                                         central banks, and fabricators. Prices could show
1,650                                                                                                 some seasonal strength in the first few months of
                                                                                                      the year . Fiscal tightening in the United States is
1,600                                                                                                 expected to reduce economic growth during the
                                                                    1,620
                                                                                                      first few months reducing concerns about infla-
1,550
                                                                                   1,550              tion, which could weigh on gold prices. In such an
1,500                                                                                                 environment gold prices could slip toward $1,550.
     J-12      J-12     A-12     S-12     O-12     N-12      D-12         J-13       F-13


SILVER                                                                                                Near Term Outlook — Prices are expected to
                                                                                                      move sideways to lower this month, as the level of
 38
                                                                                                      uncertainty regarding the approaching U.S. fiscal
                                                                                                      cliff pushes and pulls at prices. Prices could head
 36                                                                              35.50
                                                                   35                                 higher in January and February of 2013 due to
 34
                                                   32.79
                                                                                 33.45
                                                                                                      index and portfolio rebalancing activity as well as
                                                                   33                                 the approach of the Comex March futures delivery
 32
                                                                                                      period at the end of February. Seasonal demand
                                                                                                      for silver is typically stronger in the first few
                                                                   31
 30
                                                                                                      months of the year. Prices may stay above $30
                                                                                  30                  over the next three months. There is a lot of sup-
 28
                                                                                                      port at $30, but a move toward this level could
                                                                                                      trigger a spike lower, possibly toward $26. Indus-
 26
                                                                                                      trial demand remains weak, which will weigh on
   J-12      J-12     A-12     S-12     O-12     N-12      D-12         J-13      F-13                silver, but investors continue to buy on price dips.
                                                                                                      Near Term Outlook — Prices may trend higher
PLATINUM                                                                                              over the next three months. Concerns about supply
 1,800                                                                                                remain high, but strike activity in South Africa’s
 1,750                                                                                                platinum mining sector has abated significantly in
                                                                               1,700                  recent months, which may weigh on prices. Anglo
 1,700                                                          1,650                                 Platinum restarted operations at its mines where
 1,650                                                                         1,635                  illegal strikes were taking place. The company has
                                                   1,579
 1,600                                                            1,595                               lost about 200,000 ounces of potential platinum
 1,550                                                                                                output since the illegal strikes began in Septem-
                                                                               1,560
                                                                  1,540                               ber. Fresh concerns about power supply in the
 1,500
                                                                                                      country as well as the potential for new strikes are
 1,450                                                                                                expected to keep prices above $1,540 in the near
 1,400                                                                                                term in even the worse price scenario. The first
 1,350                                                                                                few months of the year are typically a seasonally
                                                                                                      strong period for platinum prices, which may keep
 1,300
      J-12     J-12    A-12     S-12    O-12     N-12 D-12              J-13     F-13
                                                                                                      platinum above $1,560 (?) and could help push
                                                                                                      prices toward $1,700 in January and February.
                                                                                                                                                  Continued
Precious Metals Advisory                                   6 December 2012                Page 4


Price Targets                                                          Key                                 Top of Range         1-Month
Nearby active Comex/Nymex prices. Rhodium prices                                                                                Projection
                                                                                                            Forecast Average
are daily BASF prices. All prices are US$/ounce.                              Average
                                                                                                                               2nd & 3rd Month
                                                                                                           Bottom of Range     Projections

PALLADIUM                                                                               Near Term Outlook — Palladium prices could
800                                                                                     potentially decline as a result of profit taking and
                                                                       750              the possibility of weaker real demand for the
750                                                                                     metal in the near to medium term. Prices have
                                                        725
                                                                                        risen sharply in recent weeks, which could result
700
                                                                                        in investors booking profits in their positions, es-
650
                                                                                        pecially toward the end of December. There also
                                           638
                                                        650                             is the possibility that fabrication demand for the
                                                                       642
600                                                     610
                                                                                        metal will soften during the first half of 2013 due
                                                                      580
                                                                                        to fiscal tightening in the United States. This
550                                                                                     could potentially push prices toward $580. Prices
                                                                                        should find support on the downside because of
500                                                                                     the constant possibility of supply disruptions
                                                                                        from South Africa.
450
   J-12     J-12    A-12   S-12   O-12   N-12    D-12         J-13     F-13

RHODIUM
                                                                                        Near Term Outlook — Rhodium prices are ex-
1,400                                                                                   pected to remain weak over the next three months.
1,350                                                                                   Rhodium prices are expected to average lower in
1,300                                                                                   December, at $1,105, from November, when
1,250
                                                                                        prices averaged $1,142, as some of the supply
                                                                     1,200
                                                                                        constraints supporting prices have eased. Prices
1,200
                                            1,142
                                                    1,150
                                                                                        could decline toward $1,000 over the next few
1,150                                                                1,130              months. Some seasonal price strength could help
                                                    1,105
1,100                                                                                   buoy prices in January and February. Demand
1,050                                                                                   prospects remain bleak, however, which has been
                                                    1,050
1,000                                                                                   weighing heavily on rhodium prices since 2011
                                                                     1,000
  950                                                                                   and may continue to do so. There is scope for fur-
                                                                                        ther declines in rhodium prices, but investors may
  900
     J-12    J-12   A-12   S-12   O-12   N-12    D-12     J-13       F-13 M-13          view prices below $1,000 or even $1,100 as a tre-
                                                                                        mendous buying opportunity.
Precious Metals Advisory                                           6 December 2012                             Page 5

 Macroeconomic Indicators
  Real Gross Domestic Product                                                                 Unemployment Rates in Developed Economies
  Quarterly Data, Quarter-over-Quarter Percentage Change                                      Monthly Data, through October 2012
  Percent                                                                                     Percent
  15                                                                                          12%
                                                                                                            Euro zone                           United States
                                                                                              11%
                                                                                                            United Kingdom                      Japan
  10                                                                                          10%
                                                                                                9%
    5                                                                                           8%
                                                                                                7%
    0                                                                                           6%
                                                                                                5%
                      USA                   China
   -5                                                                                           4%
                      Japan                 Brazil
                                                                                                3%
                      India                 EU
 -10                                                                                            2%
   Jun-96 Nov-98 Apr-01 Sep-03 Feb-06                         Jul-08     Dec-10                      05       06       07       08        09        10        11        12    13

Note: China and India is Quarterly data, with percentage change on a year-over-year basis.   Note: U.K. data is through September 2012.


  Industrial Production in Developed Economies                                                 Industrial Production in Developing Economies
  Monthly through October 2012, Year-over-Year Percentage Change                               Monthly through August 2012, Year-over-Year Percentage Change
 40%                                                                                          30%
                            Euro zone
 30%                        United States
                            United Kingdom                                                    20%
 20%
                            Japan
 10%                                                                                          10%
   0%

-10%                                                                                            0%

-20%
                                                                                             -10%
-30%
                                                                                                                      Brazil           China             India
-40%                                                                                         -20%
        95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12                                        95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12

Note: Euro Zone data is through September 2012.                                              Note: Chinese. data is through July 2012.


  Inflation - Developed Countries                                                             Inflation -Developing Countries
  Monthly CPI, Year-over-Year Percentage Change, through October 2012                         Monthly CPI, Year-over-Year Percentage Change, through October 2012
                                                                                             20%
 8%
                   Euro zone                     United Kingdom                              18%
                   Japan                         United States                               16%
 6%                                                                                                                Brazil                 India
                                                                                             14%
                                                                                                                   China
                                                                                             12%
 4%
                                                                                             10%
 2%                                                                                            8%
                                                                                               6%
 0%                                                                                            4%
                                                                                               2%
-2%                                                                                            0%
                                                                                              -2%
-4%                                                                                           -4%
        05       06           07       08         09         10        11         12                05        06        07        08           09        10        11        12
Precious Metals Advisory                           6 December 2012              Page 6

Macroeconomic Indicators (cont)
  10-Year Treasury minus Three-Month Treasury                         10-Year Nominal Treasury Yield minus 10-Year TIPS Yield
  Daily Data, through 4 December 2012                                 Daily Data, through 4 December 2012
  Percent                                                             Percent
                                                                      3.0
  6.0

  5.0                                                                 2.5
  4.0
                                                                      2.0
  3.0

  2.0                                                                 1.5
  1.0
                                                                      1.0
  0.0

 -1.0                                                                 0.5

 -2.0
    J-82 J-85 J-88 J-91 J-94 J-97 J-00 J-03 J-06 J-09 J-12            0.0
                                                                       Jan-03      Jan-05      Jan-07       Jan-09    Jan-11


  Corporate Baa-rate bond minus Ten-year Treasury                     CBOE Volatility Index: VIX
  Daily Data, through 4 December 2012                                 Daily Data, through 5 December 2012
  Percent                                                             Percent
 7.0                                                                  90

                                                                      80
 6.0
                                                                      70
 5.0
                                                                      60
 4.0                                                                  50

 3.0                                                                  40

                                                                      30
 2.0
                                                                      20
 1.0
                                                                      10
 0.0                                                                   0
  Jan-86 Jan-90 Jan-94 Jan-98 Jan-02 Jan-06 Jan-10                     Jan-04 Apr-05 Jul-06 Oct-07 Jan-09 Apr-10 Jul-11 Oct-12


 MZM Money Supply and U.S. Inflation                                  Trade-Weighted Dollar and Gold Prices
 Monthly Data, through September 2012                                 Monthly Data, through November 2012
 Percent                                                  Percent     Index                                                         $/Oz
40                                                              11                  Trade-Weighted Dollar (LHS)       Gold Prices
                                                                     150                                                            2,000
          Correlation: negative 0.11
35                                                              10                                                                  1,800
                                     MZM Money Supply (LHS)          140
30                                                              8                                                                   1,600
                                     U.S. Inflation (CPI)            130
25                                                              7                                                                   1,400
                                                                     120
20                                                             6                                                                    1,200
                                                                     110
15                                                             4                                                                    1,000
10                                                             3     100
                                                                                                                                    800
 5                                                             1      90
                                                                                                                                    600
 0                                                             0      80                                                            400
-5                                                             -1     70                                                            200
-10                                                            -3     60                                                            -
 Nov-81 May-86 Nov-90 May-95 Nov-99 May-04 Nov-08                      Jan-73 Oct-78 Jul-84 Apr-90 Jan-96 Oct-01 Jul-07
Precious Metals Advisory                            6 December 2012              Page 7

 U.S. Macroeconomic Indicators


 Real Personal Income                                                 Total U.S. Consumer Debt
 Monthly Data, through October 2012                                   Quarterly End of Period Data, through 1 July 2012

 Percent                                                              Trillion of Dollars
10.0
                                                                      16.0
 8.0
                                                                      14.0
 6.0
                                                                      12.0
 4.0
                                                                      10.0
 2.0
 0.0                                                                   8.0

-2.0                                                                   6.0

-4.0                                                                   4.0

-6.0                                                                   2.0
-8.0                                                                   0.0
    J-60    J-66    J-72   J-78   J-84   J-90   J-96   J-02   J-08       O-49 F-57          J-64 O-71 F-79      J-86 O-93 F-01     J-08


 Manufacturers' New Orders: Durable Goods                             New Orders: Nondefense Capital Goods Excluding Aircrafts
 Monthly Data, through October 2012                                   Monthly Data, through October 2012
 Billion of Dollars                                                   Billion of Dollars
 260                                                                   75

 240                                                                   70

 220                                                                   65
                                                                       60
 200
                                                                       55
 180
                                                                       50
 160
                                                                       45
 140                                                                   40
 120                                                                   35
 100                                                                   30
    F-92     J-94     O-96 F-99   J-01   O-03 F-06     J-08   O-10       F-92   J-94       O-96 F-99    J-01   O-03 F-06   J-08   O-10



 Total Construction Spending                                          Housing Starts
 Monthly Data, through October 2012                                   Monthly Data, through October 2012
                                                                      Thousands of Units
 Billions of Dollars                                                 3000
1400.0
                                                                     2500
1200.0

1000.0                                                               2000

  800.0                                                              1500
  600.0
                                                                     1000
  400.0
                                                                      500
  200.0

       0.0                                                              0
          J-93 J-95 J-97 J-99 J-01 J-03 J-05 J-07 J-09 J-11              J-59 J-64 J-69 J-74 J-79 J-84 J-89 J-94 J-99 J-04 J-09
Precious Metals Advisory                                  6 December 2012              Page 8


Gold Outlook
Gold prices may be expected to move between $1,620             As this is being written gold prices have fallen to levels
and $1,780 in December. There have been a couple of            just above support at $1,680. If prices decisively break
sharp declines in gold prices in the past two weeks, re-       below this level they could slip toward $1,660. Or, they
flecting investor profit taking and nervousness on the part    could cascade sharply lower, to $1,650 or even $1,620. If
of long investors. It may be that investor attitudes toward    prices hold above $1,680 the sense that a low has been
the state of the world and the outlook for gold are con-       made at least on a temporary basis could lead to increased
tinuing to shift, away from fear of major problems toward      demand from fabricators, central banks, and investors, all
a view that economic and political problems remain unre-       of whom have become extremely sensitive to the price of
solved but are less likely to trigger a major collapse than    gold.
investors had expected earlier
                                                               India is presently in the midst of its marriage season and
Gold settled at $1,716.50 on 28 November, down $25.80          any weakness in prices should be supportive of fabrica-
from the previous day and prices had declined to               tion demand there. The Indian rupee has also been
$1,695.80 on 4 December, down $25.30 from the prior            strengthening lately, reducing the cost of imports, which
trading session. Part of the selling on 28 November was        could further boost fabrication demand for the metal from
investors who had bought December Comex calls earlier          India.
at lower prices, who had exercised these calls at the close
of trading the day before, on options expiration day.
These investors then sold the futures contracts at the          Gold Prices: 1 January 2009 to 5 December 2012
opening of trading the next day. Additional selling is be-
                                                                $ / Oz
lieved to have been prompted by stop loss selling by           2,000
nervous longs. The sharpness of these declines is likely to
                                                               1,900
have made other remaining investors nervous, and kept
                                                               1,800
fresh investors on the sidelines, which could drive prices
lower. That said, some physically backed exchange              1,700
traded products (ETPs) saw an increase in their holdings       1,600
on both of those days, with ETP holdings reaching a re-        1,500
cord high 86.5 million ounces on 4 December. Even              1,400
though holdings are at record levels, the net additions to     1,300
holdings have not been particularly large. The strength in     1,200
incremental demand is more important in pushing prices
                                                               1,100
higher.
                                                               1,000
                                                                  Jan-10         Jul-10     Jan-11     Jul-11   Jan-12     Jul-12


Gold Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014
$ / Ounce
                                                                                     Quarterly
$1,900                                                $1,900    Year Quarter                         Change     Annual AVG Change
$1,800                                                $1,800
                                                                                       AVG
$1,700                                                $1,700
                                                                2012       IV             $1,726       4.2%       $1,675        6.7%
$1,600                                                $1,600
$1,500                                                $1,500    2013        I             $1,718      -0.4%
$1,400           Actual                               $1,400
$1,300                                                $1,300
                                                                           II             $1,667      -3.0%
                                       Projections
$1,200                                                $1,200               III            $1,608      -3.5%
$1,100                                                $1,100
$1,000                                                $1,000
                                                                           IV             $1,641       2.0%       $1,659        -1.0%
 $900                                                 $900      2014        I             $1,673       2.0%
 $800                                                 $800
 $700                                                 $700                 II             $1,623      -3.0%
     2009    2010     2011    2012    2013     2014
                                                                           III            $1,599      -1.5%
Precious Metals Advisory                           6 December 2012                  Page 9

Demand from central banks also might be expected to                      In a scenario where the fiscal cliff is averted, market sen-
rise if gold prices soften. During the first 10 months of                timent should improve driving gold prices, along with
2012, central banks had added 10.76 million ounces of                    other markets, higher at the beginning of 2013. Any com-
gold to their reported holdings, on a net basis. Some of                 promise reached on the fiscal deficit issue, which would
the strongest net additions by central banks were seen in                be positive for market sentiment, would still hurt eco-
months when prices softened or were at relatively low                    nomic growth, only less than if all of the fiscal tightening
levels. Central banks added on a net basis 2.95 million                  were to occur. As a result of this the present loose mone-
ounces of gold to their holdings in July, when the price of              tary policy is expected to remain in place, to offset eco-
gold was at the lower end of its trading range for the year.             nomic weakness arising from any fiscal tightening. This
This was the highest monthly net additions made by cen-                  might provide slight support to gold prices, but probably
tral banks during 2012. Central banks were also seen add-                would not drive prices significantly higher from current
ing 2.3 million ounces of metal to holdings when prices                  levels.
slipped lower in March 2012.
                                                                         In the less likely scenario, where no deal is reached on
For a variety of reasons investors remain interested in                  how to address the U.S. fiscal situation gold prices should
owning gold and should be expected to step in as buyers                  be expected to decline alongside other assets as investors
when prices soften. There is a lot of uncertainty sur-                   move into cash. In such a scenario monetary accommoda-
rounding the handling of the current U.S. fiscal deficit                 tion is likely to be increased significantly to support eco-
situation, which if not addressed would trigger automatic                nomic growth, which could be supportive of gold prices.
federal spending cuts and tax increases in January 2013
(the fiscal cliff). We expect that the U.S. government will              Prices
patch together a relatively superficial agreement at the
11th hour, with most of the proposed tax increases and                       Volatility in gold prices rose during November, with
budget cuts in the years beyond 2014. However, there are                     prices both rising and declining sharply on various
likely to be some increases in taxes and reductions in                       occasions during the month. Monthly average price
government spending, so the question is how much weak-                       volatility was 20.8%, which was the highest level of
ness should be expected in the first half of 2013, regard-                   monthly price volatility since July of this year. Price
less of the outcome of the political discussions. More im-                   volatility should be expected to continue rising dur-
portant for the matters at hand, the gold market, along                      ing December, as markets focus on the fiscal cliff
with broader financial markets and economic conditions                       issue in the United States. November began with gold
around the world, will be held hostage to a bathetic politi-                 prices declining sharply. Prices settled at $1,675.20
cal melodrama over the remainder of December.                                on 2 November, down from a settlement price of
                                                                             $1,715.50 the previous day. Prices recovered from



Gold Price Volatility and Gold Fabrication Demand

 Gold Price Volatility                                                   Annual Total Fabrication Demand
 Monthly, Through November 2012                                          Million Ounces                                          Million Ounces
                                                                          120                                                             120
  90%
                                                                          110                                                             110
  80%                                                                     100                           Other                             100
  70%                                                                      90                                                             90
                                                                           80                                                             80
  60%                                                                                     Electronics
                                                                           70                               Jewelry, Developed            70
  50%
                                                                           60                                                             60
  40%                                                                              Dental
                                                                           50                                                             50
  30%                                                                      40                                                             40
                                                                           30                                                             30
  20%
                                                                           20                            Jewelry, Developing Countries    20
  10%
                                                                           10                                                             10
   0%                                                                       0                                                              0
        75   78   81   84   87   90   93   96   99   02   05   08   11          77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11e
Precious Metals Advisory                          6 December 2012                   Page 10

    this sharp decline over the next two trading session,                 increase demand for gold from India. The strength in
    reaching an intraday high of $1,720.9 on 6 November                   the Indian rupee helps to reduce the cost of importing
    and settling at $1,715 that day. Prices began to soften               gold. These factors could collectively result in some
    toward the end of the month, with the sharpest de-                    strength in gold fabrication demand from India.
    cline seen on 28 November, when prices settled at
    $1,716.50 (around where they were at the beginning             Official Transactions
    of the month), down $25.80 from the previous day.
    The weakness in prices continued into the first few                   Central banks added on a net basis, 1.61 million
    days of December.                                                     ounces of gold to their holdings in October. Gross
                                                                          additions to holdings during the month were 1.75
                                                                          million ounces, and gross reductions were 141,000
Fabrication Demand                                                        ounces.
    India is presently in the middle of its marriage sea-                 The central bank of Turkey added 564,000 ounces of
    son, traditionally a strong gold buying season. The                   gold to its holdings in October, making it the largest
    recent weakness in the price of gold coupled with                     central bank buyer of gold during the month. The
    some strength in the Indian rupee is likely to help                   Turkish central bank’s holdings reached 10.28 mil-


Official Transactions and Supply

Official Sector Gold Reserve Levels                                 Total World Mine Production
Million Ounces                                    Million Ounces   Million Ounces                                      Million Ounces
1,160                                                      1,160   90                                                              90
                                                                           Indonesia
1,140                                                      1,140   85                                                              85
                                                                   80      Canada                                                  80
1,120                                                      1,120   75                                                              75
                                                                   70      Peru                                                    70
1,100                                                      1,100   65      Australia                                               65
                                                                   60                                                              60
1,080                                                      1,080   55      United States                                           55
1,060                                                      1,060   50                                                              50
                                                                   45                                                              45
1,040                                                      1,040   40                                                              40
                                                                   35                                                              35
1,020                                                      1,020   30                                                              30
                                                                   25         South Africa                                         25
                                                                                                       Other Market Economies
1,000                                                      1,000   20                                                              20
 980                                                       980     15                                                              15
                                                                   10                               Russia               China     10
 960                                                       960      5     Transitional Economies                                   5
                                                                    0                                                              0
 940                                                       940        73 75 77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 0911e
        80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12p


 Official Sector Changes In Gold Holdings                          Official Sector Changes In Gold Holdings in 2009 - October 2012
 2012 Through October                                              Excludes China, India and IMF Transactions,
 Million Ounces                                  Million Ounces
                                                                    Million Ounces                                      Million Ounces
 30                                                          30
                                                                    7.0                                                              7.0
 25                                                          25
         Net Additions/Reductions                                                                   Gross Additions
 20                                                          20     6.0                                                              6.0
                                                                                                    Gross Reductions
 15                                                          15     5.0                                                              5.0
        Gross Additions
 10                                                          10                                     Net Additions/Reductions
                                                                    4.0                                                              4.0
  5                                                          5
  0                                                          0      3.0                                                              3.0
 -5                                                          -5     2.0                                                              2.0
-10                                                          -10    1.0                                                              1.0
-15                                                          -15
                                                                    0.0                                                              0.0
-20                                                          -20
                                        Gross Reductions           -1.0                                                            -1.0
-25                                                          -25
-30                                                          -30   -2.0                                                            -2.0
       04     05    06    07    08    09    10   11     12            Jan-09 Aug-09 Mar-10 Oct-10 May-11 Dec-11 Jul-12
Precious Metals Advisory                                  6 December 2012        Page 11


   lion ounces, a record high, in October. The central                    during the first 10 months with gross reduction of
   bank of Brazil added 552,000 ounces of gold to its                     290,000 ounces.
   holdings in October, taking total holdings of gold to
   1.69 million ounces. This was the second consecutive            Supply
   month that the central bank added gold, after making
   no additions to holdings between October 2001 and                      The global production-weighted cash cost for gold
   August 2012. The central bank of Kazakhstan re-                        mining continued to rise during the third quarter of
   sumed purchasing gold after being a seller of the                      2012 reaching $733/ounce, up from $730/ounce in
   metal in September. The central bank purchased                         the second quarter of 2012 and $662/ounce in the
   242,000 ounces of gold in October, raising its hold-                   third quarter of 2011. On average the global gold
   ings to a record high 3.6 million ounces.                              mining industry is still enjoying a healthy margin
                                                                          between cash costs and gold prices. The average
   The Bank of International Settlements’ gold holdings                   price of gold during the third quarter of 2012 was
   rose by 371,429 ounces in October. Other central                       $1,654.37. The price of gold has not been rising in
   banks that added gold to their holdings included the                   the same fashion as it was in the past few years. This
   central bank of Russia (13,000 ounces), Mongolia                       coupled with continuing increases in cash costs is
   (1,000 ounces), Greece (1,000 ounces), and Belarus                     squeezing producer margins. During the third quarter
   (2,000 ounces).                                                        of 2011 the average price of gold was $1,700 and
   The central banks of Germany reduced its holdings                      cash costs were $662/ounce, giving producers an av-
   by 135,000 ounces in October to 109.03 million                         erage margin of $1,038/ounce in that quarter.
   ounces. This was the second time that Germany re-
   duced its holdings this year, with the first reduction
   made in June. The central bank of Mexico reduced its            Investment Demand
   holdings for the sixth consecutive month in October,
   taking its total holdings of gold to 4.01 million                      Gold exchange traded product holdings continued to
   ounces. This level of gold holdings is still 600,000                   rise in November. Total holdings reached 86.3 mil-
   ounces higher than levels at the end of 2011.                          lion ounces at the end of the month, up 932,050
   Reported net additions to central bank gold holdings                   ounces from 85.4 million ounces at the end of Octo-
   during the first 10 months of the year were 10.76 mil-                 ber. Holdings continued to rise during the first few
   lion ounces, driven entirely by an increase in gross                   days of December, reaching a record high 86.5 mil-
   purchases made by central banks. Gross additions to                    lion ounces on 4 December. Even though holdings
   central bank gold holdings were 11.06 million ounces                   are at record levels, the net additions to holdings have


Investment Demand

Month-end Change in ETF Gold Holdings and % Change in Gold Price   Exchange Traded Funds' Physical Gold Holdings
Through November 2012                                              Million Ounces                                        Million Ounces
% Change                                                           100                                                              100
                                                 Million Ounces             Japan        HDFC
40%                                                          8              Religare     SBI
                                                                     90     Quantum      Reliance
                                                                                                                                   90
                                Change in ETF Gold Holdings
                                                                            Kotak        UTI
                                Gold Price %Change M-t-M             80     AUUSA        CSGLDE                                    80
30%                                                          6
                                                                            CSGLDC       CSGOLD
                                                                     70     SGLD         SGLN                                      70
20%                                                           4             AGOL         GLTR
                                                                     60     CGL          GBEES                                     60
                                                                            Sprott       German
                                                                     50     Turkey       SGBS                                      50
10%                                                           2
                                                                            GOLD         NYSE
                                                                     40     JB           ETF                                       40
 0%                                                           0             ZKB          IAU
                                                                     30     GLD          GLD                                       30
                                                                            GBS          GOLD
-10%                                                          -2     20     CGT          CEF                                       20
                                                                     10                                                            10
-20%                                                          -4
   Jan-07      May-08      Sep-09      Jan-11      May-12            -                                                             0
                                                                         20032004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
                                                                   Note: Data as of 30 November 2012
Precious Metals Advisory                                 6 December 2012           Page 12


       not been very strong. The strength in this incremental                             end of November, total open interest was 44.3 mil-
       demand is more important to price increases.                                       lion ounces and was down to 43.4 million ounces by
       Investors in exchange traded funds were seen adding                                4 December.
       to their holdings when the price of gold was declin-                               Open interest in the December Comex contract de-
       ing or was relatively depressed. This shows that in-                               clined over the course of November as market par-
       vestors remain interested in the metal but are also                                ticipants either rolled forward or closed out their po-
       price sensitive and are reluctant to purchase the metal                            sitions. Open interest in this contract slipped from
       when prices rise.                                                                  29.7 million ounces at the beginning of November to
                                                                                          462,300 ounces at the end of the month. Open inter-
Markets and Inventories                                                                   est in the nearby active February Comex contract was
                                                                                          at 28.6 million ounces on 4 December, down from
       Total open interest in the Comex gold futures con-                                 29.3 million ounces at the end of November.
       tract rose to 49.3 million ounces on 23 November,                                  Gold delivered via the December Comex contract
       from 45.7 million ounces at the end of October. Total                              totaled 240,100 ounces as of 5 December. Comex
       open interest softened over the remainder of Novem-                                registered inventories rose by 67,830 ounces on 5
       ber and into the first few days of December. At the                                December from 2.53 million ounces at the end of
                                                                                          November. Total eligible stocks meanwhile declined

Markets and Inventories
Gross Long and Short Positions of Comex Disaggragated Non-Commercial Positions      Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions
Comex Gold Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012               Comex Gold Futures & Options.Weekly Data,through 27November 2012
  Million Ounces                                                  Million Ounces
  35                                                                        35      Million Ounces                                   Million Ounces
                   Money Managers                                 Long              35                                                           35
  30               Other Traders                                            30
                   Net Position                                                     30                                                           30
  25                                                                        25                                           Long
                                                                                    25                                                           25
  20                                                                        20      20                                                           20
                                                                                            Net Fund Position in Comex
  15                                                                        15      15                                                           15
  10                                                                        10      10                                                           10

   5                                                                        5        5                                                           5
                                                                                     0                                                           0
   0                                                                        0
                                                                                     -5                                                          -5
  -5                                                          Short         -5                                  Short
                                                                                    -10                                                          -10
 -10                                                                       -10        A-95 D-96 J-98 M-00O-01 J-03 J-05 S-06 A-08 D-09 A-11
   Jun-06 Apr-07 Mar-08 Jan-09 Nov-09 Oct-10 Aug-11 Jun-12


 Comex Gold Inventories & Total Open Interest                                   O    Gold Price and Total Open Interest
                                                              M
 Daily, Through 5 December 2012                                                      Daily, Through 5 December 2012
 Million Ounces                                      Million Ounces                 $/Ounce                                            Million Ounces
13                                                              70                  2,000                                                         70
12     Total Open Interest (Right Scale)
                                                                                    1,800                                                         65
11                                                              60
10                                                                                  1,600                                                         60
 9                                                              50                                                                                55
                                                                                    1,400          Total Open Interest
 8                                                                                                                                                50
                                                                40                  1,200
 7
                                                                                                                                                  45
 6                                                                                  1,000
                                         Eligible Stocks        30                                                                  Gold          40
 5
                                                                                     800
 4                                                              20                                                                                35
 3                                                                                   600                                                          30
 2                                                              10                   400
                 Registered Stocks                                                                                                                25
 1
 0                                                              0                    200                                                          20
  J-06 A-06 A-07 D-07 J-08 M-09O-09M-10 J-11 A-11M-12N-12                              2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Precious Metals Advisory                            6 December 2012                  Page 13

       by 54,713 ounces to 8.8 million ounces over the same                             ber, reducing the increase in net long positions, to
       period of time, which resulted in total Comex inven-                             3.04 million ounces on 27 November from 2.7 mil-
       tories rising to 11.4 million ounces on 4 December,                              lion ounces on 30 October.
       up 13,117 ounces from the end of November.
       Net long positions held by large non-commercial                                  Clearing activity by member banks of the London
       market participants rose during November reaching                                Bullion Market Association declined to 19.9 million
       21.2 million ounces on 27 November from 19.3 mil-                                ounces in October on average per day from 22.4 mil-
       lion ounces on 30 October. The increase in net long                              lion ounces in September. The average value traded
       positions was driven entirely by an increase in gross                            per day declined to $34.7 billion in October from
       long positions, which reached 24.2 million ounces on                             $39.2 billion in September. The average number of
       27 November from 22.1 million ounces at the end of                               transfers slipped to 2,453 in October from 2,911 in
       October. Gross short positions rose during Novem-                                September.


