Clinical Case
Partha Choudhary/48/M
 LURRAR- date of transplantation 7/6/2011
 Developed progressive anemic symptoms after
  transplantation, with chest pain on exertion.
 Pre Tx Hb-9.2, gradually decreasing Hb post Tx-
  6.5 on discharge till 5.4g/dl one month after the
  DOTx.
 History of EPO use (iv) for 2 yrs, max 10,000U till
  Tx and sc after that for 3 doses.
 Preserved TLC and Plat with NC,NC picture and
  retic of 0.5%, and MCV of 82
Clinical Case
 Ferritin-790mcg/ml and TSAT-80%
 Stool occult blood X3-negative
 UGI Endoscopy-normal
 USG abdomen-normal
 No response to Vit B12 and folic acid
    supplementation.
   Mild rise of serum creat from 1.1mg% to
    1.65mg%
   CMV DNA PCR-negative
   Anti-EPO antibodies-pending
   Parvovirus B19-positive
Mini review
CJASN:193-199; 2008
 First recognized in 2002.
                     Casadevall et al. N Engl J Med 346:
 469–475, 2002
 It was initially reported in patients who were
 treated with epoetin manufactured by Ortho-
 Biotec outside the United States (Eprex, Erypo
 [Ortho Biologics, LLC, Manati, Puerto Rico])

 But cases have since been reported with all
 commercially available ESA (Epogen, Aranesp,
 Procrit, NeoRecormon)
Diagnosis of ESA induced PRCA
 This is characterised by
 progressive, severe, normocytic, normochromic
 anemia of sudden on-set; reticulocytopenia; and
 a striking, almost complete absence of erythroid
 precursor cells in the bone marrow.

 Hemoglobin levels decrease at a rate of
 approximately 0.1 g/dl per d (1 g/L per
 d), corresponding to the red blood cell lifespan.

 The hallmark of PRCA is the absence of
 erythroblasts from an otherwise normal bone
 marrow.
Diagnosis of ESA induced PRCA
Bone marrow in PRCA
Classification of Pure Red Cell Aplasia
 Self-limited
   Transient erythroblastopenia of childhood
   Transient aplastic crisis of hemolysis (acute B19 parvovirus
    infection)
 Fetal red blood cell aplasia
   Nonimmune hydrops fetalis (in utero B19 parvovirus infection)
 Hereditary pure red cell aplasia
   Congenital pure red cell aplasia (Diamond-Blackfan syndrome)
 Acquired pure red cell aplasia
   Thymoma and malignancy
      Thymoma
      Lymphoid malignancies (and more rarely other hematologic diseases)
      Paraneoplastic to solid tumors
   Connective tissue disorders with immunologic abnormalities
     Systemic lupus erythematosus, juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, rheumatoid
       arthritis
     Multiple endocrine gland insufficiency
   Virus
     Persistent B19 parvovirus, hepatitis, adult T cell leukemia virus, Epstein-
       Barr virus
   Pregnancy
   Drugs
     Especially
Drugs implicated in PRCA




Causality may be established using the following three criteria:
(1) at least five patients reported,
(2) reports from at least three separate investigators, and
(3) a minimum of one case of probable or higher causality using a published
   assessment scale.
Pathogenesis of ESA induced
PRCA

 The pathogenetic mechanism has been shown
 clearly to be secondary to the development of
 neutralizing anti-erythropoietin antibodies.

 These antibodies, which recognize all available
 ESA (epoetin alfa, epoetin beta, and darbepoetin
 alfa) as well as endogenous erythropoietin, block
 the interaction between erythropoietin and its
 receptor.
Clinical approach to PRCA suspect
case
1. First thing to ascertain whether the ESA
   resistance is partial or severe. ESA related
   PRCA follows an “all or none”
   phenomenon, which means that if there is less
   than severe ESA resistance, then the cause is
   not ESA induced PRCA.
2. Bone marrow examination to confirm the
   presence of severe erythroid hypoplasia.
3. Anti-ESA antibodies are needed for completing
   the diagnostic criteria, absence makes ESA
   induced PRCA unlikely.
4. Other causes of hypo responsiveness to ESA
   should also be evaluated
Conditions causing ESA
resistance
Treatment
 Patients who are diagnosed with ESA induced
  PRCA should have the ESA stopped immediately
  but cessation alone may not cause remission.
 Regular blood transfusions till the antibodies
  disappear.
 In cases of PRCA induced by drugs other than
  ESA’s, the disease generally remits in 1-2 weeks.
 Patients who develop antibody-mediated PRCA in
  response to ESA treatment are unlikely to
  respond to treatment with other erythropoietic
  agents, because there is substantial
  crossreactivity among erythropoietic agents,
  including endogenous erythropoietin.
Treatment
 In patients with CKD and ESA-induced
  PRCA, immunosuppressive treatment is usually
  required to induce disappearance of anti-
  erythropoietin antibodies.
 Recovery rates from PRCA is 2% without
  immunosuppressive therapy, 52% after
  immunosuppressive treatment(s) outside the renal
  transplantation setting, and 95% after kidney
  transplantation.
                             Bennett et al. Blood 106:3343–
  3347, 2005
 In the absence of kidney transplantation, treatment of
  PRCA includes oral administration of
  prednisone, usually at a starting dosage of 1 mg/kg
  per d. In patients with idiopathic
  PRCA, corticosteroids produce responses in
  approximately 50% of patients
 Similar response rates were reported in patients with
Treatment

