Creating Executive Support
for Marketing Initiatives
JOHN DOHERTY
John Doherty
Senior Consultant, Distilled NYC
John.doherty@distilled.net
@dohertyjf
Today we’re talking about
Boss or Client Management
Proving ROI is our #1 challenge
@dohertyjfSource: http://dis.tl/1124N0v
Procuring Budget is #2
@dohertyjfSource: http://dis.tl/1124N0v
Your job is not to deliver
reports.
Your job is to effect change.
SEO is easy, but causing
change is hard.
Most SEOs
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
A Few Words About Your
Boss/Client
They’re not idiots.
This is my boss. He’s actually quite
smart.
They’re human too.
I said human.
You need to understand
Who makes the budget decisions?
What are their motivators?
What are the key company metrics?
What are the company’s goals?
Your Responsibilities
“[See] your offering as your
market sees it - not as you
see it.”
Matt Gratt
http://www.quora.com/Marketing/What-is-the-
hardest-part-about-being-a-marketer/answer/Matt-
Gratt?srid=5pX&share=1
Help Execs Prioritize
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
At any point in time,
you have many
initiatives. Which
ones will have the
biggest impact on the
metrics your bosses
care about?
Present Hard Data
@dohertyjfAnd what that means.
Compelling Business Case
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
If we increase traffic X%,
we can make $X,XXX per
month.
This is music to a Director’s ears.
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
If we increase traffic X%,
we can make $X,XXX per
month.
This is music to a Director’s ears.
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
The “Why”
Think Big, Start Small
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Think Big, Start Small
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Big Dreams
Highest Impact
Initiative
Speak Their Language
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
If you walk into a room
talking about linking root
domains and
infographics, you will
fail. If you talk the
metrics they care about
and your high level
plans, you’ll most likely
succeed.
How do we make a case for
what we need?
Psychology
@dohertyjfhttps://twitter.com/neyne/status/335443057749159936
The Right Metrics
@dohertyjfAll valid metrics, depending on who you’re reporting to.
Hard Comparison Data
@dohertyjfThe Price of Technical SEO Debt
Them
Us
Hard and Honest Projections
@dohertyjfThe Price of Technical SEO Debt
Psychology
Goal: Make It Easy To Say Yes
@dohertyjfhttp://okdork.com/2012/10/09/make-it-easy-to-say-yes/l
“What Are *Your* Goals?”
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
The best way to learn what your boss/client wants to hear is to ask them
their goals.
Then you can pitch for what you want using the metrics they will resonate
with.
“What can I show you that will make you say yes?”
“Can you show me examples of reports you like?”
High Risk/Low Risk
@dohertyjfGet Executive Management Approval
Low risk are either proven as “fundamentals”
and best practices, or have proven valuable for
your company in the past.
High risk are tasks that are either expensive up
front, or have no quantifiable ROI before you
complete them.
High Risk/Low Risk 80/20 Rule
@dohertyjfPareto Principle
You can ask for about 20% of your resources for high risk initiatives. 80%
of your resources are dedicated towards the activities that you know
work.
Wouldn’t it be awesome if we could dedicate 80% of our efforts towards
new initiatives?
High Risk/Low Risk
@dohertyjf
Low Risk/Low Impact is easy to
pitch and get approval for, but
will not move the needle
significantly.
High Risk/High Impact is
harder to say yes to, and
should be pitched after
success is shown
Impact
Risk
Low Risk/High Impact is the
sweet spot, as it’s easy to say
YES and will move the needle.
High Risk/Low Impact is
not a good case to pitch.
John Doherty
Data
“Every good argument
begins with data.”
Abraham Lincoln
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Revenue Tracking in Analytics
provides important numbers
@dohertyjfEcommerce Tracking for Google in GA
CRO
Revenue Tracking in Analytics
provides important numbers
@dohertyjfEcommerce Tracking for Google in GA
CRO
SEO
Direct vs Influenced
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Direct vs Influenced
@dohertyjf
