Participation under compulsion
1 like691 views
The document discusses issues around initiating and maintaining student participation in online learning platforms and social software. It notes that requiring participation through external controls like grading can increase activity but may not foster deeper learning or collaboration. Simply providing tools and expecting voluntary participation often results in low levels of engagement. Instead, participation is more successful when it serves student interests and needs, allows a sense of ownership, and supports different types of learning like expanding opportunities rather than just completing tasks. Overall, the question is raised whether true participation, autonomy and collaboration can be achieved through compulsory controls or if new pedagogical models are needed.
![Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “Eachstudentwas required to submit one post and one comment per week for nine weeks …” (Halic et al. 2010:3)“Participants were told […] they must write at least one journal every week.“ (Xie et al. 2008: 21)](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/grellrau-participationundercompulsion-100927150127-phpapp02/85/Participation-under-compulsion-8-320.jpg)
![Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “[...] students were required to participate in two rounds of peer assessment exercises. The article assignment was worth 30% of the total course grade, while the peer-feedback assignment was worth 5% of the total course grade.” (Xiao & Lucking 2008: 189)](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/grellrau-participationundercompulsion-100927150127-phpapp02/85/Participation-under-compulsion-9-320.jpg)
![Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “[…] grading structure and due dates were important to induce students to participate.” (Sarkar 2009: 3)External control as a necessity? Any didactical underpinning?A focus on consequences ?](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/grellrau-participationundercompulsion-100927150127-phpapp02/85/Participation-under-compulsion-10-320.jpg)
Participation under compulsion
- 1. Participation under compulsionProf. Dr. Petra Grell, University of PotsdamFranco Rau B. Ed., University of Potsdam
- 2. “It would be foolish to ignore thetremendous opportunities the Social Web offers to education.”(Wheeler, 2009: 4)
- 3. Exemplary overview journals & conference proceedings
- 4. articles which include in their title one of the terms :- „social software“, „Web 2.0“, „wiki“, „blog“, „microblog“, „eportfolio“, „collaborative learning“, „blogging“, „peer feedback“ or „learning communities“
- 6. Lack of Participation “After 5 weeks (halfway through the teaching term) there had been zero posts to the wiki” (Cole 2009: 144)Disregarding problems of participation “In addition, this study did not attempt to make comparisons between students who used blogs and those who did not,…“ (Halic et al. 2010: 7)
- 7. Initiating ParticipationBasic scaffolding & guidance“An explicit precondition for this case study was the use of weblogs on a voluntary basis.”(Safran 2008: 131)“The mentoringtutors themselves committed posts to the community regularly in order to encourage the students to participate.” (Safran 2008: 133)
- 8. Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “Eachstudentwas required to submit one post and one comment per week for nine weeks …” (Halic et al. 2010:3)“Participants were told […] they must write at least one journal every week.“ (Xie et al. 2008: 21)
- 9. Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “[...] students were required to participate in two rounds of peer assessment exercises. The article assignment was worth 30% of the total course grade, while the peer-feedback assignment was worth 5% of the total course grade.” (Xiao & Lucking 2008: 189)
- 10. Initiating ParticipationExternal Control “[…] grading structure and due dates were important to induce students to participate.” (Sarkar 2009: 3)External control as a necessity? Any didactical underpinning?A focus on consequences ?
- 11. Initiating ParticipationAwareness: consequences of external control„Although the volume of posts increased due to the obligatory use of the application, students appeared to be ‘playing the game’ rather than using the tool for their own purposes” (Ebner et al. 2010: 97)
- 12. Reflecting the impact ofnon-voluntary participation “In effect, transformation at the highest level, wherein students become a collaborative community generating and evaluating each other's ideas and altering their own perspectives or viewpoints, typically did not occur.” (Bonk et al. 2009: 132)
- 13. Reflecting the impact of non-voluntary participation“Specifically, education exists in a consumerist culture where altruistic acts are devalued and individual effort is rewarded. Consequently, promoting wiki involvement requires some assessed element.” (Cole 2009:145) “Social networking technologies, specially Wiki’s, involve a large element of altruistic behaviour. Further work is needed to determine whether it is possible to create new pedagogic structures of learning to promote collaborative behaviours amongst students that are not directlyassessable” (Cole 2009: 146)
- 14. Reflecting the impact of non-voluntary participation“Educational technology must support student needs by creating a balance between the needs of both stakeholders (lecturers and students). There must be a balance between the cost (time invested learning and using the new technology) and the benefits (engagement, interest and improved learning).” (Cole 2009: 144)
- 15. DiscussionParticipation is not just “activating”, it is based on interests, usefulness and a sense of ownershipSubject-scientific learning theory: “defensive learning” to ward off a threat,“expansive learning” to open up opportunities of actingThe fundamental question is: Is it possible to achieve participation, self-reliance, maturity and autonomy through control and heteronomy?
