|JASON ARTERO|
          |MARY JO DAVIS|
         |MELISSA HASWELL|
       |JENNIFER STRICKLAND|
           |NICK WAGNER|




Measuring student learning
Assessing student learning
• Difficult to assess student learning accurately
• As Noddings text said, when you measure
  student learning, do you measure the ability
  of the teacher?
• Testing/assessing a challenge for many people
Assessment in the movies
General info about student assessment
• General ideas to share about assessment
  value, process, need for assessment, etc……
Perspective for each of us based on
         our experiences

• Jason—middle school student assessment
• Mary Jo—college learning-focused assessment
• Melissa—science based assessment
• Jennifer—project and state mandated
  assessment
• Nick—outcome based assessment


• Give roadmap for presentation
Learning Assessment

Middle level assessment (is this your
      focus?)—Jason Artero
College skills Assessment

        Mary Jo Davis
Freshmen Experience Class Assessment

• First year class to have students learn about
  campus life, study habits, liberal arts learning
• Focus on experiential learning
   – Introduce students to new topics or ideas in
     several ways
         – Textbook readings
         – Guest speakers
         – Campus experiential activities
   – Have students reflect on perspective/feelings
     learning/experiences of the topic
Assessment tools used
• Self-reflection papers
• Journals
• Journey activities—experiential learning
  activities
  – Scavenger hunt
  – Attending new activity
  – Study/learning style testing—informally—and
    reflection written on findings
• Learn by doing—demonstrating learning
  through accurately completing activity
Science Learning Assessment

        Melissa Haswell
How do students learn science?
• Students are not all at the same level
• Some students memorize better than others
• In introductory science classes, the entire
  grade should not be based on exams
  – why?
     • Students are adjusting to a new “language”
     • Varied methods enhance student learning


                                                    Play movie
Core Terminology
• Type of Assessment
  – Exams: multiple choice, matching, true/false,
    list/define
• Type of Learning
  – Rote memorzation
• Rationale
  – Students must learn meaning of basic science
    terms in order to understand major science
    concepts
Major Scientific Concepts
• Type of Assessment
   –   Case study analysis
   –   Essay questions
   –   Group discussion questions
   –   Group activities
• Type of Learning
   – Higher level cognition/understanding
• Rationale
   – Once foundation terms are memorized, students are more
     likely to understand scientific theories & concepts
Project-based assessment

      Jennifer Strickland
Project-based learning
• Minimal use of pencil-paper tests

• Use of opinion-based writings
  – Have students write an opinion essay on same
    topic
  – From John Steinbeck’s “Of Mice and Men”
    “Is it ever justifiable to take the life of another
    living being?”
Project-based learning
 Move to small group learning activities
 Students take larger stance and support their
  position
 Group gathers notes from reading supporting
  their position
 Incorporate real-life stories (news) for support
 Present findings to class and justify position the
  taken
Project-based learning
 Students actively engaged with reading
 Discussion based on literature and real life
 Demonstrates their level of understanding of novel
  better than simple testing facts
 When testing, use essay questions– to find out what
  student knows about topic.
Standardized testing

    Jennifer Strickland
Standardized Testing
                   PROS
        •Can track progress of students
       •Guidance to teachers for content
  •Gives parents idea of what child is learning


                   CONS
                 •Teach to test
   •Pressure on student, teacher, and district
              •Changes frequently
•No clear communication with schools from state
Project-Based Assessment
• Students investigate challenging
  questions or situation posed by
  instructor
• Student driven learning
• Complex concepts explored
• Collaborative
Standardized Test
                         vs
               Project-Based Learning
STANDARDIZED
•Test at center of learning
•Assessment once a year
•Individual
•School environment

PROJECT-BASED
•Students at center of learning
•Frequent opportunities for assessment throughout year
•Collaborative
•Real world environment
Philosophy behind assessments
STANDARDIZED
•All individuals behind “veil of ignorance”
(Noddings, p. 179)
•Rawls- emphasis on procedures
•“each person [has] an equal right to the most
extensive liberty compatible with a similar
liberty for others.” (Noddings, p. 185)
Philosophy behind assessments
PROJECT-BASED
• Knowledge “products of inquiry and construction
  through social interaction” (Noddings, p.36)
• Philosopher John Dewey supports
• Naturalistic pragmatism (natural explanation / effects
  through inquiry and hypothesis testing)
• “[S]chool cannot prepare students for democratic life
  by simply giving them masses of information to be
  used at some later time” (Noddings, p. 36)
Outcome-based Assessment

        Nick Wagner
Student Learning Assessment
 Student Learning – Necessity of accountability
  & assessment of student learning INSIDE the
  classroom
 Measurements
   Standardized Tests
   Student Outcomes
Housing & ResLife Learning Assessment

• Focus on “Student Outcomes”

• Conceptualization of student learning outside
  of the classroom
  – Extremely vital to those 1st & 2nd year “vulnerable”
    residential students in higher education
Housing & Reslife Learning Assessment

• How do we do this? – More Qualitative
  – Community Development
  – Programming (FYRE, Monitor GPA, University
    Resources)
  – Diversity
     • Modeling attitudes & values that celebrate our
       differences & similarities
  – Student Conduct / Personal Development
     • Fire Safety
     • Alcohol abuse & violations
Housing & Reslife Learning Assessment

 Programs + Learning = Student OUTCOMES

Outcomes Identified as:
1.Residents are well prepared to succeed in
  the classroom & professional endeavors
2.Problematic behavior can be changed
3.Increased communication will lead to the
  use & development of university academic
  resources
Multiple views of assessment
•   Middle school
•   College
•   Science based
•   Project based
•   Standardized testing
•   Outcome based testing

• HOW TO FIT IT ALL TOGETHER???
Questions?????

