Beyond GIS/GPS:
                                                                                                       engine will show interactively coast-
                                                                                                       line features down to 30-meter resolu-
                                                                                                       tion on a spheroid projection. This is
                                                                                                       only the beginning. To develop "fly-
                                                                                                       by" realistic renderings of critical



     Trends in Spatial
                                                                                                       locations, one can overlay T. Van
                                                                                                       Sant's global surface imagery (Van
                                                                                                       Sant, 1989],- drape it over available
                                                                                                       digital elevation models (DEMs); add
                                                                                                       reflections, mottling and clouds; and



      Data Handling
                                                                                                       load the information into a graphic
                                                                                                       workstation. Such renderings offer
                                                                                                       real-time visualization for emergency
                                                                                                       planning, search and rescue or com-
                                                                                                       mand and control.
                                                                                                           Better still, one can derive DEMs
            BY  ANDREW ZOLNAI AND                                                                      from SPOT or, soon, ERS-1 images to
                                                                                                       obtain a sound map base for planning
              MI CHAEL MARCHAND                                                                        pipeline routing or tracking air, land


 A       lthough some areas are better      stations. A person can now point-and-                      or sea vehicles anywhere in the world.
         attuned to 3-D visualization       click through spatial what-ifs or                          For example, radio and line-of-sight
         due to the subject matter, GIS     monitor assets worldwide at a desk-                        intervisibility calculations using
 is bound to move in that direction         top workstation costing less than                          terrain models help to predict in real-
 rapidly with evolving technologies in      $10,000.                                                   time whether a signal will reach its
 true 3-D databases and 3-D graphic            A key advantage of object data-                         intended recipient in VHF/UHF or
 workstations. These are exciting           bases is the ability to interact with                      what search-and-rescue plane is able
 times with raster, vector and tabular      cartographic elements. Such object                         to see units with its sensors over a
 data merged and distributed over           queries allow users to zoom into                           given flight path.
 heterogeneous networks. Experience         geographic areas ad-infinitum and by-                          Interactivity is again paramount to
 in the private and public resources        pass the problem of scaling vs. display,                    the whole process. For example,
 sector [Crain et al., 19911 suggests the   thereby abating the longstanding bane                       Axion Spatial Imaging, a firm in
 following ideal scenario: A corporate      of cartographers of which items to                          Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, designs
 relational database resides on a server,   show at what scale.                                         Tcrraxion, an integrated system for
 while workstations store client spatial                                                                vehicle tracking, mission control, and
 project databases; the server's rela-      Command and Control                                         search and rescue (Figure 1). A land,
 tional database management system             Worldwide cultural databases are                         sea or air vehicle is monitored against
 (RDBMS) provides the standards and         available, and the right database                           a DEM on a home base graphic work-
 flexibility to maintain databases of                                                                   station with dynamic route corridors.
 various sources, while workstation
 project data benefit from the speed of
 object-oriented spatial indexing. Key
 issues include data integrity, access
 and delivery, processing speed, setup
 cost and maintenance. Paramount to
 these technical issues is the consider-
 ation of individual, work group and
 corporate "work style." In a trend of
 collapsing hierarchies, engineers may
 not have access to technicians, and
 managers may have to draw their own
 conclusions on their own desktop
 systems.
     Where is this profusion of solutions
 leading us in these days of
 phenomenally increased availability
 of data, software and hardware?
 Command-and-control and decision-
 support systems extend beyond
 classical GIS applications and serve to
 illustrate new directions in GIS and
 global positioning system (GPS]
 technologies. Both systems benefit
 from tremendous advances in object-
 oriented systems and graphic work-

52   NOVEMBER 1992
                                            Figure 1. Terraxion's terrain editor with satellite texture mapping, running on a Silicon Graphics Iris
                                            Indigo workstation, allows images to be tilted, stretched and filtered to highlight desired features
                                                        and angles. The product also performs intervisibiiity mapping interactively.


