Methods and Models of Health
Education
Col Zulfiquer Ahmed Amin
M Phil, MPH, PGD (Health Economics), MBBS
Armed Forces Medical Institute (AFMI)
What is ‘Method’ and ‘Model’
Method:
A procedure, technique, or way of doing
something, especially in accordance with a
definite plan.
It is operational.
Model:
A standard or example for imitation or
comparison.
It is abstract, theory, conceptual.
Methods of health education
Methods of health education are the techniques or
ways in which series of activities are carried out to
communicate ideas, information and develops
necessary skills and attitude.
Methods of Health Education
home and interacting with individual and family member
Types of Individual HE Method
Ø Moderator summarizes and highlights the points
Ø Audience are allowed to put questions and seek
clarification
Ø Example: Talk-Show in presence of audience
Ø In the end, audience may ask questions
Example: Formation Study period
Seminar
Example: Seminar on Bird Flu
Large gathering of individuals or members of one or several
organizations, for discussing matters of common interest.
Example: Annual General Meeting (AGM)
In workshops participants get fully involved in the
learning process: small and large group discussions,
activities & exercises, opportunities to practice applying
the concepts that are presented.
Example: Workshop on CPR by presence of intensivists
Brainstorming is a group creativity technique by which
efforts are made to find a conclusion for a specific
problem by gathering a list of ideas spontaneously
contributed by its members.
BUZZ GROUP
• A large group is divided into small groups, of
not more than 10-12 people in each small
group and they are given a time to discuss the
problem.
• Then, the whole group is reconvened and the
reporters of the small groups will report their
findings and recommendation
A campaign is an intensive activity undertaken at an opportune
moment for a brief period, focusing attention in a concerted
manner towards a particular problem so as to stimulate the
widest possible interest in the community.
Campaign method is used only after found acceptable to the
local people.
Campaigns maximize their chances of success through the
coordination of media efforts with a mix of other interpersonal
and community-based communication channels.
Example: EPI Campaign
● A focus group discussion (FGD) is a good way to
gather together people from similar backgrounds or
experiences to discuss a specific topic of interest.
● Focus group discussion is one of the most popular
qualitative research methods.
● It is a discussion guided by the moderator according
to the prepared interview guidelines.
● The survey is carried out in several groups of not less
than 6 and not more than 12 persons selected in
accordance with the research aims.
● Carefully developed 5-6 questions.
● The optimal duration of a group discussion is 1.5 - 2
hours.
The warm atmosphere created during an interview and
encouraged by the moderator allows disclosing participants'
habits, convictions, opinions, preferences, tastes, associations,
etc.
Consequently, the focus group discussion reveals mental maps,
stream of consciousness, latent demands.
● A systematic forecasting method that involves structured
interaction among a group of experts on a subject.
● The Delphi Technique typically includes at least two
rounds of experts answering questions and giving
justification for their answers, providing the opportunity
between rounds for changes and revisions.
● The multiple rounds, which are stopped after a pre-
defined criterion is reached, enable the group of experts
to arrive at a consensus forecast on the subject being
discussed.
• The Delphi Method seeks to achieve a consensus
among the group members through a series of
questionnaires.
• The series of questionnaires sent either by email or
via computerized system, to a pre-selected group of
experts.
• Nobody ‘looses face’, because the questionnaires are
answered anonymously
• The answers are summarized and sent back to the
group members along with the next questionnaire.
• This process is repeated until a group consensus is
reached. This usually only takes two iterations, but
can sometimes takes as as many as six rounds before
any consensus is reached
□ e-Health
□ m-Health
mHealth (mobile health) is a general term for
the use of mobile phones and other wireless
technology in medical care. The most common
application of mHealth is the use of mobile
phones and communication devices to educate
consumers about preventive health care
services.
E-Health is short for electronic health. E-health simply means the
application of the latest information and communication
technologies in all health-related fields such as collecting,
storing, restoring, analyzing and managing the information,
unifying the electronic health records, disseminating and sharing
medical information, surgeries and healthcare remotely.
Which one is the right method of
Health Education?
