QUALITY PERFORMANCE
IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji. Puthuparambil,RN,RM,MSN
MOHAP Innovation Pioneer/ ER Nurse
Saqar Hospital, RAK
ROAD TO QPI BEGINS WITH STRATEGIC PLANNING
STRATEGY
The plans and activities developed by an organization in
pursuit of its goals and objectives, particularly in regard to positioning
itself to meet external demands relative to its competition” (Shortell,
Morrison, & Robbins, 1985)
STRATEGY PLANNING
The one way of coping with a dynamic and complex
environment
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
PRIORITIES FOR QUALITY AND PERFORMANCE
IMPROVEMENT
GOALS OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
(GINTER, SWAYNE & DUNCAN, 2002)
• Provide a framework of thinking
• Create a fit between the organization and its external
environment
• Provide a process for coping with change and organizational
renewal
• Foster anticipation, innovation and excellence
• Facilitate consistent decision making and
• Create organizational focus
CULTURE TO SUPPORT QUALITY
A sense of identity for employees
and commitment to something
larger than themselves
Enhance cooperation
Create a system of informal rules
spelling out how people are
expected to behave &
Creates distinctions between
organizations, allowing a definite
competition advantage to develop
GENERAL PRACTICES OF EXEMPLARY
LEADERS
(KOUZES & POSNER (2002))
• Inspire a shared vision
• Challenge the system
• Enable others to Act
• Model the way
• Encourage the Heart
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
DEVELOPMENT OF QPI ACTION PLANS
A standard format includes
• Who(accountability)
• What (Specific actions or steps to be followed)
• When (Time frame)
• Status (Progress made and ongoing
monitoring) &
• Completion (Closure or closing the loop)
Projects
Goal: Improving a defined process to complete
redesign or even designing a new process or
system
FRAMEWORK FOR EXECUTION OF
PLANS FOR A QPI PROJECT
(NOLAN, 2007)
ENVIRONMENT INFRASTRUCTURE
Provide Day-to-Day
leaders for Microsystems
Spread and Sustain
Provide Leaders for Large
System Projects
Achieve
strategic Goals
Build
Capability
Manage local
improvement
STEPS IN PROGRAMME DEVELOPMENT
• Determine who, what, when, where, how and
why
• Structure the design
• Choose and develop a sampling method
• Determine and conduct training
• Delegate responsibilities
• Facilitate coordination
• Forecast budget
• Conduct pilots or test of change
DECISION MAKING QPI TOOLS
• Brainstorming
• Multivoting
• Nominal Group technique
• Delphi Method
• Failure mode and Effect Analysis(FMEA)
• Prioritization Matrix
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
BRAINSTORMING
• Define the brainstorming topic
• Inform that all ideas are good ideas and all
comments /evaluation should be held in
abeyance until the brainstorming is complete
• Give everyone a few minutes
• Have the team members call out their ideas
• One person should write the ideas on a flip
chart
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
MULTIVOTING
• It is an easy, quick method for determining
the most popular or important items from a
list
• Uses a series of votes to cut the list in half
each time, thus reducing the number of items
to be considered
NOMINAL GROUP TECHNIQUE
• Generating a large number of ideas in which
each members works by himself or herself
• More structured than brainstorming and
multivoting
DELPHI METHOD
• Combination of brainstorming, multivoting and
nominal group technique
• Used when group members are not in one location
and often is conducted by e-mail when a meeting is
not feasible
• After each step in process, the data are sent to one
person, who compiles the data and send out the next
round for participation to complete
FAILURE MODE AND EFFECT ANALYSIS
• Preventive approach to identify failures and
opportunities for error and can be used for process as
well as equipment
• Healthcare FMEA used in healthcare
PRIORITIZATION MATRIX
• Organizes tasks, issues or actions and prioritizes them
based on agreed –upon criteria
• Combines tree diagram and L-shaped matrix diagram,
displaying the best possible effect
• Used before more complex matrices are needed
• Applies options under discussion to the priority
consideration of the organization
VARIATION
Variation is critical in QPI process
COMMON-CAUSE VARIATION
On a control chart, this type of variation is exhibited as points between
the control limits in no particular pattern
SPECIAL-CAUSE VARIATION
Points that fall outside the control limits or, when inside the control