                                                                           6 Copyright GIS World, Inc.. 156 E. Boardwalk Dnvs, Suite 250, Fort Collins, CO aO525. USA
A tanker leaving its shipping lane, for
  example, trips an alarm signal at
  home base, and the region is scanned
  on the workstation to assess whether
  the ship may have run aground or if
  piracy is suspected. Search and rescue
  and law enforcement can be dis-
  patched within minutes of the inci-
  dent with immensely improved
  intelligence on existing hazards. Thus,
  hundreds of vehicles can be tracked
  simultaneously worldwide on a
  Silicon Graphics (his Indigo or better)
  3-D workstation or 80386/'486 PCs for
  small fleets.

  Decision Support Systems
     The ability to link data with maps
  is nothing new, but adding financials
  to perform interactive profit-and-loss
  what-ifs strikes at the heart of any
  business venture. Imagine being able
  to extend a road on a vector map
  overlaid on a raster image filtered to
  highlight slopes and to interactively
  create pie charts of the economics of a
                                                                          Figure 2. Facet offers slope analysis with vector road maps, bar charts and pie charts linked for
  logging operation. These applications                                                              cost analysis on Sun SPARC workstations.
  can be performed by using a function                                 outgrowths of existing technologies.                   the International Digital Geographic
  that calculates road-building costs vs.                              From enterprise wide GIS to individual                 Working Group. It is critical to estab-
  logging accessibility and revenues.                                  workstations, he they windows into                     lish standards or put data "loaders"
  Facet, a decision-support system                                     corporate data or standalone projects,                 (to reformat and filter data) in the
  supported and marketed by Facet                                      a continuous array of applications is                  public domain with the explosion of
  Decision Systems, Calgary, Alberta,                                  emerging in the industry. User-driven                  publicly available databases from
  and Vancouver, British Columbia,                                     demand is creating ingenious new                       "canned" applications such as the
  Canada, allows such operations by                                    software programs, and a continued                     Digital Chart of the World from
  linking objects in a spreadsheet-like                                drop in hardware prices is bringing all                Environmental Systems Research
  front end, where each cell-object can                                this to today's desktops.                              Institute and the U.S. Defense Map-
  be another "spreadsheet,'7 a vector                                      A key element is the ability to                    ping Agency, to "semirefined" data
  map and/or a raster image (Figure 2).                                create project subsets of corporate                    such as Digital Line Graphs from the
     Using Facet, the profit-and-loss                                  data, as well as subsets of subsets, and               U.S. Geological Survey, to "raw" data
  exercise would consist briefly of cells                              so on. "Classical" relational databases                from various federal agencies.
  calculating the financial operations,                                and structured query language (SQL)                        The partition of tasks proposed
  where items are formulas, input data                                 standards do not allow imbricate data                  earlier in this article addresses the
  or values automatically derived from                                 sets (akin to Russian papier-mache                     dichotomy of RDBMS server and
  linked maps and/or images. Originally                                dolls-within-dolls|. Moreover, the                     client project spatial datahases.
  developed by MacDonald Dettwiler,                                    speed of relational technology makes                   Notwithstanding enormous existing
  Richmond, British Columbia, the                                      it better suited to handle corporate                   investments in software and hard-
  software resides on a Sun SPARC                                      tabular data on a server rather than to                ware, is there a way to seamlessly
  station and uses object-oriented data                                process spatially indexed data. Object                 integrate the two aspects of server and
  management to link such disparate                                    datahases may best address the latter                  client into one? At first glance, Axion
  elements. The product is meant to be                                 with XYZ coordinates and attributes                    offers end-user applications a 3-D
  the binding agent among many data                                    embedded in the objects. These                         graphic workstation performing
  sources and facilitate the decision-                                 components also allow fast graphical                   command and control. Taken one
  making process by bringing to the                                    display and spatial indexing on a                      step further, the vehicles that are the
  desktop relevant data in an intuitively                              project basis. They do not, as yet, offer              object of tracking, as well as a variety
  driven, yet powerful, fashion.                                       data standards to facilitate cross-                    of other pertinent data, could be
  Object Databases and 3-D                                             database information exchange, as has                  resident in database servers rather
                                                                       been done in the relational realm.                     than client project spatial databases.
