Pragmatic CQRS with existing applications and databases (Digital Xchange, May 2019)
Download as PPTX, PDF2 likes1,167 views
The document discusses the implementation of Pragmatic CQRS (Command Query Responsibility Segregation) in a digital exchange context, emphasizing its benefits for performance, scalability, and developer productivity. Key challenges include data duplication, eventual consistency, and integration complexities while ensuring data availability and authorization. The document also outlines the architecture, technologies, and methodologies necessary for successfully deploying CQRS in various applications.
![JIT vs AOT Data Integration
• JIT
• Process [synchronous] request for data ‘just in in time’
• Only data that is requested
• Fresh as can be
• All authorization rules applied
• Single Source of Truth
• Transformation & Aggregation at request time
• Hard (runtime) dependencies from consumer on producer
• AOT
• Pre-process / pre-share data ‘ahead of time’
• Potentially includes data that will never be requested
• Data can be outdated
Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/pragmaticcqrs-digitalxchange-may2019-190520060306/85/Pragmatic-CQRS-with-existing-applications-and-databases-Digital-Xchange-May-2019-33-320.jpg)
Pragmatic CQRS with existing applications and databases (Digital Xchange, May 2019)
- 1. Pragmatic CQRS Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Lucas Jellema, CTO & Architect at AMIS Digital Xchange Bergisches Rheinland, May 2019
- 2. Lucas Jellema Architect / Developer 1994 started in IT at Oracle 2002 joined AMIS Currently CTO & Solution Architect Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 3. BOL - CQRS Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 4. Books Online - WebShop Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Products Product updates firewall Data manipulation Data Quality (enforcement) <10K transactions Batch jobs next to online Speed is nice Read only On line Speed is crucial XHTML & JSON > 5M visits Webshop visits - searches - product details - Orders
- 5. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Products Products Products Webshop visits - searches - product details - Orders firewall Data manipulation Data Quality (enforcement) <10K transactions Batch jobs next to online Speed is nice Read only On line Speed is crucial XHTML & JSON > 1M visits DMZ Read only JSON documents Images Text Search Scale Horizontally Stale but consistent Products Nightly generation Product updates
- 6. What is different? • DML != Query • Duplication of Data (<> evil) • Data in multiple physical locations • ACID is not an absolute truth • Eventual Consistency (relaxed freshness) • NoSQL – not everything is relational • Data preprocessed, stored and produced for a special consumer • TCO is not a given – and it matters Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 7. Why? • Performance • Scalability • Availability • Development productivity • Agility through decoupling • Reduction in TCO Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 8. Common mechanism for Duplicating Data to improve performance, scalability and developer productivity Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Many Complex, Heavy Queries: Complex Joins, Expensive Aggregations Inserts, Updates and the odd Delete
- 9. Common mechanism for Duplicating Data to improve performance, scalability and developer productivity Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Many Simple Cheap Queries Inserts, Updates and the odd Delete Many Simple Cheap Queries Required and feasible consistency: REFRESH ON COMMIT or scheduled refresh
- 10. Utility Company looking for Performance, Scalability and Availability in their core data sets Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Meter Readings batch Invoicing Billing Marketing Campaigns Load on Core Systems & effect on Performance Availability Core Systems
- 11. Utility Company looking for Performance, Scalability and Availability in their core data sets Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Meter Readings Invoicing Billing Marketing Campaigns CRM Cache DB Meter Readings Cache DB
- 12. Utility Company looking for Performance, Scalability and Availability in their core data sets Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Meter Readings Invoicing Billing Marketing Campaigns CRM Cache DB Meter Readings Cache DB
- 13. Practical Challenges • Publish all change events from sources • Event schema evolution • Lag in Cache Databases • “eventual consistency” • Differences between sources and cache databases • Initial creation of Cache Databases • Scale and event storm • Business and Mission Critical availability • Data Authorization • Logic enforced in source (applications) • GDPR Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Meter Readings Invoicing Billing Marketing Campaigns CRM Cache DB Meter Readings Cache DB
- 14. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Products Data Manipulation Data Retrieval CQRS
- 15. Same Data, Multiple – different – Usage Scenarios • Different in: • Why • What – grain, aggregation, breadth, type of and variation in queries • How – format, language, accuracy and freshness, consistency • When – frequency, time of day | week | month, 24/7 • Where – latency, band width, off line • Who – scale, different roles & user groups Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 16. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Special Products Product Clusters ProductsData Manipulation Data Retrieval Food Stuff Toys Quick Product Search Index Product Store in SaaS app CQRS: Command Query Responsibility Segregation
- 17. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange MongoDB ORDERS Oracle Database DVX_ORDERS
- 18. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange MongoDB ORDERS Oracle Database DVX_ORDERS
- 19. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange 19 MongoDB ORDERS Oracle Database DVX_ORDERS
- 20. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange µ µ 20 MongoDB ORDERS Oracle Database DVX_ORDERS
