CREATIVITY AND ROI! 
! 
in 15 minutes… 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
“…the sub-atomic particle 
of creativity is the ‘Idea” 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What is an idea?! 
! 
! 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What’s the Greatest Idea of the last 100 years? 
CARS 
JWT/Tracey Follows 2013 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
INTERNET 
MORE POPULAR 
LESS POPULAR 
MORE POPULAR 
LESS POPULAR 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Old things in a new way 
or 
New things in an old way 
OTHERWISE IT’S JUST AN OBSERVATION! 
There are definitions: 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
An idea is the meaning between 
‘what is’ and ‘what could be’ that 
connects people 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Surprise, delight, teach, shock, inspire, 
move and enthrall and exhilarate – 
ideas have the power to change the 
world, start wars or save lives. 
Never underestimate their potency. 
Various 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What’s the ROI of a…. 
Basket ball? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
KOBE = $220m 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What’s the ROI of a…. 
Piano? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
ELTON = $400m 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What’s the ROI of a…. 
Camera? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
ANNIE = $20m 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Better questions: 
1. Where do they come from? 
2. How do we know if we’ve had one? 
3. What is their value? 
4. How can we get more of them? 
5. What might stop us? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
1. Where do they come from? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
There are techniques… 
James Webb Young 
“The habit of mind 
which leads to a search 
for relationships 
between facts becomes 
of the highest 
importance in the 
production of ideas.” 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
There is hard work… 
John Hegarty 
“An idea is a thought or 
plan formed by mental 
effort” 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
2. How do we know if we’ve had one? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
There is actual science: The ‘AHA Moment’ 
1) Appears suddenly 
2) Can be processed smoothly 
3) Elicits positive affect 
4) It appears to be true 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
3. What is their value? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Basket ball? 
Remember this? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Indifference is the enemy 
of marketing expenditure 
A provocation: 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
‘Potent’ ads live longer: 
Successful ideas stick in the mind longer. 
They have slower decay rates. 
Jon Leach 2011. 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Ads that win awards are 
11 times more effective. 
IPA 2010 
They deliver value: 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
A lot of value: 
Over 2 years, advertising in the UK for 
John Lewis generated £261m 
incremental revenue 
IPA VOLUME 21 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Sustained over time: 
In China, advertising for 
Dove generated £25.5m 
incremental revenue over 
16 months 
IPA VOLUME 21 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
IPA 2013 
"Creatively awarded campaigns are 
a more reliable investment - they 
achieve greater effectiveness 
levels” 
Efficacy has been proved: 
Peter Field 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
4. How can we get more of them?! 
! 
! 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Patronage: 
Gaius Cilnius Maecenas 
Carlo de Medici 
Vincenzo Giustiniani 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
“Let us remember that most of the world’s great works 
of art are the fruit of spendaholic patronage by 
magnificos who knew how to tell the accountants 
where to go… 
The best argument in favour of generosity is that no 
one remembers a skinflint fondly.” 
Jonathan Jones, Guardian 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
5. What might stop us?! 
! 
! 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
“A provocative idea is the magic. 
It's not linked to media spend. 
A marketer's only exposure to risk is to 
not develop a powerful creative idea.” 
Bert Moore, CSO Lowe Worldwide 
A warning: 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
“The best ads tend to come from 
the highest-margin agencies” 
Laurence Green. Fallon 
A correlation: 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
What value does procurement bring at this point? 
MEDIA 
80% 
10% 
10% 
AGENCY FEEPRODUCTION 
WHY ???? 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
WTF?????? 
* Signing on fee of £1m 
* Reduction in agency fees currently paid 
* Minimum 10% saving via consolidated buying 
JULY 2010 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
Ted Levitt nails it: 
‘Consumers don’t really ‘need’ communications; it is a commercial, 
rather than a customer, imperative. 
What consumers need is better products, improved service, easier 
lives, a cleaner world, and more health and happiness.’ 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
THANK YOU 
#dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow

Mark Hancock, Planning Director, The Real Adventure Unlimited...

  • 1.
