SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Linked Open Data
in limbo
Co-creation as a catalyst for
open cultural heritage resources
Open Belgium 12.03.2018
Sam Donvil Alina Saenko
sam@packed.be alina@packed.be
@PACKEDvzw
• 2006 - 2010: Platform for Archiving and Conservation of Art on Electronic
and Digital Media
• 2011 - present: Centre of Expertise Digital Heritage
• Flemish, Belgian and European projects
• Support for ICT-processes at heritage and arts organisations (o.a.
creating, storage, cataloguing, online access, exchange and reuse) and
policy thereof
• Central concern: sustainability (digital heritage is vulnerable)
The museum as a changing concept: antiquity >
museion
Role: scholarship
Audience: research
community
The museum as a changing concept: renaissance >
cabinet of curiosities
Role: prestige, display of ‘all’
objects
Audience: privileged visitors,
courtiers
The museum as a changing concept: enlightenment
and modern era > birth of the modern museum
Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, not
necessarily display
Audience: research community & privileged
visitors
Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, national
prestige
Audience: research community, large middle class
audiences
The museum as a changing concept: contemporary
era > changing consumer demands
The museum as a changing concept: contemporary
era > memory institution as an online knowledge
source
Future
interpretation:
-Share
-Contextualise
-Coordinate
-Facilitate
Conventional
interpretation:
-Control quality
-Control access
Current ICOM definition:
A museum is a non-profit, permanent
institution in the service of society and
its development, open to the public,
which acquires, conserves, researches,
communicates and exhibits the tangible
and intangible heritage of humanity and
its environment for the purposes of
education, study and enjoyment.
Accumulation and
registration of data
Back-office:
- Not a ‘popular’ topic to invest in
- Often no ‘digital mindset’ inside the institutions > external IT services
Data
- Messy and not complete, but a lot of potential knowledge
- Captured on different carriers (systems, digital and analogue files)
- Often closed (and obsolete) software
Audio-visual material
- Different tools and DAMs, but not good enough
- ‘Analogue mindset’: distributed versions and copies
The situation in the Flemish artmuseums
Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources
2012 http://smak.be/collectie_kunstenaar.php?kunstwerk_id=1461&l=a&kunstenaar_id=41
Open source tool:
https://github.com/PACKED-vzw/resolver
Resolver-tool
Resolver
Persistent URI: 2016 - ... http://resolver.smak.be/collection/work/data/3385
http://smak.be/nl/kunstwerk/75872016
http://newwebsite.be/3542019
http://evenbetterwebsite.be/lod/the-journey2030
Enrichment of data via external authorities
External authorities:
- Wikidata, VIAF, RKDartists, ODIS,
Geonames, AAT (Getty Vocabularies),
Iconclass
https://www.projectcest.be/wiki/Publicatie:Project_Persist
ente_identificatie
Visualisations with internally shared data
Acquisition source:
From which source did a museum
acquire artworks? (5 museums)
- Private
- Artist
- Gallery
- Government
- The Monarchy
- The Church
https://thedatahub.github.io/
Blueprint distributed AV management
Making data and images
accessible
Open Cultuur Data project
Open data on Wikimedia platforms
Why Wikimedia?
● visibility
● reuse
● engagement
Wikidata
○ Royal Museum of Fine Arts Antwerp (7.798 artworks)
○ Museum of Fine Arts Ghent (6.973 artworks)
○ Groeningemuseum Brugge (2.858 artworks)
○ M - Museum Leuven (3.137 artworks)
○ Mu.ZEE (3.979 artworks)
○ S.M.A.K. (2.579 artworks)
Wikimedia Commons
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Data enrichment and reuse
Conclusion and next steps
Why Linked Open Data in Limbo?
digital movement <> no digital mindset
reducing costs <> out-of-control IT-budgets
new ‘digital’ audiences <> losing ‘traditional’ audiences
showing off with fancy tools <> locked up in obsolete technology
engaging with the ‘crowd’ <> abandoned web portals
- More IT profiles in the cultural heritage sector and less dependence on the providers
- More freedom to play around and test things out
- Better open infrastructures and tools that make better internal workflows and LOD
possible:
- Back office tools: Collection Management Systems, DAMs , Datahubs…
- Publishing online tools: Resolvers, API’s...
- Reusing: Wikimedia art viewers, apps...
- etc...
- Vocal and demanding audience:
- (examples of) reuse
- curating/enriching data
Wishlist
- Datahub project fase 2 en 3
- Resolver-tool op Open Summer of Code 2018
- Wikimedia projects:
- Public Domain publication
- Publishing images and more structured data
- Reusing in Wikipedia-articles and outside of the platform
- Networked cultural data
- survey on the current demand for cultural heritage data by various
sectors
Do you see yourself contributing to one of the projects or to the wishlist?
Idea’s or feedback? Please contact us!
PACKED vzw 2018 -...
Thank you!
Questions? Feedback?
Sam Donvil Alina Saenko
sam@packed.be alina@packed.be
@PACKEDvzw