Show this to your execs to get buy-in for more
work, but have exact numbers prepared as well.
Direct vs Influenced
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Don’t just pitch SEO initiatives though. Use this to
get things done internally.
A Few More Psychological
Examples
Competitor Data Inspires Action
@dohertyjfInbound Marketing Competitor Analysis
Negative Numbers Inspire Action
@dohertyjf
Negative Numbers Inspire Action
@dohertyjf
Never be accusatory/assign blame to your boss
for inaction. Instead, show your strategy for
moving forward.
Previous Success Inspires Action
@dohertyjfInbound Marketing Competitor Analysis
Internal Case Studies
@dohertyjfPitch and pitch again
Comparisons
@dohertyjfIf we don’t do X, then….
Comparisons
@dohertyjfIf we don’t do X, then….
Case Study
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjfThe links were extremely low quality
About 50% of their
backlink profile was
links from sites with
a Domain Authority
of under 20. They
were hit repeatedly
by algorithm
changes.
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjf
http://www.johnfdoherty.com/paid-links-backlink-profile-
visualized/
Free-submit-url-seo.biz
http://pub20.bravenet.com/f
reelink
http://www.txtlinks.com
http://allcladdagh.com/newli
nks21.htm
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjf
One of their sites that
brought in ~10% of their
revenue was hit with a
manual link penalty. CEO
was keen to avoid this on
others.
Tip: Negative case studies
can be very powerful when
you want someone to do
something.
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjfThe goal was better links and to prove content works.
I pitched them on doing
a piece of high quality
content. These are the
links we got.
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjfLinks were much better.
I pitched them on doing
a piece of high quality
content. These are the
links we got.
DA90
DA89
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjf
Their backlink profile
has leveled out.
This is old.
Client Had Been Buying Links
@dohertyjf
And their organic traffic is up almost 100% in a year and a half. We now
have buy-in to do 4 more big pieces of content.
Pitch A Test
Metrics
Some Metrics Are Standard
@dohertyjf
Some Are Not
@dohertyjf
https://twitter.com/randfish/status/33381936123832729
6
Metrics Marketers Report On
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
YoY Increase in Traffic
Direct Conversions by Channel
Influenced Conversions by
Channel
Competitor Trends
Metrics Marketers Report On
@dohertyjf
YoY Increase in Traffic
Direct Conversions by Channel
Influenced Conversions by
Channel
Competitor Trends
“What metrics does
your boss care
about?”
Projections
Creating Good Projections
@dohertyjf
((Metric Increase)*(Conversion %)*(Value Per
Visit)) – ((hours)*(hourly rate))
SEO Projections
@dohertyjf
((Potential Traffic) *(Value Per Visit)) –
((hours)*(hourly rate))
Your best data comes from your own
Analytics.
@dohertyjfEcommerce Tracking for Google in GA
Example
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Client wants to grow their site by $250k in
revenue this year. They convert at 1.71% from
organic traffic at $5.68/visit.
$250,000 = 44,000 new
visitors.
Example
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Client wants to grow their site by $250k in
revenue this year. They convert at 1.71% from
organic traffic at $5.68/visit.
$250,000 = 44,000 new
visitors.
Is this possible?
Example
@dohertyjfWhat Channels Convert Best (GA Page)
We need some help.
How You Pitch or Deliver
Work Makes A Difference
Primary Point of Contact
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Email – gets things done quickly, builds trust
Spreadsheets with documents for communicating data
Phone calls to answer questions a few days later (also keeps your
recommendations top of mind)
Director Level
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Powerpoint for presenting a business case
Phone calls and meetings for followup
Clear call to action at the end (even if none)
Executive Suite
@dohertyjfJohn Doherty
Powerpoint - for presenting a business case
PRESENT IN PERSON
Clear the presentation with your POC/Director first.
In Conclusion
Thanks.
Any questions?
JOHN DOHERTY
John.doherty@distilled.net
@dohertyjf