Bullion Coins
                                                                                    Monthly U.S. Eagle and Buffalo Gold Coin Sale s by the U.S. Mint
 Monthly U.S. Mint Gold Coin Sales to Dealers
                                                                                    Month                                2010         2011          2012
 Thousand Ounces                                                  Thousand Ounces
350                                                                           350   January                            85,000      133,500        140,500
                                                                                    Fe bruary                          84,000       92,500         28,000
300                                                                           300   March                             102,000      111,500         88,500
                                                                                    April                             117,000      128,500         29,000
250                                                                           250   May                               260,500      122,500         62,500
                                                                                    June                              185,000       67,000         70,000
200                                                                           200   July                              175,000       76,500         34,500
                                                                                    August                             57,000      140,000         48,000
150                                                                           150   Se pte mbe r                       98,000      104,000         77,000
                                                                                    O ctobe r                          94,000       62,500         70,000
100                                                                           100   Nove mbe r                        112,000       49,500        153,000
                                                                                    De ce mbe r                        60,000       86,500
50                                                                            50
                                                                                    YTD Total June 2012             1,369,500    1,088,000        801,000
                                                                                     % Change YOY                      -0.6%       -20.6%         -26.4%
 0                                                                            0
      92       94    96    98       00   02    04    06    08      10    12         Annual Total                    1,429,500    1,174,500        801,000
                                                                                     % Change Previous Year           -12.0%       -17.8%




World Gold Supply and Demand                                                        Gold Quarterly Average Price Projections
 Million Ounces                                                                      $/Ounce, through Q3 2014


  140                                                                         140    $2,000                                                         $2,000
  130                                         Investment Demand               130
  120                                                                         120    $1,800                                                         $1,800
  110                                                                         110
                                                                                     $1,600                                                         $1,600
  100                                                                         100
                 Available Supply
      90                                                                      90     $1,400                                         Projections     $1,400
      80                                                                      80                     Actual
                                                                                     $1,200                                                         $1,200
      70                                                                      70
      60                                                                      60     $1,000                                                         $1,000
      50                                                                      50
                                                                                      $800                                                          $800
      40                                                                      40
      30                                                                      30      $600                                                          $600
                                                    Fabrication Demand
      20                                                                      20
                                                                                      $400                                                          $400
      10                                                                      10
      0                                                                      0        $200                                                          $200
           50 53 56 59 62 65 68 71 74 77 80 83 86 89 92 95 98 01 04 07 10 13p            2002     2004    2006    2008    2010     2012      2014
Precious Metals Advisory                 6 December 2012           Page 14

Bullion Coins                                                 Sales during the first 11 months of 2012 declined to
                                                              124,000 ounces, down 19.2% from the same period
   U.S. Mint gold coin sales reached 153,000 ounces in        in 2011.
   November, the highest level reached since July 2010        Premiums on both the American Eagle and American
   when sales had totaled 175,000 ounces. Sales during        Buffalo gold coins remained mostly flat during No-
   the first 11 months of 2012 totaled 801,000 ounces,        vember. This suggests that the market was well sup-
   down 26.4% over the same period in 2011. On a year         plied and could potentially result in softening in de-
   -on-year basis, sales during November 2012 were up         mand from dealers in December.
   209%, however.
   U.S. Mint American Eagle gold coin sales reached
   136,500 ounces during November 2012, the highest
   level of sales for these coins since July 2010. Sales of
   these coins during the first eleven months of the year
   reached 677,000 ounces, down 27.6% from the corre-
   sponding period in 2011.
   American Buffalo gold coin sales continued to rise in
   November reaching 16,500 ounces during the month.
   This was up from 8,500 ounces from the same period
   in 2011 and up from 11,000 ounces in October 2012.
Precious Metals Advisory                                              6 December 2012                         Page 15

Gold Statistical Position
Million Ounces
Supply                                                    2007               2008               2009                2010               2011              2012p              2013p
Mine Production
 China                                                     8.7                 9.1                10.1               11.0                11.6               12.3               13.0
 Australia                                                 7.9                 6.9                 7.2                8.4                 8.3                8.1                8.4
 United States                                             7.7                 7.5                 7.2                7.4                 7.6                7.2                7.4
 South Africa                                              8.2                 7.1                 6.6                6.2                 6.0                5.3                5.1
 Peru                                                      5.5                 5.8                 5.9                5.3                 5.3                5.4                5.5
 Indonesia                                                 3.7                 2.1                 4.0                3.4                 2.5                1.8                2.0
 Canada                                                    3.3                 3.1                 3.1                2.9                 3.2                3.2                3.1
 Other Market Economies                                   20.4                21.5                23.1               24.6                25.0               26.0               28.0
 Total                                                   65.3                62.9                67.1               69.2                69.4               69.3               72.6
 % Change Year Ago                                     -0.7%               -3.6%                6.6%               3.1%                0.3%              -0.2%               4.8%
Secondary Supply                                         33.8                39.8                41.2               40.3                40.6               40.7               38.3
 % Change Year Ago                                     22.5%               17.8%                3.7%              -2.1%                0.5%               0.3%              -6.0%
Transitional Economy
 Sales                                                    11.3               12.0                10.5                9.7                 9.0                7.5                7.0
 % Change Year Ago                                       9.7%               6.2%                    -             -7.6%                    -                  -                  -
Total Supply                                             110.3              114.7               118.8              119.2               119.0              117.6              118.1
 % Change Year Ago                                       6.5%               4.0%                3.6%               0.3%               -0.2%              -1.2%               0.4%
Fabrication Demand
Industrial Demand
 Electronics                                               9.1                 9.1                7.9                 8.5                 8.5                8.4                 8.6
 Dental/Medical                                            2.5                 2.4                2.2                 2.2                 2.1                2.1                 2.1
 Other                                                     3.9                 4.6                4.1                 4.1                 4.7                4.8                 4.9
 Total                                                   15.4                16.1               14.2                14.8                15.3               15.3                15.6
 % Change Year Ago                                     15.6%                4.2%             -11.9%                4.6%                3.1%               0.0%                1.8%
Jewelry
 Developed Countries                                       14.9               12.4                9.4                 8.7                 8.4                8.2                 8.1
 Developing Countries                                      60.0               58.4               48.0                49.6                49.1               51.0                53.8
 Total                                                    74.9               70.8               57.3                58.3                57.5               59.2                61.8
 % Change Year Ago                                      -0.8%              -5.5%             -19.0%                1.7%               -1.4%               3.0%                4.5%
Total Fabrication Demand                                  90.4               86.9               71.4                73.1                72.7               74.5                77.4
 % Change Year Ago                                       1.7%              -3.9%             -17.8%                2.4%               -0.5%               2.4%                3.9%
Stock Demand
Total Official Transactions                             -16.0                  0.2               16.8              10.1                12.7               11.0                 9.0
 % Change Year Ago                                     37.2%                  NM                 NM             -39.9%               25.9%             -13.6%              -18.2%
Net Private Investment
 Official Coins                                            4.4                 5.0                6.0                6.3                  4.5                4.1                3.6
 Bullion                                                  28.8                18.1               20.1               24.7                 26.0               25.4               25.6
 Medallions                                                2.8                 4.5                4.5                5.0                  3.0                2.7                2.4
 Total                                                   36.0                27.6               30.6               36.0                 33.5               32.1               31.7
 % Change Year Ago                                     36.5%              -23.3%              10.7%              17.8%                -6.9%              -4.1%              -1.4%
Total Stock Demand                                       20.0                27.8               47.4               46.1                 46.3               43.1               40.7
 % Change Year Ago                                     36.0%               39.3%              70.4%              -2.7%                 0.3%              -6.7%              -5.6%
Total Demand
(Fabrication Plus Stock Change)                          110.3              114.7               118.8              119.2              119.0             117.6                118.1
Price Per Ounce                                                                                                                                           YTD
 High                                                  $842.70          $1,004.30          $1,218.30           $1,421.40          $1,889.70          $1,796.50
 Low                                                    606.90             705.00             807.30            1,052.80           1,318.40           1536.60
 Average                                                700.11             872.82             974.70            1,228.63           1,572.00           1669.27
 % Change Year Ago                                     15.4%              24.7%              11.7%               26.1%              27.9%                6.5%
*Million Ounces; Source: CPM Group; Notes: There may be discrepancies in totals and percent changes due to rounding; Net official sales are indicated by negative numbers; The price
is the Comex nearby active settlement, 2012 Through 11 October. Longer term projections are available in CPM Group's Gold Supply, Demand, and Price: 10-Year Projections report; e
-- estimates; p -- projections; NM -- Not meaningful; December 5, 2012
Precious Metals Advisory                             6 December 2012                   Page 16


Silver Outlook
Silver prices rose last month, after trending lower in Oc-      volumes in the Comex silver futures market are down
tober. The roll of the December contract into the March         about 30%, clearing volumes in the London interbank
and forward month contracts helped boost prices. This           market are 20% lower this year than last year, silver Ea-
coupled with seasonal demand for the metal ahead of Di-         gle bullion sales are down 15% year-to-date, and silver
wali, contributed to the 11.3% trough-to-peak increase in       ETP net purchases are the lowest seen since 2005
settlement prices between 2 and 29 November.                    (excluding 2011 when investors sold a net of 24.4 million
                                                                ounces of silver ETPs). CPM Group is projecting invest-
Silver prices have been trending lower since April of last      ment demand for silver to fall to 124.3 million ounces in
year. Each price rally has ended at lower highs. Intraday       2012 from 133.2 million ounces last year. A further de-
peaks went from $49.82 in April 2011 to $44.09 in Au-           cline in investment demand to 102.0 million ounces in
gust 2011 to $37.48 in February 2012 to $35.45 in Octo-         projected for 2013 while prices may come off by 8%
ber 2012 to the most recent peak of $34.35 on 29 Novem-         from 2012 levels.
ber. Price support throughout this period has been firmly
positioned at $26.25. Going forward CPM Group expects           Silver prices are projected to move sideways to lower this
further declines in silver prices, driven by continued          month amid reduced trading activity during the holiday
weakness in industrial demand and rising supply. These          season in the Western hemisphere. Investor concerns
future declines, however, may be limited. Over the past         about the fiscal cliff so far have appeared immaterial to
year, despite a broad decline in the price of the metal,        the silver market. It seems investor views about the ap-
investors have remained relatively interested in silver as a
form of investment. Investors have purchased a net of           Silver Prices: 1 January 2010 to 5 December 2012
40.6 million ounces of silver exchange traded products
                                                                $ / Oz
(ETPs), more than reversing the 24.4 million ounces of
                                                                 52
silver ETPs sold during 2011. Last month, the U.S. Mint
                                                                 48
witnessed a spike in November bullion coin sales, selling        44
3.2 million ounces of silver Eagle bullion coins, up             40
128.3% from last November, to authorized dealers. Also,          36
net long positions held by non-commercial Comex mar-             32
ket participants in silver futures and options have been         28
increasing since July and open interest in Comex silver          24
futures rose above levels seen in April of last year when        20
prices peaked last month.                                        16
                                                                 12
Even though investment demand has been positive this             8
                                                                 Jan-10     Jul-10    Jan-11     Jul-11     Jan-12      Jul-12
year thus far, 2012 pales in comparison to 2011. Trading

Silver Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014
$ / Ounce
                                                                                  Quarterly
 $48                                                      $48   Year Quarter                     Change     Annual AVG Change
                                                                                    AVG
 $44                                                      $44
 $40                                                      $40
                                                                2012       IV        $32.72       9.7%         $31.32            -6.0%
 $36                                                      $36   2013       I         $29.47       0.9%
          Actual
 $32                                                      $32
                                                                           II        $30.08       -8.0%
 $28                                                      $28
                                                                           III       $32.99       -4.0%
 $24                                                      $24
 $20                                                      $20              IV        $33.28       3.0%         $30.89            -1.3%
 $16                                                      $16   2014       I         $30.62       4.0%
                                            Projections
 $12                                                      $12
                                                                           II        $29.40       -1.0%
  $8                                                      $8
   2009            2010   2011    2012      2013                           III       $30.28       -6.0%
Precious Metals Advisory                          6 December 2012                   Page 17

proaching fiscal cliff are mixed, resulting in no net im-           and Australian output is up 19.1% so far this year.
pact on price direction. Prices may rise in January and             Chilean and Bolivian output both declined strongly
February, ahead of the March contract delivery period at            this year relative to 2011.
the end of February and due to portfolio rebalancing.               Approximately 25 new silver-producing mines began
Prices are expected to trade above $30 and below $35.50             production this year so far, four of which are primary
over the next three months.                                         silver mines. The largest mine by annual silver ca-
                                                                    pacity is Aurcana’s Shafter mine in the United States,
Prices                                                              which started production in the first half of the year.
                                                                    The second largest was Mawson West’s Dikulushi
    Silver prices trended higher in November. Continu-              mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo. These 25
    ing a decline that began in October, silver prices fell         mines will add around 15.0 million ounces to silver
    during the first three days of the month. Silver traded         mine production capacity once fully ramped up.
    to an intraday low of $30.66 on 5 November, the
    lowest price since the first half of September. Prices    Fabrication Demand
    began to rise thereafter, touching an intraday peak of
    $34.40 on 29 November, a 12.2% increase from the 5              Net imports of silver in China fell to 5.7 million
    November intraday trough. Silver settled at $33.20              ounces in October, down from 6.2 million ounces in
    on 3 November, down 3.3% from the previous day.
    Prices averaged $32.82 last month, down 1.1% from
    the previous month, despite rising prices.                Silver Supply
    Silver price volatility rose last month to 29.0% from     World S ilver Mine Production
    19.0% in October. This was the highest monthly            Million Troy Ounces
    volatility rate since June.                                                                    Jan- S ept                    %∆
                                                                                                  2011         2012
Supply                                                        M exico                            113.1        122.5              8.3%
                                                              China                               77.9        106.9             37.1%
    Silver mine production fell to 68.1 million ounces in     Peru                                81.0         83.4              3.0%
    September from 69.2 million ounces the previous           Australia                           40.0         47.6             19.1%
    month, according to the World Bureau of Metal Sta-        Chile                               31.3         27.2            -13.1%
    tistics. Silver output from mines rose to 608.5 million   Bolivia                             29.3         26.4             -9.8%
    ounces this year through September, up 8.3% from          Subtotal                           372.6        414.0            11.1%
    562.0 million ounces in the same period in 2011.          Other Countries                    189.4        194.5              2.7%
    Output in Mexico, China, Peru, and Australia rose         Total                              562.0        608.5              8.3%
    during the first nine months of the year relative to
    2011. Chinese silver mine production is up 37.1%          Source: WBM S
                                                              Note: Russia, the sixth largest silver-producing country, was
Silver Prices                                                 excluded due to lack of comparable data.

Silver Price Volatility                                        Monthly Silver Mine Production
Monthly, Through November 2012                                 Through September 2012
                                                               Mln Oz
 100%                                                         71
  90%
                                                              69
  80%
  70%                                                         67

  60%                                                         65
  50%                                                         63
  40%
                                                              61
  30%
                                                              59
  20%
  10%                                                         57
   0%                                                         55
         75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11                    Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 Aug-12
Precious Metals Advisory                                       6 December 2012                 Page 18

       September and 6.1 million ounces in October 2011.                                                 pacity of farmers, which make up about 70% of In-
       Gross imports were lower and gross exports were                                                   dia’s work force.
       higher last month relative to September.
       Demand for silver in India for Diwali and the wed-                                        Investment Demand
       ding season benefited from high gold prices last
       month, but overall demand may have been flat to                                                   Silver exchange traded product holdings increased by
       lower year-on-year. Gold and silver sales in cities                                               1.1% of 6.7 million ounces last month from 601.4
       appeared positive, but rural areas posted weak de-                                                million ounces at the end of October. Holdings rose
       mand, mostly due to the delay of harvesting. Adverse                                              to a monthly peak of 612.2 million ounces on 15 No-
       monsoon weather delayed harvesting activities by                                                  vember, just shy of the record high of 615.1 million
       approximately a month. This limited the buying ca-                                                ounces reached on 25 April 2011. Holdings declined

 Silver Demand
 Production-Weighted World Industrial Production                                                  Chinese Silver Imports and Exports
 Percentage Change from a Year Ago, Through September 2012                                        Monthly, Through October 2012
15%
                                                                                                   25                                                                 25

10%                                                                                                20                                                                 20

                                                                                                   15                                                                 15
 5%
                                                                                                   10                                                                 10

                                                                                                   5                                                                  5
 0%
                                                                                                   0                                                                  0

 -5%                                                                                               -5                                                                 -5

                                                                                                  -10                                                                 -10
-10%                                                                                                                                                 Gross Imports
                                                                                                  -15                                                                 -15
                                                                                                                                                     Gross Exports
-15%                                                                                              -20                                                                 -20
                                                                                                                                                     Net Trade
   2005m01     2006m04      2007m07      2008m10     2010m01      2011m04      2012m07
                                                                                                  -25                                                                 -25
 Source: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis                                            J-05 S-05 M-06 J-07 S-07 M-08 J-09 S-09 M-10 J-11 S-11 M-12


 Silver Investment Demand
 Silver Exchange Traded Product Holdings                                                         S ilver ETP Holdings
 Through 30 November 2012                                                                        Data as of 30 November, Changes from 31 October
  Mln Oz
700
             Japan                     SSLV                                                                           Month-end Holdings      %∆        Ounce ∆
             SSLN                      WITE                                                      CEF                           76,964,103 -    0.0%             0
600
             GLTR                      PSLV                                                      S LV iS hares                314,448,448 ↓   -1.4% -4,589,504
             SVR.UN                    SBT.U                                                     ETF - ETFS                    28,649,144 ↑    2.6%       733,212
500
             Julius Baer               SIVR                                ZKB                   ZKB S ilver                   88,742,680 ↑    1.6% 1,367,048
             MSL                       PHAG                                                      S ilver MS L                   2,267,399 ↓   -1.3%       -30,852
400
                                                                                                 S IVR - ETFS                  18,417,787 ↓   -0.6%      -103,618
300                                                                                              Julius Baer S ilver           17,222,990 ↑    3.1%       515,000
                                                                                                 GLTR - ETFS                    3,143,830 ↓    0.0%             0
                                                                           SLV
200                                                                                              WITE - ETFS                    3,347,751 ↓   -2.8%       -95,306
                                                                                                 PS LV                         49,287,863 ↑ 21.8% 8,814,961
100                                                                                              S VR                           2,335,561 ↑    2.3%        52,647
                                                                           CEF                   S BT                             740,423 ↓   -0.1%        -1,052
  0                                                                                              S S LN -iS hares                 487,905 ↓    0.0%          -230
      02            07         08          09         10          11          12
                                                                                                 S S LV                           319,641 ↑ 64.6%         125,468
Note: CEF-Central Fund of Canada traded on the Toronto Stock Exchange. SLV-iShares Silver
                                                                                                 S ilver Mitsubishi             1,652,548 ↓   -6.9%      -122,173
Trust traded on the American Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich Cantonal traded on the Swiss Exchange.
ETF-ETF Securities traded on the London Stock Exchange and Australian Securities Exchange, and   Total                        608,028,073 ↑    1.1% 6,665,602
New York Stock Exchange. Julius Baer traded on the Swiss Exchange. SIVR-ETF Securities traded
                                                                                                 YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings* ↑    7.2% 40,596,837
on the New York Stock Exchange. MSL-ETF Securities traded on the Australian Stock Exchange.
GLTR—ETF Securities traded on NYSE. WITE—ETF Securities traded on NYSE. SSLN—iShares             *YTD data through 30 November. Percentage change is from end of
ETP traded on the London Stock Exchange. SSLV—Source ETP traded on the London Stock Ex-
change. Silver Mitsubishi—Mitsubishi’s silver ETP traded at the Tokyo Stock Exchange.
                                                                                                 previous year.
Precious Metals Advisory                            6 December 2012                          Page 19

                                                                 on 30 October to 215.5 million ounces on 27 Novem-
    thereafter, to 608.0 million ounces on 30 November.          ber, according to CFTC data. Net long positions held
    Silver ETP holdings are up 7.2%, or 40.6 million             by these market participants have been trending
    ounces, this year so far.                                    higher since the beginning of July. Gross long posi-
                                                                 tions rose by 26.1 million ounces while gross short
Coins                                                            positions increased 3.5 million ounces during the pe-
                                                                 riod.
    The U.S. Mint delivered 3.2 million ounces of silver         The daily average number of ounces transferred in
    Eagle bullion coins to authorized dealers in Novem-          the London interbank market during October was
    ber, up 128.3% from 1.4 million ounces delivered in          98.1 million ounces, down from 124.3 million ounces
    November 2011. Coins sales by the U.S. Mint are              in the previous month. The daily value of ounces
    down 15.5% so far this year from the same period in          transferred averaged $3.26 billion, down from $4.18
    2011.                                                        billion in September and the number of transfers fell
                                                                 to 757 from 967 in the previous month.
Markets and Inventories

    Open interest in Comex silver futures rose from         Silver Markets
    696.2 million ounces on 31 October to 774.4 million
    ounces on 23 November, an 11.2% increase. Open           Comex Silver Inventories & Total Open Interest                                   O
                                                                                                                               M
    interest in Comex silver futures has been increasing     Daily, Through 5 December 2012
    since December of last year. The 23 November peak        Mln Ozs                                                                Mln Ozs
    was higher than the April 2011 peak of 764.7 million     1,000                                                                    1,000
    ounces. Open interest came off after 23 November,          900                          Total Open Interest                       900
    falling to 722.1 million ounces on 3 December.             800                                                                    800
    Open interest in the most active nearby March con-         700                                                                    700
    tract was 446.1 million ounces on 30 November. This        600                                                                    600
    was 3.1 times the amount of metal stored in Comex          500                                                                    500
    warehouses.
                                                               400                                                                    400
    Daily trading volumes of Comex silver futures aver-
                                                               300                                                                    300
    aged 326.7 million ounces in November, 71.7%                            Registered Stocks
                                                                                                                  Eligible Stocks
                                                               200                                                                    200
    higher than the daily average rate of 190.1 million
                                                               100                                                                    100
    ounces in October.
                                                                  0                                                                   0
    Large non-commercial market participants’ net long             J-06 O-06 A-07 M-08 M-09 D-09 S-10 J-11 M-12
    positions increased 11.7% from 192.9 million ounces

Bullion Coins
                                                            Monthly U.S. Eagle Silve r Coin Sale s by the U.S. Mint

U.S. Mint Silver Coin Sales                                 Month                                     2010       2011       2012
                                                            January                              3,592,500 6,422,000 6,107,000
Million Ozs                                   Million Ozs
                                                            Fe bruary                            2,050,000 3,240,000 1,490,000
 6.5                                               6.5
                                                            March                                3,381,000 2,767,000 2,542,000
 6.0                                               6.0
                                                            April                                2,507,500 2,819,000 1,520,000
 5.5                                               5.5
 5.0                                               5.0      May                                  3,636,500 3,653,500 2,875,000
 4.5                                               4.5      June                                 3,001,000 3,402,000 2,858,000
 4.0                                               4.0      July                                 2,981,000 2,968,000 2,278,000
 3.5                                               3.5      August                               2,451,000 3,679,500 2,870,000
 3.0                                               3.0      Se pte mbe r                         1,880,000 4,460,500 3,255,000
 2.5                                               2.5      O ctobe r                            3,150,000 3,064,000 3,153,000
 2.0                                               2.0      Nove mbe r                           4,260,000 1,384,000 3,159,500
 1.5                                               1.5      De ce mbe r                          1,772,000 2,009,000
 1.0                                               1.0      YTD Total June 2012                 18,168,500 37,859,500 32,107,500
 0.5                                               0.5
                                                             % Change YOY                          351.4%     108.4%     -15.2%
 0.0                                               0.0
     92 9394 95 96 97                                       Annual Total                        34,662,500 39,868,500 32,107,500
                                                             % Change Previous Year                 48.1%      15.0%
Precious Metals Advisory                                        6 December 2012                          Page 20


