LECTURE 3
26 September 2022
(2.00 – 4.00 pm)
Introduction to Scientific Research,
Paradigms and the Quantitative and
Qualitative Approaches
Scientific Research
 a systematic, controlled empirical and
critical investigation of propositions
about the presumed relationships
about various phenomena.
Systematic
This implies that the procedures
adopted to undertake an investigation
follow a certain logical sequence. The
different steps cannot be taken in a
haphazard way. Some procedures must
follow others
Controlled
 many factors affect an outcome: A particular event is seldom
the result of a one-to-one relationship; some relationships are
more complex than others; and most outcomes are a sequel to
the interplay of a multiplicity of relationships and interacting
factors.
 In a study of cause-and-effect relationships it is important to
be able to link the effect(s) with the cause(s) and vice versa.
 In the study of causation, the establishment of this linkage is
essential; however, in practice, particularly in the social
sciences, it is extremely difficult – and often impossible – to
make the link.
Critical
 Critical scrutiny of the procedures used and
the methods employed is crucial to a
research enquiry.
 The process of investigation must be fool-
proof and free from any drawbacks.
 The process adopted and the procedures
used must be able to withstand critical
scrutiny
Scientific Research
 a way to gather or collect evidence for our
practice.
 one of the ways to find answers to our
questions.
 is a process for collecting, analysing and
interpreting information to answer
questions.
Scientific Research
 a research study to find out answers to a question
means that the process being applied:
 is being undertaken within a framework of a set
of philosophies;
 uses procedures, methods and techniques that
have been tested for their validity and reliability;
 is designed to be unbiased and objective
Scientific Research
A set of ideas, a framework (theory,
ontology)
A set of questions (epistemology)
Specific ways (methodology, analysis)
Research Paradigms
 beliefs about the nature of knowledge
a set of philosophical assumptions
about the phenomena to be
studied, about how they can be
understood.
Research Paradigms
 a perspective about research held by a
community of researchers. This perspective
is based on a set of shared assumptions,
concepts, values, and practices,
terminology, methods and techniques to
understand social phenomena.
Research Paradigms
 are characterized by their distinctive:
 ontology—“what is the nature of the knowable? or what is
the nature of reality?”
 epistemology—“what is the relationship between the
knower (the inquirer) and the known (or knowable)?” or
what is the paradigm’s theory of knowledge
 methodology— “how should the inquirer go about finding
out knowledge?” or, more specifically, what methods
should be used in research?
Ontology (1)
 a philosophical belief system about the nature of
social reality—what can be known and how, or
what are the characteristics of things that exist?
 For example, is the social world patterned and
predictable, or is the social world continually
being constructed through human interactions and
rituals?
Ontology (2)
These assumptions represent the two
very different ontological perspectives
A researcher’s ontological assumptions
impact topic selection, the formulation
of research questions, and strategies
for conducting the research
Epistemology
 The researcher’s ontological and
epistemological positions form the
philosophical basis of a research project
 This philosophical foundation impacts every
aspect of the research process, including
topic selection, question formulation,
method selection, sampling, and research
design
Research Paradigms
 Each dimension impacts how a research
question is formulated, how a project is
conceptualized, and how a study is carried
out.
 ontological and epistemological positions
invariably inform methodological and
methods choices
Research Paradigms
guide a researcher to discover
knowledge
- positivism
- interpretivism
- critical theory/science
positivism
there are universal laws that govern
social events, and uncovering these
laws enables researchers to describe,
predict, and control social
phenomena.
Quantitative Approach
 Based on “the model of science” -
Positivism
Positivism
 Positivism holds that there is a knowable reality that
exists independent of the research process.
 The social world, like the natural world, is governed by
rules, which result in patterns.
 Accordingly, causal relationships between variables exist
and can even be identified, proven, and explained.
 Thus, patterned social reality is predictable and can
potentially be controlled. This describes the nature of
social reality from the positivist perspective.
Positivism
 Reality consists of what is available to the senses
(what can be seen, smelt, touched, etc.).
 Inquiry should be based upon scientific
observation.