More Related Content

PDF
SearchLove Boston 2013_Mack Fogelson_Think Differently
PDF
Enabling and Celebrating The DOers
PDF
THE PROFITABLE AGENCY [INBOUND 2014]
PPTX
The Myths of Big Data
PDF
2019-08 Digital Marketing Tools - August 2019
PDF
State of SEO: The Top Opportunities & Risks for the Next 12 Months
PDF
The Role of Online Building Product Directories for Marketing
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2017 | Rhea Drysdale | Reputation Marketing Tactics to Driv...
SearchLove Boston 2013_Mack Fogelson_Think Differently
Enabling and Celebrating The DOers
THE PROFITABLE AGENCY [INBOUND 2014]
The Myths of Big Data
2019-08 Digital Marketing Tools - August 2019
State of SEO: The Top Opportunities & Risks for the Next 12 Months
The Role of Online Building Product Directories for Marketing
SearchLove Boston 2017 | Rhea Drysdale | Reputation Marketing Tactics to Driv...

What's hot (20)

PDF
Webinar how to scale a dream sales team
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2017 | Kirsty Hulse | Content Marketing: Work Less and Win ...
PPTX
Moz: A New Beginning
PDF
Wil Reynolds - What Happens When An ‘SEO Guy’ Starts Doing PPC?
PDF
10 Most Common Website & Marketing Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
PDF
How to Become an OpenCompany
PDF
Chris Shedd - Thought Leadership Disrupted: New Rules for the Content Age
DOCX
Chad Carlisle Good Production
PDF
Cliff Seal - Death to Boring B2B Marketing: Driving Innovation with Design Th...
PDF
Brighton SEO July 2021 Presentation
PDF
The Importance of A/B Testing
PDF
5 Content-First Marketing Steps to Jurassic Conversion
PDF
Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Marketing Automation
PDF
Blueprint for High Performing B2B Marketing Campaigns
PDF
9 inbound marketing insights revealed 2014
PDF
Hacking Inbound: 25+ Proven B2B Lead Generation Campaigns and Quick Wins
PDF
90 min adwords startup - Q3 2013 update
PDF
Marketingsherpa Top 5 Lead Gen Case Studies
PDF
Myth-Busting Personalization in the Candidate Experience
PDF
Site speed for in-house marketers | BrightonSEO
Webinar how to scale a dream sales team
SearchLove Boston 2017 | Kirsty Hulse | Content Marketing: Work Less and Win ...
Moz: A New Beginning
Wil Reynolds - What Happens When An ‘SEO Guy’ Starts Doing PPC?
10 Most Common Website & Marketing Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)
How to Become an OpenCompany
Chris Shedd - Thought Leadership Disrupted: New Rules for the Content Age
Chad Carlisle Good Production
Cliff Seal - Death to Boring B2B Marketing: Driving Innovation with Design Th...
Brighton SEO July 2021 Presentation
The Importance of A/B Testing
5 Content-First Marketing Steps to Jurassic Conversion
Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Marketing Automation
Blueprint for High Performing B2B Marketing Campaigns
9 inbound marketing insights revealed 2014
Hacking Inbound: 25+ Proven B2B Lead Generation Campaigns and Quick Wins
90 min adwords startup - Q3 2013 update
Marketingsherpa Top 5 Lead Gen Case Studies
Myth-Busting Personalization in the Candidate Experience
Site speed for in-house marketers | BrightonSEO
Ad

Viewers also liked (12)

PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Eppie Vojt_Scaling Outreach
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Wil Reynolds_How we Get Unstuck
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Dr Pete_Do It Yourself Data Driven Content
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Kate MorrisInternational seo
PDF
The Mighty Nudge: The Future of SEO, Social Media, & Content Marketing
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Bill Slawski_Future Search
PPTX
Using unicode with php
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Phil Nottingham_Leveraging video for links
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Ross Hudgens_Actionable Content Marketing Tips
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2013_Abby Covert_Search is the Front Door to UX
PPTX
The Future of Search - Will Critchlow's presentation at FODM 2013
PPTX
SearchLove Boston 2013_Will Critchlow_Technical SEO
SearchLove Boston 2013_Eppie Vojt_Scaling Outreach
SearchLove Boston 2013_Wil Reynolds_How we Get Unstuck
SearchLove Boston 2013_Dr Pete_Do It Yourself Data Driven Content
SearchLove Boston 2013_Kate MorrisInternational seo
The Mighty Nudge: The Future of SEO, Social Media, & Content Marketing
SearchLove Boston 2013_Bill Slawski_Future Search
Using unicode with php
SearchLove Boston 2013_Phil Nottingham_Leveraging video for links
SearchLove Boston 2013_Ross Hudgens_Actionable Content Marketing Tips
SearchLove Boston 2013_Abby Covert_Search is the Front Door to UX
The Future of Search - Will Critchlow's presentation at FODM 2013
SearchLove Boston 2013_Will Critchlow_Technical SEO
Ad

Similar to SearchLove Boston 2013_John Doherty_Creating executive support for marketing initiatives (20)