Silver Markets
 Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions                                     Gross Long and Short Positions of Commercial Positions
 Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012                        Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012
Mln Ozs                                                                          Mln Ozs
                                                                                               Mln Ozs                                                                          Mln Ozs
400                                                                                400          400                                                                              400
                     Net Fund Position in Comex
 350                                                                               350                                    Long
                                                                                                 300                                                                             300
                                                                                                                                      Net Position
 300                                                                               300           200                                                                             200
 250          Long                                                                 250           100                                                                             100
 200                                                                               200                0                                                                          0
 150                                                                               150           -100                                                                            -100
 100                                                                               100           -200                                                                            -200
  50                                                                               50            -300                                                                            -300
   0                                                                               0             -400                                                                            -400
  -50                                                                              -50           -500                     Short                                                  -500
 -100                                                                              -100          -600                                                                            -600
                                                                     Short
 -150                                                                              -150          -700                                                                            -700
 -200                                                                              -200          -800                                                                            -800
     A-95       M-97      J-99   A-01    S-03     N-05    D-07     J-10   F-12                       A-95   M-97   J-99     A-01    S-03    N-05     D-07        J-10    F-12


Gross Long and Short Positions of Comex Disaggragated Non-Commercial Positions
Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012
                                                                                                Silver Prices and Open Interest
                                                                                                Daily, Through 5 December 2012
    Mln Ozs                                                                      Mln Ozs
  400                                                                                  400     $/Ounces                                                             Million Ounces
                Long                                                                            52                                                                              1,000
  300                                                                                  300      48                                                                              900
                                                                                                      Total Open Interest
                                                                                                44
                                                                                                40                                                                              800
  200                                                                                  200      36                                                                              700
                                                                                                32                                                                              600
  100                                                                                  100      28
                                                                                                                                                                                500
                                                                                                24
                                                                                                20                                                                              400
        0                                                                              0
                                                                                                16                                                                              300
                                                                                                12                                                                              200
                                                  Money Managers
 -100                                                                                  -100      8
                                                  Other Traders                                  4                                       Prices (Left Scale)                    100
                Short
                                                  Net Position                                   0                                                                              0
 -200                                                                                  -200
                                                                                                   03 04 05 06 07                   08      09     10       11      12     13
    Jun-06 Apr-07          Feb-08   Dec-08 Oct-09     Aug-10 Jun-11 Apr-12


World Silver Supply and Demand                                                                 Silver Quarterly Average Price Projections
                                                                                               $/Ounce, through Q3 2014

                                                                                                $46                                                                              $46
1,100                                                                                  1,100
                                                                                                $42                                                                              $42
1,000                                                                                  1,000    $38                                                                              $38
                             Fabrication Demand
 900                                                                                    900     $34                                                                              $34

 800                                                                                    800     $30                                                                              $30
                                                                                                                   Actual
                                                                                                $26                                                                              $26
 700                                                                                    700
                                                                                                $22                                                                              $22
 600                                                                  Supply            600
                                                                                                $18                                                                              $18
                                                                                                                                                                  Projections
 500                                                                                    500     $14                                                                              $14

 400                                                                                    400     $10                                                                              $10
                                                                                                 $6                                                                              $6
 300                                                                                    300
                                                                                                 $2                                                                              $2
 200                                                                                    200       1999        2002           2005          2008         2011             2014
            60 63 66 68 72 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11
Precious Metals Advisory                                                      6 December 2012                             Page 21

 Silver Statistical Position
Million Ounces

Supply                                                       2007                   2008                   2009                  2010                   2011                 2012p                  2013p
Mine Production
 Mexico                                                       99.5                  104.1                  114.3                  128.6                 152.8                  160.9                  161.3
 United States                                                39.0                   40.2                   39.9                   40.8                  36.0                   34.3                   35.4
 Peru                                                        112.3                  118.5                  126.1                  116.9                 109.8                  109.0                  111.4
 Canada                                                       27.7                   24.3                   20.3                   19.2                  18.4                   17.8                   18.8
 Australia                                                    60.5                   61.9                   52.5                   60.4                  55.5                   57.0                   58.2
 China                                                        97.9                   96.3                  107.9                  112.5                 128.6                  135.4                  142.7
Other                                                        190.2                  189.6                  212.8                  207.8                 212.6                  208.5                  217.4
 Total                                                      627.1                  634.8                  673.8                  686.2                 713.6                  722.9                  745.1
 % Change Year Ago                                          5.0%                   1.2%                   6.1%                   1.9%                  4.0%                   1.3%                   3.1%
Secondary Supply
 Old Scrap                                                   242.2                  251.5                  249.9                  262.8                  270.8                 263.0                  255.0
 Coin Melt                                                     5.0                    4.0                    4.0                    2.0                    1.5                   3.0                    3.0
Other Supply                                                     0                      1                      2                      3                      4                     5                      6
 Indian Scrap                                                 16.1                   17.5                   21.7                   15.7                    4.8                  13.8                   10.0
 Total                                                      263.3                  273.0                  275.6                  280.5                  277.1                 279.8                  268.0
 % Change Year Ago                                         -1.9%                   3.7%                   1.0%                   1.8%                  -1.2%                  1.0%                  -4.2%
Other Supply
 Government Disposals                                           8.0                      0                      0                    3.8                   2.4                       0                     0
 Net Exports from
   Transitional Economies                                       5                     3                      1                     2                       2                      2                        2
 Total                                                         13                     3                      1                   5.8                     4.4                      2                        2
 % Change Year Ago                                        -45.8%                -76.9%                 -66.7%                480.0%                  -23.5%                 -55.0%
Total Supply                                                903.4                 910.8                  950.4                 972.5                   995.1                1,004.7               1,015.1
% Change Year Ago                                           1.5%                  0.8%                   4.3%                  2.3%                    2.3%                   1.0%                  1.0%
Fabrication Demand
 Photography                                                 161.5                  133.5                  119.4                  110.9                 102.6                   96.8                   93.1
 Jewelry & Silverware                                        284.7                  278.9                  276.5                  286.5                 290.9                  296.1                  308.0
 Electronics and Batteries                                   195.9                  204.3                  201.1                  212.8                 221.8                  234.4                  248.4
 Solar Panels                                                  6.3                   15.5                   22.6                   48.6                  59.8                   60.2                   64.0
 Other Uses                                                  212.3                  213.5                  176.4                  178.3                 178.8                  183.2                  189.5
 Other Countries                                               8.2                    9.7                    7.5                    6.5                   8.0                    9.7                   10.0
 Net Imports into the
   Transitional Economies
Total Fabrication Demand                                    869.0                  855.3                  803.6                  843.5                 861.9                  880.4                  913.0
 % Change Year Ago                                          1.3%                  -1.6%                  -6.1%                   5.0%                  2.2%                   2.1%                   2.6%
Net Surplus or Deficit                                       34.4                   55.5                  146.8                  129.0                 133.2                  124.4                  102.0
Addenda
 Coinage                                                       29.2                   54.4                  66.2                   82.5                   98.7                  79.7                    70.9
Price Per Ounce                                                                                                                                                                YTD
High                                                        $15.55                $20.79                 $19.33                 $30.94                 $48.58                 $37.14
Low                                                          11.50                  8.79                  10.44                  14.83                  26.81                  26.25
Average                                                      13.45                 14.97                  14.67                  20.31                  35.29                  31.15
% Change Year Ago                                          15.9%                 11.3%                   -2.0%                 38.4%                  73.8%                 -12.8%

*Million Ounces; Notes: Totals may not equal the sum of categories due to rounding. Mine production in Poland, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia is included in "other" mine
production; Photography, jewelry and silverware, electronics, and 'other' industrial use reflects demand in Europe, the United States, and Japan.; These sectors include Canada from 1979, Mexico from 1982,
Hong Kong from 1985, Thailand from 1986, India from 1987, Australia, Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Argentina, Chile, Korea, Pakistan, and Bangladesh from 1989, and Taiwan from 1990; Demand excludes the
transitional economies, except for imports.; The price is the Comex nearby active settlement, percent change from year earlier period. 2012 through 6 December. There may be discrepancies due to rounding; p
- projections; NM - Not meaningful; Source: CPM Group 6 December 2012.
Precious Metals Advisory                                 6 December 2012               Page 22


Platinum Outlook
Platinum prices may trend higher over the next three              ment rate stood at 25.5% in the third quarter of the year
months, driven by portfolio rebalancing, investor con-            and has been rising since the fourth quarter of 2011.
cerns about the uncertainty of supply flows from South            South Africa’s chronically high unemployment rate is
Africa, and the roll of the nearby active January contract        one contributing factor to the increase in illegal strike
into forward months. Fabrication demand weakness in               activity this year, as many mine workers are supporting
Europe is expected to limit price increases over the next         unemployed family members and experiencing extreme
three months, however. Prices could rise toward $1,700            cost pressures. Discussions about transitioning to a cen-
and remain above $1,540 over the three-month projected            tralized wage-bargaining structure for the platinum min-
period.                                                           ing industry have been progressing. The gold mining in-
                                                                  dustry adopted this procedure long ago and authorities
Supply constraints eased in November after Anglo Plati-           have been assessing the possibility of using this model in
num announced it had achieved a resolution to the illegal         the platinum industry. This could reduce labor issues in
strikes at its Rustenburg, Union, and Amandabult opera-           the future, but in the interim will serve as a source of un-
tions on 15 November. The company lost almost                     certainty to the platinum market.
200,000 ounces of potential platinum output since the
first strikes at the Rustenburg operations began in Sep-
tember. Atlatsa Resources reported it planned on restart-
ing operations at its jointly owned Bokoni mine. Strike
activity began there in October. CPM Group expected               Platinum Prices: 1 January 2010 to 5 December 2012
mine supply in South Africa to decline to 4.1 million              $ / Oz
ounces in 2012, down 12.1% from the previous year.
This compares to a 4.7% increase in South African output
                                                                   1900
projected for 2012 at the beginning of the year.

The platinum industry in South Africa remains highly
vulnerable to supply shocks at present. Although illegal           1700
strike activity has abated substantially, there is still poten-
tial for more strikes to occur in the near future. According
to Susan Shabangu, the country’s Mineral Resources                 1500
Minister, the platinum mining industry has shed 3,332
jobs in the past six months. South Africa’s unemploy-
                                                                   1300
                                                                     Jan-10         Jul-10     Jan-11    Jul-11   Jan-12   Jul-12



Platinum Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014
$ / Ounce
                                                                                        Quarterly
                                                                  Year Quarter                          Change    Annual AVG Change
                                                                                          AVG
$1,900                                                   $1,900
                                                                  2012        IV             $1,604       6.5%       $1,556         -5.4%
$1,700      Actual                                       $1,700   2013         I             $1,615       0.7%
                                                                              II             $1,567      -3.0%
$1,500                                                   $1,500
                                                                              III            $1,527      -2.5%

$1,300                                                   $1,300
                                                                              IV             $1,634       7.0%       $1,586         1.9%

                                           Projections            2014         I             $1,693       3.6%
$1,100                                                   $1,100               II             $1,719       1.5%
                                                                              III            $1,658      -3.5%
  $900                                                   $900
     2009       2010   2011     2012    2013     2014
Precious Metals Advisory                6 December 2012            Page 23

In addition to wage issues, fresh concerns about the sup-       tential output during the strike, which is about 4.1%
ply of electricity surfaced last month. Eskom, the main         of South African platinum output in 2011. Workers
utility provider in the country, reported that its supply/      accepted Anglo’s wage offer, which increased
demand balance of electricity was extremely narrow due          monthly base salaries by 400 South African rand and
to unplanned outages. This fresh uncertainty may be sup-        included a one off allowance payable upon returning
portive of prices over the next few weeks.                      to work. CPM Group estimates that Anglo Platinum’s
                                                                output could be around 12% lower in 2012 from the
Prices                                                          previous year.
                                                                Impala Platinum reported results for the quarter
    Prices trended higher last month, from an intraday          ended 30 September last month. The company pro-
    low of $1,534.50 on 7 November to an intraday high          duced 454,000 refined ounces of platinum during the
    of $1,626.60 on 23 November, a 6.0% increase. Plati-        quarter, up 17.0% from 388,000 ounces produced in
    num traded sideways after 23 November, mostly be-           the same quarter in 2011. The company decided to
    tween $1,580 and $1,625. Prices averaged $1,579.40          defer its phase 2 expansion plants at Zimplats to 2015
    for the month, down 3.5% from the previous month.           as part of its capital preservation measures. Cash
    The monthly volatility rate fell to 15.7% in Novem-         costs at Impala mines increased by around 15%, due
    ber from 19.7% the previous month. This was lower           to poor mining quality at its Rustenburg operations,
    than the 24.9% rate in November of last year and was        wage pressures, and adverse exchange rates.
    the lowest monthly rate since July of 2011.                 The strike that began at the Bokoni mine, jointly
                                                                owned by Atlatsa Resources and Anglo Platinum, on
                                                                1 October may have ended or will come to an end
                                                                soon. Atlatsa reported in its 3 December press release
Supply                                                          that it was currently in the process of “re-hiring
                                                                workers with the view to re-commencing operations
    Anglo Platinum restarted operations on 15 November          as soon as possible.” The Bokoni mine is one of the
    at its Rustenburg mines, where an illegal strike had        highest cost mines in the industry and only produces
    halted mining activities since 13 September, and its        about 100,000 ounces of platinum a year.
    Union and Amandelbult operations, where strike ac-          Renewed concerns about South Africa’s power sup-
    tion began in early October. These operations ac-           ply surfaced in the first week of December. Eskom,
    count nearly 60% of the company’s South African             the main power provider in the country, reported it
    platinum production capacity and roughly 30% of             only had about 2% of excess supply of electricity.
    total South African platinum production capacity. In        The narrow margin was attributed to unplanned out-
    the company’s 15 November press release, Anglo              ages. About four years ago, the country experienced
    Platinum reported it had lost 191,359 ounces of po-         rolling blackouts due to an electricity shortage. These
                                                                blackouts halted PGM mining operations and contrib-
Platinum Prices                                                 uted to the PGM price spikes of 2008.


Platinum Price Volatility
Monthly, Through November 2012

100%
 90%
 80%
 70%
 60%
 50%
 40%
 30%
 20%
 10%
  0%
       75   79   83    87    91   95   99   03   07   11
Precious Metals Advisory                          6 December 2012             Page 24

Fabrication Demand                                                        year. Sales this year through November in Germany,
                                                                          France, Italy, and Spain are down 1.2%, 13.7%
    Commercial vehicle demand in the United States and                    20.0%, and 12.8% year-on-year.
    Japan are up 10.0% and 21.5% this year through Oc-                    Gross imports of platinum in China are up 2.5% this
    tober from the same period a year ago. Commercial                     year through October from the same period in 2011.
    vehicle sales in Western Europe and China are down                    Trading volumes of platinum on the Shanghai Gold
    10.6% and 7.9%, respectively. Commercial vehicles                     Exchange are down 1.3% this year through Novem-
    have large engines, which holding other factors con-                  ber from 2011 levels. Trading volumes in November
    stant requires higher PGM loadings in the fitted auto                 fell to 161,525 ounces, down 0.9% from November
    catalysts. These auto catalysts typically are more                    2011.
    platinum intensive, due to the sulfur content of the
    diesel fuel often used.                                        Investment Demand
    Passenger car demand in Western Europe was 6.9%
    lower in 2012 through October from the same period                    Investors were net sellers of platinum exchange
    a year ago. Sales in the major auto markets last                      traded products in November, reducing their holdings
    month were lower than last year’s sales levels. Ger-                  by 19,365 ounces or 1.3% from the end of October.
    many’s auto market worsened last month. Sales fell                    Holdings totaled 1.5 million ounces on 30 November,
    to 259,846 vehicles, down 3.5% from a year ago.                       up 15.0% from the end of 2011. Holdings are down
    Auto sales in France, Italy, and Spain all showed                     2.8% from a peak of 1.6 million ounces reached in
    double-digit declines in November from the previous                   late September.

Platinum Fabrication Demand

Annual Growth in New Car Registrations in Europe                    Commercial Vehicle Sales in Major Auto Markets
                                                                    Change over same period a year ago
                         2009        2010          2011 2012YTD
                                                                    Y-o-Y % Chg.                                           Y-o-Y % Chg.
Germany                 24.4%      -23.2%          8.2%    -1.2%   40%                                                              40%
France                  10.9%        1.4%         -2.5%   -13.7%           China       USA       Europe    Japan
                                                                   30%                                                               30%
Italy                   -0.9%      -10.4%        -10.7%   -20.0%
United Kingdom          -6.6%        2.2%         -4.9%     4.7%   20%                                                               20%

S pain                 -16.8%        3.9%        -17.9%   -12.8%   10%                                                               10%
Western Europe          -1.7%       -5.1%         -1.3%    -6.9%
                                                                    0%                                                               0%
S ource: ACEA via Bloomberg.
                                                                   -10%                                                              -10%
Note: Country data through November, except for the U.K.,
which is through October. Western Europe data through              -20%                                                              -20%
October.
                                                                   -30%                                                              -30%


 Annual Change in European Passenger Car Sales                     -40%                                                              -40%
                                                                            2007      2008       2009     2010     2011   2012 YTD
 30.0%                                                              Note: 2012 Through October
                                        Germany
                                        France
 20.0%
                                        Italy
                                        United Kingdom
 10.0%
                                        Spain
                                        Western Europe
  0.0%


-10.0%


-20.0%


-30.0%
            2009          2010          2011        2012YTD
 Note: 2012 through November Western Europe and U.K. through
 October.
Precious Metals Advisory                                       6 December 2012                    Page 25

Markets & Inventories                                                                                    Daily trading volumes of Nymex platinum futures
                                                                                                         fell to 416,259 ounces in November from 460,122
       Open interest in Nymex platinum futures fell from                                                 ounces in October.
       3.06 million ounces on 31 October to a monthly low                                                Large non-commercial Nymex market participants
       of 2.98 million ounces on 20 November. Open inter-                                                raised their net long positions in platinum futures by
       est began rising thereafter, touching 3.10 million                                                466,400 ounces between 30 October and 27 Novem-
       ounces on 3 December.                                                                             ber, a 52.2% increase. Gross long positions increased
       Open interest in the nearby active January contract                                               by 21% and gross short positions decreased by 42.5%
       trended lower last month, from 2.87 million ounces at                                             during the period.
       the end of October to 2.73 million ounces on 4 De-
       cember, a 5.0% decrease.


 Platinum Investment Demand                                                                       Platinum Markets
Platinum ETF Holdings                                                                             Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions
Data as of 30 November 2012, Changes from 31 October                                              Platinum Futures & Options. Weekly Data, Through 30 October 2012
                                                                                                  '000 Ozs                                        '000 Ozs
                     Month-end Holdings                                % ∆ Ounce ∆                2,700                                             2,700
PPLT ETF S ecurities             491,581                       ↓     -1.0%   -5,058               2,400                                             2,400
                                                                                                  2,100                                  Long       2,100
Platinum ZKB                     353,395                       ↓      0.0%     -161
                                                                                                  1,800                                             1,800
Platinum Julius Baer             105,670                       ↓     -0.2%     -250                           Net Fund Position in Nymex
                                                                                                  1,500                                             1,500
PHPT ETFS                        518,384                       ↑      2.1%   11,002
                                                                                                  1,200                                             1,200
GLTR - ETFS                        8,471                       ↑      2.7%      225                 900                                             900
WITE - ETFS                        7,319                        ─     0.0%        0                 600                                             600
Platinum MS L                      5,108                       ↑      2.7%      136                 300                                             300
S PLT iS hares                     3,279                       ↓      0.0%       -1                   0                                              0
S PPT S ource                     14,677                        ─     0.0%        0                -300                                             -300
Japan Mitsubishi                  15,882                        ─     0.0%        0                -600
                                                                                                                                          Short
                                                                                                                                                    -600
Total                          1,523,766                       ↓     -1.3%  -19,365                -900                                             -900
YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings*                       ↑     15.0% 198,302               -1,200                                             -1,200
                                                                                                       A-95 M-97 J-99 D-01 J-04 F-06 A-08 M-10 J-12
*YTD Holdings as of 30 November 2012. Percentage change is

 Platinum Exchange Traded Product Holdings
 Daily, through 30 November 2012                                                                  Platinum Prices, Total Open Interest, and Nymex Inventories
                                                                                                  Daily, Through 5 December 2012
 Mln Oz                                                                            Mln Oz         $ / Oz                                                              Mln Ozs
 1.8                                                                                   1.8       3,000                                                                     3.5
          SPPT - LSE Source
 1.6                                                                                    1.6
          SPLT-LSE iShares                                                                       2,500                                                                     3.0
 1.4                                                                                    1.4
          WITE-NYSE ETFS
                                                                                                                 Prices (Left scale)                                       2.5
 1.2                                                                                    1.2      2,000
          GLTR-NYSE ETFS
                                                                        PPLT
 1.0                                                                    NYSE            1.0                                                                                2.0
          Julius Baer Platinum                                                                   1,500
 0.8                                                                                    0.8
          MSL ASX                                                                                                                                                          1.5
                                                                 ZKB
 0.6                                                           Platinum                 0.6      1,000
          Tokyo Mitsubishi                                                                                                                                                 1.0
 0.4                                                                                    0.4
                                                                                                                                                       Nymex Stocks
                                                                                                  500                                                                      0.5
 0.2                                                       PHPT LSE                     0.2
                                                                                                                                       Open Interest

 0.0                                                                                    0.0          0                                                                     0.0
 20-Apr-07     20-Apr-08     20-Apr-09     20-Apr-10     20-Apr-11     20-Apr-12
                                                                                                     D-02 F-04 A-05 J-06 S-07 N-08 J-10 M-11 M-12

Note: PHPT-ETF Securities’ platinum ETF traded on the London Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich
Cantonal's platinum ETF traded. PPLT-ETF Securities’ platinum ETF traded on the New York
Stock Exchange. Julius Baer’s platinum ETF traded on the Swiss Exchange. MSL-Metals Securities
Australia platinum ETF. GLTR-ETF Securities’ Precious Metals Basket ETF traded on the New
York Stock Exchange. WITE-ETF Securities’ white metals basket ETF traded on the New York
Stock Exchange. SPLT-iShares platinum ETC traded on the London Stock Exchange. SPPT-
Source’s platinum ETP traded on the London Stock Exchange. Tokyo-Mitsubishi’s Japanese
Platinum ETC.
Precious Metals Advisory                                                6 December 2012                          Page 26

Platinum Statistical Position

Platinum Statistical Position
Supply                                                        2007                2008               2009              2010e                2011              2012p              2013p
Mine Production
 South Africa                                                 5,039               4,778              4,537               4,684              4,695               4,128              4,581
 Russia                                                         935                 800                804                 834                811                 803                823
 Canada                                                         206                 235                144                  96                247                 257                270
 United States                                                  128                 119                126                 113                122                 118                119
 Other                                                          363                 369                403                 457                510                 519                530
 Total                                                        6,672               6,301              6,014               6,184              6,385               5,826              6,322
 % Change Year Ago                                           -5.1%               -5.6%              -4.6%                2.8%               3.3%               -8.8%               8.5%
Secondary Supply
 Total                                                          920               1,000                750                964                 988                 998              1,038
 % Change Year Ago                                           13.6%                8.7%             -25.0%              28.5%                2.5%                1.0%               4.0%
Total Supply                                                  7,592              7,301               6,764              7,147               7,373              6,824              7,360
 % Change Year Ago                                           -3.2%               -3.8%              -7.4%                5.7%               3.2%               -7.4%               7.9%
Fabrication Demand
 Auto                                                          4,195              3,785               2,740              3,081               3,173              3,285              3,341
 Jewelry                                                       1,772              1,698               2,283              1,926               1,946              1,974              2,038
 Other                                                         1,877              1,975               1,959              2,196               2,196              2,240              2,298
Total Demand                                                  7,844              7,457               6,982              7,202               7,315              7,499              7,677
 % Change Year Ago                                            0.3%               -4.9%              -6.4%                3.2%               1.6%                2.5%               2.4%
Net Surplus or Deficit                                         -252                -157               -218                 -55                  58               -675               -316
Price Per Ounce                                                                                                                                                  YTD
 High                                                    $1,549.30           $2,276.10          $1,506.30           $1,809.60          $1,905.70           $1,725.10
 Low                                                     $1,112.00             $787.20            $922.20           $1,460.00          $1,363.40           $1,386.40
 Average                                                 $1,314.46           $1,579.31          $1,214.50           $1,614.22          $1,722.39           $1,552.35
 % Change Year Ago                                          14.6%               20.1%             -23.1%               32.9%               6.7%              -12.3%

*Thousand Troy Ounces; Notes: Excludes transitional economies, except as noted. Secondary production statistics exclude toll-refined material; Prices are settlement prices for the nearby
active contract on the New York Mercantile Exchange. 2012 through 6 December. Changes in market inventories are year-end. *Changes in 1997 market inventories exclude U.S. Industry
stocks since the U.S. Bureau of Mines ceased publication of U.S. Industry stock level data in the third quarter of 1997; As of 2006 Inventories includes changes in ETF holdings; There may
be discrepancies due to rounding; NA -- not available; e -- estimates; p -- projections; Sources: U.S. Bureau of Mines, Statistics Canada, trade sources, CPM Group; 6 December 2012.




