SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Free Software and business innovation
Karsten Gerloff
<gerloff@fsfeurope.org>
President
Free Software Foundation Europe
November 12, 2010
Gartner: 100% adoption rate until November
2009
“Adoption of open-source software (OSS) is
becoming pervasive, with 85 percent of
companies surveyed currently using OSS in
their enterprises and the remaining 15
percent expecting to in the next 12 months,
according to Gartner, Inc.”
Gartner Newsroom, 17 November, 2008
GNU/Linux is poised to become a 50 billion
dollar ecosystem by 2011.
Linux Foundation
What is Free Software?
Free as in Freedom!
1. use
2. study
3. share
4. improve
What is Free Software?
Free as in Freedom!
1. use
2. study
3. share
4. improve
What is Free Software?
Free as in Freedom!
1. use
2. study
3. share
4. improve
What is Free Software?
Free as in Freedom!
1. use
2. study
3. share
4. improve
What is Free Software?
Free as in Freedom!
1. use
2. study
3. share
4. improve
How does this work?
Software is covered by copyright
Developer grants license
(the right) license grants you Freedom
Commercial?
Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial
a) don’t know what they’re talking about
b) want to sell you non-Free software
c) both.
Commercial?
Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial
a) don’t know what they’re talking about
b) want to sell you non-Free software
c) both.
Commercial?
Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial
a) don’t know what they’re talking about
b) want to sell you non-Free software
c) both.
Commercial?
Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial
a) don’t know what they’re talking about
b) want to sell you non-Free software
c) both.
If it’s free, how can you earn money?
Free as in freedom, not price
Earn money in almost any way you can think of
Software is not a business. It’s the foundation for a business.
Abbildung: Red Hat at JMP Securities Annual Research Conference, May
11, 2010
Abbildung: Press release of German LinuxVerband, Dec. 17, 2009
Free Software and innovation
Monopolies (copyright, patents) act as a tax on innovation
Free Software = tax-free innovation
Study: Free Software saves European industry 36% on R&D1
1
Ghosh et al.: FLOSSImpact (2006), 11
Competition and cooperation
Businesses can cooperate and compete at the same time
Copyleft secures investment
Working together to improve common platform
Competition and cooperation: Linux kernel
Abbildung: Top 10 contributors to 2.6.35 Linux kernel. Greg
Kroah-Hartmann, LWN, July 14, 2010.
Software model: Free vs proprietary
Development model: closed vs open
Revenue model
What about the license sales?
Less than 20% of software revenue from proprietary packaged
software
More than 80% of software revenue has nothing to do with
license sales
Most programmers are paid for their time, not for licenses
Innovation unshackled
Free Software removes constraints on business innovation
Free Software enables “deep” service and support
Free Software builds skills and keeps spending local
Some business models
Product specialist: “best knowledge here”
Platform providers: quality, stability support
Integrators: Customised solutions for clients
Some more business models
Training and documentation
Compliance engineering
Dual licensing2
2
Daffara, Carlo: Our definition of OSS-based business models.
http://carlodaffara.conecta.it/?p=104
Those are just a few options.
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
Choose your own way
Do you have to give the software away? No.
Do you have to stick to a particular license?
No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.)
But choose your license wisely.
Do you have to contribute back?
No. But there are advantages:
Better integration with the rest of the codebase
Influence over the project’s direction
But how about selling licenses anyway?
“Open core” is a bait-and-switch:
Distribute basic version gratis
Sell non-free license for features
Vendor keeps benefits of Free Software for himself...
...while the customer doesn’t enjoy any freedom
Watchwords: “Community / Enterprise version”
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think clearly.
Where do you add value?
What basis do you build upon?
What are your constraints?
What are your opportunities?
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think clearly.
Where do you add value?
What basis do you build upon?
What are your constraints?
What are your opportunities?
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think clearly.
Where do you add value?
What basis do you build upon?
What are your constraints?
What are your opportunities?
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think clearly.
Where do you add value?
What basis do you build upon?
What are your constraints?
What are your opportunities?
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think clearly.
Where do you add value?
What basis do you build upon?
What are your constraints?
What are your opportunities?
Takeaways for businesspeople
Think together
Can you cooperate with others to take on a bigger task?
Think ahead
Governance: making your project last
Invest in suppliers?
Takeaways for policymakers
Please don’t block the road.
Fix public procurement!
Stick to the rules
Ask for control: Free Software, Open Standards
invest for the long term
Use Free Software strategically to help new businesses to
grow.
Free up public sector software.
More ideas for policymakers
Oppose software patents.
Be creative about regional development
Tax credits for Free Software R&D?
If you don’t do it, others will.
http://fsfe.org
gerloff@fsfeurope.org