- 21. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Special Products Product Clusters ProductsData Manipulation Data Retrieval Food Stuff Toys Quick Product Search Index Product Store in SaaS app CQRS Steps and Challenges
- 22. CQRS Steps and Challenges Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Special Products Product Clusters ProductsData Manipulation Data Retrieval Food Stuff Toys Quick Product Search Index Product Store in SaaS app Detect changes Extract Data Transport Data Convert Data Apply Data Spot and Handle Errors Governance & Evolution Enforce Constraints & Authorization
- 23. From C to Q • How quickly? • How frequently? • How reliably? • How atomically? • Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Products Quick Product Search Index
- 24. Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 25. From C to Q • How quickly? • How frequently? • How reliably? • How atomic? • • Data Authorization Considerations • Locations & Connectivity • Full resynch | restore of Query Store Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Products Quick Product Search Index
- 26. Typical CQRS Architecture Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Event Platform Source systems Poll Consume Detect & Retrieve Change Change Reporters Distributed Change Event Hub Change Projectors Destination systems Transform & Apply (re)Calculate & Record Convert, Translate, StoreEvent Schema Governance Monitoring & Error Handling
- 27. Technologies to support CQRS • Detecting and Extracting and Publishing Changes • Database specific change detection • Debezium, Kafka Connect, SOA Suite Inbound Adapters, • Cloud Adapters in iPaaS platforms and SaaS products • Decoupled gathering & queueing of change events (preferably distributed and technology agnostic; options for long term event retention) • Kafka, Rabbit MQ, AWS SQS, JMS • Handling change – transport, transform, apply • Query Stores – picked based on data use case requirement, not for CQRS • Any database, in memory cache Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 28. Detecting and Extracting and Publishing Changes Oracle Database as source • Oracle GoldenGate, Oracle Data Integrator • Data Integration Platform Cloud • SOA Suite Inbound Database Adapter • Custom: • Polling • Log Mining • Triggers (publishing DML change events) • Record in Table or AQ/JMS • Push over HTTP • Write to file • Materialized View (Log) • Flashback Query • Continuous Query Notification (DB QRCN) • To PL/SQL package or Java application Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Poll Consume Detect & Retrieve Change
- 29. Detecting and Extracting and Publishing Changes from many sources – Debezium, Kafka Connect, Apache Kafka Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CDC Debezium Apache Kafka
- 30. iPaaS (Cloud) Adapters for SaaS & Platform • Prepackaged Change Event Detectors Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 31. JIT vs AOT Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 32. Ahead of Time • Prepare products Ahead of Time instead of upon request • When the time to deliver (to request) is too long • When the complexity of a JIT-approach is too high • When the capacity does not allow for JIT-peak production • When the overhead and waste of AOT are justified Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 33. JIT vs AOT Data Integration • JIT • Process [synchronous] request for data ‘just in in time’ • Only data that is requested • Fresh as can be • All authorization rules applied • Single Source of Truth • Transformation & Aggregation at request time • Hard (runtime) dependencies from consumer on producer • AOT • Pre-process / pre-share data ‘ahead of time’ • Potentially includes data that will never be requested • Data can be outdated Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 34. Backend For Frontend Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 35. CQRS => Data Backend For Frontend: Optimized data set for special use case • Shape & Format • Right Grained (aggregation, consolidation) • Filtered • Enriched (from multiple sources) • Location • Time (refreshed at the right time) • Search Options • BASE (eventually – when? – consistent) • Authorization • GDPR Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange UI APIs (backend for frontend) Data Store Master Database
- 36. Domain Driven Design Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange • Context Mapping and Bounded Context • Ubiquitous Language • Microservices • Domain Events • Anti Corruption Layer (ACL) • Autonomous Bubble pattern
- 37. Final Demo • Microservice Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 38. Microservices • Agile | Flexible | Scalable | (Re)Deployable • Independent | Decoupled | Isolated • Communicate asynchronously, via events • Have their own private bounded context – the data they require to function • Their lifeblood Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 39. Microservices State Cache RDBMS Document Store NoSQL Generic Platform for running microservices Event Hub Big Data Block Storage LDAP Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 40. Bounded context of microservices • A micoservice needs to be able to run independently • It needs to contain & own all data required to run • It cannot depend on other microservices API Customer APIUI OrderCustomerModified event Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 41. Autonomous Bubble pattern in DDD • Getting started with Domain Driven Design in the context of Legacy Systems • Synchronizing Anti Corruption Layer • Translate anything that crosses a context boundary Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 42. Autonomous Bubble pattern in DDD Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Legacy New Application Other Context
- 43. Autonomous Bubble pattern in DDD Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Legacy New Application Other Context Event Publisher Event Publisher Q Q Q Coordinator consume
- 44. Event Sourcing Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 45. Utility Company: Rebuild Cache Database Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Meter Readings CRM Cache DB Meter Readings Cache DB