World Platinum Supply and Demand Balance                                                          Platinum Quarterly Average Price Projections
 Thou. Ounces                                                                                       $/Ounce, through Q3 2014



  9,000                                                                          9,000              $2,600                                                                         $2,600
  8,000                                                                          8,000
                                                                                                    $2,200                                                                         $2,200
                       Total Supply
  7,000                                                                          7,000
                       Total Demand
  6,000                                                                          6,000              $1,800                                                                         $1,800

  5,000                                                                          5,000                                    Actual
                                                                                                    $1,400                                                                         $1,400
  4,000                                                                          4,000                                                                                  Projections
  3,000                                                                          3,000              $1,000                                                                         $1,000

  2,000                                                                          2,000
                                                                                                      $600                                                                         $600
  1,000                                                                          1,000
       0                                                     0                                        $200                                                                         $200
           1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013p                                            1999           2002         2005         2008        2011         2014
Precious Metals Advisory                                6 December 2012                 Page 27


Palladium Outlook
Palladium has price supportive mine supply fundamentals          becomes a concern and investors liquidate their positions.
but the fabrication demand fundamentals could weaken             Prices are unlikely to decline below these levels because
over the next few months, which could weigh on prices.           of the price supportive mine supply fundamentals. On the
The illegal labor strikes at South African mines have            upside prices could rise toward $725. If prices break past
been resolved, for the most part, but there are still several    this level prices are could find resistance at $750. Prices
country related risks, such as poor infrastructure and gov-      are likely to rise to these levels in the event that the fiscal
ernment policies that could hamper mine supply in the            cliff is averted. In such a scenario, all asset prices could
future. Since none of these factors is an active issue at        potentially see at least an initial increase in value.
present these problems are expected to be more price sup-
portive than factors that result in pushing higher the price
of palladium.
On the fabrication demand side, there has been strength
in demand from two of palladium’s largest uses, auto
catalysts and semiconductors. Much of the demand
growth in both of these areas has been driven by stronger
growth from the United States. Fabrication demand is
likely to be hurt in the first half of next year as the U.S.     Palladium Prices
undergoes fiscal tightening. Irrespective of how U.S.             Palladium Prices: 1 January 2009 to 5 December 2012
politicians handle the fiscal cliff situation, there will be a
                                                                    $ / Oz
negative impact on the economy. If the fiscal cliff is             900
averted, the scenario we assign the greatest probability,          850
the negative impact of the fiscal tightening will be less          800
than if no decision is made on how to handle the situa-            750
tion, a scenario we consider to be unlikely. Additionally,         700
the U.S. auto market is beginning to show signs of an              650
increase in inventory levels for some models, despite the          600
strong growth in demand for auto in the U.S. market this
                                                                   550
year. This could weigh on future palladium demand.
                                                                   500
On the downside, palladium prices could potentially de-            450
cline toward $600 or even $580 if fabrication demand               400
                                                                   350
                                                                     Jan-10         Jul-10    Jan-11   Jul-11   Jan-12     Jul-12

Palladium Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014
$ / Ounce
                                                                                        Quarterly
   $900                                                  $900    Year Quarter                          Change   Annual AVG Change
                                                                                          AVG
   $800                                                  $800
            Actual                                               2012         IV             $640       4.1%        $642            -12.6%
   $700                                                  $700
   $600                                                  $600    2013          I             $632       -1.3%

   $500                                                  $500                 II             $638       1.0%
   $400                                                  $400                 III            $625       -2.0%
                                          Projections
   $300                                                  $300                 IV             $678       8.5%        $643            0.2%
   $200                                                  $200    2014          I             $722       6.4%
   $100                                                  $100
                                                                              II             $738       2.2%
     $0                                                  $0
      2009       2010   2011    2012    2013     2014                         III            $710       -3.7%
Precious Metals Advisory                                6 December 2012            Page 28


Prices                                                                               There are several structural problems with South Af-
                                                                                     rica’s mining industry, however, which should con-
     Palladium prices rose by around 13% during Novem-                               tinue to threaten supply and should underpin palla-
     ber. Prices settled at $686.25 on 30 November, up                               dium prices.
     from $609.80 on 31 October. Palladium prices settled
     higher on more days than it settled lower, during No-                       Fabrication Demand
     vember. The roll of the then nearby active December
     Nymex contract, coupled with an increase in invest-                             Monthly U.S. light-duty vehicle sales continued to
     ment demand helped to drive palladium prices                                    rise in November reaching 1.13 million, up 14.8%
     higher. In November, palladium prices retraced all of                           from the corresponding period in 2011. For the first
     the losses that it suffered between the last week of                            11 months of 2012, U.S. light-duty vehicle sales to-
     September and the end of October.                                               taled 13.08 million, up 13.8% or 1.6 million vehicles
                                                                                     over the same period in 2011. Availability of cheap
Supply                                                                               and relatively easy financing has been the primary
                                                                                     driver of demand during 2012. Demand in November
     Strikes at South Africa’s platinum group metal mines                            also is said to be helped by the destruction of cars
     were resolved for the most part during November.                                due to Superstorm Sandy. It is estimated that around

Palladium Price Volatility and Fabrication Demand

Palladium Price Volatility                                                       U.S. Vehicle Sales
Monthly, Through November 2012                                                   Monthly Data, Through November 2012
                                                                                 Thousand Vehicles
100%
                                                                                 1,600
 90%                                                                                                       2010          2011        2012
                                                                                 1,400
 80%
 70%                                                                             1,200
 60%                                                                             1,000
 50%
                                                                                   800
 40%
 30%                                                                               600

 20%                                                                               400
 10%                                                                               200
  0%
       77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13                      -
                                                                                          Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

 Annual Percentage Change in Auto Sales                                          Chinese Vehicle Sales
                                                                                 Monthly ,Through October 2012
 60.0%
                                                                                 Thousand Vehicles
 50.0%
                                                                                 2,000
 40.0%                                                                                                      2010        2011       2012
                                                                                 1,900
 30.0%                                                                           1,800
 20.0%                                                                           1,700
 10.0%                                                                           1,600
  0.0%                                                                           1,500
 -10.0%                                                                          1,400

 -20.0%                                                                          1,300
                                    Brazil          Russia
 -30.0%
                                                                                 1,200
                                    India           China
                                                                                 1,100
 -40.0%
                2009             2010             2011           2012 YTD        1,000
 Source: Bloomberg. Note: 2012 data through September. Brazil through October.           Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Precious Metals Advisory                                      6 December 2012          Page 29



      250,000 vehicles were lost to the storm.                                                     Investment Demand
      One area of concern with regard to future demand for
      palladium is that there is a significant build up in the                                            Palladium exchange traded product (ETP) holdings
      inventory of certain vehicles despite the increase in                                               rose at the beginning of November, rising to 1.91
      demand.                                                                                             million ounces on 5 November. Holdings slipped
      According to the Semiconductor Industry Associa-                                                    lower over the next few days reaching a low of 1.862
      tion, global semiconductor sales in October rose to                                                 million ounces on 15 November. Holdings rose over
      $25.2 billion, up 1.7% from the prior month. Year-to-                                               the remainder of November, rising back to levels
      date sales through October 2012 were down 3.7%                                                      near those seen at the beginning of the month. On 30
      from the corresponding period in 2011.                                                              November, palladium ETP holdings had reached 1.89
                                                                                                          million ounces.
                                                                                                          Investor holdings in palladium ETPs had continued
 Palladium Investment Demand                                                                              to rise into the first few days of December, with hold-
                                                                                                          ings reaching around 1.9 million ounces on 5 Decem-
 Net Sales/Purchases of Palladium ETPs                                                                    ber.
 Thousand Ounces                                                         Thousand Ounces
 1,200                                                                                  1,200      Markets & Inventories
 1,000                                                                                  1,000
                                                                                                          Total open interest in the Nymex palladium contract
   800                                                                                  800               rose during November. Total open interest rose from
   600                                                                                  600               2.07 million ounces at the end of October to 2.3 mil-
                                                                                                          lion ounces at the end of November. The increase in
   400                                                                                  400
                                                                                                          total open interest gained momentum toward the end
   200                                                                                  200               of the month, rising to a high of 2.35 million ounces
      0                                                                                 0
                                                                                                          on 29 November from 2.16 million ounces on 21 No-
                                                                                                          vember. Total open interest continued to rise into the
  -200                                                                                  -200              first few days of December. On 3 December, total
  -400                                                                                  -400              open interest was at 2.36 million ounces.
                                                                                                          Open interest in the December Nymex contract de-
  -600                                                                                  -600
             2007         2008        2009         2010           2011     2012 YTD                       clined over the course of November as market par-
                                                                                                          ticipants either rolled forward or closed out their po-
Palladium ETP Holdings                                                                                    sitions. Open interest in this contract slipped from
Data as of 30 November Changes from 30 October
                                                                                                          1.89 million ounces at the beginning of November to
               Month-end Holdings                                           %∆        Ounce ∆
PALL ETF S ecurities        712,675                          ↓            -5.6%        -39,819
Palladium ZKB - S IX        355,276                          ↓             0.0%           -161      Palladium ETP Holdings
Palladium Julius Baer       133,923                          ↑             1.0%          1,400      Through November 2012
PHPD ETF S ecurities        550,721                          ↑             6.6%         36,587      Mln Oz                                                  Mln Oz
                                                                                                    2.5                                                         2.5
GLTR - ETFS                  12,633                          ↑             2.3%            292                 Mitsubishi
WITE - ETFS                   5,875                           ─            0.0%              0
                                                                                                               SPAL
Palladium MS L - AS X         3,812                          ↑             2.8%            106      2.0                                                         2.0
S PDM iS hares                6,348                          ↓             0.0%             -2                 SPDM
S PAL S ource               102,982                          ↑             1.5%          1,509                 WITE
Mitsubishi                   12,539                                        0.0%              0      1.5                                       PALL              1.5
                                                              ─
Total                     1,896,784                          ↓             0.0%            -86                 GLTR                           NYSE
YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings*                                              191,994       1.0        Julius Baer                                      1.0
*As of 30 November
                                                                                                               MSL ASX                         ZKB
Note: PHPD-ETF Palladium traded on the London Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich Cantonal's                 0.5                                                         0.5
palladium ETF traded. PALL—ETFS Palladium traded on the New York Stock Exchange . Metals
Securities Australia . Julius Baer’s palladium ETF traded on the Swiss Exchange. Precious Metals                                               PHPD LSE
Basket ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. WITE-ETF Securities’ white metals basket
ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. SPDM-iShares’ palladium ETC traded on the                0.0                                                         0.0
London Stock Exchange. SPAL-Source’s palladium ETC traded on the London Stock Exchange.               2007     2008         2009     2010    2011    2012
Mitsubishi is palladium ETP traded on Tokyo Stock Exchange.
                                                                                                    Source: ETP issuer websites, Bloomberg
Precious Metals Advisory                                  6 December 2012                   Page 30


      84,400 ounces at the end of the month. Based on the
      increase in total open interest over this time it is most
      likely that market participants rolled their positions
      into future months. Open interest in the nearby active
      March Comex contract was at 2.3 million ounces on
      4 December, up from 2.2 million ounces at the end of
      November.
      Palladium delivered via the December Nymex con-
      tract totaled 77,600 ounces as of 5 December. Nymex
      registered inventories were unchanged at 531,100
      ounces during the first 5 days of the December.
      Net long positions held by large non-commercial
      market participants rose to 1.36 million ounces on 27
      November, the highest level that net long positions
      have been at since August 2011. On 2 August 2011,
      net long positions had reached 1.72 million ounces.
      The increase in net long positions, which were at
      892,900 ounces at the end of October, was driven by
      a combination of an increase in gross long positions
      and a decline in gross short positions. Gross long po-
      sitions reached 1.61 million ounces on 27 November,
      the highest level since 2 August 2011 when they
      were at 1.9 million ounces. Gross shorts also declined
      during November, slipping to 252,700 ounces on 27
      November from 439,500 ounces at the end of Octo-
      ber.




Palladium Markets

Palladium Prices, Total Open Interest, and Nymex Inventories                 Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions
Daily, Through 5 December 2012                                               Nymex Palladium Futures &Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012
 $ / Oz                                                           Mln Ozs                                                                     '000 Ozs
                                                                             '000 Ozs
900                                                                    3.0     2,000                                                            2,000
                                                                               1,800                                                            1,800
800                                                                            1,600     Long                                                   1,600
                                                                       2.5
                                                                               1,400                                                            1,400
700        Prices (Left scale)                                                 1,200                                                            1,200
                                                                       2.0     1,000         Net Position in Nymex                              1,000
600
                                                                                 800                                                            800
500                                                                    1.5       600                                                            600
                                                                                 400                                                            400
400                                                                              200                                                            200
                                                        Open           1.0         0                                                            0
                                                       Interest
300                                                                             -200                                                            -200
                                                                       0.5      -400                                                            -400
200                                                                             -600                                                            -600
                                 Nymex Stocks                                            Short
                                                                                -800                                                            -800
100                                                          0.0              -1,000                                                            -1,000
  D-02 S-03 J-04M-05M-06J-07 N-07 S-08 J-09 A-10F-11 D-11O-12                       A-95 S-96 M-98 A-99 O-02 M-04 A-05 J-07 J-08 D-09 M-11 O-12
Precious Metals Advisory                                                 6 December 2012                          Page 31

Palladium Statistical Position
Supply                                                      2007                2008               2009                2010             2011e               2012p              2013p
Mine Production
 Russia                                                      3,120             2,737                2,686              2,732              2,714               2,671              2,698
 South Africa                                                2,630             2,447                2,443              2,616              2,638               2,348              2,612
 Canada                                                        550               513                  229                250                503                 539                603
 United States                                                 423               394                  418                382                407                 395                397
 Others                                                        539               442                  550                571                615                 630                632
Total                                                       7,262             6,533                6,326              6,551              6,876               6,583              6,941
% Change Year Ago                                          -2.0%            -10.0%                -3.2%               3.5%               5.0%               -4.3%               5.4%
Secondary Supply
Total                                                       1,508              1,585              1,347              1,664               1,730               1,791              1,881
% Change Year Ago                                           7.2%               5.1%             -15.0%              23.5%                4.0%                3.5%               5.0%
Total Supply                                                8,770              8,118              7,673              8,214               8,607               8,374              8,822
% Change Year Ago                                          -0.5%              -7.4%              -5.5%               7.1%                4.8%               -2.7%               5.4%
Fabrication Demand
 Electronics                                                1,200               1,125               1,095             1,179               1,207               1,243              1,284
 Automotive                                                 4,545               4,252               3,960             4,656               4,919               5,338              5,688
 Dental                                                       776                 775                 782               784                 782                 783                779
 Other                                                      1,241               1,285               1,206             1,152               1,137               1,133              1,178
Total Demand                                               7,762               7,437               7,043             7,771               8,045               8,497              8,929
% Change Year Ago                                          2.1%               -4.2%               -5.3%             10.3%                3.5%                5.6%               5.1%
Net Surplus or Deficit                                     1,007                 681                 631               444                 561                -123               -108
Price Per Ounce                                                                                                                                              YTD
 High                                                    $389.50             $600.00            $410.00             $804.90            $857.70            $719.75
 Low                                                     $315.20             $160.30            $176.10             $380.05            $564.15            $561.60
 Average                                                 $358.28             $352.98            $266.75             $529.11            $733.85            $640.31
% Change Year Ago                                        10.8%                -1.5%             -24.4%              98.4%              38.7%              -13.5%
*Thousand Troy Ounces; Notes: Excludes transitional economies, except as noted. Secondary production statistics exclude toll-refined material. Prices are settlement prices for the active


World Palladium Supply and Demand Balance                                                          Palladium Quarterly Average Price Projections
 Thou. Ounces                                                                                       $/Ounce, through Q3 2014
10,000                                                                             10,000

 9,000                                                                             9,000            $1,100                                                                           $1,100
                        Total Supply                                                                $1,000                                                                           $1,000
 8,000                                                                             8,000
                        Total Demand                                                                  $900                                                                           $900
 7,000                                                                             7,000
                                                                                                      $800                                                                           $800
 6,000                                                                             6,000
                                                                                                      $700                           Actual                                          $700
 5,000                                                                             5,000
                                                                                                      $600                                                                           $600
 4,000                                                                             4,000              $500                                                                P          $500
                                                                                                                                                                          r
                                                                                                                                                                          o
 3,000                                                                             3,000              $400                                                                j
                                                                                                                                                                          e          $400
                                                                                                                                                                          c
                                                                                                                                                                          t
                                                                                                                                                                          i
                                                                                                                                                                          o
 2,000                                                                             2,000              $300                                                                n
                                                                                                                                                                          s
                                                                                                                                                                                     $300
                                                                                                      $200                                                                           $200
 1,000                                                                             1,000
                                                                                                      $100                                                                           $100
      0                                                                           0                      1999           2002         2005          2008         2011          2014
          1976   1981      1986      1991      1996      2001      2006      2011e
Precious Metals Advisory                                  6 December 2012                     Page 32


 Rhodium
 The Price of Rhodium                                                                Rhodium Supply and Demand
 Monthly Average NY Dealer Price, Through November 2012
                                                                                     Thousand Ounces                                         Thousand Ounces
    $/Oz                                                                   $/Oz
                                                                                     1,400                                                                 1,400
  $10,000                                                                $10,000
   $9,000                                                                $9,000      1,200                                                                 1,200
                                                                                                                                   Demand
   $8,000                                                                $8,000
                                                                                     1,000                                                                 1,000
   $7,000                                                                $7,000
   $6,000                                                                $6,000       800                                                                  800
   $5,000                                                                $5,000                                                             Supply
                                                                                      600                                                                  600
   $4,000                                                                $4,000
   $3,000                                                                $3,000       400                                                                  400
   $2,000                                                                $2,000
                                                                                      200                                                                  200
   $1,000                                                                $1,000
         $0                                                              $0             0                                                                  0
              72 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11                                      1976    1981   1986   1991   1996     2001   2006     2011




Rhodium Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014
$ / Ounce
                                                                                                            Quarterly
                                                                                     Year Quarter                         Change     Annual AVG Change
  $3,000                                                                 $3,000                               AVG

  $2,500                                                                 $2,500      2012           IV       $1,145        -2.0%          $1,276          -25.9%
                                                      Projections                    2013            I       $1,120        -2.2%
  $2,000                                                                 $2,000
                                                                                                    II       $1,193        6.5%
                           Actual
  $1,500                                                                 $1,500
                                                                                                    III      $1,300        9.0%

  $1,000                                                                 $1,000                     IV       $1,404        8.0%           $1,254          -1.7%
                                                                                     2014            I       $1,460        4.0%
    $500                                                                 $500
                                                                                                    II       $1,387        -5.0%
         $0                                                              $0                         III      $1,360        -2.0%
          2009      2010      2011       2012       2013      2014


  Rhodium Exchange Traded Product Holdings
  Daily, Through 1 December 2012
  Ounces                                                                 Ounces
60,000                                                                     60,000

50,000                                                                      50,000

40,000                                                                      40,000

30,000                                                                      30,000

20,000                                                                      20,000

10,000                                                                      10,000

     0                                                                        0
    May-11        Sep-11       Jan-12       May-12         Sep-12
 Note: Metal is stored in the United Kingdom and is the combined holdings of the
 ETC's two primary listings, the db Physical Rhodium ETC (EUR) traded on the
 Xetra and Borse Italiano and the db Physical Rhodium ETC traded on the LSE.
 Source: db, Bloomberg
Precious Metals Advisory                             6 December 2012         Page 33


Precious Metal Price Table
                  Gold                 Silver             Platinum            Palladium               Rhodium
  Yr      Q            Quarterly            Quarterly            Quarterly           Quarterly               Quarterly
                          %                    %                    %                   %                       %
              Price     Change     Price     Change     Price     Change     Price    Change         Price    Change

2003    I     $353       8.8%      $4.67       3.1%     $654      11.8%      $245     -13.6%         $608     -11.4%
        II    $348      -1.4%      $4.60      -1.5%     $640      -2.1%      $171     -30.1%         $509     -16.4%
        III   $364       4.7%      $5.02       9.1%     $693       8.3%      $193     12.8%          $497      -2.4%
        IV    $393       8.0%      $5.30       5.5%     $766      10.5%      $203      5.0%          $476      -4.2%

2004    I     $409       4.1%      $6.72     26.8%      $864      12.9%      $245     20.6%          $598     25.7%
        II    $394      -3.8%      $6.26     -6.8%      $830      -4.0%      $259       5.9%         $773     29.2%
        III   $403       2.3%      $6.51      4.0%      $837       0.8%      $218     -16.1%        $1,030    33.3%
        IV    $435       8.1%      $7.27     11.8%      $850       1.6%      $210      -3.5%        $1,210    17.5%

2005    I     $428      -1.6%      $7.00     -3.7%      $865       1.8%      $191     -9.0%         $1,448    19.7%
        II    $429       0.2%      $7.17      2.4%      $873       0.9%      $193      0.9%         $1,567     8.2%
        III   $441       2.8%      $7.10     -1.0%      $899       3.0%      $189     -1.8%         $2,058    31.3%
        IV    $487      10.5%      $8.11     14.2%      $962       6.9%      $243     28.6%         $2,795    35.8%

2006    I     $556      14.3%       $9.74    20.1%      $1,042     8.4%      $295     21.2%         $3,355    20.0%
        II    $630      13.2%      $12.26    25.9%      $1,189    14.0%      $350     18.6%         $4,655    38.7%
        III   $623      -1.2%      $11.72    -4.5%      $1,223     2.9%      $326     -6.7%         $4,531    -2.7%
        IV    $608      -2.3%      $12.68     8.2%      $1,130    -7.6%      $325     -0.5%         $4,896     8.1%

2007    I     $652       7.2%      $13.36     5.4%      $1,198     6.0%      $347      6.9%         $5,762    17.7%
        II    $671       2.8%      $13.37     0.1%      $1,298     8.4%      $372      7.1%         $5,990     4.0%
        III   $684       2.0%      $12.80    -4.3%      $1,301     0.2%      $352     -5.5%         $6,006     0.3%
        IV    $794      16.0%      $14.33    12.0%      $1,457    12.0%      $365      3.9%         $6,463     7.6%

2008    I     $928      17.0%      $11.79    -17.8%     $1,889     29.6%     $451     23.5%         $8,069     24.9%
        II    $898      -3.2%      $17.20     45.9%     $2,037      7.9%     $449      -0.5%        $9,275     14.9%
        III   $870      -3.2%      $14.97    -13.0%     $1,532    -24.8%     $328     -27.0%        $6,277    -32.3%
        IV    $795      -8.6%      $10.18    -32.0%      $871     -43.2%     $192     -41.4%        $1,424    -77.3%

2009    I      $910     14.5%      $12.64    24.1%      $1,030    18.3%      $201      4.4%         $1,060    -25.6%
        II     $924      1.5%      $13.75     8.9%      $1,179    14.4%      $236     17.6%         $1,283     21.0%
        III    $962      4.1%      $14.77     0.4%      $1,239     5.2%      $276     16.8%         $1,523     18.7%
        IV    $1,101    14.4%      $17.58    19.0%      $1,400    13.0%      $351     27.5%         $2,045     34.3%

2010    I     $1,110     0.9%      $16.92    -3.7%      $1,562    11.6%      $441     25.4%         $2,440     19.3%
        II    $1,197     7.9%      $18.36     8.5%      $1,634     4.6%      $496     12.5%         $2,592      6.2%
        III   $1,228     2.5%      $19.00     3.5%      $1,556    -4.8%      $496      0.1%         $2,204    -15.0%
        IV    $1,369    11.5%      $25.59    34.7%      $1,701     9.3%      $679     36.8%         $2,329      5.7%

2011    I     $1,386     1.2%      $31.74     24.0%     $1,797      5.6%     $793     16.8%         $2,436     4.6%
        II    $1,507     8.7%      $38.42     21.1%     $1,788     -0.5%     $761      -4.0%        $2,179    -10.6%
        III   $1,700    12.8%      $38.86      1.1%     $1,774     -0.7%     $755      -0.8%        $1,894    -13.1%
        IV    $1,686    -0.8%      $31.84    -18.0%     $1,534    -13.5%     $631     -16.3%        $1,588    -16.1%

2012p   I     $1,693     0.4%      $32.72      2.8%     $1,613     5.1%      $685      8.5%         $1,462     -8.0%
        II    $1,622    -4.2%      $29.47    -10.0%     $1,503    -6.9%      $629     -8.1%         $1,328     -9.2%
        III   $1,657     2.1%      $30.08      2.1%     $1,505     0.2%      $615     -2.3%         $1,168    -12.0%
        IV    $1,726     4.2%      $32.99      9.7%     $1,604     6.5%      $640      4.1%         $1,145     -2.0%
2013p   I     $1,718    -0.4%      $33.28      0.9%     $1,615     0.7%      $632     -1.3%         $1,120     -2.2%
        II    $1,667    -3.0%      $30.62     -8.0%     $1,567    -3.0%      $638      1.0%         $1,193      6.5%
        III   $1,608    -3.5%      $29.40     -4.0%     $1,527    -2.5%      $625     -2.0%         $1,300      9.0%
        IV    $1,641     2.0%      $30.28      3.0%     $1,634     7.0%      $678      8.5%         $1,404      8.0%
2014p   I     $1,673     2.0%      $31.49      4.0%     $1,693     3.6%      $722      6.4%         $1,460      4.0%
        II    $1,623    -3.0%      $31.17     -1.0%     $1,719     1.5%      $738      2.2%         $1,387     -5.0%
        III   $1,599    -1.5%      $29.30     -6.0%     $1,658    -3.5%      $710     -3.7%         $1,360     -2.0%
Precious Metals Advisory                      6 December 2012          Page 34


Precious Metals Equities
Financial Performance                                One Month    One Year
                                            Price                          52 Week Range        P/E Dividend Yield %
December 6, 2012                                     % Change    % Change

South African Gold Finance Houses             US$
AngloGold Ashanti                            30.29       -9.1%       -34.1%   380.20/251.99    11.43      0.22   0.5%
Gold Fields                                  11.47       -7.4%       -30.7%    139.13/95.51     9.41      0.21   1.4%
Harmony Gold Mining Co. Ltd.                  7.51       -4.7%       -45.5%    115.95/64.10    13.70      0.07   0.5%
Randgold & Exploration Co.                  102.77      -13.4%        -1.7%     78.92/44.80    22.35      0.20   0.2%

North American Gold Mining Companies          US$
Agnico-Eagle                                 53.06       -3.4%        22.0%     57.35/31.42     NM        0.64   1.0%
Barrick Gold                                 33.43       -6.0%       -34.7%     51.81/31.00     0.00      0.48   1.0%
Goldcorp                                     36.82      -16.5%       -29.3%     52.55/31.54    19.59      0.41   0.8%
Kinross Gold                                  9.63        2.9%       -30.4%      13.98/7.11     0.00      0.10   0.6%
Yamana Gold                                  17.73       -9.9%         8.7%     20.61/12.76    37.13      0.18   1.4%

International Multi-Metal Companies           US$
BHP                                          36.12       -0.5%        -3.8%     38.25/30.09    12.21      0.92   1.9%
Rio Tinto PLC                                52.02        2.2%        -0.4%     40.29/26.48    23.11      1.26   1.8%

Australian Gold Mining Companies              US$
Newcrest Mining Ltd.                         25.30       -7.1%       -27.2%     36.10/20.89    16.53      0.27   0.7%

Silver Mining Companies                       US$
Coeur d'Alene Mines Corp.                    22.06       -8.5%       -23.6%     31.97/15.15    91.84      0.00   0.0%
Compania de Minas Buenaventura S.A.          33.09       -5.3%       -12.9%     43.90/30.86    10.88      0.49   1.3%
Industrias Peñoles S.A. de C.V.              49.70       -0.6%         8.2%   694.50/504.05    29.27      1.58   4.2%
Pan American Silver Corp.                    18.08      -15.8%       -26.4%     26.78/13.79    11.13      0.10   0.3%
Silver Standard Resources Inc.               13.58       -7.0%        -5.2%     18.14/10.18    33.31      0.00   0.0%

Platinum Mining Companies                     US$
Adriana Resources                             0.38      -17.2%       -59.6%        1.38/0.38    NM        0.00   0.0%
Anglo American Platinum Corp.                47.70        3.5%       -30.3%   598.50/358.74     NM        1.01   1.1%
Aquarius Platinum (A$)                        0.68       -0.9%       -76.2%        2.88/0.48    NM        0.08   1.6%
Eurasia Mining plc. (£)                       0.01        0.6%       -26.3%        0.01/0.00    NM        0.00   0.0%
Jubilee Platinum (£)                          0.12       -7.2%       -43.2%        0.18/0.07    NM        0.00   0.0%
Impala Platinum                              17.51       -3.0%       -18.0%   180.83/123.47    22.06      0.62   2.3%
North American Palladium                      1.41       -7.5%       -56.2%        3.34/1.28    NM        0.00   0.0%
Pacific North West Capital (C$)               0.05       -8.7%       -57.4%        0.17/0.05    NM        0.00   0.0%
Stillwater Mining Company                    11.29        3.5%        -2.9%      15.24/7.47    22.47      0.00   0.0%
Trend Mining Company                          0.00        0.0%       -66.7%        0.01/0.00    NM        0.00   0.0%
Zimplats (A$)                                 8.61        1.3%       -24.8%      12.00/7.50     7.38      0.00   0.0%


Notes: NM-Not Meaningful. NE-No earnings; Source Capital IQ, Bloomberg.
Precious Metals Advisory                                                6 December 2012                         Page 35


Market Metrics

Metals Markets                                                                                Indices
                      November         O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year                                                       November          O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year
Gold                  $1,721.82       $1,746.08     $1,745.50     -1.4%                       Nasdaq                              3,010           2,977        2,620      14.9%
Silver                   $33.20          $32.32        $32.41      2.5%                       DJIA                              13,026          13,096       12,046        8.1%
Platinum              $1,604.60       $1,577.00     $1,560.80      2.8%                       S&P 510                             1,416           1,412        1,247      13.6%
Palladium               $686.25         $609.80       $610.00     12.5%                       FT World Stock                        383             379          345      10.9%
Rhodium               $1,125.00       $1,125.00     $1,625.00    -30.8%                       U.S. T -bills                      0.08%           0.11%        0.02%      400.0%
Iridium               $1,050.00       $1,050.00     $1,085.00     -3.2%                       U.S. 10 Yr Notes                   1.62%           1.69%        2.07%      -21.9%
Ruthenium                $90.00         $110.00       $120.00    -25.0%                       $-Euro Interest Rate              -0.12%          -0.09%       -1.46%      -92.0%
Osmium                  $350.00         $350.00       $350.00      0.0%                         Differential
                                                                                              CRB Commodity Index                  299.0           295.8              313.8           -4.7%
                                                                                              Economist Commodity*
Currencies                                                                                      Dollar Index                       187.2           187.5              178.2           5.1%
                      November          O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year                         Euro Index                         180.0           179.6              166.2           8.3%
$/Euro                     1.30             1.30        1.35       -3.7%                      FT Gold Mines Index                  2,919           3,211              3,898         -25.1%
Japanese Yen/$            82.48            79.77       77.60        2.8%                      XAU Gold & Silver Equity             170.2           188.3              208.3         -18.3%
$/British Pound            1.60             1.61        1.57       2.69%                      T remont Man. Futures
U.S. T W$                  N/A             98.96       99.52       -0.6%                        Account Index, Return              -0.1%          -2.3%              0.52%             N/A
                                                                                              Oil (Nymex CL)                      $88.91         $92.19            $100.36          -11.4%
                                                                                               *Base year was adjusted to 2005 from 2000



                           Real GDP                  Consumer Prices             Interest Rates          Money Supply            Monetary Reserves ($BN)               Industrial Prod.
                         2012     2011               2012            2011                  2012                  2012                     2012              2011                   2012
                           3Q       3Q           O ctober        O ctober                 Latest                Latest                  March             March                  Latest
United States            2.7%     1.3%               0.1%            0.0%                 0.10%                 13.1%                    $51.1             $54.2                   1.7%
Eurozone                -0.1%     0.1%               0.2%            0.4%                -0.02%                  6.0%                   $208.1            $210.7                  -2.3%
United Kingdom           1.0%     0.6%               0.5%            0.1%                 0.35%                  4.3%                    $58.7             $57.0                   0.0%
Japan                   -0.9%     2.3%               0.0%            0.1%                 0.00%                  3.2%                 $1,211.0          $1,058.1                  -1.5%

China                    7.7%     9.5%              -0.1%             0.1%                  6.00%                    6.1%             $3,305.0          $3,145.8                     10.0%
India                    5.3%     6.7%               9.6%             9.4%                  8.00%                    8.1%               $260.1            $282.0                     -0.4%




Notes: Gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and copper nearby active Comex or Nymex. Minor PGMs are Metals Week dealer prices; Interest rates are 3-month money market rates for the
U.S., Euro,U.K.,and Japan; Interest rates are one-year rates for China & India; $-Euro interest rate differential is the spread between rates available on the 90-day government notes of
each; Money supply is percent change from previous year; Money supply is M1, UK is M0; Monetary reserves excluding gold; NA - Not Available.

