Value Discussion and Professional Positioning of Rotary
Rotary International Convention
1-5 June 2019 – Hamburg, Germany
Break-out-Session – 4 June 2019
Education and avoiding intercultural conflicts using Rotarian ethics
President – Ties Möckelmann – Rotary Club Lüneburg – TMGes@t-online.de
Preliminary note
In 2007, the German council of governors declared: "Rotary is a community of
values". At conferences, in the Rotary Magazine, but above all in the clubs
themselves, the importance of moral values for the self-understanding, the
togetherness and the activities of the Rotarian community has been intensively
discussed ever since. RC Lüneburg has also set up a value committee that deals
with the ethical foundations of Rotary and that in this paper inspires a return to
the ideas that led to the founding of Rotary.
The challenge
Rotary can look back on a unique track record. More than 1.2 million people from
different professions are involved in more than 30,000 clubs around the world; a
lively exchange in the clubs, districts and in the international organization creates
friendship and promotes international understanding; Diverse local and
international community service projects strengthen educational projects and
cultural infrastructure, help those in need or support medical care worldwide.
However, this success concept has been copied so frequently that Rotary is barely
different from many other interest groups and clubs, all of whom strive equally to
interest the personalities of our society and to attract new members.
As a consequence of this
• Rotary is losing more and more members in core countries. The organization no
longer seems attractive enough to inspire people for their goals and to gather
their friends once a week at the Rotary table;
• removes the identification with the organization. Fewer and fewer members
proudly wear the Rotary Needle or publicly recognize themselves as Rotarians;
• talented young people are increasingly reluctant to question organizations such
as Rotary and question what is the guiding idea of an organization for which they
are committed;
• increasingly suffers Rotary togetherness. The presence in the weekly meetings is
steadily decreasing, which permanently undermines the Rotarian friendship;
• gaining membership becomes more difficult. In the past, it was a great privilege
to be addressed by Rotary, but now the cancellations are piling up;
• the reputation of Rotary - unlike that of organizations with a clear focus on
content such as Unicef, Greenpeace or Amnesty International - is low in the
public;
• In its national donation ranking, Rotary is not even among the top one hundred
nonprofit organizations. Hardly any member today would get the idea to override
Rotary's personal estate.
(for example, see "Strategic Plan 2014 Survey" at:
my.rotary.org/en/document/strategic-plan-survey-results-2017)
Causes for this development
When Paul Harris and his associates founded the first Rotary Club in Chicago in
1905, they immediately saw the excesses of rampant capitalism. Unrestrained
egoism and stormy growth threatened to disrupt the normative bond of society.
Against this background, the founding fathers of Rotary developed the idea to
assemble morally integrity personalities from different professional groups who
want to serve the common good in mutual solidarity. The daily actions of the
Rotarians should be based on the values in their profession and society, which
were formulated in 1932 by Herbert Taylor in the Four-Question-Trial.
After the Second World War, however, the founding idea of Rotary was
increasingly understood as a "charity". Now, donations and active assistance
should be used to fund projects primarily in the social and educational fields. By
contrast, the original idea that Rotarians serve the common good by orienting
their daily work and social life to moral values and thus acting exemplary in
society has taken a back seat.
The fact that Rotary is losing its radiance today, getting bogged down in countless
unspecific support projects, having difficulties in gaining interesting new members
and scarcely motivating its current members for its Rotary goals, seems to have
its roots here.
Opportunities for Rotary
By contrast, the founding idea of Rotary has lost nothing of its relevance. On the
contrary, in a world where income and wealth inequalities are growing, national
and international conflicts are increasing, and mutual consideration is dwindling,
it is more relevant than ever. A look at the four-question test, which is obligatory
for all Rotarians, makes it clear that Rotary was not originally great
A look at the four-sample test, which is obligatory for all Rotarians, makes it clear
that Rotary was originally not designed primarily as a service club, but as a
community of values. The problems that Rotary was once founded to tackle have
by no means diminished but have been increasingly lost sight of.
Therefore, Rotary does not have to reinvent itself, but instead has to revert to its
founding idea as a community of values. Rotarian friendship should not remain a
mere phrase, but should rest on an ethical foundation. The common good
orientation must not be confused in any sponsored projects, but must be
recognizable in the daily actions of each Rotarian. If Rotary wants to regain its
unmistakable position, the organization must therefore focus on what it was once
founded for: professional ethics. As a union of leaders from the diverse
professions of our society, Rotary is predestined to do so like no other
organization in the world.
Recommendations
A concentration of Rotary on its original core competency, professional ethics,
would have practical consequences. The topics that are already being dealt with
in various funding projects - education, development and health - would have to
be more focused on the Rotary core competence of the profession. The following
examples of professionally oriented Rotary projects show the potential:
Rotary should
• offer local schools to use the expertise of Rotarians as part of their vocational
orientation and professional ethics in teaching or in teaching-intensive projects;
• in youth exchanges, continue to prepare pupils and students for the role of
ambassadors of the Rotarian idea of fighting against selfishness, greed and
corruption through decent work and daily life;
• Organize Ryla seminars with a different understanding of leadership: "Conduct
decency";
• award a Rotary Award, which is awarded for ethically exemplary behavior in
different professions;
• substantiate the intended return by establishing a scientific "Rotary Institute for
Business and Professional Ethics", anchor it in the long term in society and stage it
in publicity.
• All Rotarians are invited to submit further suggestions for the practical
implementation of the ethical refocusing of the organization and the club life.
Result
To increase its attractiveness, to help its members to understand themselves
more clearly, and to better focus their use of resources, Rotary should reflect on
its origins as a community of values. Professional ethics, as a link between diverse
cultures, could help Rotarians to look back on their community with pride and
make the world a little more decent.

