DOMAIN FORUM, DECEMBER 5, 2014 
New gTLDs, Year One
NEW gTLDs, YEAR ONE 
Stéphane Van Gelder 
Chairman Milathan 
GNSO Chair (2010-2013) 
NomCom Chair (2014-2015)
ONE YEAR OF DELEGATIONS
FIRST NEW GTLDS TO BE DELEGATED 
4 IDN New gTLDs were first to be added 
to the root on October 23, 2013
ONE YEAR OF EVALUATIONS 
All 1930 applications received by ICANN 
in June 2012 have now gone through 
Initial Evaluation.
CURRENT STATUS 
1586 passed IE 
292 withdrawn 
52 unlikely to proceed
BREAKDOWN OF 1586 IE PASSES 
1176 invited to contracting 
540 signed 
582 in process 
54 awaiting response
BREAKDOWN OF 1586 IE PASSES 
410 not yet eligible 
5 objections 
18 GAC advice 
390 in contention
END RESULT… 
418 new gTLDs delegated mid October 
2014
LET’S TALK NUMBERS
INITIAL ICANN FORECAST 
ICANN FY 2015 (up to June 30, 2015) 
Forecast: 
33 million new gTLD domains 
https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/proposed-opplan-budget-fy15-09may14-en.pdf
REAL REGISTRATION NUMBERS 
Stats on November 1, 2014: 
3 million* names registered 
*3 071 320 on Nov 1, 2014 http://ntldstats.com/
REVISED ICANN FORECAST 
On September 16, 2014, ICANN adopted 
revised budget: 
15 million new gTLD domains 
https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/adopted-opplan-budget-fy15-16sep14-en.pdf
FIRST TO ONE MILLION 
On October 13, 2014, Donuts became 
the first new gTLD registry to reach one 
million registrations with: heavenly.coffee 
http://www.donuts.co/news/donuts-registers-one-millionth-new-gtld-address/#more-2739
NEW gTLD TOP 10 
XYZ 706 634 
BERLIN 153 742 
CLUB 133 121 
REALTOR 83 929 
WANG 82 151 
GURU 75 685 
OVH 54 280 
NYC 54 060 
LONDON 49 650 
PHOTOGRAPHY 47 809 
On 11 Nov 
2014
BUSINESS MODEL ANALYSIS
FREE DOMAINS 
For example: .XYZ or .OVH
PLUSES 
þ High registration volumes 
þ Visibility 
þ Domains as "hook" for other products
MINUSES 
ý Registry image 
ý Lower perception of worth for DNs 
ý No revenue for registry
GENERICS 
For example: .CLUB or .GURU
PLUSES 
þ More diversity in namespace 
þ Better suited to new uses 
þ More likely to speak to general public
MINUSES 
ý Just another Dot COM? 
ý Too many generic TLDs to count? 
ý TM protection
GEOs 
For example: .BERLIN or .LONDON
PLUSES 
þ Geo and cultural links 
þ Easy for public to identify with TLD 
þ Boost to public services
MINUSES 
ý Overlap with equivalent ccTLD? 
ý Registration rules can be complex 
ý Of limited interest outside region
IDNs 
For example: . 公司 or . 在线
þ New markets 
þ New uses 
þ New users 
PLUSES
MINUSES 
ý Technical complexity 
ý Risk of user exclusion? 
ý Universal Acceptance
WHAT NOW? 
Missed the boat? 
Got great ideas for a TLD? 
Worried there are too many already? 
… 
There will be a next round!
NEXT ROUND, WHEN? 
ICANN to evaluate current round and 
build on this experience.
ROUND 1 REVIEW 
Areas being reviewed: 
þ Program operations 
þ Applicant support program 
þ Application processing & evaluation 
þ Contention resolution 
þ Objection process & dispute resolution 
þ Contracting & transition to delegation
ROUND 1 REVIEW 
Each area reviewed on 6 criteria: 
þ Efficiency 
þ Effectiveness 
þ Fairness 
þ Predictability 
þ Security & stability 
þ Alignment with policy & implementation guidance
EXPECTED TIMELINE
NEXT ROUND, IN 2018-2019? 
ICANN now saying work on Round 1 will 
not complete until 2017 at earliest. 
Subsequent community Round 2 
development work expected to take more 
than a year…
THANKS! 
Questions? 
Too shy to ask now? Email me on 
svg@milathan.com

Milathan domain forum

  • 1.
