This study investigated the influence of extraction conditions on the yield of phenolic compounds and antioxidant capacity from broccoli and lamb's lettuce. For lamb's lettuce, methanol extraction with stirring yielded the highest levels of antioxidants. For broccoli, soxhlet extraction with water produced the greatest total phenolic content and antioxidant capacity. Overall, lamb's lettuce contained higher amounts of polyphenols and greater antioxidant activity than broccoli as measured by two assays. The results demonstrate that extraction technique and solvent choice significantly impact recovery of beneficial antioxidant compounds from plant materials.