□ Medical Model
□ Motivational Model
□ Social Intervention Model
Medical Model
● Did not bridge the gap between knowledge and behavior
Motivation Model of Health Education
‘Motivation Model’ of Health Education
conceptualizes that people are motivated to
change behavior to healthy practices, when a
particular health-behavior addresses or arouse
their ‘need’. In other word, needs and wants of
the individuals have to be tackled by framing an
incentive plan.
1. The Rational Model This model, also known as the
“knowledge, attitudes, practices model” (KAP), is based on the
premise that increasing a person’s knowledge will prompt a
behaviour change.
2. The Health Belief Model (HBM): Human health decision-
making and subsequent behaviour is based on the following six
constructs:
- perceived susceptibility,
- severity,
- benefits and barriers,
- cues to action and
- self-efficacy.
This model proposes that people, when presented with a risk
message, engage in two appraisal processes: a determination of
whether they are susceptible to the threat and whether the
threat is severe; and whether the recommended action can
reduce that threat (i.e. response efficacy) and whether they can
successfully perform the recommended action (i.e. self-efficacy).
Health Belief Model (HBM)
● Perceived susceptibility.
The subjective perception of the risk the individual is at
from a state or condition.
● Perceived severity.
Subjective evaluation of the seriousness of the
consequences associated with the state or condition.
● Perceived threat.
The product/sum of severity and susceptibility. This
combined quantum might be seen as indicative of the
level of motivation an individual has to act to avoid a
particular outcome.
HBM
● Perceived benefits.
The subjectively understood positive benefits of taking a
health action to offset a perceived threat. This
perception will be influenced not only by specific
proximal factors, but an individual’s overall ‘health
motivation’.
● Perceived barriers.
The perceived negatively valued aspects of taking the
action, or overcoming anticipated barriers to taking it.
● Self -efficacy.
Belief in one’s ability to execute a given behaviour.
● Expectations, which are the product/sum of perceived
benefits, barriers and self-efficacy. This may be seen as
indicative of the extent to which the individual will try to
take a given action.
● Cues to action.
Reminders or prompts to take actions consistent with an
intention, ranging from advertising to personal
communications from health professionals, family
members and/or peers.
● Demographic and socio-economic variables.
These may include age, race, ethnicity (cultural identity),
education and income.
3. The trans-theoretical model of change. Behaviour change is
viewed as a progression through a series of five stages: Pre-
contemplation, Contemplation, Preparation, Action and
Maintenance. People have specific informational needs at each
stage, and health educators can offer the most effective
intervention strategies based on the recipients’ stage of change.
4. The theory of planned behaviour: The theory holds
that intent is influenced not only by the attitude towards
behaviour but also the perception of social norms (the
strength of others’ opinions on the behaviour and a
person’s own motivation to comply with those of
significant others).
5. The activated health education model: This is a three-
phase model that actively engages individuals in the
assessment of their health (experiential phase); presents
information and creates awareness of the target
behaviour (awareness phase); and facilitates its
identification and clarification of personal health values
and develops a customized plan for behaviour change
(responsibility phase).
6. Social cognitive theory: According to this theory, three main
factors affect the likelihood that a person will change health
behaviour: self-efficacy, goals and outcome expectancies. If
individuals have a sense of self-efficacy, they can change
behaviour even when faced with obstacles.
7. Communication theory: This theory holds that multilevel
strategies are necessary depending on who is being targeted,
such as tailored messages at the individual level, targeted
messages at the group level, social marketing at the community
level, media advocacy at the policy level and mass media
campaigns at the population level.
8. Diffusion of innovation theory: This theory holds that there
are five categories of people:
innovators, early adopters, early majority adopters, late majority
adopters and laggards; and the numbers in each category are
distributed normally: the classic bell curve. By identifying the
characteristics of people in each adopter category, health
educators can more effectively plan and implement strategies
that are customized to their needs.
Diffusion of Innovation
Early adopters tend to be integrated into the local social system more than
innovators. People in the early adopter category seem to have the greatest degree of
opinion leadership in most social systems. They provide advice and information sought
by other adopters about an innovation. Change agents will seek out early adopters to
help speed the diffusion process. The early adopter is usually respected by his or her
peers and has a reputation for successful and discrete use of new ideas.
Methods and Models of Health Education
Methods and Models of Health Education

Methods and Models of Health Education

  • 1.