More Related Content

PDF
Why do Companies Write Open Source Software
Nadav Har'El
 
PPT
EDU 682 (for student)
Han Gao
 
PPTX
How to use etrade mobile to purchase share
Han Gao
 
PPTX
Etrade presentation
InFlight23
 
PPT
The Business of Software, Distribution, and System Integration
ISA Marketing & Sales Summit
 
PPTX
What is eBusiness
Carol Skyring
 
PPTX
e-Business
Biplab Mukherjee
 
PPT
E Business Introduction
Mrirfan
 
Why do Companies Write Open Source Software
Nadav Har'El
 
EDU 682 (for student)
Han Gao
 
How to use etrade mobile to purchase share
Han Gao
 
Etrade presentation
InFlight23
 
The Business of Software, Distribution, and System Integration
ISA Marketing & Sales Summit
 
What is eBusiness
Carol Skyring
 
e-Business
Biplab Mukherjee
 
E Business Introduction
Mrirfan
 

Similar to Free Software and Business Innovation (20)

PPTX
My Seminar
Esha Bindra
 
ODP
Free & Open Source Software For Nonprofits: NTEN Webinar
Gregory Heller
 
PPTX
Why is open source software is good for business
Shihab Darkrider
 
PPT
Open Source in the Enterprise: Compliance and Risk Management
Sebastiano Cobianco
 
PPT
Free and Open Source Software
Moinuddin Ahmed
 
PPT
Open Source: Lessons Learned (2006)
Matt Asay
 
ODP
Fundamentals of Free and Open Source Software
Ross Gardler
 
ODP
Understanding Free/Open Source Software (FOSS) and the Benefit to E-Commerce
Ir. Dr. R.Badlishah Ahmad
 
ODP
Open Source In Further Education
Ross Gardler
 
PPTX
Free and open source software
Amit Bshwas
 
PPT
Fosss
sgulzar
 
PDF
An Introduction to Free and Open Source Software Licensing and Business Models
Great Wide Open
 
ODP
FLOSS in SMEs
ivan_s2011
 
PDF
IrmaBorst
Ernest Stoepker
 
PDF
Open Source SW Business
SANGHEE SHIN
 
PDF
"Open Source licensing and software quality" by Monty Michael Widenius @ eLib...
eLiberatica
 
PDF
Open Source Software[1]
amckay1578
 
PDF
Software Open Source in ambito industriale
Better Software
 
PPT
Introduction To Open Source Licenses
Harley Pascua
 
PPTX
Open source presentation_v03
Sergi Torrellas
 
My Seminar
Esha Bindra
 
Free & Open Source Software For Nonprofits: NTEN Webinar
Gregory Heller
 
Why is open source software is good for business
Shihab Darkrider
 
Open Source in the Enterprise: Compliance and Risk Management
Sebastiano Cobianco
 
Free and Open Source Software
Moinuddin Ahmed
 
Open Source: Lessons Learned (2006)
Matt Asay
 
Fundamentals of Free and Open Source Software
Ross Gardler
 
Understanding Free/Open Source Software (FOSS) and the Benefit to E-Commerce
Ir. Dr. R.Badlishah Ahmad
 
Open Source In Further Education
Ross Gardler
 
Free and open source software
Amit Bshwas
 
Fosss
sgulzar
 
An Introduction to Free and Open Source Software Licensing and Business Models
Great Wide Open
 
FLOSS in SMEs
ivan_s2011
 
IrmaBorst
Ernest Stoepker
 
Open Source SW Business
SANGHEE SHIN
 
"Open Source licensing and software quality" by Monty Michael Widenius @ eLib...
eLiberatica
 
