How long do nosocomial pathogens
persist on inanimate surfaces?
A systematic review
Reviewed by
Dr. Sayan Chakraborty
MD (JR-2), Dept. of Tropical Medicine
Calcutta School of Tropical Medicine
Author: Axel Kramer
BMC Infectious Diseases BMC series open,
inclusive and trusted 2006 6:130
DOI: 10.1186/147123346130
© Kramer et al; licensee BioMed Central
Ltd. 2006
Received: 26 April 2006
Accepted: 16 August 2006
Published: 16 August 2006
BACKGROUND
• Global infection control community: ongoing
controversy about the appropriate t/t of
inanimate surfaces in hospitals
• Non-antimicrobial detergents/ antimicrobial
agents ??
• Parameters to be noted:
 Type of ward
 Expected frequency of hand contact with a
surface
Persistence of nosocomial pathogens on surfaces
METHODS
• Search strategy:
Reviewed in MedLine on the internet
homepage of the National Library of Medicine
Standard textbooks on infection control,
bacteriology and virology
• Selecting studies: Reports with experimental
evidence
• Interpretation of studies: Pathogens were
grouped according to importance and
persistence
RESULTS
• Persistence of bacteria
RESULTS- Bacteria
RESULTS - Bacteria
• Gram negative persist longer than gram positive
• Humid conditions improved persistence
• Only Staphylococcus aureus persist longer at low
humidity
• Low temperatures, e.g., 4°C or 6°C, also improved
persistence
• Test material -no consistent result. However,
longer persistence noted on plastic & steel
• Longer persistence with higher inocula, in the
presence of protein, serum, sputum or without
dust
RESULTS- Fungi
The presence of serum or albumin, low temp &
high humidity lead to longer persistence
RESULTS - Virus
RESULTS - Virus
RESULTS - VIRUS
• Viruses of Respiratory tract: a few days
• Viruses of GI tract: 2 months
• Blood borne viruses eg HBV or HIV > 1 week
• High humidity: Entero- & Rhinovirus
• Low humidity: HSV & HAV
• Low temp: Astro-, Adeno-, Polio, HSV & HAV
• Type of material inconsistent
• Non-porous substance- Influenza; Fomica &
gloves- RSV; Telephone receiver- FCV
• Longer persistence in fecal suspension & higher
inoculum
DISCUSSION
• Factors influencing higher persistence:
Low temperature
High humidity
Higher inoculum
Type of surface & suspension medium –
inconsistent
• Cryptosporidium species survive on dry
surfaces for only 2 hours
HAND HYGIENE
• Transmission to hands:
 Escherichia coli (100%)
 Salmonella spp. (100%)
 Staphylococcus aureus (100%)
 Candida albicans (90%)
 Rhino virus (61%)
 HAV (22% – 33%)
 Rota virus (16%).
• Contaminated hands can transfer viruses to 5 more
surfaces or 14 other subjects.
• Recontaminating of surface, as in HAV.
• Compliance rates of healthcare workers in hand
hygiene around 50%
Common modes of transmission from inanimate
surfaces to susceptible patients
DISCUSSION …. contd
• During outbreaks, role of environmental
contamination stronger for Clostridium
difficile, MRSA and VRE than for Pseudomonas
aeruginosa or Acinetobacter baumannii
• Routine treatment of floors with surface
disinfectants - no significant impact
• Disinfection of surfaces in the immediate
environment of patients reduce nosocomial
infection
CONCLUSION
• Most nosocomial pathogens persist on
inanimate surfaces for weeks or even months
• Disinfection of surfaces in specific patient care
areas
• PROPER HAND HYGIENE
THANK YOU

Persistence of microbes

  • 1.
    How long donosocomial pathogens persist on inanimate surfaces? A systematic review Reviewed by Dr. Sayan Chakraborty MD (JR-2), Dept. of Tropical Medicine Calcutta School of Tropical Medicine
  • 2.
    Author: Axel Kramer BMCInfectious Diseases BMC series open, inclusive and trusted 2006 6:130 DOI: 10.1186/147123346130 © Kramer et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2006 Received: 26 April 2006 Accepted: 16 August 2006 Published: 16 August 2006
  • 3.
    BACKGROUND • Global infectioncontrol community: ongoing controversy about the appropriate t/t of inanimate surfaces in hospitals • Non-antimicrobial detergents/ antimicrobial agents ?? • Parameters to be noted:  Type of ward  Expected frequency of hand contact with a surface Persistence of nosocomial pathogens on surfaces
  • 4.
    METHODS • Search strategy: Reviewedin MedLine on the internet homepage of the National Library of Medicine Standard textbooks on infection control, bacteriology and virology • Selecting studies: Reports with experimental evidence • Interpretation of studies: Pathogens were grouped according to importance and persistence
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
    RESULTS - Bacteria •Gram negative persist longer than gram positive • Humid conditions improved persistence • Only Staphylococcus aureus persist longer at low humidity • Low temperatures, e.g., 4°C or 6°C, also improved persistence • Test material -no consistent result. However, longer persistence noted on plastic & steel • Longer persistence with higher inocula, in the presence of protein, serum, sputum or without dust
  • 8.
    RESULTS- Fungi The presenceof serum or albumin, low temp & high humidity lead to longer persistence
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
    RESULTS - VIRUS •Viruses of Respiratory tract: a few days • Viruses of GI tract: 2 months • Blood borne viruses eg HBV or HIV > 1 week • High humidity: Entero- & Rhinovirus • Low humidity: HSV & HAV • Low temp: Astro-, Adeno-, Polio, HSV & HAV • Type of material inconsistent • Non-porous substance- Influenza; Fomica & gloves- RSV; Telephone receiver- FCV • Longer persistence in fecal suspension & higher inoculum
  • 12.
    DISCUSSION • Factors influencinghigher persistence: Low temperature High humidity Higher inoculum Type of surface & suspension medium – inconsistent • Cryptosporidium species survive on dry surfaces for only 2 hours
  • 13.
    HAND HYGIENE • Transmissionto hands:  Escherichia coli (100%)  Salmonella spp. (100%)  Staphylococcus aureus (100%)  Candida albicans (90%)  Rhino virus (61%)  HAV (22% – 33%)  Rota virus (16%). • Contaminated hands can transfer viruses to 5 more surfaces or 14 other subjects. • Recontaminating of surface, as in HAV. • Compliance rates of healthcare workers in hand hygiene around 50%
  • 14.
    Common modes oftransmission from inanimate surfaces to susceptible patients
  • 15.
    DISCUSSION …. contd •During outbreaks, role of environmental contamination stronger for Clostridium difficile, MRSA and VRE than for Pseudomonas aeruginosa or Acinetobacter baumannii • Routine treatment of floors with surface disinfectants - no significant impact • Disinfection of surfaces in the immediate environment of patients reduce nosocomial infection
  • 16.
    CONCLUSION • Most nosocomialpathogens persist on inanimate surfaces for weeks or even months • Disinfection of surfaces in specific patient care areas • PROPER HAND HYGIENE
  • 17.