More Related Content

PDF
The Rotary Foundation Annual Report 2015-16
PPTX
Rotary orientation power point updated january 22 2013
PPTX
Strategies for Advancing Women in Rotary Leadership
PDF
Rotary Africa - March 2018
PPTX
Increase Rotary's Impact and Reach through Rotary Community Corps Presentation
PPTX
Light Up Rotary Through Vocational Service RD5340 2014-15 District Assembly
PPTX
Effective Inter-Generational Collaboration
PDF
Increase Rotary's Impact and Reach through Rotary Community Corps Handout
The Rotary Foundation Annual Report 2015-16
Rotary orientation power point updated january 22 2013
Strategies for Advancing Women in Rotary Leadership
Rotary Africa - March 2018
Increase Rotary's Impact and Reach through Rotary Community Corps Presentation
Light Up Rotary Through Vocational Service RD5340 2014-15 District Assembly
Effective Inter-Generational Collaboration
Increase Rotary's Impact and Reach through Rotary Community Corps Handout

What's hot (19)

PPT
Rotary Member Recruitment
PPTX
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
PPTX
Fire Up Your Rotaract Club Membership (#Rotaract15)
PDF
Rotary Africa - April 2018
PPTX
Let's Increase Financial Integrity Around the World!
PPTX
Women in Rotary Illuminate
PPT
Rotaract presentation 5-1-10
PPT
Rotary International Ppt Presentation
PDF
Rotary's Areas of Focus_2014 Rotaract Preconvention
PPT
Rotaract Présentation Powerpoint (English)
PPT
How to Start and Sustain Rotaract & Interact Clubs
PDF
Engaging the New Generation of Rotary - Rotary International Convention Toro...
PPTX
Meet Rotary's People of Action: Young Innovators
PPTX
Rotary Club Orientation
PPTX
Paul Harris Society: Rotary's Fast-Growing Donor Group Presentation
PPTX
Rotaract Orientation
PPTX
How to Promote Rotary and Membership: New Ideas
PPTX
Contemporary Rotaract: A Sustainable Rotary Membership Model
PPTX
Strong Projects Strengthen Clubs
Rotary Member Recruitment
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
Fire Up Your Rotaract Club Membership (#Rotaract15)
Rotary Africa - April 2018
Let's Increase Financial Integrity Around the World!
Women in Rotary Illuminate
Rotaract presentation 5-1-10
Rotary International Ppt Presentation
Rotary's Areas of Focus_2014 Rotaract Preconvention
Rotaract Présentation Powerpoint (English)
How to Start and Sustain Rotaract & Interact Clubs
Engaging the New Generation of Rotary - Rotary International Convention Toro...
Meet Rotary's People of Action: Young Innovators
Rotary Club Orientation
Paul Harris Society: Rotary's Fast-Growing Donor Group Presentation
Rotaract Orientation
How to Promote Rotary and Membership: New Ideas
Contemporary Rotaract: A Sustainable Rotary Membership Model
Strong Projects Strengthen Clubs
Ad