- 17. References[1] Anderson, N., & Lin, C., (2009). Exploring technologies for building collaborative learning communities among diverse student populations. In Proceedings of the 14th Annual ACM SIGCSE Conference on innovation and Technology in Computer Science Education. NY: ACM, 243-247. [2] Bonk, C. J, Lee, M. M., Kim, N., & Lin, M.-F. G. (2009). The tensions of transformation in three cross-institutional wikibook projects. The Internet and Higher Education, 12(3-4), 126-135.[3] Cole M. (2009). Using Wiki technology to support student engagement: Lessons from the trenches. Computers & Education. 52(1), 141-146. [4] Ebner M., & Maurer H. (2009). Can Weblogs and Microblogs Change Traditional Scientific Writing?. Future Internet. 1(1), 47-58.[5] Ebner, M., Lienhardt, C., Rohs, M., & Meyer, I. (2010) Microblogs in Higher Education - A chance to facilitate informal and process-oriented learning?. Computers & Education. 55(1), 92-100.[6] Ehlers, U.-D., Adelsberger, H.H., & Teschler, S. (2009). Reflexion im Netz: Auf dem Weg zur Employability im Studium. In N. Apostolopoulos, H. Hoffmann, V. Mansmann & A. Schwill (Hrsg.), E-Learning 2009. Lernen im digitalen Zeitalter. Münster: WaxmannVerlag, 15-29.[7] Halic, O., Lee, D., Paulus T., & Spence Marsha (2010). To blog or not to blog: Student perceptions of blog effectiveness for learning in a college-level course. The Internet and Higher Education, In Press, ISSN 1096-7516, DOI: 10.1016/j.iheduc.2010.04.001.[8] Hermann, C. & Janzen, A. (2009). Electures-Wiki – Aktive Nutzung von Vorlesungsaufzeichnungen. In A. Schwill & N. Apostolopoulos (Hrsg.), Lernen im Digitalen Zeitalter. DeLFI 2009 – Die 7. E-Learning Fachtagung Informatik. Bonn: Köllen Druck+Verlag GmbH, 127-138.[9] Meyer, K.A. (2010). A comparison of Web 2.0 tools in a doctoral course. The Internet and Higher Education, In Press, Corrected Proof, Available online 11 February 2010, ISSN 1096-7516, DOI: 10.1016/j.iheduc.2010.02.002.[10] Öner, D. (2009). Pre-service teachers' experiences with Wiki: challenges of asynchronous collaboration. In Proceedings of the 5th international Symposium on Wikis and Open. WikiSym ‘09. New York, NY: ACM, 1-2.[11] Requena-Carrión, J., Rodríguez-González, A. B., Marques, A. G., and Gutiérrez-Pérez, D. (2009). Work in progress - implantation of a collaborative student-centered learning environment in a wireless technology course. In Proceedings of the 39th IEEE international Conference on Frontiers in Education Conference. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE Press, 918-919. [12] Safran, C. (2008). Blogging in higher education programming lectures: an empirical study. In Proceedings of the 12th international Conference on Entertainment and Media in the Ubiquitous. New York, NY: ACM, 131-135.[13] Sarkar, S. (2009). Wiki-enhanced social scribing of lectures: a case study in an undergraduate course. In Proceedings of the 39th IEEE international Conference on Frontiers in Education Conference. Piscataway, NJ: IEEE Press, 1408-1413.[14]Wheeler S (2009). Learning Space Mashups: Combining Web 2.0 Tools to Create Collaborative and Reflective Learning Spaces. Future Internet. 1(1), 3-13.[15] Xiao, Y., & Lucking R. (2008). The impact of two types of peer assessment on students’ performance and satisfaction within a Wiki environment. The Internet and Higher Education. 11(3-4), 186-193.[16]Xie, Y., Ke, F., & Sharma, P. (2008) The effect of peer feedback for blogging on college students' reflective learning processes. The Internet and Higher Education. 11(1), 18-25.Image sources„Little Johnny“:http://www.flickr.com/photos/feminaerecta/542692574/„Class“: http://www.flickr.com/photos/hibr/4878398891/ „Sleeping “: http://www.flickr.com/photos/sveinhal/2533808944/„Start “: http://www.flickr.com/photos/lincolnblues/4030184673/„Attention“: http://www.flickr.com/photos/hurstville1/3732218078/„The Thinker“: http://www.flickr.com/photos/baboon/110993877/