DISTANCE LEARNING
    ARCHITECTURE




          Professor Mike Keppell
Director, The Flexible Learning Institute &
      Professor of Higher Education
         Charles Sturt University

                     1
                                              1
2
    2
MULTI-CAMPUSES




      3
                 3
QUESTIONS

How many work at a
distance education
university?

How many have
studied a subject or
degree via distance?

How many have
undertaken continuing
education courses at a
distance?
                         4
                             4
What                  When




        Distance
Why     Learning      Where
       Architecture




Who                   How

             5


                              5
CHALLENGES

Distance education
landscape

Learning and teaching

Learning spaces

Assessment

Transformation

                        6
                            6
WHAT IS DISTANCE
  EDUCATION?

 WHAT IS DISTANCE
   LEARNING?

WHAT IS A DISTANCE
   LEARNER?
         7
                     7
WHAT IS DISTANCE
EDUCATION AND LEARNING?
System of education in which the majority of learning
takes place with the learner and the teacher
separated by space and/or time, the gap
between the two being bridged by technology (DEHub).

Distance learning can cater for a wide variety of
diverse needs for both on-campus and distance learners
and is usually characterised by greater flexibility for
the learner, convenience of time and place for learning
and the ability to work at one’s own pace (DEHub).


                          8
                                                          8
DISTANCE LEARNER

A distance learner is
one who experiences the
majority (80+%) of their
learning off-campus at a
distance from the teacher
and consequently has
limited face-to-face
interaction with their
teachers and peers
(DEHub).

                            9
                                9
LEARNING & TEACHING
         10
                      10
Print               Online




      Blended                     Face-to-Face


                     DVD



When should print/DVD/online/F2F/blended be used?
                        11
                                                    11
DESIGN FOR DISTANCE
          LEARNING
Distance education requires a
redesign of degree/course/
subject/activity structure.
Access and equity issues
Degree experience versus
subject experience
Learning for now and learning
for the future
Graduate attributes
Capstone
                            12
                                 12
TEACHER-STUDENT
             DYNAMIC

Distance education requires
distinctive learning and
teaching strategies.

Mix of independent learning
and peer learning

Mix of synchronous and
asynchronous interactions

Importance of feedback

                              13
                                   13
INTERACTIONS

Information access

Interactive learning

Networked learning

Student-generated
content

(Herrington & Oliver
2001).

                       14
                            14
COMMUNICATION
            STRATEGIES


Distance education requires
different methods of
communication using
electronic technologies.

Synchronous & asynchronous

Written, voice, video

e.g. podcasts
                              15
                                   15
CHALLENGES

Design of degrees, subjects, activities, assessment

Proportion of synchronous and asynchronous
interactions.

Synchronous and asynchronous communication

Proportion of independent and peer learning

How do you teach when you can’t see facial
expressions?

                            16
                                                      16
WHAT TOOLS ASSIST
DISTANCE LEARNING?




        17
                     17
Tools                                    Affordance

                                            information access, interactive
  Learning Management Systems
                                        learning, networked learning, student-
   (Moodle, Sakai, Blackboard)
                                                   generated content

Teleconferences, videoconferences,
                                                       synchronous
             Skype

        Podcasts, vodcasts                             asynchronous

   Web-conferencing tools (e.g.
                                                       participation
      elluminate, wimba)


web 2.0 tools (YouTube, Facebook,           social networking, student-generated
  blogs, wikis, Twitter, Flickr, etc                      content


                                       18
                                                                                   18
WHAT SPACES ARE USED FOR
  DISTANCE LEARNING?
           19
                           19
DIVERSITY OF LEARNING SPACES

     Physical             Blended                Virtual


Formal     Informal                    Formal         Informal



                Mobile              Personal


                                  Professional
                Outdoor
                                    Practice
                             20
                                                                 20
FORMAL & INFORMAL SPACES




            21
                           21
VIRTUAL LEARNING SPACES


Formal virtual learning spaces
Informal virtual learning spaces
Independent learning
Peer learning




                       22
                                   22
Formal Virtual        Informal Virtual
Learning Spaces        Learning Spaces

   Moodle                  Facebook
    Sakai                    Flickr
 Blackboard                YouTube
                            Twitter


  Formal                     Formal
                                I
                            Informal
  Informal

                  23
                                          23
FLEXIBILITY OF LEARNING SPACES
 Flexible learning and teaching spaces allow
 adaptability over time for different uses.
 Spaces need to be used for students who are both
 physically present and students who never visit the
 campus.
 In addition homes, cars, buses, hotels, cafes become
 mobile spaces where the student undertakes
 learning.
 Studying subject materials while travelling to work via
 train or bus may represent the learning space for
 some students
                          24
                                                           24
25
     25
26
     26
ASSESSMENT
    27
             27
WHAT IS ASSESSMENT?