PDF
Search Engine Results: The Best Measure?
PDF
SEO Tactics, Fanbase Management, and Trends to watch
PDF
Five Trends to Leverage
PPTX
Megacomm - Data Analytics for Business Results
PDF
Crafting a Marketing Career on Your Terms in a Rapidly Changing Business Worl...
PDF
B2B Inbound Marketing: Top Tactics, Goals, and Challenges
PPTX
No Nonsense Content Marketing - MNsearch 2017 - Slideshare
PDF
5 Steps to Creating an Actionable Content Marketing Strategy
PDF
Webinar: Tools for Modern Marketing
PDF
Five Digital Marketing Steps to Dominate Online Like A Superhero
PDF
Digital Evolution in B2B marketing
PPT
Tavant4Pak Webinar WebAnalytics Aug192010
PPT
Google Analytics Joomla Chicago 200905
PDF
The Future Of B2B Marketing / By @TheCoolestCool
PPTX
How To Measure The ROI of Content Marketing
PPTX
7 Marketing Automation Strategies That Actually Drive Business Results
PPTX
How to Prove Marketing ROI: Overcoming Digital Marketing Challenges
PPT
Websitelately
PPTX
Get Your Marketing Noticed Now – And Get Real Results!
PDF
Business & Marketing Fundamentals
Search Engine Results: The Best Measure?
SEO Tactics, Fanbase Management, and Trends to watch
Five Trends to Leverage
Megacomm - Data Analytics for Business Results
Crafting a Marketing Career on Your Terms in a Rapidly Changing Business Worl...
B2B Inbound Marketing: Top Tactics, Goals, and Challenges
No Nonsense Content Marketing - MNsearch 2017 - Slideshare
5 Steps to Creating an Actionable Content Marketing Strategy
Webinar: Tools for Modern Marketing
Five Digital Marketing Steps to Dominate Online Like A Superhero
Digital Evolution in B2B marketing
Tavant4Pak Webinar WebAnalytics Aug192010
Google Analytics Joomla Chicago 200905
The Future Of B2B Marketing / By @TheCoolestCool
How To Measure The ROI of Content Marketing
7 Marketing Automation Strategies That Actually Drive Business Results
How to Prove Marketing ROI: Overcoming Digital Marketing Challenges
Websitelately
Get Your Marketing Noticed Now – And Get Real Results!
Business & Marketing Fundamentals

More from Distilled (20)

PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Will Critchlow - Misunderstood Concepts at the Heart...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Stacey MacNaught - Actioning Search Intent: What to ...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Lindsay Wassell - Managing Multinational & Multiling...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Dr. Pete Meyers - Scaling Keyword Research: More Isn...
PDF
SearchLoveLondon 2019 - Faisal Anderson - Spying on Google: Using Log File An...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Rory Truesdale - Using the SERPs to Know Your Audience
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Rand Fishkin - The Search Landscape in 2019
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Jes Scholtz - Giving Robots an All Access Pass
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Heather Physioc - Building a Discoverability Powerhouse
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Andi Jarvis - The Science of Persuasion
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Luke Carthy - Finding Powerful CRO and UX Opportunit...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Greg Gifford - Doc Brown's Plutonium-powered Local S...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Sarah Gurbach - Using Qualitative Data to Make Human...
PDF
SearchLove London 2019 - Marie Haynes - Practical Tips for Improving E-A-T
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Rand Fishkin - Building Influence in 2019
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Courtney Cox Wakefield - Voice Search and Instant An...
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Tom Anthony - Search in 2020: Technologies That Will...
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Derek Gleason - Benchmarking Success for Client Site...
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Kameron Jenkins - The Modern Search Writer’s Toolkit
PDF
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Joy Hawkins - 10 Ways to Get Results with Local SEO
SearchLove London 2019 - Will Critchlow - Misunderstood Concepts at the Heart...
SearchLove London 2019 - Stacey MacNaught - Actioning Search Intent: What to ...
SearchLove London 2019 - Lindsay Wassell - Managing Multinational & Multiling...
SearchLove London 2019 - Dr. Pete Meyers - Scaling Keyword Research: More Isn...
SearchLoveLondon 2019 - Faisal Anderson - Spying on Google: Using Log File An...
SearchLove London 2019 - Rory Truesdale - Using the SERPs to Know Your Audience
SearchLove London 2019 - Rand Fishkin - The Search Landscape in 2019
SearchLove London 2019 - Jes Scholtz - Giving Robots an All Access Pass
SearchLove London 2019 - Heather Physioc - Building a Discoverability Powerhouse
SearchLove London 2019 - Andi Jarvis - The Science of Persuasion
SearchLove London 2019 - Luke Carthy - Finding Powerful CRO and UX Opportunit...
SearchLove London 2019 - Greg Gifford - Doc Brown's Plutonium-powered Local S...
SearchLove London 2019 - Sarah Gurbach - Using Qualitative Data to Make Human...
SearchLove London 2019 - Marie Haynes - Practical Tips for Improving E-A-T
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Rand Fishkin - Building Influence in 2019
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Courtney Cox Wakefield - Voice Search and Instant An...
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Tom Anthony - Search in 2020: Technologies That Will...
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Derek Gleason - Benchmarking Success for Client Site...
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Kameron Jenkins - The Modern Search Writer’s Toolkit
SearchLove Boston 2019 - Joy Hawkins - 10 Ways to Get Results with Local SEO