limits, exhibit certain patterns
ROOT-CAUSE ANALYSIS
When a variation is inherent in the process and a reduction of
the variations is desired, the root cause must be identified to eliminate
tampering with the effective components of the process
AREAS NEED TO FOCUS IN ANALYSIS
• Human Factors: Communication and Information
Management Systems
• Human factors : Training
• Human Factors : Fatigue and scheduling
• Environmental factors
• Equipment factors
• Rules, policies and procedures
• Leadership systems and culture (White, 2004)
TOOLS USED TO ELIMINATE OR MINIMIZE
THE ROOT CAUSES OF THE VARIATION
• Spaghetti Diagram/ layout diagram
Graphic representation of the flow of traffic or
movement
• Checklist
Standard way to ensure completion of critical
tasks for a process or activity
• Checklist
Standard way to ensure completion of critical tasks for a
process or activity
• 5-S diagram
Represents Sorts, Straighten, Scrub/Shine,
Systematize/Sustain, Standardize
Value stream Mapping
Map of the process in which only value added steps
for the customer are retained and other waste removed
Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
• Voice of the customers
List of needs, wants and desires of the customer
of a process output
• Supplier Input Process output
customer(SIPOC)
To identify the key drivers of a process
PROCESS STEPS IN HEALTHCARE
Note: Need clear understanding of data, types of data and tools
The Improvement process seeks to accomplish the
following :
• Ensure the project is a priority and is aligned with the strategic plan
• Ensure leadership support and commitment
• Assess the priority and feasibility of initiatives
• Clarify the aim, stated in specific measurable terms
• Present baseline data analysis
• Demonstrate that the aim is based on own data and identified the specific
problem to be solved , enhanced or redesigned
• Select and interdisciplinary team
• Map the current process and collect data on key aspects of the process
• Define measures and collect data
• Describe the change to be made
• Implement the change(Pilot tests)
• Study the effects of the changes and make a decision
• Map the new process
• Spread the change throughout in a defined implementation plan
• Sustain the improvement by monitoring
Quality performance improvement
Quality performance improvement

Quality performance improvement

  • 1.
    QUALITY PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS Mr.Thomaskutty Saji. Puthuparambil,RN,RM,MSN MOHAP Innovation Pioneer/ ER Nurse Saqar Hospital, RAK
  • 3.
    ROAD TO QPIBEGINS WITH STRATEGIC PLANNING STRATEGY The plans and activities developed by an organization in pursuit of its goals and objectives, particularly in regard to positioning itself to meet external demands relative to its competition” (Shortell, Morrison, & Robbins, 1985) STRATEGY PLANNING The one way of coping with a dynamic and complex environment Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN PRIORITIES FOR QUALITY AND PERFORMANCE IMPROVEMENT
  • 4.
    GOALS OF STRATEGICMANAGEMENT (GINTER, SWAYNE & DUNCAN, 2002) • Provide a framework of thinking • Create a fit between the organization and its external environment • Provide a process for coping with change and organizational renewal • Foster anticipation, innovation and excellence • Facilitate consistent decision making and • Create organizational focus
  • 5.
    CULTURE TO SUPPORTQUALITY A sense of identity for employees and commitment to something larger than themselves Enhance cooperation Create a system of informal rules spelling out how people are expected to behave & Creates distinctions between organizations, allowing a definite competition advantage to develop
  • 6.
    GENERAL PRACTICES OFEXEMPLARY LEADERS (KOUZES & POSNER (2002)) • Inspire a shared vision • Challenge the system • Enable others to Act • Model the way • Encourage the Heart Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
  • 7.
    DEVELOPMENT OF QPIACTION PLANS A standard format includes • Who(accountability) • What (Specific actions or steps to be followed) • When (Time frame) • Status (Progress made and ongoing monitoring) & • Completion (Closure or closing the loop)
  • 8.
    Projects Goal: Improving adefined process to complete redesign or even designing a new process or system
  • 9.
    FRAMEWORK FOR EXECUTIONOF PLANS FOR A QPI PROJECT (NOLAN, 2007) ENVIRONMENT INFRASTRUCTURE Provide Day-to-Day leaders for Microsystems Spread and Sustain Provide Leaders for Large System Projects Achieve strategic Goals Build Capability Manage local improvement
  • 10.