- 46. Utility Company: Rebuild Cache Database From Event Store Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange CRM Cache DB Meter Readings Cache DB
- 47. Event Sourcing Driving CQRS Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Events Event Store Current State accountId: 123 amount: 10 Owner: Jane Doe
- 48. Event Sourcing Driving CQRS Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Events Event Store Current State Other State Aggregate
- 49. Event Sourcing • Event Store is immutable – append-only log of domain state transitions • Replay events • to (re)construct a representation of the current state (aggregate) • up to a specific time to recreate moments in time • in Test environment to investigate an issue • on a remote location to create mirror & share state across boundaries • produce a fine grained audit trail • Challenges • Time required to reconstruct state • Grain of aggregates / definition of domain events Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 50. Distributed Database with Event Sourcing & Current State Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange World State
- 51. Collective Data Set and Equal Data Position Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 52. Industrial Data Space Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 53. Data Sharing Ecosystems • Multiple independent organizations • Mutually benefit from having access to the same data at the same time • Share data & Have access to data with minimum of overhead and with equality among the ecosystem partners • Partners are on different network domains, physical locations, technology stacks, … • New Partners can join • Partners can leave • Consensus on what constitutes correct data Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 54. Collective Dataset Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Company A Company C Company D Company E Company F Collective Dataset Company B
- 55. Collective Dataset Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Company A Company C Company D Company E Company F Central Database Enterprise Service Bus Canonical SOAP WS/ REST API for Sending Inserts/Updates/Deletes and for Requesting current data Just In Time Integration Company B
- 56. Collective Dataset = Collective Data Change Events Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Company A Company C Company D Company E Company F Central Event Platform Interfaces for Publishing and Consuming Events Note: events can be consumed asynchronously Ahead of Time Integration Company B
- 57. Collective Dataset => Collective Data Store Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange Company A Company C Company D Company E Company F Ahead of Time Integration Company B
- 58. Summary • Why: very different data usage patterns • What: provide tailored query channels for usage patterns (Backend for Frontend) • How: replicate data from source datastore to query store – with appropriate format, grain-level, scalability, location, availability, query options • When: source database(s) cannot fulfil non-functional requirements • With: change detectors & publishers, event platform, change projectors and governance on event definitions, monitoring & error handling • Challenges: scale, speed, consistency, authorization, initial build & full rebuild • Benefits: performance at scale, availability, developer productivity, agility, lower TCO and … Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange
- 59. Contact Details Pragmatic CQRS - Digital Xchange • Blog: technology.amis.nl • Email: [email protected] • : lucasjellema • : lucas-jellema • : www.amis.nl, [email protected] +31 306016000 Edisonbaan 15, Nieuwegein
Editor's Notes
- #17: Data manipulation and retrieval in separate places (physical data proliferation) Query store is optimized for consumers Level of detail, format, filters applied For performance and scalability, independence, productivity lower license fees and lower TCO, security
- #22: Data manipulation and retrieval in separate places (physical data proliferation) Query store is optimized for consumers Level of detail, format, filters applied For performance and scalability, independence, productivity lower license fees and lower TCO, security
- #23: No Event Sourcing No events (?) No green field Packages Applications/SaaS Databases (RDBMS, NoSQL) getting changes from applications directly Challenges – at scale, with enough speed and consistently: do not let query store get into an exposed state that could not exist/be right! Detect relevant changes Extract relevant changes Transport Convert Apply in correct order and reliably (no lost events) Note: after detect and extract, an event can be published
- #27: Destination system: can be cache, or even only the programmatic representation – without any data duplication Dumb pipes, smart end points
- #30: MySQL: binlog; Postgres: wnte-ahead log; MongoDB op log
- #31: AnyPoint Zapier SSI OIC Dell Boomi
- #40: All data stores are distributed Or at least distributedly available They can be local or on cloud (latency is important) Data in generic data store is still owned by only one microservice – no one can touch it Only in DWH and BigData do we deliberately take copies of data and disown them
- #43: http://domainlanguage.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/GettingStartedWithDDDWhenSurroundedByLegacySystemsV1.pdf
- #49: Events are immutable facts Current state (active record) is derived from sum of events Read optimized aggregates are created for specific use case – based on events and rebuildable at any time
- #50: Events are immutable facts Current state (active record) is derived from sum of events Read optimized aggregates are created for specific use case – based on events and rebuildable at any time
- #52: Blockchain!
- #56: Central Database plus ESB plus send updates and request data?
- #57: Central Database plus ESB plus send updates and request data?
- #58: Central Database plus ESB plus send updates and request data?
- #59: Central Database plus ESB plus send updates and request data?