More Related Content

PDF
Silver Wheaton Corporate Presentation
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report 150212
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report for 210912
PDF
Aem march presentation_updated28march2011
PDF
CFB Silver Report — March 2010
PDF
Silver_Initiating_BCM CDM FVI SLW
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report for 161012
Silver Wheaton Corporate Presentation
Keynote commodity daily report 150212
Keynote commodity daily report for 210912
Aem march presentation_updated28march2011
CFB Silver Report — March 2010
Silver_Initiating_BCM CDM FVI SLW
Keynote commodity daily report for 161012

What's hot (18)

PDF
Start here-investing-in-silver
PPTX
May 10 I Session 1 I GBIH
PPT
Gold as an asset class
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report 150312
PDF
LCC copper gold report 20140317
PDF
Why gold is different from other assets
PDF
Pwc global-gold-price-survey-results-2014-11-en
PDF
The evolving structure_of_gold_demand_and_supply
PPTX
Outlook for precious metals prices
PDF
Glitering gold
DOCX
Gold Economy in India
PPTX
All about gold and gold pricing
PDF
Ural sib russia emerging opportunities & outlook conference
PDF
Gold report 2011
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report for 120213
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report 010212
PDF
Increase in gold prices has given a fresh opportunity to the investors
Start here-investing-in-silver
May 10 I Session 1 I GBIH
Gold as an asset class
Keynote commodity daily report 150312
LCC copper gold report 20140317
Why gold is different from other assets
Pwc global-gold-price-survey-results-2014-11-en
The evolving structure_of_gold_demand_and_supply
Outlook for precious metals prices
Glitering gold
Gold Economy in India
All about gold and gold pricing
Ural sib russia emerging opportunities & outlook conference
Gold report 2011
Keynote commodity daily report for 120213
Keynote commodity daily report 010212
Increase in gold prices has given a fresh opportunity to the investors

Viewers also liked (20)

PDF
Jupiterimages Catalog
PDF
CQ Associates v8
PPTX
ChefsChoice Newspaper Editorial Coverage
PPT
Topic 3_Particle physics lesson notes
PDF
Caloosa Tech Times - November 2009
PPTX
竺宇峰
PDF
Ihmtrend2012del1 kopia
PPT
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
PPT
Sentieri Digitali 2010 - La comunicazione nell'era delle realtà virtuali (by ...
PDF
Can Pharma Use Digital and Social Media Effectively?
ODP
PPT
Mondi virtuali, numeri e prospettive
PDF
User Experience at Darien Library
PPT
Karina
PPT
Earth Science Jeopardy
PPS
Savethedate3
PPT
1 konsep-dasar-akuntansi2
PPTX
Ccm Smim2l
Jupiterimages Catalog
CQ Associates v8
ChefsChoice Newspaper Editorial Coverage
Topic 3_Particle physics lesson notes
Caloosa Tech Times - November 2009
竺宇峰
Ihmtrend2012del1 kopia
Digital Trails Dave King 1 5 10 Part 1 D3
Sentieri Digitali 2010 - La comunicazione nell'era delle realtà virtuali (by ...
Can Pharma Use Digital and Social Media Effectively?
Mondi virtuali, numeri e prospettive
User Experience at Darien Library
Karina
Earth Science Jeopardy
Savethedate3
1 konsep-dasar-akuntansi2
Ccm Smim2l

Similar to Cpm precious metals advisory 2012 12-06 (20)

PDF
Buy Gold Coins-Become gold investor
PDF
The Silver Market in 2011
PDF
Linear Note 7 Precious Metals
DOC
The New Gold Seasonal Trends
PDF
Priceofsilver
PDF
Daily commodity-report
PDF
Daily commodity-report
PDF
DAILY COMMODITY REPORT BY EPIC RESEARCH- 17 DECEMBER 2012
PDF
Daily commodity-report by epic research 17 dec 2012
PDF
DAILY COMMODITY REPORT BY EPIC RESEARCH- 17 DECEMBER 2012
PPTX
Can you pass the 2011 gold quiz
PPTX
April 9 | Session 1 | GBIH
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report 190911
PDF
Objective Capital Precious Metals, Diamonds and Gemstones Investment Summit: ...
PDF
Commodity Research Report 26 December 2016 Ways2Capital
PDF
Great panthersilverjan2013presentation
PDF
Spring 2014 - 4 Catalysts for a Bull Run in Precious Metals
PDF
Why Silver Is The Best Investment Over The Next Decade
PDF
Commodity Research Report 09 January 2017 Ways2Capital
PDF
Keynote commodity daily report for 070113
Buy Gold Coins-Become gold investor
The Silver Market in 2011
Linear Note 7 Precious Metals
The New Gold Seasonal Trends
Priceofsilver
Daily commodity-report
Daily commodity-report
DAILY COMMODITY REPORT BY EPIC RESEARCH- 17 DECEMBER 2012
Daily commodity-report by epic research 17 dec 2012
DAILY COMMODITY REPORT BY EPIC RESEARCH- 17 DECEMBER 2012
Can you pass the 2011 gold quiz
April 9 | Session 1 | GBIH
Keynote commodity daily report 190911
Objective Capital Precious Metals, Diamonds and Gemstones Investment Summit: ...
Commodity Research Report 26 December 2016 Ways2Capital
Great panthersilverjan2013presentation
Spring 2014 - 4 Catalysts for a Bull Run in Precious Metals
Why Silver Is The Best Investment Over The Next Decade
Commodity Research Report 09 January 2017 Ways2Capital
Keynote commodity daily report for 070113

More from Hochleitner Marine (17)

PDF
World gold council gold-investor report- 1st q 2013
PPTX
One 2 One Rollover
PDF
Breaking banks up is hard to do - Not hard to fail
PDF
Inflationary deflation creating a new bubble in money
PDF
Epmf brochure
PDF
Eu vat free coin list
PDF
Accredited gold bar manufacturers
PDF
Fit 7 mistakes_gold_traders_make
PDF
The evolving structure_of_gold_demand_and_supply
PDF
Why gold is different from other assets
PDF
Gold bullion coins guide
PDF
Scotia report oct 12
PDF
Gold wars - A golden renaissance presentation
PDF
Gold as a strategic asset
PDF
The strategic case for gold
PDF
Wgc gold as_strategic_asset_european_investors-1
PPTX
AMP Gold Ownership Certificate
World gold council gold-investor report- 1st q 2013
One 2 One Rollover
Breaking banks up is hard to do - Not hard to fail
Inflationary deflation creating a new bubble in money
Epmf brochure
Eu vat free coin list
Accredited gold bar manufacturers
Fit 7 mistakes_gold_traders_make
The evolving structure_of_gold_demand_and_supply
Why gold is different from other assets
Gold bullion coins guide
Scotia report oct 12
Gold wars - A golden renaissance presentation
Gold as a strategic asset
The strategic case for gold
Wgc gold as_strategic_asset_european_investors-1
AMP Gold Ownership Certificate

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
Leveraging the power of data for sustainable development
DOCX
Internship company LUSA Trading and Services Joint Stock Company
PPTX
ECN 3235 GROUP 28 PRESENTATION PLANNING.pptx
PPTX
GOKULAM GOPALAN INDUSTRIES (Alen Saji).pptx
PDF
Altcoin momentum and ETF-driven ETH flows clash with a cooling Bitcoin; Wall ...
PPTX
IREE - Harnessing Artificial Intelligence The Future of Accounting and Financ...
PDF
Histpry of Economic thoughts _I_Chapter3.pdf
PPTX
Market Structures_-Perfect Competition, Monopoly, Monopolistic Competition 7 ...
PPTX
481696537-Pediatric-pharmacokinetic.pptx
PDF
Micro 8 - Cost Function of Microeconomics
PPTX
Polio disease ujsn3 iksnuss. Isnnej.pptx
PDF
The Complete Guide to Corporate Tax in the UAE
PPTX
NON - FARM - AREAS - OF - EMPLOYMENT.pptx
PPTX
FIN657 ISSUES ETHICS HYPERINFLATION IN VENEZUELA CRISIS
DOCX
INCREASING THE BRAND AWARENESS OF SULWHASOO COSMETICS IN THE VIETNAMESE MARKET
PPTX
Introduction-of-Macroeconomics.pptx.....
PDF
Entrep Part I entrepreneurship and business
PPTX
Policy Incentives for Small scale industries
PDF
LCP-Inheritance-tax-on-pensions-2025.pdf
PDF
Cost and GHG emission reduction strategies for Aquaculture by B.pdf
Leveraging the power of data for sustainable development
Internship company LUSA Trading and Services Joint Stock Company
ECN 3235 GROUP 28 PRESENTATION PLANNING.pptx
GOKULAM GOPALAN INDUSTRIES (Alen Saji).pptx
Altcoin momentum and ETF-driven ETH flows clash with a cooling Bitcoin; Wall ...
IREE - Harnessing Artificial Intelligence The Future of Accounting and Financ...
Histpry of Economic thoughts _I_Chapter3.pdf
Market Structures_-Perfect Competition, Monopoly, Monopolistic Competition 7 ...
481696537-Pediatric-pharmacokinetic.pptx
Micro 8 - Cost Function of Microeconomics
Polio disease ujsn3 iksnuss. Isnnej.pptx
The Complete Guide to Corporate Tax in the UAE
NON - FARM - AREAS - OF - EMPLOYMENT.pptx
FIN657 ISSUES ETHICS HYPERINFLATION IN VENEZUELA CRISIS
INCREASING THE BRAND AWARENESS OF SULWHASOO COSMETICS IN THE VIETNAMESE MARKET
Introduction-of-Macroeconomics.pptx.....
Entrep Part I entrepreneurship and business
Policy Incentives for Small scale industries
LCP-Inheritance-tax-on-pensions-2025.pdf
Cost and GHG emission reduction strategies for Aquaculture by B.pdf