Near final presentation 899

  • 1.
    |JASON ARTERO| |MARY JO DAVIS| |MELISSA HASWELL| |JENNIFER STRICKLAND| |NICK WAGNER| Measuring student learning
  • 2.
    Assessing student learning •Difficult to assess student learning accurately • As Noddings text said, when you measure student learning, do you measure the ability of the teacher? • Testing/assessing a challenge for many people
  • 3.
  • 4.
    General info aboutstudent assessment • General ideas to share about assessment value, process, need for assessment, etc……
  • 5.
    Perspective for eachof us based on our experiences • Jason—middle school student assessment • Mary Jo—college learning-focused assessment • Melissa—science based assessment • Jennifer—project and state mandated assessment • Nick—outcome based assessment • Give roadmap for presentation
  • 6.
    Learning Assessment Middle levelassessment (is this your focus?)—Jason Artero
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Freshmen Experience ClassAssessment • First year class to have students learn about campus life, study habits, liberal arts learning • Focus on experiential learning – Introduce students to new topics or ideas in several ways – Textbook readings – Guest speakers – Campus experiential activities – Have students reflect on perspective/feelings learning/experiences of the topic
  • 9.
    Assessment tools used •Self-reflection papers • Journals • Journey activities—experiential learning activities – Scavenger hunt – Attending new activity – Study/learning style testing—informally—and reflection written on findings • Learn by doing—demonstrating learning through accurately completing activity
  • 10.
  • 11.
    How do studentslearn science? • Students are not all at the same level • Some students memorize better than others • In introductory science classes, the entire grade should not be based on exams – why? • Students are adjusting to a new “language” • Varied methods enhance student learning Play movie
  • 12.
    Core Terminology • Typeof Assessment – Exams: multiple choice, matching, true/false, list/define • Type of Learning – Rote memorzation • Rationale – Students must learn meaning of basic science terms in order to understand major science concepts
  • 13.
    Major Scientific Concepts •Type of Assessment – Case study analysis – Essay questions – Group discussion questions – Group activities • Type of Learning – Higher level cognition/understanding • Rationale – Once foundation terms are memorized, students are more likely to understand scientific theories & concepts
  • 14.
    Project-based assessment Jennifer Strickland
  • 15.
    Project-based learning • Minimaluse of pencil-paper tests • Use of opinion-based writings – Have students write an opinion essay on same topic – From John Steinbeck’s “Of Mice and Men” “Is it ever justifiable to take the life of another living being?”
  • 16.
    Project-based learning  Moveto small group learning activities  Students take larger stance and support their position  Group gathers notes from reading supporting their position  Incorporate real-life stories (news) for support  Present findings to class and justify position the taken
  • 17.
    Project-based learning  Studentsactively engaged with reading  Discussion based on literature and real life  Demonstrates their level of understanding of novel better than simple testing facts  When testing, use essay questions– to find out what student knows about topic.
  • 18.
    Standardized testing Jennifer Strickland
  • 19.
    Standardized Testing PROS •Can track progress of students •Guidance to teachers for content •Gives parents idea of what child is learning CONS •Teach to test •Pressure on student, teacher, and district •Changes frequently •No clear communication with schools from state
  • 20.
    Project-Based Assessment • Studentsinvestigate challenging questions or situation posed by instructor • Student driven learning • Complex concepts explored • Collaborative
  • 21.
    Standardized Test vs Project-Based Learning STANDARDIZED •Test at center of learning •Assessment once a year •Individual •School environment PROJECT-BASED •Students at center of learning •Frequent opportunities for assessment throughout year •Collaborative •Real world environment
  • 22.
    Philosophy behind assessments STANDARDIZED •Allindividuals behind “veil of ignorance” (Noddings, p. 179) •Rawls- emphasis on procedures •“each person [has] an equal right to the most extensive liberty compatible with a similar liberty for others.” (Noddings, p. 185)
  • 23.
    Philosophy behind assessments PROJECT-BASED •Knowledge “products of inquiry and construction through social interaction” (Noddings, p.36) • Philosopher John Dewey supports • Naturalistic pragmatism (natural explanation / effects through inquiry and hypothesis testing) • “[S]chool cannot prepare students for democratic life by simply giving them masses of information to be used at some later time” (Noddings, p. 36)
  • 24.
  • 25.
    Student Learning Assessment Student Learning – Necessity of accountability & assessment of student learning INSIDE the classroom  Measurements  Standardized Tests  Student Outcomes
  • 26.
    Housing & ResLifeLearning Assessment • Focus on “Student Outcomes” • Conceptualization of student learning outside of the classroom – Extremely vital to those 1st & 2nd year “vulnerable” residential students in higher education
  • 27.
    Housing & ReslifeLearning Assessment • How do we do this? – More Qualitative – Community Development – Programming (FYRE, Monitor GPA, University Resources) – Diversity • Modeling attitudes & values that celebrate our differences & similarities – Student Conduct / Personal Development • Fire Safety • Alcohol abuse & violations
  • 28.
    Housing & ReslifeLearning Assessment Programs + Learning = Student OUTCOMES Outcomes Identified as: 1.Residents are well prepared to succeed in the classroom & professional endeavors 2.Problematic behavior can be changed 3.Increased communication will lead to the use & development of university academic resources
  • 29.
    Multiple views ofassessment • Middle school • College • Science based • Project based • Standardized testing • Outcome based testing • HOW TO FIT IT ALL TOGETHER???
  • 30.