www.trcsolutions.com
Planning a Successful Microgrid
January 22, 2015
Bill Moran, Senior Electrical Engineer
Mark Lorentzen, Vice President, Energy Efficiency
2
Today’s Grid
Source: http://peswiki.com/index.php/Directory:Smart_Grid
3
Tomorrow’s Microgrids
Georgia Tech, Climate and Energy Policy Lab
http://www.cepl.gatech.edu/drupal/
4
TRC Microgrid Team
-
A pioneer in groundbreaking scientific and engineering developments since
1969, TRC is a national engineering, consulting and construction management
firm that provides integrated services to three primary markets:
Energy | Environmental | Infrastructure
 Expert problem solvers
 100+ U.S. offices
London office
 3,000+ employees
 NYSE: TRR
5
Company Profile
TRC’s Guiding Principles
Our Mission
’
creativity, experience, integrity and dedication to deliver superior solutions to
’ f .
Our Vision
We will solve the challenges of making the Earth a better place to live –
community by community and project by project.
ENR Top 500 Design Firms
7
"The energy market growth is inevitable and one of
the largest sectors for capital investment. Any
design firm working and supporting that market
will have a bright future.“
Chris Vincze, CEO, TRC Companies Inc.
E32 36 TRC Cos. Inc., Lowell, Mass.
Rank
2013 2012
Firm Firm Type
Growth Drivers
Reliability | Power Supply | Aging Generation Assets | Regulatory
8
 Electrical Transmission, Distribution &
Substation Engineering
 Energy Efficiency, Demand Response, Renewable Energy, CHP
 Communications Engineering
Transformation
High-Profile Private Sector Clients
9
Working With All Levels of Government
10
State and Local Federal
11
Speaker Highlights
Bill Moran has over 35 years' experience in
electrical power generation and distribution
with a focus on the design, construction and
operation of large campus type power
distribution systems. Bill is the lead technical
consultant supporting the development of
f ’ Microgrid Grant
and Loan Pilot Program.
He is a key member of the TRC Microgrid
Team, a multidiscipline team of experts
assembled to help clients plan, design and
build microgrids.
William Moran
Senior Electrical Engineer
TRC Companies, Inc.
12
• Microgrid development – where to start
• Site selection and types of distribution
• Load management
• Generation sources
• Microgrid protection and controls
• Grounding
Overview
13
• Multiple critical facilities
• Physical location – Critical Facilities and generation all within
reasonable walking distance; voltage drop and cost of
distribution feeders are considerations
• Widely spaced facilities with numerous non-critical sites
between will greatly increase cost of microgrid; separating
critical and non critical facilities require additional switching
equipment and possibly a dedicated circuit
• Are all microgrid facilities within a campus, or will power have
to cross public roads?
• What does the microgrid look like?
Microgrid Development – Site Selection
14
Campus Microgrid
Typical campus system has a single owner of all facilities, and
is often served from a single utility meter.
15
Lateral Island Microgrid
LEGEND
CF = CRITICAL FACILITY
NC = NON-CRITICAL FACILITY
Fed from a single utility distribution
feeder, which also feeds non-critical
facilities that are not included in
microgrid.
16
Dedicated Circuit Microgrid
LEGEND
CF = CRITICAL FACILITY
NC = NON-CRITICAL FACILITY
Expensive – redundant distribution circuit to connect
critical facilities with microgrid generation.