Cpm precious metals advisory 2012 12-06

  • 1. Precious Metals Advisory Vol. XXV, No. 12 6 December 2012 Precious Metals Prices May Lack Direction in 2013 Next Scheduled Issue: 10 January 2012 Market Data (Data as of 6 December; changes from 8 November) There is a tremendous amount of uncertainty in the mar- ket regarding the economy and the future for precious Nymex/Comex Nearby Active Prices %∆ $∆ metals prices. As a result precious metals investors may Gold 1,701.80 ↓ -1.4% -24.20 wait on the sidelines in December. Many price-moving Silver 33.11 ↑ 2.7% 0.87 factors appear already priced into the market, such as de- Platinum 1,600.70 ↑ 3.8% 58.20 mand expectations for the PGMs and silver, a continua- Palladium 697.05 ↑ 13.5% 82.70 tion of the recession in Western Europe, China’s reduced Rhodium* 1,100.00 ↓ -4.3% -50.00 economic growth trajectory, and sovereign debt handling *Rhodium price is BASF daily settlement price. in Europe. The approaching U.S. fiscal cliff may have Nymex/Comex Inventories oz ∆ oz contributed to precious metals price increases in Novem- Gold ber and may continue to influence prices through the end Eligible 8,800,826 ↑ 119,225 8,681,601 of the year. Registered 2,602,693 ↑ 15,114 2,587,579 T otal 11,403,519 ↑ 134,339 11,269,180 Silver Precious metals prices typically move higher in the first Eligible 105,456,690 ↓ -1,141,470 106,598,160 few months of the year due to seasonal factors. Overall, Registered 39,836,930 ↑ 3,428,100 36,408,830 however, prices are expected to average modestly lower T otal 145,293,620 ↑ 2,286,630 143,006,990 in 2013 relative to 2012 levels. Investment demand vol- Platinum - T otal 207,850 ↑ 9,350 198,500 umes for gold and silver are expected to come off further Palladium - T otal 531,100 ↓ -2,000 533,100 next year, which will be the primary driver behind lower Open Interest1 oz ∆ oz gold and silver prices. Investors are expected to continue Gold to welcome opportunities to buy at price dips. That ten- February 27,853,400 ↑ 21,074,800 6,778,600 T otal 42,851,800 ↓ -2,187,500 45,039,300 dency to view dips in prices as buying opportunities Silver could dissipate as the year progresses if sell-offs are not March 426,995,000 ↑ 318,450,000 108,545,000 followed by significant rallies, as investors would begin T otal 704,615,000 ↑ 15,535,000 689,080,000 Platinum to re-evaluate their longer term bullish sentiments in light January 2,724,400 ↓ -79,200 2,803,600 of weaker prices. The platinum group metals may trade April 344,950 ↑ 154,100 190,850 3,091,700 3,005,250 modestly higher on an annual average basis, with weak T otal ↑ 86,450 Palladium fabrication demand limiting the upside and constrained March 2,362,200 ↑ 2,074,900 287,300 supply keeping prices well supported. T otal 2,377,100 ↑ 200,700 2,176,400 The primary concern at present in the precious metals 1 Data as of 5 December; changes from 7 November. markets is when to expect demand growth to strengthen. In 2010 and 2011, assessing demand was fairly easy – Indicators %∆ $∆ these were recovery years so demand was rising rapidly DJIA 13,074.0 ↑ 2.1% 263 for cars and electronics containing PGMs and silver and FT World Stock Index 383.6 ↑ 3.0% 11.07 for gold jewelry in the booming Chinese and Indian mar- FT Gold Mines Index 2,777.8 ↓ -11.2% -351.79 kets. In 2012, demand expectations for all the precious CRB Index 297.9 ↑ 2.1% 6.07 metals came off. India’s economy slowed and its govern- T -Bills 0.09% ↑ 5.6% 0.01% ment raised import taxes on gold in order to reduce its ICE Dollar Index 80.24 ↓ -0.7% -0.55 current account deficit, which weighed on gold jewelry $ / Euro 1.30 ↑ 1.8% $0.023 sales. Europe’s auto market contracted, weighing on ex- pectations for PGM demand growth. China’s economic Report Contents Prices in 2013…...…......……….....p.1 Palladium..….………......……...p.27 growth slowed, adding further pressure to demand expec- Price Targets...………....…………p.3 Rhodium.…….….......……….…p.32 tations. The demand picture in 2012 is expected to spill Macroeconomic Indicators………p.5 Precious Metals Price Table......p.33 into 2013, will no material changes to prospects for Gold……...……….……...….…….p.8 Equities and Metrics Table..p.34-35 growth. Silver………………...…………..p.16 Platinum………………………...p.22 Copyright CPM Group 2012. Not for reproduction or retransmission without written consent of CPM Group. Precious Metals Advisory is published monthly by CPM Group and is distributed via e-mail. The views expressed within are solely those of CPM Group. Such information has not been verified, nor does CPM make any representation as to its accuracy or completeness. Any statements non-factual in nature constitute only current opinions, which are subject to change. While every effort has been made to ensure that the accuracy of the material contained in the reports is correct, CPM Group cannot be held liable for errors or omissions. CPM Group is not soliciting any action based on it. Information contained here should not be relied on as specific investment or market timing advice. At times the principals and associates of CPM Group may have long or short positions in some of the markets mentioned here.
  • 2. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 2 Precious Metals Prices May Lack Direction in 2013 (cont.) The lack of demand upside in 2013, especially through the first three quarters, is expected to weigh on precious metals prices. If the European and U.S. economies begin to pick up later in the year, industrial demand for pre- cious metals could help to improve price appreciation prospects. Commodities Research and Consulting, Asset Management, and Investment Banking CPM Group, founded in 1986, is an authoritative commodities research and consulting company. It is independent of all producers, processors, financial institutions, and other companies having commercial positions in commodities. CPM Group has extensive experience in commodities research, trading, and finance, equipping the company to provide finan- cial advice and consulting grounded in hands-on experience. email: [email protected] Telephone 212-785-8320 www.cpmgroup.com
  • 3. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 3 Price Targets Key Top of Range 1-Month Nearby active Comex/Nymex prices. Rhodium prices Projection Forecast Average are daily BASF prices. All prices are US$/ounce. Average 2nd & 3rd Month Bottom of Range Projections GOLD Near Term Outlook — Gold prices could poten- tially move in a wide range between $1,620 and 1,850 $1,780 during December. If prices settle below 1,780 1,800 1,800 $1,680, prices could decline toward $1,650 or even $1,620. A decline in prices or consolidation 1,750 at present low levels could induce bargain buying 1,710 1,715 by various market participants including investors, 1,700 1,721 central banks, and fabricators. Prices could show 1,650 some seasonal strength in the first few months of the year . Fiscal tightening in the United States is 1,600 expected to reduce economic growth during the 1,620 first few months reducing concerns about infla- 1,550 1,550 tion, which could weigh on gold prices. In such an 1,500 environment gold prices could slip toward $1,550. J-12 J-12 A-12 S-12 O-12 N-12 D-12 J-13 F-13 SILVER Near Term Outlook — Prices are expected to move sideways to lower this month, as the level of 38 uncertainty regarding the approaching U.S. fiscal cliff pushes and pulls at prices. Prices could head 36 35.50 35 higher in January and February of 2013 due to 34 32.79 33.45 index and portfolio rebalancing activity as well as 33 the approach of the Comex March futures delivery 32 period at the end of February. Seasonal demand for silver is typically stronger in the first few 31 30 months of the year. Prices may stay above $30 30 over the next three months. There is a lot of sup- 28 port at $30, but a move toward this level could trigger a spike lower, possibly toward $26. Indus- 26 trial demand remains weak, which will weigh on J-12 J-12 A-12 S-12 O-12 N-12 D-12 J-13 F-13 silver, but investors continue to buy on price dips. Near Term Outlook — Prices may trend higher PLATINUM over the next three months. Concerns about supply 1,800 remain high, but strike activity in South Africa’s 1,750 platinum mining sector has abated significantly in 1,700 recent months, which may weigh on prices. Anglo 1,700 1,650 Platinum restarted operations at its mines where 1,650 1,635 illegal strikes were taking place. The company has 1,579 1,600 1,595 lost about 200,000 ounces of potential platinum 1,550 output since the illegal strikes began in Septem- 1,560 1,540 ber. Fresh concerns about power supply in the 1,500 country as well as the potential for new strikes are 1,450 expected to keep prices above $1,540 in the near 1,400 term in even the worse price scenario. The first 1,350 few months of the year are typically a seasonally strong period for platinum prices, which may keep 1,300 J-12 J-12 A-12 S-12 O-12 N-12 D-12 J-13 F-13 platinum above $1,560 (?) and could help push prices toward $1,700 in January and February. Continued
  • 4. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 4 Price Targets Key Top of Range 1-Month Nearby active Comex/Nymex prices. Rhodium prices Projection Forecast Average are daily BASF prices. All prices are US$/ounce. Average 2nd & 3rd Month Bottom of Range Projections PALLADIUM Near Term Outlook — Palladium prices could 800 potentially decline as a result of profit taking and 750 the possibility of weaker real demand for the 750 metal in the near to medium term. Prices have 725 risen sharply in recent weeks, which could result 700 in investors booking profits in their positions, es- 650 pecially toward the end of December. There also 638 650 is the possibility that fabrication demand for the 642 600 610 metal will soften during the first half of 2013 due 580 to fiscal tightening in the United States. This 550 could potentially push prices toward $580. Prices should find support on the downside because of 500 the constant possibility of supply disruptions from South Africa. 450 J-12 J-12 A-12 S-12 O-12 N-12 D-12 J-13 F-13 RHODIUM Near Term Outlook — Rhodium prices are ex- 1,400 pected to remain weak over the next three months. 1,350 Rhodium prices are expected to average lower in 1,300 December, at $1,105, from November, when 1,250 prices averaged $1,142, as some of the supply 1,200 constraints supporting prices have eased. Prices 1,200 1,142 1,150 could decline toward $1,000 over the next few 1,150 1,130 months. Some seasonal price strength could help 1,105 1,100 buoy prices in January and February. Demand 1,050 prospects remain bleak, however, which has been 1,050 1,000 weighing heavily on rhodium prices since 2011 1,000 950 and may continue to do so. There is scope for fur- ther declines in rhodium prices, but investors may 900 J-12 J-12 A-12 S-12 O-12 N-12 D-12 J-13 F-13 M-13 view prices below $1,000 or even $1,100 as a tre- mendous buying opportunity.
  • 5. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 5 Macroeconomic Indicators Real Gross Domestic Product Unemployment Rates in Developed Economies Quarterly Data, Quarter-over-Quarter Percentage Change Monthly Data, through October 2012 Percent Percent 15 12% Euro zone United States 11% United Kingdom Japan 10 10% 9% 5 8% 7% 0 6% 5% USA China -5 4% Japan Brazil 3% India EU -10 2% Jun-96 Nov-98 Apr-01 Sep-03 Feb-06 Jul-08 Dec-10 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 Note: China and India is Quarterly data, with percentage change on a year-over-year basis. Note: U.K. data is through September 2012. Industrial Production in Developed Economies Industrial Production in Developing Economies Monthly through October 2012, Year-over-Year Percentage Change Monthly through August 2012, Year-over-Year Percentage Change 40% 30% Euro zone 30% United States United Kingdom 20% 20% Japan 10% 10% 0% -10% 0% -20% -10% -30% Brazil China India -40% -20% 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 Note: Euro Zone data is through September 2012. Note: Chinese. data is through July 2012. Inflation - Developed Countries Inflation -Developing Countries Monthly CPI, Year-over-Year Percentage Change, through October 2012 Monthly CPI, Year-over-Year Percentage Change, through October 2012 20% 8% Euro zone United Kingdom 18% Japan United States 16% 6% Brazil India 14% China 12% 4% 10% 2% 8% 6% 0% 4% 2% -2% 0% -2% -4% -4% 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12
  • 6. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 6 Macroeconomic Indicators (cont) 10-Year Treasury minus Three-Month Treasury 10-Year Nominal Treasury Yield minus 10-Year TIPS Yield Daily Data, through 4 December 2012 Daily Data, through 4 December 2012 Percent Percent 3.0 6.0 5.0 2.5 4.0 2.0 3.0 2.0 1.5 1.0 1.0 0.0 -1.0 0.5 -2.0 J-82 J-85 J-88 J-91 J-94 J-97 J-00 J-03 J-06 J-09 J-12 0.0 Jan-03 Jan-05 Jan-07 Jan-09 Jan-11 Corporate Baa-rate bond minus Ten-year Treasury CBOE Volatility Index: VIX Daily Data, through 4 December 2012 Daily Data, through 5 December 2012 Percent Percent 7.0 90 80 6.0 70 5.0 60 4.0 50 3.0 40 30 2.0 20 1.0 10 0.0 0 Jan-86 Jan-90 Jan-94 Jan-98 Jan-02 Jan-06 Jan-10 Jan-04 Apr-05 Jul-06 Oct-07 Jan-09 Apr-10 Jul-11 Oct-12 MZM Money Supply and U.S. Inflation Trade-Weighted Dollar and Gold Prices Monthly Data, through September 2012 Monthly Data, through November 2012 Percent Percent Index $/Oz 40 11 Trade-Weighted Dollar (LHS) Gold Prices 150 2,000 Correlation: negative 0.11 35 10 1,800 MZM Money Supply (LHS) 140 30 8 1,600 U.S. Inflation (CPI) 130 25 7 1,400 120 20 6 1,200 110 15 4 1,000 10 3 100 800 5 1 90 600 0 0 80 400 -5 -1 70 200 -10 -3 60 - Nov-81 May-86 Nov-90 May-95 Nov-99 May-04 Nov-08 Jan-73 Oct-78 Jul-84 Apr-90 Jan-96 Oct-01 Jul-07
  • 7. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 7 U.S. Macroeconomic Indicators Real Personal Income Total U.S. Consumer Debt Monthly Data, through October 2012 Quarterly End of Period Data, through 1 July 2012 Percent Trillion of Dollars 10.0 16.0 8.0 14.0 6.0 12.0 4.0 10.0 2.0 0.0 8.0 -2.0 6.0 -4.0 4.0 -6.0 2.0 -8.0 0.0 J-60 J-66 J-72 J-78 J-84 J-90 J-96 J-02 J-08 O-49 F-57 J-64 O-71 F-79 J-86 O-93 F-01 J-08 Manufacturers' New Orders: Durable Goods New Orders: Nondefense Capital Goods Excluding Aircrafts Monthly Data, through October 2012 Monthly Data, through October 2012 Billion of Dollars Billion of Dollars 260 75 240 70 220 65 60 200 55 180 50 160 45 140 40 120 35 100 30 F-92 J-94 O-96 F-99 J-01 O-03 F-06 J-08 O-10 F-92 J-94 O-96 F-99 J-01 O-03 F-06 J-08 O-10 Total Construction Spending Housing Starts Monthly Data, through October 2012 Monthly Data, through October 2012 Thousands of Units Billions of Dollars 3000 1400.0 2500 1200.0 1000.0 2000 800.0 1500 600.0 1000 400.0 500 200.0 0.0 0 J-93 J-95 J-97 J-99 J-01 J-03 J-05 J-07 J-09 J-11 J-59 J-64 J-69 J-74 J-79 J-84 J-89 J-94 J-99 J-04 J-09
  • 8. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 8 Gold Outlook Gold prices may be expected to move between $1,620 As this is being written gold prices have fallen to levels and $1,780 in December. There have been a couple of just above support at $1,680. If prices decisively break sharp declines in gold prices in the past two weeks, re- below this level they could slip toward $1,660. Or, they flecting investor profit taking and nervousness on the part could cascade sharply lower, to $1,650 or even $1,620. If of long investors. It may be that investor attitudes toward prices hold above $1,680 the sense that a low has been the state of the world and the outlook for gold are con- made at least on a temporary basis could lead to increased tinuing to shift, away from fear of major problems toward demand from fabricators, central banks, and investors, all a view that economic and political problems remain unre- of whom have become extremely sensitive to the price of solved but are less likely to trigger a major collapse than gold. investors had expected earlier India is presently in the midst of its marriage season and Gold settled at $1,716.50 on 28 November, down $25.80 any weakness in prices should be supportive of fabrica- from the previous day and prices had declined to tion demand there. The Indian rupee has also been $1,695.80 on 4 December, down $25.30 from the prior strengthening lately, reducing the cost of imports, which trading session. Part of the selling on 28 November was could further boost fabrication demand for the metal from investors who had bought December Comex calls earlier India. at lower prices, who had exercised these calls at the close of trading the day before, on options expiration day. These investors then sold the futures contracts at the Gold Prices: 1 January 2009 to 5 December 2012 opening of trading the next day. Additional selling is be- $ / Oz lieved to have been prompted by stop loss selling by 2,000 nervous longs. The sharpness of these declines is likely to 1,900 have made other remaining investors nervous, and kept 1,800 fresh investors on the sidelines, which could drive prices lower. That said, some physically backed exchange 1,700 traded products (ETPs) saw an increase in their holdings 1,600 on both of those days, with ETP holdings reaching a re- 1,500 cord high 86.5 million ounces on 4 December. Even 1,400 though holdings are at record levels, the net additions to 1,300 holdings have not been particularly large. The strength in 1,200 incremental demand is more important in pushing prices 1,100 higher. 1,000 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 Jul-12 Gold Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014 $ / Ounce Quarterly $1,900 $1,900 Year Quarter Change Annual AVG Change $1,800 $1,800 AVG $1,700 $1,700 2012 IV $1,726 4.2% $1,675 6.7% $1,600 $1,600 $1,500 $1,500 2013 I $1,718 -0.4% $1,400 Actual $1,400 $1,300 $1,300 II $1,667 -3.0% Projections $1,200 $1,200 III $1,608 -3.5% $1,100 $1,100 $1,000 $1,000 IV $1,641 2.0% $1,659 -1.0% $900 $900 2014 I $1,673 2.0% $800 $800 $700 $700 II $1,623 -3.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 III $1,599 -1.5%
  • 9. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 9 Demand from central banks also might be expected to In a scenario where the fiscal cliff is averted, market sen- rise if gold prices soften. During the first 10 months of timent should improve driving gold prices, along with 2012, central banks had added 10.76 million ounces of other markets, higher at the beginning of 2013. Any com- gold to their reported holdings, on a net basis. Some of promise reached on the fiscal deficit issue, which would the strongest net additions by central banks were seen in be positive for market sentiment, would still hurt eco- months when prices softened or were at relatively low nomic growth, only less than if all of the fiscal tightening levels. Central banks added on a net basis 2.95 million were to occur. As a result of this the present loose mone- ounces of gold to their holdings in July, when the price of tary policy is expected to remain in place, to offset eco- gold was at the lower end of its trading range for the year. nomic weakness arising from any fiscal tightening. This This was the highest monthly net additions made by cen- might provide slight support to gold prices, but probably tral banks during 2012. Central banks were also seen add- would not drive prices significantly higher from current ing 2.3 million ounces of metal to holdings when prices levels. slipped lower in March 2012. In the less likely scenario, where no deal is reached on For a variety of reasons investors remain interested in how to address the U.S. fiscal situation gold prices should owning gold and should be expected to step in as buyers be expected to decline alongside other assets as investors when prices soften. There is a lot of uncertainty sur- move into cash. In such a scenario monetary accommoda- rounding the handling of the current U.S. fiscal deficit tion is likely to be increased significantly to support eco- situation, which if not addressed would trigger automatic nomic growth, which could be supportive of gold prices. federal spending cuts and tax increases in January 2013 (the fiscal cliff). We expect that the U.S. government will Prices patch together a relatively superficial agreement at the 11th hour, with most of the proposed tax increases and Volatility in gold prices rose during November, with budget cuts in the years beyond 2014. However, there are prices both rising and declining sharply on various likely to be some increases in taxes and reductions in occasions during the month. Monthly average price government spending, so the question is how much weak- volatility was 20.8%, which was the highest level of ness should be expected in the first half of 2013, regard- monthly price volatility since July of this year. Price less of the outcome of the political discussions. More im- volatility should be expected to continue rising dur- portant for the matters at hand, the gold market, along ing December, as markets focus on the fiscal cliff with broader financial markets and economic conditions issue in the United States. November began with gold around the world, will be held hostage to a bathetic politi- prices declining sharply. Prices settled at $1,675.20 cal melodrama over the remainder of December. on 2 November, down from a settlement price of $1,715.50 the previous day. Prices recovered from Gold Price Volatility and Gold Fabrication Demand Gold Price Volatility Annual Total Fabrication Demand Monthly, Through November 2012 Million Ounces Million Ounces 120 120 90% 110 110 80% 100 Other 100 70% 90 90 80 80 60% Electronics 70 Jewelry, Developed 70 50% 60 60 40% Dental 50 50 30% 40 40 30 30 20% 20 Jewelry, Developing Countries 20 10% 10 10 0% 0 0 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11 77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11e
  • 10. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 10 this sharp decline over the next two trading session, increase demand for gold from India. The strength in reaching an intraday high of $1,720.9 on 6 November the Indian rupee helps to reduce the cost of importing and settling at $1,715 that day. Prices began to soften gold. These factors could collectively result in some toward the end of the month, with the sharpest de- strength in gold fabrication demand from India. cline seen on 28 November, when prices settled at $1,716.50 (around where they were at the beginning Official Transactions of the month), down $25.80 from the previous day. The weakness in prices continued into the first few Central banks added on a net basis, 1.61 million days of December. ounces of gold to their holdings in October. Gross additions to holdings during the month were 1.75 million ounces, and gross reductions were 141,000 Fabrication Demand ounces. India is presently in the middle of its marriage sea- The central bank of Turkey added 564,000 ounces of son, traditionally a strong gold buying season. The gold to its holdings in October, making it the largest recent weakness in the price of gold coupled with central bank buyer of gold during the month. The some strength in the Indian rupee is likely to help Turkish central bank’s holdings reached 10.28 mil- Official Transactions and Supply Official Sector Gold Reserve Levels Total World Mine Production Million Ounces Million Ounces Million Ounces Million Ounces 1,160 1,160 90 90 Indonesia 1,140 1,140 85 85 80 Canada 80 1,120 1,120 75 75 70 Peru 70 1,100 1,100 65 Australia 65 60 60 1,080 1,080 55 United States 55 1,060 1,060 50 50 45 45 1,040 1,040 40 40 35 35 1,020 1,020 30 30 25 South Africa 25 Other Market Economies 1,000 1,000 20 20 980 980 15 15 10 Russia China 10 960 960 5 Transitional Economies 5 0 0 940 940 73 75 77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 0911e 80 82 84 86 88 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12p Official Sector Changes In Gold Holdings Official Sector Changes In Gold Holdings in 2009 - October 2012 2012 Through October Excludes China, India and IMF Transactions, Million Ounces Million Ounces Million Ounces Million Ounces 30 30 7.0 7.0 25 25 Net Additions/Reductions Gross Additions 20 20 6.0 6.0 Gross Reductions 15 15 5.0 5.0 Gross Additions 10 10 Net Additions/Reductions 4.0 4.0 5 5 0 0 3.0 3.0 -5 -5 2.0 2.0 -10 -10 1.0 1.0 -15 -15 0.0 0.0 -20 -20 Gross Reductions -1.0 -1.0 -25 -25 -30 -30 -2.0 -2.0 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 Jan-09 Aug-09 Mar-10 Oct-10 May-11 Dec-11 Jul-12
  • 11. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 11 lion ounces, a record high, in October. The central during the first 10 months with gross reduction of bank of Brazil added 552,000 ounces of gold to its 290,000 ounces. holdings in October, taking total holdings of gold to 1.69 million ounces. This was the second consecutive Supply month that the central bank added gold, after making no additions to holdings between October 2001 and The global production-weighted cash cost for gold August 2012. The central bank of Kazakhstan re- mining continued to rise during the third quarter of sumed purchasing gold after being a seller of the 2012 reaching $733/ounce, up from $730/ounce in metal in September. The central bank purchased the second quarter of 2012 and $662/ounce in the 242,000 ounces of gold in October, raising its hold- third quarter of 2011. On average the global gold ings to a record high 3.6 million ounces. mining industry is still enjoying a healthy margin between cash costs and gold prices. The average The Bank of International Settlements’ gold holdings price of gold during the third quarter of 2012 was rose by 371,429 ounces in October. Other central $1,654.37. The price of gold has not been rising in banks that added gold to their holdings included the the same fashion as it was in the past few years. This central bank of Russia (13,000 ounces), Mongolia coupled with continuing increases in cash costs is (1,000 ounces), Greece (1,000 ounces), and Belarus squeezing producer margins. During the third quarter (2,000 ounces). of 2011 the average price of gold was $1,700 and The central banks of Germany reduced its holdings cash costs were $662/ounce, giving producers an av- by 135,000 ounces in October to 109.03 million erage margin of $1,038/ounce in that quarter. ounces. This was the second time that Germany re- duced its holdings this year, with the first reduction made in June. The central bank of Mexico reduced its Investment Demand holdings for the sixth consecutive month in October, taking its total holdings of gold to 4.01 million Gold exchange traded product holdings continued to ounces. This level of gold holdings is still 600,000 rise in November. Total holdings reached 86.3 mil- ounces higher than levels at the end of 2011. lion ounces at the end of the month, up 932,050 Reported net additions to central bank gold holdings ounces from 85.4 million ounces at the end of Octo- during the first 10 months of the year were 10.76 mil- ber. Holdings continued to rise during the first few lion ounces, driven entirely by an increase in gross days of December, reaching a record high 86.5 mil- purchases made by central banks. Gross additions to lion ounces on 4 December. Even though holdings central bank gold holdings were 11.06 million ounces are at record levels, the net additions to holdings have Investment Demand Month-end Change in ETF Gold Holdings and % Change in Gold Price Exchange Traded Funds' Physical Gold Holdings Through November 2012 Million Ounces Million Ounces % Change 100 100 Million Ounces Japan HDFC 40% 8 Religare SBI 90 Quantum Reliance 90 Change in ETF Gold Holdings Kotak UTI Gold Price %Change M-t-M 80 AUUSA CSGLDE 80 30% 6 CSGLDC CSGOLD 70 SGLD SGLN 70 20% 4 AGOL GLTR 60 CGL GBEES 60 Sprott German 50 Turkey SGBS 50 10% 2 GOLD NYSE 40 JB ETF 40 0% 0 ZKB IAU 30 GLD GLD 30 GBS GOLD -10% -2 20 CGT CEF 20 10 10 -20% -4 Jan-07 May-08 Sep-09 Jan-11 May-12 - 0 20032004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Note: Data as of 30 November 2012
  • 12. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 12 not been very strong. The strength in this incremental end of November, total open interest was 44.3 mil- demand is more important to price increases. lion ounces and was down to 43.4 million ounces by Investors in exchange traded funds were seen adding 4 December. to their holdings when the price of gold was declin- Open interest in the December Comex contract de- ing or was relatively depressed. This shows that in- clined over the course of November as market par- vestors remain interested in the metal but are also ticipants either rolled forward or closed out their po- price sensitive and are reluctant to purchase the metal sitions. Open interest in this contract slipped from when prices rise. 29.7 million ounces at the beginning of November to 462,300 ounces at the end of the month. Open inter- Markets and Inventories est in the nearby active February Comex contract was at 28.6 million ounces on 4 December, down from Total open interest in the Comex gold futures con- 29.3 million ounces at the end of November. tract rose to 49.3 million ounces on 23 November, Gold delivered via the December Comex contract from 45.7 million ounces at the end of October. Total totaled 240,100 ounces as of 5 December. Comex open interest softened over the remainder of Novem- registered inventories rose by 67,830 ounces on 5 ber and into the first few days of December. At the December from 2.53 million ounces at the end of November. Total eligible stocks meanwhile declined Markets and Inventories Gross Long and Short Positions of Comex Disaggragated Non-Commercial Positions Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions Comex Gold Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012 Comex Gold Futures & Options.Weekly Data,through 27November 2012 Million Ounces Million Ounces 35 35 Million Ounces Million Ounces Money Managers Long 35 35 30 Other Traders 30 Net Position 30 30 25 25 Long 25 25 20 20 20 20 Net Fund Position in Comex 15 15 15 15 10 10 10 10 5 5 5 5 0 0 0 0 -5 -5 -5 Short -5 Short -10 -10 -10 -10 A-95 D-96 J-98 M-00O-01 J-03 J-05 S-06 A-08 D-09 A-11 Jun-06 Apr-07 Mar-08 Jan-09 Nov-09 Oct-10 Aug-11 Jun-12 Comex Gold Inventories & Total Open Interest O Gold Price and Total Open Interest M Daily, Through 5 December 2012 Daily, Through 5 December 2012 Million Ounces Million Ounces $/Ounce Million Ounces 13 70 2,000 70 12 Total Open Interest (Right Scale) 1,800 65 11 60 10 1,600 60 9 50 55 1,400 Total Open Interest 8 50 40 1,200 7 45 6 1,000 Eligible Stocks 30 Gold 40 5 800 4 20 35 3 600 30 2 10 400 Registered Stocks 25 1 0 0 200 20 J-06 A-06 A-07 D-07 J-08 M-09O-09M-10 J-11 A-11M-12N-12 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