 The natural and human sciences share common
logical and methodological principles, dealing
with facts and not with values.
Assumptions about positivism
 As physical world and social world are
similar, then social phenomena can be
studied as in physical phenomena.
 As theory is universal, then principles and
inferences can be used to describe an
individual’s behavior and phenomena in
the settings.
Quantitative Approach
 Formulate a research question
 Develop a hypothesis
 Define variables
 Construct measurement instrument
 Coding
 Sampling (random sampling)
 Reliability and validity checks
Interpretivism
 to understand how people see, think, and feel
about the world, seeking to grasp diverse
perspectives in their own terms.
 Here, the links between perspectives and actions,
and between behaviour and its effects, are seen
as complex and uncertain, rather than reducible
to statements about fixed relationships.
critical theory
Refers to the notion of equity or social
justice.
seeks to explain social inequities
through which individuals can take
actions to change injustices
Qualitative Research
a broad approach to the study of social
phenomena
a way of knowing through collecting /
gathering data by organizing and
interpreting information obtained from
people using his/her eyes and ears.
Qualitative Research
A situated activity that locates the
observer in the world
Consists of a set of interpretive,
material practices that make the
world visible.
Qualitative Research
 is enacted in naturalistic settings,
 draws on multiple methods that respect the
humanity of the participants in the study,
 focuses on context,
 is emergent and evolving, and
 is fundamentally interpretive.
Qualitative Research
 if the purpose of the study is primarily to describe
a situation, phenomenon, problem or event
 if the information is gathered through the use of
variables measured on nominal or ordinal scales
(qualitative measurement scales).
 if the analysis is done to establish the variation in
the situation, phenomenon or problem without
quantifying it.
Qualitative Research
A situated activity that locates the
observer in the world
Consists of a set of interpretive,
material practices that make the
world visible.
Qualitative Research as Process
A set of ideas, a framework (theory,
ontology)
A set of questions (epistemology)
Specific ways (methodology, analysis)

Lecture3 - Intro to Scientific Research.pdf

  • 1.
    LECTURE 3 26 September2022 (2.00 – 4.00 pm) Introduction to Scientific Research, Paradigms and the Quantitative and Qualitative Approaches
  • 2.
    Scientific Research  asystematic, controlled empirical and critical investigation of propositions about the presumed relationships about various phenomena.
  • 3.
    Systematic This implies thatthe procedures adopted to undertake an investigation follow a certain logical sequence. The different steps cannot be taken in a haphazard way. Some procedures must follow others
  • 4.
    Controlled  many factorsaffect an outcome: A particular event is seldom the result of a one-to-one relationship; some relationships are more complex than others; and most outcomes are a sequel to the interplay of a multiplicity of relationships and interacting factors.  In a study of cause-and-effect relationships it is important to be able to link the effect(s) with the cause(s) and vice versa.  In the study of causation, the establishment of this linkage is essential; however, in practice, particularly in the social sciences, it is extremely difficult – and often impossible – to make the link.
  • 5.
    Critical  Critical scrutinyof the procedures used and the methods employed is crucial to a research enquiry.  The process of investigation must be fool- proof and free from any drawbacks.  The process adopted and the procedures used must be able to withstand critical scrutiny
  • 6.
    Scientific Research  away to gather or collect evidence for our practice.  one of the ways to find answers to our questions.  is a process for collecting, analysing and interpreting information to answer questions.
  • 7.
    Scientific Research  aresearch study to find out answers to a question means that the process being applied:  is being undertaken within a framework of a set of philosophies;  uses procedures, methods and techniques that have been tested for their validity and reliability;  is designed to be unbiased and objective
  • 8.
    Scientific Research A setof ideas, a framework (theory, ontology) A set of questions (epistemology) Specific ways (methodology, analysis)
  • 9.
    Research Paradigms  beliefsabout the nature of knowledge a set of philosophical assumptions about the phenomena to be studied, about how they can be understood.
  • 10.
    Research Paradigms  aperspective about research held by a community of researchers. This perspective is based on a set of shared assumptions, concepts, values, and practices, terminology, methods and techniques to understand social phenomena.