  Workstations                                                         This situation is changing with the                        Facet proposes to "glue" such
     The commonality in Axion's                                        object-based SAIF data standard                        applications together, manage call-out
  vehicle tracking system and Facet's                                  adopted by the Canadian General                        tasks (such as preparing databases for
  decision-support system are the new                                  Standards Board Committee, rather                      client applications), and bring perti-
  database tools and affordable hardware                               than tables as, for example, SDTS of                   nent data and analytical power to the
  platforms that allow interactive                                     the U.S. National Institute of Stan-                   manager's desktop. The client-server
  heterogeneous data manipulation in                                   dards and Technology, or DIGEST of                     model, with a remote client such as
  3-D. These advancements represent                                                                                           an aircraft linked by satellite to



© Copyright GIS Wottd, Inc., 156 E. Boardwalk Drivo, Suite 250, Fort Collins, CO 805Z5. USA                                                                  NOVEMBER 1992    53
monitor a fleet, can have the decision-              4.Object data will be normalized to
support server at home base analyze                  facilitate data exchange between
the profitability of routes or quickly               processes and databases. Perfor
assemble data for crisis management.                 mance and reliability of systems and
These individual tasks may have been                 data integrity will rely on this.
done before, but this new technology                 Object databases will not reach
allows it to be done interactively in                critical mass oi acceptance until
real-time in mission-critical applica-               then, and loaders will need to be in
tions.                                               the public domain.
3-D and 4-D Database                                 5.Graphics libraries will be standard
                                                     ized to distribute such applications
Engines                                              seamlessly across heterogeneous
    One can map future applications                  networks. UNIX is settling into
beyond the two examples used. Object                 standardization, and graphics appli
databases will mature into true 3-D                  cations also must mature.
database engines. Seismic tomography
and holograms of the Loma Prieta                      Continued Evolution
earthquake epicenters in California                     The number and variety of options
two years ago (Harmaway, 1991) are                   that address spatial data handling are
two examples of what 3-D                             increasing daily. Environmental
visualization can do. If attribute tables            impact assessment is the fastest
are properly indexed in 3-D, a true 3-D              growing field in North America, and
GIS ensues. For example, the                         the booming of public 3-D data sets,
performance of a refinery or nuclear                 for example, from NASA (Strand,
reactor can be monitored in 4-D (3-D                 1992), may contribute to pushing GIS
and real-time attributes are parameters              from 2-D attributes and DEMs to true
from facilities!, or the evolution of                3-D databases. Simulations now can
reservoir depletion or contaminant                   be realistic enough to push the enve
dispersal underground can be mapped                  lope of "virtual reality" into real-
(the latter includes probabilistic and               world applications, and handle data
geostatistical attributes, which are                 sets in 3-D, 4-D and beyond.         §
best-guess distributions of rock and
fluid properties in the subsurface].                     Andrew Zolnai is Calgary AB
Real time adds tremendous "dimen-                     manager for Axion Spatial Imaging
sion" to emergency response in                        Ltd. Michael Marchand is vice presi-
environmental disasters.                              dent, product research in Calgary AB
    What does a 3-D/4-D database                      for Facet Decision Systems. Both can
entail that does not exist already?                   be reached at PO Box 61121, Kens-
Here is a wish list of perceived needs                ington Postal Outlet, Calgary AB,
to move database engines into the                     Canada, T2N 4S6.
future; it is hoped that individuals
will add their own in a swell of uses                 References
for true 3-D GIS (Raper, 1989).                          Crain, I., M. Marchand and M.
1.The third dimension will not be part                Legasse, Eds. 1991. GIS and Energy,
of attributes, but a key at the same                  URISA 1991 Conference Proceedings.
level as X and Y, and attributes will                    Harmaway, W. 1991. California
be properly indexed in 3-D; time                      -the Earthquake, the Hologram. Best
need not, as that would require                       Shots - Winning Images from the
parallelization.                                      Second International Visual Comput-
2.Attribute tables will be embedded in                ing Awards Contest, Iris Universe,
3-D objects, so 3-D computations                      No. 18.
can be performed on them, for                            Raper,J., Ed. 1989. Three-Dimen-
example, not to violate spatial                       sional Applications in Geographic
adjacency constraints or allow data                   Information Systems, Taylor &
spatial filtering.                                    Francis.