 Other therapies like
 cyclophosphamide, cyclosporine, daclizumab and
 rituximab have also been tried with success.

 PRCA induced by parvovirus respond to IVIg but
 the response is poor in ESA induced PRCA

 Rechallenge with a different epoetin preparation
 should be considered with caution and only when
 anti-epoetin antibody levels have become
 undetectable.
Reasons for the development of
antibodies against EPREX
 The incidence rate rose drastically between 1998
 and 2002, after a change in the formulation in
 which human serum albumin was eliminated and
 replaced by polysorbate-80 to avoid the risk for
 virus or transmission.

 Several hypothesis have been put forth to explain
 the breakage of the B cell tolerance but are not
 satisfactory.

 The presence of epoetin-loaded micelles in the
 stored formulation has been suggested as a
 It has been proposed that leachates released from
 rubber stoppers used only in syringes from Ortho
 Biotech could act as adjuvants and induce an immune
 response against erythropoietin, but experimental
 data substantiating this claim are controversial.

 However, the micelle hypothesis and the leachate
 hypothesis were not convincing due the universal
 presence in EPO syringes and the rarity of the
 condition.

 Another explanation that was put forward was the use
 of silicon in as lubricants in the Eprex syringes
 (NEJM 2004)
NEJM 2004
Parvovirus B19 in renal transplant
recipients




                             Nature Reviews 2007
Parvovirus B19 related PRCA in
renal transplant recipients
 The onset of anemia after transplantation has
 been reported to occur from 2 weeks to 63
 months, although most of the documented cases
 occurred within the first 3 months.

 Fever and flu-like symptoms can be seen at
 presentation. Weakness, dyspnea and orthostatic
 hypotension are often present, and are related to
 the abrupt onset of severe anemia.

 Arthralgias and rashes are less common
 manifestations because of impaired antibody
Parvovirus B19 related PRCA in
renal transplant recipients