  • 13. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 13 by 54,713 ounces to 8.8 million ounces over the same ber, reducing the increase in net long positions, to period of time, which resulted in total Comex inven- 3.04 million ounces on 27 November from 2.7 mil- tories rising to 11.4 million ounces on 4 December, lion ounces on 30 October. up 13,117 ounces from the end of November. Net long positions held by large non-commercial Clearing activity by member banks of the London market participants rose during November reaching Bullion Market Association declined to 19.9 million 21.2 million ounces on 27 November from 19.3 mil- ounces in October on average per day from 22.4 mil- lion ounces on 30 October. The increase in net long lion ounces in September. The average value traded positions was driven entirely by an increase in gross per day declined to $34.7 billion in October from long positions, which reached 24.2 million ounces on $39.2 billion in September. The average number of 27 November from 22.1 million ounces at the end of transfers slipped to 2,453 in October from 2,911 in October. Gross short positions rose during Novem- September. Bullion Coins Monthly U.S. Eagle and Buffalo Gold Coin Sale s by the U.S. Mint Monthly U.S. Mint Gold Coin Sales to Dealers Month 2010 2011 2012 Thousand Ounces Thousand Ounces 350 350 January 85,000 133,500 140,500 Fe bruary 84,000 92,500 28,000 300 300 March 102,000 111,500 88,500 April 117,000 128,500 29,000 250 250 May 260,500 122,500 62,500 June 185,000 67,000 70,000 200 200 July 175,000 76,500 34,500 August 57,000 140,000 48,000 150 150 Se pte mbe r 98,000 104,000 77,000 O ctobe r 94,000 62,500 70,000 100 100 Nove mbe r 112,000 49,500 153,000 De ce mbe r 60,000 86,500 50 50 YTD Total June 2012 1,369,500 1,088,000 801,000 % Change YOY -0.6% -20.6% -26.4% 0 0 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10 12 Annual Total 1,429,500 1,174,500 801,000 % Change Previous Year -12.0% -17.8% World Gold Supply and Demand Gold Quarterly Average Price Projections Million Ounces $/Ounce, through Q3 2014 140 140 $2,000 $2,000 130 Investment Demand 130 120 120 $1,800 $1,800 110 110 $1,600 $1,600 100 100 Available Supply 90 90 $1,400 Projections $1,400 80 80 Actual $1,200 $1,200 70 70 60 60 $1,000 $1,000 50 50 $800 $800 40 40 30 30 $600 $600 Fabrication Demand 20 20 $400 $400 10 10 0 0 $200 $200 50 53 56 59 62 65 68 71 74 77 80 83 86 89 92 95 98 01 04 07 10 13p 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
  • 14. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 14 Bullion Coins Sales during the first 11 months of 2012 declined to 124,000 ounces, down 19.2% from the same period U.S. Mint gold coin sales reached 153,000 ounces in in 2011. November, the highest level reached since July 2010 Premiums on both the American Eagle and American when sales had totaled 175,000 ounces. Sales during Buffalo gold coins remained mostly flat during No- the first 11 months of 2012 totaled 801,000 ounces, vember. This suggests that the market was well sup- down 26.4% over the same period in 2011. On a year plied and could potentially result in softening in de- -on-year basis, sales during November 2012 were up mand from dealers in December. 209%, however. U.S. Mint American Eagle gold coin sales reached 136,500 ounces during November 2012, the highest level of sales for these coins since July 2010. Sales of these coins during the first eleven months of the year reached 677,000 ounces, down 27.6% from the corre- sponding period in 2011. American Buffalo gold coin sales continued to rise in November reaching 16,500 ounces during the month. This was up from 8,500 ounces from the same period in 2011 and up from 11,000 ounces in October 2012.
  • 15. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 15 Gold Statistical Position Million Ounces Supply 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012p 2013p Mine Production China 8.7 9.1 10.1 11.0 11.6 12.3 13.0 Australia 7.9 6.9 7.2 8.4 8.3 8.1 8.4 United States 7.7 7.5 7.2 7.4 7.6 7.2 7.4 South Africa 8.2 7.1 6.6 6.2 6.0 5.3 5.1 Peru 5.5 5.8 5.9 5.3 5.3 5.4 5.5 Indonesia 3.7 2.1 4.0 3.4 2.5 1.8 2.0 Canada 3.3 3.1 3.1 2.9 3.2 3.2 3.1 Other Market Economies 20.4 21.5 23.1 24.6 25.0 26.0 28.0 Total 65.3 62.9 67.1 69.2 69.4 69.3 72.6 % Change Year Ago -0.7% -3.6% 6.6% 3.1% 0.3% -0.2% 4.8% Secondary Supply 33.8 39.8 41.2 40.3 40.6 40.7 38.3 % Change Year Ago 22.5% 17.8% 3.7% -2.1% 0.5% 0.3% -6.0% Transitional Economy Sales 11.3 12.0 10.5 9.7 9.0 7.5 7.0 % Change Year Ago 9.7% 6.2% - -7.6% - - - Total Supply 110.3 114.7 118.8 119.2 119.0 117.6 118.1 % Change Year Ago 6.5% 4.0% 3.6% 0.3% -0.2% -1.2% 0.4% Fabrication Demand Industrial Demand Electronics 9.1 9.1 7.9 8.5 8.5 8.4 8.6 Dental/Medical 2.5 2.4 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.1 2.1 Other 3.9 4.6 4.1 4.1 4.7 4.8 4.9 Total 15.4 16.1 14.2 14.8 15.3 15.3 15.6 % Change Year Ago 15.6% 4.2% -11.9% 4.6% 3.1% 0.0% 1.8% Jewelry Developed Countries 14.9 12.4 9.4 8.7 8.4 8.2 8.1 Developing Countries 60.0 58.4 48.0 49.6 49.1 51.0 53.8 Total 74.9 70.8 57.3 58.3 57.5 59.2 61.8 % Change Year Ago -0.8% -5.5% -19.0% 1.7% -1.4% 3.0% 4.5% Total Fabrication Demand 90.4 86.9 71.4 73.1 72.7 74.5 77.4 % Change Year Ago 1.7% -3.9% -17.8% 2.4% -0.5% 2.4% 3.9% Stock Demand Total Official Transactions -16.0 0.2 16.8 10.1 12.7 11.0 9.0 % Change Year Ago 37.2% NM NM -39.9% 25.9% -13.6% -18.2% Net Private Investment Official Coins 4.4 5.0 6.0 6.3 4.5 4.1 3.6 Bullion 28.8 18.1 20.1 24.7 26.0 25.4 25.6 Medallions 2.8 4.5 4.5 5.0 3.0 2.7 2.4 Total 36.0 27.6 30.6 36.0 33.5 32.1 31.7 % Change Year Ago 36.5% -23.3% 10.7% 17.8% -6.9% -4.1% -1.4% Total Stock Demand 20.0 27.8 47.4 46.1 46.3 43.1 40.7 % Change Year Ago 36.0% 39.3% 70.4% -2.7% 0.3% -6.7% -5.6% Total Demand (Fabrication Plus Stock Change) 110.3 114.7 118.8 119.2 119.0 117.6 118.1 Price Per Ounce YTD High $842.70 $1,004.30 $1,218.30 $1,421.40 $1,889.70 $1,796.50 Low 606.90 705.00 807.30 1,052.80 1,318.40 1536.60 Average 700.11 872.82 974.70 1,228.63 1,572.00 1669.27 % Change Year Ago 15.4% 24.7% 11.7% 26.1% 27.9% 6.5% *Million Ounces; Source: CPM Group; Notes: There may be discrepancies in totals and percent changes due to rounding; Net official sales are indicated by negative numbers; The price is the Comex nearby active settlement, 2012 Through 11 October. Longer term projections are available in CPM Group's Gold Supply, Demand, and Price: 10-Year Projections report; e -- estimates; p -- projections; NM -- Not meaningful; December 5, 2012
  • 16. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 16 Silver Outlook Silver prices rose last month, after trending lower in Oc- volumes in the Comex silver futures market are down tober. The roll of the December contract into the March about 30%, clearing volumes in the London interbank and forward month contracts helped boost prices. This market are 20% lower this year than last year, silver Ea- coupled with seasonal demand for the metal ahead of Di- gle bullion sales are down 15% year-to-date, and silver wali, contributed to the 11.3% trough-to-peak increase in ETP net purchases are the lowest seen since 2005 settlement prices between 2 and 29 November. (excluding 2011 when investors sold a net of 24.4 million ounces of silver ETPs). CPM Group is projecting invest- Silver prices have been trending lower since April of last ment demand for silver to fall to 124.3 million ounces in year. Each price rally has ended at lower highs. Intraday 2012 from 133.2 million ounces last year. A further de- peaks went from $49.82 in April 2011 to $44.09 in Au- cline in investment demand to 102.0 million ounces in gust 2011 to $37.48 in February 2012 to $35.45 in Octo- projected for 2013 while prices may come off by 8% ber 2012 to the most recent peak of $34.35 on 29 Novem- from 2012 levels. ber. Price support throughout this period has been firmly positioned at $26.25. Going forward CPM Group expects Silver prices are projected to move sideways to lower this further declines in silver prices, driven by continued month amid reduced trading activity during the holiday weakness in industrial demand and rising supply. These season in the Western hemisphere. Investor concerns future declines, however, may be limited. Over the past about the fiscal cliff so far have appeared immaterial to year, despite a broad decline in the price of the metal, the silver market. It seems investor views about the ap- investors have remained relatively interested in silver as a form of investment. Investors have purchased a net of Silver Prices: 1 January 2010 to 5 December 2012 40.6 million ounces of silver exchange traded products $ / Oz (ETPs), more than reversing the 24.4 million ounces of 52 silver ETPs sold during 2011. Last month, the U.S. Mint 48 witnessed a spike in November bullion coin sales, selling 44 3.2 million ounces of silver Eagle bullion coins, up 40 128.3% from last November, to authorized dealers. Also, 36 net long positions held by non-commercial Comex mar- 32 ket participants in silver futures and options have been 28 increasing since July and open interest in Comex silver 24 futures rose above levels seen in April of last year when 20 prices peaked last month. 16 12 Even though investment demand has been positive this 8 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 Jul-12 year thus far, 2012 pales in comparison to 2011. Trading Silver Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014 $ / Ounce Quarterly $48 $48 Year Quarter Change Annual AVG Change AVG $44 $44 $40 $40 2012 IV $32.72 9.7% $31.32 -6.0% $36 $36 2013 I $29.47 0.9% Actual $32 $32 II $30.08 -8.0% $28 $28 III $32.99 -4.0% $24 $24 $20 $20 IV $33.28 3.0% $30.89 -1.3% $16 $16 2014 I $30.62 4.0% Projections $12 $12 II $29.40 -1.0% $8 $8 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 III $30.28 -6.0%
  • 17. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 17 proaching fiscal cliff are mixed, resulting in no net im- and Australian output is up 19.1% so far this year. pact on price direction. Prices may rise in January and Chilean and Bolivian output both declined strongly February, ahead of the March contract delivery period at this year relative to 2011. the end of February and due to portfolio rebalancing. Approximately 25 new silver-producing mines began Prices are expected to trade above $30 and below $35.50 production this year so far, four of which are primary over the next three months. silver mines. The largest mine by annual silver ca- pacity is Aurcana’s Shafter mine in the United States, Prices which started production in the first half of the year. The second largest was Mawson West’s Dikulushi Silver prices trended higher in November. Continu- mine in the Democratic Republic of Congo. These 25 ing a decline that began in October, silver prices fell mines will add around 15.0 million ounces to silver during the first three days of the month. Silver traded mine production capacity once fully ramped up. to an intraday low of $30.66 on 5 November, the lowest price since the first half of September. Prices Fabrication Demand began to rise thereafter, touching an intraday peak of $34.40 on 29 November, a 12.2% increase from the 5 Net imports of silver in China fell to 5.7 million November intraday trough. Silver settled at $33.20 ounces in October, down from 6.2 million ounces in on 3 November, down 3.3% from the previous day. Prices averaged $32.82 last month, down 1.1% from the previous month, despite rising prices. Silver Supply Silver price volatility rose last month to 29.0% from World S ilver Mine Production 19.0% in October. This was the highest monthly Million Troy Ounces volatility rate since June. Jan- S ept %∆ 2011 2012 Supply M exico 113.1 122.5 8.3% China 77.9 106.9 37.1% Silver mine production fell to 68.1 million ounces in Peru 81.0 83.4 3.0% September from 69.2 million ounces the previous Australia 40.0 47.6 19.1% month, according to the World Bureau of Metal Sta- Chile 31.3 27.2 -13.1% tistics. Silver output from mines rose to 608.5 million Bolivia 29.3 26.4 -9.8% ounces this year through September, up 8.3% from Subtotal 372.6 414.0 11.1% 562.0 million ounces in the same period in 2011. Other Countries 189.4 194.5 2.7% Output in Mexico, China, Peru, and Australia rose Total 562.0 608.5 8.3% during the first nine months of the year relative to 2011. Chinese silver mine production is up 37.1% Source: WBM S Note: Russia, the sixth largest silver-producing country, was Silver Prices excluded due to lack of comparable data. Silver Price Volatility Monthly Silver Mine Production Monthly, Through November 2012 Through September 2012 Mln Oz 100% 71 90% 69 80% 70% 67 60% 65 50% 63 40% 61 30% 59 20% 10% 57 0% 55 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11 Apr-10 Aug-10 Dec-10 Apr-11 Aug-11 Dec-11 Apr-12 Aug-12
  • 18. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 18 September and 6.1 million ounces in October 2011. pacity of farmers, which make up about 70% of In- Gross imports were lower and gross exports were dia’s work force. higher last month relative to September. Demand for silver in India for Diwali and the wed- Investment Demand ding season benefited from high gold prices last month, but overall demand may have been flat to Silver exchange traded product holdings increased by lower year-on-year. Gold and silver sales in cities 1.1% of 6.7 million ounces last month from 601.4 appeared positive, but rural areas posted weak de- million ounces at the end of October. Holdings rose mand, mostly due to the delay of harvesting. Adverse to a monthly peak of 612.2 million ounces on 15 No- monsoon weather delayed harvesting activities by vember, just shy of the record high of 615.1 million approximately a month. This limited the buying ca- ounces reached on 25 April 2011. Holdings declined Silver Demand Production-Weighted World Industrial Production Chinese Silver Imports and Exports Percentage Change from a Year Ago, Through September 2012 Monthly, Through October 2012 15% 25 25 10% 20 20 15 15 5% 10 10 5 5 0% 0 0 -5% -5 -5 -10 -10 -10% Gross Imports -15 -15 Gross Exports -15% -20 -20 Net Trade 2005m01 2006m04 2007m07 2008m10 2010m01 2011m04 2012m07 -25 -25 Source: CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis J-05 S-05 M-06 J-07 S-07 M-08 J-09 S-09 M-10 J-11 S-11 M-12 Silver Investment Demand Silver Exchange Traded Product Holdings S ilver ETP Holdings Through 30 November 2012 Data as of 30 November, Changes from 31 October Mln Oz 700 Japan SSLV Month-end Holdings %∆ Ounce ∆ SSLN WITE CEF 76,964,103 - 0.0% 0 600 GLTR PSLV S LV iS hares 314,448,448 ↓ -1.4% -4,589,504 SVR.UN SBT.U ETF - ETFS 28,649,144 ↑ 2.6% 733,212 500 Julius Baer SIVR ZKB ZKB S ilver 88,742,680 ↑ 1.6% 1,367,048 MSL PHAG S ilver MS L 2,267,399 ↓ -1.3% -30,852 400 S IVR - ETFS 18,417,787 ↓ -0.6% -103,618 300 Julius Baer S ilver 17,222,990 ↑ 3.1% 515,000 GLTR - ETFS 3,143,830 ↓ 0.0% 0 SLV 200 WITE - ETFS 3,347,751 ↓ -2.8% -95,306 PS LV 49,287,863 ↑ 21.8% 8,814,961 100 S VR 2,335,561 ↑ 2.3% 52,647 CEF S BT 740,423 ↓ -0.1% -1,052 0 S S LN -iS hares 487,905 ↓ 0.0% -230 02 07 08 09 10 11 12 S S LV 319,641 ↑ 64.6% 125,468 Note: CEF-Central Fund of Canada traded on the Toronto Stock Exchange. SLV-iShares Silver S ilver Mitsubishi 1,652,548 ↓ -6.9% -122,173 Trust traded on the American Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich Cantonal traded on the Swiss Exchange. ETF-ETF Securities traded on the London Stock Exchange and Australian Securities Exchange, and Total 608,028,073 ↑ 1.1% 6,665,602 New York Stock Exchange. Julius Baer traded on the Swiss Exchange. SIVR-ETF Securities traded YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings* ↑ 7.2% 40,596,837 on the New York Stock Exchange. MSL-ETF Securities traded on the Australian Stock Exchange. GLTR—ETF Securities traded on NYSE. WITE—ETF Securities traded on NYSE. SSLN—iShares *YTD data through 30 November. Percentage change is from end of ETP traded on the London Stock Exchange. SSLV—Source ETP traded on the London Stock Ex- change. Silver Mitsubishi—Mitsubishi’s silver ETP traded at the Tokyo Stock Exchange. previous year.
  • 19. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 19 on 30 October to 215.5 million ounces on 27 Novem- thereafter, to 608.0 million ounces on 30 November. ber, according to CFTC data. Net long positions held Silver ETP holdings are up 7.2%, or 40.6 million by these market participants have been trending ounces, this year so far. higher since the beginning of July. Gross long posi- tions rose by 26.1 million ounces while gross short Coins positions increased 3.5 million ounces during the pe- riod. The U.S. Mint delivered 3.2 million ounces of silver The daily average number of ounces transferred in Eagle bullion coins to authorized dealers in Novem- the London interbank market during October was ber, up 128.3% from 1.4 million ounces delivered in 98.1 million ounces, down from 124.3 million ounces November 2011. Coins sales by the U.S. Mint are in the previous month. The daily value of ounces down 15.5% so far this year from the same period in transferred averaged $3.26 billion, down from $4.18 2011. billion in September and the number of transfers fell to 757 from 967 in the previous month. Markets and Inventories Open interest in Comex silver futures rose from Silver Markets 696.2 million ounces on 31 October to 774.4 million ounces on 23 November, an 11.2% increase. Open Comex Silver Inventories & Total Open Interest O M interest in Comex silver futures has been increasing Daily, Through 5 December 2012 since December of last year. The 23 November peak Mln Ozs Mln Ozs was higher than the April 2011 peak of 764.7 million 1,000 1,000 ounces. Open interest came off after 23 November, 900 Total Open Interest 900 falling to 722.1 million ounces on 3 December. 800 800 Open interest in the most active nearby March con- 700 700 tract was 446.1 million ounces on 30 November. This 600 600 was 3.1 times the amount of metal stored in Comex 500 500 warehouses. 400 400 Daily trading volumes of Comex silver futures aver- 300 300 aged 326.7 million ounces in November, 71.7% Registered Stocks Eligible Stocks 200 200 higher than the daily average rate of 190.1 million 100 100 ounces in October. 0 0 Large non-commercial market participants’ net long J-06 O-06 A-07 M-08 M-09 D-09 S-10 J-11 M-12 positions increased 11.7% from 192.9 million ounces Bullion Coins Monthly U.S. Eagle Silve r Coin Sale s by the U.S. Mint U.S. Mint Silver Coin Sales Month 2010 2011 2012 January 3,592,500 6,422,000 6,107,000 Million Ozs Million Ozs Fe bruary 2,050,000 3,240,000 1,490,000 6.5 6.5 March 3,381,000 2,767,000 2,542,000 6.0 6.0 April 2,507,500 2,819,000 1,520,000 5.5 5.5 5.0 5.0 May 3,636,500 3,653,500 2,875,000 4.5 4.5 June 3,001,000 3,402,000 2,858,000 4.0 4.0 July 2,981,000 2,968,000 2,278,000 3.5 3.5 August 2,451,000 3,679,500 2,870,000 3.0 3.0 Se pte mbe r 1,880,000 4,460,500 3,255,000 2.5 2.5 O ctobe r 3,150,000 3,064,000 3,153,000 2.0 2.0 Nove mbe r 4,260,000 1,384,000 3,159,500 1.5 1.5 De ce mbe r 1,772,000 2,009,000 1.0 1.0 YTD Total June 2012 18,168,500 37,859,500 32,107,500 0.5 0.5 % Change YOY 351.4% 108.4% -15.2% 0.0 0.0 92 9394 95 96 97 Annual Total 34,662,500 39,868,500 32,107,500 % Change Previous Year 48.1% 15.0%
  • 20. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 20 Silver Markets Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions Gross Long and Short Positions of Commercial Positions Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012 Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012 Mln Ozs Mln Ozs Mln Ozs Mln Ozs 400 400 400 400 Net Fund Position in Comex 350 350 Long 300 300 Net Position 300 300 200 200 250 Long 250 100 100 200 200 0 0 150 150 -100 -100 100 100 -200 -200 50 50 -300 -300 0 0 -400 -400 -50 -50 -500 Short -500 -100 -100 -600 -600 Short -150 -150 -700 -700 -200 -200 -800 -800 A-95 M-97 J-99 A-01 S-03 N-05 D-07 J-10 F-12 A-95 M-97 J-99 A-01 S-03 N-05 D-07 J-10 F-12 Gross Long and Short Positions of Comex Disaggragated Non-Commercial Positions Comex Silver Futures and Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012 Silver Prices and Open Interest Daily, Through 5 December 2012 Mln Ozs Mln Ozs 400 400 $/Ounces Million Ounces Long 52 1,000 300 300 48 900 Total Open Interest 44 40 800 200 200 36 700 32 600 100 100 28 500 24 20 400 0 0 16 300 12 200 Money Managers -100 -100 8 Other Traders 4 Prices (Left Scale) 100 Short Net Position 0 0 -200 -200 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 Jun-06 Apr-07 Feb-08 Dec-08 Oct-09 Aug-10 Jun-11 Apr-12 World Silver Supply and Demand Silver Quarterly Average Price Projections $/Ounce, through Q3 2014 $46 $46 1,100 1,100 $42 $42 1,000 1,000 $38 $38 Fabrication Demand 900 900 $34 $34 800 800 $30 $30 Actual $26 $26 700 700 $22 $22 600 Supply 600 $18 $18 Projections 500 500 $14 $14 400 400 $10 $10 $6 $6 300 300 $2 $2 200 200 1999 2002 2005 2008 2011 2014 60 63 66 68 72 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11
  • 21. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 21 Silver Statistical Position Million Ounces Supply 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012p 2013p Mine Production Mexico 99.5 104.1 114.3 128.6 152.8 160.9 161.3 United States 39.0 40.2 39.9 40.8 36.0 34.3 35.4 Peru 112.3 118.5 126.1 116.9 109.8 109.0 111.4 Canada 27.7 24.3 20.3 19.2 18.4 17.8 18.8 Australia 60.5 61.9 52.5 60.4 55.5 57.0 58.2 China 97.9 96.3 107.9 112.5 128.6 135.4 142.7 Other 190.2 189.6 212.8 207.8 212.6 208.5 217.4 Total 627.1 634.8 673.8 686.2 713.6 722.9 745.1 % Change Year Ago 5.0% 1.2% 6.1% 1.9% 4.0% 1.3% 3.1% Secondary Supply Old Scrap 242.2 251.5 249.9 262.8 270.8 263.0 255.0 Coin Melt 5.0 4.0 4.0 2.0 1.5 3.0 3.0 Other Supply 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Indian Scrap 16.1 17.5 21.7 15.7 4.8 13.8 10.0 Total 263.3 273.0 275.6 280.5 277.1 279.8 268.0 % Change Year Ago -1.9% 3.7% 1.0% 1.8% -1.2% 1.0% -4.2% Other Supply Government Disposals 8.0 0 0 3.8 2.4 0 0 Net Exports from Transitional Economies 5 3 1 2 2 2 2 Total 13 3 1 5.8 4.4 2 2 % Change Year Ago -45.8% -76.9% -66.7% 480.0% -23.5% -55.0% Total Supply 903.4 910.8 950.4 972.5 995.1 1,004.7 1,015.1 % Change Year Ago 1.5% 0.8% 4.3% 2.3% 2.3% 1.0% 1.0% Fabrication Demand Photography 161.5 133.5 119.4 110.9 102.6 96.8 93.1 Jewelry & Silverware 284.7 278.9 276.5 286.5 290.9 296.1 308.0 Electronics and Batteries 195.9 204.3 201.1 212.8 221.8 234.4 248.4 Solar Panels 6.3 15.5 22.6 48.6 59.8 60.2 64.0 Other Uses 212.3 213.5 176.4 178.3 178.8 183.2 189.5 Other Countries 8.2 9.7 7.5 6.5 8.0 9.7 10.0 Net Imports into the Transitional Economies Total Fabrication Demand 869.0 855.3 803.6 843.5 861.9 880.4 913.0 % Change Year Ago 1.3% -1.6% -6.1% 5.0% 2.2% 2.1% 2.6% Net Surplus or Deficit 34.4 55.5 146.8 129.0 133.2 124.4 102.0 Addenda Coinage 29.2 54.4 66.2 82.5 98.7 79.7 70.9 Price Per Ounce YTD High $15.55 $20.79 $19.33 $30.94 $48.58 $37.14 Low 11.50 8.79 10.44 14.83 26.81 26.25 Average 13.45 14.97 14.67 20.31 35.29 31.15 % Change Year Ago 15.9% 11.3% -2.0% 38.4% 73.8% -12.8% *Million Ounces; Notes: Totals may not equal the sum of categories due to rounding. Mine production in Poland, Bulgaria, Romania, Hungary, the Czech Republic, and Slovakia is included in "other" mine production; Photography, jewelry and silverware, electronics, and 'other' industrial use reflects demand in Europe, the United States, and Japan.; These sectors include Canada from 1979, Mexico from 1982, Hong Kong from 1985, Thailand from 1986, India from 1987, Australia, Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Argentina, Chile, Korea, Pakistan, and Bangladesh from 1989, and Taiwan from 1990; Demand excludes the transitional economies, except for imports.; The price is the Comex nearby active settlement, percent change from year earlier period. 2012 through 6 December. There may be discrepancies due to rounding; p - projections; NM - Not meaningful; Source: CPM Group 6 December 2012.
  • 22. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 22 Platinum Outlook Platinum prices may trend higher over the next three ment rate stood at 25.5% in the third quarter of the year months, driven by portfolio rebalancing, investor con- and has been rising since the fourth quarter of 2011. cerns about the uncertainty of supply flows from South South Africa’s chronically high unemployment rate is Africa, and the roll of the nearby active January contract one contributing factor to the increase in illegal strike into forward months. Fabrication demand weakness in activity this year, as many mine workers are supporting Europe is expected to limit price increases over the next unemployed family members and experiencing extreme three months, however. Prices could rise toward $1,700 cost pressures. Discussions about transitioning to a cen- and remain above $1,540 over the three-month projected tralized wage-bargaining structure for the platinum min- period. ing industry have been progressing. The gold mining in- dustry adopted this procedure long ago and authorities Supply constraints eased in November after Anglo Plati- have been assessing the possibility of using this model in num announced it had achieved a resolution to the illegal the platinum industry. This could reduce labor issues in strikes at its Rustenburg, Union, and Amandabult opera- the future, but in the interim will serve as a source of un- tions on 15 November. The company lost almost certainty to the platinum market. 200,000 ounces of potential platinum output since the first strikes at the Rustenburg operations began in Sep- tember. Atlatsa Resources reported it planned on restart- ing operations at its jointly owned Bokoni mine. Strike activity began there in October. CPM Group expected Platinum Prices: 1 January 2010 to 5 December 2012 mine supply in South Africa to decline to 4.1 million $ / Oz ounces in 2012, down 12.1% from the previous year. This compares to a 4.7% increase in South African output 1900 projected for 2012 at the beginning of the year. The platinum industry in South Africa remains highly vulnerable to supply shocks at present. Although illegal 1700 strike activity has abated substantially, there is still poten- tial for more strikes to occur in the near future. According to Susan Shabangu, the country’s Mineral Resources 1500 Minister, the platinum mining industry has shed 3,332 jobs in the past six months. South Africa’s unemploy- 1300 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 Jul-12 Platinum Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014 $ / Ounce Quarterly Year Quarter Change Annual AVG Change AVG $1,900 $1,900 2012 IV $1,604 6.5% $1,556 -5.4% $1,700 Actual $1,700 2013 I $1,615 0.7% II $1,567 -3.0% $1,500 $1,500 III $1,527 -2.5% $1,300 $1,300 IV $1,634 7.0% $1,586 1.9% Projections 2014 I $1,693 3.6% $1,100 $1,100 II $1,719 1.5% III $1,658 -3.5% $900 $900 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
  • 23. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 23 In addition to wage issues, fresh concerns about the sup- tential output during the strike, which is about 4.1% ply of electricity surfaced last month. Eskom, the main of South African platinum output in 2011. Workers utility provider in the country, reported that its supply/ accepted Anglo’s wage offer, which increased demand balance of electricity was extremely narrow due monthly base salaries by 400 South African rand and to unplanned outages. This fresh uncertainty may be sup- included a one off allowance payable upon returning portive of prices over the next few weeks. to work. CPM Group estimates that Anglo Platinum’s output could be around 12% lower in 2012 from the Prices previous year. Impala Platinum reported results for the quarter Prices trended higher last month, from an intraday ended 30 September last month. The company pro- low of $1,534.50 on 7 November to an intraday high duced 454,000 refined ounces of platinum during the of $1,626.60 on 23 November, a 6.0% increase. Plati- quarter, up 17.0% from 388,000 ounces produced in num traded sideways after 23 November, mostly be- the same quarter in 2011. The company decided to tween $1,580 and $1,625. Prices averaged $1,579.40 defer its phase 2 expansion plants at Zimplats to 2015 for the month, down 3.5% from the previous month. as part of its capital preservation measures. Cash The monthly volatility rate fell to 15.7% in Novem- costs at Impala mines increased by around 15%, due ber from 19.7% the previous month. This was lower to poor mining quality at its Rustenburg operations, than the 24.9% rate in November of last year and was wage pressures, and adverse exchange rates. the lowest monthly rate since July of 2011. The strike that began at the Bokoni mine, jointly owned by Atlatsa Resources and Anglo Platinum, on 1 October may have ended or will come to an end soon. Atlatsa reported in its 3 December press release Supply that it was currently in the process of “re-hiring workers with the view to re-commencing operations Anglo Platinum restarted operations on 15 November as soon as possible.” The Bokoni mine is one of the at its Rustenburg mines, where an illegal strike had highest cost mines in the industry and only produces halted mining activities since 13 September, and its about 100,000 ounces of platinum a year. Union and Amandelbult operations, where strike ac- Renewed concerns about South Africa’s power sup- tion began in early October. These operations ac- ply surfaced in the first week of December. Eskom, count nearly 60% of the company’s South African the main power provider in the country, reported it platinum production capacity and roughly 30% of only had about 2% of excess supply of electricity. total South African platinum production capacity. In The narrow margin was attributed to unplanned out- the company’s 15 November press release, Anglo ages. About four years ago, the country experienced Platinum reported it had lost 191,359 ounces of po- rolling blackouts due to an electricity shortage. These blackouts halted PGM mining operations and contrib- Platinum Prices uted to the PGM price spikes of 2008. Platinum Price Volatility Monthly, Through November 2012 100% 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 75 79 83 87 91 95 99 03 07 11