Similar to Education and Avoiding Intercultural Conflict Using Rotarian Ethics (20)

PPTX
ROTARY PPT
PPTX
Best Practices in Vocational Service
PPTX
ABC's of RotaryDistrict 6440 March 2018
PPT
Rotary Information
PPTX
Introduction to Rotaract
PDF
Rotary Africa - May 2018
PDF
Rotary Africa Sept 2017
PPTX
New Member Orientation Presentation (1).pptx
PPTX
New Members Orientation (Revised)
PPT
Bringing Vocational Service to Life: Rotary Code of Conduct
PDF
PPTX
Interact Club - Basic
PDF
1 drr july_07_bulletin
PDF
Rotary - 2013 Strengthening Rotary
PPTX
New Members Orientation
PDF
Rotary Basics 3 2010
PDF
Rotary Basics 3 2010
PDF
Engaging the New Generation of Rotary
PDF
Rotary International Volunteers Handbook 2007-2008
PDF
An Introduction to Vocational Service
ROTARY PPT
Best Practices in Vocational Service
ABC's of RotaryDistrict 6440 March 2018
Rotary Information
Introduction to Rotaract
Rotary Africa - May 2018
Rotary Africa Sept 2017
New Member Orientation Presentation (1).pptx
New Members Orientation (Revised)
Bringing Vocational Service to Life: Rotary Code of Conduct
Interact Club - Basic
1 drr july_07_bulletin
Rotary - 2013 Strengthening Rotary
New Members Orientation
Rotary Basics 3 2010
Rotary Basics 3 2010
Engaging the New Generation of Rotary
Rotary International Volunteers Handbook 2007-2008
An Introduction to Vocational Service
Ad

More from Rotary International (20)

PPTX
THE_PROMOTER_-_DRR_TRAINING_PRECON_2022.pptx
PPTX
RIC 22 MDIO Breakout.pptx
PPTX
IC22 Winning Teams - Nicole Peña.pptx
PPTX
DRR Training The Organizer.pptx
PPTX
IC22 Rotaract - Keys to level up your influence_Casas&Guerra (2).pptx
PPTX
Service Ambassadors Presentation.pptx
PPTX
DRR Training_The Trainer 2022.pptx
PPTX
Burnout management.pptx
PPTX
Leadership Development Program Presentation.pptx
PPTX
RI Convention 2022_Rotaract Pre Convention_2022.06.04 NewGen Peacebuilders.pptx
PPTX
IC22 Rotaract Intro to DRR Training.pptx
PPTX
351 930-1020.pptx
PPTX
IC22 Rotaract Precon_Making an Impact Through Rotary Grants.pptx
PPTX
Lets Celebrate Inclusion.pptx
PPTX
IC22 Rotaract Networking Impactful Service Project.pptx
PPTX
Membership Engagement Presentation.pptx
PPTX
Lessons Learned.pptx
PDF
Nurturing Strategic Partnerships.pdf
PPTX
Panel Discussion environment_ (003).pptx
PPTX
General Session June 4.pptx
THE_PROMOTER_-_DRR_TRAINING_PRECON_2022.pptx
RIC 22 MDIO Breakout.pptx
IC22 Winning Teams - Nicole Peña.pptx
DRR Training The Organizer.pptx
IC22 Rotaract - Keys to level up your influence_Casas&Guerra (2).pptx
Service Ambassadors Presentation.pptx
DRR Training_The Trainer 2022.pptx
Burnout management.pptx
Leadership Development Program Presentation.pptx
RI Convention 2022_Rotaract Pre Convention_2022.06.04 NewGen Peacebuilders.pptx
IC22 Rotaract Intro to DRR Training.pptx
351 930-1020.pptx
IC22 Rotaract Precon_Making an Impact Through Rotary Grants.pptx
Lets Celebrate Inclusion.pptx
IC22 Rotaract Networking Impactful Service Project.pptx
Membership Engagement Presentation.pptx
Lessons Learned.pptx
Nurturing Strategic Partnerships.pdf
Panel Discussion environment_ (003).pptx
General Session June 4.pptx

Recently uploaded (20)