 Formative and Summative
 Assessment OF Learning
 Assessment FOR Learning
 Assessment AS Learning
 Learning-Oriented Assessment


                 28
                                28
FORMATIVE AND
SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT
Formative Assessment               Summative Assessment


Assessment FOR learning            Assessment OF learning

Generally carried out              Generally carried out at the
during a course or project.        end of a course or project.

Typically used to provide
                                   Typically used to assign
students with feedback to
                                   students a grade or mark.
aid learning.
Common forms: self-                Common forms:
assessment, peer-                  examination, written final
assessment                         assignment
                              29
                                                                  29
ASSESSMENT OF
           LEARNING
Predominant form of assessment
Usually summative
Certifies student learning
Used to report about progress
Usually consists of tests or exams
Represented by marks or letter grades
Feedback is usually in the form of marks or grades
Often used for a comparison between students
(Earl, 2003).
                        30
                                                     30
ASSESSMENT FOR
          LEARNING
Shifts emphasis from summative to formative
Shifts emphasis from making judgements to
descriptions which are useful for the next stage of
learning
Focuses on feedback to enhance individual
students learning
Still focused on the teacher’s role in the
assessment process (Earl, 2003).


                         31
                                                      31
ASSESSMENT AS
          LEARNING
Emphasises the student’s role in the
assessment process
Students are regarded as active, engaged and
critical assessors
Students monitor what they are learning - make
adjustments, adaptations and major
adjustments to their own learning
Self assessment is the heart of the matter (Earl,
2003).

                       32
                                                    32
LEARNING-ORIENTED
   ASSESSMENT

Assessment tasks AS learning tasks
Students as self-evaluators
Feedback as feedforward


                 (Carless, Joughin, Liu, 2006;
                       Keppell & Carless, 2006)



                  33
                                                  33
ONE OF THE GREATEST
 CHALLENGES IN HIGHER
EDUCATION IS TO DESIGN
SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT
   THAT PERFORMS A
  FORMATIVE FUNCTION
(CARLESS, JOUGHIN, LIU,
      2006, P.8)
           34
                          34
ASSESSMENT TASKS AS
    LEARNING TASKS
Assessment tasks need to promote desired learning
outcomes and dispositions
Constructive alignment of objectives, content and
assessment (Biggs, 1999)
Tasks should require distribution of student time and
effort throughout, not just short bursts of energy
towards the end (Gibbs & Simpson, 2004)
A relationship between assessment tasks and real-
world tasks, cooperative rather than competitive tasks
Some degree of student choice in assessment tasks.
                         35
                                                         35
Learning-oriented assessment




                         Student
Assessment tasks     involvement in      Forward-looking
as learning tasks      assessment           feedback
                        processes




                            36
                                                           36
FORWARD-LOOKING
      FEEDBACK

Students need to receive appropriate feedback which
they can use to ‘feed forward’ into future work.
Feedback should be less final and judgemental
(Boud, 1995)
Feedback should be more interactive and forward-
looking (Carless, 2002)
Feedback should be timely and with a potential to
be acted upon (Gibbs & Simpson, 2004)

                       37
                                                      37
TEACHING FELLOWSHIPS
         38
                       38
SUPPORT & STRATEGIC CHANGE
  OF LEARNING & TEACHING
                                    • Sakai
                      Division of   • Professional
                     Learning and       Development
                       Teaching     •   Educational
                       Services         Designers

                 •    Teaching
  The Flexible        Fellowships    The Education
   Learning      •    Standards       for Practice
   Institute     •    Learning          Institute
                      Spaces
                 •    Policy
                           39
                                                      39
FLEXIBLE LEARNING

“Flexible learning” provides opportunities to
improve the student learning experience through
flexibility in time, pace, place (physical, virtual, on-
campus, off-campus), mode of study (print-based,
face-to-face, blended, online), teaching approach
(collaborative, independent), forms of assessment
and staffing. It may utilise a wide range of media,
environments, learning spaces and technologies for
learning and teaching.

                          40
                                                          40
BLENDED & FLEXIBLE
         LEARNING


“Blended and flexible learning” is a design
approach that examines the relationships between
flexible learning opportunities, in order to optimise
student engagement and equivalence in learning
outcomes regardless of mode of study (Keppell,
2010, p. 3).



                         41
                                                       41
REDESIGN OF COURSES &
   SUBJECTS THROUGH
 BLENDED AND FLEXIBLE
        LEARNING




          42
                        42
TEACHING FELLOWSHIP
        SCHEME
Funded by DVC (Academic)

Development of potential leaders through
Distributive leadership

Facilitate collaborative professional
relationships

Proactively redesign courses and subjects

Promote and facilitate CSU Interact as a pivotal
teaching and learning hub.