    STEPS IN PROGRAMMEDEVELOPMENT • Determine who, what, when, where, how and why • Structure the design • Choose and develop a sampling method • Determine and conduct training • Delegate responsibilities • Facilitate coordination • Forecast budget • Conduct pilots or test of change
  • 11.
    DECISION MAKING QPITOOLS • Brainstorming • Multivoting • Nominal Group technique • Delphi Method • Failure mode and Effect Analysis(FMEA) • Prioritization Matrix Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
  • 12.
    BRAINSTORMING • Define thebrainstorming topic • Inform that all ideas are good ideas and all comments /evaluation should be held in abeyance until the brainstorming is complete • Give everyone a few minutes • Have the team members call out their ideas • One person should write the ideas on a flip chart Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
  • 13.
    MULTIVOTING • It isan easy, quick method for determining the most popular or important items from a list • Uses a series of votes to cut the list in half each time, thus reducing the number of items to be considered
  • 14.
    NOMINAL GROUP TECHNIQUE •Generating a large number of ideas in which each members works by himself or herself • More structured than brainstorming and multivoting
  • 15.
    DELPHI METHOD • Combinationof brainstorming, multivoting and nominal group technique • Used when group members are not in one location and often is conducted by e-mail when a meeting is not feasible • After each step in process, the data are sent to one person, who compiles the data and send out the next round for participation to complete
  • 16.
    FAILURE MODE ANDEFFECT ANALYSIS • Preventive approach to identify failures and opportunities for error and can be used for process as well as equipment • Healthcare FMEA used in healthcare
  • 17.
    PRIORITIZATION MATRIX • Organizestasks, issues or actions and prioritizes them based on agreed –upon criteria • Combines tree diagram and L-shaped matrix diagram, displaying the best possible effect • Used before more complex matrices are needed • Applies options under discussion to the priority consideration of the organization
  • 19.
    VARIATION Variation is criticalin QPI process COMMON-CAUSE VARIATION On a control chart, this type of variation is exhibited as points between the control limits in no particular pattern SPECIAL-CAUSE VARIATION Points that fall outside the control limits or, when inside the control limits, exhibit certain patterns ROOT-CAUSE ANALYSIS When a variation is inherent in the process and a reduction of the variations is desired, the root cause must be identified to eliminate tampering with the effective components of the process
  • 20.
    AREAS NEED TOFOCUS IN ANALYSIS • Human Factors: Communication and Information Management Systems • Human factors : Training • Human Factors : Fatigue and scheduling • Environmental factors • Equipment factors • Rules, policies and procedures • Leadership systems and culture (White, 2004)
  • 21.
    TOOLS USED TOELIMINATE OR MINIMIZE THE ROOT CAUSES OF THE VARIATION • Spaghetti Diagram/ layout diagram Graphic representation of the flow of traffic or movement • Checklist Standard way to ensure completion of critical tasks for a process or activity
  • 22.
    • Checklist Standard wayto ensure completion of critical tasks for a process or activity • 5-S diagram Represents Sorts, Straighten, Scrub/Shine, Systematize/Sustain, Standardize
  • 24.
    Value stream Mapping Mapof the process in which only value added steps for the customer are retained and other waste removed Mr. Thomaskutty Saji,RN,RM,MSN
  • 25.
    • Voice ofthe customers List of needs, wants and desires of the customer of a process output • Supplier Input Process output customer(SIPOC) To identify the key drivers of a process
  • 26.
    PROCESS STEPS INHEALTHCARE Note: Need clear understanding of data, types of data and tools
  • 27.
    The Improvement processseeks to accomplish the following : • Ensure the project is a priority and is aligned with the strategic plan • Ensure leadership support and commitment • Assess the priority and feasibility of initiatives • Clarify the aim, stated in specific measurable terms • Present baseline data analysis • Demonstrate that the aim is based on own data and identified the specific problem to be solved , enhanced or redesigned • Select and interdisciplinary team • Map the current process and collect data on key aspects of the process • Define measures and collect data • Describe the change to be made • Implement the change(Pilot tests) • Study the effects of the changes and make a decision • Map the new process • Spread the change throughout in a defined implementation plan • Sustain the improvement by monitoring