3.Graphic user interfaces will be                        Strand, E.J. 1992. NASA's EOS
developed into "human interfaces"                     Program Marks New Era in Global
to reduce the disconnectedness the                    Change Research, GIS WORLD, Vol.
user feels to the simulated environ                   5, No. 2 (March 1992).
ment he or she is travelling through.                    Tipper, J.C. 1991. A Prototype
Dynamic Visualization Systems                         General-Purpose Dynamic Visualiza-
(Tipper, 1991) will enhance the                       tion System, Geobyte, Vol. 6, No. 3
linkage between GIS/RDBMS and                         (June 1991).
application programs.                                    Van Sant, T. 1989. Geosphere
                                                      Project, Santa Monica, Calif.


                          B Copyright GIS Work), Inc., 155 E Boardwalk Dive, Suite 250, For) Collins. CO80Sa5, USA

Nov92GISworld

  • 1.
    Beyond GIS/GPS: engine will show interactively coast- line features down to 30-meter resolu- tion on a spheroid projection. This is only the beginning. To develop "fly- by" realistic renderings of critical Trends in Spatial locations, one can overlay T. Van Sant's global surface imagery (Van Sant, 1989],- drape it over available digital elevation models (DEMs); add reflections, mottling and clouds; and Data Handling load the information into a graphic workstation. Such renderings offer real-time visualization for emergency planning, search and rescue or com- mand and control. Better still, one can derive DEMs BY ANDREW ZOLNAI AND from SPOT or, soon, ERS-1 images to obtain a sound map base for planning MI CHAEL MARCHAND pipeline routing or tracking air, land A lthough some areas are better stations. A person can now point-and- or sea vehicles anywhere in the world. attuned to 3-D visualization click through spatial what-ifs or For example, radio and line-of-sight due to the subject matter, GIS monitor assets worldwide at a desk- intervisibility calculations using is bound to move in that direction top workstation costing less than terrain models help to predict in real- rapidly with evolving technologies in $10,000. time whether a signal will reach its true 3-D databases and 3-D graphic A key advantage of object data- intended recipient in VHF/UHF or workstations. These are exciting bases is the ability to interact with what search-and-rescue plane is able times with raster, vector and tabular cartographic elements. Such object to see units with its sensors over a data merged and distributed over queries allow users to zoom into given flight path. heterogeneous networks. Experience geographic areas ad-infinitum and by- Interactivity is again paramount to in the private and public resources pass the problem of scaling vs. display, the whole process. For example, sector [Crain et al., 19911 suggests the thereby abating the longstanding bane Axion Spatial Imaging, a firm in following ideal scenario: A corporate of cartographers of which items to Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, designs relational database resides on a server, show at what scale. Tcrraxion, an integrated system for while workstations store client spatial vehicle tracking, mission control, and project databases; the server's rela- Command and Control search and rescue (Figure 1). A land, tional database management system Worldwide cultural databases are sea or air vehicle is monitored against (RDBMS) provides the standards and available, and the right database a DEM on a home base graphic work- flexibility to maintain databases of station with dynamic route corridors. various sources, while workstation project data benefit from the speed of object-oriented spatial indexing. Key issues include data integrity, access and delivery, processing speed, setup cost and maintenance. Paramount to these technical issues is the consider- ation of individual, work group and corporate "work style." In a trend of collapsing hierarchies, engineers may not have access to technicians, and managers may have to draw their own conclusions on their own desktop systems. Where is this profusion of solutions leading us in these days of phenomenally increased availability of data, software and hardware? Command-and-control and decision- support systems extend beyond classical GIS applications and serve to illustrate new directions in GIS and global positioning system (GPS] technologies. Both systems benefit from tremendous advances in object- oriented systems and graphic work- 52 NOVEMBER 1992 Figure 1. Terraxion's terrain editor with satellite texture mapping, running on a Silicon Graphics Iris Indigo workstation, allows images to be tilted, stretched and filtered to highlight desired features and angles. The product also performs intervisibiiity mapping interactively. 6 Copyright GIS World, Inc.. 156 E. Boardwalk Dnvs, Suite 250, Fort Collins, CO aO525. USA
  • 2.