17
Meet with the utility
• Identify feeder(s) to be incorporated into microgrid
• Identify primary system voltage and grounding
method
• Identify critical facilities to be included in microgrid
• Obtain DG interconnection requirements
• Discuss system hardening and reliability
improvements
– Undergrounding, loop feeds, automatic sectionalizing
Steps to Project Development
18
Loop Feed Distribution
Features
• Redundant circuit path to each
facility
• Protective relay functionality to
isolate system faults
• Communication with other loop
switches for coordinated
operation
• Establishes self-healing
distribution
• Minimizes outages to individual
facility
19
Underground Loop Distribution Switch
20
Meet with Engineering consultants – establish scope of services
• Load Study
Prerequisite: upgrade metering to provide real time demand data
(1 minute interval ideal), 12 months data preferred
On Peak: 6AM – 8PM average load
Peak load and duration of peak
Off Peak: 8PM – 6 AM average load
Identify loads that can be time-shifted to off peak
• Motor starting study
Inventory motors over 1 HP
Size of largest motor
Motors over 10 HP: consider soft start or at a minimum wye-delta
starting (mandatory for inverter based systems)
Calculate starting currents for large motors
Know expected motor operating schedule and what motors operate
concurrently
Steps to Project Development
21
• Load shedding study
– Tier 1 Loads (must run, most critical)
– Tier 2 Loads – less critical, to be shed short term to
preserve spinning reserve capacity
– Tier 3 Loads – emergency load reduction to avoid blackout
• Short circuit study
– Calculate available fault current when grid connected
– Calculate available fault current when islanded
Engineering Studies
22
• ANSI/IEEE standard symbols
• Point(s) of common coupling shown
• Location and type of isolation switch and circuit
breaker shown
• All protective relay functions shown
• Transformer grounding shown
• Transformer impedances shown
• Meters and metering connections shown
One-Line Electrical Diagram
23
Typical One-Line
24
Generation selection
• Land availability
• Environmental considerations
• Energy resources
– Wind
– Solar
– River or tidal flow
– Fossil fuels
• Effect of uncontrolled renewables (wind and solar)
de-stabilizes islanded microgrid and creates need for
energy storage
Steps to Project Development
25
• Generation must match the load – exactly
– Overload= under frequency trip (0.16 seconds response time)
– High speed load shedding a necessity
• Provisions for peaks (spinning reserve)
– Normally 15-20% of operating load
– Depends on system load profile
• Surge capacity (motor starting)
– Reactive power requirements
– Voltage control
Powering a Microgrid
26
Generator types
• Synchronous
– Voltage and current source
– Can supply or absorb reactive power
• Induction
– Current source only
– Requires system source of excitation voltage
– No voltage control
• Inverter
– Current source, externally commutated (UL-1741)
– Current and voltage source, self commutated
– Limited fault current
– Limited reactive power capability
Powering a Microgrid
27
Generator characteristics
• Base load – slowly changing or fixed
output (slow ramp rate)
– Lean burn natural gas
– Fuel cell
– Gas turbine (large) > 5MW
– Hydro
• Peaking – rapid response to follow
system loads
– Diesel
– Rich burn natural gas
– Inverters
– Small gas turbines < 2MW
Powering a Microgrid
Fuel Cells
7 MW Gas Turbine
Diesel Generator
28
Energy Storage
• Load and generation
smoothing
– Short term 0-15 minutes
– Flywheel
– Battery & inverter
• Time shifting
– Reserve energy for peaking
– Transferring PV generation to
dark hours
Powering a Microgrid
Flywheel
1 MW Battery & Inverter
29
Operation when grid connected
• Frequency controlled by grid
• Voltage controlled by grid
• Reactive power (VAR) demand supplied by grid
• Distributed generation controlled to maintain desired
power output (kW)
• Higher available fault current, Utility source +
Generation
Microgrid Controls
30
Islanded Operation
• Frequency must be controlled by microgrid generation
• Microgrid must be able to absorb swings in load
• Ramp rate of generators becomes an issue
• How is load shared among multiple generators?