    Methods and Modelsof Health Education Col Zulfiquer Ahmed Amin M Phil, MPH, PGD (Health Economics), MBBS Armed Forces Medical Institute (AFMI)
  • 2.
    What is ‘Method’and ‘Model’ Method: A procedure, technique, or way of doing something, especially in accordance with a definite plan. It is operational. Model: A standard or example for imitation or comparison. It is abstract, theory, conceptual.
  • 3.
    Methods of healtheducation Methods of health education are the techniques or ways in which series of activities are carried out to communicate ideas, information and develops necessary skills and attitude.
  • 5.
  • 6.
    home and interactingwith individual and family member
  • 9.
  • 23.
    Ø Moderator summarizesand highlights the points Ø Audience are allowed to put questions and seek clarification Ø Example: Talk-Show in presence of audience
  • 24.
    Ø In theend, audience may ask questions
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
    Large gathering ofindividuals or members of one or several organizations, for discussing matters of common interest. Example: Annual General Meeting (AGM)
  • 29.
    In workshops participantsget fully involved in the learning process: small and large group discussions, activities & exercises, opportunities to practice applying the concepts that are presented. Example: Workshop on CPR by presence of intensivists
  • 32.
    Brainstorming is agroup creativity technique by which efforts are made to find a conclusion for a specific problem by gathering a list of ideas spontaneously contributed by its members.
  • 33.
    BUZZ GROUP • Alarge group is divided into small groups, of not more than 10-12 people in each small group and they are given a time to discuss the problem. • Then, the whole group is reconvened and the reporters of the small groups will report their findings and recommendation
  • 35.
    A campaign isan intensive activity undertaken at an opportune moment for a brief period, focusing attention in a concerted manner towards a particular problem so as to stimulate the widest possible interest in the community. Campaign method is used only after found acceptable to the local people. Campaigns maximize their chances of success through the coordination of media efforts with a mix of other interpersonal and community-based communication channels. Example: EPI Campaign
  • 37.
    ● A focusgroup discussion (FGD) is a good way to gather together people from similar backgrounds or experiences to discuss a specific topic of interest. ● Focus group discussion is one of the most popular qualitative research methods. ● It is a discussion guided by the moderator according to the prepared interview guidelines. ● The survey is carried out in several groups of not less than 6 and not more than 12 persons selected in accordance with the research aims. ● Carefully developed 5-6 questions. ● The optimal duration of a group discussion is 1.5 - 2 hours.
  • 38.
    The warm atmospherecreated during an interview and encouraged by the moderator allows disclosing participants' habits, convictions, opinions, preferences, tastes, associations, etc. Consequently, the focus group discussion reveals mental maps, stream of consciousness, latent demands.
  • 40.
    ● A systematicforecasting method that involves structured interaction among a group of experts on a subject. ● The Delphi Technique typically includes at least two rounds of experts answering questions and giving justification for their answers, providing the opportunity between rounds for changes and revisions. ● The multiple rounds, which are stopped after a pre- defined criterion is reached, enable the group of experts to arrive at a consensus forecast on the subject being discussed.
  • 41.
    • The DelphiMethod seeks to achieve a consensus among the group members through a series of questionnaires. • The series of questionnaires sent either by email or via computerized system, to a pre-selected group of experts. • Nobody ‘looses face’, because the questionnaires are answered anonymously • The answers are summarized and sent back to the group members along with the next questionnaire. • This process is repeated until a group consensus is reached. This usually only takes two iterations, but can sometimes takes as as many as six rounds before any consensus is reached
  • 46.
  • 47.
    mHealth (mobile health)is a general term for the use of mobile phones and other wireless technology in medical care. The most common application of mHealth is the use of mobile phones and communication devices to educate consumers about preventive health care services.
  • 48.
    E-Health is shortfor electronic health. E-health simply means the application of the latest information and communication technologies in all health-related fields such as collecting, storing, restoring, analyzing and managing the information, unifying the electronic health records, disseminating and sharing medical information, surgeries and healthcare remotely.
  • 50.
    Which one isthe right method of Health Education?
  • 51.
    □ Medical Model □Motivational Model □ Social Intervention Model
  • 52.