    A tanker leavingits shipping lane, for example, trips an alarm signal at home base, and the region is scanned on the workstation to assess whether the ship may have run aground or if piracy is suspected. Search and rescue and law enforcement can be dis- patched within minutes of the inci- dent with immensely improved intelligence on existing hazards. Thus, hundreds of vehicles can be tracked simultaneously worldwide on a Silicon Graphics (his Indigo or better) 3-D workstation or 80386/'486 PCs for small fleets. Decision Support Systems The ability to link data with maps is nothing new, but adding financials to perform interactive profit-and-loss what-ifs strikes at the heart of any business venture. Imagine being able to extend a road on a vector map overlaid on a raster image filtered to highlight slopes and to interactively create pie charts of the economics of a Figure 2. Facet offers slope analysis with vector road maps, bar charts and pie charts linked for logging operation. These applications cost analysis on Sun SPARC workstations. can be performed by using a function outgrowths of existing technologies. the International Digital Geographic that calculates road-building costs vs. From enterprise wide GIS to individual Working Group. It is critical to estab- logging accessibility and revenues. workstations, he they windows into lish standards or put data "loaders" Facet, a decision-support system corporate data or standalone projects, (to reformat and filter data) in the supported and marketed by Facet a continuous array of applications is public domain with the explosion of Decision Systems, Calgary, Alberta, emerging in the industry. User-driven publicly available databases from and Vancouver, British Columbia, demand is creating ingenious new "canned" applications such as the Canada, allows such operations by software programs, and a continued Digital Chart of the World from linking objects in a spreadsheet-like drop in hardware prices is bringing all Environmental Systems Research front end, where each cell-object can this to today's desktops. Institute and the U.S. Defense Map- be another "spreadsheet,'7 a vector A key element is the ability to ping Agency, to "semirefined" data map and/or a raster image (Figure 2). create project subsets of corporate such as Digital Line Graphs from the Using Facet, the profit-and-loss data, as well as subsets of subsets, and U.S. Geological Survey, to "raw" data exercise would consist briefly of cells so on. "Classical" relational databases from various federal agencies. calculating the financial operations, and structured query language (SQL) The partition of tasks proposed where items are formulas, input data standards do not allow imbricate data earlier in this article addresses the or values automatically derived from sets (akin to Russian papier-mache dichotomy of RDBMS server and linked maps and/or images. Originally dolls-within-dolls|. Moreover, the client project spatial datahases. developed by MacDonald Dettwiler, speed of relational technology makes Notwithstanding enormous existing Richmond, British Columbia, the it better suited to handle corporate investments in software and hard- software resides on a Sun SPARC tabular data on a server rather than to ware, is there a way to seamlessly station and uses object-oriented data process spatially indexed data. Object integrate the two aspects of server and management to link such disparate datahases may best address the latter client into one? At first glance, Axion elements. The product is meant to be with XYZ coordinates and attributes offers end-user applications a 3-D the binding agent among many data embedded in the objects. These graphic workstation performing sources and facilitate the decision- components also allow fast graphical command and control. Taken one making process by bringing to the display and spatial indexing on a step further, the vehicles that are the desktop relevant data in an intuitively project basis. They do not, as yet, offer object of tracking, as well as a variety driven, yet powerful, fashion. data standards to facilitate cross- of other pertinent data, could be Object Databases and 3-D database information exchange, as has resident in database servers rather been done in the relational realm. than client project spatial databases. Workstations This situation is changing with the Facet proposes to "glue" such The commonality in Axion's object-based SAIF data standard applications together, manage call-out vehicle tracking system and Facet's adopted by the Canadian General tasks (such as preparing databases for decision-support system are the new Standards Board Committee, rather client applications), and bring perti- database tools and affordable hardware than tables as, for example, SDTS of nent data and analytical power to the platforms that allow interactive the U.S. National Institute of Stan- manager's desktop. The client-server heterogeneous data manipulation in dards and Technology, or DIGEST of model, with a remote client such as 3-D. These advancements represent an aircraft linked by satellite to © Copyright GIS Wottd, Inc., 156 E. Boardwalk Drivo, Suite 250, Fort Collins, CO 805Z5. USA NOVEMBER 1992 53
  • 3.