    CREATIVITY AND ROI! ! in 15 minutes… #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 2.
    “…the sub-atomic particle of creativity is the ‘Idea” #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 3.
    What is anidea?! ! ! #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 4.
  • 5.
    What’s the GreatestIdea of the last 100 years? CARS JWT/Tracey Follows 2013 #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 6.
    INTERNET MORE POPULAR LESS POPULAR MORE POPULAR LESS POPULAR #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 7.
    Old things ina new way or New things in an old way OTHERWISE IT’S JUST AN OBSERVATION! There are definitions: #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 8.
    An idea isthe meaning between ‘what is’ and ‘what could be’ that connects people #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 9.
    Surprise, delight, teach,shock, inspire, move and enthrall and exhilarate – ideas have the power to change the world, start wars or save lives. Never underestimate their potency. Various #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 10.
    What’s the ROIof a…. Basket ball? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 11.
    KOBE = $220m #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 12.
    What’s the ROIof a…. Piano? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 13.
    ELTON = $400m #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 14.
    What’s the ROIof a…. Camera? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 15.
    ANNIE = $20m #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 16.
    Better questions: 1.Where do they come from? 2. How do we know if we’ve had one? 3. What is their value? 4. How can we get more of them? 5. What might stop us? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 17.
    1. Where dothey come from? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 18.
    There are techniques… James Webb Young “The habit of mind which leads to a search for relationships between facts becomes of the highest importance in the production of ideas.” #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 19.
    There is hardwork… John Hegarty “An idea is a thought or plan formed by mental effort” #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 20.
    2. How dowe know if we’ve had one? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 21.
    There is actualscience: The ‘AHA Moment’ 1) Appears suddenly 2) Can be processed smoothly 3) Elicits positive affect 4) It appears to be true #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 22.
    3. What istheir value? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 23.
    Basket ball? Rememberthis? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 24.
    Indifference is theenemy of marketing expenditure A provocation: #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 25.
    ‘Potent’ ads livelonger: Successful ideas stick in the mind longer. They have slower decay rates. Jon Leach 2011. #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 26.
    Ads that winawards are 11 times more effective. IPA 2010 They deliver value: #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 27.
    A lot ofvalue: Over 2 years, advertising in the UK for John Lewis generated £261m incremental revenue IPA VOLUME 21 #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 28.
    Sustained over time: In China, advertising for Dove generated £25.5m incremental revenue over 16 months IPA VOLUME 21 #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 29.
    IPA 2013 "Creativelyawarded campaigns are a more reliable investment - they achieve greater effectiveness levels” Efficacy has been proved: Peter Field #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 30.
    4. How canwe get more of them?! ! ! #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 31.
    Patronage: Gaius CilniusMaecenas Carlo de Medici Vincenzo Giustiniani #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36.
  • 37.
    “Let us rememberthat most of the world’s great works of art are the fruit of spendaholic patronage by magnificos who knew how to tell the accountants where to go… The best argument in favour of generosity is that no one remembers a skinflint fondly.” Jonathan Jones, Guardian #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 38.
    5. What mightstop us?! ! ! #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 39.
    “A provocative ideais the magic. It's not linked to media spend. A marketer's only exposure to risk is to not develop a powerful creative idea.” Bert Moore, CSO Lowe Worldwide A warning: #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 40.
    “The best adstend to come from the highest-margin agencies” Laurence Green. Fallon A correlation: #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 41.
    What value doesprocurement bring at this point? MEDIA 80% 10% 10% AGENCY FEEPRODUCTION WHY ???? #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 42.
    WTF?????? * Signingon fee of £1m * Reduction in agency fees currently paid * Minimum 10% saving via consolidated buying JULY 2010 #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 43.
    Ted Levitt nailsit: ‘Consumers don’t really ‘need’ communications; it is a commercial, rather than a customer, imperative. What consumers need is better products, improved service, easier lives, a cleaner world, and more health and happiness.’ #dmaZEDTalks Mark Hancock @holycow
  • 44.
    THANK YOU #dmaZEDTalksMark Hancock @holycow