PPTX
ISO 9001 awarness for government offices 2015
PPT
4. Goverment Servant (Conduct) Rules, 1964.ppt
PPTX
PPT odisha stete tribal museum OSTM-13.08.25 - Copy.pptx
PPTX
IMPLEMENTING RULES AND REGULATIONS OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 11058 ENTITLED “AN ACT...
PPTX
Unit 3 - Genetic engineering.ppvvxtm.pptx
PPTX
Waste sos management to build robotic sol
PDF
Good-Citizenship-2.pdjshegmjaefhaljfhalfjqfwjhefjlw3r
PPTX
AFP-ORGANIZATION-NEW-MS1 (1).pptx Navy Army and reserve officer andnational
PDF
A Comparative Analysis of Digital Transformation in Public Administration.pdf
PPTX
SlideEgg_66119-Responsible Sourcing.pptx
PPTX
Human_Population_Growth and demographic crisis.pptx
PDF
runhidefightpresentationatacommunity.pdf
PDF
The Varying Effectiveness of Decentralization in Regional Governments
PPTX
ROADMAP AND PATHWAYS TO EXIT AND SUSTAINABILITY.pptx
PDF
Dean, Jodi: Canal House Concept Paper.pdf
PDF
POCSO ACT in India and its implications.
PPTX
Gender, Power Dynamic and Gender Based V
PPTX
KOFC INDOCTRINATION 2025-2026 DISTRICT T-40 PPT 1.pptx
PDF
The Ways The Abhay Bhutada Foundation Is Helping Indian STEM Education
PDF
Europe's Political and Economic, Energy Clouds- September 2025 (Updated Draft)
ISO 9001 awarness for government offices 2015
4. Goverment Servant (Conduct) Rules, 1964.ppt
PPT odisha stete tribal museum OSTM-13.08.25 - Copy.pptx
IMPLEMENTING RULES AND REGULATIONS OF REPUBLIC ACT NO. 11058 ENTITLED “AN ACT...
Unit 3 - Genetic engineering.ppvvxtm.pptx
Waste sos management to build robotic sol
Good-Citizenship-2.pdjshegmjaefhaljfhalfjqfwjhefjlw3r
AFP-ORGANIZATION-NEW-MS1 (1).pptx Navy Army and reserve officer andnational
A Comparative Analysis of Digital Transformation in Public Administration.pdf
SlideEgg_66119-Responsible Sourcing.pptx
Human_Population_Growth and demographic crisis.pptx
runhidefightpresentationatacommunity.pdf
The Varying Effectiveness of Decentralization in Regional Governments
ROADMAP AND PATHWAYS TO EXIT AND SUSTAINABILITY.pptx
Dean, Jodi: Canal House Concept Paper.pdf
POCSO ACT in India and its implications.
Gender, Power Dynamic and Gender Based V
KOFC INDOCTRINATION 2025-2026 DISTRICT T-40 PPT 1.pptx
The Ways The Abhay Bhutada Foundation Is Helping Indian STEM Education
Europe's Political and Economic, Energy Clouds- September 2025 (Updated Draft)