    monitor a fleet,can have the decision- 4.Object data will be normalized to support server at home base analyze facilitate data exchange between the profitability of routes or quickly processes and databases. Perfor assemble data for crisis management. mance and reliability of systems and These individual tasks may have been data integrity will rely on this. done before, but this new technology Object databases will not reach allows it to be done interactively in critical mass oi acceptance until real-time in mission-critical applica- then, and loaders will need to be in tions. the public domain. 3-D and 4-D Database 5.Graphics libraries will be standard ized to distribute such applications Engines seamlessly across heterogeneous One can map future applications networks. UNIX is settling into beyond the two examples used. Object standardization, and graphics appli databases will mature into true 3-D cations also must mature. database engines. Seismic tomography and holograms of the Loma Prieta Continued Evolution earthquake epicenters in California The number and variety of options two years ago (Harmaway, 1991) are that address spatial data handling are two examples of what 3-D increasing daily. Environmental visualization can do. If attribute tables impact assessment is the fastest are properly indexed in 3-D, a true 3-D growing field in North America, and GIS ensues. For example, the the booming of public 3-D data sets, performance of a refinery or nuclear for example, from NASA (Strand, reactor can be monitored in 4-D (3-D 1992), may contribute to pushing GIS and real-time attributes are parameters from 2-D attributes and DEMs to true from facilities!, or the evolution of 3-D databases. Simulations now can reservoir depletion or contaminant be realistic enough to push the enve dispersal underground can be mapped lope of "virtual reality" into real- (the latter includes probabilistic and world applications, and handle data geostatistical attributes, which are sets in 3-D, 4-D and beyond. § best-guess distributions of rock and fluid properties in the subsurface]. Andrew Zolnai is Calgary AB Real time adds tremendous "dimen- manager for Axion Spatial Imaging sion" to emergency response in Ltd. Michael Marchand is vice presi- environmental disasters. dent, product research in Calgary AB What does a 3-D/4-D database for Facet Decision Systems. Both can entail that does not exist already? be reached at PO Box 61121, Kens- Here is a wish list of perceived needs ington Postal Outlet, Calgary AB, to move database engines into the Canada, T2N 4S6. future; it is hoped that individuals will add their own in a swell of uses References for true 3-D GIS (Raper, 1989). Crain, I., M. Marchand and M. 1.The third dimension will not be part Legasse, Eds. 1991. GIS and Energy, of attributes, but a key at the same URISA 1991 Conference Proceedings. level as X and Y, and attributes will Harmaway, W. 1991. California be properly indexed in 3-D; time -the Earthquake, the Hologram. Best need not, as that would require Shots - Winning Images from the parallelization. Second International Visual Comput- 2.Attribute tables will be embedded in ing Awards Contest, Iris Universe, 3-D objects, so 3-D computations No. 18. can be performed on them, for Raper,J., Ed. 1989. Three-Dimen- example, not to violate spatial sional Applications in Geographic adjacency constraints or allow data Information Systems, Taylor & spatial filtering. Francis. 3.Graphic user interfaces will be Strand, E.J. 1992. NASA's EOS developed into "human interfaces" Program Marks New Era in Global to reduce the disconnectedness the Change Research, GIS WORLD, Vol. user feels to the simulated environ 5, No. 2 (March 1992). ment he or she is travelling through. Tipper, J.C. 1991. A Prototype Dynamic Visualization Systems General-Purpose Dynamic Visualiza- (Tipper, 1991) will enhance the tion System, Geobyte, Vol. 6, No. 3 linkage between GIS/RDBMS and (June 1991). application programs. Van Sant, T. 1989. Geosphere Project, Santa Monica, Calif. B Copyright GIS Work), Inc., 155 E Boardwalk Dive, Suite 250, For) Collins. CO80Sa5, USA