                          Nature Reviews 2007
THANK YOU

PRCA post renal transplant-a case and review

  • 1.
    Clinical Case Partha Choudhary/48/M LURRAR- date of transplantation 7/6/2011  Developed progressive anemic symptoms after transplantation, with chest pain on exertion.  Pre Tx Hb-9.2, gradually decreasing Hb post Tx- 6.5 on discharge till 5.4g/dl one month after the DOTx.  History of EPO use (iv) for 2 yrs, max 10,000U till Tx and sc after that for 3 doses.  Preserved TLC and Plat with NC,NC picture and retic of 0.5%, and MCV of 82
  • 2.
    Clinical Case  Ferritin-790mcg/mland TSAT-80%  Stool occult blood X3-negative  UGI Endoscopy-normal  USG abdomen-normal  No response to Vit B12 and folic acid supplementation.  Mild rise of serum creat from 1.1mg% to 1.65mg%  CMV DNA PCR-negative  Anti-EPO antibodies-pending  Parvovirus B19-positive
  • 3.
  • 4.
     First recognizedin 2002. Casadevall et al. N Engl J Med 346: 469–475, 2002  It was initially reported in patients who were treated with epoetin manufactured by Ortho- Biotec outside the United States (Eprex, Erypo [Ortho Biologics, LLC, Manati, Puerto Rico])  But cases have since been reported with all commercially available ESA (Epogen, Aranesp, Procrit, NeoRecormon)
  • 5.
    Diagnosis of ESAinduced PRCA  This is characterised by progressive, severe, normocytic, normochromic anemia of sudden on-set; reticulocytopenia; and a striking, almost complete absence of erythroid precursor cells in the bone marrow.  Hemoglobin levels decrease at a rate of approximately 0.1 g/dl per d (1 g/L per d), corresponding to the red blood cell lifespan.  The hallmark of PRCA is the absence of erythroblasts from an otherwise normal bone marrow.
  • 6.
    Diagnosis of ESAinduced PRCA
  • 7.
  • 8.
    Classification of PureRed Cell Aplasia  Self-limited  Transient erythroblastopenia of childhood  Transient aplastic crisis of hemolysis (acute B19 parvovirus infection)  Fetal red blood cell aplasia  Nonimmune hydrops fetalis (in utero B19 parvovirus infection)  Hereditary pure red cell aplasia  Congenital pure red cell aplasia (Diamond-Blackfan syndrome)  Acquired pure red cell aplasia  Thymoma and malignancy  Thymoma  Lymphoid malignancies (and more rarely other hematologic diseases)  Paraneoplastic to solid tumors  Connective tissue disorders with immunologic abnormalities  Systemic lupus erythematosus, juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, rheumatoid arthritis  Multiple endocrine gland insufficiency  Virus  Persistent B19 parvovirus, hepatitis, adult T cell leukemia virus, Epstein- Barr virus  Pregnancy  Drugs  Especially
  • 9.
    Drugs implicated inPRCA Causality may be established using the following three criteria: (1) at least five patients reported, (2) reports from at least three separate investigators, and (3) a minimum of one case of probable or higher causality using a published assessment scale.
  • 10.
    Pathogenesis of ESAinduced PRCA  The pathogenetic mechanism has been shown clearly to be secondary to the development of neutralizing anti-erythropoietin antibodies.  These antibodies, which recognize all available ESA (epoetin alfa, epoetin beta, and darbepoetin alfa) as well as endogenous erythropoietin, block the interaction between erythropoietin and its receptor.
  • 11.
    Clinical approach toPRCA suspect case 1. First thing to ascertain whether the ESA resistance is partial or severe. ESA related PRCA follows an “all or none” phenomenon, which means that if there is less than severe ESA resistance, then the cause is not ESA induced PRCA. 2. Bone marrow examination to confirm the presence of severe erythroid hypoplasia. 3. Anti-ESA antibodies are needed for completing the diagnostic criteria, absence makes ESA induced PRCA unlikely. 4. Other causes of hypo responsiveness to ESA should also be evaluated
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Treatment  Patients whoare diagnosed with ESA induced PRCA should have the ESA stopped immediately but cessation alone may not cause remission.  Regular blood transfusions till the antibodies disappear.  In cases of PRCA induced by drugs other than ESA’s, the disease generally remits in 1-2 weeks.  Patients who develop antibody-mediated PRCA in response to ESA treatment are unlikely to respond to treatment with other erythropoietic agents, because there is substantial crossreactivity among erythropoietic agents, including endogenous erythropoietin.
  • 14.
    Treatment  In patientswith CKD and ESA-induced PRCA, immunosuppressive treatment is usually required to induce disappearance of anti- erythropoietin antibodies.  Recovery rates from PRCA is 2% without immunosuppressive therapy, 52% after immunosuppressive treatment(s) outside the renal transplantation setting, and 95% after kidney transplantation. Bennett et al. Blood 106:3343– 3347, 2005  In the absence of kidney transplantation, treatment of PRCA includes oral administration of prednisone, usually at a starting dosage of 1 mg/kg per d. In patients with idiopathic PRCA, corticosteroids produce responses in approximately 50% of patients  Similar response rates were reported in patients with
  • 15.
    Treatment  Other therapieslike cyclophosphamide, cyclosporine, daclizumab and rituximab have also been tried with success.  PRCA induced by parvovirus respond to IVIg but the response is poor in ESA induced PRCA  Rechallenge with a different epoetin preparation should be considered with caution and only when anti-epoetin antibody levels have become undetectable.
  • 16.
    Reasons for thedevelopment of antibodies against EPREX  The incidence rate rose drastically between 1998 and 2002, after a change in the formulation in which human serum albumin was eliminated and replaced by polysorbate-80 to avoid the risk for virus or transmission.  Several hypothesis have been put forth to explain the breakage of the B cell tolerance but are not satisfactory.  The presence of epoetin-loaded micelles in the stored formulation has been suggested as a
  • 17.
     It hasbeen proposed that leachates released from rubber stoppers used only in syringes from Ortho Biotech could act as adjuvants and induce an immune response against erythropoietin, but experimental data substantiating this claim are controversial.  However, the micelle hypothesis and the leachate hypothesis were not convincing due the universal presence in EPO syringes and the rarity of the condition.  Another explanation that was put forward was the use of silicon in as lubricants in the Eprex syringes (NEJM 2004)
  • 18.
  • 19.
    Parvovirus B19 inrenal transplant recipients Nature Reviews 2007
  • 20.
    Parvovirus B19 relatedPRCA in renal transplant recipients  The onset of anemia after transplantation has been reported to occur from 2 weeks to 63 months, although most of the documented cases occurred within the first 3 months.  Fever and flu-like symptoms can be seen at presentation. Weakness, dyspnea and orthostatic hypotension are often present, and are related to the abrupt onset of severe anemia.  Arthralgias and rashes are less common manifestations because of impaired antibody
  • 21.
    Parvovirus B19 relatedPRCA in renal transplant recipients Nature Reviews 2007
  • 22.