More Related Content

What's hot (19)

PPT
Introducing DARIAH
Sally Chambers
 
PPT
Towards DARIAH in Belgium
Sally Chambers
 
PPT
Facilitating digital research in the humanities: from local services to Europ...
Sally Chambers
 
PDF
Connecting archaeology and architecture data
CARARE
 
PPTX
Europeana Archaeology
CARARE
 
PPTX
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage: Standards and metadata
CARARE
 
PDF
Escena Digital, a new product to dissemination of heritage
MAE Centre de Documentació i Museu de les Arts Escèniques
 
PDF
Work Package 4 - Month 6 by Sam Leon
Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana
 
PDF
CEMEC Discovery Programme discussion digital heritage
Marco Streefkerk
 
PPT
From Catalogue 2.0 to the digital humanities: exploring the future of librari...
Sally Chambers
 
PPTX
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage
CARARE
 
PPT
Dynamics and partnerships with local associations involved in LoCloud: a case...
locloud
 
PPTX
A History of Digitization - summary
Trilce Navarrete
 
PPT
Open Culture Data: Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Butigan vucaj dh_ilde
Tamara Butigan
 
PPT
130130 luxinnovation -europeana cip ict psp workshop
Patrick Peiffer
 
PDF
Dissemination of Heritage: Experience of the Museu of Performing Arts (BCN)
annavalls
 
PDF
3D reconstructions for story telling and understanding
CARARE
 
Introducing DARIAH
Sally Chambers
 
Towards DARIAH in Belgium
Sally Chambers
 
Facilitating digital research in the humanities: from local services to Europ...
Sally Chambers
 
Connecting archaeology and architecture data
CARARE
 
Europeana Archaeology
CARARE
 
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage: Standards and metadata
CARARE
 
Escena Digital, a new product to dissemination of heritage
MAE Centre de Documentació i Museu de les Arts Escèniques
 
Work Package 4 - Month 6 by Sam Leon
Digitised Manuscripts to Europeana
 
CEMEC Discovery Programme discussion digital heritage
Marco Streefkerk
 
From Catalogue 2.0 to the digital humanities: exploring the future of librari...
Sally Chambers
 
Sharing 3D Cultural Heritage
CARARE
 
Dynamics and partnerships with local associations involved in LoCloud: a case...
locloud
 
A History of Digitization - summary
Trilce Navarrete
 
Open Culture Data: Opening GLAM Data Bottom-up
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Butigan vucaj dh_ilde
Tamara Butigan
 
130130 luxinnovation -europeana cip ict psp workshop
Patrick Peiffer
 
Dissemination of Heritage: Experience of the Museu of Performing Arts (BCN)
annavalls
 
3D reconstructions for story telling and understanding
CARARE
 

Similar to Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources (20)

PDF
Shifting minds open belgium 2019
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
PDF
20190304 shifting minds open belgium 2019
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
PDF
20190304_shifting_minds_open_belgium_2019
Samuel Donvil
 
PDF
20190304 shifting minds_open_belgium_2019
PACKED vzw
 
PPT
ePSI Trailblazers
maartenbrinkerink
 
PPTX
ALIADA Project. AtCult
aliada project
 
PPT
Project "The Digital City Revives, A Case Study of Web Archaeology"
Tjarda de Haan
 
PPT
Museum digital trends_icofom
Conxa Rodà
 
PPT
Project ‘The Digital City Revives’. A Case Study of Web Archaeology
Tjarda de Haan
 
PPTX
2014 06-20 fac visual art and design bandung institute of technology ml
Monika Lechner
 