  • 11.
    Research Paradigms  arecharacterized by their distinctive:  ontology—“what is the nature of the knowable? or what is the nature of reality?”  epistemology—“what is the relationship between the knower (the inquirer) and the known (or knowable)?” or what is the paradigm’s theory of knowledge  methodology— “how should the inquirer go about finding out knowledge?” or, more specifically, what methods should be used in research?
  • 12.
    Ontology (1)  aphilosophical belief system about the nature of social reality—what can be known and how, or what are the characteristics of things that exist?  For example, is the social world patterned and predictable, or is the social world continually being constructed through human interactions and rituals?
  • 13.
    Ontology (2) These assumptionsrepresent the two very different ontological perspectives A researcher’s ontological assumptions impact topic selection, the formulation of research questions, and strategies for conducting the research
  • 14.
    Epistemology  The researcher’sontological and epistemological positions form the philosophical basis of a research project  This philosophical foundation impacts every aspect of the research process, including topic selection, question formulation, method selection, sampling, and research design
  • 15.
    Research Paradigms  Eachdimension impacts how a research question is formulated, how a project is conceptualized, and how a study is carried out.  ontological and epistemological positions invariably inform methodological and methods choices
  • 16.
    Research Paradigms guide aresearcher to discover knowledge - positivism - interpretivism - critical theory/science
  • 17.
    positivism there are universallaws that govern social events, and uncovering these laws enables researchers to describe, predict, and control social phenomena.
  • 18.
    Quantitative Approach  Basedon “the model of science” - Positivism
  • 19.
    Positivism  Positivism holdsthat there is a knowable reality that exists independent of the research process.  The social world, like the natural world, is governed by rules, which result in patterns.  Accordingly, causal relationships between variables exist and can even be identified, proven, and explained.  Thus, patterned social reality is predictable and can potentially be controlled. This describes the nature of social reality from the positivist perspective.
  • 20.
    Positivism  Reality consistsof what is available to the senses (what can be seen, smelt, touched, etc.).  Inquiry should be based upon scientific observation.  The natural and human sciences share common logical and methodological principles, dealing with facts and not with values.
  • 21.
    Assumptions about positivism As physical world and social world are similar, then social phenomena can be studied as in physical phenomena.  As theory is universal, then principles and inferences can be used to describe an individual’s behavior and phenomena in the settings.
  • 22.
    Quantitative Approach  Formulatea research question  Develop a hypothesis  Define variables  Construct measurement instrument  Coding  Sampling (random sampling)  Reliability and validity checks
  • 23.
    Interpretivism  to understandhow people see, think, and feel about the world, seeking to grasp diverse perspectives in their own terms.  Here, the links between perspectives and actions, and between behaviour and its effects, are seen as complex and uncertain, rather than reducible to statements about fixed relationships.
  • 24.
    critical theory Refers tothe notion of equity or social justice. seeks to explain social inequities through which individuals can take actions to change injustices
  • 25.
    Qualitative Research a broadapproach to the study of social phenomena a way of knowing through collecting / gathering data by organizing and interpreting information obtained from people using his/her eyes and ears.
  • 26.
    Qualitative Research A situatedactivity that locates the observer in the world Consists of a set of interpretive, material practices that make the world visible.
  • 27.
    Qualitative Research  isenacted in naturalistic settings,  draws on multiple methods that respect the humanity of the participants in the study,  focuses on context,  is emergent and evolving, and  is fundamentally interpretive.
  • 28.
    Qualitative Research  ifthe purpose of the study is primarily to describe a situation, phenomenon, problem or event  if the information is gathered through the use of variables measured on nominal or ordinal scales (qualitative measurement scales).  if the analysis is done to establish the variation in the situation, phenomenon or problem without quantifying it.
  • 29.
    Qualitative Research A situatedactivity that locates the observer in the world Consists of a set of interpretive, material practices that make the world visible.
  • 30.
    Qualitative Research asProcess A set of ideas, a framework (theory, ontology) A set of questions (epistemology) Specific ways (methodology, analysis)