                         43
                                                   43
TEACHING FELLOWSHIP
         SCHEME

Participation of all twenty-four schools at the
university

2008 - 6 fellows; 2009 - 5 fellows; 2010 - 5 fellows; 2011
- 6 fellows

The Fellowship scheme provides a .5 release from
regular teaching duties over a 12 month period.




                           44
                                                             44
CHALLENGES

Distance education
landscape

Learning and teaching

Learning spaces

Assessment

Transformation

                        45
                             45
46
     46
http://www.csu.edu.au/division/landt/flexible-learning/

           http://www.ascilite.org.au/
                          47
                                                         47
48
     48

National Learning & Teaching Forum: Distance Learning Architecture

  • 1.
    DISTANCE LEARNING ARCHITECTURE Professor Mike Keppell Director, The Flexible Learning Institute & Professor of Higher Education Charles Sturt University 1 1
  • 2.
    2 2
  • 3.
  • 4.
    QUESTIONS How many workat a distance education university? How many have studied a subject or degree via distance? How many have undertaken continuing education courses at a distance? 4 4
  • 5.
    What When Distance Why Learning Where Architecture Who How 5 5
  • 6.
    CHALLENGES Distance education landscape Learning andteaching Learning spaces Assessment Transformation 6 6
  • 7.
    WHAT IS DISTANCE EDUCATION? WHAT IS DISTANCE LEARNING? WHAT IS A DISTANCE LEARNER? 7 7
  • 8.
    WHAT IS DISTANCE EDUCATIONAND LEARNING? System of education in which the majority of learning takes place with the learner and the teacher separated by space and/or time, the gap between the two being bridged by technology (DEHub). Distance learning can cater for a wide variety of diverse needs for both on-campus and distance learners and is usually characterised by greater flexibility for the learner, convenience of time and place for learning and the ability to work at one’s own pace (DEHub). 8 8
  • 9.
    DISTANCE LEARNER A distancelearner is one who experiences the majority (80+%) of their learning off-campus at a distance from the teacher and consequently has limited face-to-face interaction with their teachers and peers (DEHub). 9 9
  • 10.
  • 11.
    Print Online Blended Face-to-Face DVD When should print/DVD/online/F2F/blended be used? 11 11
  • 12.
    DESIGN FOR DISTANCE LEARNING Distance education requires a redesign of degree/course/ subject/activity structure. Access and equity issues Degree experience versus subject experience Learning for now and learning for the future Graduate attributes Capstone 12 12
  • 13.
    TEACHER-STUDENT DYNAMIC Distance education requires distinctive learning and teaching strategies. Mix of independent learning and peer learning Mix of synchronous and asynchronous interactions Importance of feedback 13 13
  • 14.
    INTERACTIONS Information access Interactive learning Networkedlearning Student-generated content (Herrington & Oliver 2001). 14 14
  • 15.
    COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES Distance education requires different methods of communication using electronic technologies. Synchronous & asynchronous Written, voice, video e.g. podcasts 15 15
  • 16.
    CHALLENGES Design of degrees,subjects, activities, assessment Proportion of synchronous and asynchronous interactions. Synchronous and asynchronous communication Proportion of independent and peer learning How do you teach when you can’t see facial expressions? 16 16
  • 17.
  • 18.
    Tools Affordance information access, interactive Learning Management Systems learning, networked learning, student- (Moodle, Sakai, Blackboard) generated content Teleconferences, videoconferences, synchronous Skype Podcasts, vodcasts asynchronous Web-conferencing tools (e.g. participation elluminate, wimba) web 2.0 tools (YouTube, Facebook, social networking, student-generated blogs, wikis, Twitter, Flickr, etc content 18 18
  • 19.
    WHAT SPACES AREUSED FOR DISTANCE LEARNING? 19 19
  • 20.
    DIVERSITY OF LEARNINGSPACES Physical Blended Virtual Formal Informal Formal Informal Mobile Personal Professional Outdoor Practice 20 20
  • 21.
    FORMAL & INFORMALSPACES 21 21
  • 22.
    VIRTUAL LEARNING SPACES Formalvirtual learning spaces Informal virtual learning spaces Independent learning Peer learning 22 22
  • 23.
    Formal Virtual Informal Virtual Learning Spaces Learning Spaces Moodle Facebook Sakai Flickr Blackboard YouTube Twitter Formal Formal I Informal Informal 23 23
  • 24.
    FLEXIBILITY OF LEARNINGSPACES Flexible learning and teaching spaces allow adaptability over time for different uses. Spaces need to be used for students who are both physically present and students who never visit the campus. In addition homes, cars, buses, hotels, cafes become mobile spaces where the student undertakes learning. Studying subject materials while travelling to work via train or bus may represent the learning space for some students 24 24