PPT
Project 'The Digital City Revives'. A Case Study of Web Archaeology
Tjarda de Haan
 
PPT
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
Antoine Isaac
 
PPT
Linking Data the ALM way (Boris Zetterlund)
Národní technická knihovna (NTK)
 
PPTX
Archive Ecologies
Shauna Jin
 
PPTX
Library information and science pptx. 2024
sayanlalbaba
 
PDF
Datahub for museums (poster)
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
PPT
Datahub for museums (poster)
PACKED vzw
 
PPT
Presentation about the project: re:DDS, Web Archaeology. The REconstruction o...
Tjarda de Haan
 
PPT
re:DDS, case study for Web Archaeology the REconstruction of De Digitale Stad
Tjarda de Haan
 
PDF
Guide for being a Culture Hack Scotland data partner v1
Sync
 
Shifting minds open belgium 2019
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
20190304 shifting minds open belgium 2019
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
20190304_shifting_minds_open_belgium_2019
Samuel Donvil
 
20190304 shifting minds_open_belgium_2019
PACKED vzw
 
ePSI Trailblazers
maartenbrinkerink
 
ALIADA Project. AtCult
aliada project
 
Project "The Digital City Revives, A Case Study of Web Archaeology"
Tjarda de Haan
 
Museum digital trends_icofom
Conxa Rodà
 
Project ‘The Digital City Revives’. A Case Study of Web Archaeology
Tjarda de Haan
 
2014 06-20 fac visual art and design bandung institute of technology ml
Monika Lechner
 
Project 'The Digital City Revives'. A Case Study of Web Archaeology
Tjarda de Haan
 
Culture Hack panel SXSW 2013
Antoine Isaac
 
Linking Data the ALM way (Boris Zetterlund)
Národní technická knihovna (NTK)
 
Archive Ecologies
Shauna Jin
 
Library information and science pptx. 2024
sayanlalbaba
 
Datahub for museums (poster)
meemoo, Vlaams instituut voor het archief
 
Datahub for museums (poster)
PACKED vzw
 
Presentation about the project: re:DDS, Web Archaeology. The REconstruction o...
Tjarda de Haan
 
re:DDS, case study for Web Archaeology the REconstruction of De Digitale Stad
Tjarda de Haan
 
Guide for being a Culture Hack Scotland data partner v1
Sync
 
Ad

More from Open Knowledge Belgium (20)

PPTX
Open Data Stories You haven't heard!
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
A​ FUNUMENTARY:​ Take what you can, give nothing back...​ ​(NOT)
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Smarter by Open Data: Process and Practice in Flevoland (NL)
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Open Knowledge for Social Innovation
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Smart Flanders: Tackling urban challenges through Open Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
EIF and NIFO connecting public administrations, businesses, and citizens
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Connecting Open data for solving the fiscal transparency puzzle in the EU
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Open Government and Networked European Democracy
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
Mundaneum Factories for Open Tokenomics
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
MIRVA: The European Open Recognition Project
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
Bike for Brussels - Open Summer of Code 2017
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
The story behind SNCB alerts
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
Traffic safety - answering tough questions with open data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
Eliminating data roadbloacks to get by traffic roadblocks without pain
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
A journey to Linked Open Touristic Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
How we use the massive open lidar dataset for the benfit of our clients
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
mu.semte.ch: A transitional architecture for Linked Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PPTX
Linked Open Chatbots
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
The role and value of making data inventories
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
PDF
Open for Business
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Open Data Stories You haven't heard!
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
A​ FUNUMENTARY:​ Take what you can, give nothing back...​ ​(NOT)
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Smarter by Open Data: Process and Practice in Flevoland (NL)
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Open Knowledge for Social Innovation
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Smart Flanders: Tackling urban challenges through Open Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
EIF and NIFO connecting public administrations, businesses, and citizens
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Connecting Open data for solving the fiscal transparency puzzle in the EU
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Open Government and Networked European Democracy
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Mundaneum Factories for Open Tokenomics
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
MIRVA: The European Open Recognition Project
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Bike for Brussels - Open Summer of Code 2017
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
The story behind SNCB alerts
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Traffic safety - answering tough questions with open data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Eliminating data roadbloacks to get by traffic roadblocks without pain
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
A journey to Linked Open Touristic Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
How we use the massive open lidar dataset for the benfit of our clients
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
mu.semte.ch: A transitional architecture for Linked Data
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Linked Open Chatbots
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
The role and value of making data inventories
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Open for Business
Open Knowledge Belgium
 
