Press Rights
Today’s Concepts
Press Rights
• Privilege
  – Fair report
  – Opinion
  – Fair comment and criticism
• Freedom from Newsroom
  Searches
  – Unless you’re suspected of
    involvement in a crime, destruction
    of evidence, or someone could be
    hurt
          » Harrower P. 140
Press Rights
• Shield Laws
  – Allow reporters to protect,
    “shield” their confidential
    sources and notes; only in 34
    (32?) states; no federal
    courts have shield laws,
    meaning, reporters choose
    between revealing their
    sources or going to jail.
    (Example: Judith Miller of the
    NYTimes)               Harrower p.140
• Three key areas:
  – Open courtrooms
  – Open meetings
  – Open records

             Harrower p.141
Harrower p.141
Harrower p.141
• Open Records – Key questions:
  – Material such as defense secrets, medical
    files, and sensitive law-enforcement data
    are exempt. Who categorizes the
    information?
  – Reporters can file a FOIA Request –
    Freedom of Information Act
                                                Harrower p.141
• Examples of news stories stemming from
  FOIA requests:
  – New York Daily News exposes government’s
    misrepresentation of “Ground Zero”
    environmental contamination
  – Dayton Daily News identifies most dangerous
    workplaces in the country
  – The money trail: mismanagement of funds for
    Hurricane Katrina victims (various media)
          » Source: Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press
• “Although FOIA is an important source of information,
  reporters should recognize its limitations. Information
  obtained through a FOIA request is rarely the story
  itself. Rather, it can be used to verify other sources and
  information. Sometimes information obtained from a
  request can simply identify leads or sources for a story
  that the reporter later can follow up on in person.”
             » Source: Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press

Press Rights

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 4.
    Press Rights • Privilege – Fair report – Opinion – Fair comment and criticism • Freedom from Newsroom Searches – Unless you’re suspected of involvement in a crime, destruction of evidence, or someone could be hurt » Harrower P. 140
  • 5.
    Press Rights • ShieldLaws – Allow reporters to protect, “shield” their confidential sources and notes; only in 34 (32?) states; no federal courts have shield laws, meaning, reporters choose between revealing their sources or going to jail. (Example: Judith Miller of the NYTimes) Harrower p.140
  • 6.
    • Three keyareas: – Open courtrooms – Open meetings – Open records Harrower p.141
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
    • Open Records– Key questions: – Material such as defense secrets, medical files, and sensitive law-enforcement data are exempt. Who categorizes the information? – Reporters can file a FOIA Request – Freedom of Information Act Harrower p.141
  • 10.
    • Examples ofnews stories stemming from FOIA requests: – New York Daily News exposes government’s misrepresentation of “Ground Zero” environmental contamination – Dayton Daily News identifies most dangerous workplaces in the country – The money trail: mismanagement of funds for Hurricane Katrina victims (various media) » Source: Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press
  • 11.
    • “Although FOIAis an important source of information, reporters should recognize its limitations. Information obtained through a FOIA request is rarely the story itself. Rather, it can be used to verify other sources and information. Sometimes information obtained from a request can simply identify leads or sources for a story that the reporter later can follow up on in person.” » Source: Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press