• Isochronous vs. droop governing
• Lower available fault current (generator only)
– Will likely require different settings for protective relays
– Different short circuit coordination requirements
– Potentially greater arc-flash requirements (longer clearing
times)
Microgrid Controls
31
Protection
• Grid connected
– Higher available fault currents
– Need to identify external vs. internal faults to prevent false tripping
– Fast break away from grid on external fault
– Tight control of short time frequency and voltage tripping
– Provide for low generation voltage and frequency ride through; keep
generation on line as long as possible to support grid
– Separate from utility to preserve microgrid and generation
Protection and Controls
32
Protection
• Island Mode
– Lower fault currents may require separate settings
– Wider tolerances on frequency and voltage tripping of generation
– Coordinate settings with load management controls to shed Tier 2
loads before frequency degrades on overload
– Look at downstream devices, may not properly coordinate tripping
with lower fault current
Protection and Controls
33
Controls
• Grid connected
– Generation dispatch – maximize economics, use historical data
– Load management – maintain preplanned load preservation scheme
using real-time data; always ready for transition to island mode
• Island Mode
– Generation dispatch
• Establish base load capacity
• Establish peaking capacity (load following) (frequency regulation)
• Start additional generation as needed
• Maintaining spinning reserve
Protection and Controls
34
Controls
• Island Mode - Load management
– Shed Tier 2 (and Tier 3 if required) on transfer to island
mode
– Restore loads when sufficient generation capacity is on line
– Maintain real time list of Tier 2 loads to be shed to
preserve microgrid
– Activate load shed during system disturbance, restore
loads when able
Protection and Controls
35
Controls
• Synchronization - Closed transition
– Shift generation to frequency and voltage control upon
separation from utility
– Monitor external grid voltage and frequency for return of
normal service (IEEE-1547 five minute delay of retransfer
after stabilization)
– When ready, adjust microgrid voltage and frequency to
match utility source
– Close utility tie breaker
– Transition generation to grid paralleled mode
– Shut down excess generation
Protection and Controls
36
• Primary system grounding when islanded
– Delta system
• Grounding transformer
– Wye system
• Generator Grounding
– Ground fault current islanded vs. grid parallel
– Grounding resistor vs. reactor
– Generator step-up transformer – Wye-Wye?
• Ground fault currents grid connected vs. island mode
Grounding
37
Microgrid Development
• Identify facilities to be served
• Consult with utility for feasibility
• Identify facility loads
• Define physical and electrical boundaries and ownership of
distribution and generation
Design
• Design interconnection and physical layout of Microgrid
• Select and locate appropriate generation sources
• Design protection system for grid parallel and island modes
• Configure load management controls
• Obtain Interconnection Agreement with host utility
Conclusion
Questions?
Mark Lorentzen
P: 607.330.0322 | E: MLorentzen@trcsolutions.com
Bill Moran
P: 774.235.2602 | E: WMoran@trcsolutions.com
www.trcsolutions.com

Planning a successful microgrid

  • 1.
    www.trcsolutions.com Planning a SuccessfulMicrogrid January 22, 2015 Bill Moran, Senior Electrical Engineer Mark Lorentzen, Vice President, Energy Efficiency
  • 2.
  • 3.
    3 Tomorrow’s Microgrids Georgia Tech,Climate and Energy Policy Lab http://www.cepl.gatech.edu/drupal/
  • 4.
  • 5.
    A pioneer ingroundbreaking scientific and engineering developments since 1969, TRC is a national engineering, consulting and construction management firm that provides integrated services to three primary markets: Energy | Environmental | Infrastructure  Expert problem solvers  100+ U.S. offices London office  3,000+ employees  NYSE: TRR 5 Company Profile
  • 6.
    TRC’s Guiding Principles OurMission ’ creativity, experience, integrity and dedication to deliver superior solutions to ’ f . Our Vision We will solve the challenges of making the Earth a better place to live – community by community and project by project.
  • 7.
    ENR Top 500Design Firms 7 "The energy market growth is inevitable and one of the largest sectors for capital investment. Any design firm working and supporting that market will have a bright future.“ Chris Vincze, CEO, TRC Companies Inc. E32 36 TRC Cos. Inc., Lowell, Mass. Rank 2013 2012 Firm Firm Type
  • 8.
    Growth Drivers Reliability |Power Supply | Aging Generation Assets | Regulatory 8  Electrical Transmission, Distribution & Substation Engineering  Energy Efficiency, Demand Response, Renewable Energy, CHP  Communications Engineering Transformation
  • 9.
  • 10.
    Working With AllLevels of Government 10 State and Local Federal
  • 11.
    11 Speaker Highlights Bill Moranhas over 35 years' experience in electrical power generation and distribution with a focus on the design, construction and operation of large campus type power distribution systems. Bill is the lead technical consultant supporting the development of f ’ Microgrid Grant and Loan Pilot Program. He is a key member of the TRC Microgrid Team, a multidiscipline team of experts assembled to help clients plan, design and build microgrids. William Moran Senior Electrical Engineer TRC Companies, Inc.