Ad

Recently uploaded (20)

PDF
McKinsey - Global Energy Perspective 2023_11.pdf
niyudha
 
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - The Physics of Requirement Sciences Through Application...
apidays
 
PPTX
HSE WEEKLY REPORT for dummies and lazzzzy.pptx
ahmedibrahim691723
 
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - The Double Life of the API Product Manager, Emmanuel Pa...
apidays
 
PDF
Key_Statistical_Techniques_in_Analytics_by_CA_Suvidha_Chaplot.pdf
CA Suvidha Chaplot
 
PPTX
Fluvial_Civilizations_Presentation (1).pptx
alisslovemendoza7
 
PPTX
Future_of_AI_Presentation for everyone.pptx
boranamanju07
 
PDF
apidays Munich 2025 - Developer Portals, API Catalogs, and Marketplaces, Miri...
apidays
 
PPTX
short term project on AI Driven Data Analytics
JMJCollegeComputerde
 
PDF
SUMMER INTERNSHIP REPORT[1] (AutoRecovered) (6) (1).pdf
pandeydiksha814
 
PPTX
Presentation (1) (1).pptx k8hhfftuiiigff
karthikjagath2005
 
PDF
202501214233242351219 QASS Session 2.pdf
lauramejiamillan
 
PPTX
Customer Segmentation: Seeing the Trees and the Forest Simultaneously
Sione Palu
 
PPTX
UVA-Ortho-PPT-Final-1.pptx Data analytics relevant to the top
chinnusindhu1
 
PPTX
Introduction to computer chapter one 2017.pptx
mensunmarley
 
PPTX
lecture 13 mind test academy it skills.pptx
ggesjmrasoolpark
 
PDF
Classifcation using Machine Learning and deep learning
bhaveshagrawal35
 
PPT
From Vision to Reality: The Digital India Revolution
Harsh Bharvadiya
 
PPTX
short term internship project on Data visualization
JMJCollegeComputerde
 
PDF
Blue Futuristic Cyber Security Presentation.pdf
tanvikhunt1003
 
McKinsey - Global Energy Perspective 2023_11.pdf
niyudha
 
apidays Munich 2025 - The Physics of Requirement Sciences Through Application...
apidays
 
HSE WEEKLY REPORT for dummies and lazzzzy.pptx
ahmedibrahim691723
 
apidays Munich 2025 - The Double Life of the API Product Manager, Emmanuel Pa...
apidays
 
Key_Statistical_Techniques_in_Analytics_by_CA_Suvidha_Chaplot.pdf
CA Suvidha Chaplot
 
Fluvial_Civilizations_Presentation (1).pptx
alisslovemendoza7
 
Future_of_AI_Presentation for everyone.pptx
boranamanju07
 
apidays Munich 2025 - Developer Portals, API Catalogs, and Marketplaces, Miri...
apidays
 