    Medical Model ● Didnot bridge the gap between knowledge and behavior
  • 54.
    Motivation Model ofHealth Education ‘Motivation Model’ of Health Education conceptualizes that people are motivated to change behavior to healthy practices, when a particular health-behavior addresses or arouse their ‘need’. In other word, needs and wants of the individuals have to be tackled by framing an incentive plan.
  • 58.
    1. The RationalModel This model, also known as the “knowledge, attitudes, practices model” (KAP), is based on the premise that increasing a person’s knowledge will prompt a behaviour change. 2. The Health Belief Model (HBM): Human health decision- making and subsequent behaviour is based on the following six constructs: - perceived susceptibility, - severity, - benefits and barriers, - cues to action and - self-efficacy. This model proposes that people, when presented with a risk message, engage in two appraisal processes: a determination of whether they are susceptible to the threat and whether the threat is severe; and whether the recommended action can reduce that threat (i.e. response efficacy) and whether they can successfully perform the recommended action (i.e. self-efficacy).
  • 59.
  • 60.
    ● Perceived susceptibility. Thesubjective perception of the risk the individual is at from a state or condition. ● Perceived severity. Subjective evaluation of the seriousness of the consequences associated with the state or condition. ● Perceived threat. The product/sum of severity and susceptibility. This combined quantum might be seen as indicative of the level of motivation an individual has to act to avoid a particular outcome. HBM
  • 61.
    ● Perceived benefits. Thesubjectively understood positive benefits of taking a health action to offset a perceived threat. This perception will be influenced not only by specific proximal factors, but an individual’s overall ‘health motivation’. ● Perceived barriers. The perceived negatively valued aspects of taking the action, or overcoming anticipated barriers to taking it. ● Self -efficacy. Belief in one’s ability to execute a given behaviour.
  • 62.
    ● Expectations, whichare the product/sum of perceived benefits, barriers and self-efficacy. This may be seen as indicative of the extent to which the individual will try to take a given action. ● Cues to action. Reminders or prompts to take actions consistent with an intention, ranging from advertising to personal communications from health professionals, family members and/or peers. ● Demographic and socio-economic variables. These may include age, race, ethnicity (cultural identity), education and income.
  • 63.
    3. The trans-theoreticalmodel of change. Behaviour change is viewed as a progression through a series of five stages: Pre- contemplation, Contemplation, Preparation, Action and Maintenance. People have specific informational needs at each stage, and health educators can offer the most effective intervention strategies based on the recipients’ stage of change.
  • 64.
    4. The theoryof planned behaviour: The theory holds that intent is influenced not only by the attitude towards behaviour but also the perception of social norms (the strength of others’ opinions on the behaviour and a person’s own motivation to comply with those of significant others). 5. The activated health education model: This is a three- phase model that actively engages individuals in the assessment of their health (experiential phase); presents information and creates awareness of the target behaviour (awareness phase); and facilitates its identification and clarification of personal health values and develops a customized plan for behaviour change (responsibility phase).
  • 66.
    6. Social cognitivetheory: According to this theory, three main factors affect the likelihood that a person will change health behaviour: self-efficacy, goals and outcome expectancies. If individuals have a sense of self-efficacy, they can change behaviour even when faced with obstacles.
  • 67.
    7. Communication theory:This theory holds that multilevel strategies are necessary depending on who is being targeted, such as tailored messages at the individual level, targeted messages at the group level, social marketing at the community level, media advocacy at the policy level and mass media campaigns at the population level. 8. Diffusion of innovation theory: This theory holds that there are five categories of people: innovators, early adopters, early majority adopters, late majority adopters and laggards; and the numbers in each category are distributed normally: the classic bell curve. By identifying the characteristics of people in each adopter category, health educators can more effectively plan and implement strategies that are customized to their needs.
  • 68.
    Diffusion of Innovation Earlyadopters tend to be integrated into the local social system more than innovators. People in the early adopter category seem to have the greatest degree of opinion leadership in most social systems. They provide advice and information sought by other adopters about an innovation. Change agents will seek out early adopters to help speed the diffusion process. The early adopter is usually respected by his or her peers and has a reputation for successful and discrete use of new ideas.