Open Source Software[1]
amckay1578
 
Software Open Source in ambito industriale
Better Software
 
Introduction To Open Source Licenses
Harley Pascua
 
Open source presentation_v03
Sergi Torrellas
 
Ad

More from South Tyrol Free Software Conference (20)

PDF
SFSCON24 - Marina Latini - 1, 2, 3, Doc Kit!
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Carmen Delgado Ivar Grimstad - Nurturing OpenJDK distribution: Ecl...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Eduardo Guerra - codEEmoji – Making code more informative with emojis
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Juri Solovjov - How to start contributing and still have fun
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Michal Skipala & Bruno Rossi - Monolith Splitter
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Jorge Melegati - Software Engineering Automation: From early tools...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Chiara Civardi & Dominika Tasarz Sochacka - The Crucial Role of Op...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Moritz Mock, Barbara Russo & Jorge Melegati - Can Test Driven Deve...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Aurelio Buonomo & Christian Zanotti - Apisense – Easily monitor an...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Giovanni Giannotta & Orneda Lecini - Approaches to Object Detectio...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Alberto Nicoletti - The SMART Box of AURA Project
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Luca Alloatti - Open-source silicon chips
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Roberto Innocenti - 2025 scenario on OpenISA OpenPower Open Hardwa...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Juan Rico - Enabling global interoperability among smart devices ...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Seckin Celik & Davide Serpico - Adoption Determinants of Open Hard...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Stefan Mutschlechner - Smart Werke Meran - Lorawan Use Cases
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Mattia Pizzirani - Raspberry Pi and Node-RED: Open Source Tools fo...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Attaullah Buriro - ClapMetrics: Decoding Users Genderand Age Throu...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Joseph P. De Veaugh Geiss - Opt out? Opt in? Opt Green! Bringing F...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
PDF
SFSCON24 - Fulvio Mastrogiovanni - On the ethical challenges raised by robots...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Marina Latini - 1, 2, 3, Doc Kit!
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Carmen Delgado Ivar Grimstad - Nurturing OpenJDK distribution: Ecl...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Eduardo Guerra - codEEmoji – Making code more informative with emojis
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Juri Solovjov - How to start contributing and still have fun
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Michal Skipala & Bruno Rossi - Monolith Splitter
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Jorge Melegati - Software Engineering Automation: From early tools...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Chiara Civardi & Dominika Tasarz Sochacka - The Crucial Role of Op...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Moritz Mock, Barbara Russo & Jorge Melegati - Can Test Driven Deve...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Aurelio Buonomo & Christian Zanotti - Apisense – Easily monitor an...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Giovanni Giannotta & Orneda Lecini - Approaches to Object Detectio...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Alberto Nicoletti - The SMART Box of AURA Project
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Luca Alloatti - Open-source silicon chips
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Roberto Innocenti - 2025 scenario on OpenISA OpenPower Open Hardwa...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Juan Rico - Enabling global interoperability among smart devices ...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Seckin Celik & Davide Serpico - Adoption Determinants of Open Hard...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Stefan Mutschlechner - Smart Werke Meran - Lorawan Use Cases
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Mattia Pizzirani - Raspberry Pi and Node-RED: Open Source Tools fo...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Attaullah Buriro - ClapMetrics: Decoding Users Genderand Age Throu...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Joseph P. De Veaugh Geiss - Opt out? Opt in? Opt Green! Bringing F...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
SFSCON24 - Fulvio Mastrogiovanni - On the ethical challenges raised by robots...
South Tyrol Free Software Conference
 