Education and Avoiding Intercultural Conflict Using Rotarian Ethics

  • 1. Value Discussion and Professional Positioning of Rotary Rotary International Convention 1-5 June 2019 – Hamburg, Germany Break-out-Session – 4 June 2019 Education and avoiding intercultural conflicts using Rotarian ethics President – Ties Möckelmann – Rotary Club Lüneburg – [email protected] Preliminary note In 2007, the German council of governors declared: "Rotary is a community of values". At conferences, in the Rotary Magazine, but above all in the clubs themselves, the importance of moral values for the self-understanding, the togetherness and the activities of the Rotarian community has been intensively discussed ever since. RC Lüneburg has also set up a value committee that deals with the ethical foundations of Rotary and that in this paper inspires a return to the ideas that led to the founding of Rotary. The challenge Rotary can look back on a unique track record. More than 1.2 million people from different professions are involved in more than 30,000 clubs around the world; a lively exchange in the clubs, districts and in the international organization creates friendship and promotes international understanding; Diverse local and international community service projects strengthen educational projects and cultural infrastructure, help those in need or support medical care worldwide. However, this success concept has been copied so frequently that Rotary is barely different from many other interest groups and clubs, all of whom strive equally to interest the personalities of our society and to attract new members.
  • 2. As a consequence of this • Rotary is losing more and more members in core countries. The organization no longer seems attractive enough to inspire people for their goals and to gather their friends once a week at the Rotary table; • removes the identification with the organization. Fewer and fewer members proudly wear the Rotary Needle or publicly recognize themselves as Rotarians; • talented young people are increasingly reluctant to question organizations such as Rotary and question what is the guiding idea of an organization for which they are committed; • increasingly suffers Rotary togetherness. The presence in the weekly meetings is steadily decreasing, which permanently undermines the Rotarian friendship; • gaining membership becomes more difficult. In the past, it was a great privilege to be addressed by Rotary, but now the cancellations are piling up; • the reputation of Rotary - unlike that of organizations with a clear focus on content such as Unicef, Greenpeace or Amnesty International - is low in the public; • In its national donation ranking, Rotary is not even among the top one hundred nonprofit organizations. Hardly any member today would get the idea to override Rotary's personal estate. (for example, see "Strategic Plan 2014 Survey" at: my.rotary.org/en/document/strategic-plan-survey-results-2017) Causes for this development When Paul Harris and his associates founded the first Rotary Club in Chicago in 1905, they immediately saw the excesses of rampant capitalism. Unrestrained egoism and stormy growth threatened to disrupt the normative bond of society. Against this background, the founding fathers of Rotary developed the idea to assemble morally integrity personalities from different professional groups who want to serve the common good in mutual solidarity. The daily actions of the Rotarians should be based on the values in their profession and society, which were formulated in 1932 by Herbert Taylor in the Four-Question-Trial. After the Second World War, however, the founding idea of Rotary was increasingly understood as a "charity". Now, donations and active assistance should be used to fund projects primarily in the social and educational fields. By contrast, the original idea that Rotarians serve the common good by orienting their daily work and social life to moral values and thus acting exemplary in society has taken a back seat.
  • 3. The fact that Rotary is losing its radiance today, getting bogged down in countless unspecific support projects, having difficulties in gaining interesting new members and scarcely motivating its current members for its Rotary goals, seems to have its roots here. Opportunities for Rotary By contrast, the founding idea of Rotary has lost nothing of its relevance. On the contrary, in a world where income and wealth inequalities are growing, national and international conflicts are increasing, and mutual consideration is dwindling, it is more relevant than ever. A look at the four-question test, which is obligatory for all Rotarians, makes it clear that Rotary was not originally great A look at the four-sample test, which is obligatory for all Rotarians, makes it clear that Rotary was originally not designed primarily as a service club, but as a community of values. The problems that Rotary was once founded to tackle have by no means diminished but have been increasingly lost sight of. Therefore, Rotary does not have to reinvent itself, but instead has to revert to its founding idea as a community of values. Rotarian friendship should not remain a mere phrase, but should rest on an ethical foundation. The common good orientation must not be confused in any sponsored projects, but must be recognizable in the daily actions of each Rotarian. If Rotary wants to regain its unmistakable position, the organization must therefore focus on what it was once founded for: professional ethics. As a union of leaders from the diverse professions of our society, Rotary is predestined to do so like no other organization in the world. Recommendations A concentration of Rotary on its original core competency, professional ethics, would have practical consequences. The topics that are already being dealt with in various funding projects - education, development and health - would have to be more focused on the Rotary core competence of the profession. The following examples of professionally oriented Rotary projects show the potential: Rotary should • offer local schools to use the expertise of Rotarians as part of their vocational orientation and professional ethics in teaching or in teaching-intensive projects;
  • 4. • in youth exchanges, continue to prepare pupils and students for the role of ambassadors of the Rotarian idea of fighting against selfishness, greed and corruption through decent work and daily life; • Organize Ryla seminars with a different understanding of leadership: "Conduct decency"; • award a Rotary Award, which is awarded for ethically exemplary behavior in different professions; • substantiate the intended return by establishing a scientific "Rotary Institute for Business and Professional Ethics", anchor it in the long term in society and stage it in publicity. • All Rotarians are invited to submit further suggestions for the practical implementation of the ethical refocusing of the organization and the club life. Result To increase its attractiveness, to help its members to understand themselves more clearly, and to better focus their use of resources, Rotary should reflect on its origins as a community of values. Professional ethics, as a link between diverse cultures, could help Rotarians to look back on their community with pride and make the world a little more decent.