  • 12.
    12 • Microgrid development– where to start • Site selection and types of distribution • Load management • Generation sources • Microgrid protection and controls • Grounding Overview
  • 13.
    13 • Multiple criticalfacilities • Physical location – Critical Facilities and generation all within reasonable walking distance; voltage drop and cost of distribution feeders are considerations • Widely spaced facilities with numerous non-critical sites between will greatly increase cost of microgrid; separating critical and non critical facilities require additional switching equipment and possibly a dedicated circuit • Are all microgrid facilities within a campus, or will power have to cross public roads? • What does the microgrid look like? Microgrid Development – Site Selection
  • 14.
    14 Campus Microgrid Typical campussystem has a single owner of all facilities, and is often served from a single utility meter.
  • 15.
    15 Lateral Island Microgrid LEGEND CF= CRITICAL FACILITY NC = NON-CRITICAL FACILITY Fed from a single utility distribution feeder, which also feeds non-critical facilities that are not included in microgrid.
  • 16.
    16 Dedicated Circuit Microgrid LEGEND CF= CRITICAL FACILITY NC = NON-CRITICAL FACILITY Expensive – redundant distribution circuit to connect critical facilities with microgrid generation.
  • 17.
    17 Meet with theutility • Identify feeder(s) to be incorporated into microgrid • Identify primary system voltage and grounding method • Identify critical facilities to be included in microgrid • Obtain DG interconnection requirements • Discuss system hardening and reliability improvements – Undergrounding, loop feeds, automatic sectionalizing Steps to Project Development
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Features • Redundant circuitpath to each facility • Protective relay functionality to isolate system faults • Communication with other loop switches for coordinated operation • Establishes self-healing distribution • Minimizes outages to individual facility 19 Underground Loop Distribution Switch
  • 20.
    20 Meet with Engineeringconsultants – establish scope of services • Load Study Prerequisite: upgrade metering to provide real time demand data (1 minute interval ideal), 12 months data preferred On Peak: 6AM – 8PM average load Peak load and duration of peak Off Peak: 8PM – 6 AM average load Identify loads that can be time-shifted to off peak • Motor starting study Inventory motors over 1 HP Size of largest motor Motors over 10 HP: consider soft start or at a minimum wye-delta starting (mandatory for inverter based systems) Calculate starting currents for large motors Know expected motor operating schedule and what motors operate concurrently Steps to Project Development
  • 21.
    21 • Load sheddingstudy – Tier 1 Loads (must run, most critical) – Tier 2 Loads – less critical, to be shed short term to preserve spinning reserve capacity – Tier 3 Loads – emergency load reduction to avoid blackout • Short circuit study – Calculate available fault current when grid connected – Calculate available fault current when islanded Engineering Studies
  • 22.
    22 • ANSI/IEEE standardsymbols • Point(s) of common coupling shown • Location and type of isolation switch and circuit breaker shown • All protective relay functions shown • Transformer grounding shown • Transformer impedances shown • Meters and metering connections shown One-Line Electrical Diagram
  • 23.
  • 24.
    24 Generation selection • Landavailability • Environmental considerations • Energy resources – Wind – Solar – River or tidal flow – Fossil fuels • Effect of uncontrolled renewables (wind and solar) de-stabilizes islanded microgrid and creates need for energy storage Steps to Project Development
  • 25.
    25 • Generation mustmatch the load – exactly – Overload= under frequency trip (0.16 seconds response time) – High speed load shedding a necessity • Provisions for peaks (spinning reserve) – Normally 15-20% of operating load – Depends on system load profile • Surge capacity (motor starting) – Reactive power requirements – Voltage control Powering a Microgrid
  • 26.
    26 Generator types • Synchronous –Voltage and current source – Can supply or absorb reactive power • Induction – Current source only – Requires system source of excitation voltage – No voltage control • Inverter – Current source, externally commutated (UL-1741) – Current and voltage source, self commutated – Limited fault current – Limited reactive power capability Powering a Microgrid
  • 27.