Ad

Free Software and Business Innovation

  • 1. Free Software and business innovation Karsten Gerloff <[email protected]> President Free Software Foundation Europe November 12, 2010
  • 2. Gartner: 100% adoption rate until November 2009 “Adoption of open-source software (OSS) is becoming pervasive, with 85 percent of companies surveyed currently using OSS in their enterprises and the remaining 15 percent expecting to in the next 12 months, according to Gartner, Inc.” Gartner Newsroom, 17 November, 2008
  • 3. GNU/Linux is poised to become a 50 billion dollar ecosystem by 2011. Linux Foundation
  • 4. What is Free Software? Free as in Freedom! 1. use 2. study 3. share 4. improve
  • 5. What is Free Software? Free as in Freedom! 1. use 2. study 3. share 4. improve
  • 6. What is Free Software? Free as in Freedom! 1. use 2. study 3. share 4. improve
  • 7. What is Free Software? Free as in Freedom! 1. use 2. study 3. share 4. improve
  • 8. What is Free Software? Free as in Freedom! 1. use 2. study 3. share 4. improve
  • 9. How does this work? Software is covered by copyright Developer grants license (the right) license grants you Freedom
  • 10. Commercial? Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial a) don’t know what they’re talking about b) want to sell you non-Free software c) both.
  • 11. Commercial? Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial a) don’t know what they’re talking about b) want to sell you non-Free software c) both.
  • 12. Commercial? Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial a) don’t know what they’re talking about b) want to sell you non-Free software c) both.
  • 13. Commercial? Those who claim that Free Software is non-commercial a) don’t know what they’re talking about b) want to sell you non-Free software c) both.
  • 14. If it’s free, how can you earn money? Free as in freedom, not price Earn money in almost any way you can think of Software is not a business. It’s the foundation for a business.
  • 15. Abbildung: Red Hat at JMP Securities Annual Research Conference, May 11, 2010
  • 16. Abbildung: Press release of German LinuxVerband, Dec. 17, 2009
  • 17. Free Software and innovation Monopolies (copyright, patents) act as a tax on innovation Free Software = tax-free innovation Study: Free Software saves European industry 36% on R&D1 1 Ghosh et al.: FLOSSImpact (2006), 11
  • 18. Competition and cooperation Businesses can cooperate and compete at the same time Copyleft secures investment Working together to improve common platform
  • 19. Competition and cooperation: Linux kernel Abbildung: Top 10 contributors to 2.6.35 Linux kernel. Greg Kroah-Hartmann, LWN, July 14, 2010.
  • 20. Software model: Free vs proprietary
  • 23. What about the license sales? Less than 20% of software revenue from proprietary packaged software More than 80% of software revenue has nothing to do with license sales Most programmers are paid for their time, not for licenses
  • 24. Innovation unshackled Free Software removes constraints on business innovation Free Software enables “deep” service and support Free Software builds skills and keeps spending local
  • 25. Some business models Product specialist: “best knowledge here” Platform providers: quality, stability support Integrators: Customised solutions for clients
  • 26. Some more business models Training and documentation Compliance engineering Dual licensing2 2 Daffara, Carlo: Our definition of OSS-based business models. http://carlodaffara.conecta.it/?p=104
  • 27. Those are just a few options.
  • 28. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 29. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 30. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 31. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 32. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 33. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 34. Choose your own way Do you have to give the software away? No. Do you have to stick to a particular license? No. (Not if it’s your own software, anyway.) But choose your license wisely. Do you have to contribute back? No. But there are advantages: Better integration with the rest of the codebase Influence over the project’s direction
  • 35. But how about selling licenses anyway? “Open core” is a bait-and-switch: Distribute basic version gratis Sell non-free license for features Vendor keeps benefits of Free Software for himself... ...while the customer doesn’t enjoy any freedom Watchwords: “Community / Enterprise version”
  • 36. Takeaways for businesspeople Think clearly. Where do you add value? What basis do you build upon? What are your constraints? What are your opportunities?
  • 37. Takeaways for businesspeople Think clearly. Where do you add value? What basis do you build upon? What are your constraints? What are your opportunities?
  • 38. Takeaways for businesspeople Think clearly. Where do you add value? What basis do you build upon? What are your constraints? What are your opportunities?
  • 39. Takeaways for businesspeople Think clearly. Where do you add value? What basis do you build upon? What are your constraints? What are your opportunities?
  • 40. Takeaways for businesspeople Think clearly. Where do you add value? What basis do you build upon? What are your constraints? What are your opportunities?
  • 41. Takeaways for businesspeople Think together Can you cooperate with others to take on a bigger task? Think ahead Governance: making your project last Invest in suppliers?
  • 42. Takeaways for policymakers Please don’t block the road. Fix public procurement! Stick to the rules Ask for control: Free Software, Open Standards invest for the long term Use Free Software strategically to help new businesses to grow. Free up public sector software.
  • 43. More ideas for policymakers Oppose software patents. Be creative about regional development Tax credits for Free Software R&D?
  • 44. If you don’t do it, others will.