  • 24. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 24 Fabrication Demand year. Sales this year through November in Germany, France, Italy, and Spain are down 1.2%, 13.7% Commercial vehicle demand in the United States and 20.0%, and 12.8% year-on-year. Japan are up 10.0% and 21.5% this year through Oc- Gross imports of platinum in China are up 2.5% this tober from the same period a year ago. Commercial year through October from the same period in 2011. vehicle sales in Western Europe and China are down Trading volumes of platinum on the Shanghai Gold 10.6% and 7.9%, respectively. Commercial vehicles Exchange are down 1.3% this year through Novem- have large engines, which holding other factors con- ber from 2011 levels. Trading volumes in November stant requires higher PGM loadings in the fitted auto fell to 161,525 ounces, down 0.9% from November catalysts. These auto catalysts typically are more 2011. platinum intensive, due to the sulfur content of the diesel fuel often used. Investment Demand Passenger car demand in Western Europe was 6.9% lower in 2012 through October from the same period Investors were net sellers of platinum exchange a year ago. Sales in the major auto markets last traded products in November, reducing their holdings month were lower than last year’s sales levels. Ger- by 19,365 ounces or 1.3% from the end of October. many’s auto market worsened last month. Sales fell Holdings totaled 1.5 million ounces on 30 November, to 259,846 vehicles, down 3.5% from a year ago. up 15.0% from the end of 2011. Holdings are down Auto sales in France, Italy, and Spain all showed 2.8% from a peak of 1.6 million ounces reached in double-digit declines in November from the previous late September. Platinum Fabrication Demand Annual Growth in New Car Registrations in Europe Commercial Vehicle Sales in Major Auto Markets Change over same period a year ago 2009 2010 2011 2012YTD Y-o-Y % Chg. Y-o-Y % Chg. Germany 24.4% -23.2% 8.2% -1.2% 40% 40% France 10.9% 1.4% -2.5% -13.7% China USA Europe Japan 30% 30% Italy -0.9% -10.4% -10.7% -20.0% United Kingdom -6.6% 2.2% -4.9% 4.7% 20% 20% S pain -16.8% 3.9% -17.9% -12.8% 10% 10% Western Europe -1.7% -5.1% -1.3% -6.9% 0% 0% S ource: ACEA via Bloomberg. -10% -10% Note: Country data through November, except for the U.K., which is through October. Western Europe data through -20% -20% October. -30% -30% Annual Change in European Passenger Car Sales -40% -40% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 YTD 30.0% Note: 2012 Through October Germany France 20.0% Italy United Kingdom 10.0% Spain Western Europe 0.0% -10.0% -20.0% -30.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012YTD Note: 2012 through November Western Europe and U.K. through October.
  • 25. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 25 Markets & Inventories Daily trading volumes of Nymex platinum futures fell to 416,259 ounces in November from 460,122 Open interest in Nymex platinum futures fell from ounces in October. 3.06 million ounces on 31 October to a monthly low Large non-commercial Nymex market participants of 2.98 million ounces on 20 November. Open inter- raised their net long positions in platinum futures by est began rising thereafter, touching 3.10 million 466,400 ounces between 30 October and 27 Novem- ounces on 3 December. ber, a 52.2% increase. Gross long positions increased Open interest in the nearby active January contract by 21% and gross short positions decreased by 42.5% trended lower last month, from 2.87 million ounces at during the period. the end of October to 2.73 million ounces on 4 De- cember, a 5.0% decrease. Platinum Investment Demand Platinum Markets Platinum ETF Holdings Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions Data as of 30 November 2012, Changes from 31 October Platinum Futures & Options. Weekly Data, Through 30 October 2012 '000 Ozs '000 Ozs Month-end Holdings % ∆ Ounce ∆ 2,700 2,700 PPLT ETF S ecurities 491,581 ↓ -1.0% -5,058 2,400 2,400 2,100 Long 2,100 Platinum ZKB 353,395 ↓ 0.0% -161 1,800 1,800 Platinum Julius Baer 105,670 ↓ -0.2% -250 Net Fund Position in Nymex 1,500 1,500 PHPT ETFS 518,384 ↑ 2.1% 11,002 1,200 1,200 GLTR - ETFS 8,471 ↑ 2.7% 225 900 900 WITE - ETFS 7,319 ─ 0.0% 0 600 600 Platinum MS L 5,108 ↑ 2.7% 136 300 300 S PLT iS hares 3,279 ↓ 0.0% -1 0 0 S PPT S ource 14,677 ─ 0.0% 0 -300 -300 Japan Mitsubishi 15,882 ─ 0.0% 0 -600 Short -600 Total 1,523,766 ↓ -1.3% -19,365 -900 -900 YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings* ↑ 15.0% 198,302 -1,200 -1,200 A-95 M-97 J-99 D-01 J-04 F-06 A-08 M-10 J-12 *YTD Holdings as of 30 November 2012. Percentage change is Platinum Exchange Traded Product Holdings Daily, through 30 November 2012 Platinum Prices, Total Open Interest, and Nymex Inventories Daily, Through 5 December 2012 Mln Oz Mln Oz $ / Oz Mln Ozs 1.8 1.8 3,000 3.5 SPPT - LSE Source 1.6 1.6 SPLT-LSE iShares 2,500 3.0 1.4 1.4 WITE-NYSE ETFS Prices (Left scale) 2.5 1.2 1.2 2,000 GLTR-NYSE ETFS PPLT 1.0 NYSE 1.0 2.0 Julius Baer Platinum 1,500 0.8 0.8 MSL ASX 1.5 ZKB 0.6 Platinum 0.6 1,000 Tokyo Mitsubishi 1.0 0.4 0.4 Nymex Stocks 500 0.5 0.2 PHPT LSE 0.2 Open Interest 0.0 0.0 0 0.0 20-Apr-07 20-Apr-08 20-Apr-09 20-Apr-10 20-Apr-11 20-Apr-12 D-02 F-04 A-05 J-06 S-07 N-08 J-10 M-11 M-12 Note: PHPT-ETF Securities’ platinum ETF traded on the London Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich Cantonal's platinum ETF traded. PPLT-ETF Securities’ platinum ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. Julius Baer’s platinum ETF traded on the Swiss Exchange. MSL-Metals Securities Australia platinum ETF. GLTR-ETF Securities’ Precious Metals Basket ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. WITE-ETF Securities’ white metals basket ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. SPLT-iShares platinum ETC traded on the London Stock Exchange. SPPT- Source’s platinum ETP traded on the London Stock Exchange. Tokyo-Mitsubishi’s Japanese Platinum ETC.
  • 26. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 26 Platinum Statistical Position Platinum Statistical Position Supply 2007 2008 2009 2010e 2011 2012p 2013p Mine Production South Africa 5,039 4,778 4,537 4,684 4,695 4,128 4,581 Russia 935 800 804 834 811 803 823 Canada 206 235 144 96 247 257 270 United States 128 119 126 113 122 118 119 Other 363 369 403 457 510 519 530 Total 6,672 6,301 6,014 6,184 6,385 5,826 6,322 % Change Year Ago -5.1% -5.6% -4.6% 2.8% 3.3% -8.8% 8.5% Secondary Supply Total 920 1,000 750 964 988 998 1,038 % Change Year Ago 13.6% 8.7% -25.0% 28.5% 2.5% 1.0% 4.0% Total Supply 7,592 7,301 6,764 7,147 7,373 6,824 7,360 % Change Year Ago -3.2% -3.8% -7.4% 5.7% 3.2% -7.4% 7.9% Fabrication Demand Auto 4,195 3,785 2,740 3,081 3,173 3,285 3,341 Jewelry 1,772 1,698 2,283 1,926 1,946 1,974 2,038 Other 1,877 1,975 1,959 2,196 2,196 2,240 2,298 Total Demand 7,844 7,457 6,982 7,202 7,315 7,499 7,677 % Change Year Ago 0.3% -4.9% -6.4% 3.2% 1.6% 2.5% 2.4% Net Surplus or Deficit -252 -157 -218 -55 58 -675 -316 Price Per Ounce YTD High $1,549.30 $2,276.10 $1,506.30 $1,809.60 $1,905.70 $1,725.10 Low $1,112.00 $787.20 $922.20 $1,460.00 $1,363.40 $1,386.40 Average $1,314.46 $1,579.31 $1,214.50 $1,614.22 $1,722.39 $1,552.35 % Change Year Ago 14.6% 20.1% -23.1% 32.9% 6.7% -12.3% *Thousand Troy Ounces; Notes: Excludes transitional economies, except as noted. Secondary production statistics exclude toll-refined material; Prices are settlement prices for the nearby active contract on the New York Mercantile Exchange. 2012 through 6 December. Changes in market inventories are year-end. *Changes in 1997 market inventories exclude U.S. Industry stocks since the U.S. Bureau of Mines ceased publication of U.S. Industry stock level data in the third quarter of 1997; As of 2006 Inventories includes changes in ETF holdings; There may be discrepancies due to rounding; NA -- not available; e -- estimates; p -- projections; Sources: U.S. Bureau of Mines, Statistics Canada, trade sources, CPM Group; 6 December 2012. World Platinum Supply and Demand Balance Platinum Quarterly Average Price Projections Thou. Ounces $/Ounce, through Q3 2014 9,000 9,000 $2,600 $2,600 8,000 8,000 $2,200 $2,200 Total Supply 7,000 7,000 Total Demand 6,000 6,000 $1,800 $1,800 5,000 5,000 Actual $1,400 $1,400 4,000 4,000 Projections 3,000 3,000 $1,000 $1,000 2,000 2,000 $600 $600 1,000 1,000 0 0 $200 $200 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009 2013p 1999 2002 2005 2008 2011 2014
  • 27. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 27 Palladium Outlook Palladium has price supportive mine supply fundamentals becomes a concern and investors liquidate their positions. but the fabrication demand fundamentals could weaken Prices are unlikely to decline below these levels because over the next few months, which could weigh on prices. of the price supportive mine supply fundamentals. On the The illegal labor strikes at South African mines have upside prices could rise toward $725. If prices break past been resolved, for the most part, but there are still several this level prices are could find resistance at $750. Prices country related risks, such as poor infrastructure and gov- are likely to rise to these levels in the event that the fiscal ernment policies that could hamper mine supply in the cliff is averted. In such a scenario, all asset prices could future. Since none of these factors is an active issue at potentially see at least an initial increase in value. present these problems are expected to be more price sup- portive than factors that result in pushing higher the price of palladium. On the fabrication demand side, there has been strength in demand from two of palladium’s largest uses, auto catalysts and semiconductors. Much of the demand growth in both of these areas has been driven by stronger growth from the United States. Fabrication demand is likely to be hurt in the first half of next year as the U.S. Palladium Prices undergoes fiscal tightening. Irrespective of how U.S. Palladium Prices: 1 January 2009 to 5 December 2012 politicians handle the fiscal cliff situation, there will be a $ / Oz negative impact on the economy. If the fiscal cliff is 900 averted, the scenario we assign the greatest probability, 850 the negative impact of the fiscal tightening will be less 800 than if no decision is made on how to handle the situa- 750 tion, a scenario we consider to be unlikely. Additionally, 700 the U.S. auto market is beginning to show signs of an 650 increase in inventory levels for some models, despite the 600 strong growth in demand for auto in the U.S. market this 550 year. This could weigh on future palladium demand. 500 On the downside, palladium prices could potentially de- 450 cline toward $600 or even $580 if fabrication demand 400 350 Jan-10 Jul-10 Jan-11 Jul-11 Jan-12 Jul-12 Palladium Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014 $ / Ounce Quarterly $900 $900 Year Quarter Change Annual AVG Change AVG $800 $800 Actual 2012 IV $640 4.1% $642 -12.6% $700 $700 $600 $600 2013 I $632 -1.3% $500 $500 II $638 1.0% $400 $400 III $625 -2.0% Projections $300 $300 IV $678 8.5% $643 0.2% $200 $200 2014 I $722 6.4% $100 $100 II $738 2.2% $0 $0 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 III $710 -3.7%
  • 28. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 28 Prices There are several structural problems with South Af- rica’s mining industry, however, which should con- Palladium prices rose by around 13% during Novem- tinue to threaten supply and should underpin palla- ber. Prices settled at $686.25 on 30 November, up dium prices. from $609.80 on 31 October. Palladium prices settled higher on more days than it settled lower, during No- Fabrication Demand vember. The roll of the then nearby active December Nymex contract, coupled with an increase in invest- Monthly U.S. light-duty vehicle sales continued to ment demand helped to drive palladium prices rise in November reaching 1.13 million, up 14.8% higher. In November, palladium prices retraced all of from the corresponding period in 2011. For the first the losses that it suffered between the last week of 11 months of 2012, U.S. light-duty vehicle sales to- September and the end of October. taled 13.08 million, up 13.8% or 1.6 million vehicles over the same period in 2011. Availability of cheap Supply and relatively easy financing has been the primary driver of demand during 2012. Demand in November Strikes at South Africa’s platinum group metal mines also is said to be helped by the destruction of cars were resolved for the most part during November. due to Superstorm Sandy. It is estimated that around Palladium Price Volatility and Fabrication Demand Palladium Price Volatility U.S. Vehicle Sales Monthly, Through November 2012 Monthly Data, Through November 2012 Thousand Vehicles 100% 1,600 90% 2010 2011 2012 1,400 80% 70% 1,200 60% 1,000 50% 800 40% 30% 600 20% 400 10% 200 0% 77 79 81 83 85 87 89 91 93 95 97 99 01 03 05 07 09 11 13 - Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Annual Percentage Change in Auto Sales Chinese Vehicle Sales Monthly ,Through October 2012 60.0% Thousand Vehicles 50.0% 2,000 40.0% 2010 2011 2012 1,900 30.0% 1,800 20.0% 1,700 10.0% 1,600 0.0% 1,500 -10.0% 1,400 -20.0% 1,300 Brazil Russia -30.0% 1,200 India China 1,100 -40.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012 YTD 1,000 Source: Bloomberg. Note: 2012 data through September. Brazil through October. Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
  • 29. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 29 250,000 vehicles were lost to the storm. Investment Demand One area of concern with regard to future demand for palladium is that there is a significant build up in the Palladium exchange traded product (ETP) holdings inventory of certain vehicles despite the increase in rose at the beginning of November, rising to 1.91 demand. million ounces on 5 November. Holdings slipped According to the Semiconductor Industry Associa- lower over the next few days reaching a low of 1.862 tion, global semiconductor sales in October rose to million ounces on 15 November. Holdings rose over $25.2 billion, up 1.7% from the prior month. Year-to- the remainder of November, rising back to levels date sales through October 2012 were down 3.7% near those seen at the beginning of the month. On 30 from the corresponding period in 2011. November, palladium ETP holdings had reached 1.89 million ounces. Investor holdings in palladium ETPs had continued Palladium Investment Demand to rise into the first few days of December, with hold- ings reaching around 1.9 million ounces on 5 Decem- Net Sales/Purchases of Palladium ETPs ber. Thousand Ounces Thousand Ounces 1,200 1,200 Markets & Inventories 1,000 1,000 Total open interest in the Nymex palladium contract 800 800 rose during November. Total open interest rose from 600 600 2.07 million ounces at the end of October to 2.3 mil- lion ounces at the end of November. The increase in 400 400 total open interest gained momentum toward the end 200 200 of the month, rising to a high of 2.35 million ounces 0 0 on 29 November from 2.16 million ounces on 21 No- vember. Total open interest continued to rise into the -200 -200 first few days of December. On 3 December, total -400 -400 open interest was at 2.36 million ounces. Open interest in the December Nymex contract de- -600 -600 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 YTD clined over the course of November as market par- ticipants either rolled forward or closed out their po- Palladium ETP Holdings sitions. Open interest in this contract slipped from Data as of 30 November Changes from 30 October 1.89 million ounces at the beginning of November to Month-end Holdings %∆ Ounce ∆ PALL ETF S ecurities 712,675 ↓ -5.6% -39,819 Palladium ZKB - S IX 355,276 ↓ 0.0% -161 Palladium ETP Holdings Palladium Julius Baer 133,923 ↑ 1.0% 1,400 Through November 2012 PHPD ETF S ecurities 550,721 ↑ 6.6% 36,587 Mln Oz Mln Oz 2.5 2.5 GLTR - ETFS 12,633 ↑ 2.3% 292 Mitsubishi WITE - ETFS 5,875 ─ 0.0% 0 SPAL Palladium MS L - AS X 3,812 ↑ 2.8% 106 2.0 2.0 S PDM iS hares 6,348 ↓ 0.0% -2 SPDM S PAL S ource 102,982 ↑ 1.5% 1,509 WITE Mitsubishi 12,539 0.0% 0 1.5 PALL 1.5 ─ Total 1,896,784 ↓ 0.0% -86 GLTR NYSE YTD Net Additions to Total ETF Holdings* 191,994 1.0 Julius Baer 1.0 *As of 30 November MSL ASX ZKB Note: PHPD-ETF Palladium traded on the London Stock Exchange. ZKB-Zurich Cantonal's 0.5 0.5 palladium ETF traded. PALL—ETFS Palladium traded on the New York Stock Exchange . Metals Securities Australia . Julius Baer’s palladium ETF traded on the Swiss Exchange. Precious Metals PHPD LSE Basket ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. WITE-ETF Securities’ white metals basket ETF traded on the New York Stock Exchange. SPDM-iShares’ palladium ETC traded on the 0.0 0.0 London Stock Exchange. SPAL-Source’s palladium ETC traded on the London Stock Exchange. 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Mitsubishi is palladium ETP traded on Tokyo Stock Exchange. Source: ETP issuer websites, Bloomberg
  • 30. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 30 84,400 ounces at the end of the month. Based on the increase in total open interest over this time it is most likely that market participants rolled their positions into future months. Open interest in the nearby active March Comex contract was at 2.3 million ounces on 4 December, up from 2.2 million ounces at the end of November. Palladium delivered via the December Nymex con- tract totaled 77,600 ounces as of 5 December. Nymex registered inventories were unchanged at 531,100 ounces during the first 5 days of the December. Net long positions held by large non-commercial market participants rose to 1.36 million ounces on 27 November, the highest level that net long positions have been at since August 2011. On 2 August 2011, net long positions had reached 1.72 million ounces. The increase in net long positions, which were at 892,900 ounces at the end of October, was driven by a combination of an increase in gross long positions and a decline in gross short positions. Gross long po- sitions reached 1.61 million ounces on 27 November, the highest level since 2 August 2011 when they were at 1.9 million ounces. Gross shorts also declined during November, slipping to 252,700 ounces on 27 November from 439,500 ounces at the end of Octo- ber. Palladium Markets Palladium Prices, Total Open Interest, and Nymex Inventories Gross Long and Short Positions of Non-Commercial Positions Daily, Through 5 December 2012 Nymex Palladium Futures &Options. Weekly Data, Through 27 November 2012 $ / Oz Mln Ozs '000 Ozs '000 Ozs 900 3.0 2,000 2,000 1,800 1,800 800 1,600 Long 1,600 2.5 1,400 1,400 700 Prices (Left scale) 1,200 1,200 2.0 1,000 Net Position in Nymex 1,000 600 800 800 500 1.5 600 600 400 400 400 200 200 Open 1.0 0 0 Interest 300 -200 -200 0.5 -400 -400 200 -600 -600 Nymex Stocks Short -800 -800 100 0.0 -1,000 -1,000 D-02 S-03 J-04M-05M-06J-07 N-07 S-08 J-09 A-10F-11 D-11O-12 A-95 S-96 M-98 A-99 O-02 M-04 A-05 J-07 J-08 D-09 M-11 O-12
  • 31. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 31 Palladium Statistical Position Supply 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011e 2012p 2013p Mine Production Russia 3,120 2,737 2,686 2,732 2,714 2,671 2,698 South Africa 2,630 2,447 2,443 2,616 2,638 2,348 2,612 Canada 550 513 229 250 503 539 603 United States 423 394 418 382 407 395 397 Others 539 442 550 571 615 630 632 Total 7,262 6,533 6,326 6,551 6,876 6,583 6,941 % Change Year Ago -2.0% -10.0% -3.2% 3.5% 5.0% -4.3% 5.4% Secondary Supply Total 1,508 1,585 1,347 1,664 1,730 1,791 1,881 % Change Year Ago 7.2% 5.1% -15.0% 23.5% 4.0% 3.5% 5.0% Total Supply 8,770 8,118 7,673 8,214 8,607 8,374 8,822 % Change Year Ago -0.5% -7.4% -5.5% 7.1% 4.8% -2.7% 5.4% Fabrication Demand Electronics 1,200 1,125 1,095 1,179 1,207 1,243 1,284 Automotive 4,545 4,252 3,960 4,656 4,919 5,338 5,688 Dental 776 775 782 784 782 783 779 Other 1,241 1,285 1,206 1,152 1,137 1,133 1,178 Total Demand 7,762 7,437 7,043 7,771 8,045 8,497 8,929 % Change Year Ago 2.1% -4.2% -5.3% 10.3% 3.5% 5.6% 5.1% Net Surplus or Deficit 1,007 681 631 444 561 -123 -108 Price Per Ounce YTD High $389.50 $600.00 $410.00 $804.90 $857.70 $719.75 Low $315.20 $160.30 $176.10 $380.05 $564.15 $561.60 Average $358.28 $352.98 $266.75 $529.11 $733.85 $640.31 % Change Year Ago 10.8% -1.5% -24.4% 98.4% 38.7% -13.5% *Thousand Troy Ounces; Notes: Excludes transitional economies, except as noted. Secondary production statistics exclude toll-refined material. Prices are settlement prices for the active World Palladium Supply and Demand Balance Palladium Quarterly Average Price Projections Thou. Ounces $/Ounce, through Q3 2014 10,000 10,000 9,000 9,000 $1,100 $1,100 Total Supply $1,000 $1,000 8,000 8,000 Total Demand $900 $900 7,000 7,000 $800 $800 6,000 6,000 $700 Actual $700 5,000 5,000 $600 $600 4,000 4,000 $500 P $500 r o 3,000 3,000 $400 j e $400 c t i o 2,000 2,000 $300 n s $300 $200 $200 1,000 1,000 $100 $100 0 0 1999 2002 2005 2008 2011 2014 1976 1981 1986 1991 1996 2001 2006 2011e
  • 32. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 32 Rhodium The Price of Rhodium Rhodium Supply and Demand Monthly Average NY Dealer Price, Through November 2012 Thousand Ounces Thousand Ounces $/Oz $/Oz 1,400 1,400 $10,000 $10,000 $9,000 $9,000 1,200 1,200 Demand $8,000 $8,000 1,000 1,000 $7,000 $7,000 $6,000 $6,000 800 800 $5,000 $5,000 Supply 600 600 $4,000 $4,000 $3,000 $3,000 400 400 $2,000 $2,000 200 200 $1,000 $1,000 $0 $0 0 0 72 75 78 81 84 87 90 93 96 99 02 05 08 11 1976 1981 1986 1991 1996 2001 2006 2011 Rhodium Quarterly Average Price Projections to Q3 2014 $ / Ounce Quarterly Year Quarter Change Annual AVG Change $3,000 $3,000 AVG $2,500 $2,500 2012 IV $1,145 -2.0% $1,276 -25.9% Projections 2013 I $1,120 -2.2% $2,000 $2,000 II $1,193 6.5% Actual $1,500 $1,500 III $1,300 9.0% $1,000 $1,000 IV $1,404 8.0% $1,254 -1.7% 2014 I $1,460 4.0% $500 $500 II $1,387 -5.0% $0 $0 III $1,360 -2.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 Rhodium Exchange Traded Product Holdings Daily, Through 1 December 2012 Ounces Ounces 60,000 60,000 50,000 50,000 40,000 40,000 30,000 30,000 20,000 20,000 10,000 10,000 0 0 May-11 Sep-11 Jan-12 May-12 Sep-12 Note: Metal is stored in the United Kingdom and is the combined holdings of the ETC's two primary listings, the db Physical Rhodium ETC (EUR) traded on the Xetra and Borse Italiano and the db Physical Rhodium ETC traded on the LSE. Source: db, Bloomberg
  • 33. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 33 Precious Metal Price Table Gold Silver Platinum Palladium Rhodium Yr Q Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly Quarterly % % % % % Price Change Price Change Price Change Price Change Price Change 2003 I $353 8.8% $4.67 3.1% $654 11.8% $245 -13.6% $608 -11.4% II $348 -1.4% $4.60 -1.5% $640 -2.1% $171 -30.1% $509 -16.4% III $364 4.7% $5.02 9.1% $693 8.3% $193 12.8% $497 -2.4% IV $393 8.0% $5.30 5.5% $766 10.5% $203 5.0% $476 -4.2% 2004 I $409 4.1% $6.72 26.8% $864 12.9% $245 20.6% $598 25.7% II $394 -3.8% $6.26 -6.8% $830 -4.0% $259 5.9% $773 29.2% III $403 2.3% $6.51 4.0% $837 0.8% $218 -16.1% $1,030 33.3% IV $435 8.1% $7.27 11.8% $850 1.6% $210 -3.5% $1,210 17.5% 2005 I $428 -1.6% $7.00 -3.7% $865 1.8% $191 -9.0% $1,448 19.7% II $429 0.2% $7.17 2.4% $873 0.9% $193 0.9% $1,567 8.2% III $441 2.8% $7.10 -1.0% $899 3.0% $189 -1.8% $2,058 31.3% IV $487 10.5% $8.11 14.2% $962 6.9% $243 28.6% $2,795 35.8% 2006 I $556 14.3% $9.74 20.1% $1,042 8.4% $295 21.2% $3,355 20.0% II $630 13.2% $12.26 25.9% $1,189 14.0% $350 18.6% $4,655 38.7% III $623 -1.2% $11.72 -4.5% $1,223 2.9% $326 -6.7% $4,531 -2.7% IV $608 -2.3% $12.68 8.2% $1,130 -7.6% $325 -0.5% $4,896 8.1% 2007 I $652 7.2% $13.36 5.4% $1,198 6.0% $347 6.9% $5,762 17.7% II $671 2.8% $13.37 0.1% $1,298 8.4% $372 7.1% $5,990 4.0% III $684 2.0% $12.80 -4.3% $1,301 0.2% $352 -5.5% $6,006 0.3% IV $794 16.0% $14.33 12.0% $1,457 12.0% $365 3.9% $6,463 7.6% 2008 I $928 17.0% $11.79 -17.8% $1,889 29.6% $451 23.5% $8,069 24.9% II $898 -3.2% $17.20 45.9% $2,037 7.9% $449 -0.5% $9,275 14.9% III $870 -3.2% $14.97 -13.0% $1,532 -24.8% $328 -27.0% $6,277 -32.3% IV $795 -8.6% $10.18 -32.0% $871 -43.2% $192 -41.4% $1,424 -77.3% 2009 I $910 14.5% $12.64 24.1% $1,030 18.3% $201 4.4% $1,060 -25.6% II $924 1.5% $13.75 8.9% $1,179 14.4% $236 17.6% $1,283 21.0% III $962 4.1% $14.77 0.4% $1,239 5.2% $276 16.8% $1,523 18.7% IV $1,101 14.4% $17.58 19.0% $1,400 13.0% $351 27.5% $2,045 34.3% 2010 I $1,110 0.9% $16.92 -3.7% $1,562 11.6% $441 25.4% $2,440 19.3% II $1,197 7.9% $18.36 8.5% $1,634 4.6% $496 12.5% $2,592 6.2% III $1,228 2.5% $19.00 3.5% $1,556 -4.8% $496 0.1% $2,204 -15.0% IV $1,369 11.5% $25.59 34.7% $1,701 9.3% $679 36.8% $2,329 5.7% 2011 I $1,386 1.2% $31.74 24.0% $1,797 5.6% $793 16.8% $2,436 4.6% II $1,507 8.7% $38.42 21.1% $1,788 -0.5% $761 -4.0% $2,179 -10.6% III $1,700 12.8% $38.86 1.1% $1,774 -0.7% $755 -0.8% $1,894 -13.1% IV $1,686 -0.8% $31.84 -18.0% $1,534 -13.5% $631 -16.3% $1,588 -16.1% 2012p I $1,693 0.4% $32.72 2.8% $1,613 5.1% $685 8.5% $1,462 -8.0% II $1,622 -4.2% $29.47 -10.0% $1,503 -6.9% $629 -8.1% $1,328 -9.2% III $1,657 2.1% $30.08 2.1% $1,505 0.2% $615 -2.3% $1,168 -12.0% IV $1,726 4.2% $32.99 9.7% $1,604 6.5% $640 4.1% $1,145 -2.0% 2013p I $1,718 -0.4% $33.28 0.9% $1,615 0.7% $632 -1.3% $1,120 -2.2% II $1,667 -3.0% $30.62 -8.0% $1,567 -3.0% $638 1.0% $1,193 6.5% III $1,608 -3.5% $29.40 -4.0% $1,527 -2.5% $625 -2.0% $1,300 9.0% IV $1,641 2.0% $30.28 3.0% $1,634 7.0% $678 8.5% $1,404 8.0% 2014p I $1,673 2.0% $31.49 4.0% $1,693 3.6% $722 6.4% $1,460 4.0% II $1,623 -3.0% $31.17 -1.0% $1,719 1.5% $738 2.2% $1,387 -5.0% III $1,599 -1.5% $29.30 -6.0% $1,658 -3.5% $710 -3.7% $1,360 -2.0%
  • 34. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 34 Precious Metals Equities Financial Performance One Month One Year Price 52 Week Range P/E Dividend Yield % December 6, 2012 % Change % Change South African Gold Finance Houses US$ AngloGold Ashanti 30.29 -9.1% -34.1% 380.20/251.99 11.43 0.22 0.5% Gold Fields 11.47 -7.4% -30.7% 139.13/95.51 9.41 0.21 1.4% Harmony Gold Mining Co. Ltd. 7.51 -4.7% -45.5% 115.95/64.10 13.70 0.07 0.5% Randgold & Exploration Co. 102.77 -13.4% -1.7% 78.92/44.80 22.35 0.20 0.2% North American Gold Mining Companies US$ Agnico-Eagle 53.06 -3.4% 22.0% 57.35/31.42 NM 0.64 1.0% Barrick Gold 33.43 -6.0% -34.7% 51.81/31.00 0.00 0.48 1.0% Goldcorp 36.82 -16.5% -29.3% 52.55/31.54 19.59 0.41 0.8% Kinross Gold 9.63 2.9% -30.4% 13.98/7.11 0.00 0.10 0.6% Yamana Gold 17.73 -9.9% 8.7% 20.61/12.76 37.13 0.18 1.4% International Multi-Metal Companies US$ BHP 36.12 -0.5% -3.8% 38.25/30.09 12.21 0.92 1.9% Rio Tinto PLC 52.02 2.2% -0.4% 40.29/26.48 23.11 1.26 1.8% Australian Gold Mining Companies US$ Newcrest Mining Ltd. 25.30 -7.1% -27.2% 36.10/20.89 16.53 0.27 0.7% Silver Mining Companies US$ Coeur d'Alene Mines Corp. 22.06 -8.5% -23.6% 31.97/15.15 91.84 0.00 0.0% Compania de Minas Buenaventura S.A. 33.09 -5.3% -12.9% 43.90/30.86 10.88 0.49 1.3% Industrias Peñoles S.A. de C.V. 49.70 -0.6% 8.2% 694.50/504.05 29.27 1.58 4.2% Pan American Silver Corp. 18.08 -15.8% -26.4% 26.78/13.79 11.13 0.10 0.3% Silver Standard Resources Inc. 13.58 -7.0% -5.2% 18.14/10.18 33.31 0.00 0.0% Platinum Mining Companies US$ Adriana Resources 0.38 -17.2% -59.6% 1.38/0.38 NM 0.00 0.0% Anglo American Platinum Corp. 47.70 3.5% -30.3% 598.50/358.74 NM 1.01 1.1% Aquarius Platinum (A$) 0.68 -0.9% -76.2% 2.88/0.48 NM 0.08 1.6% Eurasia Mining plc. (£) 0.01 0.6% -26.3% 0.01/0.00 NM 0.00 0.0% Jubilee Platinum (£) 0.12 -7.2% -43.2% 0.18/0.07 NM 0.00 0.0% Impala Platinum 17.51 -3.0% -18.0% 180.83/123.47 22.06 0.62 2.3% North American Palladium 1.41 -7.5% -56.2% 3.34/1.28 NM 0.00 0.0% Pacific North West Capital (C$) 0.05 -8.7% -57.4% 0.17/0.05 NM 0.00 0.0% Stillwater Mining Company 11.29 3.5% -2.9% 15.24/7.47 22.47 0.00 0.0% Trend Mining Company 0.00 0.0% -66.7% 0.01/0.00 NM 0.00 0.0% Zimplats (A$) 8.61 1.3% -24.8% 12.00/7.50 7.38 0.00 0.0% Notes: NM-Not Meaningful. NE-No earnings; Source Capital IQ, Bloomberg.
  • 35. Precious Metals Advisory 6 December 2012 Page 35 Market Metrics Metals Markets Indices November O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year November O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year Gold $1,721.82 $1,746.08 $1,745.50 -1.4% Nasdaq 3,010 2,977 2,620 14.9% Silver $33.20 $32.32 $32.41 2.5% DJIA 13,026 13,096 12,046 8.1% Platinum $1,604.60 $1,577.00 $1,560.80 2.8% S&P 510 1,416 1,412 1,247 13.6% Palladium $686.25 $609.80 $610.00 12.5% FT World Stock 383 379 345 10.9% Rhodium $1,125.00 $1,125.00 $1,625.00 -30.8% U.S. T -bills 0.08% 0.11% 0.02% 400.0% Iridium $1,050.00 $1,050.00 $1,085.00 -3.2% U.S. 10 Yr Notes 1.62% 1.69% 2.07% -21.9% Ruthenium $90.00 $110.00 $120.00 -25.0% $-Euro Interest Rate -0.12% -0.09% -1.46% -92.0% Osmium $350.00 $350.00 $350.00 0.0% Differential CRB Commodity Index 299.0 295.8 313.8 -4.7% Economist Commodity* Currencies Dollar Index 187.2 187.5 178.2 5.1% November O ctober November '11 % ?1-Year Euro Index 180.0 179.6 166.2 8.3% $/Euro 1.30 1.30 1.35 -3.7% FT Gold Mines Index 2,919 3,211 3,898 -25.1% Japanese Yen/$ 82.48 79.77 77.60 2.8% XAU Gold & Silver Equity 170.2 188.3 208.3 -18.3% $/British Pound 1.60 1.61 1.57 2.69% T remont Man. Futures U.S. T W$ N/A 98.96 99.52 -0.6% Account Index, Return -0.1% -2.3% 0.52% N/A Oil (Nymex CL) $88.91 $92.19 $100.36 -11.4% *Base year was adjusted to 2005 from 2000 Real GDP Consumer Prices Interest Rates Money Supply Monetary Reserves ($BN) Industrial Prod. 2012 2011 2012 2011 2012 2012 2012 2011 2012 3Q 3Q O ctober O ctober Latest Latest March March Latest United States 2.7% 1.3% 0.1% 0.0% 0.10% 13.1% $51.1 $54.2 1.7% Eurozone -0.1% 0.1% 0.2% 0.4% -0.02% 6.0% $208.1 $210.7 -2.3% United Kingdom 1.0% 0.6% 0.5% 0.1% 0.35% 4.3% $58.7 $57.0 0.0% Japan -0.9% 2.3% 0.0% 0.1% 0.00% 3.2% $1,211.0 $1,058.1 -1.5% China 7.7% 9.5% -0.1% 0.1% 6.00% 6.1% $3,305.0 $3,145.8 10.0% India 5.3% 6.7% 9.6% 9.4% 8.00% 8.1% $260.1 $282.0 -0.4% Notes: Gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and copper nearby active Comex or Nymex. Minor PGMs are Metals Week dealer prices; Interest rates are 3-month money market rates for the U.S., Euro,U.K.,and Japan; Interest rates are one-year rates for China & India; $-Euro interest rate differential is the spread between rates available on the 90-day government notes of each; Money supply is percent change from previous year; Money supply is M1, UK is M0; Monetary reserves excluding gold; NA - Not Available.