    27 Generator characteristics • Baseload – slowly changing or fixed output (slow ramp rate) – Lean burn natural gas – Fuel cell – Gas turbine (large) > 5MW – Hydro • Peaking – rapid response to follow system loads – Diesel – Rich burn natural gas – Inverters – Small gas turbines < 2MW Powering a Microgrid Fuel Cells 7 MW Gas Turbine Diesel Generator
  • 28.
    28 Energy Storage • Loadand generation smoothing – Short term 0-15 minutes – Flywheel – Battery & inverter • Time shifting – Reserve energy for peaking – Transferring PV generation to dark hours Powering a Microgrid Flywheel 1 MW Battery & Inverter
  • 29.
    29 Operation when gridconnected • Frequency controlled by grid • Voltage controlled by grid • Reactive power (VAR) demand supplied by grid • Distributed generation controlled to maintain desired power output (kW) • Higher available fault current, Utility source + Generation Microgrid Controls
  • 30.
    30 Islanded Operation • Frequencymust be controlled by microgrid generation • Microgrid must be able to absorb swings in load • Ramp rate of generators becomes an issue • How is load shared among multiple generators? • Isochronous vs. droop governing • Lower available fault current (generator only) – Will likely require different settings for protective relays – Different short circuit coordination requirements – Potentially greater arc-flash requirements (longer clearing times) Microgrid Controls
  • 31.
    31 Protection • Grid connected –Higher available fault currents – Need to identify external vs. internal faults to prevent false tripping – Fast break away from grid on external fault – Tight control of short time frequency and voltage tripping – Provide for low generation voltage and frequency ride through; keep generation on line as long as possible to support grid – Separate from utility to preserve microgrid and generation Protection and Controls
  • 32.
    32 Protection • Island Mode –Lower fault currents may require separate settings – Wider tolerances on frequency and voltage tripping of generation – Coordinate settings with load management controls to shed Tier 2 loads before frequency degrades on overload – Look at downstream devices, may not properly coordinate tripping with lower fault current Protection and Controls
  • 33.
    33 Controls • Grid connected –Generation dispatch – maximize economics, use historical data – Load management – maintain preplanned load preservation scheme using real-time data; always ready for transition to island mode • Island Mode – Generation dispatch • Establish base load capacity • Establish peaking capacity (load following) (frequency regulation) • Start additional generation as needed • Maintaining spinning reserve Protection and Controls
  • 34.
    34 Controls • Island Mode- Load management – Shed Tier 2 (and Tier 3 if required) on transfer to island mode – Restore loads when sufficient generation capacity is on line – Maintain real time list of Tier 2 loads to be shed to preserve microgrid – Activate load shed during system disturbance, restore loads when able Protection and Controls
  • 35.
    35 Controls • Synchronization -Closed transition – Shift generation to frequency and voltage control upon separation from utility – Monitor external grid voltage and frequency for return of normal service (IEEE-1547 five minute delay of retransfer after stabilization) – When ready, adjust microgrid voltage and frequency to match utility source – Close utility tie breaker – Transition generation to grid paralleled mode – Shut down excess generation Protection and Controls
  • 36.
    36 • Primary systemgrounding when islanded – Delta system • Grounding transformer – Wye system • Generator Grounding – Ground fault current islanded vs. grid parallel – Grounding resistor vs. reactor – Generator step-up transformer – Wye-Wye? • Ground fault currents grid connected vs. island mode Grounding
  • 37.
    37 Microgrid Development • Identifyfacilities to be served • Consult with utility for feasibility • Identify facility loads • Define physical and electrical boundaries and ownership of distribution and generation Design • Design interconnection and physical layout of Microgrid • Select and locate appropriate generation sources • Design protection system for grid parallel and island modes • Configure load management controls • Obtain Interconnection Agreement with host utility Conclusion
  • 38.
    Questions? Mark Lorentzen P: 607.330.0322| E: [email protected] Bill Moran P: 774.235.2602 | E: [email protected] www.trcsolutions.com

Editor's Notes