    DOMAIN FORUM, DECEMBER5, 2014 New gTLDs, Year One
  • 2.
    NEW gTLDs, YEARONE Stéphane Van Gelder Chairman Milathan GNSO Chair (2010-2013) NomCom Chair (2014-2015)
  • 3.
    ONE YEAR OFDELEGATIONS
  • 4.
    FIRST NEW GTLDSTO BE DELEGATED 4 IDN New gTLDs were first to be added to the root on October 23, 2013
  • 5.
    ONE YEAR OFEVALUATIONS All 1930 applications received by ICANN in June 2012 have now gone through Initial Evaluation.
  • 6.
    CURRENT STATUS 1586passed IE 292 withdrawn 52 unlikely to proceed
  • 7.
    BREAKDOWN OF 1586IE PASSES 1176 invited to contracting 540 signed 582 in process 54 awaiting response
  • 8.
    BREAKDOWN OF 1586IE PASSES 410 not yet eligible 5 objections 18 GAC advice 390 in contention
  • 9.
    END RESULT… 418new gTLDs delegated mid October 2014
  • 10.
  • 11.
    INITIAL ICANN FORECAST ICANN FY 2015 (up to June 30, 2015) Forecast: 33 million new gTLD domains https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/proposed-opplan-budget-fy15-09may14-en.pdf
  • 12.
    REAL REGISTRATION NUMBERS Stats on November 1, 2014: 3 million* names registered *3 071 320 on Nov 1, 2014 http://ntldstats.com/
  • 13.
    REVISED ICANN FORECAST On September 16, 2014, ICANN adopted revised budget: 15 million new gTLD domains https://www.icann.org/en/system/files/files/adopted-opplan-budget-fy15-16sep14-en.pdf
  • 14.
    FIRST TO ONEMILLION On October 13, 2014, Donuts became the first new gTLD registry to reach one million registrations with: heavenly.coffee http://www.donuts.co/news/donuts-registers-one-millionth-new-gtld-address/#more-2739
  • 15.
    NEW gTLD TOP10 XYZ 706 634 BERLIN 153 742 CLUB 133 121 REALTOR 83 929 WANG 82 151 GURU 75 685 OVH 54 280 NYC 54 060 LONDON 49 650 PHOTOGRAPHY 47 809 On 11 Nov 2014
  • 16.
  • 17.
    FREE DOMAINS Forexample: .XYZ or .OVH
  • 18.
    PLUSES þ Highregistration volumes þ Visibility þ Domains as "hook" for other products
  • 19.
    MINUSES ý Registryimage ý Lower perception of worth for DNs ý No revenue for registry
  • 20.
    GENERICS For example:.CLUB or .GURU
  • 21.
    PLUSES þ Morediversity in namespace þ Better suited to new uses þ More likely to speak to general public
  • 22.
    MINUSES ý Justanother Dot COM? ý Too many generic TLDs to count? ý TM protection
  • 23.
    GEOs For example:.BERLIN or .LONDON
  • 24.
    PLUSES þ Geoand cultural links þ Easy for public to identify with TLD þ Boost to public services
  • 25.
    MINUSES ý Overlapwith equivalent ccTLD? ý Registration rules can be complex ý Of limited interest outside region
  • 26.
    IDNs For example:. 公司 or . 在线
  • 27.
    þ New markets þ New uses þ New users PLUSES
  • 28.
    MINUSES ý Technicalcomplexity ý Risk of user exclusion? ý Universal Acceptance
  • 29.
    WHAT NOW? Missedthe boat? Got great ideas for a TLD? Worried there are too many already? … There will be a next round!
  • 30.
    NEXT ROUND, WHEN? ICANN to evaluate current round and build on this experience.
  • 31.
    ROUND 1 REVIEW Areas being reviewed: þ Program operations þ Applicant support program þ Application processing & evaluation þ Contention resolution þ Objection process & dispute resolution þ Contracting & transition to delegation
  • 32.
    ROUND 1 REVIEW Each area reviewed on 6 criteria: þ Efficiency þ Effectiveness þ Fairness þ Predictability þ Security & stability þ Alignment with policy & implementation guidance
  • 33.
  • 34.
    NEXT ROUND, IN2018-2019? ICANN now saying work on Round 1 will not complete until 2017 at earliest. Subsequent community Round 2 development work expected to take more than a year…
  • 35.
    THANKS! Questions? Tooshy to ask now? Email me on [email protected]