  • 25.
    25 25
  • 26.
    26 26
  • 27.
  • 28.
    WHAT IS ASSESSMENT? Formative and Summative Assessment OF Learning Assessment FOR Learning Assessment AS Learning Learning-Oriented Assessment 28 28
  • 29.
    FORMATIVE AND SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT FormativeAssessment Summative Assessment Assessment FOR learning Assessment OF learning Generally carried out Generally carried out at the during a course or project. end of a course or project. Typically used to provide Typically used to assign students with feedback to students a grade or mark. aid learning. Common forms: self- Common forms: assessment, peer- examination, written final assessment assignment 29 29
  • 30.
    ASSESSMENT OF LEARNING Predominant form of assessment Usually summative Certifies student learning Used to report about progress Usually consists of tests or exams Represented by marks or letter grades Feedback is usually in the form of marks or grades Often used for a comparison between students (Earl, 2003). 30 30
  • 31.
    ASSESSMENT FOR LEARNING Shifts emphasis from summative to formative Shifts emphasis from making judgements to descriptions which are useful for the next stage of learning Focuses on feedback to enhance individual students learning Still focused on the teacher’s role in the assessment process (Earl, 2003). 31 31
  • 32.
    ASSESSMENT AS LEARNING Emphasises the student’s role in the assessment process Students are regarded as active, engaged and critical assessors Students monitor what they are learning - make adjustments, adaptations and major adjustments to their own learning Self assessment is the heart of the matter (Earl, 2003). 32 32
  • 33.
    LEARNING-ORIENTED ASSESSMENT Assessment tasks AS learning tasks Students as self-evaluators Feedback as feedforward (Carless, Joughin, Liu, 2006; Keppell & Carless, 2006) 33 33
  • 34.
    ONE OF THEGREATEST CHALLENGES IN HIGHER EDUCATION IS TO DESIGN SUMMATIVE ASSESSMENT THAT PERFORMS A FORMATIVE FUNCTION (CARLESS, JOUGHIN, LIU, 2006, P.8) 34 34
  • 35.
    ASSESSMENT TASKS AS LEARNING TASKS Assessment tasks need to promote desired learning outcomes and dispositions Constructive alignment of objectives, content and assessment (Biggs, 1999) Tasks should require distribution of student time and effort throughout, not just short bursts of energy towards the end (Gibbs & Simpson, 2004) A relationship between assessment tasks and real- world tasks, cooperative rather than competitive tasks Some degree of student choice in assessment tasks. 35 35
  • 36.
    Learning-oriented assessment Student Assessment tasks involvement in Forward-looking as learning tasks assessment feedback processes 36 36
  • 37.
    FORWARD-LOOKING FEEDBACK Students need to receive appropriate feedback which they can use to ‘feed forward’ into future work. Feedback should be less final and judgemental (Boud, 1995) Feedback should be more interactive and forward- looking (Carless, 2002) Feedback should be timely and with a potential to be acted upon (Gibbs & Simpson, 2004) 37 37
  • 38.
  • 39.
    SUPPORT & STRATEGICCHANGE OF LEARNING & TEACHING • Sakai Division of • Professional Learning and Development Teaching • Educational Services Designers • Teaching The Flexible Fellowships The Education Learning • Standards for Practice Institute • Learning Institute Spaces • Policy 39 39
  • 40.
    FLEXIBLE LEARNING “Flexible learning”provides opportunities to improve the student learning experience through flexibility in time, pace, place (physical, virtual, on- campus, off-campus), mode of study (print-based, face-to-face, blended, online), teaching approach (collaborative, independent), forms of assessment and staffing. It may utilise a wide range of media, environments, learning spaces and technologies for learning and teaching. 40 40
  • 41.
    BLENDED & FLEXIBLE LEARNING “Blended and flexible learning” is a design approach that examines the relationships between flexible learning opportunities, in order to optimise student engagement and equivalence in learning outcomes regardless of mode of study (Keppell, 2010, p. 3). 41 41
  • 42.
    REDESIGN OF COURSES& SUBJECTS THROUGH BLENDED AND FLEXIBLE LEARNING 42 42
  • 43.
    TEACHING FELLOWSHIP SCHEME Funded by DVC (Academic) Development of potential leaders through Distributive leadership Facilitate collaborative professional relationships Proactively redesign courses and subjects Promote and facilitate CSU Interact as a pivotal teaching and learning hub. 43 43
  • 44.
    TEACHING FELLOWSHIP SCHEME Participation of all twenty-four schools at the university 2008 - 6 fellows; 2009 - 5 fellows; 2010 - 5 fellows; 2011 - 6 fellows The Fellowship scheme provides a .5 release from regular teaching duties over a 12 month period. 44 44
  • 45.
    CHALLENGES Distance education landscape Learning andteaching Learning spaces Assessment Transformation 45 45
  • 46.
    46 46
  • 47.
    http://www.csu.edu.au/division/landt/flexible-learning/ http://www.ascilite.org.au/ 47 47
  • 48.
    48 48