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
The-Future-of-Automotive-Quality-is-Here-AI-Driven-Engineering.pdf
PDF
Dell Pro Micro: Speed customer interactions, patient processing, and learning...
PDF
IT-ITes Industry bjjbnkmkhkhknbmhkhmjhjkhj
PDF
Transform-Your-Streaming-Platform-with-AI-Driven-Quality-Engineering.pdf
PDF
Rapid Prototyping: A lecture on prototyping techniques for interface design
PDF
Aug23rd - Mulesoft Community Workshop - Hyd, India.pdf
PDF
The-2025-Engineering-Revolution-AI-Quality-and-DevOps-Convergence.pdf
PPTX
Module 1 Introduction to Web Programming .pptx
PDF
Improvisation in detection of pomegranate leaf disease using transfer learni...
PDF
Convolutional neural network based encoder-decoder for efficient real-time ob...
PDF
Data Virtualization in Action: Scaling APIs and Apps with FME
PDF
EIS-Webinar-Regulated-Industries-2025-08.pdf
PPTX
AI-driven Assurance Across Your End-to-end Network With ThousandEyes
PPTX
agenticai-neweraofintelligence-250529192801-1b5e6870.pptx
PDF
Introduction to MCP and A2A Protocols: Enabling Agent Communication
PPTX
MuleSoft-Compete-Deck for midddleware integrations
PDF
Accessing-Finance-in-Jordan-MENA 2024 2025.pdf
PDF
INTERSPEECH 2025 「Recent Advances and Future Directions in Voice Conversion」
PPTX
Internet of Everything -Basic concepts details
PDF
A hybrid framework for wild animal classification using fine-tuned DenseNet12...
The-Future-of-Automotive-Quality-is-Here-AI-Driven-Engineering.pdf
Dell Pro Micro: Speed customer interactions, patient processing, and learning...
IT-ITes Industry bjjbnkmkhkhknbmhkhmjhjkhj
Transform-Your-Streaming-Platform-with-AI-Driven-Quality-Engineering.pdf
Rapid Prototyping: A lecture on prototyping techniques for interface design
Aug23rd - Mulesoft Community Workshop - Hyd, India.pdf
The-2025-Engineering-Revolution-AI-Quality-and-DevOps-Convergence.pdf
Module 1 Introduction to Web Programming .pptx
Improvisation in detection of pomegranate leaf disease using transfer learni...
Convolutional neural network based encoder-decoder for efficient real-time ob...
Data Virtualization in Action: Scaling APIs and Apps with FME
EIS-Webinar-Regulated-Industries-2025-08.pdf
AI-driven Assurance Across Your End-to-end Network With ThousandEyes
agenticai-neweraofintelligence-250529192801-1b5e6870.pptx
Introduction to MCP and A2A Protocols: Enabling Agent Communication
MuleSoft-Compete-Deck for midddleware integrations
Accessing-Finance-in-Jordan-MENA 2024 2025.pdf
INTERSPEECH 2025 「Recent Advances and Future Directions in Voice Conversion」
Internet of Everything -Basic concepts details
A hybrid framework for wild animal classification using fine-tuned DenseNet12...

SearchLove Boston 2013_John Doherty_Creating executive support for marketing initiatives

Editor's Notes

  • #71: Potential Revenue*Potential Traffic/(hours)*(hourly rate)
  • #72: Potential Revenue*Potential Traffic/(hours)*(hourly rate)