short term project on AI Driven Data Analytics
JMJCollegeComputerde
 
SUMMER INTERNSHIP REPORT[1] (AutoRecovered) (6) (1).pdf
pandeydiksha814
 
Presentation (1) (1).pptx k8hhfftuiiigff
karthikjagath2005
 
202501214233242351219 QASS Session 2.pdf
lauramejiamillan
 
Customer Segmentation: Seeing the Trees and the Forest Simultaneously
Sione Palu
 
UVA-Ortho-PPT-Final-1.pptx Data analytics relevant to the top
chinnusindhu1
 
Introduction to computer chapter one 2017.pptx
mensunmarley
 
lecture 13 mind test academy it skills.pptx
ggesjmrasoolpark
 
Classifcation using Machine Learning and deep learning
bhaveshagrawal35
 
From Vision to Reality: The Digital India Revolution
Harsh Bharvadiya
 
short term internship project on Data visualization
JMJCollegeComputerde
 
Blue Futuristic Cyber Security Presentation.pdf
tanvikhunt1003
 

Linked Open Data in limbo: Open cultural heritage resources

  • 1. Linked Open Data in limbo Co-creation as a catalyst for open cultural heritage resources Open Belgium 12.03.2018 Sam Donvil Alina Saenko [email protected] [email protected] @PACKEDvzw
  • 2. • 2006 - 2010: Platform for Archiving and Conservation of Art on Electronic and Digital Media • 2011 - present: Centre of Expertise Digital Heritage • Flemish, Belgian and European projects • Support for ICT-processes at heritage and arts organisations (o.a. creating, storage, cataloguing, online access, exchange and reuse) and policy thereof • Central concern: sustainability (digital heritage is vulnerable)
  • 3. The museum as a changing concept: antiquity > museion Role: scholarship Audience: research community
  • 4. The museum as a changing concept: renaissance > cabinet of curiosities Role: prestige, display of ‘all’ objects Audience: privileged visitors, courtiers
  • 5. The museum as a changing concept: enlightenment and modern era > birth of the modern museum Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, not necessarily display Audience: research community & privileged visitors Role: scholarship & caretaking of objects, national prestige Audience: research community, large middle class audiences
  • 6. The museum as a changing concept: contemporary era > changing consumer demands
  • 7. The museum as a changing concept: contemporary era > memory institution as an online knowledge source Future interpretation: -Share -Contextualise -Coordinate -Facilitate Conventional interpretation: -Control quality -Control access Current ICOM definition: A museum is a non-profit, permanent institution in the service of society and its development, open to the public, which acquires, conserves, researches, communicates and exhibits the tangible and intangible heritage of humanity and its environment for the purposes of education, study and enjoyment.
  • 9. Back-office: - Not a ‘popular’ topic to invest in - Often no ‘digital mindset’ inside the institutions > external IT services Data - Messy and not complete, but a lot of potential knowledge - Captured on different carriers (systems, digital and analogue files) - Often closed (and obsolete) software Audio-visual material - Different tools and DAMs, but not good enough - ‘Analogue mindset’: distributed versions and copies The situation in the Flemish artmuseums
  • 13. Resolver Persistent URI: 2016 - ... http://resolver.smak.be/collection/work/data/3385 http://smak.be/nl/kunstwerk/75872016 http://newwebsite.be/3542019 http://evenbetterwebsite.be/lod/the-journey2030
  • 14. Enrichment of data via external authorities External authorities: - Wikidata, VIAF, RKDartists, ODIS, Geonames, AAT (Getty Vocabularies), Iconclass https://www.projectcest.be/wiki/Publicatie:Project_Persist ente_identificatie
  • 15. Visualisations with internally shared data Acquisition source: From which source did a museum acquire artworks? (5 museums) - Private - Artist - Gallery - Government - The Monarchy - The Church
  • 18. Making data and images accessible
  • 19. Open Cultuur Data project
  • 20. Open data on Wikimedia platforms Why Wikimedia? ● visibility ● reuse ● engagement
  • 21. Wikidata ○ Royal Museum of Fine Arts Antwerp (7.798 artworks) ○ Museum of Fine Arts Ghent (6.973 artworks) ○ Groeningemuseum Brugge (2.858 artworks) ○ M - Museum Leuven (3.137 artworks) ○ Mu.ZEE (3.979 artworks) ○ S.M.A.K. (2.579 artworks)
  • 31. Why Linked Open Data in Limbo? digital movement <> no digital mindset reducing costs <> out-of-control IT-budgets new ‘digital’ audiences <> losing ‘traditional’ audiences showing off with fancy tools <> locked up in obsolete technology engaging with the ‘crowd’ <> abandoned web portals
  • 32. - More IT profiles in the cultural heritage sector and less dependence on the providers - More freedom to play around and test things out - Better open infrastructures and tools that make better internal workflows and LOD possible: - Back office tools: Collection Management Systems, DAMs , Datahubs… - Publishing online tools: Resolvers, API’s... - Reusing: Wikimedia art viewers, apps... - etc... - Vocal and demanding audience: - (examples of) reuse - curating/enriching data Wishlist
  • 33. - Datahub project fase 2 en 3 - Resolver-tool op Open Summer of Code 2018 - Wikimedia projects: - Public Domain publication - Publishing images and more structured data - Reusing in Wikipedia-articles and outside of the platform - Networked cultural data - survey on the current demand for cultural heritage data by various sectors Do you see yourself contributing to one of the projects or to the wishlist? Idea’s or feedback? Please contact us! PACKED vzw 2018 -...